Core mutations that promote the calcium-induced allosteric transition of bovine recoverin

Bringing the Ca2+ sensitivity of myristoylated recoverin into the physiological range

The prototypical Ca²⁺-sensor protein recoverin (Rec) is thought to regulate the activity of rhodopsin kinase (GRK1) in photoreceptors by switching from a relaxed (R) disc membrane-bound conformation in the dark to a more compact, cytosol-diffusing tense (T) conformation upon cell illumination. However, the apparent affinity for Ca²⁺ of its physiologically relevant form (myristoylated recoverin) is almost two orders of magnitude too low to support this mechanism in vivo. In this work, we compared the individual and synergistic roles of the myristic moiety, the GRK1 target and the disc membrane in modulating the calcium sensitivity of Rec. We show that the sole presence of the target or the disc membrane alone are not sufficient to achieve a physiological response to changes in intracellular [Ca²⁺]. Instead, the simultaneous presence of GRK1 and membrane allows the T to R transition to occur in a physiological range of [Ca²⁺] with high cooperativity via a conformational selection mechanism that drives the structural transitions of Rec in the presence of multiple ligands. Our conclusions may apply to other sensory transduction systems involving protein complexes and biological membranes.

Crystal Structure of Recoverin with Calcium Ions Bound to Both Functional EF Hands

Recoverin (Rv), a small Ca(2+)-binding protein that inhibits rhodopsin kinase (RK), has four EF hands, two of which are functional (EF2 and EF3). Activation requires Ca(2+) in both EF hands, but crystal structures have never been observed with Ca(2+) ions in both sites; all previous structures have Ca(2+) bound to only EF3. We suspected that this was due to an intermolecular crystal contact between T80 and a surface glutamate (E153) that precluded coordination of a Ca(2+) ion in EF2. We constructed the E153A mutant, determined its X-ray crystal structure to 1.2 Å resolution, and showed that two Ca(2+) ions are bound, one in EF3 and one in EF2. Additionally, several other residues are shown to adopt conformations in the 2Ca(2+) structure not seen previously and not seen in a second structure of the E153A mutant containing Na(+) instead of Ca(2+) in the EF2 site. The side-chain rearrangements in these residues form a 28 Å allosteric cascade along the surface of the protein connecting the Ca(2+)-binding site of EF2 with the active-site pocket responsible for binding RK.

A highly conserved cysteine of neuronal calcium-sensing proteins controls cooperative binding of Ca2+ to recoverin

Recoverin, a 23-kDa Ca(2+)-binding protein of the neuronal calcium sensing (NCS) family, inhibits rhodopsin kinase, a Ser/Thr kinase responsible for termination of photoactivated rhodopsin in rod photoreceptor cells. Recoverin has two functional EF hands and a myristoylated N terminus. The myristoyl chain imparts cooperativity to the Ca(2+)-binding sites through an allosteric mechanism involving a conformational equilibrium between R and T states of the protein. Ca(2+) binds preferentially to the R state; the myristoyl chain binds preferentially to the T state. In the absence of myristoylation, the R state predominates, and consequently, binding of Ca(2+) to the non-myristoylated protein is not cooperative. We show here that a mutation, C39A, of a highly conserved Cys residue among NCS proteins, increases the apparent cooperativity for binding of Ca(2+) to non-myristoylated recoverin. The binding data can be explained by an effect on the T/R equilibrium to favor the T state without affecting the intrinsic binding constants for the two Ca(2+) sites.

Double electron-electron resonance probes Ca²⁺-induced conformational changes and dimerization of recoverin

Recoverin, a member of the neuronal calcium sensor (NCS) branch of the calmodulin superfamily, is expressed in retinal photoreceptor cells and serves as a calcium sensor in vision. Ca²⁺-induced conformational changes in recoverin cause extrusion of its covalently attached myristate (termed Ca²⁺-myristoyl switch) that promotes translocation of recoverin to disk membranes during phototransduction in retinal rod cells. Here we report double electron-electron resonance (DEER) experiments on recoverin that probe Ca²⁺-induced changes in distance as measured by the dipolar coupling between spin-labels strategically positioned at engineered cysteine residues on the protein surface. The DEER distance between nitroxide spin-labels attached at C39 and N120C is 2.5 ± 0.1 nm for Ca²⁺-free recoverin and 3.7 ± 0.1 nm for Ca²⁺-bound recoverin. An additional DEER distance (5-6 nm) observed for Ca²⁺-bound recoverin may represent an intermolecular distance between C39 and N120. ¹⁵N NMR relaxation analysis and CW-EPR experiments both confirm that Ca²⁺-bound recoverin forms a dimer at protein concentrations above 100 μM, whereas Ca²⁺-free recoverin is monomeric. We propose that Ca²⁺-induced dimerization of recoverin at the disk membrane surface may play a role in regulating Ca²⁺-dependent phosphorylation of dimeric rhodopsin. The DEER approach will be useful for elucidating dimeric structures of NCS proteins in general for which Ca²⁺-induced dimerization is functionally important but not well understood.

Structural Biology of a Major Signaling Network that Regulates Plant Abiotic Stress: The CBL-CIPK Mediated Pathway

The Arabidopsis SOS2 family of twenty-six protein kinases (CIPKs), their interacting activators, the SOS3 family of ten calcium-binding proteins (CBLs) and protein phosphatases type 2C (PP2C), function together in decoding calcium signals elicited by different environmental stimuli. Biochemical data suggest that stable CBL-CIPK or CIPK-PP2C complexes may be regulating the activity of various substrates controlling ion homeostasis. The available structural information provides a general regulatory mechanism in which calcium perception by CBLs and kinase activation is coupled. The structural basis of this molecular mechanism and the specificity of the network is reviewed and discussed in detail.

Conformational dynamics of recoverin's Ca2+-myristoyl switch probed by 15N NMR relaxation dispersion and chemical shift analysis

Recoverin, a member of the neuronal calcium sensor (NCS) branch of the calmodulin superfamily, serves as a calcium sensor in retinal rod cells. Ca(2+) -induced conformational changes in recoverin promote extrusion of its covalently attached myristate, known as the Ca(2+)-myristoyl switch. Here, we present nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxation dispersion and chemical shift analysis on (15) N-labeled recoverin to probe main chain conformational dynamics. (15) N NMR relaxation data suggest that Ca(2+)-free recoverin undergoes millisecond conformational dynamics at particular amide sites throughout the protein. The addition of trace Ca(2+) levels (0.05 equivalents) increases the number of residues that show detectable relaxation dispersion. The Ca(2+)-dependent chemical shifts and relaxation dispersion suggest that recoverin has an intermediate conformational state (I) between the sequestered apo state (T) and Ca(2+) saturated extruded state (R): T ↔ I ↔ R. The first step is a fast conformational equilibrium ([T]/[I] < 100) on the millisecond time scale (τ(ex) δω < 1). The final step (I ↔ R) is much slower (τ(ex) δω > 1). The main chain structure of I is similar in part to the structure of half-saturated E85Q recoverin with a sequestered myristoyl group. We propose that millisecond dynamics during T ↔ I may transiently increase the exposure of Ca(2+)-binding sites to initiate Ca(2+) binding that drives extrusion of the myristoyl group during I ↔ R.

Ca2+-dependent conformational changes in the neuronal Ca2+-sensor recoverin probed by the fluorescent dye Alexa647

Recoverin belongs to the superfamily of EF-hand Ca2+-binding proteins and operates as a Ca2+-sensor in vertebrate photoreceptor cells, where it regulates the activity of rhodopsin kinase GRK1 in a Ca2+-dependent manner. Ca2+-dependent conformational changes in recoverin are allosterically controlled by the covalently attached myristoyl group. The amino acid sequence of recoverin harbors a unique cysteine at position 38. The cysteine can be modified by the fluorescent dye Alexa647 using a maleimide-thiol coupling step. Introduction of Alexa647 into recoverin did not disturb the biological function of recoverin, as it can regulate rhodopsin kinase activity like unlabeled recoverin. Performance of the Ca2+-myristoyl switch of labeled recoverin was monitored by Ca2+-dependent association with immobilized lipids using surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy. When the Ca2+-concentration was varied, labeled myristoylated recoverin showed a 37%-change in fluorescence emission and a 34%-change in excitation intensity, emission and excitation maxima shifted by 6 and 18 nm, respectively. In contrast, labeled nonmyristoylated recoverin exhibited only minimal changes. Time-resolved fluorescence measurements showed biexponentiell fluorescence decay, in which the slower time constant of 2 ns was specifically influenced by Ca2+-induced conformational changes. A similar influence on the slower time constant was observed with the recoverin mutant RecE85Q that has a disabled EF-hand 2, but no such influence was detected with the mutant RecE121Q (EF-hand 3 is nonfunctional) that contains the myristoyl group in a clamped position. We conclude from our results that Alexa647 bound to cysteine 38 can monitor the conformational transition in recoverin that is under control of the myristoyl group.

Single-step purification of myristoylated and nonmyristoylated recoverin and substrate dependence of myristoylation level

Recoverin is cotranslationally modified by the covalent linkage of a myristoyl group to its N terminus. It is a member of a family of Ca(2+)-myristoyl switch proteins. Recombinant myristoylated revoverin is currently produced by the cotransformation of bacteria with recoverin and an enzyme that allows N-myristoylation and by supplementing the culture medium with myristic acid. A large variation in the myristoylation level of recoverin and in the amount of myristic acid supplied to the culture medium can be found in the literature. Moreover, although it is known to strongly affect bacterial growth, the amount of ethanol used to solubilize myristic acid is only scarcely mentioned. To improve our understanding of the parameters responsible for recombinant recoverin myristoylation, the effects of myristic acid and ethanol on recoverin myristoylation and expression levels have been systematically studied. In addition, a single-step purification procedure to produce purified myristoylated and nonmyristoylated recombinant recoverin has also been devised. Finally, sodium myristate has been used as an efficient alternative substrate to achieve high myristoylation and expression levels of recoverin. Given that a large number of proteins are myristoylated, these procedures could be applied to several other proteins in addition to recoverin.

Recoverin regulates light-dependent phosphodiesterase activity in retinal rods

The Ca²⁺-binding protein recoverin may regulate visual transduction in retinal rods and cones, but its functional role and mechanism of action remain controversial. We compared the photoresponses of rods from control mice and from mice in which the recoverin gene was knocked out. Our analysis indicates that Ca²⁺-recoverin prolongs the dark-adapted flash response and increases the rod's sensitivity to dim steady light. Knockout rods had faster Ca²⁺ dynamics, indicating that recoverin is a significant Ca²⁺ buffer in the outer segment, but incorporation of exogenous buffer did not restore wild-type behavior. We infer that Ca²⁺-recoverin potentiates light-triggered phosphodiesterase activity, probably by effectively prolonging the catalytic activity of photoexcited rhodopsin.

An early stage of Mason-Pfizer monkey virus budding is regulated by the hydrophobicity of the Gag matrix domain core

Intracellular capsid transport and release of Mason-Pfizer monkey virus are dependent on myristylation of the Gag matrix domain (MA). A myristylated MA mutant, in which Thr41 and Thr78 are replaced with isoleucines, assembles capsids that are transported to the plasma membrane but are blocked in an early budding step. Since the nuclear magnetic resonance structure of MA showed that these Thr residues point into the hydrophobic core of the protein, it was hypothesized that the T41I/T78I mutant was defective in release of myristic acid from the more hydrophobic core. In order to further investigate whether an increase in the hydrophobicity of the MA core modulates capsid-membrane interactions and viral budding, three tyrosine residues (11, 28, and 67), oriented toward the MA core, were replaced individually or in a pair-wise combination with the more hydrophobic phenylalanine residue(s). As a control, Tyr82, oriented toward the outer surface of MA, was also replaced with phenylalanine. These Tyr-to-Phe substitutions did not alter capsid assembly compared to wild type in a capsid assembly assay. Pulse-chase, immunofluorescence, and electron microscopy studies demonstrated that single substitutions of Tyr11, Tyr28, and Tyr67 recapitulated the T41I/T78I mutant phenotype of decreased budding kinetics and accumulation of capsids at the plasma membrane. MA double mutants with a combination of these Tyr substitutions exhibited a phenotype that was even more defective in budding. In contrast, MA mutants with Tyr82 replaced by Phe resulted in a transport-defective phenotype. These results strongly support the hypothesis that myristic acid is sequestered inside MA prior to capsid-membrane interactions.

Juvenile hormone III-dependent conformational changes of the nuclear receptor ultraspiracle

The identification of potential endogenous or synthetic ligands for orphan receptors in the steroid receptor superfamily is important both for discerning endogenous regulatory pathways and for designing receptor inhibitors. The insect nuclear receptor Ultraspiracle (USP), an ortholog of vertebrate RXR, has long been treated as an orphan receptor. We have tested here the fit of terpenoid ligands to the JH III-binding site of monomeric and homo-oligomeric USP from Drosophila melanogaster (dUSP). dUSP specifically bound juvenile hormone III (JH III), but not control farnesol or JH III acid, and also specifically changed in conformation upon binding of JH III in a fluorescence binding assay. Juvenile hormone III binding caused intramolecular changes in receptor conformation, and stabilized the receptor's dimeric/oligomeric quaternary structure. In both a radiometric competition assay and the fluorescence binding assay the synthetic JH III agonist methoprene specifically competed with JH III for binding to dUSP, the first demonstration of specific binding of a biologically active JH III analog to an insect nuclear receptor. The recombinant dUSP bound with specificity to a DR12 hormone response element in a gel shift assay. The same DR12 element conferred enhanced transcriptional responsiveness of a transfected juvenile hormone esterase core promoter to treatment of transfected cells with JH III, but not to treatment with retinoic acid or T3. The activity of JH III or JH III-like structures, but not structures without JH III biological activity, to bind specifically to dUSP and activate its conformational change, provide evidence of a terpenoid endogenous ligand for Ultraspiracle, and offer the prospect that synthetic, terpenoid structures may be discovered that can agonize or antagonize USP function in vivo.

Effects of mutations in the calcium-binding sites of recoverin on its calcium affinity: evidence for successive filling of the calcium binding sites

A molecule of the photoreceptor Ca(2+)-binding protein recoverin contains four potential EF-hand Ca(2+)-binding sites, of which only two, the second and the third, are capable of binding calcium ions. We have studied the effects of substitutions in the second, third and fourth EF-hand sites of recoverin on its Ca(2+)-binding properties and some other characteristics, using intrinsic fluorescence, circular dichroism spectroscopy and differential scanning microcalorimetry. The interaction of the two operating binding sites of wild-type recoverin with calcium increases the protein's thermal stability, but makes the environment around the tryptophan residues more flexible. The amino acid substitution in the EF-hand 3 (E121Q) totally abolishes the high calcium affinity of recoverin, while the mutation in the EF-hand 2 (E85Q) causes only a moderate decrease in calcium binding. Based on this evidence, we suggest that the binding of calcium ions to recoverin is a sequential process with the EF-hand 3 being filled first. Estimation of Ca(2+)-binding constants according to the sequential binding scheme gave the values 3.7 x 10(6) and 3.1 x 10(5) M(-1) for third and second EF-hands, respectively. The substitutions in the EF-hand 2 or 3 (or in both the sites simultaneously) do not disturb significantly either tertiary or secondary structure of the apo-protein. Amino acid substitutions, which have been designed to restore the calcium affinity of the EF-hand 4 (G160D, K161E, K162N, D165G and K166Q), increase the calcium capacity and affinity of recoverin but also perturb the protein structure and decrease the thermostability of its apo-form.