Degradation of MyoD by the ubiquitin pathway: regulation by specific DNA-binding and identification of a novel site for ubiquitination

Deubiquitinases in muscle physiology and disorders

In vivo, muscle and neuronal cells are post-mitotic, and their function is predominantly regulated by proteostasis, a multilayer molecular process that maintains a delicate balance of protein homeostasis. The ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS) is a key regulator of proteostasis. A dysfunctional UPS is a hallmark of muscle ageing and is often impacted in neuromuscular disorders (NMDs). Malfunction of the UPS often results in aberrant protein accumulation which can lead to protein aggregation and/or mis-localization affecting its function. Deubiquitinating enzymes (DUBs) are key players in the UPS, controlling protein turnover and maintaining the free ubiquitin pool. Several mutations in DUB encoding genes are linked to human NMDs, such as ATXN3, OTUD7A, UCHL1 and USP14, whilst other NMDs are associated with dysregulation of DUB expression. USP5, USP9X and USP14 are implicated in synaptic transmission and remodeling at the neuromuscular junction. Mice lacking USP19 show increased maintenance of lean muscle mass. In this review, we highlight the involvement of DUBs in muscle physiology and NMDs, particularly in processes affecting muscle regeneration, degeneration and inflammation following muscle injury. DUBs have recently garnered much respect as promising drug targets, and their roles in muscle maturation, regeneration and degeneration may provide the framework for novel therapeutics to treat muscular disorders including NMDs, sarcopenia and cachexia.

NEDD4 Regulates PAX7 Levels Promoting Activation of the Differentiation Program in Skeletal Muscle Precursors

The transcription factor Pax7 regulates skeletal muscle stem cell (satellite cells) specification and maintenance through various mechanisms, including repressing the activity of the muscle regulatory factor MyoD. Hence, Pax7-to-MyoD protein ratios can determine maintenance of the committed-undifferentiated state or activation of the differentiation program. Pax7 expression decreases sharply in differentiating myoblasts but is maintained in cells (re)acquiring quiescence, yet the mechanisms regulating Pax7 levels based on differentiation status are not well understood. Here we show that Pax7 levels are directly regulated by the ubiquitin-ligase Nedd4. Our results indicate that Nedd4 is expressed in quiescent and activated satellite cells, that Nedd4 and Pax7 physically interact during early muscle differentiation-correlating with Pax7 ubiquitination and decline-and that Nedd4 loss of function prevented this effect. Furthermore, even transient nuclear accumulation of Nedd4 induced a drop in Pax7 levels and precocious muscle differentiation. Consequently, we propose that Nedd4 functions as a novel Pax7 regulator, which activity is temporally and spatially controlled to modulate the Pax7 protein levels and therefore satellite cell fate.

Autophagy is required and protects against apoptosis during myoblast differentiation

Several degradative systems assist in formation of multinucleated terminally differentiated myotubes. However, the role of autophagy in this process has not been examined. GFP-LC3B (light chain 3 beta) puncta, LC3B-II protein and LysoTracker fluorescence increased during C2C12 cell differentiation. Importantly, accumulation of LC3B-II protein occurred in CQ (chloroquine)-treated cells throughout differentiation. Furthermore, BECN1 (beclin 1), ATG7 (autophagy-related 7) and ATG12-5 protein increased, whereas SQSTM1/p62 (sequestosome 1) protein was rapidly reduced during differentiation. A transient decrease in BECN1-BCL2 association was observed from day 0.5 to 2 of differentiation. Chemical inhibition of JNK (c-Jun N-terminal kinase) during differentiation reduced LC3B-II protein and GFP-LC3B puncta and maintained BECN1-BCL2 association. Inhibition of autophagy by 3MA (3-methyladenine) or shRNA against Atg7 (shAtg7) resulted in lower myosin heavy chain expression, as well as impaired myoblast fusion and differentiation. Interestingly, 3MA treatment during differentiation increased transient CASP3 (caspase 3) activation, DNA fragmentation and the percentage of apoptotic nuclei. Similarly, shAtg7 cells had increased DNA fragmentation during differentiation compared with the controls. Collectively, these data demonstrate that autophagy increases and is required during myoblast differentiation. Moreover, autophagy protects differentiating myoblasts from apoptotic cell death.

The Proteasome: A Novel Therapeutic Target in Haematopoietic Malignancy

The proteasome plays a key role in regulating protein degradation in eukaryotic cells. A range of synthetic inhibitors of proteasome activity have been developed which have helped elucidate its role in the cell. These inhibitors have selectively induced apoptosis in malignant cells in vitro suggesting that the proteasome may be a novel therapeutic target. First generation proteasome inhibitors are currently showing promise in phase II/III clinical trials for patients with multiple myeloma.

Minireview: ubiquitination-regulated G protein-coupled receptor signaling and trafficking

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are the largest and most diverse superfamily of membrane proteins and mediate most cellular responses to hormones and neurotransmitters. Posttranslational modifications are considered the main regulators of all GPCRs. In addition to phosphorylation, glycosylation, and palmitoylation, increasing evidence as reviewed here reveals that ubiquitination also regulates the magnitude and temporospatial aspects of GPCR signaling. Posttranslational protein modification by ubiquitin is a key molecular mechanism governing proteins degradation. Ubiquitination mediates the covalent conjugation of ubiquitin, a highly conserved polypeptide of 76 amino acids, to protein substrates. This process is catalyzed by 3 enzymes acting in tandem: an E1, ubiquitin-activating enzyme; an E2, ubiquitin-carrying enzyme; and an E3, ubiquitin ligase. Ubiquitination is counteracted by deubiquitinating enzymes that deconjugate ubiquitin-modified proteins and rescue the substrate from proteasomal degradation. Although ubiquitination is known to target many GPCRs for lysosomal or proteasomal degradation, emerging findings define novel roles for the basal status of ubiquitination and for rapid deubiquitination and transubiquitination controlling cell surface expression and cellular responsiveness of some GPCRs. In this review, we highlight the classical and novel roles of ubiquitin in the regulation of GPCR function, signaling, and trafficking.

Down-regulation of MyoD by calpain 3 promotes generation of reserve cells in C2C12 myoblasts

Calpain 3 is a calcium-dependent cysteine protease that is primarily expressed in skeletal muscle and is implicated in limb girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A. To date, its best characterized function is located within the sarcomere, but this protease is found in other cellular compartments, which suggests that it exerts multiple roles. Here, we present evidence that calpain 3 is involved in the myogenic differentiation process. In the course of in vitro culture of myoblasts to fully differentiated myotubes, a population of quiescent undifferentiated "reserve cells" are maintained. These reserve cells are closely related to satellite cells responsible for adult muscle regeneration. In the present work, we observe that reserve cells express higher levels of endogenous Capn3 mRNA than proliferating myoblasts. We show that calpain 3 participates in the establishment of the pool of reserve cells by decreasing the transcriptional activity of the key myogenic regulator MyoD via proteolysis independently of the ubiquitin-proteasome degradation pathway. Our results identify calpain 3 as a potential new player in the muscular regeneration process by promoting renewal of the satellite cell compartment.

CDK11p58 represses vitamin D receptor-mediated transcriptional activation through promoting its ubiquitin-proteasome degradation

Vitamin D receptor (VDR) is a member of the nuclear receptor superfamily and regulates transcription of target genes. In this study, we identified CDK11(p58) as a novel protein involved in the regulation of VDR. CDK11(p58), a member of the large family of p34cdc2-related kinases, is associated with cell cycle progression, tumorigenesis, and apoptotic signaling. Our study demonstrated that CDK11(p58) interacted with VDR and repressed VDR-dependent transcriptional activation. Furthermore, overexpression of CDK11(p58) decreased the stability of VDR through promoting its ubiquitin-proteasome-mediated degradation. Taken together, these results suggest that CDK11(p58) is involved in the negative regulation of VDR.

Glucocorticoids differentially regulate degradation of MyoD and Id1 by N-terminal ubiquitination to promote muscle protein catabolism

Accelerated protein degradation via the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway is the principal cause of skeletal muscle wasting associated with common human disease states and pharmacological treatment with glucocorticoids. Although many protein regulatory factors essential for muscle development and regeneration are degraded via the ubiquitin system, little is known about the mechanisms and regulation of this pathway that promote wasting muscle. Here, we demonstrate that, in differentiated myotubes, glucocorticoid, via the glucocorticoid receptor, selectively induces a decrease in protein abundance of MyoD, a master switch for muscle development and regeneration, but not that of its negative regulator Id1. This decrease in MyoD protein results from accelerated degradation after glucocorticoid exposure. Using MyoD and Id1 mutants deficient in either N terminus-dependent or internal lysine-dependent ubiquitination, we further show that these ubiquitination pathways of MyoD degradation are regulated differently from those of Id1 degradation. Specifically, glucocorticoid activates the N-terminal ubiquitination pathway in MyoD degradation in myotubes, without concomitant effects on Id1 degradation. This effect of glucocorticoid on MyoD and Id1 protein degradation is associated with the distinct cellular compartments in which their degradation occurs. Taken together, these results support a key role for the N terminus-dependent ubiquitination pathway in the physiology of muscle protein degradation.

Ubiquitin-proteasome-mediated degradation, intracellular localization, and protein synthesis of MyoD and Id1 during muscle differentiation

Mammalian skeletal myogenesis results in the differentiation of myoblasts to mature syncytial myotubes, a process regulated by an intricate genetic network of at least three protein families: muscle regulatory factors, E proteins, and Id proteins. MyoD, a key muscle regulatory factor, and its negative regulator Id1 have both been shown to be degraded by the ubiquitin-proteasome system. Using C2C12 cells and confocal fluorescence microscopy, we showed that MyoD and Id1 co-localize within the nucleus in proliferating myoblasts. In mature myotubes, in contrast, they reside in distinctive subcellular compartments, with MyoD within the nucleus and Id1 exclusively in the cytoplasm. Cellular abundance of Id1 was markedly diminished from the very onset of muscle differentiation, whereas MyoD abundance was reduced to a much lesser extent and only at the later stages of differentiation. These reductions in MyoD and Id1 protein levels seem to result from a change in the rate of protein synthesis rather than the rate of degradation. In vivo protein stability studies revealed that the rates of ubiquitin-proteasome-mediated MyoD and Id1 degradation are independent of myogenic differentiation state. Id1 and MyoD were both rapidly degraded, each with a t 1/2 approximately = 1 h in myoblasts and in myotubes. Furthermore, relative protein synthesis rates for MyoD and Id1 were significantly diminished during myoblast to myotube differentiation. These results provide insight as to the interaction between MyoD and Id1 in the process of muscle differentiation and have implications for the involvement of the ubiquitin-proteasome-mediated protein degradation and protein synthesis in muscle differentiation and metabolism under abnormal and pathological conditions.

Proteasomes are tightly associated to myofibrils in mature skeletal muscle

Proteasomes are the major actors of nonlysosomal cytoplasmic protein degradation. In particular, these large protein complexes (about 2500 kDa) are considered to be responsible for muscular degradation during skeletal muscle atrophy. Despite their unusual and important size, they are widely described as soluble and mobile in the cytoplasm. In mature skeletal muscle, we have previously observed a sarcomeric distribution of proteasomes, as revealed by the distribution of alpha1/p27K, a subunit of the 20S core-particle (prosome) of proteasome. Here, we extend these observations at the electron microscopic level in vivo. We also show that this sarcomeric pattern is dependent of the extension of the sarcomere. Using isolated myofibrils, we demonstrate that proteasomes are still attached to the myofibrils after the isolation procedure, and reproduce the observations made in vivo. In addition, the extraction of actin by gelsolin largely removes proteasomes from isolated myofibrils, but some of them are held in place after this extraction, showing a sarcomeric disposition in the absence of any detectable actin, and suggesting the existence of another molecular partner for these interactions. From these results, we conclude that most of detectable 20S proteasomes in skeletal muscle cells is tightly attached to the myofibrils.

Casein Kinase II phosphorylation-induced conformational switch triggers degradation of the papillomavirus E2 protein

The major phosphorylation sites of the bovine papillomavirus E2 transactivator protein are two serine residues, 298 and 301, that are located in a flexible hinge region between the DNA binding and transactivation domains. Phosphorylation of serine residue 301 promotes ubiquitination and rapid degradation of the E2 protein by the proteasome pathway. To understand the mechanism through which phosphorylation regulates the intracellular levels of this unique papillomavirus regulatory protein, we have carried out an extensive mutational analysis of the region surrounding the phosphorylation sites of the E2 protein. Our results indicate that casein kinase II phosphorylates serine 301. However, phosphorylation of serine 301 is not a sufficient recognition motif for proteasomal degradation; other residues that directly surround the phosphorylation sites are crucial for E2 degradation. The phenotypes of E2 proteins mutated in this region indicate that phosphorylation of serine 301 induces a conformational change that leads to degradation of the E2 protein. In support of this model, circular dichroism studies of the conformational tendencies of peptides from this region indicate that phosphorylation at position 301 decreases the local thermodynamic stability of this region. Thus, this region appears to have evolved to display a marginal local thermodynamic stability that can be regulated by phosphorylation, leading to targeted degradation of the E2 protein.

Context of multiubiquitin chain attachment influences the rate of Sic1 degradation

The ubiquitin-dependent targeting of proteins to the proteasome is an essential mechanism for regulating eukaryotic protein stability. Here we define the minimal signal for the degradation of the S phase CDK inhibitor Sic1. Of 20 lysines scattered throughout Sic1, 6 N-terminal lysines serve as major ubiquitination sites. Sic1 lacking these lysines (K0N) is stable in vivo, but readdition of any one restores turnover. Nevertheless, ubiquitin chains attached at different N-terminal lysines specify degradation in vitro at markedly different rates. Moreover, although K0N can be ubiquitinated by SCF(Cdc4)/Cdc34 in vitro in the absence (but not in the presence) of S-CDK, it is degraded slowly. Our results reveal that a single multiubiquitin chain can sustain a physiological turnover rate, but that chain position plays an unexpectedly significant role in the rate of proteasomal proteolysis.

Regulation of apoptosis by the ubiquitin and proteasome pathway

Regulated proteolysis plays important roles in cell physiology as well as in pathological conditions. In most of the cases, regulated proteolysis is carried out by the ubiquitin- and proteasome-dependent proteolytic system, which is also in charge of the bulk of cytoplasmic proteolysis. However, apoptosis or the process of programmed cell death is regulated by a different proteolytic system, i.e. by caspases, a family of specialized cysteine proteases. Nevertheless, there is plenty of evidence of a crosstalk between the apoptotic pathways and the ubiquitin and proteasome system, whose function in apoptosis appears to be very complex. Proteasome inhibitors induce apoptosis in multiple cell types, while in other they are relatively harmless or even prevent apoptosis induced by other stimuli. Proteasomes degrade specific proteins during apoptosis, but on the other hand some components of the proteasome system are degraded by caspases. The knowledge about the involvement of the ubiquitin- and proteasome-dependent system in apoptosis is already clinically exploited, since proteasome inhibitors are being tested as experimental drugs in the treatment of cancer and other pathological conditions, where manipulation of apoptosis is desirable.

A novel active site-directed probe specific for deubiquitylating enzymes reveals proteasome association of USP14

A C-terminally modified ubiquitin (Ub) derivative, ubiquitin vinyl sulfone (UbVS), was synthesized as an active site-directed probe that irreversibly modifies a subset of Ub C-terminal hydrolases (UCHs) and Ub-specific processing proteases (UBPs). Specificity of UbVS for deubiquitylating enzymes (DUBs) is demonstrated not only by inhibition of [(125)I]UbVS labeling with N-ethylmaleimide and Ub aldehyde, but also by genetic analysis. [(125)I]UbVS modifies six of the 17 known and putative yeast deubiquitylating enzymes (Yuh1p, Ubp1p, Ubp2p, Ubp6p, Ubp12p and Ubp15p), as revealed by analysis of corresponding mutant strains. In mammalian cells, greater numbers of polypeptides are labeled, most of which are likely to be DUBs. Using [(125)I]UbVS as a probe, we report the association of an additional DUB with the mammalian 26S proteasome. In addition to the 37 kDa enzyme reported to be part of the 19S cap, we identified USP14, a mammalian homolog of yeast Ubp6p, as being bound to the proteasome. Remarkably, labeling of 26S-associated USP14 with [(125)I]UbVS is increased when proteasome function is impaired, suggesting functional coupling between the activities of USP14 and the proteasome.

Regenerating soleus and extensor digitorum longus muscles of the rat show elevated levels of TNF-alpha and its receptors, TNFR-60 and TNFR-80

We measured the mRNA and protein levels of tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) and the transcript levels of its receptors (TNFR-60 and TNFR-80) in the rat soleus (slow twitch) and extensor digitorum longus (EDL; fast twitch) muscles regenerating from notexin-induced necrosis. On the first day after administration of the toxin, when most fibers were necrotic and invaded by inflammatory cells/macrophages, dramatic increases of transcript and protein levels of TNF-alpha and of the mRNA levels of its receptors were observed. The transcript levels of TNF-alpha and TNFR-60, but not of TNFR-80, showed a second but smaller increase at the time when newly formed muscle fibers became reinnervated. In situ hybridization showed that on day 1, during the phase of extensive necrosis, the transcript of TNF-alpha was abundantly present and on day 4 of regeneration it was most often seen in areas devoid of desmin. The mRNA level of TNF-alpha was not detectable in BC(3)H1- and C2C12-cultured myoblasts and it was low in freeze-injured muscle, corresponding to the relatively mild degree of inflammation elicited by freezing. Therefore, our results are most consistent with the view that inflammatory cells/macrophages are the main source of TNF-alpha.

Characterisation of the human and mouse orthologues of the Drosophila ariadne gene

The specificity of the ubiquitin degradation system is regulated through interaction between individual ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes (E2s) and multiple ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3s). Here we describe the characterisation of a novel gene (ARIH1) that encodes the human homologue of Drosophila ariadne which interacts with the E2s, UbcH7 and UbcH8 and represents a component of an E3 complex. Three PACs (189N19, 142P17 and 179H7) were isolated that contain this gene. Using these PACs as probes, we mapped ARIH1 to human chromosome 15q24 by fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH). Sequencing of the ARIH1 PACs showed that the gene has 13 introns. In addition, we isolated two PACs (345D8 and 571P19) containing the mouse orthologue (Arih1) of ARIH1. The intron-exon structure of Arih1 was identical to ARIH1 and the proteins demonstrated a 98% identity at the amino acid level. Furthermore, comparison of Drosophila ariadne with ARIH1 indicates an identity at the amino acid level of 70% and introns at 3/7 identical sites. The high degree of homology demonstrated by the mouse and human orthologues of Drosophila ariadne indicates an important, conserved biological function, consistent with a putative role in ubiquitylation.

Regulation of muscle regulatory factors by DNA-binding, interacting proteins, and post-transcriptional modifications

Skeletal muscle differentiation is influenced by multiple pathways, which regulate the activity of myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs)-the myogenic basic helix-loop-helix proteins and the MEF2-family members-in positive or negative ways. Here we will review and discuss the network of signals that regulate MRF function during myocyte proliferation, differentiation, and post-mitotic growth. Elucidating the mechanisms governing muscle-specific transcription will provide important insight in better understanding the embryonic development of muscle at the molecular level and will have important implications in setting out strategies aimed at muscle regeneration. Since the activity of MRFs are compromised in tumors of myogenic derivation-the rhabdomyosarcomas-the studies summarized in this review can provide a useful tool to uncover the molecular basis underlying the formation of these tumors.

Ubiquitin-dependent signaling: the role of ubiquitination in the response of cells to their environment

The response of a cell to its external environment requires rapid and significant alteration of protein amount, localization and/or function. This regulation involves a complex combination of processes that control synthesis, localization and degradation. All of these processes must be properly regulated and are often interrelated. Intracellular proteolysis is largely accomplished by the ubiquitin-dependent system and has been shown to be required for growth control, cell cycle regulation, receptor function, development and the stress response. Substrates subject to regulated degradation by this system include cyclins and cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors, tumor suppressors, transcription factors and cell surface receptors. In addition, proteins that are damaged by oxidation or that are improperly folded or localized are substrates whose degradation by this system often leads to antigen presentation on the surface of the cell in the context of Class I major histocompatibility complex molecules. A very large body of work in the last fifteen years has shown that degradation by this system requires the covalent attachment of a small protein called ubiquitin and that this modification serves to direct target proteins for degradation by a 26S proteolytic particle, the proteasome. Thus, the attachment of the ubiquitin domain is of vital importance in regulating normal growth and differentiation, as well as in defending against cellular damage caused by xenobiotics, environmental insults, infection and mutation. This review focuses on the role of ubiquitination in the cellular signaling pathways that deal with these external influences.