Interplay between Orientation at Electrodes and Copper Activation of Thermus thermophilus Laccase for O2 Reduction

Integrated Experimental and Theoretical Investigation of Copper Active Site Properties of a Lytic Polysaccharide Monooxygenase from Serratia marcescens

In this paper, we employed a multidisciplinary approach, combining experimental techniques and density functional theory (DFT) calculations to elucidate key features of the copper coordination environment of the bacterial lytic polysaccharide monooxygenase (LPMO) from Serratia marcescens (SmAA10). The structure of the holo-enzyme was successfully obtained by X-ray crystallography. We then determined the copper(II) binding affinity using competing ligands and observed that the affinity of the histidine brace ligands for copper is significantly higher than previously described. UV-vis, advanced electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) techniques, including high-energy resolution fluorescence detected (HERFD) XAS, were further used to gain insight into the copper environment in both the Cu(II) and Cu(I) redox states. The experimental data were successfully rationalized by DFT models, offering valuable information on the electronic structure and coordination geometry of the copper center. Finally, the Cu(II)/Cu(I) redox potential was determined using two different methods at ca. 350 mV vs NHE and rationalized by DFT calculations. This integrated approach not only advances our knowledge of the active site properties of SmAA10 but also establishes a robust framework for future studies of similar enzymatic systems.

Copper homeostasis and copper-induced cell death： Novel targeting for intervention in the pathogenesis of vascular aging

Copper-induced cell death, also known as cuproptosis, is distinct from other types of cell death such as apoptosis, necrosis, and ferroptosis. It can trigger the accumulation of lethal reactive oxygen species, leading to the onset and progression of aging. The significant increases in copper ion levels in the aging populations confirm a close relationship between copper homeostasis and vascular aging. On the other hand, vascular aging is also closely related to the occurrence of various cardiovascular diseases throughout the aging process. However, the specific causes of vascular aging are not clear, and different living environments and stress patterns can lead to individualized vascular aging. By exploring the correlations between copper-induced cell death and vascular aging, we can gain a novel perspective on the pathogenesis of vascular aging and enhance the prognosis of atherosclerosis. This article aims to provide a comprehensive review of the impacts of copper homeostasis on vascular aging, including their effects on endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells, oxidative stress, ferroptosis, intestinal flora, and other related factors. Furthermore, we intend to discuss potential strategies involving cuproptosis and provide new insights for copper-related vascular aging.

High electrolyte concentration effect on enzymatic oxygen reduction

The nature, the composition and the concentration of electrolytes is essential for electrocatalysis involving redox enzymes. Here, we discuss the effect of various electrolyte compositions with increasing ionic strengths on the stability and activity towards O₂ reduction of the bilirubin oxidase from Myrothecium verrucaria (Mv BOD). Different salts, Na₂SO₄, (NH₄)₂SO₄, NaCl, NaClO₄, added to a phosphate buffer (PB) were evaluated with concentrations ranging from 100 mM up to 1.7 M. On functionalized carbon nanotube-modified electrodes, it was shown that the catalytic current progressively decreased with increasing salt concentrations. The process was reversible suggesting it was not related to enzyme leakage. The enzyme was then immobilized on gold electrodes modified by self-assembling of thiols. When the enzyme was simply adsorbed, the catalytic current decreased in a reversible way, thus behaving similarly as on carbon nanotubes. Enzyme mobility at the interface induced by a modification in the interactions between the protein and the electrode upon salt addition may account for this behavior. When the enzyme was covalently attached, the catalytic current increased. Enzyme compaction is proposed to be at the origin of such catalytic current increase because of shorter distances between the first copper site electron acceptor and the electrode.

Hydrogenase-based electrode for hydrogen sensing in a fermentation bioreactor

The hydrogen-based economy will require not only sustainable hydrogen production but also sensitive and cheap hydrogen sensors. Commercially available H₂ sensors are limited by either use of noble metals or elevated temperatures. In nature, hydrogenase enzymes present high affinity and selectivity for hydrogen, while being able to operate in mild conditions. This study aims at evaluating the performance of an electrochemical sensor based on carbon nanomaterials with immobilised hydrogenase from the hyperthermophilic bacterium Aquifex aeolicus for H₂ detection. The effect of various parameters, including the surface chemistry, dispersion degree and amount of deposited carbon nanotubes, enzyme concentration, temperature and pH on the H₂ oxidation are investigated. Although the highest catalytic response is obtained at a temperature around 60 °C, a noticeable current can be obtained at room temperature with a low amount of protein less than 1 μM. An original pulse-strategy to ensure H₂ diffusion to the bioelectrode allows to reach H₂ sensitivity of 4 μA cm^-2 per % H₂ and a linear range between 1 and 20%. Sustainable hydrogen was then produced through dark fermentation performed by a synthetic bacterial consortium in an up-flow anaerobic packed-bed bioreactor. Thanks to the outstanding properties of the A. aeolicus hydrogenase, the biosensor was demonstrated to be quite insensitive to CO₂ and H₂S produced as the main co-products of the bioreactor. Finally, the bioelectrode was used for the in situ measurement of H₂ produced in the bioreactor in steady-state.

Supramolecular assembly of benzophenone alanine and copper presents high laccase-like activity for the degradation of phenolic pollutants

Laccases are multicopper oxidases of significant importance for the degradation of phenolic pollutants. Because of the inherent defects of natural laccases in practical applications, herein, we discovered highly effective and non-cytotoxic laccase-like metallo-nanofibers based on the supramolecular assembly of single unnatural amino acid, benzophenone-alanine (BpA), in combination with copper ions. Structural analysis revealed that the catalytic BpA-Cu nanofibers possess a Cu(I)-Cu(II) electron transfer system similar to that in natural laccase. Our BpA-Cu nanofibers exhibit 4 times higher substrate affinity and 24% higher catalytic efficiency than the well-known high-performance industrialized laccase (Novozym 51003) in 2,4-dichlorophenol degradation. In addition, the BpA-Cu nanofibers were demonstrated to be stable (>75% residual activity) in long-term storage at a wide range of pH, ionic strength, temperature, ethanol, and water sample, and to be readily recovered for pollutant degradation, keeping 83% of the laccase activity after 10 catalytic recycles. Remarkably, the nanofibers displayed a wide substrate spectrum, detecting and degrading a variety of phenolic pollutants with high activity than other laccase mimics reported in the literature. Furthermore, the biocompatibility of the material was proved with cultured cells. These findings demonstrated the potential of BpA-Cu nanofibers in mimicking laccases for environmental remediation.

Gentle one-step co-precipitation to synthesize bimetallic CoCu-MOF immobilized laccase for boosting enzyme stability and Congo red removal

Laccase has received extensive attention in pollutant degradation due to its high efficiency and environmental friendliness, but free laccase has poor stability, easy inactivation, and difficulty in recycling, which limited its application. It was a smart strategy to construct a synergistic system for the efficient adsorption and degradation of pollutants by enzyme immobilization to improve the stability and recyclability of the enzyme. In this study, the materials were synthesized by a one-step co-precipitation method. With Cu-MOF as the main body, Co²⁺ was introduced to construct bimetallic CoCu-MOF as the protective carrier of the enzyme. The enzyme-carrying capacity and enzyme activity of Lac@CoCu-MOF were 2-fold and 3.5-fold higher than those of Lac@Cu-MOF, respectively. Lac@MOF composites had a good protective effect on enzyme in various interfering environments. At pH = 7, free laccase was completely inactivated and Lac@CoCu-MOF maintained 51.76% enzyme activity. In addition, the removal rate of Congo red by Lac@CoCu-MOF reached 90 % in 1 h at pH = 4 % and 95 % in 5 h at pH = 7, and the final TOC mineralization rate reached 86.05 %. After six cycles, the degradation rate of Lac@CoCu-MOF remained above 75 %. Therefore, Lac@CoCu-MOF was constructed with the advantages of enzyme immobilization (enhanced stability and easy operation), material adsorption, and biocatalysis (fast diffusion and high activity), which has great guiding significance for the industrial application of enzyme.

Biosensing Dopamine and L-Epinephrine with Laccase (Trametes pubescens) Immobilized on a Gold Modified Electrode

Engineering electrode surfaces through the electrodeposition of gold may provide a range of advantages in the context of biosensor development, such as greatly enhanced surface area, improved conductivity and versatile functionalization. In this work we report on the development of an electrochemical biosensor for the laccase-catalyzed assay of two catecholamines—dopamine and L-epinephrine. Variety of electrochemical techniques—cyclic voltammetry, differential pulse voltammetry, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and constant potential amperometry have been used in its characterization. It has been demonstrated that the laccase electrode is capable of sensing dopamine using two distinct techniques—differential pulse voltammetry and constant potential amperometry, the latter being suitable for the assay of L-epinephrine as well. The biosensor response to both catecholamines, examined by constant potential chronoamperometry over the potential range from 0.2 to −0.1 V (vs. Ag|AgCl, sat KCl) showed the highest electrode sensitivity at 0 and −0.1 V. The dependencies of the current density on either catecholamine’s concentration was found to follow the Michaelis—Menten kinetics with apparent constants K_M^app = 0.116 ± 0.015 mM for dopamine and K_M^app = 0.245 ± 0.031 mM for L-epinephrine and linear dynamic ranges spanning up to 0.10 mM and 0.20 mM, respectively. Calculated limits of detection for both analytes were found to be within the sub-micromolar concentration range. The biosensor applicability to the assay of dopamine concentration in a pharmaceutical product was demonstrated (with recovery rates between 99% and 106%, n = 3).

Modulating the adsorption orientation of methionine-rich laccase by tailoring the surface chemistry of single-walled carbon nanotubes

Achieving fast electron transfer process between oxidoreductase and electrodes is pivotal for the biocathode of enzymatic biofuel cells (EBFCs). However, in-depth understanding of the interplay mechanism between enzymes and electrode materials remains challenging when designing and constructing EBFCs. Herein, atomic-scale insight into the direct electron transfer (DET) behavior of Thermus thermophilus laccase (TtLac) with a special methionine-rich β-hairpin motif adsorbed on the carboxyl-functionalized carbon nanotube (COOH-CNT) and amino-functionalized carbon nanotube (NH₂-CNT) surfaces were disclosed by multi-scale molecular simulations. Simulation results reveal that electrostatic modification is an effective way to tune the DET behavior for TtLac on the modified-CNTs electrode surface. Surprisingly, the positively charged TtLac can be attracted by both negatively charged COOH-CNT and positively charged NH₂-CNT surfaces, yet only the latter is capable to trigger the DET process due to the 'lying-on' adsorption orientation. Specifically, the T1 copper site is near the methionine-rich β-hairpin motif, which is the key binding site for TtLac binding onto the NH₂-CNT surface via electrostatic interaction, π-π stacking and cation-π interaction. Moreover, TtLac on the NH₂-CNT surface undergoes less conformational changes than those on the COOH-CNT surface, which allows the laccase stability and catalytic efficiency to be well preserved. These findings provide a fundamental guidance for future design and fabrication of methionine-rich laccase-based EBFCs with high power output and long lifespan.

Engineering Electro- and Photocatalytic Carbon Materials for CO2 Reduction by Formate Dehydrogenase

Semiartificial approaches to renewable fuel synthesis exploit the integration of enzymes with synthetic materials for kinetically efficient fuel production. Here, a CO₂ reductase, formate dehydrogenase (FDH) from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough, is interfaced with carbon nanotubes (CNTs) and amorphous carbon dots (a-CDs). Each carbon substrate, tailored for electro- and photocatalysis, is functionalized with positive (-NHMe₂⁺) and negative (-COO^-) chemical surface groups to understand and optimize the electrostatic effect of protein association and orientation on CO₂ reduction. Immobilization of FDH on positively charged CNT electrodes results in efficient and reversible electrochemical CO₂ reduction via direct electron transfer with >90% Faradaic efficiency and -250 μA cm^-2 at -0.6 V vs SHE (pH 6.7 and 25 °C) for formate production. In contrast, negatively charged CNTs only result in marginal currents with immobilized FDH. Quartz crystal microbalance analysis and attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy confirm the high binding affinity of active FDH to CNTs. FDH has subsequently been coupled to a-CDs, where the benefits of the positive charge (-NHMe₂⁺-terminated a-CDs) were translated to a functional CD-FDH hybrid photocatalyst. High rates of photocatalytic CO₂ reduction (turnover frequency: 3.5 × 10³ h^-1; AM 1.5G) with dl-dithiothreitol as the sacrificial electron donor were obtained after 6 h, providing benchmark rates for homogeneous photocatalytic CO₂ reduction with metal-free light absorbers. This work provides a rational basis to understand interfacial surface/enzyme interactions at electrodes and photosensitizers to guide improvements with catalytic biohybrid materials.

Improving Orientation, Packing Density, and Molecular Arrangement in Self-Assembled Monolayers of Bianchoring Ferrocene-Triazole Derivatives by "Click" Chemistry

This work describes the self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of two ferrocene derivatives with two anchoring groups (at the bottom and at the top of the SAM) deposited on ultraflat template-stripped gold substrates by cyclic voltammetry and analyzed by complementary surface characterization techniques. The SAM of each molecule is deposited by three different protocols: direct deposition (one step), click reaction on the surface (two steps), and reverse click reaction on the surface (two steps). The SAM structure is well studied to determine the SAM orientation, SAM arrangement, and ferrocene position within the SAM. Electron transfer kinetics have also been studied, which agree with the quality of each SAM. With the help of two anchoring groups and click-chemistry active functional groups, we have shown that the two molecules can be deposited by controlling the position of ferrocene at either end. We further investigated the involvement of the triazole five-membered ring in the electron transfer mechanism. We have found that a carbon spacer between ferrocene and triazole improves the SAM packing. This study enhances the understanding of tethering thiol and thiol acetate anchoring groups on gold by a controlled orientation, which may help in the development of functional molecular devices requiring two anchoring groups.

Iron single-atom anchored N-doped carbon as a 'laccase-like' nanozyme for the degradation and detection of phenolic pollutants and adrenaline

To solve the inherent defects of laccase, the first iron single-atom anchored N-doped carbon material (Fe₁@CN-20) as a laccase mimic was disclosed. The FeN₄ structure of this material can well mimic the catalytic activity of laccase. Although Fe₁@CN-20 has a lower metal content (2.9 wt%) than any previously reported laccase mimics, it exhibits kinetic constants comparable to those of laccase, as its K_m (Michaelis constant) and V_max (maximum rate) are 0.070 mM and 2.25 µM/min respectively, which are similar to those of laccase (0.078 mM, 2.49 µM/min). This catalyst displays excellent stability even under extreme pH (2-9), high temperature (100 °C), strong ionic strength (500 mM of NaCl), high ethanol concentration (volume ratio 40%) and long storage time (2 months). Additionally, it can be reused for at least 7 times with only a slight loss in activity. Therefore, this material has a much lower price and better stability and recyclability than laccase, which has been applied in the detection and degradation of a series of phenolic compounds. In the detection of adrenaline, Fe₁@CN-20 achieved a detection limit of 1.3 µM, indicating it is more sensitive than laccase (3.9 µM).

Catalytic oxidative dehydrogenation of N-heterocycles with nitrogen/phosphorus co-doped porous carbon materials

A metal-free oxidative dehydrogenation of N-heterocycles utilizing a nitrogen/phosphorus co-doped porous carbon (NPCH) catalyst is reported. The optimal material is robust against traditional poisoning agents and shows high antioxidant resistance. It exhibits good catalytic performance for the synthesis of various quinoline, indole, isoquinoline, and quinoxaline ‘on-water’ under air atmosphere. The active sites in the NPCH catalyst are proposed to be phosphorus and nitrogen centers within the porous carbon network.

Green oxidations made easy. Metal-free dehydrogenation of N-heterocycles are possible in using N,P-co-doped porous carbon materials “on” water using air.

Facile synthesis of recyclable laccase-mineral hybrid complexes with enhanced activity and stability for biodegradation of Evans Blue dye

Two morphologies of laccase-mineral hybrid complexes, i.e., laccase-mineral hybrid nanoflowers (La-HNF) and nanopetals (La-HNP), were synthesized via biomineralization using Cu₃ (PO₄)₂·3H₂O as the mineral for Evans Blue (EB) dye biodegradation. XRD patterns and FT-IR spectra results revealed the successful immobilization of laccase via in-situ formed Cu₃(PO₄)₂·3H₂O crystals. Compared with free laccase, laccase-mineral hybrid complexes showed higher enzymatic activity due to the activation effect induced by copper ions of Cu₃(PO₄)₂·3H₂O, further, the improved kinetic parameters of laccase-mineral hybrid complexes could be ascribed to nanoscale-dispersed laccase molecules within hybrid complexes. For EB dye biodegradation, the reason why the biodegradation efficiency (94.9%) of La-HNF was higher than that (86.8%) of La-HNP could be synergistic effect of immobilized laccase within 3D hierarchical structure of La-HNF. In addition, the optimized biodegradation conditions (pH 4.6 and 40 °C) of La-HNF were obtained, moreover, 93.2% and 48.1% of EB dye were biodegraded by La-HNF after stored for 30 days and reused for 10 cycles, respectively, demonstrating La-HNF have good practicability.

From Enzyme Stability to Enzymatic Bioelectrode Stabilization Processes

Bioelectrocatalysis using redox enzymes appears as a sustainable way for biosensing, electricity production, or biosynthesis of fine products. Despite advances in the knowledge of parameters that drive the efficiency of enzymatic electrocatalysis, the weak stability of bioelectrodes prevents large scale development of bioelectrocatalysis. In this review, starting from the understanding of the parameters that drive protein instability, we will discuss the main strategies available to improve all enzyme stability, including use of chemicals, protein engineering and immobilization. Considering in a second step the additional requirements for use of redox enzymes, we will evaluate how far these general strategies can be applied to bioelectrocatalysis.

In Situ Spectroelectrochemical Investigations of Electrode-Confined Electron-Transferring Proteins and Redox Enzymes

This perspective analyzes recent advances in the spectroelectrochemical investigation of redox proteins and enzymes immobilized on biocompatible or biomimetic electrode surfaces. Specifically, the article highlights new insights obtained by surface-enhanced resonance Raman (SERR), surface-enhanced infrared absorption (SEIRA), protein film infrared electrochemistry (PFIRE), polarization modulation infrared reflection-absorption spectroscopy (PMIRRAS), Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), and differential electrochemical mass spectrometry (DMES)-based spectroelectrochemical methods on the structure, orientation, dynamics, and reaction mechanisms for a variety of immobilized species. This includes small heme and copper electron shuttling proteins, large respiratory complexes, hydrogenases, multicopper oxidases, alcohol dehydrogenases, endonucleases, NO-reductases, and dye decolorizing peroxidases, among other enzymes. Finally, I discuss the challenges and foreseeable future developments toward a better understanding of the functioning of these complex macromolecules and their exploitation in technological devices.

Mutations in the coordination spheres of T1 Cu affect Cu2+-activation of the laccase from Thermus thermophilus

Thermus thermophilus laccase belongs to the sub-class of multicopper oxidases that is activated by the extra binding of copper to a methionine-rich domain allowing an electron pathway from the substrate to the conventional first electron acceptor, the T1 Cu. In this work, two key amino acid residues in the 1st and 2nd coordination spheres of T1 Cu are mutated in view of tuning their redox potential and investigating their influence on copper-related activity. Evolution of the kinetic parameters after copper addition highlights that both mutations play a key role influencing the enzymatic activity in distinct unexpected ways. These results clearly indicate that the methionine rich domain is not the only actor in the cuprous oxidase activity of CueO-like enzymes.

Direct Electrochemical Enzyme Electron Transfer on Electrodes Modified by Self-Assembled Molecular Monolayers

Self-assembled molecular monolayers (SAMs) have long been recognized as crucial “bridges” between redox enzymes and solid electrode surfaces, on which the enzymes undergo direct electron transfer (DET)—for example, in enzymatic biofuel cells (EBFCs) and biosensors. SAMs possess a wide range of terminal groups that enable productive enzyme adsorption and fine-tuning in favorable orientations on the electrode. The tunneling distance and SAM chain length, and the contacting terminal SAM groups, are the most significant controlling factors in DET-type bioelectrocatalysis. In particular, SAM-modified nanostructured electrode materials have recently been extensively explored to improve the catalytic activity and stability of redox proteins immobilized on electrochemical surfaces. In this report, we present an overview of recent investigations of electrochemical enzyme DET processes on SAMs with a focus on single-crystal and nanoporous gold electrodes. Specifically, we consider the preparation and characterization methods of SAMs, as well as SAM applications in promoting interfacial electrochemical electron transfer of redox proteins and enzymes. The strategic selection of SAMs to accord with the properties of the core redox protein/enzymes is also highlighted.

Rational Surface Modification of Carbon Nanomaterials for Improved Direct Electron Transfer-Type Bioelectrocatalysis of Redox Enzymes

Interfacial electron transfer between redox enzymes and electrodes is a key step for enzymatic bioelectrocatalysis in various bioelectrochemical devices. Although the use of carbon nanomaterials enables an increasing number of redox enzymes to carry out bioelectrocatalysis involving direct electron transfer (DET), the role of carbon nanomaterials in interfacial electron transfer remains unclear. Based on the recent progress reported in the literature, in this mini review, the significance of carbon nanomaterials on DET-type bioelectrocatalysis is discussed. Strategies for the oriented immobilization of redox enzymes in rationally modified carbon nanomaterials are also summarized and discussed. Furthermore, techniques to probe redox enzymes in carbon nanomaterials are introduced.

Nanosecond Laser-Fabricated Monolayer of Gold Nanoparticles on ITO for Bioelectrocatalysis

Redox enzymes can be envisioned as biocatalysts in various electrocatalytic-based devices. Among factors that play roles in bioelectrochemistry limitations, the effect of enzyme-enzyme neighboring interaction on electrocatalysis has rarely been investigated, although critical in vivo. We report in this work an in-depth study of gold nanoparticles prepared by laser ablation in the ultimate goal of determining the relationship between activity and enzyme density on electrodes. Nanosecond laser interaction with nanometric gold films deposited on indium tin oxide support was used to generate in situ gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) free from any stabilizers. A comprehensive analysis of AuNP size and coverage, as well as total geometric surface vs. electroactive surface is provided as a function of the thickness of the treated gold layer. Using microscopy and electrochemistry, the long-term stability of AuNP-based electrodes in the atmosphere and in the electrolyte is demonstrated. AuNPs formed by laser treatment are then modified by thiol chemistry and their electrochemical behavior is tested with a redox probe. Finally, enzyme adsorption and bioelectrocatalysis are evaluated in the case of two enzymes, i.e., the Myrothecium verrucaria bilirubin oxidase and the Thermus thermophilus laccase. Behaving differently on charged surfaces, they allow demonstrating the validity of laser treated AuNPs for bioelectrocatalysis.

Electron Transfer via Helical Oligopeptide to Laccase Including Chiral Schiff Base Copper Mediators

The oxygen reduction efficiency of a laccase-modified electrode was found to depend on the chirality of the oligopeptide linker used to bind the enzyme to the surface. At the same time, the electron transfer between the cathode electrode and the enzyme is improved by using a copper(II) complex with amino-acid derivative Schiff base ligand with/without azobenzene moiety as a mediator. The increased electrochemical current under both O2 and N2 proves that both the mediators are active towards the enzyme.

Photo-Tunable Azobenzene-Anthraquinone Schiff Base Copper Complexes as Mediators for Laccase in Biofuel Cell Cathode

Induced chirality (achiral target in chiral matrix such as proteins) sometimes play a useful role in evaluating supramolecular systems involving biomolecules. Enzymatic fuel cells, which generate electricity via enzymatic redox reactions at electrodes hold a significant potential for sustainable power. Bacterial laccase, a multi-copper oxidase, was used in the cathodic compartment of the enzymatic biofuel cells because of its low redox potential. Three new salen Cu(II) complexes were designed and investigated as mediators. The Schiff base ligands consisted of both a redox-active (anthraquinone) and a photochromic (azobenzene) moiety. The interaction between laccase and a mediator was examined with induced circular dichroism (CD) and the docking tool to observe in which of the laccase domains the mediators bind as well as study the photo-induced tuning of both the cis-trans photoisomerization and orientation by the Weigert effect. Both the electrochemical and photochromic properties are also discussed and compared using density functional theory (DFT), time-dependent (TD)-DFT, and docking simulations.

Inhibition in multicopper oxidases: a critical review

This review critiques the literature on inhibition of O₂-reduction catalysis in multicopper oxidases like laccase and bilirubin oxidase and provide recommendations for best practice when carrying out experiments and interpreting published data.