Risk assessment based on high-dose animal exposure experiments

Effects of Diuron [3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea] on the urinary bladder of male Wistar rats

Diuron (3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea) is a substituted urea herbicide widely used on agricultural crops such as soy, cotton and sugar cane. In a previous long-term study this herbicide exerted carcinogenic activity on the urinary bladder mucosa of male Wistar rats. In general, the genotoxic and mutagenic potentials of Diuron are considered to be negative. The present study aimed to evaluate the mode of action of Diuron on the urinary bladder mucosa of male Wistar rats. Six-week old male Wistar rats were fed pelleted Nuvilab diet mixed with Diuron at 125, 500 and 2500 ppm. As a positive control, 8.3% sodium saccharin (NaS) was fed in the diet. Preceding the sacrifice of the animals at the 20th week, urinary pH was measured and the genotoxic potential of Diuron was evaluated by the comet assay. Histological urothelial lesions in the urinary bladder and in the renal pelvis mucosa, cell proliferation/apoptosis evaluations, and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) of the urinary bladder mucosa were also performed. No DNA changes were found in urothelial or peripheral blood cells, and urinary pH was comparable to controls in all Diuron groups. In the urinary bladder urothelium, the incidence of simple hyperplasia (SH) by light microscopy was significantly increased (7/10; p<0.005) in the 2500 ppm Diuron group but not at the lower doses. By SEM, three of five animals treated with 2500 ppm Diuron showed urothelial cell necrosis and hyperplasia. In the renal pelvis, the incidence of SH was significantly increased in the Diuron 500 and 2500 ppm and in the NaS 8.3% groups. Cell proliferation was significantly increased in the Diuron 2500 ppm (p<0.05) and NaS 8.3% (p<0.05) groups. The results indicate that a high dietary concentration of Diuron is associated with urothelial necrosis and continuous regenerative cell proliferation that leads to urothelial hyperplasia.

Are dietary fiber-induced alterations in colonic epithelial cell proliferation predictive of fiber's effect on colon cancer?

Alterations in cell proliferation of the colon have been observed as a result of changes in amount and type of dietary fiber and in relation to risk of developing colon cancer. Although some human observational and intervention studies contribute to the database, most information results from experiments on rodents. Because of numerous contradictory reports linking dietary fiber, cell proliferation, and colon cancer, we undertook a critical review of existing methods in an attempt to explain the inconsistencies. Although there may be some individual types of dietary fiber that protect against chemically induced colon cancer, dietary fiber as a single entity does not appear to afford any consistent protection. Because of significant differences in experimental protocols among laboratories, it is not yet possible to state with certainty that increases in cell proliferation, induced by fiber consumption, are predictive of increased tumorigenesis. Much of what has been observed and interpreted as elevation of risk may simply be normal homeostatic changes in cell proliferation. Even though fermentation to short-chain fatty acids is a mechanistically attractive hypothesis to explain why fiber modulates cytokinetics, data do not consistently support short-chain fatty acids as biological intermediates in risk of colon cancer. The state of the art in this field has not yet progressed to the point where a clear effect of dietary fiber on cytokinetics and colon carcinogenesis can be assessed with any degree of certainty. Additional markers of apoptosis, differentiation, and cell-cell communication may be required for a more accurate analysis of the relation among fiber, cytokinetics, and colon cancer.

Potency grading in carcinogen classification

In 1992 the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development decided to harmonize carcinogen classification systems. A proposal for a harmonized classification system is currently being considered by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). In many countries, classification of a chemical as carcinogenic triggers labeling requirements. Implicit in the labeling requirements are often restrictions on the sale of consumer products and workplace regulations. Many of the current classification systems for carcinogens use a single concentration limit for the minimum concentration of a carcinogen in a preparation (mixture) that requires labeling. For high-potency carcinogens, one concentration limit may not adequately express the hazard, whereas for low-potency carcinogens, one limit may overestimate the hazard caused by the carcinogen in the preparation (mixture). The potency grading system discussed consists of three potency groups: high-, medium-, and low-potency carcinogens. It is envisioned that the different classes will trigger different labeling requirements. In the process of potency grading, a preliminary conclusion as to whether a substance shows high, medium, or low potency is initially based on a tumorigenic dose descriptor. The preliminary potency evaluation may then be modified after due consideration of a number of additional elements. These may include evaluation of the dose-response curve; site-, species-, strain-, and sex-specific activity; mechanisms including genotoxicity; mechanistic relevance to humans; toxicokinetics; and other factors. The potency grading system discussed is applicable to most carcinogen classification systems, including that currently being considered by the OECD.

Pesticide residues in food: investigation of disparities in cancer risk estimates

Much of the public perceives that exposure to synthetic pesticide residues in the diet is a major cause of cancer. The National Research Council (NRC), in a 1987 report, Regulating Pesticides in Food: The Delaney Paradox, evaluated cancer risks for 29 pesticides that are rodent carcinogens and estimated that the risks for 23 were greater than one-in-a-million. In contrast, our group has ranked possible carcinogenic hazards from a variety of human exposures to rodent carcinogens using the HERP (Human Exposure/Rodent Potency) index, and found that dietary residues of synthetic pesticides ranked low. This paper evaluates the disparities in these analyses by examining the two components of risk assessment: carcinogenic potency in rodents and human exposure. Potency estimates based on rodent bioassay data are shown to be similar whether calculated, as in the NRC report, as the regulatory q1* or as TD50. In contrast, estimates of dietary exposure to residues of synthetic pesticides vary enormously, depending on whether they are based on the Theoretical Maximum Residue Contribution (TMRC) calculated by the Environmental Protection Agency vs. the average dietary residues measured by the Food and Drug Administration in the Total Diet Study (TDS). The TMRC is the theoretical maximum human exposure anticipated under the most severe field application conditions, which are far greater than dietary residues measured in the TDS. Several independent exposure studies suggest that the FDA dietary residues are reasonable estimates of average human exposures, whereas TMRC values are large overestimates. Using standard methodology and measured dietary residues in the TDS, the estimate of excess cancer risk from average lifetime exposure to synthetic pesticide residues in the diet appears to be less than one-in-a-million for each of the ten pesticides for which adequate data were available.

Elemental carbon-based method for occupational monitoring of particulate diesel exhaust: methodology and exposure issues

Diesel exhaust has been classified a probable human carcinogen, and the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) has recommended that employers reduce workers' exposures. Because diesel exhaust is a chemically complex mixture containing thousands of compounds, some measure of exposure must be selected. Previously used methods involving gravimetry or analysis of the soluble organic fraction of diesel soot lack adequate sensitivity and selectivity for low-level determination of particulate diesel exhaust; a new analytical approach was therefore needed. In this paper, results of investigation of a thermal-optical technique for the analysis of the carbonaceous fraction of particulate diesel exhaust are discussed. With this technique, speciation of organic and elemental carbon is accomplished through temperature and atmosphere control and by an optical feature that corrects for pyrolytically generated carbon, or "char,' which is formed during the analysis of some materials. The thermal-optical method was selected because the instrument has desirable design features not present in other carbon analysers. Although various carbon types are determined by the method, elemental carbon is the superior marker of diesel particulate matter because elemental carbon constitutes a large fraction of the particulate mass, it can be quantified at low levels and its only significant source in most workplaces is the diesel engine. Exposure-related issues and sampling methods for particulate diesel exhaust also are discussed.

Saccharin mechanistic data and risk assessment: urine composition, enhanced cell proliferation, and tumor promotion

Sodium saccharin (NaSac) produces bladder tumors consistently in male rats only after lifetime exposure that begins at birth. NaSac is not metabolized and is negative in most genotoxicity tests. NaSac-induced cell damage and proliferation have been proposed as important factors in tumor promotion, and dose-response information demonstrating a threshold for these parameters is available. One theory proposes that high levels of NaSac, combined with protein in a high Na+, high pH environment found only in the male rat, form toxic microscopic crystals; therefore, NaSac-induced tumors may not be relevant to human carcinogenesis.

Role of cell proliferation in regenerative and neoplastic disease

DNA replication does not have 100% fidelity. Consequently, a chemical can increase the risk of cancer either by directly damaging DNA (genotoxic) or by increasing the number of cell replications, or both. Increased cell proliferation can be produced by increasing cell births (by direct mitogenesis or regeneration following toxicity), or decreasing cell deaths (by inhibiting apoptosis or differentiation). Cell proliferation can affect the dose-response curve for genotoxic carcinogens and is the basis for carcinogenicity by nongenotoxic agents. Bladder carcinogens will be used to illustrate these mechanisms, and their implications with respect to human risk assessment will be presented.

Cell proliferation in the bladder and implications for cancer risk assessment

Chemicals can increase carcinogenic risk by either directly damaging DNA or increasing cell replication or they can do both. These effects have different implications for a biologically-based extrapolation from rodent bioassays to humans. 2-Acetylaminofluorene (2-AAF) administered at low doses to mice for a lifetime has a different dose-response for the liver (approximately linear) compared to the urinary bladder (apparent no effect dose of 45 ppm with a sigmoidal dose response at 60-150 ppm), which can be explained if carcinogen metabolism, DNA adduct formation and cell proliferation effects are considered. In contrast to 2-AAF and other genotoxic chemicals, chemicals which form calculi in the urine do not generally damage DNA directly but increase cell proliferation dramatically by eroding the bladder surface, leading to regenerative hyperplasia. This occurs only at doses at which calculi form; lower doses do not produce calculi and, therefore, do not increase cell proliferation or cause tumors. Extrapolation to humans from the rodent bioassay should be dependent on dose requirements for formation of calculi rather than any type of statistical extrapolation to lower doses. Saccharin and other sodium salts administered at high doses to rats also produce bladder cancer by increasing cell proliferation. These salts do not affect mice, hamsters, guinea pig or monkeys. Based on dose and mechanistic considerations, saccharin and these other sodium salts are unlikely to be human carcinogens. Extrapolation to possible human cancer risk requires biological determinations rather than simply using statistical formulations.

Role of urinary physiology and chemistry in bladder carcinogenesis

Urine is a complex mixture of numerous substances, only some of which are described above. Literally thousands of substances have been identified in normal urine, including a variety of ions, non-ionic substances and macromolecules. Their presence and concentrations are highly variable, dependent on fluid intake and on nutritional, physiological and biochemical influences. Marked diurnal variations exist. Methodologies involved in the collection and analysis of these components can greatly influence the interpretation of the results. The influence of these various parameters in the urine on bladder carcinogenicity can be either direct or indirect. A major difficulty in studying this aspect of urothelial carcinogenesis is that it is essentially impossible to alter only one variable in the urine at a time. Alteration of any one variable results in physiological alteration of several other of the constituents in the urine. In addition, the processes involved in urothelial carcinogenesis frequently involve a complex interaction of multiple variables, such as volume, osmolality, cationic concentration, anionic concentration, quantitative and qualitative differences in protein, and generation of precipitate, crystals or calculi. Thus, it is likely that the actual mechanisms involved in the carcinogenic process with many of these chemicals, particularly those that are non-genotoxic, will involve a complex interaction of several constituents of the urine. Although this poses a formidable obstacle to our understanding in experimental situations as well as in extrapolating to humans, the role of specific factors appears to be discernible and should offer insight into the risk assessment process (Cohen and Ellwein, 1991 a,b and 1992).

Rodent bladder tumors do not always predict for humans

Dr. David Clayson, 20 years ago, suggested that chemicals which lead to the formation of calculi in rodents might pose an artifact with respect to extrapolation to potential carcinogenic risk to humans. We reviewed what has been learned about the role of calculi in urinary bladder carcinogenesis in the ensuing 20 years, along with several examples. Formation of microcrystalluria and amorphous precipitate also poses problems in interpretation and examples are described. The chemicals producing these solid urinary materials are non-genotoxic, with marked increase in cell proliferation being the mode of action by which they are able to produce cancer in long-term rodent bioassays.

Relationship of DNA adducts derived from 2-acetylaminofluorene to cell proliferation and the induction of rodent liver and bladder tumors

Pharmacokinetic models have been developed to assist in extrapolating results from rodent bioassays. However, in numerous circumstances, it is necessary to combine such models with cellular response models to fully define interspecies and dose extrapolations. Interactions between pharmacokinetic target tissue end points (DNA adduct formation) and cellular proliferation in liver and urinary bladder carcinogenesis is illustrated with the results from the ED01 study involving 2-acetylaminofluorene administered to female mice. The interaction of genotoxic and cell proliferative effects are also illustrated in a co-carcinogenesis study with low doses of N-[4-(5-nitro-2-furyl)-2-thiazolyl]formamide and high doses of sodium saccharin. The application of such interactions to humans is illustrated for the case of cigarette smoke-induced bladder cancer.

Mechanisms of non-genotoxic carcinogenesis

Until recently, the mechanism of carcinogenesis has been regarded as a two-stage phenomenon involving damage to the genetic material, which initiates the process, followed by a cell-division stimulus, which promotes the development of the tumour. However, exposure to some chemicals has been shown to result in carcinogenesis without involvement of the initiation step. The mechanism of non-genotoxic carcinogenesis is not fully understood, but is believed to involve stimulation of cell division with a consequent increased probability of a mutation occurring spontaneously. In this article, Ian Shaw and Huw Jones review the theories of non-genotoxic carcinogenesis with reference to specific examples of known non-genotoxic carcinogens.

Protein restriction (PR) and caloric restriction (CR) compared: effects on DNA damage, carcinogenesis, and oxidative damage

Protein restriction (PR) and caloric restriction (CR) similarly impinge upon various physiological factors that can significantly inhibit the growth of DNA-damaged tissue and, therefore, carcinogenesis. Whether this effect is largely, or only in part, due to simple inhibition of body weight gain is examined. Among their many other health-improving effects, PR and CR delay the onset of puberty. It has been suggested that animals have developed mechanisms to cope with lean periods and that, when food is limited, resources are diverted from those physiological functions that offer no benefit for immediate survival (e.g., reproductive capacity) to thereby support an increase in the maintenance functions that prolong life. PR has also been shown to affect numerous other varied mechanisms that can affect carcinogenesis, including gene expression and metabolism of xenobiotics. The effects of PR on initiational and promotional growth of DNA-damaged tissue is also discussed. PR also seems to boost antioxidant defenses and inhibit the accumulation of oxidative damage (as does CR). Protein restricted animals have been shown to accumulate more calories, but develop fewer preneoplastic lesions and tumors than their high-protein counterparts. This observation seems quite counter to most ideas about dietary restrictions and CR. Despite the fact that both PR and CR induce many beneficial physiological effects in common, it is possible that PR is the more feasible option for human consideration. The levels of PR likely to improve health without negative side effects are discussed.