Revealing the Hidden Costs of Organization in Host-Guest Chemistry Using Chloride-Binding Foldamers and Their Solvent Dependence

Light- and Temperature-Controlled Hybridization, Chiral Induction and Handedness of Helical Foldamers

Helical foldamers have attracted much attention over the last decades given their resemblance to certain biomacromolecules and their potential in domains as different as pharmaceutics, catalysis and photonics. Various research groups have successfully controlled the right- or left- handedness of these oligomers by introducing stereogenic centers through covalent or non-covalent chemistry. However, developing helical structures whose handedness can be reversibly switched remains a major challenge for chemists. To date, such an achievement has been reported with light-responsive single-stranded foldamers only. Herein, we demonstrate that grafting a unidirectional motor onto foldamer strands constitutes a relevant strategy to i) control the single or double helical state of a foldamer, ii) switch on the chiral induction process from the motor to the helical strands and iii) select the handedness of double helical structures through photochemical and thermal stimulations.

Selective aqueous anion recognition in an anionic host

Water-soluble Fe4L4 4- cages can be synthesized in a multicomponent self-assembly process exploiting functionalized trigonal ligands, FeII salts, and water-soluble sulfonated formylpyridine components. The cages are soluble in purely aqueous solution and display an overall 4- charge, but are capable of binding suitably sized non-coordinating anions in the host cavity despite their anionic nature. Anions such as PF6 - or AsF6 - occupy the internal cavity, whereas anions that are too small (BF4 -) or too large (NTf2 -) are not encapsulated. The external anionic charge and sterically blocked ligand cores limit the exchange rate of bound anions, as no exchange is seen over a period of weeks with the anion-filled cages, and internalization of added PF6 - by an empty cage takes multiple weeks, despite the strong affinity of the cavity for PF6 - ions. In the future, this recognition mechanism could be used to control release of anions for environmental applications.

A New Bis-Urea Based Cage Receptor for Anions: Synthesis, Solid State Structures and Binding Studies

The synthesis and characterization of a novel bis-urea-based cage receptor for anions (3S,15S)-3,15,20,25-tetramethyl-1,4,6,12,14,17,20,25-octaazatricyclo[15.5.5.17.11]octacosa-7(28),10-diene-2,5,13,16-tetraone (L) is reported. L is a macro-bicyclic ligand built on the 1,7-dimethyl-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane scaffold to obtain a cage topology in which two ureido moieties have been inserted as binding sites for anions. L can interact with anion guests (G) via H-bonding; in particular, it binds both spherical (Cl-) and V-shaped anions (AcO-) as well as more complex carboxylate anions, such as the norfloxacin (Nor-). NMR experiments highlight that the interaction between L and G mainly occurs at the ureido moieties. L forms L-G adducts of 1 : 1 ([LG]-) and 1 : 2 ([LG2]2-) stoichiometry with Cl- and AcO-. Otherwise, in the case of Nor- only the formation of the [LG]- complex is observed. L shows higher formation constants values for [LAcO]- (2.9) and [LNor]- (3.6) than [LCl]- suggesting a stronger interaction with the carboxylate anions. In the solid state, three crystal structures of the HL⋅G species were obtained (G=Cl-, AcO-, ClO4 -) highlighting the H-bonding interaction between the chloride, acetate or perchlorate anions and the -NH functions of the ureido fragment. The comparison between the two parent open chain receptors (Lb-c) and L has been reported and discussed.

Probing Noncovalent Interaction Strengths of Host-Guest Complexes Using Negative Ion Photoelectron Spectroscopy

Noncovalent interactions (NCIs) are crucial for the formation and stability of host-guest complexes, which have wide-ranging implications across various fields, including biology, chemistry, materials science, pharmaceuticals, and environmental science. However, since NCIs are relatively weak and sensitive to bulk perturbation, direct and accurate measurement of their absolute strength has always been a significant challenge. This concept article aims to demonstrate the gas-phase electrospray ionization (ESI)-negative ion photoelectron spectroscopy (NIPES) as a direct and precise technique to measure the absolute interaction strength, probe nature of NCIs, and reveal the electronic structural information for host-guest complexes. Our recent studies in investigating various host-guest complexes that involve various types of NCIs such as anion-π, (di)hydrogen bonding, charge-separated ionic interactions, are overviewed. Finally, a summary and outlook are provided for this field.

Redox-Regulated and Guest-Driven Transformations of Aromatic Oligoamide Foldamers in Advanced Structures

In this study, we demonstrate that an aromatic oligoamide sequence assembles into a trimeric helix-turn-helix architecture with a disulfide linkage, and upon cleavage of this linkage, it reconstructs into an antiparallel double helix. The antiparallel double helix is accessible to encapsulate a diacid guest within its cavity, forming a 2:1 host-guest complex. In contrast, hydrogen-bonding interactions between the trimeric-assembled structure and guests induce a conformational shift in the trimeric helix, resulting in a cross-shaped double-helix complex at a 2:2 host-guest ratio. Interconversions between the trimeric helix and the antiparallel double helix, along with their respective host-guest complexes, can be initiated through thiol/disulfide redox-mediated regulation.

Visible-Light Driven Control Over Triply and Quadruply Hydrogen-Bonded Supramolecular Assemblies

Supramolecular polymers offer tremendous potential to produce new "smart" materials, however, there remains a need to develop systems that are responsive to external stimuli. In this work, visible-light responsive hydrogen-bonded supramolecular polymers comprising photoresponsive supramolecular synthons (I-III) consisting of two hydrogen bonding motifs (HBMs) connected by a central ortho-tetrafluorinated azobenzene have been characterized by DOSY NMR and viscometry. Comparison of different hydrogen-bonding motifs reveals that assembly in the low and high concentration regimes is strongly influenced by the strength of association between the HBMs. I, Incorporating a triply hydrogen-bonded heterodimer, was found to exhibit concentration dependent switching between a monomeric pseudo-cycle and supramolecular oligomer through intermolecular hydrogen bonding interactions between the HBMs. II, Based on the same photoresponsive scaffold, and incorporating a quadruply hydrogen-bonded homodimer was found to form a supramolecular polymer which was dependent upon the ring-chain equilibrium and thus dependent upon both concentration and photochemical stimulus. Finally, III, incorporating a quadruply hydrogen-bonded heterodimer represents the first photoswitchable AB type hydrogen-bonded supramolecular polymer. Depending on the concentration and photostationary state, four different assemblies dominate for both monomers II and III, demonstrating the ability to control supramolecular assembly and physical properties triggered by light.

Solvent effects in anion recognition

Anion recognition is pertinent to a range of environmental, medicinal and industrial applications. Recent progress in the field has relied on advances in synthetic host design to afford a broad range of potent recognition motifs and novel supramolecular structures capable of effective binding both in solution and at derived molecular films. However, performance in aqueous media remains a critical challenge. Understanding the effects of bulk and local solvent on anion recognition by host scaffolds is imperative if effective and selective detection in real-world media is to be viable. This Review seeks to provide a framework within which these effects can be considered both experimentally and theoretically. We highlight proposed models for solvation effects on anion binding and discuss approaches to retain strong anion binding in highly competitive (polar) solvents. The synthetic design principles for exploiting the aforementioned solvent effects are explored.

Dynamic mechanostereochemical switching of a co-conformationally flexible [2]catenane controlled by specific ionic guests

Responsive synthetic receptors for adaptive recognition of different ionic guests in a competitive environment are valuable molecular tools for not only ion sensing and transport, but also the development of ion-responsive smart materials and related technologies. By virtue of the mechanical chelation and ability to undergo large-amplitude co-conformational changes, described herein is the discovery of a chameleon-like [2]catenane that selectively binds copper(I) or sulfate ions and its associated co-conformational mechanostereochemical switching. This work highlights not only the advantages and versatility of catenane as a molecular skeleton in receptor design, but also its potential in constructing complex responsive systems with multiple inputs and outputs.

Solvent-Dependent Folding Behavior of a Helix-Forming Aryl-Triazole Foldamer

Aromatic foldamers make up a novel class of bioinspired molecules that display helical conformations and have functions that rely on control over their coil-helix folding preferences. While the folding has been extensively examined by experiment, it has rarely been paired with the types of atomic level insights offered by theory. We present the results of all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to examine the role of solvent polarity on driving the helical folding behavior of the aryl-triazole foldamer. The temperature-dependent enhanced sampling technique, replica-exchange MD simulations, was employed to understand the folding phenomena. The simulation results show that in a low polarity solvent (dichloromethane), the foldamer prefers to stay in the unfolded state. The unfolded state has four dipolar triazoles (5 D) in their favored all-anti geometries and favoring anti-parallel geometries. However, an increase in solvent polarity using acetonitrile resulted in solvophobic collapse, yielding the helically folded form as the predominant state. The folded helix has an all-syn geometry, with triazoles in parallel arrangements. Intermediate conformations with a mixture of syn and anti arrangements of the triazoles are of lower abundance in both the DCM and MeCN solvents. The chiral handedness of the helix observed experimentally is assigned as left-handed by correlation with computed electronic circular dichroism spectra using time-dependent density functional theory.

Macrocycles and Acyclic Cucurbit[n]urils as Pseudo[2]catenane Partners for Long-Acting Neuromuscular Blocks and Rapid Reversal In Vivo

Long-acting neuromuscular blocks followed by rapid reversal may provide prolonged surgeries with improved conditions by omitting repetitive or continuous administration of the neuromuscular blocking agent (NMBA), eliminating residual neuromuscular block and minimizing postoperative recovery, which, however, is not clinically available. Here, we demonstrate that imidazolium-based macrocycles (IMCs) and acyclic cucurbit[n]urils (ACBs) can form such partners by functioning as long-acting NMBAs and rapid reversal agents through a pseudo[2]catenation mechanism based on stable complexation with Ka values of over 109 M-1. In vivo experiments with rats reveal that, at the dose of 2- and 3-fold ED90, one IMC attains a duration of action corresponding to 158 or 442 min for human adults, covering most of prolonged surgeries. The block can be reversed by one ACB with recovery time significantly shorter than that achieved by sugammadex for reversing the block of rocuronium, the clinically most widely used intermediate-acting NMBA.

Steric and Geometrical Frustration Generate Two Higher-Order CuI12L8 Assemblies from a Triaminotriptycene Subcomponent

The use of copper(I) in metal-organic assemblies leads readily to the formation of simple grids and helicates, whereas higher-order structures require complex ligand designs. Here, we report the clean and selective syntheses of two complex and structurally distinct CuI12L8 frameworks, 1 and 2, which assemble from the same simple triaminotriptycene subcomponent and a formylpyridine around the CuI templates. Both represent new structure types. In T-symmetric 1, the copper(I) centers describe a pair of octahedra with a common center but whose vertices are offset from each other, whereas in D3-symmetric 2, the metal ions form a distorted hexagonal prism. The syntheses of these architectures illustrate how more intricate CuI-based complexes can be prepared via subcomponent self-assembly than has been possible to date through consideration of the interplay between the subcomponent geometry and solvent and electronic effects.

Switchable Metal-Ion Selectivity in Sulfur-Functionalised Pillar[5]arenes and Their Host-Guest Complexes

Nucleophilic substitution of pertosylated pillar[5]arene (P-OTs) with commercially available sulfur containing nucleophiles (KSCN, KSAc, and thiophenol), yields a series of sulfur-functionalised pillar[5]arenes. DLS results and SEM images imply that these pillararene macrocycles self-assemble in acetonitrile solution, while X-ray crystallographic evidence suggests solvent-dependent assembly in the solid state. The nature of the sulfur substituents decorating the rim of the pillararene controls binding affinities towards organic guest encapsulations within the cavity and dictates metal-ion binding properties through the formation of favorable S-M2+ coordination bonds outside the cavity, as determined by 1 H NMR and fluorescence spectroscopic experiments. Addition of a dinitrile guest containing a bis-triazole benzene spacer (btn) induced formation of pseudorotaxane host-guest complexes. Fluorescence emission signals from these discrete macrocycles were significantly attenuated in the presence of either Hg2+ or Cu2+ in solution. Analogous titrations utilizing the corresponding pseudorotaxanes alter the binding selectivity and improve fluorescence sensing sensitivity. In addition, preliminary liquid-liquid extraction studies indicate that the macrocycles facilitate the transfer of Cu2+ from the aqueous to the organic phase in comparison to extraction without pillar[5]arene ligands.

Solvent Acts as the Referee in a Match-Up Between Charged and Preorganized Receptors

The prevalence of anion-cation contacts in biomolecular recognition under aqueous conditions suggests that ionic interactions should dominate the binding of anions in solvents across both high and low polarities. Investigations of this idea using titrations in low polarity solvents are impaired by interferences from ion pairing that prevent a clear picture of binding. To address this limitation and test the impact of ion-ion interactions across multiple solvents, we quantified chloride binding to a cationic receptor after accounting for ion pairing. In these studies, we created a chelate receptor using aryl-triazole CH donors and a quinolinium unit that directs its cationic methyl inside the binding pocket. In low-polarity dichloromethane, the 1 : 1 complex (log K1 : 1 ~ 7.3) is more stable than neutral chelates, but fortuitously comparable to a preorganized macrocycle (log K1 : 1 ~ 6.9). Polar acetonitrile and DMSO diminish stabilities of the charged receptor (log K1 : 1 ~ 3.7 and 1.9) but surprisingly 100-fold more than the macrocycle. While both receptors lose stability by dielectric screening of electrostatic stability, the cationic receptor also pays additional costs of organization. Thus even though the charged receptor has stronger binding in apolar solvents, the uncharged receptor has more anion affinity in polar solvents.

The temperature-dependence of host-guest binding thermodynamics: experimental and simulation studies

The thermodynamic parameters of host-guest binding can be used to describe, understand, and predict molecular recognition events in aqueous systems. However, interpreting binding thermodynamics remains challenging, even for these relatively simple molecules, as they are determined by both direct and solvent-mediated host-guest interactions. In this contribution, we focus on the contributions of water to binding by studying binding thermodynamics, both experimentally and computationally, for a series of nearly rigid, electrically neutral host-guest systems and report the temperature-dependent thermodynamic binding contributions ΔGb(T), ΔHb(T), ΔSb(T), and ΔCp,b. Combining isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) measurements with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we provide insight into the binding forces at play for the macrocyclic hosts cucurbit[n]uril (CBn, n = 7-8) and β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) with a range of guest molecules. We find consistently negative changes in heat capacity on binding (ΔCp,b) for all systems studied herein - as well as for literature host-guest systems - indicating increased enthalpic driving forces for binding at higher temperatures. We ascribe these trends to solvation effects, as the solvent properties of water deteriorate as temperature rises. Unlike the entropic and enthalpic contributions to binding, with their differing signs and magnitudes for the classical and non-classical hydrophobic effect, heat capacity changes appear to be a unifying and more general feature of host-guest complex formation in water. This work has implications for understanding protein-ligand interactions and other complex systems in aqueous environments.

Steric Control over the Threading of Pyrophosphonates with One or Two Cyanostar Macrocycles during Pseudorotaxane Formation

The supramolecular recognition of anions is increasingly harnessed to achieve the self-assembly of supramolecular architectures, ranging from cages and polymers to (pseudo)rotaxanes. The cyanostar (CS) macrocycle has previously been shown to form 2 : 1 complexes with organophosphate anions that can be turned into [3]rotaxanes by stoppering. Here we achieved steric control over the assembly of pseudorotaxanes comprising the cyanostar macrocycle and a thread that is based, for the first time, on organo-pyrophosphonates. Subtle differences in steric bulk on the threads allowed formation of either [3]pseudorotaxanes or [2]pseudorotaxanes. We demonstrate that the threading kinetics are governed by the steric demand of the organo-pyrophosphonates and in one case, slows down to the timescale of minutes. Calculations show that the dianions are sterically offset inside the macrocycles. Our findings broaden the scope of cyanostar-anion assemblies and may have relevance for the design of molecular machines whose directionality is a result of relatively slow slipping.

Cooperativity in Photofoldamer Chloride Double Helices Turned On with Sequences and Solvents, Around with Guests, and Off with Light

Photofoldamers are sequence-defined receptors capable of switching guest binding on and off. When two foldamer strands wrap around the guest into 2:1 double helical complexes, cooperativity emerges, and with it comes the possibility to switch cooperativity with light and other stimuli. We use lessons from nonswitchable sequence isomers of aryl-triazole foldamers to guide how to vary the sequence location of azobenzenes from the end (F_END) to the interior (F_IN) and report their impact on the cooperative formation of 2:1 complexes with Cl^-. This sequence change produces a 125-fold increase from anti-cooperative (α = 0.008) for F_END to non-cooperative with F_IN (α = 1.0). Density functional theory (DFT) studies show greater H-bonding and a more relaxed double helix for F_IN. The solvent and guest complement the synthetic designs. Use of acetonitrile to enhance solvophobicity further enhances cooperativity in F_IN (α = 126) but lowers the difference in cooperativity between sequences. Surprisingly, the impact of the sequence on cooperativity is inverted when the guest size is increased from Cl^- (3.4 Å) to BF₄^- (4.1 Å). While photoconversion of interior azobenzenes was poor, the cis-cis isomer forms 1:1 complexes around chloride consistent with switching cooperativity. The effect of the guest, solvent, and light on the double-helix cooperativity depends on the sequence.

An amphiphilic macrocyclic acylhydrazone dimer: Facile synthesis and dual channel detection and removal of phthalate anion

Despite the large number of dicarboxylates' receptors, the dual channel ones capable of recognizing and removing of phthalate anion are rare and the task remains challenging. In this paper, a facilely synthesized amphiphilic macrocyclic acylhydrazone dimer (AMAD) can not only detect phthalate anion selectively, through both color changes and turn-on fluorescence in solution as well as in solid state, but is also able to remove it from either water or organic solvents. The current study paves the way for the search of more multiple functional receptors of dicarboxylates anions.

Engineered Binding Microenvironments in Halogen Bonding Polymers for Enhanced Anion Sensing

Mimicking Nature's polymeric protein architectures by designing hosts with binding cavities screened from bulk solvent is a promising approach to achieving anion recognition in competitive media. Accomplishing this, however, can be synthetically demanding. Herein we present a synthetically tractable approach, by directly incorporating potent supramolecular anion-receptive motifs into a polymeric scaffold, tuneable through a judicious selection of the co-monomer. A comprehensive analysis of anion recognition and sensing is demonstrated with redox-active, halogen bonding polymeric hosts. Notably, the polymeric hosts consistently outperform their monomeric analogues, with especially large halide binding enhancements of ca. 50-fold observed in aqueous-organic solvent mixtures. These binding enhancements are rationalised by the generation and presentation of low dielectric constant binding microenvironments from which there is appreciable solvent exclusion.

Selectivity Rule of Cryptands for Anions: Molecular Rigidity and Bonding Site

Cryptands utilize inside CH or NH groups as hydrogen bond (H-bond) donors to capture anions such as halides. In this work, the nature and selectivity of confined hydrogen bonds inside cryptands were computationally analyzed with the energy decomposition scheme based on the block-localized wavefunction method (BLW-ED), aiming at an elucidation of governing factors in the binding between cryptands and anions. It was revealed that the intrinsic strengths of inward hydrogen bonds are dominated by the electrostatic attraction, while the anion preferences (selectivity) of inner CH and NH hydrogen bonds are governed by the Pauli exchange repulsion and electrostatic interaction, respectively. Typical conformers of cages are classified into two groups, including the C_3(h) -symmetrical conformers, in which all halide anions are located near the centroids of cages, and the "semi-open" conformers, which exhibit shifted bonding sites for different halide anions. Accordingly, the difference in governing factors of selectivity is attributed to either the rigidity of cages or the binding site of anions for these two groups. In details, the C₃ conformers of NH cryptands can be enlarged more remarkably than the C_3(h) -symmetrical conformers of CH cryptands as the size of anion (ionic radius) increases, resulting in the relaxation of the Pauli repulsion and a dramatic reduction in electrostatic attraction, which eventually rules the selectivity of NH cryptands for halide anions. By contrary, the CH cryptands are more rigid and cannot effectively reduce the Pauli repulsion, which subsequently governs the anion preference. Unlike C₃ conformers whose rigidity determines the selectivity, semi-open conformers exhibit different binding sites for different anions. From F^- to I^- , the bonding site shifts toward the outside end of the pocket inside the semi-open NH cryptand, leading to the significant reduction of the electrostatic interaction that dominates the anion preference. Differently, binding sites are much less affected by the size of anion inside the semi-open CH cryptand, in which the Pauli exchange repulsion remains the key factor for the selectivity of inner hydrogen bonds.

Cyclo[2]carbazole[2]pyrrole: a preorganized calix[4]pyrrole analogue

A cyclo[2]carbazole[2]pyrrole (2) consisting of two carbazoles and two pyrroles has been synthesized by directly linking the carbazole 1- and 8-carbon atoms to the pyrrole α-carbon atoms. Macrocycle 2 is an extensively conjugated 16-membered macrocyclic ring that is fixed in a pseudo-1,3-alternate conformation. This provides a preorganized anion binding site consisting of two pyrrole subunits. ¹H NMR spectroscopic analysis revealed that only the two diagonally opposed pyrrole NH protons, as opposed to the carbazole protons, take part in anion binding. Nevertheless, cyclo[2]carbazole[2]pyrrole 2 binds representative anions with higher affinity in CD₂Cl₂ than calix[4]pyrrole (1), a well-studied non-conjugated tetrapyrrole macrocycle that binds anions via four pyrrolic NH hydrogen bond interactions. On the basis of computational studies, the higher chloride anion affinity of receptor 2 relative to 1 is rationalized in terms of a larger binding energy and a lower host strain energy associated with anion complexation. In the presence of excess fluoride or bicarbonate anions, compound 2 loses two pyrrolic NH protons to produce a stable dianionic macrocycle [2-2H]^2- displaying a quenched fluorescence.

One Hundred Carboxylate Receptors

This work presents a compilation of binding constant (logKass) values in DMSO-d6/H2O (0.5% m/m) for a variety of receptors with 12 carboxylate anions (formate, acetate, lactate, pivalate, sorbate, hexanoate, benzoate, glyphosate, glucuronate, ibuprofen, naproxen, and ketoprofen). A total of 489 logKass values are listed for 100 anion receptor molecules. Most logKass values originate from previously published articles, along with some values for previously unpublished receptor molecules, spanning a workflow of 8 years. The purpose of this study is to serve as a comprehensive information source for selecting suitable receptor candidates to be used in practical carboxylate sensing applications, such as constructing ion-selective electrodes (ISE-s). To support such decision making, all receptors are presented together with lipophilicity (logPo/w) data.

A Charge-Neutral Self-Assembled L2Zn2 Helicate as Bench-Stable Receptor for Anion Recognition at Nanomolar Concentration

The field of anion recognition chemistry is dominated by two fundamental approaches to design receptors. One relies on the formation of covalent bonds resulting in organic and often neutral host species, while the other one utilizes metal-driven self-assembly for the formation of charged receptors with well-defined nanocavities. Yet, the combination of their individual advantages in the form of charge-neutral metal-assembled bench-stable anion receptors is severely lacking. Herein, we present a fluorescent and uncharged double-stranded hydroxyquinoline-based zinc(II) helicate with the ability to bind environmentally relevant dicarboxylate anions with high fidelity in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) at nanomolar concentrations. These dianions are pinned between zinc(II) centers with binding constants up to 145 000 000 M^-1. The presented investigation exemplifies a pathway to bridge the two design approaches and combine their strength in one structural motif as an efficient anion receptor.

Dynamic Covalent Self-Assembly of Chloride- and Ion-Pair-Templated Cryptates

While supramolecular hosts capable of binding and transporting anions and ion pairs are now widely available, self-assembled architectures are still rare, even though they offer an inherent mechanism for the release of the guest ion(s). In this work, we report the dynamic covalent self-assembly of tripodal, urea-based anion cryptates that are held together by two orthoester bridgeheads. These hosts exhibit affinity for anions such as Cl- , Br- or I- in the moderate range that is typically advantageous for applications in membrane transport. In unprecedented experiments, we were able to dissociate the Cs⋅Cl ion pair by simultaneously assembling suitably sized orthoester hosts around the Cs+ and the Cl- ion.