Distribution of protein oxidation products in the proteome of thermally processed milk

Milk Whey Protein Fibrils-Effect of Stirring and Heating Time

Milk whey proteins, which are derived from skim milk through membrane filtration, exhibit valuable functional properties when transformed into a fibrillar form. This conversion enhances their suitability for various applications, including thickening, gelling, emulsification, and foaming. However, reported fibrillation methods have longer heating times, which may not be economical for the dairy industry. To address these challenges, the current study was undertaken with the objective of reducing the time required for fibril formation. In this study, 2% milk whey protein isolate (mWPI) solution at pH 2 was heated with static and stirring heating conditions at 80 °C for 20 h to convert milk whey proteins into fibrils. Fibrils were observed using the thioflavin T value, transmission electron microscopy, Tricine SDS-PAGE, rheology, and protein oxidation. Results suggest that stirring heating conditions with 14 h heating time produced fibrils with good morphology compared to static heating, showing a 6 h reduction compared to an earlier reported 80 °C for 20 h heating time. Also, stirring heating produced a uniform and homogeneous fibril solution compared to the static heating method. Gentle stirring during heating can also help to scale up fibril production in an industrial setup. The fibrillation method with processing intervention will help to produce fibrils with enhanced functionality at the pilot and industrial scales.

Effect of milk fat and its main fatty acids on oxidation and glycation level of milk

Milk is a highly nutritional food rich in protein and fat that is prone to deterioration by oxidation and glycation reactions at storage and processing. In this study, glycation products and lipid oxidation products contents in skim milk, whole milk, and milk fat simulation groups were determined to evaluate the effect of milk fat components on glycation at 120 °C for 60 min. The increase rate of carbonyl compound, main advanced glycation end products (AGEs) levels, and glycation sites number of α-casein and β-casein are higher in whole milk than that in skim milk, indicating that milk fat promoted protein glycation significantly. In milk fat simulation groups, oleic acid and linoleic acid (LA) were added to milk fat in skim milk proportionally, promoting the formation of glycation products; however, palmitic acid had no such effect. LA exhibited strong promotion on AGEs formation. Lipid oxidation radicals, protein carbonyl amine condensation, and carbonyl compound formation were critical factors for milk glycation, according to OPLS-DA results. Therefore, radicals of fat oxidation are speculated to trigger the early glycation, and carbonyl compounds of fat oxidation act as important intermediates of glycation, fat type, form, and its degradation rate, thus play essential roles in milk glycation.

Graphical abstract

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13197-022-05658-z.

Cross-linking reactions in food proteins and proteomic approaches for their detection

Various protein cross-linking reactions leading to molecular polymerization and covalent aggregates have been described in processed foods. They are an undesired side effect of processes designed to reduce bacterial load, extend shelf life, and modify technological properties, as well as being an expected result of treatments designed to modify raw material texture and function. Although the formation of these products is known to affect the sensory and technological properties of foods, the corresponding cross-linking reactions and resulting protein polymers have not yet undergone detailed molecular characterization. This is essential for describing how their generation can be related to food processing conditions and quality parameters. Due to the complex structure of cross-linked species, bottom-up proteomic procedures developed to characterize various amino acid modifications associated with food processing conditions currently offer a limited molecular description of bridged peptide structures. Recent progress in cross-linking mass spectrometry for the topological characterization of protein complexes has facilitated the development of various proteomic methods and bioinformatic tools for unveiling bridged species, which can now also be used for the detailed molecular characterization of polymeric cross-linked products in processed foods. We here examine their benefits and limitations in terms of evaluating cross-linked food proteins and propose future scenarios for application in foodomics. They offer potential for understanding the protein cross-linking formation mechanisms in processed foods, and how the inherent beneficial properties of treated foodstuffs can be preserved or enhanced.

Oxidation of Whey Proteins during Thermal Treatment Characterized by a Site-Specific LC-MS/MS-Based Proteomic Approach

Thermal treatment is often employed in food processing to tailor product properties by manipulating the ingredient functionality, but these elevated temperatures may accelerate oxidation and nutrient loss. Here, oxidation of different whey protein systems [α-lactalbumin (α-LA), β-lactoglobulin (β-LG), a mix of α-LA and β-LG (whey model), and a commercial whey protein isolate (WPI)] was investigated during heat treatment at 60-90 °C and a UHT-like treatment by LC-MS-based proteomic analysis. The relative modification levels of each oxidation site were calculated and compared among different heat treatments and sample systems. Oxidation increased significantly in protein systems after heating at ≥90 °C but decreased in systems with higher complexity [pure protein (α-LA > β-LG) > whey model > WPI]. In α-LA, Cys, Met, and Trp residues were found to be most prone to oxidation. In β-LG-containing protein systems, Cys residues were suggested to scavenge most of the reactive oxidants and undergo an oxidation-mediated disulfide rearrangement. The rearranged disulfide bonds contributed to protein aggregation, which was suggested to provide physical protection against oxidation. Overall, limited loss of amino acid residues was detected after acidic hydrolysis followed by UHPLC analysis, which showed only a minor effect of heat treatment on protein oxidation in these protein systems.

Alternatives to Cow’s Milk-Based Infant Formulas in the Prevention and Management of Cow’s Milk Allergy

Cow’s milk-based infant formulas are the most common substitute to mother’s milk in infancy when breastfeeding is impossible or insufficient, as cow’s milk is a globally available source of mammalian proteins with high nutritional value. However, cow’s milk allergy (CMA) is the most prevalent type of food allergy among infants, affecting up to 3.8% of small children. Hypoallergenic infant formulas based on hydrolysed cow’s milk proteins are commercially available for the management of CMA. Yet, there is a growing demand for more options for infant feeding, both in general but especially for the prevention and management of CMA. Milk from other mammalian sources than the cow, such as goat, sheep, camel, donkey, and horse, has received some attention in the last decade due to the different protein composition profile and protein amino acid sequences, resulting in a potentially low cross-reactivity with cow’s milk proteins. Recently, proteins from plant sources, such as potato, lentil, chickpeas, quinoa, in addition to soy and rice, have gained increased interest due to their climate friendly and vegan status as well as potential lower allergenicity. In this review, we provide an overview of current and potential future infant formulas and their relevance in CMA prevention and management.

Protein carbonylation in food and nutrition: a concise update

Protein oxidation is a topic of indisputable scientific interest given the impact of oxidized proteins on food quality and safety. Carbonylation is regarded as one of the most notable post-translational modifications in proteins and yet, this reaction and its consequences are poorly understood. From a mechanistic perspective, primary protein carbonyls (i.e. α-aminoadipic and γ-glutamic semialdehydes) have been linked to radical-mediated oxidative stress, but recent studies emphasize the role alternative carbonylation pathways linked to the Maillard reaction. Secondary protein carbonyls are introduced in proteins via covalent linkage of lipid carbonyls (i.e. protein-bound malondialdehyde). The high reactivity of protein carbonyls in foods and other biological systems indicates the intricate chemistry of these species and urges further research to provide insight into these molecular mechanisms and pathways. In particular, protein carbonyls are involved in the formation of aberrant and dysfunctional protein aggregates, undergo further oxidation to yield carboxylic acids of biological relevance and establish interactions with other biomolecules such as oxidizing lipids and phytochemicals. From a methodological perspective, the routine dinitrophenylhydrazine (DNPH) method is criticized not only for the lack of accuracy and consistency but also authors typically perform a poor interpretation of DNPH results, which leads to misleading conclusions. From a practical perspective, the biological relevance of protein carbonyls in the field of food science and nutrition is still a topic of debate. Though the implication of carbonylation on impaired protein functionality and poor protein digestibility is generally recognized, the underlying mechanism of such connections requires further clarification. From a medical perspective, protein carbonyls are highlighted as markers of protein oxidation, oxidative stress and disease. Yet, the specific role of specific protein carbonyls in the onset of particular biological impairments needs further investigations. Recent studies indicates that regardless of the origin (in vivo or dietary) protein carbonyls may act as signalling molecules which activate not only the endogenous antioxidant defences but also implicate the immune system. The present paper concisely reviews the most recent advances in this topic to identify, when applicable, potential fields of interest for future studies.

Regulation of Milk Protein Synthesis by Free and Peptide-Bound Amino Acids in Dairy Cows

Milk protein (MP) synthesis in the mammary gland of dairy cows is a complex biological process. As the substrates for protein synthesis, amino acids (AAs) are the most important nutrients for milk synthesis. Free AAs (FAAs) are the main precursors of MP synthesis, and their supplies are supplemented by peptide-bound AAs (PBAAs) in the blood. Utilization of AAs in the mammary gland of dairy cows has attracted the great interest of researchers because of the goal of increasing MP yield. Supplying sufficient and balanced AAs is critical to improve MP concentration and yield in dairy cows. Great progress has been made in understanding limiting AAs and their requirements for MP synthesis in dairy cows. This review focuses on the effects of FAA and PBAA supply on MP synthesis and their underlying mechanisms. Advances in our knowledge in the field can help us to develop more accurate models to predict dietary protein requirements for dairy cows MP synthesis, which will ultimately improve the nitrogen utilization efficiency and lactation performance of dairy cows.

Analysis of Protein Oxidation in Food and Feed Products

Food and feed proteins are subject to oxidation reactions during production, processing, and storage. Several individual oxidized amino acids have been described in model systems and food; however, protein oxidation in food is still mostly assessed by the analysis of protein carbonylation. In the present review, the chemistry of protein oxidation and its implications for protein functionality, food flavor, and nutritional physiology are briefly summarized. Limitations of generic methods targeting redox-relevant functional groups and properties of typical reaction products, such as the determination of protein carbonyls and fluorescence spectroscopy, are presented. Methods for the quantitation of individual oxidation products of susceptible amino acids, such as cysteine, methionine, phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan, are reported. Special regard is paid to limitations resulting from the required hydrolysis procedures and unintended formation of the analytes during sample pretreatment. If available, results from food analysis obtained by different methods are compared. Suggestions and requirements for future works on protein oxidation in food and nutrition are given.

Influence of seasonal variation and processing on protein glycation and oxidation in regular and hay milk

Climate and feeding influence the composition of bovine milk, which is further affected by thermal treatment inducing oxidation and Maillard reactions. This study aimed to evaluate season- and processing-related changes in the modified proteome of milk from two different feeding systems. Therefore, tryptic digests of regular and hay milk were analyzed by targeting 26 non-enzymatic modifications using LC-MS. Forty-five glycated, 48 advanced glycation endproduct (AGE-) modified, and 20 oxidized/carbonylated peptides representing 44 proteins were identified with lactosylation, formyllysine, and carboxymethyllysine being most common. The numbers and quantities of glycation- and oxidation-related modifications were similar between regular and hay milk and among seasons. The effects of pasteurization and ultra-high temperature (UHT) treatment were comparable for both milk types. In particular UHT treatment increased the numbers of identified modifications and the relative quantities of lactosylated peptides. The number of identified AGE-modified and oxidized residues increased slightly after UHT-treatment, but the contents were stable.

Characterization of macrophage stimulating compound in glycated whey protein concentrate

Whey, a by-product of cheese making, is a collection of several milk proteins and has functional and nutritional values. Whey protein concentrate (WPC) exhibits various functional effects by glycation. Studies to find sugar-binding sites in a protein having a functional effect are reported. However, it is rarely clear whether it confirms that glycated single protein exhibits the same effect of protein cluster. This study confirmed which protein sites are responsible for the effect of glycated WPC (G-WPC). β-Lactoglobulin (LG) was the major protein of G-WPC and glycated with lactose. The glycated LG increased the nitric oxide and cytokine secretion similar to G-WPC and peptide sequences of active compound was confirmed using the high molecular weight band of G-WPC. The K151 and K157 residues of LG were modified by glycation with sugar in common with G-WPC. These residues of glycated LG potentially contribute to the immune-modulation effect of G-WPC.

Whey proteins: targets of oxidation, or mediators of redox protection

Bovine whey proteins are highly valued dairy ingredients. This is primarily due to their amino acid content, digestibility, bioactivities and their processing characteristics. One of the reported bioactivities of whey proteins is antioxidant activity. Numerous dietary intervention trials with humans and animals indicate that consumption of whey products can modulate redox biomarkers to reduce oxidative stress. This bioactivity has in part been assigned to whey peptides using a range of biochemical or cellular assays in vitro. Superimposing whey peptide sequences from gastrointestinal samples, with whey peptides proven to be antioxidant in vitro, allows us to propose peptides from whey likely to exhibit antioxidant activity in the diet. However, whey proteins themselves are targets of oxidation during processing particularly when exposed to high thermal loads and/or extensive processing (e.g. infant formula manufacture). Oxidative damage of whey proteins can be selective with regard to the residues that are modified and are associated with the degree of protein unfolding, with α-Lactalbumin more susceptible than β-Lactoglobulin. Such oxidative damage may have adverse effects on human health. This review summarises how whey proteins can modulate cellular redox pathways and conversely how whey proteins can be oxidised during processing. Given the extensive processing steps that whey proteins are often subjected to, we conclude that oxidation during processing is likely to compromise the positive health attributes associated with whey proteins.

Quantitation of Methionine Sulfoxide in Milk and Milk-Based Beverages-Minimizing Artificial Oxidation by Anaerobic Enzymatic Hydrolysis

Protein oxidation in milk products may entail flavor changes through reactions at methionine residues. However, little is known about the extent of methionine oxidation in milk and milk products. In the present study, a method for quantitation of methionine, methionine sulfoxide, and methionine sulfone by a stable isotope dilution assay using HILIC-ESI-MS/MS was established. For the quantitation of protein-bound analytes, anaerobic enzymatic hydrolysis was optimized to suppress artificial methionine oxidation. Moreover, the method allowed for monitoring of artificial oxidation by coincubation of the labeled probe [²H₈]methionine. The percentage of oxidized methionine was low in UHT milk (up to 1.6%) and evaporated milk (up to 8.8%), but higher in beverages such as cocoa milk drinks (up to 19.0%) and coffee milk drinks (up to 32.8%), resulting in methionine sulfoxide concentrations of up to 6.7 g/kg protein in the latter. These products are important dietary sources of methionine sulfoxide. Model studies revealed that methionine residues can be oxidized strongly in the presence of phenolic compounds such as catechin, caffeic acid, and gallic acid, which are present in cocoa and coffee and may account for the high extent of oxidation in commercial samples.

Protein oxidation during temperature-induced amyloid aggregation of beta-lactoglobulin

Although the connection between protein oxidation, amyloid aggregation and diseases such as Alzheimer's is well known there is no information on such effects during preparation of beta-lactoglobulin fibrils. Different morphologies of amyloid aggregates of beta-lactoglobulin were prepared by incubation at pH 2 or pH 3.5 for up to 72 h. After 5 h, amyloid aggregates at pH 2 formed typical fibrils, which consisted of peptides. At pH 3.5, the amyloid aggregates were worm-like and consisted of intact protein. After 72 h, the building blocks at both pH values changed towards smaller peptides. The apparent tyrosine oxidation reached a maximum after 5 h at both pH values, whereas N-formylkynurenine and carbonyls increased continuously during 72 h. In case amyloid structures are used as edible material, the health related effects caused by protein oxidation needs to be considered.

Patterns of protein carbonylation during Medicago truncatula seed maturation

Seeds mainly acquire their physiological quality during maturation, whereas oxidative conditions reign within cells triggering protein carbonylation. To better understand the role of this protein modification in legume seeds, we compared by proteomics patterns of carbonylated proteins in maturing seeds of Medicago truncatula naturally desiccated or prematurely dried, a treatment known to impair seed quality acquisition. In both cases, protein carbonylation increased in these seeds, accompanying water removal. We identified several proteins whose extent of carbonylation varied when comparing natural desiccation and premature drying and that could therefore be responsible for the impairment of seed quality acquisition or expression. In particular, we focused on PM34, a protein specific to seeds exhibiting a high sensitivity to carbonylation and of which function in dicotyledons was not known before. PM34 proved to have a cellulase activity presumably associated with cell elongation, a process required for germination and subsequent seedling growth. We discuss the possibility that PM34 (abundance or redox state) could be used to assess crop seed quality.

Protein carbonylation sites in bovine raw milk and processed milk products

During thermal treatment of milk, proteins are oxidized, which may reduce the nutritional value of milk, abolish protein functions supporting human health, especially important for newborns, and yield potentially harmful products. The side chains of several amino acids can be oxidized to reactive carbonyls, which are often used to monitor oxidative stress in organisms. Here we mapped protein carbonylation sites in raw milk and different brands of pasteurized, ultra high temperature (UHT) treated milk, and infant formulas (IFs) after digesting the precipitated proteins with trypsin. Reactive carbonyls were derivatized with O-(biotinylcarbazoylmethyl)hydroxylamine to enrich the modified peptides by avidin-biotin affinity chromatography and analyze them by nanoRP-UPLC-ESI-MS. Overall, 53 unique carbonylated peptides (37 carbonylation sites, 15 proteins) were identified. Most carbonyls were derived from dicarbonyls (mainly glyoxal). The number of carbonylation sites increased with the harsher processing from raw milk (4) to pasteurized (16) and UHT milk (16) and to IF (24).

Dairy products and the Maillard reaction: A promising future for extensive food characterization by integrated proteomics studies

Heating of milk and dairy products is done using various technological processes with the aim of preserving microbiological safety and extending shelf-life. These treatments result in chemical modifications in milk proteins, mainly generated as a result of the Maillard reaction. Recently, different bottom-up proteomic methods have been applied to characterize the nature of these structural changes and the modified amino acids in model protein systems and/or isolated components from thermally-treated milk samples. On the other hand, different gel-based and shotgun proteomic methods have been utilized to assign glycation, oxidation and glycoxidation protein targets in diverse heated milks. These data are essential to rationalize eventual, different nutritional, antimicrobial, cell stimulative and antigenic properties of milk products, because humans ingest large quantities of corresponding thermally modified proteins on a daily basis and these molecules also occur in pharmaceuticals and cosmetics. This review provides an updated picture of the procedures developed for the proteomic characterization of variably-heated milk products, highlighting their limits as result of concomitant factors, such as the multiplicity and the different concentration of the compounds to be detected.

Methionine sulfoxide profiling of milk proteins to assess the influence of lipids on protein oxidation in milk

Methionine sulfoxide profiling revealed that protein oxidation in milk and milk products is not promoted by lipids.

Modified peptides as indicators for thermal and nonthermal reactions in processed milk

Site-specific relative quantification of β-lactoglobulin modifications in heated milk and dairy products was performed to determine their thermal and nonthermal origins and to evaluate marker candidates for milk processing. Therefore, formation kinetics of 19 different structures at 26 binding sites were analyzed by ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry with multiple reaction monitoring (UHPLC-MS/MS/MRM) after specific protein hydrolysis. The results indicate that (i) site-specific analysis of lactulosyllysine may be a more sensitive marker for mild heat treatment than its overall content; (ii) N(ε)-carboxymethyllysine, N-terminal ketoamide, and asparagine deamidation are of thermal origin and may be good markers for rather intensive heat treatment, whereas N(ε)-carboxyethyllysine reflects thermal and nonthermal processes; (iii) the relevance of methylglyoxal-derived arginine modifications is low compared to that of other modifications; (iv) oxidation of methionine and cysteine is a rather weak indicator of thermal impact; and (v) the tryptophan modifications formylkynurenine and kynurenine are of nonthermal origin and further degraded during processing.

Comprehensive analysis of nonenzymatic post-translational β-lactoglobulin modifications in processed milk by ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry

Nonenzymatic post-translational protein modifications (nePTMs) result in changes of the protein structure that may severely influence physiological and technological protein functions. In the present study, ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (UHPLC-ESI-MS/MS) was applied for the systematic identification and site-specific analysis of nePTMs of β-lactoglobulin in processed milk. For this purpose, β-lactoglobulin, which had been heated with lactose under conditions to force nePTM formation (7 d/60 °C), was screened for predicted modifications by using full scans and enhanced resolution scan experiments combined with enhanced product ion scans. Thus, the main glycation, glycoxidation, oxidation, and deamidation products of lysine, arginine, methionine, cysteine, tryptophan, and asparagine, as well as the N-terminus, were identified. Using these MS data, a very sensitive scheduled multiple reaction monitoring method suitable for the analysis of milk products was developed. Consequently, 14 different PTM structures on 25 binding sites of β-lactoglobulin were detected in different milk products.