Neutralizing antibodies against adeno-associated viruses in Sjögren's patients: implications for gene therapy

Seroprevalence of binding and neutralizing antibodies against 18 adeno-associated virus types in patients with neuromuscular disorders

High levels of pre-existing antibodies are a major challenge for the application of viral vectors since they can severely limit their efficacy. To identify promising candidates among adeno-associated virus (AAV) based vectors for future gene therapies for the treatment of hereditary neuromuscular disorders (NMDs), we investigated the antibody levels in sera from patients with NMDs against 18 AAV types, including 11 AAVs with wild-type capsids, 5 AAVs with peptide-modified capsids and 2 AAVs with shuffled capsids. With regard to the wild-type capsid AAVs, the lowest binding antibody levels were detected against AAV6, AAV5, AAV12 and AAV9, whereas the highest binding antibody levels were detected against AAV10, AAV8, AAV1, and AAV2. The lowest neutralizing antibody levels against wild-type AAVs were detected against AAV12, AAV5, AAV9, AAV7, AAV8 and AAV10, and the highest neutralizing antibody levels were detected against AAV13, AAV2 and AAV3. Interestingly, the influence of peptide modifications or shuffling of AAV capsids on antibody binding and AAV neutralization seemed to depend on the parental AAV. While the sex of the serum donors had no significant impact on binding or neutralizing antibody levels, we observed a trend to higher binding antibodies in older serum donors against some AAV types and a clear positive correlation of neutralizing antibody titers with the age of the serum donors. The disease status on the other hand did not have a meaningful impact on antibody levels, with no changes in AAV neutralization. Our data indicate that several wild-type or peptide-modified AAV may be good candidates for therapeutic application due to low pre-existing antibody levels, and that the age of potential recipients rather than their health status with regard to NMDs has the biggest impact on vector applicability.

Seroprevalence of adeno-associated virus types 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, and 9 in a Basque cohort of healthy donors

Adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) are promising gene therapy vectors, but challenges arise when treating patients with preexisting neutralizing antibodies. Worldwide seroprevalence studies provide snapshots of existing immunity in diverse populations. Owing to the uniqueness of the Basque socio-geographical landscape, we investigated the seroprevalence of eight AAV serotypes in residents of the Basque Country. We found the highest seroprevalence of AAV3, and the lowest seroprevalence of AAV9. Additionally, less than 50% of the Basque population has neutralizing antibodies against AAV4, AAV6, and AAV9. Our findings provide insight into AAV infections in the Basque region, public health, and the development of AAV-based therapeutics.

Understanding AAV vector immunogenicity: from particle to patient

Gene therapy holds promise for patients with inherited monogenic disorders, cancer, and rare genetic diseases. Naturally occurring adeno-associated virus (AAV) offers a well-suited vehicle for clinical gene transfer due to its lack of significant clinical pathogenicity and amenability to be engineered to deliver therapeutic transgenes in a variety of cell types for long-term sustained expression. AAV has been bioengineered to produce recombinant AAV (rAAV) vectors for many gene therapies that are approved or in late-stage development. However, ongoing challenges hamper wider use of rAAV vector-mediated therapies. These include immunity against rAAV vectors, limited transgene packaging capacity, sub-optimal tissue transduction, potential risks of insertional mutagenesis and vector shedding. This review focuses on aspects of immunity against rAAV, mediated by anti-AAV neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) arising after natural exposure to AAVs or after rAAV vector administration. We provide an in-depth analysis of factors determining AAV seroprevalence and examine clinical approaches to managing anti-AAV NAbs pre- and post-vector administration. Methodologies used to quantify anti-AAV NAb levels and strategies to overcome pre-existing AAV immunity are also discussed. The broad adoption of rAAV vector-mediated gene therapies will require wider clinical appreciation of their current limitations and further research to mitigate their impact.

Gene Therapeutic Delivery to the Salivary Glands

The salivary glands, exocrine glands in our body producing saliva, can be easily damaged by various factors. Radiation therapy and Sjogren's syndrome (a systemic autoimmune disease) are the two main causes of salivary gland damage, leading to a severe reduction in patients' quality of life. Gene transfer to the salivary glands has been considered a promising approach to treating the dysfunction. Gene therapy has long been applied to cure multiple diseases, including cancers, and hereditary and infectious diseases, which are proven to be safe and effective for the well-being of patients. The application of this treatment on salivary gland injuries has been studied for decades, yet its clinical progress is delayed. This chapter provides a coup d'oeil into gene transfer methods and various gene/vector types for salivary glands to help the new scientists and update established scientists on the progress that has been made during the past decades for the treatment of salivary gland disorders.

Systemic gene therapy for methylmalonic acidemia using the novel adeno-associated viral vector 44.9

Methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) is a severe and potentially lethal autosomal recessive inborn error of metabolism most frequently caused by mutations in the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MMUT) gene. Proof-of-concept adeno-associated virus (AAV) gene therapy studies using mouse models of MMA have demonstrated promise for this therapeutic approach but translation to the clinic could be limited by preexisting capsid immunity and vector potency. Here we explore the efficacy of a novel clade E capsid, 44.9, as a serotype for systemic AAV gene therapy for MMA. An anti-AAV44.9 neutralizing antibody (NAb) survey in adult volunteers (n = 19) and a large cohort of MMA patients (n = 48) revealed a seroprevalence rate of ∼26% and 13%, respectively. The efficacy of AAV44.9 gene delivery was examined in two murine models of MMA, representing neonatal lethal and juvenile phenotypes of MMA. Systemic delivery of the AAV44.9-Mmut vector prevented lethality and lowered disease-related metabolites in MMA mice. Tissue biodistribution and transgene expression studies in treated MMA mice showed that AAV44.9 was efficient at transducing the liver and heart. In summary, we establish that AAV44.9 exhibits a low prevalence of preexisting NAb in humans, is highly efficacious in the treatment of clinically severe MMA mouse models and is therefore a promising vector for clinical translation.

Mouth-Watering Results: Clinical Need, Current Approaches, and Future Directions for Salivary Gland Regeneration

Permanent damage to the salivary glands and resulting hyposalivation and xerostomia have a substantial impact on patient health, quality of life, and healthcare costs. Currently, patients rely on lifelong treatments that alleviate the symptoms, but no long-term restorative solutions exist. Recent advances in adult stem cell enrichment and transplantation, bioengineering, and gene transfer have proved successful in rescuing salivary gland function in a number of animal models that reflect human diseases and that result in hyposalivation and xerostomia. By overcoming the limitations of stem cell transplants and better understanding the mechanisms of cellular plasticity in the adult salivary gland, such studies provide encouraging evidence that a regenerative strategy for patients will be available in the near future.

Structure of the gene therapy vector, adeno-associated virus with its cell receptor, AAVR

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors are preeminent in emerging clinical gene therapies. Generalizing beyond the most tractable genetic diseases will require modulation of cell specificity and immune neutralization. Interactions of AAV with its cellular receptor, AAVR, are key to understanding cell-entry and trafficking with the rigor needed to engineer tissue-specific vectors. Cryo-electron tomography shows ordered binding of part of the flexible receptor to the viral surface, with distal domains in multiple conformations. Regions of the virus and receptor in close physical proximity can be identified by cross-linking/mass spectrometry. Cryo-electron microscopy with a two-domain receptor fragment reveals the interactions at 2.4 Å resolution. AAVR binds between AAV's spikes on a plateau that is conserved, except in one clade whose structure is AAVR-incompatible. AAVR's footprint overlaps the epitopes of several neutralizing antibodies, prompting a re-evaluation of neutralization mechanisms. The structure provides a roadmap for experimental probing and manipulation of viral-receptor interactions.

The Impact of Pre-existing Immunity on the Non-clinical Pharmacodynamics of AAV5-Based Gene Therapy

Adeno-associated virus (AAV)-based vectors are widely used for gene therapy, but the effect of pre-existing antibodies resulting from exposure to wild-type AAV is unclear. In addition, other poorly defined plasma factors could inhibit AAV vector transduction where antibodies are not detected. To better define the relationship between various forms of pre-existing AAV immunity and gene transfer, we studied valoctocogene roxaparvovec (BMN 270) in cynomolgus monkeys with varying pre-dose levels of neutralizing anti-AAV antibodies and non-antibody transduction inhibitors. BMN 270 is an AAV5-based vector for treating hemophilia A that encodes human B domain-deleted factor VIII (FVIII-SQ). After infusion of BMN 270 (6.0 × 10¹³ vg/kg) into animals with pre-existing anti-AAV5 antibodies, there was a mean decrease in maximal FVIII-SQ plasma concentration (C_max) and AUC of 74.8% and 66.9%, respectively, compared with non-immune control animals, and vector genomes in the liver were reduced. In contrast, animals with only non-antibody transduction inhibitors showed FVIII-SQ plasma concentrations and liver vector copies comparable with those of controls. These results demonstrate that animals without AAV5 antibodies are likely responders to AAV5 gene therapy, regardless of other inhibiting plasma factors. The biological threshold for tolerable AAV5 antibody levels varied between individual animals and should be evaluated further in clinical studies.

Adeno-Associated Virus Neutralizing Antibodies in Large Animals and Their Impact on Brain Intraparenchymal Gene Transfer

Pre-existing neutralizing antibody (NAb) against adeno-associated virus (AAV) commonly found in primates is a major host barrier that can severely compromise in vivo gene transfer by AAV vectors. To achieve proof-of-concept success in clinical development of recombinant AAV (rAAV)-based in vivo gene therapy, it is crucial to consider the potential interference of NAb and to enroll serologically compatible study subjects. In this study, we report a large AAV NAb dataset comprising multiple large animal species and AAV serotypes and compare two NAb assays based on in vitro or in vivo transduction inhibition, respectively. Together with previously published AAV seroepidemiology studies, these data can serve as a reference for selecting suitable serotypes, study subjects of large animal species, and potentially human patients for rAAV treatment. In addition, we modeled the intrathalamus rAAV9 delivery in the presence of circulating anti-AAV9 NAb generated by either pre-immunization or passive transfer of NAb-positive large animal serum to mice. The data showed that circulating NAb may not be the sole determinant to inhibit brain transduction. Other aspects of pre-existing AAV immunity following natural infection or rAAV administration may be further studied to establish a more accurate inclusion criterion for clinical studies employing intraparenchymal rAAV9 injections.

Unraveling the Complex Story of Immune Responses to AAV Vectors Trial After Trial

Over the past decade, vectors derived from adeno-associated virus (AAV) have established themselves as a powerful tool for in vivo gene transfer, allowing long-lasting and safe transgene expression in a variety of human tissues. Nevertheless, clinical trials demonstrated how B and T cell immune responses directed against the AAV capsid, likely arising after natural infection with wild-type AAV, might potentially impact gene transfer safety and efficacy in patients. Seroprevalence studies have evidenced that most individuals carry anti-AAV neutralizing antibodies that can inhibit recombinant AAV transduction of target cells following in vivo administration of vector particles. Likewise, liver- and muscle-directed clinical trials have shown that capsid-reactive memory CD8⁺ T cells could be reactivated and expanded upon presentation of capsid-derived antigens on transduced cells, potentially leading to loss of transgene expression and immune-mediated toxicities. In celebration of the 25th anniversary of the European Society of Gene and Cell Therapy, this review article summarizes progress made during the past decade in understanding and modulating AAV vector immunogenicity. While the knowledge generated has contributed to yield impressive clinical results, several important questions remain unanswered, making the study of immune responses to AAV a priority for the field of in vivo transfer.