Plastocyanin binding to photosystem I as a function of the charge state of the metal ion: effect of metal site conformation

Light- and Redox-Dependent Force Spectroscopy Reveals that the Interaction between Plastocyanin and Plant Photosystem I Is Favored when One Partner Is Ready for Electron Transfer

Photosynthesis is a fundamental process that converts photons into chemical energy, driven by large protein complexes at the thylakoid membranes of plants, cyanobacteria, and algae. In plants, water-soluble plastocyanin (Pc) is responsible for shuttling electrons between cytochrome b6f complex and the photosystem I (PSI) complex in the photosynthetic electron transport chain (PETC). For an efficient turnover, a transient complex must form between PSI and Pc in the PETC, which implies a balance between specificity and binding strength. Here, we studied the binding frequency and the unbinding force between suitably oriented plant PSI and Pc under redox control using single molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS). The binding frequency (observation of binding-unbinding events) between PSI and Pc depends on their respective redox states. The interaction between PSI and Pc is independent of the redox state of PSI when Pc is reduced, and it is disfavored in the dark (reduced P700) when Pc is oxidized. The frequency of interaction between PSI and Pc is higher when at least one of the partners is in a redox state ready for electron transfer (ET), and the post-ET situation (PSI_Red-Pc_Ox) leads to lower binding. In addition, we show that the binding of ET-ready Pc_Red to PSI can be regulated externally by Mg²⁺ ions in solution.

Nanosecond Dynamics at Protein Metal Sites: An Application of Perturbed Angular Correlation (PAC) of γ-Rays Spectroscopy

Metalloproteins are essential to numerous reactions in nature, and constitute approximately one-third of all known proteins. Molecular dynamics of proteins has been elucidated with great success both by experimental and theoretical methods, revealing atomic level details of function involving the organic constituents on a broad spectrum of time scales. However, the characterization of dynamics at biomolecular metal sites on nanosecond time scales is scarce in the literature. The aqua ions of many biologically relevant metal ions exhibit exchange of water molecules on the nanosecond time scale or faster, often defining their reactivity in aqueous solution, and this is presumably also a relevant time scale for the making and breaking of coordination bonds between metal ions and ligands at protein metal sites. Ligand exchange dynamics is critical for a variety of elementary steps of reactions in metallobiochemistry, for example, association and dissociation of metal bound water, association of substrate and dissociation of product in the catalytic cycle of metalloenzymes, at regulatory metal sites which require binding and dissociation of metal ions, as well as in the transport of metal ions across cell membranes or between proteins involved in metal ion homeostasis. In Perturbed Angular Correlation of γ-rays (PAC) spectroscopy, the correlation in time and space of two γ-rays emitted successively in a nuclear decay is recorded, reflecting the hyperfine interactions of the PAC probe nucleus with the surroundings. This allows for characterization of molecular and electronic structure as well as nanosecond dynamics at the PAC probe binding site. Herein, selected examples describing the application of PAC spectroscopy in probing the dynamics at protein metal sites are presented, including (1) exchange of Cd²⁺ bound water in de novo designed synthetic proteins, and the effect of remote mutations on metal site dynamics; (2) dynamics at the β-lactamase active site, where the metal ion appears to jump between the two adjacent sites; (3) structural relaxation in small blue copper proteins upon ¹¹¹Ag⁺ to ¹¹¹Cd²⁺ transformation in radioactive nuclear decay; (4) metal ion transfer between two HAH1 proteins with change in coordination number; and (5) metal ion sensor proteins with two coexisting metal site structures. With this Account, we hope to make our modest contribution to the field and perhaps spur additional interest in dynamics at protein metal sites, which we consider to be severely underexplored. Relatively little is known about detailed atomic motions at metal sites, for example, how ligand exchange processes affect protein function, and how the amino acid composition of the protein may control this facet of metal site characteristics. We also aim to provide the reader with a qualitative impression of the possibilities offered by PAC spectroscopy in bioinorganic chemistry, especially when elucidating dynamics at protein metal sites, and finally present data that may serve as benchmarks on a relevant time scale for development and tests of theoretical molecular dynamics methods applied to biomolecular metal sites.

Long lived intermediate metal site structure upon binding of cadmium to plastocyanin

Perturbed angular correlation of gamma-rays (PAC) spectroscopy of cadmium substituted plastocyanin shows one dominant metal site configuration at pH 7.5. Lowering the pH to 4.8 a fraction of the molecules undergoes structural change and loses the bound cadmium ion. At pH 4.4 all plastocyanin is in the apo-form. Increasing the pH back to neutral pH values two distinct metal site coordination geometries were observed. One of the two signals is the same as that found initially at pH 7.5; the other form is stable for hours at 1 degrees C, indicating the existence of a long lived intermediate metal site structure. The cadmium ion is surrounded by the same ligands (His37, Cys84, His87 and Met92) in both forms, however the metal center in the long lived intermediate metal site structure can be best described by a larger His-metal-His angle.

Redox-State-Dependent Complex Formation between Pseudoazurin and Nitrite Reductase

Bacterial copper-containing nitrite reductase catalyzes the reduction of nitrite to nitric oxide as part of the denitrification process. Pseudoazurin interacts with nitrite reductase in a transient fashion to supply the necessary electrons. The redox-state dependence of complex formation between pseudoazurin and nitrite reductase was studied by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry. Binding of pseudoazurin in the reduced state is characterized by the presence of two binding modes, a slow and a fast exchange mode, with a K(d)(app) of 100 microM. In the oxidized state of pseudoazurin, binding occurs in a single fast exchange mode with a similar affinity. Metal-substituted proteins have been used to show that the mode of binding of pseudoazurin is independent of the metal charge of nitrite reductase. Contrary to what was found for other cupredoxins, protonation of the exposed His ligand to the copper of pseudoazurin, His81, does not appear to be involved directly in the dual binding mode of the reduced form. A model assuming the presence of a minor form of pseudoazurin is proposed to explain the behavior of the complex in the reduced state.

Transient binding of plastocyanin to its physiological redox partners modifies the copper site geometry

The transient complexes of plastocyanin with cytochrome f and photosystem I are herein used as excellent model systems to investigate how the metal sites adapt to the changes in the protein matrix in transient complexes that are involved in redox reactions. Thus, both complexes from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 (former Anabaena sp. PCC 7119) have been analysed by X-ray absorption spectroscopy. Our data are consistent with a significant distortion of the trigonal pyramidal geometry of the Cu coordination sphere when plastocyanin binds to cytochrome f, no matter their redox states are. The resulting tetrahedral geometry shows a shortening of the distance between Cu and the S(delta) atom of its ligand Met-97, with respect to the crystallographic structure of free plastocyanin. On the other hand, when plastocyanin binds to photosystem I instead of cytochrome f, the geometric changes are not significant but a displacement in charge distribution around the metal centre can be observed. Noteworthy, the electronic density around the Cu atom increases or decreases when oxidised plastocyanin binds to cytochrome f or photosystem I, respectively, thus indicating that the protein matrix affects the electron transfer between the two partners during their transient interaction.

pH-dependent structural change of reduced spinach plastocyanin studied by perturbed angular correlation of γ-rays and dynamic light scattering

In this study the pH-dependent structural changes of reduced spinach plastocyanin were investigated using perturbed angular correlation (PAC) of gamma-rays and dynamic light scattering (DLS). PAC data of Ag-substituted plastocyanin indicated that the coordinating ligands are two histidine residues (His37, His87) and a cysteine residue (Cys84) in a planar configuration, whereas the methionine (Met92) found perpendicular to this plane is not a coordinating ligand at neutral pH. Two slightly different conformations with differences in the Cys-metal ion-His angles could be observed with PAC spectroscopy. At pH 5.3 a third coordination geometry appears which can be explained as the absence of the His87 residue and the coordination of Met92 as a ligand. With DLS the aggregation of reduced plastocyanin could be observed below pH 5.3, indicating that not only the metal binding site but also the aggregation properties of the protein change upon pH reduction. Both the structural changes at the metal binding site and the aggregation are shown to be reversible. These results support the hypothesis that the pH of the thylakoid lumen has to remain moderate during steady-state photosynthesis and indicate that low pH induced aggregation of plastocyanin might serve as a regulatory switch for photosynthesis.

Photosystem I lacking the PSI-G subunit has a higher affinity for plastocyanin and is sensitive to photodamage

PSI-G is an 11 kDa subunit of PSI in photosynthetic eukaryotes. Arabidopsis thaliana plants devoid of PSI-G have a decreased PSI content and an increased activity of NADP(+) photoreduction in vitro but otherwise no obvious phenotype. To investigate the biochemical basis for the increased activity, the kinetic parameters of the reaction between PSI and plastocyanin were determined. PSI-G clearly plays a role in the affinity for plastocyanin since the dissociation constant (K(D)) is only 12 muM in the absence of PSI-G compared to 32 muM for the wild type. On the physiological level, plants devoid of PSI-G have a more reduced Q(A). This indicates that the decreased PSI content is due to unstable PSI rather than an adaptation to the increased activity. In agreement with this indication of decreased stability, plants devoid of PSI-G were found to be more photo-inhibited both at low temperature and after high light treatment. The decreased PSI stability was confirmed in vitro by measuring PSI activity after illumination of a thylakoid suspension which clearly showed a faster decrease in PSI activity in the thylakoids lacking PSI-G. Light response of the P700 redox state in vivo showed that in the absence of PSI-G, P700 is more reduced at low light intensities. We conclude that PSI-G is involved in the binding dynamics of plastocyanin to PSI and that PSI-G is important for the stability of the PSI complex.

NMR Analysis of the Transient Complex between Membrane Photosystem I and Soluble Cytochrome c6

A structural analysis of the surface areas of cytochrome c(6), responsible for the transient interaction with photosystem I, was performed by NMR transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy. The hemeprotein was titrated by adding increasing amounts of the chlorophyllic photosystem, and the NMR spectra of the free and bound protein were analyzed in a comparative way. The NMR signals of cytochrome c(6) residues located at the hydrophobic and electrostatic patches, which both surround the heme cleft, were specifically modified by binding. The backbones of internal residues close to the hydrophobic patch of cytochrome c(6) were also affected, a fact that is ascribed to the conformational changes taking place inside the hemeprotein when interacting with photosystem I. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first structural analysis by NMR spectroscopy of a transient complex between soluble and membrane proteins.

Amicyanin metal-site structure and interaction with MADH: PAC and NMR spectroscopy of Ag-, Cd-, and Cu-amicyanin

To investigate the structural control mechanisms in the metal site of amicyanin when interacting with MADH, redox-inactive Ag(+)- and Cd(2+)-substituted amicyanins were studied with perturbed angular correlations of gamma-rays (PAC) spectroscopy. PAC experiments on (111m)Cd-substituted amicyanin revealed two different metal-site structures, which are very likely in dynamic exchange on a ~5 ns timescale. Only one structure binds to MADH. The dissociation constants, K(d), are 9+/-2 microM with MADH(red) and 38+/-11 microM with MADH(ox), indicating that the Cd-amicyanin binding affinity is regulated by the MADH redox state. PAC experiments on (111)Ag-substituted amicyanin also showed two different forms of Ag-amicyanin, probably reflecting relaxation from Ag to Cd geometry. No binding of Ag-amicyanin to MADH could be observed with PAC, suggesting that the K(d) is larger than 43 microM, based on the 95% confidence limit. NMR revealed large chemical shift differences between native copper amicyanin and both metal-substituted forms. Affected residues are found up to 15 A away from the metal ion. The Ag(+)- and Cd(2+)-substituted amicyanins demonstrate no change in coordination as a function of pH, contrary to Cu(+)-amicyanin which shows protonation of the copper ligand His96 with p K(a)=6.8. It is concluded that, contrary to other blue copper proteins, Ag(+)-amicyanin is not a close mimic of Cu(+)-amicyanin, and that structural changes in the metal site have large effects on the affinity for the redox partner.

Comparison of the binding of cadmium(II), mercury(II), and arsenic(III) to the de novo designed peptides TRI L12C and TRI L16C

Designed alpha-helical peptides of the TRI family with a general sequence Ac-G(LKALEEK)(4)G-CONH(2) were used as model systems for the study of metal-protein interactions. Variants containing cysteine residues in positions 12 (TRI L12C) and 16 (TRI L16C) were used for the metal binding studies. Cd(II) binding was investigated, and the results were compared with previous and current work on Hg(II) and As(III) binding. The metal peptide assemblies were studied with the use of UV, CD, EXAFS, (113)Cd NMR, and (111m)Cd perturbed angular correlation spectroscopy. The metalated peptide aggregates exhibited pH-dependent behavior. At high pH values, Cd(II) was bound to the three sulfurs of the three-stranded alpha-helical coiled coils. A mixture of two species was observed, including Cd(II) in a trigonal planar geometry. The complexes have UV bands at 231 nm (20 600 M(-1) cm(-1)) for TRI L12C and 232 nm (22 600 M(-1) cm(-1)) for TRI L16C, an average Cd-S bond length of 2.49 A for both cases, and a (113)Cd NMR chemical shift at 619 ppm (Cd(II)(TRI L12C)(3)(-)) or 625 ppm (Cd(II)(TRI-L16C)(3)(-)). Nuclear quadrupole interactions show that two different Cd species are present for both peptides. One species with omega(0) = 0.45 rad/ns and low eta is attributed to a trigonal planar Cd-(Cys)(3) site. The other, with a smaller omega(0), is attributed to a four-coordinate Cd(Cys)(3)(H(2)O) species. At low pH, no metal binding was observed. Hg(II) binding to TRI L12C was also found to be pH dependent, and a 3:1 sulfur-to-mercury(II) species was observed at pH 9.4. These metal peptide complexes provide insight into heavy metal binding and metalloregulatory proteins such as MerR or CadC.