Comment on “Instability of the Al42− ‘All-Metal Aromaticʼ Ion and Its Implications”

Consistent Analytical Second Derivatives of the Kohn-Sham DFT Energy in the Framework of the Conductor-Like Screening Model through Gaussian Charge Distributions

The use of implicit solvation models such as the conductor-like screening model (COSMO) in quantum chemical calculations is very common, as both a rough estimate of solvation effects as well as a general tool for stabilizing ionic molecular structures. In order to generate a smooth potential energy surface as well as consistent gradients, it is necessary to apply the Gaussian charge model (GCM) for the COSMO charges. This work introduces an efficient implementation for consistent analytical second derivatives of the electronic energy with COSMO-GCM in the framework of the Kohn-Sham density functional theory. This is used to investigate the infrared spectroscopy of amino acids in aqueous solution, where the impact of pH on the molecular structure and vibrational spectra is examined. Furthermore, the structure and stability of selected all-metal aromatic cluster ions are assessed.

From six to eight Π-electron bare rings of group-XIV elements and beyond: can planarity be deciphered from the "quasi-molecules" they embed?

Ab initio molecular orbital theory is used to study the structures of six and eight π-electron bare rings of group-XIV elements, and even larger [n]annulenes up to C₁₈H₁₈, including some of their mono-, di-, tri-, and tetra-anions. While some of the above rings are planar, others are nonplanar. A much spotlighted case is cyclo-octatetraene (C₈H₈), which is predicted to be nonplanar together with its heavier group-XIV analogues Si₈H₈ and Ge₈H₈, with the solely planar members of its family having the stoichiometric formulas C₄Si₄H₈ and C₄Ge₄H₈. A similar situation arises with the six π-electron bare rings, where benzene and substituted ones up to C₃Si₃H₆ or so are planar, while others are not. However, the explanations encountered in the literature find support in ab initio calculations for such species, often rationalized from distinct calculated features. Using second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory and, when affordable (particularly tetratomics, which may allow even higher levels), the coupled-cluster method including single, double, and perturbative triple excitations, a common rationale is suggested based on a novel concept of quasi-molecules or the (3+4)-atom partition scheme. Any criticism of tautology is therefore avoided. The same analysis has also been successfully applied to even larger [n]annulenes, to their mixed family members involving silicon and germanium atoms, and to the C₁₈ carbon ring. Furthermore, it has been extended to annulene anions to check the criteria of the popular Hückel rule for planarity and aromaticity. Exploratory work on cycloarenes is also reported. Besides a partial study of the involved potential energy surfaces, equilibrium geometries and harmonic vibrational frequencies have been calculated anew, for both the parent and the actual prototypes of the quasi-molecules.

All-metal Baird aromaticity

We have proven that Baird's rule can also be applied to a series of all-metal species with both σ- and π-aromaticity.

Beyond organic chemistry: aromaticity in atomic clusters

We describe joint experimental and theoretical studies carried out collaboratively in the authors' labs for understanding the structures and chemical bonding of novel atomic clusters, which exhibit aromaticity.

Recent developments and future prospects of all-metal aromatic compounds

The usefulness of aromaticity/antiaromaticity concepts to foresee structural stability patterns and salient features of the electronic structure of small inorganic and all-metal rings has been put forward. A critical revision of the advances made in the theoretical methods to assess the aromaticity/antiaromaticity of these compounds has also been made. In particular, the performance of local versus non-local indices has been reviewed. Finally, the passivation of these rings has been put forward as a key issue in order to prevent them from collapsing into larger aggregates and to provide them protection against the environment.

Al4(2-); the anion-π interactions and aromaticity in the presence of counter ions

The influence of presence of counter ions and π-complexation with benzene on the bonding and magnetic properties of Al(4)(2-), the most studied all-metal cluster, is studied here. It is shown that complexation by either counter ions or benzene decreases the delocalization index between Al atoms and the magnitude of bond magnetizability, that is a Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules, QTAIM, -based magnetic index of aromaticity. Benzene forms two types of π-complexes with the Al(4) framework; CH-π (T-shaped) complexes and parallel π-π stacking (PPS) complexes. It is shown that variation in the π-charge of the Al(4) framework affects the relative stability of the T-shaped/PPS complexes. Free Al(4)(2-) forms a stable T-shaped anion-π complex with benzene but in the presence of cations, formation of PPS complexes is more favourable, energetically. It is suggested that this property could be used for designing molecular switches and tuneable anion sensors.