Optimized Biorecognition of Cytochrome c 551 and Azurin Immobilized on Thiol-Terminated Monolayers Assembled on Au(111) Substrates

The thermodynamics of self-assembled monolayer formation: a computational and experimental study of thiols on a flat gold surface

A methodology based on molecular dynamics simulations is presented to determine the chemical potential of thiol self-assembled monolayers on a gold surface. The thiol de-solvation and then the monolayer formation are described by thermodynamic integration with a gradual decoupling of one molecule from the environment, with the necessary corrections to account for standard state changes. The procedure is applied both to physisorbed undissociated thiol molecules and to chemisorbed dissociated thiyl radicals, considering in the latter case the possible chemical potential of the produced hydrogen. We considered monolayers formed by either 7-mercapto-4-methylcoumarin (MMC) or 3-mercapto-propanoic acid (MPA) on a flat gold surface: the free energy profiles with respect to the monolayer density are consistent with a transition from a very stable lying-down phase at low densities to a standing-up phase at higher densities, as expected. The maximum densities of thermodynamically stable monolayers are compared to experimental measures performed with reference-free grazing-incidence X-ray fluorescence (RF-GIXRF) on the same systems, finding a better agreement in the case of chemisorbed thiyl radicals.

Study of n-Alkanethiol Self-Assembly Behavior on Iron Particles: Effect of Alkyl Chain Length and Adsorption Solvent on Resulting Iron-Based Magnetorheological Fluids

Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of organic molecules on metal surfaces are a type of inexpensive surface coating often used to improve metal substrate properties for sensors, electrochemistry, and nanofabrication applications. Iron, specifically, is one of the most commonly used metals, both as a pure metal and as an alloy due to its high conductivity, strong ferromagnetism, and low cost. However, magnetorheological fluids, which have shown impressive energy dampening in fields from civil infrastructure to biomedical devices utilizing iron dispersions, have suffered from low reliability and efficiency due to iron particle oxidation, corrosion, and settling. To understand the effect of self-assembled monolayers on iron and both the adsorbed particle's resistance against aggregation and performance impact, this work performs an in-depth study on alkanethiol-based self-assembled monolayers on iron particles. Adsorption of alkanethiols and the generation of SAMs on micron-sized iron particles were evaluated as a function of adsorption solvent polarity and alkanethiol chain length. Maximum alkanethiol loading, determined from appropriate isotherms, was found to strongly be a function of both parameters. Alkanethiol adsorption increased with increasing alkyl chain length and increasing solvent log P values in polar solvents. With respect to magnetorheologically relevant parameters, alkanethiol adsorption did not show any significant effect on both the magnetic properties of iron (as particles) and fluid on-state yield stress. The colloidal stability of n-alkanethiol adsorbed iron-based magnetorheological fluids (MRFs) was a function of both n-alkanethiol chain length and the iron particle adsorption solvent. MRFs composed of hexadecanethiol adsorbed iron prepared in polar solvents like methanol and ethanol showed excellent sedimentation stability compared to all other MRFs prepared in this study.

Nanomechanical Study of Enzyme: Coenzyme Complexes: Bipartite Sites in Plastidic Ferredoxin-NADP+ Reductase for the Interaction with NADP+

Plastidic ferredoxin-NADP⁺ reductase (FNR) transfers two electrons from two ferredoxin or flavodoxin molecules to NADP⁺, generating NADPH. The forces holding the Anabaena FNR:NADP⁺ complex were analyzed by dynamic force spectroscopy, using WT FNR and three C-terminal Y303 variants, Y303S, Y303F, and Y303W. FNR was covalently immobilized on mica and NADP⁺ attached to AFM tips. Force–distance curves were collected for different loading rates and specific unbinding forces were analyzed under the Bell–Evans model to obtain the mechanostability parameters associated with the dissociation processes. The WT FNR:NADP⁺ complex presented a higher mechanical stability than that reported for the complexes with protein partners, corroborating the stronger affinity of FNR for NADP⁺. The Y303 mutation induced changes in the FNR:NADP⁺ interaction mechanical stability. NADP⁺ dissociated from WT and Y303W in a single event related to the release of the adenine moiety of the coenzyme. However, two events described the Y303S:NADP⁺ dissociation that was also a more durable complex due to the strong binding of the nicotinamide moiety of NADP⁺ to the catalytic site. Finally, Y303F shows intermediate behavior. Therefore, Y303, reported as crucial for achieving catalytically competent active site geometry, also regulates the concerted dissociation of the bipartite nucleotide moieties of the coenzyme.

Dissecting the cytochrome c 2-reaction centre interaction in bacterial photosynthesis using single molecule force spectroscopy

The reversible docking of small, diffusible redox proteins onto a membrane protein complex is a common feature of bacterial, mitochondrial and photosynthetic electron transfer (ET) chains. Spectroscopic studies of ensembles of such redox partners have been used to determine ET rates and dissociation constants. Here, we report a single-molecule analysis of the forces that stabilise transient ET complexes. We examined the interaction of two components of bacterial photosynthesis, cytochrome c ₂ and the reaction centre (RC) complex, using dynamic force spectroscopy and PeakForce quantitative nanomechanical imaging. RC-LH1-PufX complexes, attached to silicon nitride AFM probes and maintained in a photo-oxidised state, were lowered onto a silicon oxide substrate bearing dispersed, immobilised and reduced cytochrome c ₂ molecules. Microscale patterns of cytochrome c ₂ and the cyan fluorescent protein were used to validate the specificity of recognition between tip-attached RCs and surface-tethered cytochrome c ₂ Following the transient association of photo-oxidised RC and reduced cytochrome c ₂ molecules, retraction of the RC-functionalised probe met with resistance, and forces between 112 and 887 pN were required to disrupt the post-ET RC-c ₂ complex, depending on the retraction velocities used. If tip-attached RCs were reduced instead, the probability of interaction with reduced cytochrome c ₂ molecules decreased 5-fold. Thus, the redox states of the cytochrome c ₂ haem cofactor and RC 'special pair' bacteriochlorophyll dimer are important for establishing a productive ET complex. The millisecond persistence of the post-ET cytochrome c ₂[oxidised]-RC[reduced] 'product' state is compatible with rates of cyclic photosynthetic ET, at physiologically relevant light intensities.

Vibrational Changes Induced by Electron Transfer in Surface Bound Azurin Metalloprotein Studied by Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy and Scanning Tunneling Microscopy

The copper protein azurin, due to the peculiar coupling of its optical and vibronic properties with electron transfer (ET) and its biorecognition capabilities, is a very promising candidate for bioelectronic, bio-optoelectronic and biosensor applications. However, a complete understanding of the fundamental processes relating azurin ET and its optical and vibronic characteristics with the charge transport mechanisms occurring in proteins bound to a conductive surface, the typical scenario for a biosensor or bioelectronic component, is still lacking. We studied azurin proteins bound to a gold electrode surface by scanning tunneling microscopy combined with tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (STM-TERS). Robust TER spectra were obtained, and the protein's vibronic response under optical excitation in resonance with its ligand-to-metal charge transfer band was found to be affected by the tunneling parameters, indicating a direct involvement of the active site vibrations in the electron transport process.

Multiscale sensing of antibody-antigen interactions by organic transistors and single-molecule force spectroscopy

Antibody-antigen (Ab-Ag) recognition is the primary event at the basis of many biosensing platforms. In label-free biosensors, these events occurring at solid-liquid interfaces are complex and often difficult to control technologically across the smallest length scales down to the molecular scale. Here a molecular-scale technique, such as single-molecule force spectroscopy, is performed across areas of a real electrode functionalized for the immunodetection of an inflammatory cytokine, viz. interleukin-4 (IL4). The statistical analysis of force-distance curves allows us to quantify the probability, the characteristic length scales, the adhesion energy, and the time scales of specific recognition. These results enable us to rationalize the response of an electrolyte-gated organic field-effect transistor (EGOFET) operated as an IL4 immunosensor. Two different strategies for the immobilization of IL4 antibodies on the Au gate electrode have been compared: antibodies are bound to (i) a smooth film of His-tagged protein G (PG)/Au; (ii) a 6-aminohexanethiol (HSC6NH2) self-assembled monolayer on Au through glutaraldehyde. The most sensitive EGOFET (concentration minimum detection level down to 5 nM of IL4) is obtained with the first functionalization strategy. This result is correlated to the highest probability (30%) of specific binding events detected by force spectroscopy on Ab/PG/Au electrodes, compared to 10% probability on electrodes with the second functionalization. Specifically, this demonstrates that Ab/PG/Au yields the largest areal density of oriented antibodies available for recognition. More in general, this work shows that specific recognition events in multiscale biosensors can be assessed, quantified, and optimized by means of a nanoscale technique.

Copolymers with acetyl-protected thiol pendant groups as highly efficient stabilizing agents for gold surfaces

We showed the potential of novel multifunctional sulfur-containing polymers as model ligands for the preparation of sub-5 nm gold nanoparticles.

Single-molecule dynamics and mechanisms of metalloregulators and metallochaperones

Understanding how cells regulate and transport metal ions is an important goal in the field of bioinorganic chemistry, a frontier research area that resides at the interface of chemistry and biology. This Current Topic reviews recent advances from the authors' group in using single-molecule fluorescence imaging techniques to identify the mechanisms of metal homeostatic proteins, including metalloregulators and metallochaperones. It emphasizes the novel mechanistic insights into how dynamic protein-DNA and protein-protein interactions offer efficient pathways via which MerR-family metalloregulators and copper chaperones can fulfill their functions. This work also summarizes other related single-molecule studies of bioinorganic systems and provides an outlook toward single-molecule imaging of metalloprotein functions in living cells.

Application of atomic force microscopy for characteristics of single intermolecular interactions

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) can be used to make measurements in vacuum, air, and water. The method is able to gather information about intermolecular interaction forces at the level of single molecules. This review encompasses experimental and theoretical data on the characterization of ligand-receptor interactions by AFM. The advantage of AFM in comparison with other methods developed for the characterization of single molecular interactions is its ability to estimate not only rupture forces, but also thermodynamic and kinetic parameters of the rupture of a complex. The specific features of force spectroscopy applied to ligand-receptor interactions are examined in this review from the stage of the modification of the substrate and the cantilever up to the processing and interpretation of the data. We show the specificities of the statistical analysis of the array of data based on the results of AFM measurements, and we discuss transformation of data into thermodynamic and kinetic parameters (kinetic dissociation constant, Gibbs free energy, enthalpy, and entropy). Particular attention is paid to the study of polyvalent interactions, where the definition of the constants is hampered due to the complex stoichiometry of the reactions.

An investigation of the effects of self-assembled monolayers on protein crystallisation

Most protein crystallisation begins from heterogeneous nucleation; in practice, crystallisation typically occurs in the presence of a solid surface in the solution. The solid surface provides a nucleation site such that the energy barrier for nucleation is lower on the surface than in the bulk solution. Different types of solid surfaces exhibit different surface energies, and the nucleation barriers depend on the characteristics of the solid surfaces. Therefore, treatment of the solid surface may alter the surface properties to increase the chance to obtain protein crystals. In this paper, we propose a method to modify the glass cover slip using a self-assembled monolayer (SAM) of functional groups (methyl, sulfydryl and amino), and we investigated the effect of each SAM on protein crystallisation. The results indicated that both crystallisation success rate in a reproducibility study, and crystallisation hits in a crystallisation screening study, were increased using the SAMs, among which, the methyl-modified SAM demonstrated the most significant improvement. These results illustrated that directly modifying the crystallisation plates or glass cover slips to create surfaces that favour heterogeneous nucleation can be potentially useful in practical protein crystallisation, and the utilisation of a SAM containing a functional group can be considered a promising technique for the treatment of the surfaces that will directly contact the crystallisation solution.

Interaction of p53 with Mdm2 and azurin as studied by atomic force spectroscopy

Azurin, a bacterial protein, can be internalized in cancer cells and induce apoptosis. Such anticancer effect is coupled to the formation of a complex with the tumour-suppressor p53. The mechanism by which azurin stabilizes p53 and the binding sites of their complex are still under investigation. It is also known that the predominant mechanism for p53 down-regulation implies its association to Mdm2, the main ubiquitin ligase affecting its stability. However, the p53/Mdm2 interaction, occurring at the level of both their N-terminal domains, has been characterized so far by experiments involving only partial domains of these proteins. The relevance of the p53/Mdm2 complex as a possible target of the anticancer therapies requires a deeper study of this complex as made up of the two entire proteins. Moreover, the apparent antagonist action of azurin against Mdm2, with respect of p53 regulation, might suggest the possibility that azurin binds p53 at the same site of Mdm2, preventing in such a way p53 and Mdm2 from association and thus p53 from degradation. By following the interaction of the two entire proteins by atomic force spectroscopy, we have assessed the formation of a specific complex between p53 and Mdm2. We found for it a binding strength and a dissociation rate constant typical of dynamical protein-protein interactions and we observed that azurin, even if capable to bind p53, does not compete with Mdm2 for the same binding site on p53. The formation of the p53/Mdm2/azurin ternary complex might suggest an alternative anti-cancer mechanism adopted by azurin.

A single-molecule force spectroscopy nanosensor for the identification of new antibiotics and antimalarials

An important goal of nanotechnology is the application of individual molecule handling techniques to the discovery of potential new therapeutic agents. Of particular interest is the search for new inhibitors of metabolic routes exclusive of human pathogens, such as the 2-C-methyl-D-erythritol-4-phosphate (MEP) pathway essential for the viability of most human pathogenic bacteria and of the malaria parasite. Using atomic force microscopy single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS), we have probed at the single-molecule level the interaction of 1-deoxy-D-xylulose 5-phosphate synthase (DXS), which catalyzes the first step of the MEP pathway, with its two substrates, pyruvate and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate. The data obtained in this pioneering SMFS analysis of a bisubstrate enzymatic reaction illustrate the substrate sequentiality in DXS activity and allow for the calculation of catalytic parameters with single-molecule resolution. The DXS inhibitor fluoropyruvate has been detected in our SMFS competition experiments at a concentration of 10 μM, improving by 2 orders of magnitude the sensitivity of conventional enzyme activity assays. The binding of DXS to pyruvate is a 2-step process with dissociation constants of k(off) = 6.1 × 10(-4) ± 7.5 × 10(-3) and 1.3 × 10(-2) ± 1.0 × 10(-2) s(-1), and reaction lengths of x(β) = 3.98 ± 0.33 and 0.52 ± 0.23 Å. These results constitute the first quantitative report on the use of nanotechnology for the biodiscovery of new antimalarial enzyme inhibitors and open the field for the identification of compounds represented only by a few dozens of molecules in the sensor chamber.

Methylene blue incorporation into alkanethiol SAMs on Au(111): effect of hydrocarbon chain ordering

A detailed polarization modulation infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy, scanning tunneling microscopy, and electrochemical study on methylene blue (MB) incorporation into alkanethiolate self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on Au(111) is reported. Results show that the amount of MB incorporated in the SAMs reaches a maximum for intermediate hydrocarbon chain lengths (C10-C12). Well-ordered SAMs of long alkanethiols (C > C12) hinder the incorporation of the MB molecules into the SAM. On the other hand, less ordered SAMs of short alkanethiols (C < or = C6) are not efficient to retain the MB incorporated through the defects. For C12 the amount of incorporated MB increases as the SAM disorder is increased. This information is essential to the design of efficient thiol-based Au vectors for transport and delivery of molecules as well as thiol-based Au devices for molecular sensing.

Self-assembled monolayers of thiols and dithiols on gold: new challenges for a well-known system

Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of alkanethiols and dialkanethiols on gold are key elements for building many systems and devices with applications in the wide field of nanotechnology. Despite the progress made in the knowledge of these fascinating two-dimensional molecular systems, there are still several "hot topics" that deserve special attention in order to understand and to control their physical and chemistry properties at the molecular level. This critical review focuses on some of these topics, including the nature of the molecule-gold interface, whose chemistry and structure remain elusive, the self-assembly process on planar and irregular surfaces, and on nanometre-sized objects, and the chemical reactivity and thermal stability of these systems in ambient and aqueous solutions, an issue which seriously limits their technological applications (375 references).

A combined atomic force microscopy imaging and docking study to investigate the complex between p53 DNA binding domain and Azurin

The tumor suppressor p53 interacts with the redox copper protein Azurin (AZ) forming a complex which is of some relevance in biomedicine and cancer therapy. To obtain information on the spatial organization of this complex when it is immobilized on a substrate, we have used tapping mode-atomic force microscopy (TM-AFM) imaging combined with computational docking. The vertical dimension and the bearing volume of the DNA binding domain (DBD) of p53, anchored to functionalized gold substrate through exposed lysine residues, alone and after deposing AZ, have been measured by TM-AFM. By a computational docking approach, a three-dimensional model for the DBD of p53, before and after addition of AZ, have been predicted. Then we have calculated the possible arrangements of these biomolecular systems on gold substrate by finding a good agreement with the related experimental distribution of the height. The potentiality of the approach combining TM-AFM imaging and computational docking for the study of biomolecular complexes immobilized on substrates is briefly discussed.

Functional Metalloproteins Integrated with Conductive Substrates: Detecting Single Molecules and Sensing Individual Recognition Events

In the past decade, there has been significant interest in the integration of biomaterials with electronic elements: combining biological functions of biomolecules with nanotechnology offers new perspectives for implementation of ultrasensitive hybrid nanodevices. In particular, great attention has been devoted to redox metalloproteins, since they possess unique characteristics, such as electron-transfer capability, possibility of gating redox activity, and nanometric size, which make them appealing for bioelectronics applications at the nanoscale. The reliable connection of redox proteins to electrodes, aimed at ensuring good electrical contact with the conducting substrate besides preserving protein functionality, is a fundamental step for designing a hybrid nanodevice and calls for a full characterization of the immobilized proteins, possibly at the single-molecule level. Here, we describe how a multitechnique approach, based on several scanning probe microscopy techniques, may provide a comprehensive characterization of different metalloproteins on metal electrodes, disclosing unique information not only about morphological properties of the adsorbed molecules but also about the effectiveness of electrical coupling with the conductive substrate, or even concerning the preserved biorecognition capability upon adsorption. We also show how the success of an immobilization strategy, which is of primary importance for optimal integration of metalloproteins with a metal electrode, can be promptly assessed by means of the proposed approach. Besides the characterization aspect, the complementary employment of the proposed techniques deserves major potentialities for ultrasensitive detection of adsorbed biomolecules. In particular, it is shown how sensing of single metalloproteins may be optimized by monitoring the most appropriate observable. Additionally, we suggest how the combination of several experimental techniques might offer increased versatility, real-time response, and wide applicability as a detection method, once a reproducible correlation among signals coming from different single-molecule techniques is established.

Docking and molecular dynamics simulation of the Azurin–Cytochrome c551 electron transfer complex

We coupled protein-protein docking procedure with molecular dynamics (MD) simulation to investigate the electron transfer (ET) complex Azurin-Cytochrome c551 whose transient character makes difficult a direct experimental investigation. The ensemble of complexes generated by the docking algorithm are filtered according to both the distance between the metal ions in the redox centres of the two proteins and to the involvement of suitable residues at the interface. The resulting best complex (BC) is characterized by a distance of 1.59 nm and involves Val23 and Ile59 of Cytochrome c551. The ET properties have been evaluated in the framework of the Pathways model and compared with experimental data. A 60 ns long MD simulation, carried on at full hydration, evidenced that the two protein molecules retain their mutual spatial positions upon forming the complex. An analysis of the ET properties of the complex, monitored at regular time intervals, has revealed that several different ET paths are possible, with the occasional intervening of water molecules. Furthermore, the temporal evolution of the geometric distance between the two redox centres is characterized by very fast fluctuations around an average value of 1.6 nm, with periodic jumps at 2 nm with a frequency of about 70 MHz. Such a behaviour is discussed in connection with a nonlinear dynamics of protein systems and its possible implications in the ET process are explored.