A redox switch shapes the Lon protease exit pore to facultatively regulate proteolysis

Structure, Substrate Specificity and Role of Lon Protease in Bacterial Pathogenesis and Survival

Proteases are the group of enzymes that carry out proteolysis in all forms of life and play an essential role in cell survival. By acting on specific functional proteins, proteases affect the transcriptional and post-translational pathways in a cell. Lon, FtsH, HslVU and the Clp family are among the ATP-dependent proteases responsible for intracellular proteolysis in bacteria. In bacteria, Lon protease acts as a global regulator, governs an array of important functions such as DNA replication and repair, virulence factors, stress response and biofilm formation, among others. Moreover, Lon is involved in the regulation of bacterial metabolism and toxin-antitoxin systems. Hence, understanding the contribution and mechanisms of Lon as a global regulator in bacterial pathogenesis is crucial. In this review, we discuss the structure and substrate specificity of the bacterial Lon protease, as well as its ability to regulate bacterial pathogenesis.

Catalytic cycling of human mitochondrial Lon protease

The mitochondrial Lon protease (LonP1) regulates mitochondrial health by removing redundant proteins from the mitochondrial matrix. We determined LonP1 in eight nucleotide-dependent conformational states by cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM). The flexible assembly of N-terminal domains had 3-fold symmetry, and its orientation depended on the conformational state. We show that a conserved structural motif around T803 with a high similarity to the trypsin catalytic triad is essential for proteolysis. We show that LonP1 is not regulated by redox potential, despite the presence of two conserved cysteines at disulfide-bonding distance in its unfoldase core. Our data indicate how sequential ATP hydrolysis controls substrate protein translocation in a 6-fold binding change mechanism. Substrate protein translocation, rather than ATP hydrolysis, is a rate-limiting step, suggesting that LonP1 is a Brownian ratchet with ATP hydrolysis preventing translocation reversal. 3-fold rocking motions of the flexible N-domain assembly may assist thermal unfolding of the substrate protein.

Structure and the mode of activity of Lon proteases from diverse organisms

Lon proteases, members of the AAA⁺ superfamily of enzymes, are key components of the protein quality control system in bacterial cells, as well as in the mitochondria and other specialized organelles of higher organisms. These enzymes have been subject of extensive biochemical and structural investigations, resulting in 72 crystal and solution structures, including structures of the individual domains, multi-domain constructs, and full-length proteins. However, interpretation of the latter structures still leaves some questions unanswered. Based on their amino acid sequence and details of their structure, Lon proteases can be divided into at least three subfamilies, designated as LonA, LonB, and LonC. Protomers of all Lons are single-chain polypeptides and contain two functional domains, ATPase and protease. The LonA enzymes additionally include a large N-terminal region, and different Lons may also include non-conserved inserts in the principal domains. These ATP-dependent proteases function as homohexamers, in which unfolded substrates are translocated to a large central chamber where they undergo proteolysis by a processive mechanism. X-ray crystal structures provided high-resolution models which verified that Lons are hydrolases with the rare Ser-Lys catalytic dyad. Full-length LonA enzymes have been investigated by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM), providing description of the functional enzyme at different stages of the catalytic cycle, indicating extensive flexibility of their N-terminal domains, and revealing insights into the substrate translocation mechanism. Structural studies of Lon proteases provide an interesting case for symbiosis of X-ray crystallography and cryo-EM, currently the two principal techniques for determination of macromolecular structures.

Structure-Based Design of Selective LONP1 Inhibitors for Probing In Vitro Biology

LONP1 is an AAA+ protease that maintains mitochondrial homeostasis by removing damaged or misfolded proteins. Elevated activity and expression of LONP1 promotes cancer cell proliferation and resistance to apoptosis-inducing reagents. Despite the importance of LONP1 in human biology and disease, very few LONP1 inhibitors have been described in the literature. Herein, we report the development of selective boronic acid-based LONP1 inhibitors using structure-based drug design as well as the first structures of human LONP1 bound to various inhibitors. Our efforts led to several nanomolar LONP1 inhibitors with little to no activity against the 20S proteasome that serve as tool compounds to investigate LONP1 biology.

Deletion of the lon gene augments expression of Salmonella Pathogenicity Island (SPI)-1 and metal ion uptake genes leading to the accumulation of bactericidal hydroxyl radicals and host pro-inflammatory cytokine-mediated rapid intracellular clearance

In the present study, we characterized the involvement of Lon protease in bacterial virulence and intracellular survival in Salmonella under abiotic stress conditions resembling the conditions of a natural infection. Wild type (JOL401) and the lon mutant (JOL909) Salmonella Typhimurium were exposed to low temperature, pH, osmotic, and oxidative stress conditions and changes in gene expression profiles related to virulence and metal ion uptake were investigated. Expression of candidate genes invF and hilC of Salmonella Pathogenicity Island (SPI)-1 and sifA and sseJ of SPI-2 revealed that Lon protease controls SPI-1 genes and not SPI-2 genes under all stress conditions tested. The lon mutant exhibited increased accumulation of hydroxyl (OH·) ions that lead to cell damage due to oxidative stress. This oxidative damage can also be linked to an unregulated influx of iron due to the upregulation of ion channel genes such as fepA in the lon mutant. The deletion of lon from the Salmonella genome causes oxidative damage and increased expression of virulence genes. It also prompts the secretion of host pro-inflammatory cytokines leading to early clearance of the bacteria from host cells. We conclude that poor bacterial recovery from mice infected with the lon mutant is a result of disrupted bacterial intracellular equilibrium and rapid activation of cytokine expression leading to bacterial lysis.

Crystal structure of the N domain of Lon protease from Mycobacterium avium complex

Lon protease is evolutionarily conserved in prokaryotes and eukaryotic organelles. The primary function of Lon is to selectively degrade abnormal and certain regulatory proteins to maintain the homeostasis in vivo. Lon mainly consists of three functional domains and the N-terminal domain is required for the substrate selection and recognition. However, the precise contribution of the N-terminal domain remains elusive. Here, we determined the crystal structure of the N-terminal 192-residue construct of Lon protease from Mycobacterium avium complex at 2.4 å resolution，and measured NMR-relaxation parameters of backbones. This structure consists of two subdomains, the β-strand rich N-terminal subdomain and the five-helix bundle of C-terminal subdomain, connected by a flexible linker，and is similar to the overall structure of the N domain of Escherichia coli Lon even though their sequence identity is only 26%. The obtained NMR-relaxation parameters reveal two stabilized loops involved in the structural packing of the compact N domain and a turn structure formation. The performed homology comparison suggests that structural and sequence variations in the N domain may be closely related to the substrate selectivity of Lon variants. Our results provide the structure and dynamics characterization of a new Lon N domain, and will help to define the precise contribution of the Lon N-terminal domain to the substrate recognition.

Redox-Mediated Post-Translational Modifications of Proteolytic Enzymes and Their Role in Protease Functioning

Proteolytic enzymes play a crucial role in metabolic processes, providing the cell with amino acids through the hydrolysis of multiple endogenous and exogenous proteins. In addition to this function, proteases are involved in numerous protein cascades to maintain cellular and extracellular homeostasis. The redox regulation of proteolysis provides a flexible dose-dependent mechanism for proteolytic activity control. The excessive reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) in living organisms indicate pathological conditions, so redox-sensitive proteases can swiftly induce pro-survival responses or regulated cell death (RCD). At the same time, severe protein oxidation can lead to the dysregulation of proteolysis, which induces either protein aggregation or superfluous protein hydrolysis. Therefore, oxidative stress contributes to the onset of age-related dysfunction. In the present review, we consider the post-translational modifications (PTMs) of proteolytic enzymes and their impact on homeostasis.

Salmonella expresses foreign genes during infection by degrading their silencer

The heat-stable nucleoid structuring (H-NS, also referred to as histone-like nucleoid structuring) protein silences transcription of foreign genes in a variety of Gram-negative bacterial species. To take advantage of the products encoded in foreign genes, bacteria must overcome the silencing effects of H-NS. Because H-NS amounts are believed to remain constant, overcoming gene silencing has largely been ascribed to proteins that outcompete H-NS for binding to AT-rich foreign DNA. However, we report here that the facultative intracellular pathogen Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium decreases H-NS amounts 16-fold when inside macrophages. This decrease requires both the protease Lon and the DNA-binding virulence regulator PhoP. The decrease in H-NS abundance reduces H-NS binding to foreign DNA, allowing transcription of foreign genes, including those required for intramacrophage survival. The purified Lon protease degraded free H-NS but not DNA-bound H-NS. By displacing H-NS from DNA, the PhoP protein promoted H-NS proteolysis, thereby de-repressing foreign genes-even those whose regulatory sequences are not bound by PhoP. The uncovered mechanism enables a pathogen to express foreign virulence genes during infection without the need to evolve binding sites for antisilencing proteins at each foreign gene.

Time-resolved FTIR study on the structural switching of human galectin-1 by light-induced disulfide bond formation

The light-induced disulfide bond technique, which we have previously developed, has enabled the time-resolved measurement of the disulfide-induced conformational switching of the lectin protein human galectin-1.

Cryo-EM structure of substrate-free E. coli Lon protease provides insights into the dynamics of Lon machinery

Energy-dependent Lon proteases play a key role in cellular regulation by degrading short-lived regulatory proteins and misfolded proteins in the cell. The structure of the catalytically inactive S679A mutant of Escherichia coli LonA protease (EcLon) has been determined by cryo-EM at the resolution of 3.5 Å. EcLonA without a bound substrate adopts a hexameric open-spiral quaternary structure that might represent the resting state of the enzyme. Upon interaction with substrate the open-spiral hexamer undergoes a major conformational change resulting in a compact, closed-circle hexamer as in the recent structure of a complex of Yersinia pestis LonA with a protein substrate. This major change is accomplished by the rigid-body rearrangement of the individual domains within the protomers of the complex around the hinge points in the interdomain linkers. Comparison of substrate-free and substrate-bound Lon structures allows to mark the location of putative pivotal points involved in such conformational changes.

Redox Regulation of the Mitochondrial Quality Control Protease Oma1

Aims: Normal mitochondrial function and integrity are crucial for cellular physiology. Given the paramount role of mitochondrial quality control proteases in these processes, our study focused on investigating mechanisms by which the activity of a key quality control protease Oma1 is regulated under normal conditions and in response to homeostatic insults. Results: Oma1 was found to be a redox-dependent protein that exists in a semi-oxidized state in yeast and mammalian mitochondria. Biochemical and genetic analyses provide evidence that activity and stability of the Oma1 oligomeric complex can be dynamically tuned in a reduction/oxidation-sensitive manner. Mechanistically, these features appear to be mediated by two intermembrane space (IMS)-exposed highly conserved cysteine residues, Cys²⁷² and Cys³³². These residues form a disulfide bond, which likely plays a structural role and influences conformational stability and activity of the Oma1 high-mass complex. Finally, in line with these findings, engineered Oma1 substrate is shown to engage with the protease in a redox-sensitive manner. Innovation: This study provides new insights into the function of the Oma1 protease, a central controller of mitochondrial membrane homeostasis and dynamics, and reveals the novel conserved mechanism of the redox-dependent regulation of Oma1. Conclusion: Disulfide bonds formed by IMS-exposed residues Cys²⁷² and Cys³³² play an important evolutionarily conserved role in the regulation of Oma1 function. We propose that the redox status of these cysteines may act as a redox-tunable switch to optimize Oma1 proteolytic function for specific cellular conditions or homeostatic challenges.

Allosteric disulphide bonds as reversible mechano-sensitive switches that control protein functions in the vasculature

Disulphide bonds are covalent linkages of two cysteine residues (R-S-S-R') in proteins. Unlike peptide bonds, disulphide bonds are reversible in nature allowing cleaved bonds to reform. Disulphide bonds are important structural elements that stabilise protein conformation. They can be of catalytic function found in enzymes that facilitate redox reactions in the cleavage/formation of disulphide bonds in their substrates. Emerging evidence also indicates that disulphide bonds can be of regulatory function which alter protein activity when they are cleaved or formed. This class of regulatory disulphide bonds is known as allosteric disulphide bonds. Allosteric disulphide bonds are mechano-sensitive, and stretching or twisting the sulphur-sulphur bond by mechanical force can make it easier or harder to be cleaved. This makes allosteric disulphide bonds an ideal type of mechano-sensitive switches for regulating protein functions in the vasculature where cells are continuously subjected to fluid shear force. This review will discuss the chemistry and biophysical properties of allosteric disulphide bonds and how they emerge to be mechano-sensitive switches in regulating platelet function and clot formation.

Allosteric disulfides: Sophisticated molecular structures enabling flexible protein regulation

Protein disulfide bonds link pairs of cysteine residues in polypeptide chains. Many of these bonds serve a purely structural or energetic role, but a growing subset of cleavable disulfide bonds has been shown to control the function of the mature protein in which they reside. These allosteric disulfides and the factors that cleave these bonds are being identified across biological systems and life forms and have been shown to control hemostasis, the immune response, and viral infection in mammals. The discovery of these functional disulfides and a rationale for their facile nature has been aided by the emergence of a conformational signature for allosteric bonds. This post-translational modification mostly occurs extracellularly, making these chemical events prime drug targets. Indeed, a membrane-impermeable inhibitor of one of the cleaving factors is currently being trialed as an antithrombotic agent in cancer patients. Allosteric disulfides are firmly established as a sophisticated means by which a protein's shape and function can be altered; however, the full scope of this biological regulation will not be realized without new tools and techniques to study this regulation and innovative ways of targeting it.

Determining the Redox Potential of a Protein Disulphide Bond

The redox potential of a protein disulphide bond is one of the most important factors for determining the role of a disulphide bond. Disulphide bonds can have a stabilizing role for the structure of a protein or they can play a functional role which can regulate protein bioactivity. Determining the redox potential of disulphides can help distinguish the functional from the structural disulphide bonds. In this chapter, two methods for determining the redox potential of a protein disulphide bond are described. The first method uses maleimide-biotin labeling of free cysteine thiols and western blot densitometry to determine the fraction of reduced disulphide bond under various redox-buffering conditions. The second method uses differential cysteine labeling and tandem mass spectrometry to determine the redox potential.

Multiple domains of bacterial and human Lon proteases define substrate selectivity

The Lon protease selectively degrades abnormal proteins or certain normal proteins in response to environmental and cellular conditions in many prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms. However, the mechanism(s) behind the substrate selection of normal proteins remains largely unknown. In this study, we identified 10 new substrates of F. tularensis Lon from a total of 21 candidate substrates identified in our previous work, the largest number of novel Lon substrates from a single study. Cross-species degradation of these and other known Lon substrates revealed that human Lon is unable to degrade many bacterial Lon substrates, suggestive of a “organism-adapted” substrate selection mechanism for the natural Lon variants. However, individually replacing the N, A, and P domains of human Lon with the counterparts of bacterial Lon did not enable the human protease to degrade the same bacterial Lon substrates. This result showed that the “organism-adapted” substrate selection depends on multiple domains of the Lon proteases. Further in vitro proteolysis and mass spectrometry analysis revealed a similar substrate cleavage pattern between the bacterial and human Lon variants, which was exemplified by predominant representation of leucine, alanine, and other hydrophobic amino acids at the P(−1) site within the substrates. These observations suggest that the Lon proteases select their substrates at least in part by fine structural matching with the proteins in the same organisms.

ROLE OF THIOLS IN OXIDATIVE STRESS

A well-regulated redox state is essential for normal physiological function and cellular metabolism. In most eukaryotic cells, protein cysteine thiols are most sensitive to fluctuations in the cellular redox state. Under normal physiological conditions, the cytosol has a highly reducing environment, which is due to high levels of reduced glutathione and complex system of redox enzymes that maintain glutathione in the reduced state. The reducing environment of the cytosol maintains most protein thiols in the reduced state; although some non-exposed cysteine could be present as disulfides. Upon physiological increase in cellular oxidants, such as due to growth factors, cytokines and thiol-disulfide exchange reactions, specific proteins could act as redox switches that regulate the conformation and activity of different proteins. This reversible post translational modification enables redox-sensitive dynamic changes in cell signaling and function. Physiological oxidative stress could lead to the formation of sulfenic acids, which are usually intermediate states of thiol oxidation that are converted to higher order oxidation states, intramolecular disulfides or mixed disulfides with glutathione. Such glutathiolation reactions have been found to regulate the function of several proteins involved in intracellular metabolism, signal transduction and cell structure. Excessive oxidative stress results in indiscriminate and irreversible oxidation of protein thiols, depletion of glutathione and cell death. Further elucidation of the relationship between changes in cell redox and thiol reactivity could provide a better understanding of how redox changes regulate cell function and how disruption of these relationships lead to tissue injury and dysfunction and the development of chronic diseases such as cancer and cardiovascular disease.

Identification of allosteric disulfides from labile bonds in X-ray structures

Protein disulfide bonds link pairs of cysteine sulfur atoms and are either structural or functional motifs. The allosteric disulfides control the function of the protein in which they reside when cleaved or formed. Here, we identify potential allosteric disulfides in all Protein Data Bank X-ray structures from bonds that are present in some molecules of a protein crystal but absent in others, or present in some structures of a protein but absent in others. We reasoned that the labile nature of these disulfides signifies a propensity for cleavage and so possible allosteric regulation of the protein in which the bond resides. A total of 511 labile disulfide bonds were identified. The labile disulfides are more stressed than the average bond, being characterized by high average torsional strain and stretching of the sulfur-sulfur bond and neighbouring bond angles. This pre-stress likely underpins their susceptibility to cleavage. The coagulation, complement and oxygen-sensing hypoxia inducible factor-1 pathways, which are known or have been suggested to be regulated by allosteric disulfides, are enriched in proteins containing labile disulfides. The identification of labile disulfide bonds will facilitate the study of this post-translational modification.

A Phosphorylation Switch on Lon Protease Regulates Bacterial Type III Secretion System in Host

Most pathogenic bacteria deliver virulence factors into host cytosol through type III secretion systems (T3SS) to perturb host immune responses. The expression of T3SS is often repressed in rich medium but is specifically induced in the host environment. The molecular mechanisms underlying host-specific induction of T3SS expression is not completely understood. Here we demonstrate in Xanthomonas citri that host-induced phosphorylation of the ATP-dependent protease Lon stabilizes HrpG, the master regulator of T3SS, conferring bacterial virulence. Ser/Thr/Tyr phosphoproteome analysis revealed that phosphorylation of Lon at serine 654 occurs in the citrus host. In rich medium, Lon represses T3SS by degradation of HrpG via recognition of its N terminus. Genetic and biochemical data indicate that phosphorylation at serine 654 deactivates Lon proteolytic activity and attenuates HrpG proteolysis. Substitution of alanine for Lon serine 654 resulted in repression of T3SS gene expression in the citrus host through robust degradation of HrpG and reduced bacterial virulence. Our work reveals a novel mechanism for distinct regulation of bacterial T3SS in different environments. Additionally, our data provide new insight into the role of protein posttranslational modification in the regulation of bacterial virulence.IMPORTANCE Type III secretion systems (T3SS) are an essential virulence trait of many bacterial pathogens because of their indispensable role in the delivery of virulence factors. However, expression of T3SS in the noninfection stage is energy consuming. Here, we established a model to explain the differential regulation of T3SS in host and nonhost environments. When Xanthomonas cells are grown in rich medium, the T3SS regulator HrpG is targeted by Lon protease for proteolysis. The degradation of HrpG leads to downregulated expression of HrpX and the hrp/hrc genes. When Xanthomonas cells infect the host, specific plant stimuli can be perceived and induce Lon phosphorylation at serine 654. Phosphorylation on Lon attenuates its proteolytic activity and protects HrpG from degradation. Consequently, enhanced stability of HrpG activates HrpX and turns on bacterial T3SS in the host. Our work provides a novel molecular mechanism underlying host-dependent activation of bacterial T3SS.

The High Light Response and Redox Control of Thylakoid FtsH Protease in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

In Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, the major protease involved in the maintenance of photosynthetic machinery in thylakoid membranes, the FtsH protease, mostly forms large hetero-oligomers (∼1 MDa) comprising FtsH1 and FtsH2 subunits, whatever the light intensity for growth. Upon high light exposure, the FtsH subunits display a shorter half-life, which is counterbalanced by an increase in FTSH1/2 mRNA levels, resulting in the modest upregulation of FtsH1/2 proteins. Furthermore, we found that high light increases the protease activity through a hitherto unnoticed redox-controlled reduction of intermolecular disulfide bridges. We isolated a Chlamydomonas FTSH1 promoter-deficient mutant, ftsh1-3, resulting from the insertion of a TOC1 transposon, in which the high light-induced upregulation of FTSH1 gene expression is largely lost. In ftsh1-3, the abundance of FtsH1 and FtsH2 proteins are loosely coupled (decreased by 70% and 30%, respectively) with no formation of large and stable homo-oligomers. Using strains exhibiting different accumulation levels of the FtsH1 subunit after complementation of ftsh1-3, we demonstrate that high light tolerance is tightly correlated with the abundance of the FtsH protease. Thus, the response of Chlamydomonas to light stress involves higher levels of FtsH1/2 subunits associated into large complexes with increased proteolytic activity.

An Isozyme-specific Redox Switch in Human Brain Glycogen Phosphorylase Modulates Its Allosteric Activation by AMP

Brain glycogen and its metabolism are increasingly recognized as major players in brain functions. Moreover, alteration of glycogen metabolism in the brain contributes to neurodegenerative processes. In the brain, both muscle and brain glycogen phosphorylase isozymes regulate glycogen mobilization. However, given their distinct regulatory features, these two isozymes could confer distinct metabolic functions of glycogen in brain. Interestingly, recent proteomics studies have identified isozyme-specific reactive cysteine residues in brain glycogen phosphorylase (bGP). In this study, we show that the activity of human bGP is redox-regulated through the formation of a disulfide bond involving a highly reactive cysteine unique to the bGP isozyme. We found that this disulfide bond acts as a redox switch that precludes the allosteric activation of the enzyme by AMP without affecting its activation by phosphorylation. This unique regulatory feature of bGP sheds new light on the isoform-specific regulation of glycogen phosphorylase and glycogen metabolism.