Novel initiation of RNA synthesis in vitro by vesicular stomatitis virus

Targeting cap1 RNA methyltransferases as an antiviral strategy

Methylation is one of the critical modifications that regulates numerous biological processes. Guanine capping and methylation at the 7th position (m7G) have been shown to mature mRNA for increased RNA stability and translational efficiency. The m7G capped cap0 RNA remains immature and requires additional methylation at the first nucleotide (N1-2'-O-Me), designated as cap1, to achieve full maturation. This cap1 RNA with N1-2'-O-Me prevents its recognition by innate immune sensors as non-self. Viruses have also evolved various strategies to produce self-like capped RNAs with the N1-2'-O-Me that potentially evades the antiviral response and establishes an efficient replication. In this review, we focus on the importance of the presence of N1-2'-O-Me in viral RNAs and discuss the potential for drug development by targeting host and viral N1-2'-O-methyltransferases.

Crystal Structures of Flavivirus NS5 Guanylyltransferase Reveal a GMP-Arginine Adduct

The positive-sense flavivirus RNA genome bears a cap 1 structure essential for RNA stability and viral protein translation, and the formation of cap 1 requires the virally encoded nonstructural protein NS5 harboring guanylyltransferase (GTase), cap guanine N7 methyltransferase (N7 MTase), and 5'-nucleotide ribose 2'-O MTase activities in its single-domain MTase module. Despite numerous MTase-containing structures reported, the structural evidence for a critical GMP-enzyme intermediate formation and RNA repositioning when transitioning among different reactions is missing. Here, we report 10 high-resolution MTase crystal structures of Omsk hemorrhagic fever virus (OHFV), a representative high-consequence tick-borne flavivirus, capturing previously unidentified GMP-arginine adduct structures and a rarely observed capped RNA conformation. These structures help us thread capping events in the canonical model with a structure-based hypothesis involving the flipping of the 5' nucleotide, while the observation of an m⁷GMP-arginine adduct is compatible with an alternate capping model that decouples the N7 and 2'-O methylation steps. IMPORTANCE The methyltransferase (MTase) domain of flavivirus NS5 is unique in harboring guanylyltransferase (GTase), N7 MTase, and 2'-O MTase activities, playing a central role in viral RNA capping. However, the detailed mechanisms of the multistep capping process remain elusive. Here, we report 10 crystal structures of a flavivirus MTase to help understand the guanylyl transfer from GTP to the GTase itself and the transition between guanylyl transfer and methylation steps. In particular, a previously unobserved GMP-arginine covalent intermediate was captured multiple times in MTase crystal soaking trials with GTP present in the soaking solution, supporting its role in bridging the guanylyl transfer from GTP to the GTase and subsequent transfer to the 5'-diphosphate RNA.

The Nucleocapsid of Paramyxoviruses: Structure and Function of an Encapsidated Template

Viruses of the Paramyxoviridae family share a common and complex molecular machinery for transcribing and replicating their genomes. Their non-segmented, negative-strand RNA genome is encased in a tight homopolymer of viral nucleoproteins (N). This ribonucleoprotein complex, termed a nucleocapsid, is the template of the viral polymerase complex made of the large protein (L) and its co-factor, the phosphoprotein (P). This review summarizes the current knowledge on several aspects of paramyxovirus transcription and replication, including structural and functional data on (1) the architecture of the nucleocapsid (structure of the nucleoprotein, interprotomer contacts, interaction with RNA, and organization of the disordered C-terminal tail of N), (2) the encapsidation of the genomic RNAs (structure of the nucleoprotein in complex with its chaperon P and kinetics of RNA encapsidation in vitro), and (3) the use of the nucleocapsid as a template for the polymerase complex (release of the encased RNA and interaction network allowing the progress of the polymerase complex). Finally, this review presents models of paramyxovirus transcription and replication.

RNA Synthesis and Capping by Non-segmented Negative Strand RNA Viral Polymerases: Lessons From a Prototypic Virus

Non-segmented negative strand (NNS) RNA viruses belonging to the order Mononegavirales are highly diversified eukaryotic viruses including significant human pathogens, such as rabies, measles, Nipah, and Ebola. Elucidation of their unique strategies to replicate in eukaryotic cells is crucial to aid in developing anti-NNS RNA viral agents. Over the past 40 years, vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), closely related to rabies virus, has served as a paradigm to study the fundamental molecular mechanisms of transcription and replication of NNS RNA viruses. These studies provided insights into how NNS RNA viruses synthesize 5'-capped mRNAs using their RNA-dependent RNA polymerase L proteins equipped with an unconventional mRNA capping enzyme, namely GDP polyribonucleotidyltransferase (PRNTase), domain. PRNTase or PRNTase-like domains are evolutionally conserved among L proteins of all known NNS RNA viruses and their related viruses belonging to Jingchuvirales, a newly established order, in the class Monjiviricetes, suggesting that they may have evolved from a common ancestor that acquired the unique capping system to replicate in a primitive eukaryotic host. This article reviews what has been learned from biochemical and structural studies on the VSV RNA biosynthesis machinery, and then focuses on recent advances in our understanding of regulatory and catalytic roles of the PRNTase domain in RNA synthesis and capping.

Transcriptional Control and mRNA Capping by the GDP Polyribonucleotidyltransferase Domain of the Rabies Virus Large Protein

Rabies virus (RABV) is a causative agent of a fatal neurological disease in humans and animals. The large (L) protein of RABV is a multifunctional RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, which is one of the most attractive targets for developing antiviral agents. A remarkable homology of the RABV L protein to a counterpart in vesicular stomatitis virus, a well-characterized rhabdovirus, suggests that it catalyzes mRNA processing reactions, such as 5'-capping, cap methylation, and 3'-polyadenylation, in addition to RNA synthesis. Recent breakthroughs in developing in vitro RNA synthesis and capping systems with a recombinant form of the RABV L protein have led to significant progress in our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of RABV RNA biogenesis. This review summarizes functions of RABV replication proteins in transcription and replication, and highlights new insights into roles of an unconventional mRNA capping enzyme, namely GDP polyribonucleotidyltransferase, domain of the RABV L protein in mRNA capping and transcription initiation.

The methyltransferase domain of the Sudan ebolavirus L protein specifically targets internal adenosines of RNA substrates, in addition to the cap structure

Mononegaviruses, such as Ebola virus, encode an L (large) protein that bears all the catalytic activities for replication/transcription and RNA capping. The C-terminal conserved region VI (CRVI) of L protein contains a K-D-K-E catalytic tetrad typical for 2'O methyltransferases (MTase). In mononegaviruses, cap-MTase activities have been involved in the 2'O methylation and N7 methylation of the RNA cap structure. These activities play a critical role in the viral life cycle as N7 methylation ensures efficient viral mRNA translation and 2'O methylation hampers the detection of viral RNA by the host innate immunity. The functional characterization of the MTase+CTD domain of Sudan ebolavirus (SUDV) revealed cap-independent methyltransferase activities targeting internal adenosine residues. Besides this, the MTase+CTD also methylates, the N7 position of the cap guanosine and the 2'O position of the n1 guanosine provided that the RNA is sufficiently long. Altogether, these results suggest that the filovirus MTases evolved towards a dual activity with distinct substrate specificities. Whereas it has been well established that cap-dependent methylations promote protein translation and help to mimic host RNA, the characterization of an original cap-independent methylation opens new research opportunities to elucidate the role of RNA internal methylations in the viral replication.

[The multifunctional RNA polymerase L protein of non-segmented negative strand RNA viruses catalyzes unique mRNA capping]

Non-segmented negative strand RNA viruses belonging to the Mononegavirales order possess RNA-dependent RNA polymerase L proteins within viral particles. The L protein is a multifunctional enzyme catalyzing viral RNA synthesis and processing (i.e., mRNA capping, cap methylation, and polyadenylation). Using vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) as a prototypic model virus, we have shown that the L protein catalyzes the unconventional mRNA capping reaction, which is strikingly different from the eukaryotic reaction. Furthermore, co-transcriptional pre-mRNA capping with the VSV L protein was found to be required for accurate stop?start transcription to synthesize full-length mRNAs in vitro and virus propagation in host cells. This article provides a review of historical and present studies leading to the elucidation of the molecular mechanism of VSV mRNA capping.

Signature motifs of GDP polyribonucleotidyltransferase, a non-segmented negative strand RNA viral mRNA capping enzyme, domain in the L protein are required for covalent enzyme-pRNA intermediate formation

The unconventional mRNA capping enzyme (GDP polyribonucleotidyltransferase, PRNTase; block V) domain in RNA polymerase L proteins of non-segmented negative strand (NNS) RNA viruses (e.g. rabies, measles, Ebola) contains five collinear sequence elements, Rx(3)Wx(3–8)ΦxGxζx(P/A) (motif A; Φ, hydrophobic; ζ, hydrophilic), (Y/W)ΦGSxT (motif B), W (motif C), HR (motif D) and ζxxΦx(F/Y)QxxΦ (motif E). We performed site-directed mutagenesis of the L protein of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV, a prototypic NNS RNA virus) to examine participation of these motifs in mRNA capping. Similar to the catalytic residues in motif D, G1100 in motif A, T1157 in motif B, W1188 in motif C, and F1269 and Q1270 in motif E were found to be essential or important for the PRNTase activity in the step of the covalent L-pRNA intermediate formation, but not for the GTPase activity that generates GDP (pRNA acceptor). Cap defective mutations in these residues induced termination of mRNA synthesis at position +40 followed by aberrant stop–start transcription, and abolished virus gene expression in host cells. These results suggest that the conserved motifs constitute the active site of the PRNTase domain and the L-pRNA intermediate formation followed by the cap formation is essential for successful synthesis of full-length mRNAs.

Capping of vesicular stomatitis virus pre-mRNA is required for accurate selection of transcription stop-start sites and virus propagation

The multifunctional RNA-dependent RNA polymerase L protein of vesicular stomatitis virus catalyzes unconventional pre-mRNA capping via the covalent enzyme-pRNA intermediate formation, which requires the histidine–arginine (HR) motif in the polyribonucleotidyltransferase domain. Here, the effects of cap-defective mutations in the HR motif on transcription were analyzed using an in vitro reconstituted transcription system. The wild-type L protein synthesized the leader RNA from the 3′-end of the genome followed by 5′-capped and 3′-polyadenylated mRNAs from internal genes by a stop–start transcription mechanism. Cap-defective mutants efficiently produced the leader RNA, but displayed aberrant stop–start transcription using cryptic termination and initiation signals within the first gene, resulting in sequential generation of ∼40-nucleotide transcripts with 5′-ATP from a correct mRNA-start site followed by a 28-nucleotide transcript and long 3′-polyadenylated transcript initiated with non-canonical GTP from atypical start sites. Frequent transcription termination and re-initiation within the first gene significantly attenuated the production of downstream mRNAs. Consistent with the inability of these mutants in in vitro mRNA synthesis and capping, these mutations were lethal to virus replication in cultured cells. These findings indicate that viral mRNA capping is required for accurate stop–start transcription as well as mRNA stability and translation and, therefore, for virus replication in host cells.

The viral RNA capping machinery as a target for antiviral drugs

Most viruses modify their genomic and mRNA 5′-ends with the addition of an RNA cap, allowing efficient mRNA translation, limiting degradation by cellular 5′–3′ exonucleases, and avoiding its recognition as foreign RNA by the host cell. Viral RNA caps can be synthesized or acquired through the use of a capping machinery which exhibits a significant diversity in organization, structure and mechanism relative to that of their cellular host. Therefore, viral RNA capping has emerged as an interesting field for antiviral drug design. Here, we review the different pathways and mechanisms used to produce viral mRNA 5′-caps, and present current structures, mechanisms, and inhibitors known to act on viral RNA capping.

In vitro capping and transcription of rhabdoviruses

The RNA-dependent RNA polymerase L protein of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a prototypic nonsegmented negative strand (NNS) RNA virus classified into the Rhabdoviridae family, has been used to investigate the fundamental molecular mechanisms of NNS RNA viral mRNA synthesis and processing. In vitro studies on mRNA cap formation with the VSV L protein eventually led to the discovery of the unconventional mRNA capping pathway catalyzed by the guanosine 5'-triphosphatase and RNA:GDP polyribonucleotidyltransferase (PRNTase) activities. The PRNTase activity is a novel enzymatic activity, which transfers 5'-monophosphorylated (p-) RNA from 5'-triphosphorylated (ppp-) RNA to GDP to form 5'-capped RNA (GpppRNA) in a viral mRNA-start sequence-dependent manner. This unconventional capping (pRNA transfer) reaction with PRNTase can be experimentally distinguished from the conventional capping (GMP transfer) reaction with eukaryotic GTP:RNA guanylyltransferase (GTase) on the basis of the following differences in their substrate specificity for the cap formation: PRNTase uses GDP and pppRNA, but not ppRNA, whereas GTase employs GTP, but not GDP, and ppRNA. The pRNA transfer reaction with PRNTase proceeds through a covalent enzyme-pRNA intermediate with a phosphoamide bond. Hence, to prove the PRNTase activity, it is necessary to demonstrate the following consecutive steps separately: (1) the enzyme forms a covalent enzyme-pRNA intermediate, and (2) the intermediate transfers pRNA to GDP. This article describes the methods for in vitro transcription and capping with the recombinant VSV L protein, which permit detailed characterization of its enzymatic reactions and mapping of active sites of its enzymatic domains. It is expected that these systems are adaptable to rhabdoviruses and, by extension, other NNS RNA viruses belonging to different families.

Conventional and unconventional mechanisms for capping viral mRNA

mRNAs are protected at their 5′ ends by a cap structure consisting of an N7-methylated GTP molecule linked to the first transcribed nucleotide by a 5′–5′ triphosphate bond.

The cap structure is essential for RNA splicing, export and stability, and allows the ribosomal complex to recognize mRNAs and ensure their efficient translation.

Uncapped RNA molecules are degraded in cytoplasmic granular compartments called processing bodies and may be detected as 'non-self' by the host cell, triggering antiviral innate immune responses through the production of interferons.

Conventional RNA capping (that is, of mRNAs from the host cell and from DNA viruses) requires hydrolysis of the 5′ γ-phosphate of RNA by an RNA triphosphatase, transfer of a GMP molecule onto the 5′-end of RNA by a guanylyltransferase, and methylation of this guanosine by an (guanine-N7)-methyltransferase. Subsequent methylations on the first and second transcribed nucleotides by (nucleoside-2′-O)-methyltransferases form cap-1 and cap-2 structures.

Viruses have evolved highly diverse capping mechanisms to acquire cap structures using their own or cellular capping machineries, or by stealing cap structures from cellular mRNAs.

Virally encoded RNA-capping machineries are diverse in terms of their genetic components, protein domain organization, enzyme structures, and reaction mechanisms and pathways, making viral RNA capping an attractive target for antiviral-drug design.

Capping the 5′ end of eukaryotic mRNAs with a 7-methylguanosine moiety enables efficient splicing, nuclear export and translation of mRNAs, and also limits their degradation by cellular exonucleases. Here, Canard and colleagues describe how viruses synthesize their own mRNA cap structures or steal them from host mRNAs, allowing efficient synthesis of viral proteins and avoidance of host innate immune responses.

In the eukaryotic cell, capping of mRNA 5′ ends is an essential structural modification that allows efficient mRNA translation, directs pre-mRNA splicing and mRNA export from the nucleus, limits mRNA degradation by cellular 5′–3′ exonucleases and allows recognition of foreign RNAs (including viral transcripts) as 'non-self'. However, viruses have evolved mechanisms to protect their RNA 5′ ends with either a covalently attached peptide or a cap moiety (7-methyl-Gppp, in which p is a phosphate group) that is indistinguishable from cellular mRNA cap structures. Viral RNA caps can be stolen from cellular mRNAs or synthesized using either a host- or virus-encoded capping apparatus, and these capping assemblies exhibit a wide diversity in organization, structure and mechanism. Here, we review the strategies used by viruses of eukaryotic cells to produce functional mRNA 5′-caps and escape innate immunity.

An unconventional pathway of mRNA cap formation by vesiculoviruses

mRNAs of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a prototype of nonsegmented negative strand (NNS) RNA viruses (e.g., rabies, measles, mumps, Ebola, and Borna disease viruses), possess the 5'-terminal cap structure identical to that of eukaryotic mRNAs, but the mechanism of mRNA cap formation is distinctly different from the latter. The elucidation of the unconventional capping of VSV mRNA remained elusive for three decades since the discovery of the cap structure in some viral and eukaryotic mRNAs in 1975. Only recently our biochemical studies revealed an unexpected strategy employed by vesiculoviruses (VSV and Chandipura virus, an emerging arbovirus) to generate the cap structure. This article summarizes the historical and current research that led to the discovery of the novel vesiculoviral mRNA capping reaction.

Alternate capping mechanisms for transcription of spring viremia of carp virus: evidence for independent mRNA initiation

Two alternate mechanisms of mRNA capping for spring viremia of carp virus have been observed. Under normal reaction conditions, a ppG residue of the capping GTP is transferred to a pA moiety of the 5' termini of mRNA transcripts. However, in reaction conditions where GppNHp is used instead of GTP, an alternate capping mechanism occurs whereby a pG residue of the capping GTP is transferred to a ppA moiety of the transcripts. The first mechanism is identical to that described previously for vesicular stomatitis virus (G. Abraham, D. P. Rhodes, and A. K. Banerjee, Nature [London] 255:37-40, 1975; A. K. Banerjee, S. A. Moyer, and D. P. Rhodes, Virology 61:547-558, 1974), and thus appears to be a conserved function during the evolution of rhabdoviruses. The alternate mechanism of capping indicates not only that capping can take place by two procedures, but also that the substrate termini have di- or triphosphate 5' ends, indicating that they are probably independently initiated. An analog of ATP, AppNHp, has been found to completely inhibit the initiation of transcription by spring viremia of carp virus, suggesting that a cleavage between the beta and gamma phosphates of ATP is essential for the initiation of transcription. However, in the presence of GppNHp, uncapped (ppAp and pppAp), capped (GpppAp), and capped methylated (m7GpppAmpAp and GpppAmpAp) transcripts are detected. Size analyses of oligodeoxythymidylic acid-cellulose-bound transcripts resolved by formamide gel electrophoresis demonstrated that full-size mRNA transcripts are synthesized as well as larger RNA species. The presence of GppNHp and S-adenosylhomocysteine in reaction mixtures did not have any effect on the type of unmethylated transcription products. Our results favor a transcription model postulated previously (D. H. L. Bishop, in H. Fraenkel-Conrat and R. R. Wagner, ed., Comprehensive Virology, vol. 10, Plenum Press, New York, 1977; D. H. L. Bishop and A. Flamand, in D. C. Burke and W. C. Russell, ed., Control Processes in Virus Multiplication, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1975; D. H. L. Bishop and M. S. Smith, in D. Nayak, ed., The Molecular Biology of Animal Viruses, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1977; P. Roy and D. H. L. Bishop, J. Virol. 11:487-501, 1973) in which mRNA synthesis is initiated independently; they do not support a model for transcripts being synthesized by plus-strand cleavage (A. K. Banerjee, G. Abraham, and R. J. Colonno, J. Gen. Virol. 34:1-8, 1977; A. K. Banerjee, R. J. Colonno, D. Testa, and M. T. Franze-Fernandez, in B. M. J. Mahy and R. D. Barry, ed., Negative Strand Viruses and the Host Cells, Academic Press, London, 1978).

Identification of sendai virus L protein amino acid residues affecting viral mRNA cap methylation

Viruses of the order Mononegavirales all encode a large (L) polymerase protein responsible for the replication and transcription of the viral genome as well as all posttranscriptional modifications of viral mRNAs. The L protein is conserved among all members of the Mononegavirales and has six conserved regions ("domains"). Using vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) (family Rhabdoviridae) experimental system, we and others recently identified several conserved amino acid residues within L protein domain VI which are required for viral mRNA cap methylation. To verify that these critical amino acid residues have a similar function in other members of the Mononegavirales, we examined the Sendai virus (SeV) (family Paramyxoviridae) L protein by targeting homologous amino acid residues important for cap methylation in VSV which are highly conserved among all members of the Mononegavirales and are believed to constitute the L protein catalytic and S-adenosylmethionine-binding sites. In addition, an SeV L protein mutant with a deletion of the entire domain VI was generated. First, L mutants were tested for their abilities to synthesize viral mRNAs. While the domain VI deletion completely inactivated L, most of the amino acid substitutions had minor effects on mRNA synthesis. Using a reverse genetics approach, these mutations were introduced into the SeV genome, and recombinant infectious SeV mutants with single alanine substitutions at L positions 1782, 1804, 1805, and 1806 or a double substitution at positions 1804 and 1806 were generated. The mutant SeV virions were purified, detergent activated, and analyzed for their abilities to synthesize viral mRNAs methylated at their cap structures. In addition, further studies were done to examine these SeV mutants for a possible host range phenotype, which was previously shown for VSV cap methylation-defective mutants. In agreement with a predicted role of the SeV L protein invariant lysine 1782 as a catalytic residue, the recombinant virus with a single K1782A substitution was completely defective in cap methylation and showed a host range phenotype. In addition, the E1805A mutation within the putative S-adenosylmethionine-binding site of L resulted in a 60% reduction in cap methylation. In contrast to the homologous VSV mutants, other recombinant SeV mutants with amino acid substitutions at this site were neither defective in cap methylation nor host range restricted. The results of this initial study using an SeV experimental system demonstrate similarities as well as differences between the L protein cap methylation domains in different members of the Mononegavirales.

Analysis of a structural homology model of the 2'-O-ribose methyltransferase domain within the vesicular stomatitis virus L protein

The large (L) proteins of non-segmented negative stranded (NNS) RNA viruses contain the core RNA dependent RNA polymerase activity for RNA replication and transcription as well as the activities for polyadenylating and capping the mRNA transcripts and for methylating the cap structures. There is currently no structural information available for these large multi-functional proteins. Phylogenetic analyses have led to the division of the L protein primary structure into six functional domains of high conservation that are linked by variable regions. The studies in this report investigate the role of specific amino acids within domain VI of the VSV L protein, which contains a 2'-O-ribose methyltransferase (MTase) domain. We generated a structural homology model of residues 1644-1842 within domain VI based on the crystal structure determined for the known 2'-O-ribose MTase of E. coli, RrmJ. The information generated by this homology model directed us to residues structurally important for MTase activity and SAM binding. Selected residues were analyzed by site-specific mutagenesis and the mutant L proteins were assayed for their effects on RNA synthesis and cap methylation. The goal of this study was to functionally test the model in order to gain insight into the structural constraints of this region of the L protein. The data presented here revealed specific mutations that affect transcription, replication, and 5' cap methylation, many of which resulted in polymerases temperature sensitive for RNA synthesis.

Formation of guanosine(5')tetraphospho(5')adenosine cap structure by an unconventional mRNA capping enzyme of vesicular stomatitis virus

The RNA-dependent RNA polymerase L protein of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) elicits GTPase and RNA:GDP polyribonucleotidyltransferase (PRNTase) activities to produce a 5'-cap core structure, guanosine(5')triphospho(5')adenosine (GpppA), on viral mRNAs. Here, we report that the L protein produces an unusual cap structure, guanosine(5')tetraphospho(5')adenosine (GppppA), that is formed by the transfer of the 5'-monophosphorylated viral mRNA start sequence to GTP by the PRNTase activity before the removal of the gamma-phosphate from GTP by GTPase. Interestingly, GppppA-capped and polyadenylated full-length mRNAs were also found to be synthesized by an in vitro transcription system with the native VSV RNP.

Unconventional mechanism of mRNA capping by the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of vesicular stomatitis virus

All known eukaryotic and some viral mRNA capping enzymes (CEs) transfer a GMP moiety of GTP to the 5'-diphosphate end of the acceptor RNA via a covalent enzyme-GMP intermediate to generate the cap structure. In striking contrast, the putative CE of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a prototype of nonsegmented negative-strand (NNS) RNA viruses including rabies, measles, and Ebola, incorporates the GDP moiety of GTP into the cap structure of transcribing mRNAs. Here, we report that the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase L protein of VSV catalyzes the capping reaction by an RNA:GDP polyribonucleotidyltransferase activity, in which a 5'-monophosphorylated viral mRNA-start sequence is transferred to GDP generated from GTP via a covalent enzyme-RNA intermediate. Thus, the L proteins of VSV and, by extension, other NNS RNA viruses represent a new class of viral CEs, which have evolved independently from known eukaryotic CEs.

A single amino acid change in the L-polymerase protein of vesicular stomatitis virus completely abolishes viral mRNA cap methylation

The vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) RNA polymerase synthesizes viral mRNAs with 5'-cap structures methylated at the guanine-N7 and 2'-O-adenosine positions (7mGpppA(m)). Previously, our laboratory showed that a VSV host range (hr) and temperature-sensitive (ts) mutant, hr1, had a complete defect in mRNA cap methylation and that the wild-type L protein could complement the hr1 defect in vitro. Here, we sequenced the L, P, and N genes of mutant hr1 and found only two amino acid substitutions, both residing in the L-polymerase protein, which differentiate hr1 from its wild-type parent. These mutations (N505D and D1671V) were introduced separately and together into the L gene, and their effects on VSV in vitro transcription and in vivo chloramphenicol acetyltransferase minigenome replication were studied under conditions that are permissive and nonpermissive for hr1. Neither L mutation significantly affected viral RNA synthesis at 34 degrees C in permissive (BHK) and nonpermissive (HEp-2) cells, but D1671V reduced in vitro transcription and genome replication by about 50% at 40 degrees C in both cell lines. Recombinant VSV bearing each mutation were isolated, and the hr and ts phenotypes in infected cells were the result of a single D1671V substitution in the L protein. While the mutations did not significantly affect mRNA synthesis by purified viruses, 5'-cap analyses of product mRNAs clearly demonstrated that the D1671V mutation abrogated all methyltransferase activity. Sequence analysis suggests that an aspartic acid at amino acid 1671 is a critical residue within a putative conserved S-adenosyl-l-methionine-binding domain of the L protein.

Transcriptional control of the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of vesicular stomatitis virus

The nonsegmented negative strand (NNS) RNA viruses include some of the mosr problematic human, animal and plant pathogens extant: for example, rabies virus, Ebola virus, respiratory syncytial virus, the parainfluenza viruses, measles and infectious hemapoietic necrosis virus. The key feature of transcriptional control in the NNS RNA viruses is polymerase entry at a single 3' proximal site followed by obligatory sequential transcription of the linear array of genes. The levels of gene expression are primarily regulated by their position on the genome. The promoter proximal gene is transcribed in greatest abundance and each successive downstream gene is synthesized in progressively lower amounts due to attenuation of transcription at each successive gene junction. In addition, NNS RNA virus gene expression is regulated by cis-acting sequences that reside at the beginning and end of each gene and the intergenic junctions. Using vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), the prototypic NNS, many of these control elements have been identified.The signals for transcription initiation and 5' end modification and for 3' end polyadenylation and termination have been elucidated. The sequences that determine the ability of the polymerase to slip on the template to generate polyadenylate have been identified and polyadenylation has been shown to be template dependent and integral to the termination process. Transcriptional termination is a key element in control of gene expression of the negative strand RNA viruses and a means by which expression of individual genes may be silenced or regulated within the framework of a single transcriptional promoter. In addition, the fundamental question of the site of entry of the polymerase during transcription has been reexamined and our understanding of the process altered and updated. The ability to engineer changes into infectious viruses has confirmed the action of these elements and as a consequence, it has been shown that transcriptional control is key to controlling the outcome of a viral infection. Finally, the principles of transcriptional regulation have been utilized to develop a new paradigm for systematic attenuation of virulence to develop live attenuated viral vaccines.

Unique capping activity of the recombinant RNA polymerase (L) of vesicular stomatitis virus: association of cellular capping enzyme with the L protein

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a prototype of non-segmented negative strand RNA viruses, packages an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (L) which, together with an associated phosphoprotein (P), transcribes the genome RNA, in vitro and in vivo, into mRNAs that are capped at the 5'-ends. However, unlike cellular guanlylyltransferase (GT), the RNA polymerase incorporates GDP in the capped structure, as Gp(alpha)p(beta)-p(alpha)A. In an effort to characterize the capping activity of the RNA polymerase, we have purified recombinant L (rL) protein expressed in insect cells. The rL, like the virion L polymerase, also caps transcribed mRNAs with identical unique cap structure. Interestingly, the purified rL is found to be tightly bound to the GT of the insect cell during all stages of purification. VSV grown in baby hamster kidney cells also packages cellular GT of the murine cell, suggesting that VSV L protein or its associated proteins may have a strong affinity for the cellular GT. The GT bound to rL, however, formed E-GMP complex, whereas no such complex was detected with the rL protein. It appears that the L protein may contain the putative active site for the unique capping reaction or the tightly bound cellular GT may by some unknown mechanism participate in the unique capping reaction.

Novel binding of GTP to the phosphoprotein (P) of vesicular stomatitis virus

The phosphoprotein (P) of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) is a subunit of the RNA polymerase (L) that transcribes the negative strand genome RNA into mRNAs both in vitro and in vivo. We have previously shown that the P protein of VSV, expressed in E. coli, is biologically inactive unless phosphorylated at specific serine residues by cellular casein kinase II (CKII). In the present study we present evidence that the P protein, in addition to being phosphorylated, binds covalently to GTP only when it is phosphorylated. Competition experiments show that ATP, ADP, GTP, and GDP can compete for the binding site(s) of GTP but not AMP, GMP, CTP, or UTP. Interestingly, once GTP is bound to P protein it cannot be displaced by unlabeled GTP. The GTP binding site has been mapped within the domain where the phosphorylation of P protein by CKII occurs. Finally, we show that phosphorylation negative P mutants P3A (P60A, P62A, P64A), P3E (P60E, P62E, P64E), and P3R (P60R, P62R, P64R) failed to bind to GTP, indicating that phosphorylation of P is indeed essential for binding to GTP. Although the precise role of binding of GTP to P is unclear, it appears that phosphorylation of P may initiate a structural change within the P protein allowing GTP to bind, thus manifesting biological function to the transcription factor.

Identification of a minimal size requirement for termination of vesicular stomatitis virus mRNA: implications for the mechanism of transcription

The nonsegmented negative-strand RNA (NNS) viruses have a single-stranded RNA genome tightly encapsidated by the viral nucleocapsid protein. The viral polymerase transcribes the genome responding to specific gene-start and gene-end sequences to yield a series of discrete monocistronic mRNAs. These mRNAs are not produced in equimolar amounts; rather, their abundance reflects the position of the gene with respect to the single 3'-proximal polymerase entry site. Promoter-proximal genes are transcribed in greater abundance than more distal genes due to a localized transcriptional attenuation at each gene junction. In recent years, the application of reverse genetics to the NNS viruses has allowed an examination of the role of the gene-start and gene-end sequences in regulating mRNA synthesis. These studies have defined specific sequences required for initiation, 5' modification, termination, and polyadenylation of the viral mRNAs. In the present report, working with Vesicular stomatitis virus, the prototypic Rhabdovirus, we demonstrate that a gene-end sequence must be positioned a minimal distance from a gene-start sequence for the polymerase to efficiently terminate transcription. Gene-end sequences were almost completely ignored in transcriptional units less than 51 nucleotides. Transcriptional units of 51 to 64 nucleotides allowed termination at the gene-end sequence, although the frequency with which polymerase failed to terminate and instead read through the gene-end sequence to generate a bicistronic transcript was enhanced compared to the observed 1 to 3% for wild-type viral mRNAs. In all instances, failure to terminate at the gene end prevented initiation at the downstream gene start site. In contrast to this size requirement, we show that the sequence between the gene-start and gene-end signals, or its potential to adopt an RNA secondary structure, had only a minor effect on the efficiency with which polymerase terminated transcription. We suggest three possible explanations for the failure of polymerase to terminate transcription in response to a gene-end sequence positioned close to a gene-start sequence which contribute to our emerging picture of the mechanism of transcriptional regulation in this group of viruses.

Transcript initiation and 5'-end modifications are separable events during vesicular stomatitis virus transcription

In this report we describe a novel, bipartite vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) replication system which was used to study the effect of mutations in the transcription start sequence on transcript initiation and 5'-mRNA modifications. The bipartite replication system consisted of two genomic RNAs, one of which (VSVDeltaG) was a recombinant VSV genome with the G gene deleted and the other (GFC) contained the G gene and two non-VSV reporter genes (green fluorescent protein [GFP] and chloramphenicol acetyltransferase [CAT]). Coinfection of cells with these two components resulted in high-level virus production and gave titers similar to that from wild-type-VSV-infected cells. Mutations were introduced within the first 3 nucleotides of the transcription start sequence of the third gene (CAT) of GFC. The effects of these changes on the synthesis and accumulation of CAT transcripts during in vivo transcription (e.g., in infected cells), and during in vitro transcription were determined. As we had reported previously (E. A. Stillman and M. A. Whitt, J. Virol. 71:2127-2137, 1997), changing the first and third nucleotides (NT-1 and NT-3) reduced CAT transcript levels in vivo to near undetectable levels. Similarly, changing NT-2 to a purine also resulted in the detection of very small amounts of CAT mRNA from infected cells. In contrast to the results in vivo, the NT-1C mutant and all of the second-position mutants produced near-wild-type amounts of CAT mRNA in the in vitro system, indicating that the mutations did not prevent transcript initiation per se but, rather, generated transcripts that were unstable in vivo. Oligo (dT) selection and Northern blot analysis revealed that the transcripts produced from these mutants did not contain a poly(A)(+) tail and were truncated, ranging in size from 40 to 200 nucleotides. Immunoprecipitation analysis of cDNA-RNA hybrids with an antibody that recognizes trimethylguanosine revealed that the truncated mutant transcripts were not properly modified at the 5' end, indicating the transcripts either were not capped or were not methylated. This is the first demonstration that transcript initiation and capping/methylation are separable events during VSV transcription. A model is proposed in which polymerase processivity is linked to proper 5'-end modification. The model suggests that a proofreading mechanism exists for VSV and possibly other nonsegmented minus-strand RNA viruses, whereby if some transcripts do not become capped during transcription in a normal infection, a signal is transduced such that the polymerase undergoes abortive elongation and the defective transcript is terminated prematurely and subsequently degraded.

Specific binding of guanosine 5'-diphosphate with the NS protein of vesicular stomatitis virus

A soluble protein fraction containing L, NS, G and M proteins of vesicular stomatitis virus was prepared by treatment of Triton-disrupted virions with 0.8M NaCl. Incubation of the soluble fraction with beta-32P GDP followed by analysis of the proteins by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed specific labeling of the NS protein. The NS-GDP complex was sensitive to phosphatase treatment, suggesting non-covalent binding. No binding of GDP to NS protein was detected when the soluble fraction was pre-heated at 100 degrees C for 1 min. or Mg++ was omitted from the incubation mixture. The binding was inhibited by ATP consistent with competition for a common nucleotide binding site.

Sequential synthesis of small capped RNA transcripts in vitro by vesicular stomatitis virus

Using purified viral or intracellular transcriptive complexes (RNP cores) of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), we have identified several small RNA species, ranging in size from 12 to 47 nucleotides in length that are synthesized in vitro by the genomic RNA. One group of small RNA transcripts is composed of three species that are capped at their 5' termini. Two of the capped species are from the start of the N gene and one is from the start of the NS gene. Unlike the previously described 5' triphosphated small RNAs, the templates encoding these small capped RNAs had uv target sizes greater than their respective lengths. In addition, these RNAs appeared sequentially during synchronized in vitro transcription reactions. Thus, these results provide evidence that sequences representing the 5'-capped termini of N and NS mRNAs are synthesized concomitantly with their respective mRNAs rather than simultaneously at the onset of transcription as proposed for the multiple entry, start-stop model (D. Testa, P. K. Chanda, and A. K. Banerjee, 1980, Cell 21, pp. 267-275). Together with the inability of the internally initiated 5'-triphosphated RNAs to be chased into mRNA (R. A. Lazzarini, I. Chien, F. Yang, and J. D. Keene, 1982, J. Gen. Virol. 58, 429-441), these results support a single entry model of VSV mRNA transcription.

In vitro transcription of defective interfering particles of influenza virus produces polyadenylic acid-containing complementary RNAs

Influenza virus defective interfering (DI) RNAs, which originate from polymerase genes by simple internal deletion, can be transcribed in vitro. These DI RNA transcripts contain covalently linked polyadenylic acid, and their synthesis is dependent on ApG or capped RNAs as primers. Furthermore, like the standard viral RNA transcripts, they are complementary in nature and are slightly smaller in size compared with the corresponding DI RNAs. Hybridization of the specific DI RNA transcripts with the corresponding DI RNA segments and analysis of the duplex RNA by gel electrophoresis indicate that they are not incomplete polymerase gene transcripts, but rather the transcripts of the DI RNAs. Since influenza virus DI RNAs contain both the 5' and the 3' termini and transcribe polyadenylic acid-containing complementary RNAs in vitro the mechanism of interference may differ from that of the 5' DI RNAs of Sendai and vesicular stomatitis viruses.

Host range mutants of vesicular stomatitis virus defective in in vitro RNA methylation

The viral RNA polymerase of detergent-treated vesicular stomatitis virus normally synthesizes viral mRNAs in vitro that are both guanylylated and methylated to give 5'-terminal 7mGpppAm caps. We have characterized a virus host range mutant, hr 1, that is totally defective in vitro in the methylation of mRNA, although full-length polyadenylylated mRNAs with 5' termini of the form GpppA are synthesized in normal yields. A second mutant, hr 8, is partially defective in methylation and synthesizes mRNAs in vitro with primarily GpppA and some GpppAm 5' termini. When used for in vitro translation, the unmethylated hr 1 mutant mRNA shows, as expected, reduced synthesis of viral proteins. These data provide direct evidence that the vesicular stomatitis virus-associated methyltransferase activities are virus encoded.

Synthesis of capped and uncapped methylated oligonucleotides by the virion transcriptase of spring viremia of carp virus, a rhabdovirus

Capped and uncapped methylated oligonucleotides, five and six nucleotides in length, were synthesized in vitro in spring viremia of carp virus transcription reaction mixtures containing ATP + CTP, ATP + CTP + GTP, or ATP + CTP + UTP, but not in any other combinations of two or three ribonucleoside triphosphates. The oligonucleotides that have been characterized are consistent with the structures: m7GpppAmpNpCpNpN, GpppAmpNpCpNpN, pppAmpNpCpNpN, and ppAmpNpCpNpN--i.e., similar to those of the termini of transcripts made in complete reaction mixtures. Because both capped and uncapped methylated oligonucleotides were synthesized, it can be concluded that methylation of the penultimate nucleotide can precede capping and methylation of the capping nucleotide. Our results also indicate that capping and methylation are processes that can take place prior to mRNA chain completion.

In vivo transcription of the 5'-terminal extracistronic region of vesicular stomatitis virus RNA

In vivo transcription and polyadenylation at the junction of the L cistron and the 5'-terminal extracistronic region of vesicular stomatitis virus RNA was investigated. Annealing of 5'32P-labeled RNA representing the 5'-terminal noncoding 77 nucleotides of vesicular stomatitis virus genomic RNA to L gene mRNA resulted in specific duplex formation. Two specific RNase T1- and RNase A resistant duplexes, 66 and 77 nucleotides long, bound to oligodeoxythymidylic acid cellulose. The specific sizes of the duplexes and their selection by oligodeoxythymidylic acid cellulose chromatography demonstrated that they were covalently linked to the polyadenylic acid tail of L gene mRNA. These data strongly suggest that the viral polymerase polyadenylates L gene mRNA in vivo by using the stretch of seven uridine residues at the end of the L cistron and that the polymerase can resume transcribing the 5'-terminal extracistronic region, resulting in a covalent linkage of the transcript to the polyadenylic acid tail of L gene mRNA.

Initiation of transcription by RNA polymerase II in permeable, SV40-infected or noninfected, CVI cells; evidence for multiple promoters of SV40 late transcription

CV1 cells were made permeable by treatment with lysolecithin and incubated in a transcription mixture containing ribonucleoside triphosphates including ATP or GTP 32P-labeled either in the alpha or beta position. 5'-terminal cap structures (7mGpgamma pbeta palpha X) on newly synthesized RNA were analyzed by digestion with nuclease P1 or with ribonuclease T2/bacterial alkaline phosphatase. Cap structures obtained after labeling with alpha-32P-GTP show that the 32P is found only adjacent to the 7mG residue (i.e., in the gamma position) and adjacent to the penultimate Gm or G nucleotide (i.e., in the alpha position). Analysis of RNA synthesized in the presence of beta-32P-ATP, however, shows GpppA cap structures which are labeled only in the beta position. In the presence of beta-32-p-GTP, only GpppG structures are labeled; these findings exclude the hypothesis that caps are synthesized from GTP and a monophosphate 5'-terminal RNA molecule. The results imply that the initial transcripts are used for cap formation, which indicates that the large majority (if not all) of capping sites correspond to initiation sites for transcription. In cells infected with wild-types SV40 the distribution of virus-specific caps is similar when labeled either with beta-32P-ATP or with alpha-32P-GTP or with 32p-phosphate. Thus, evidence is presented that heterogeneity of the cap structures in late SV40 is a consequence of independent initiation events and not of processing of a primary transcript followed by capping of the 5' ends generated.

Replicative RNA synthesis and nucleocapsid assembly in vesicular stomatitis virus-infected permeable cells

A permeable-cell system has been developed to study the replication of vesicular stomatitis virus. When vesicular stomatitis virus-infected BHK cells were permeabilized by lysolecithin treatment, they incorporated nucleoside triphosphates into RNA and amino acids into proteins at nearly normal rates. The viral mRNA's synthesized appeared normal in polarity, size distribution, and polyadenylation, and all five viral proteins were synthesized. Replication of the viral genome proceeded, and full-length RNA strands were synthesized in amounts and polarities resembling those found in intact cells. These full-length RNAs associated with viral N proteins to form RNase-resistant nucleocapsids of normal buoyant density. Permeable cells appear to represent ideal hosts for studying vesicular stomatitis virus replication since they closely mimic in vivo conditions while retaining much of the experimental flexibility of current in vitro systems.

Unique mode of transcription in vitro by Vesicular stomatitis virus

In addition to the five mRNA species and 47 nucleotide long leader RNA synthesized by purified virions of vesicular stomatitis virus, at least three discrete low molecular weight RNA species having approximate chain lengths of 28, 42 and 70 nucleotides can be detected in vitro. Each of these RNA species displays a unique and characteristic T1 fingerprint profile and contains (p)ppAA as its 5' terminus. By partial sequence analyses, two of the small RNA products, 42 and 28 bases long, were found to contain 5' terminal sequences identical to those in the N and NS mRNAs, respectively. Ultraviolet inactivation studies demonstrate that each of these RNA species has a target size in agreement with its molecular weight indicating independent initiation. Kinetic studies show that the small RNA species are synthesized within 1 min, while mRNA chain completion occurs later in the sequential order N-NS-M-G. These results indicate that viral mRNA synthesis occurs in vitro by multiple initiations at different promoter sites on the genome RNA, and that the elongation and completion of the individual mRNAs depend on prior transcription of 3' proximal genes. We present a model for viral mRNA synthesis in vitro.

Absence of detectable capping and methylating enzymes in influenza virions

In the presence of Mg(2+) and a specific dinucleotide primer (ApG or GpG), the influenza virion transcriptase synthesizes the eight discrete segments of complementary RNA (cRNA) containing polyadenylic acid (Plotch and Krug, J. Virol. 21:24-34, 1977). Virions were examined for their ability to cap and methylate cRNA containing di- or triphosphorylated 5' termini. By using the primers ppApG, pppApG, or ppGpG, viral cRNA was synthesized in vitro with [alpha-(32)P]-GTP and S-[methyl-(3)H]adenosylmethionine as labeled precursors. DEAE-Sephadex chromatography of the RNase T2 digest of the cRNA product demonstrated no (3)H incorporation at all and the absence of a (32)P-labeled cap structure. The 5' terminus of ppApG-primed cRNA could be capped and methylated by enzymes from vaccinia virus, indicating that the two 5'-terminal phosphates derived from the primer were preserved in the product cRNA. The cap structure formed by the vaccinia enzymes and released by RNase T2 digestion as m(7)GpppA(m)pGp was radioactively labeled at its 3'-terminal phosphate only when [alpha-(32)P]CTP was used as the labeled precursor during transcription. This indicates that the 5'-terminal sequence of the cRNA is ppApGpC and that, therefore, ppApG most probably initiates transcription exactly at the 3' GpCpU(OH) terminus of the virion RNA templates. Virions were also tested for their ability to cap and methylate ppApG in the absence of transcription. No such activities were detected, whereas under the same conditions the vaccinia virus enzymes successfully capped and methylated this compound. Consequently, these experiments, together with those reported earlier, have not detected in influenza virions any capping and methylating enzymes active on the 5'-initiated termini of viral cRNA chains synthesized in vitro, whether these termini possess one, two, or three phosphates. Some mechanism for capping and methylation of viral cRNA must, however, exist, because the viral mRNA (cRNA) synthesized in the infected cell contains 5'-terminal methylated cap structures (Krug et al., J. Virol. 20:45-53, 1976). Possible mechanisms are discussed.

Spatial configuration of mRNA 5'-terminus

Nuclear magnetic resonance investigation has revealed that the 5'-terminus m7G5'ppp5'Am of mRNA displays a spatial configuration in which the bases form stacked arrays. Details of the conformation as derived from coupling constants, shift trends and ring current considerations are discussed.