A mitochondrial tRNA anticodon swap associated with a muscle disease

A new family with a case of severe early-onset muscle fatigue and a peculiar maternally inherited painful swelling in chewing muscles associated with homoplasmic m.15992A>T mutation in mitochondrial tRNAPro

A 16-year-old boy was evaluated for a history of exercise-induced fatigability associated with nausea even after minimal effort, lower limbs muscle hypotrophy, and swelling of the masseter muscles after chewing. Laboratory tests were remarkable for hyperlactatemia and metabolic acidosis after short physical activity. The muscle biopsy showed non-specific mitochondrial alterations and an increase in intrafibral lipids. Biochemical analysis showed reduced activity of the respiratory chain complexes. Mitochondrial DNA sequencing revealed the presence of a homoplasmic variant m.15992A>T in the MT-TP gene, coding for the mt-tRNAPro in the patient, in his mother and in his brother. Pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in MT-TP gene are rare. They are responsible for different clinical presentation, almost ever involving the muscle tissue. We report the first family with exercise-induced muscle weakness and swelling of the chewing muscles due to m.15992A>T variant in absence of J1c10 haplogroup, confirming its pathogenicity.

The Mitochondrial tRNASer(UCN) Gene: A Novel m.7484A>G Mutation Associated with Mitochondrial Encephalomyopathy and Literature Review

Mitochondrial tRNA^Ser(UCN) is considered a hot-spot for non-syndromic and aminoglycoside-induced hearing loss. However, many patients have been described with more extensive neurological diseases, mainly including epilepsy, myoclonus, ataxia, and myopathy. We describe a novel homoplasmic m.7484A>G mutation in the tRNA^Ser(UCN) gene affecting the third base of the anticodon triplet in a girl with profound intellectual disability, spastic tetraplegia, sensorineural hearing loss, a clinical history of epilepsia partialis continua and vomiting, typical of MELAS syndrome, leading to a myoclonic epilepticus status, and myopathy with severe COX deficiency at muscle biopsy. The mutation was also found in the homoplasmic condition in the mother who presented with mild cognitive deficit, cerebellar ataxia, myoclonic epilepsy, sensorineural hearing loss and myopathy with COX deficient ragged-red fibers consistent with MERRF syndrome. This is the first anticodon mutation in the tRNA^Ser(UCN) and the second homoplasmic mutation in the anticodon triplet reported to date.

The Evolutionary Dynamics of the Mitochondrial tRNA in the Cichlid Fish Family

Simple Summary

Cichlids are a unique example of fish diversity and species richness which have been explained by sympatric speciation at different freshwater sources in Africa. The mitochondria contribute to cell vitality by providing energy. It contains a circular genome with an established translation system that is spatially independent of the cytosolic counterpart. The current study aimed to investigate the evolutionary dynamics of the mitochondrial tRNA and its role in cichlids’ diversity. The available cichlid mitogenomes in the public database were filtered, in addition to newly sequenced accessions from a specific cichlid group known as the haplotilapiine lineage that is widely distributed in the Egyptian sector of the Nile River. Based on the comparative analysis of mitogenomic data, we identified 22 tRNA genes, in which a single gene was D-armless, while the cloverleaf secondary structure subdivided into stem-loop formations was predicted and used to define the levels of genetic divergence for the remained tRNAs. Peculiarly, in cichlids, the formation known as “T-arm” showed the lowest polymorphism levels among other structures in contrast to other organisms (e.g., scorpions). Comparing the whole family to the specific haplotilapiine lineage showed that the tryptophan tRNA was the most conserved tRNA, with signatures of possible purifying selection.

Abstract

The mitochondrial transfer RNA genes (tRNAs) attract more attention due to their highly dynamic and rapidly evolving nature. The current study aimed to detect and evaluate the dynamics, characteristic patterns, and variations of mitochondrial tRNAs. The study was conducted in two main parts: first, the published mitogenomic sequences of cichlids mt tRNAs have been filtered. Second, the filtered mitochondrial tRNA and additional new mitogenomes representing the most prevalent Egyptian tilapiine were compared and analyzed. Our results revealed that all 22 tRNAs of cichlids folded into a classical cloverleaf secondary structure with four domains, except for trnS^GCU, missing the D domain in all cichlids. When consensus tRNAs were compared, most of the mutations were observed in the trnP at nucleotide levels (substitutions and indels), in contrast to trnL^UAA. From a structural perspective, the anticodon loop and T-loop formations were the most conserved structures among all parts of the tRNA in contrast to the A-stem and D-loop formations. The trnW was the lowest polymorphic unneutral tRNA among all cichlids (both the family and the haplotilapiine lineage), in contrast with the neutral trnD that was extremely polymorphic among and within the haplotilapiine lineage species compared to other cichlids species. From a phylogenetic perspective, the trnC was extremely hypervariable and neutral tRNA in both haplotilapiine lineage and cichlids but was unable to report correct phylogenetic signal for the cichlids. In contrast to trnI and trnY, less variable neutral tRNAs that were able to cluster the haplotilapiine lineage and cichlids species as previously reported. By observing the DNA polymorphism in the coding DNA sequences (CDS), the highest affected amino acid by non-synonymous mutations was isoleucine and was equally mutated to valine and vice versa; no correlation between mutations in CDS and tRNAs was statistically found. The current study provides an insight into the mitochondrial tRNA evolution and its effect on the cichlid diversity and speciation model at the maternal level.

Redox Signaling and Stress in Inherited Myopathies

Significance: Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are highly reactive compounds that behave like a double-edged sword; they damage cellular structures and act as second messengers in signal transduction. Mitochondria and endoplasmic reticulum (ER) are interconnected organelles with a central role in ROS production, detoxification, and oxidative stress response. Skeletal muscle is the most abundant tissue in mammals and one of the most metabolically active ones and thus relies mainly on oxidative phosphorylation (OxPhos) to synthesize adenosine triphosphate. The impairment of OxPhos leads to myopathy and increased ROS production, thus affecting both redox poise and signaling. In addition, ROS enter the ER and trigger ER stress and its maladaptive response, which also lead to a myopathic phenotype with mitochondrial involvement. Here, we review the role of ROS signaling in myopathies due to either mitochondrial or ER dysfunction. Recent Advances: Relevant advances have been evolving over the last 10 years on the intricate ROS-dependent pathways that act as modifiers of the disease course in several myopathies. To this end, pathways related to mitochondrial biogenesis, satellite cell differentiation, and ER stress have been studied extensively in myopathies. Critical Issues: The analysis of the chemistry and the exact quantitation, as well as the localization of ROS, are still challenging due to the intrinsic labile nature of ROS and the technical limitations of their sensors. Future Directions: The mechanistic studies of the pathogenesis of mitochondrial and ER-related myopathies offer a unique possibility to discover novel ROS-dependent pathways. Antioxid. Redox Signal. 37, 301-323.

Co-occurrence of m.15992A>G and m.15077G>A Is Associated With a High Penetrance of Maternally Inherited Hypertension in a Chinese Pedigree

BACKGROUND

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) pathogenic variants have been identified to be associated with maternally inherited essential hypertension (MIEH). However, the distinctive clinical features and molecular pathogenesis of MIEH are not fully understood.

METHODS

In this study, we collected a Chinese MIEH family with extraordinary higher penetrance of essential hypertension (88.89%) and early ages of onset (31-40 years old), and performed clinical and genetic characterization for this family. The complete mitochondrial genome of the proband was sequenced and analyzed.

RESULTS

The maternally related members in this family were presented with severe increased blood pressure, left ventricular remodeling, and metabolic abnormalities. Through sequencing the entire mtDNA of the proband and performing systematic analysis of the mtDNA variants with a phylogenic approach, we identified a potentially pathogenic tRNA variant (m.15992A>G in the MT-TP gene) that may account for the MIEH in this family. One nonsynonymous variant (m.15077G>A in the MT-CYB gene) was identified to play a synergistic role with m.15992A>G to cause a high penetrance of MIEH.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results, together with previous findings, have indicated that tRNA pathogenic variants in the mtDNA could act important roles in the pathogenesis of MIEH through reducing mitochondrial translation and disturbing mitochondrial function.

Cytochrome c oxidase deficiency

Cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficiency is characterized by a high degree of genetic and phenotypic heterogeneity, partly reflecting the extreme structural complexity, multiple post-translational modification, variable, tissue-specific composition, and the high number of and intricate connections among the assembly factors of this enzyme. In fact, decreased COX specific activity can manifest with different degrees of severity, affect the whole organism or specific tissues, and develop a wide spectrum of disease natural history, including disease onsets ranging from birth to late adulthood. More than 30 genes have been linked to COX deficiency, but the list is still incomplete and in fact constantly updated. We here discuss the current knowledge about COX in health and disease, focusing on genetic aetiology and link to clinical manifestations. In addition, information concerning either fundamental biological features of the enzymes or biochemical signatures of its defects have been provided by experimental in vivo models, including yeast, fly, mouse and fish, which expanded our knowledge on the functional features and the phenotypical consequences of different forms of COX deficiency.

Progressive external ophthalmoplegia due to a recurrent de novo m.15990C>T MT-TP (mt-tRNAPro) gene variant

Progressive external ophthalmoplegia is typically associated with single or multiple mtDNA deletions but occasionally mtDNA single nucleotide variants within mitochondrial transfer RNAs (mt-tRNAs) are identified. We report a 34-year-old female sporadic patient with progressive external ophthalmoplegia accompanied by exercise intolerance but neither fixed weakness nor multisystemic involvement. Histopathologically, abundant COX-deficient fibres were present in muscle with immunofluorescence analysis confirming the loss of mitochondrial complex I and IV proteins. Molecular genetic analysis identified a rare heteroplasmic m.15990C>T mt-tRNA^Pro variant reported previously in a single patient with childhood-onset myopathy. The variant in our patient was restricted to muscle. Single muscle fibre analysis identified higher heteroplasmy load in COX-deficient fibres than COX-normal fibres, confirming segregation of high heteroplasmic load with a biochemical defect. Our case highlights the phenotypic variability typically observed with pathogenic mt-tRNA mutations, whilst the identification of a second case with the m.15990C>T mutation not only confirms pathogenicity but shows that de novo mt-tRNA point mutations can arise in multiple, unrelated patients.

Interpretation of mitochondrial tRNA variants

PURPOSE

To develop criteria to interpret mitochondrial transfer RNA (mt-tRNA) variants based on unique characteristics of mitochondrial genetics and conserved structural/functional properties of tRNA.

METHODS

We developed rules on a set of established pathogenic/benign variants by examining heteroplasmy correlations with phenotype, tissue distribution, family members, and among unrelated families from published literature. We validated these deduced rules using our new cases and applied them to classify novel variants.

RESULTS

Evaluation of previously reported pathogenic variants found that 80.6% had sufficient evidence to support phenotypic correlation with heteroplasmy levels among and within families. The remaining variants were downgraded due to the lack of similar evidence. Application of the verified criteria resulted in rescoring 80.8% of reported variants of uncertain significance (VUS) to benign and likely benign. Among 97 novel variants, none met pathogenic criteria. A large proportion of novel variants (84.5%) remained as VUS, while only 10.3% were likely pathogenic. Detection of these novel variants in additional individuals would facilitate their classification.

CONCLUSION

Proper interpretation of mt-tRNA variants is crucial for accurate clinical diagnosis and genetic counseling. Correlations with tissue distribution, heteroplasmy levels, predicted perturbations to tRNA structure, and phenotypes provide important evidence for determining the clinical significance of mt-tRNA variants.

Clinical and molecular characteristics of newly reported mitochondrial disease entity caused by biallelic PARS2 mutations

Most of the 19 mitochondrial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (mt-aaRSs) involved in mitochondrial protein synthesis are already linked to specific entities, one of the exceptions being PARS2 mutations for which pathogenic significance is not finally validated. The aim of the study was to characterize the PARS2- related phenotype.Three siblings with biallelic PARS2 mutations presented from birth with infantile spasms, secondary microcephaly, and similar facial dysmorphy. Mental development was deeply impaired with speech absence and no eye contact. A dilated cardiomyopathy and multiorgan failure developed in childhood at the terminal stage, together with mitochondrial dysfunction triggered by valproate administration.Brain MRI showed progressive volume loss of the frontal lobes, both cortical and subcortical, with widening of the cortical sulci and frontal horns of the lateral ventricles. Hypoplasia of the corpus callosum and progressive demyelination were additional findings. Similar brain features were seen in three already reported PARS2 patients and seemed specific for this defect when compared with other mt-aaRSs defects (DARS2, EARS2, IARS2, and RARS2).Striking resemblance of the phenotype and Alpers-like brain MRI changes with predominance of frontal cerebral volume loss (FCVL-AS) in six patients from three families of different ethnicity with PARS2 mutations, justifies to distinguish the condition as a new disease entity.

Mitochondrial energy generation disorders: genes, mechanisms, and clues to pathology

Inherited disorders of oxidative phosphorylation cause the clinically and genetically heterogeneous diseases known as mitochondrial energy generation disorders, or mitochondrial diseases. Over the last three decades, mutations causing these disorders have been identified in almost 290 genes, but many patients still remain without a molecular diagnosis. Moreover, while our knowledge of the genetic causes is continually expanding, our understanding into how these defects lead to cellular dysfunction and organ pathology is still incomplete. Here, we review recent developments in disease gene discovery, functional characterization, and shared pathogenic parameters influencing disease pathology that offer promising avenues toward the development of effective therapies.

Non-coding RNAs and disease: the classical ncRNAs make a comeback

Many human diseases have been attributed to mutation in the protein coding regions of the human genome. The protein coding portion of the human genome, however, is very small compared with the non-coding portion of the genome. As such, there are a disproportionate number of diseases attributed to the coding compared with the non-coding portion of the genome. It is now clear that the non-coding portion of the genome produces many functional non-coding RNAs and these RNAs are slowly being linked to human diseases. Here we discuss examples where mutation in classical non-coding RNAs have been attributed to human disease and identify the future potential for the non-coding portion of the genome in disease biology.

Nucleoside modifications in the regulation of gene expression: focus on tRNA

Both, DNA and RNA nucleoside modifications contribute to the complex multi-level regulation of gene expression. Modified bases in tRNAs modulate protein translation rates in a highly dynamic manner. Synonymous codons, which differ by the third nucleoside in the triplet but code for the same amino acid, may be utilized at different rates according to codon-anticodon affinity. Nucleoside modifications in the tRNA anticodon loop can favor the interaction with selected codons by stabilizing specific base pairs. Similarly, weakening of base pairing can discriminate against binding to near-cognate codons. mRNAs enriched in favored codons are translated in higher rates constituting a fine-tuning mechanism for protein synthesis. This so-called codon bias establishes a basic protein level, but sometimes it is necessary to further adjust the production rate of a particular protein to actual requirements, brought by, e.g., stages in circadian rhythms, cell cycle progression or exposure to stress. Such an adjustment is realized by the dynamic change of tRNA modifications resulting in the preferential translation of mRNAs coding for example for stress proteins to facilitate cell survival. Furthermore, tRNAs contribute in an entirely different way to another, less specific stress response consisting in modification-dependent tRNA cleavage that contributes to the general down-regulation of protein synthesis. In this review, we summarize control functions of nucleoside modifications in gene regulation with a focus on recent findings on protein synthesis control by tRNA base modifications.

A novel mitochondrial tRNA Arg mutation resulting in an anticodon swap in a patient with mitochondrial encephalomyopathy

We report a mutation in the anticodon of the tRNA(Arg) gene (m.10437 G>A), resulting in an anticodon swap from GCU to ACU, which is the anticodon of tRNA(Trp), in a boy with mitochondrial encephalomyopathy. Enzyme histochemical analysis of muscle tissue and biochemical analysis of isolated muscle mitochondria demonstrated cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficiency. Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis showed that 90% of muscle and 82% of urinary epithelium mtDNA harbored the mutation. The mutation was not identified in blood, fibroblasts, hair roots, or buccal epithelial cells and it was absent in the asymptomatic mother, suggesting that it was a de novo mutation. Single-fiber PCR analysis showed that the proportion of mutated mtDNA correlated with enzyme histochemical COX deficiency. This mutation adds to the three previously described disease-causing mutations in tRNA(Arg), but it is the first mutation occurring in the anticodon of tRNA(Arg).

Mutation in an mtDNA protein-coding gene: prenatal diagnosis aided by fetal muscle biopsy

Prenatal diagnosis of disorders due to mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) tRNA gene mutations is problematic. Experience in families harboring the protein-coding ATPase 6 m.8993T>G mutation suggests that the mutant load is homogeneous in different tissues, thus allowing prenatal diagnosis. We have encountered a novel protein-coding gene mutation, m.10198C>T in MT-ND3. A baby girl homoplasmic for this mutation died at 3 months after severe psychomotor regression and respiratory arrest. The mother had no detectable mutation in accessible tissues. The product of a second pregnancy showed only wild-type mt genomes in amniocytes, chorionic villi, and biopsied fetal muscle. This second girl is now 18 months old and healthy. Our observations support the concept that the pathogenic mutation in this patient appeared de novo and that fetal muscle biopsy is a useful aide in prenatal diagnosis.

Identification of the novel mutation m.5658T>C in the mitochondrial tRNA(Asn) gene in a patient with myopathy, bilateral ptosis and ophthalmoparesis

We report a heteroplasmic novel mutation m.5658T>C in the mt-tRNA(Asn) gene in a patient who initially presented myopathy, bilateral ptosis and ophthalmoparesis and several years later developed a non-nephrotic proteinuria. The muscle biopsy showed cytochrome c oxidase (COX) negative and ragged red fibers and in the kidney biopsy that was taken in order to identify the causes of non-nephrotic proteinuria, a focal segmental glomerulosclerosis was observed. Using laser capture microdissection we isolated COX negative fibers and COX positive fibers from the muscle of the patient and determined that there was a clear increase in the mutation load in the COX negative muscle fibers. However, the low degree of mutation load found in the renal biopsy of the patient does not allow us to conclude that the m.5658T>C mutation is responsible for focal glomerulosclerosis. Additionally, we hypothesize that the mutated m.5658T nucleotide might be structurally relevant, as it is one of the fifteen nucleotides conserved in all the species analyzed and is situated contiguously to the discriminator base in the 3'end of the mt-tRNA, where the tRNase Z cleaves the 3' trailer sequence during mt-tRNA maturation.

A new duplication in the mitochondrially encoded tRNA proline gene in a patient with dilated cardiomyopathy

Mitochondria provide an environment conducive to mutations in DNA molecules (mtDNA). Analyses of mtDNA have shown mutations potentially leading to many cardiovascular traits. Here, we describe a patient with dilated cardiomyopathy and new mtDNA duplication. The patient presented symptoms of heart failure New York Heart Association functional class III and was diagnosed with non-familial dilated cardiomyopathy with important left ventricular systolic dysfunction. Sequencing of mtDNA control region was done, and a 15 bp duplication was observed between nucleotides 16,018 and 16,032. Part of this duplication is localized within the tRNA proline gene (tRNA(Pro)) that has an important role in cell protection against oxidative stress and is considered an important regulatory factor for cellular reactive oxygen species balance. This duplication could alter the stability or secondary structure of tRNA(Pro), affecting mt-protein synthesis. In turn, the presence of duplication in tRNA(Pro) could cause some oxidative stress imbalance and, so, mitochondrial dysfunction could result in the pathogenicity.

Clinical and cellular consequences of the mutation m.12300G>A in the mitochondrial tRNA(Leu(CUN)) gene

We report, for the first time, a patient with an overlap MERRF-NARP syndrome who carries the mutation m.12300G>A in the mitochondrial tRNA(Leu(CUN)) gene. The mutation was heteroplamic and more abundant in her muscle and fibroblast than in blood from her oligosymptomatic mother. Single muscle fiber analysis revealed that the proportion of mutant mtDNA in ragged red fibers was higher than that in normal fibers. Combined defects of mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes were detected in muscle, fibroblasts and transmitochondrial hybrid cells. Significant reduction of total ATP and mitochondrial membrane potential and an increased production of reactive oxygen species were observed.

Human mitochondrial transfer RNAs: role of pathogenic mutation in disease

The human mitochondrial genome encodes 13 proteins. All are subunits of the respiratory chain complexes involved in energy metabolism. These proteins are translated by a set of 22 mitochondrial transfer RNAs (tRNAs) that are required for codon reading. Human mitochondrial tRNA genes are hotspots for pathogenic mutations and have attracted interest over the last two decades with the rapid discovery of point mutations associated with a vast array of neuromuscular disorders and diverse clinical phenotypes. In this review, we use a scoring system to determine the pathogenicity of the mutations and summarize the current knowledge of structure-function relationships of these mutant tRNAs. We also provide readers with an overview of a large variety of mechanisms by which mutations may affect the mitochondrial translation machinery and cause disease.

A functionally dominant mitochondrial DNA mutation

Mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) tRNA genes can be considered functionally recessive because they result in a clinical or biochemical phenotype only when the percentage of mutant molecules exceeds a critical threshold value, in the range of 70-90%. We report a novel mtDNA mutation that contradicts this rule, since it caused a severe multisystem disorder and respiratory chain (RC) deficiency even at low levels of heteroplasmy. We studied a 13-year-old boy with clinical, radiological and biochemical evidence of a mitochondrial disorder. We detected a novel heteroplasmic C>T mutation at nucleotide 5545 of mtDNA, which was present at unusually low levels (<25%) in affected tissues. The pathogenic threshold for the mutation in cybrids was between 4 and 8%, implying a dominant mechanism of action. The mutation affects the central base of the anticodon triplet of tRNA(Trp) and it may alter the codon specificity of the affected tRNA. These findings introduce the concept of dominance in mitochondrial genetics and pose new diagnostic challenges, because such mutations may easily escape detection. Moreover, similar mutations arising stochastically and accumulating in a minority of mtDNA molecules during the aging process may severely impair RC function in cells.

Pathogenic mechanism of a human mitochondrial tRNAPhe mutation associated with myoclonic epilepsy with ragged red fibers syndrome

Human mitochondrial tRNA (hmt-tRNA) mutations are associated with a variety of diseases including mitochondrial myopathies, diabetes, encephalopathies, and deafness. Because the current understanding of the precise molecular mechanisms of these mutations is limited, there is no efficient method to treat their associated mitochondrial diseases. Here, we use a variety of known mutations in hmt-tRNA(Phe) to investigate the mechanisms that lead to malfunctions. We tested the impact of hmt-tRNA(Phe) mutations on aminoacylation, structure, and translation elongation-factor binding. The majority of the mutants were pleiotropic, exhibiting defects in aminoacylation, global structure, and elongation-factor binding. One notable exception was the G34A anticodon mutation of hmt-tRNA(Phe) (mitochondrial DNA mutation G611A), which is associated with MERRF (myoclonic epilepsy with ragged red fibers). In vitro, the G34A mutation decreases aminoacylation activity by 100-fold, but does not affect global folding or recognition by elongation factor. Furthermore, G34A hmt-tRNA(Phe) does not undergo adenosine-to-inosine (A-to-I) editing, ruling out miscoding as a possible mechanism for mitochondrial malfunction. To improve the aminoacylation state of the mutant tRNA, we modified the tRNA binding domain of the nucleus-encoded human mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase, which aminoacylates hmt-tRNA(Phe) with cognate phenylalanine. This variant enzyme displayed significantly improved aminoacylation efficiency for the G34A mutant, suggesting a general strategy to treat certain classes of mitochondrial diseases by modification of the corresponding nuclear gene.

Mutations in mtDNA: are we scraping the bottom of the barrel?

The small, maternally inherited mtDNA has turned out to be a Pandora's box of pathogenic mutations: 12 years into the era of "mitochondrial medicine," about 100 pathogenic point mutations and innumerable rearrangements have been associated with a bewildering variety of multisystemic as well as tissue-specific human diseases. After reviewing the principles of mitochondrial genetics, we compare and contrast the clinical and pathological features of disorders due to mutations in genes affecting mitochondrial protein synthesis with those of mutations in protein-coding genes. In contrast to the striking progress in our understanding of etiology, pathogenesis is only partially explained by the rules of mitochondrial genetics and remains largely terra incognita. We review recent progress in prenatal diagnosis and epidemiology. Therapy is still woefully inadequate, but a number of promising approaches are being developed.

Late-onset mitochondrial myopathy with dystrophic changes due to a G7497A mutation in the mitochondrial tRNA(Ser(UCN)) gene

Mutations of mitochondrial tRNA genes are usually associated with multi-systemic disorders with onset of symptoms in childhood or early adulthood. Dystrophic myopathic changes are not typical features of these disorders. We report two siblings with a severe progressive myopathy of late onset without external ophthalmoplegia and without involvement of the central and peripheral nervous system. Muscle biopsy specimens showed severe myopathic changes similar to those found in muscular dystrophies. Molecular analysis revealed a G7497A mutation in the mitochondrial tRNA(Ser(UCN)) gene. In both patients, the proportion of mutated mitochondrial DNA in muscle was more than 97%. Mitochondrial disorder associated with the G7497A mutation has to be included into the differential diagnosis of severe progressive late-onset myopathy with histopathological dystrophic myopathic changes. Mitochondrial myopathy and high level of mutated mtDNA might be a characteristic of the G7497A tRNA(Ser(UCN)) mutation.

Contrasting phenotypes in three patients with novel mutations in mitochondrial tRNA genes

We studied three patients, each harboring a novel mutation at a highly conserved position in a different mitochondrial tRNA gene. The mutation in patient 1 (T5543C) was associated with isolated mitochondrial myopathy, and occurred in the anticodon loop of tRNA(Trp). In patient 2, with mitochondrial myopathy and marked retinopathy, the mutation (G14710A) resulted in an anticodon swap (Glu to Lys) in tRNA(Glu). Patient 3, who manifested mitochondrial encephalomyopathy and moderate retinal dysfunction, harbored a mutation (C3287A) in the TpsiC loop of tRNA(Leu(UUR)). The mutations were heteroplasmic in muscle in all cases, and sporadic in two cases. PCR-RFLP analysis in all patients showed much higher amounts of mutated mtDNA in affected tissue (muscle) than unaffected tissue (blood), and significantly higher levels of mutated mtDNA in cytochrome c oxidase (COX)-negative muscle fibers than in COX-positive fibers, confirming the pathogenicity of these mutations. The mutation was also detected in single hair roots from all three patients, indicating that each mutation must have arisen early in embryonic development or in maternal germ cells. This suggests that individual hair root analyses may reflect a wider tissue distribution of mutated mtDNA than is clinically apparent, and might be useful in predicting prognosis and, perhaps, the risk of transmitting the mutation to offspring. Our data suggest a correlation between clinical phenotype and distribution of mutated mtDNA in muscle versus hair roots. Furthermore, the high threshold for phenotypic expression in single muscle fibers (92-96%) suggests that therapies may only need to increase the percentage of wild-type mtDNA by a small amount to be beneficial.

Techniques and pitfalls in the detection of pathogenic mitochondrial DNA mutations

Mutations in the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) are now recognized as major contributors to human pathologies and possibly to normal aging. A large number of rearrangements and point mutations in protein coding and tRNA genes have been identified in patients with mitochondrial disorders. In this review, we discuss genotype-phenotype correlations in mitochondrial diseases and common techniques used to identify pathogenic mtDNA mutations in human tissues. Although most of these approaches employ standard molecular biology tools, the co-existence of wild-type and mutated mtDNA (mtDNA heteroplasmy) in diseased tissues complicates both the detection and accurate determination of the size of the mutated fractions. To address these problems, novel approaches were developed and are discussed in this review.

A novel mutation in the mitochondrial tRNAPhe gene associated with mitochondrial myopathy

We report a novel heteroplasmic T-->C mutation at nt position 582 within the mitochondrial tRNA(Phe) gene of a 70-year-old woman with mitochondrial myopathy. No other family members were affected, suggesting that our patient was a sporadic case. The muscle showed frequent ragged red fibers and 43% cytochrome c oxidase deficient fibers. The mutation alters a conserved base pairing in the aminoacyl acceptor stem. The mutation load was 70% in muscle homogenate and varied from 0 to 95% in individual muscle fiber segments. Cytochrome c oxidase-negative fibers showed significantly higher levels of mutated mtDNA (>75%) than Cytochrome c oxidase-positive fibers (<55%). This mutation adds to the previously described four pathogenic mutations in the tRNA(Phe) gene.

Dropped head presentation of mitochondrial myopathy

Dropped head secondary to weakness of the neck extensors has been reported in a wide assortment of neuromuscular disorders. Infrequently, dropped head can be the first sign of disease. We describe two patients with dropped head as the presenting manifestation of mitochondrial myopathy. In both patients, serum lactate was elevated and muscle biopsy showed mitochondrial proliferation. Mitochondrial myopathy should be considered in the differential diagnosis of dropped head syndrome, particularly when other, more common causes such as myasthenia gravis, polymyositis, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis have been excluded by appropriate laboratory and electrophysiological studies.

Mutation and intracellular clonal expansion of mitochondrial genomes: two synergistic components of the aging process?

The foundations of the Mitochondrial mutational theory of aging include two assumptions: the high abundance of mitochondrial mutations and their ability to clonally expand within individual cells. The up-to-date data pertinent to these assumptions is reviewed and semi-quantitative estimates of the frequencies of mutants and intracellular expansions are offered. The incidence of mutations in various aged tissues may be on the order of one mutant per mitochondrial genome copy, and most of the cells are likely to be affected by intracellular clonal expansions of mitochondrial genomes. Thus aged tissue may be considered a mosaic of cells with different mutant mitochondrial genotypes. Interestingly, independent studies show that a wide range of aged tissues presents with a mosaic of cells with different mitochondrial phenotypes. The necessary methodologies are available to explore whether the two mosaics are causally related. The answer apparently is positive in muscle; other tissues, brain in particular, await exploration.

Design and Use of a Peptide Nucleic Acid for Detection of the Heteroplasmic Low-Frequency Mitochondrial Encephalomyopathy, Lactic Acidosis, and Stroke-like Episodes (MELAS) Mutation in Human Mitochondrial DNA

Background: Most pathogenic human mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations are heteroplasmic (i.e., mutant and wild-type mtDNA coexist in the same individual) and are difficult to detect when their concentration is a small proportion of that of wild-type mtDNA molecules. We describe a simple methodology to detect low proportions of the single base pair heteroplasmic mutation, A3243G, that has been associated with the disease mitochondrial encephalomyopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) in total DNA extracted from blood.

Methods: Three peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) were designed to bind to the wild-type mtDNA in the region of nucleotide position 3243, thus blocking PCR amplification of the wild-type mtDNA while permitting the mutant DNA to become the dominant product and readily discernable. DNA was obtained from both apparently healthy and MELAS individuals. Optimum PCR temperatures were based on the measured ultraviolet thermal stability of the DNA/PNA duplexes. The presence or absence of the mutation was determined by sequencing.

Results: In the absence of PNAs, the heteroplasmic mutation was either difficult to detect or undetectable by PCR and sequencing. Only PNA 3 successfully inhibited amplification of the wild-type mtDNA while allowing the mutant mtDNA to amplify. In the presence of PNA 3, we were able to detect the heteroplasmic mutation when its concentration was as low as 0.1% of the concentration of the wild-type sequence.

Conclusion: This methodology permits easy detection of low concentrations of the MELAS A3243G mutation in blood by standard PCR and sequencing methods.

A novel mitochondrial DNA tRNA(Ile) (A4267G) mutation in a sporadic patient with mitochondrial myopathy

We describe a novel mutation in the mitochondrial tRNA(Ile) gene, an A to G transition at nucleotide position 4267, in a 37-year-old woman with myopathy, ataxia and sensorineural hearing loss. The A4267G mutation was heteroplasmic in several of the proband's tissues and single fibre analysis revealed significantly higher levels of mutated mitochondrial DNA in cytochrome c oxidase-deficient fibres than cytochrome c oxidase-positive fibres. It is predicted to disrupt a highly conserved base pair within the aminoacyl acceptor stem of the tRNA causing functional impairment, and as such fulfils all the accepted criteria for pathogenicity. Moreover, we were unable to detect the A4267G mutation in lymphocytes, buccal epithelia and hair of the patient's mother and two siblings, implying that the A4267G transition represents a sporadic, germline mutation.

Mitochondrial diseases

Since the first reports of disorders associated with mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) defects more than a decade ago, the small mtDNA circle has been a Pandora's box of pathogenic mutations associated with human diseases. The "morbidity map" of mtDNA has gone from one point mutation and a few deletions in 1988 to more than 110 point mutations as of September, 2001. Nuclear DNA defects affecting mitochondrial function and mtDNA replication and integrity have also been identified in the past few years and more are expected. As a result, human "mitochondrial" diseases have evolved beyond the novelty diagnoses of a decade ago into an important area of medicine, and thus, the diagnostic principles of these disorders ought to be familiar to the clinician. In this article, the authors, we summarize the principles of mitochondrial genetics and discuss the common phenotypes, general diagnostic approach, and possible therapeutic venues for these fascinating disorders.

mtLOH (mitochondrial loss of heteroplasmy), aging, and 'surrogate self'

In tribute to Dr Strehler, an attempt is made to use a style of reasoning found in some of his later papers as an outline of this article. First, general arguments in favor of the involvement of somatic mutations in mtDNA in the aging process are presented. Second, evidence is provided in support of a general tendency of mitochondrial genomes to reach homoplasmic state at the cellular level, for which we propose the term mitochondrial loss of heteroplasmy (mtLOH). This process is likely to facilitate the involvement of mtDNA mutations in the aging process by streamlining the phenotypic expression of the mutant genotype. Third, preliminary evidence of the very high incidence of clonal deletions in pigmented neurons of substantia nigra is reported. This observation highlights the possibility that accumulation of mtDNA mutations specific in certain cell types of a complex tissue may account for the involvement of mtDNA mutations in the aging process despite the relatively low average incidence of these mutations in the tissue as a whole. High incidence of mtDNA deletions in pigmented neurons evokes Strehler's idea that efforts to delay aging may not be the most cost-efficient way of preserving 'self awareness and a joyful sense of life', as he put it. A potential alternative suggested by Strehler, i.e. creation of a 'surrogate self' by computer simulation may deserve more attention than it currently enjoys.

Frequent intracellular clonal expansions of somatic mtDNA mutations: significance and mechanisms

It has been proposed that age-dependent accumulation of somatic mutations in mtDNA is responsible for some aspects of the aging process. However, most cells contain hundreds to thousands of mtDNA molecules. Any nascent somatic mutant therefore appears as a single copy among a majority of wild-type species. A single mutant molecule is unlikely to influence the physiology of the cell and thus cannot play a role in the aging process. To affect cellular physiology, the nascent somatic mutants must somehow accumulate clonally in the cell to significant levels. The evidence supporting the view that, indeed, clonal expansion of mtDNA mutations is a widespread process in various human tissues, and the mechanisms by which clonal expansions may affect the aging process, are reviewed. Originally, clonal expansion was demonstrated for mtDNA with large deletions in muscle. Cell-by-cell analysis of human cardiomyocytes and buccal epithelial cells revealed that clonal expansion affects point mtDNA mutations as well as deletions. Expansions are not limited to muscle, but likely are present in most tissues, and almost every cell of an aged tissue is likely to be affected by an expansion. While the very existence of clonal expansion is beyond doubt, the mechanisms driving this process are largely controversial. The hypotheses explaining expansion includes random or various selective mechanisms, or both. We show that the spectra of expanded point mutations are drastically different in cardiomyocytes and epithelial cells. This suggests that the mechanisms of expansion in these tissues are different. In particular, we propose random segregation and positive selection models for epithelial and muscle cells, respectively.

Mitochondrial DNA mutations in human disease

The small, maternally inherited mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) has turned out to be a Pandora's box of pathogenic mutations: 13 years into the era of "molecular mitochondrial medicine," more than 100 pathogenic point mutations and innumerable rearrangements have been associated with a striking variety of multisystemic as well as tissue-specific human diseases. After reviewing the principles of mitochondrial genetics, we consider disorders due to mutations in genes affecting mitochondrial protein synthesis and disorders due to mutations in protein-coding genes. In contrast to the remarkable progress in our understanding of etiology, pathogenesis is only partially explained by the rules of mitochondrial genetics and remains largely unclear. We review recent progress in prenatal diagnosis, epidemiology, and in the development of animal models harboring mtDNA mutations.

Recognition of mitochondrial DNA deletion syndrome with non-neuromuscular multisystemic manifestation

PURPOSE

To correlate the molecular characteristics of the mtDNA deletions with clinical phenotypes.

METHODS

Southern analysis and polymerase chain reaction (PCR)/DNA sequencing were used to determine the size and location of deletions in 16 patients with mtDNA deletion syndrome. An additional 48 reported cases from the literature were also included in the statistical analysis.

RESULTS

The common 5-kb deletion is found in eight of nine patients with Kearns-Sayre syndrome (KSS), mitochondrial myopathies (MM), or progressive external ophthalmoplegia (PEO). The rare/novel deletions were found in six of seven patients with extra-neuromuscular multisystemic manifestations and infantile/early childhood onset.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with mtDNA deletion syndrome who manifest non-neuromuscular multisystemic disorders at a very young age usually harbor mutant mtDNA with novel or rare deletions in every tissue analyzed. For this group of patients, it is possible to use the less invasive blood specimens instead of muscle biopsies for molecular diagnosis. Overwhelmingly, the common 5-kb deletion is mostly seen in the muscle specimens of patients with KSS and age of onset after the second decade of life.

Paradoxes in longevity: sequence analysis of mtDNA haplogroup J in centenarians

Previous studies have shown that mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplogroup J is significantly over-represented in healthy centenarians with respect to younger controls, thus suggesting that this haplogroup predisposes to successful aging and longevity. On the other hand, the same haplogroup is reported to have elevated frequency in some complex diseases. To verify if centenarians clustered in a particular lineage within J we have sequenced the D-loop region from 18 centenarians and 18 younger controls, previously characterized to be J. Then the entire mtDNA molecule was sequenced in a sub-sample of nine centenarians to find possible functional mutations associated with haplogroup J in successful aging. No clustering of the J haplogroup mtDNA from centenarians was observed. In addition, most of the mutations found are known as disease-associated mutations. The general picture that emerges from the study is that the J haplogroup of centenarians is surprisingly similar to that found in complex diseases, as well as in Leber Hereditary Optic Neuropathy. This finding implies that the same mutations could predispose to disease or longevity, probably according to individual-specific genetic backgrounds and stochastic events. This data reveals another paradox of centenarians and confirms the complexity of the longevity trait.

Human mitochondrial DNA diseases

The mitochondrial encephalomyopathies are a genetically heterogeneous group of disorders associated with impaired oxidative phosphorylation. Patients may exhibit a wide range of clinical symptoms and experience significant morbidity and mortality. There is currently no curative treatment. At present the majority of genetically defined mitochondrial encephalomyopathies are caused by mutations in mitochondrial DNA. The underlying molecular mechanisms and the complex relationship between genotype and phenotype in these mitochondrial DNA diseases remain only partially understood. We describe the key features of mitochondrial DNA genetics and outline some of the common disease phenotypes associated with mtDNA defects. A classification of pathogenic mitochondrial DNA point mutations which may have therapeutic implications is outlined.

Mitochondrial dysfunction and neuromuscular disease

Mitochondrial diseases are a heterogeneous group of disorders with widely varying clinical features, due to defects in mitochondrial function. Involvement of both muscle and nerve is common in mitochondrial disease. In some cases, this involvement is subclinical or a minor part of a multisystem disorder, but myopathy and neuropathy are a major, often presenting, feature of a number of mitochondrial syndromes. In addition, mitochondrial dysfunction may play a role in a number of classic neuromuscular diseases. This article reviews the role of mitochondrial dysfunction in neuromuscular disease and discusses a rational approach to diagnosis and treatment of patients presenting with a neuromuscular syndrome due to mitochondrial disease.

A novel myopathy-associated mitochondrial DNA mutation altering the conserved size of the tRNA(Gln) anticodon loop

We report a novel mitochondrial DNA alteration in a 12-year-old boy with myopathy. We identified a single nucleotide insertion (an adenine) in the mitochondrial tRNA-glutamine gene. This addition of an additional adenine in a polyadenine stretch (at mitochondrial DNA positions 4366-4369), alters the length of the evolutionary conserved anticodon loop from seven to eight bases. The nt-4370 addition was heteroplasmic and was abundant in the patient's muscle. Lower proportions of mutated mitochondrial DNA were observed in skin fibroblasts, but were below detectable levels in white blood cells. A muscle biopsy of the patient showed ragged red fibers and an unusually high percentage of cytochrome c oxidase-deficient fibers (89%). The pathogenicity of the mutation was also evident by the fact that fibers harboring lower levels of the mutation showed normal cytochrome c oxidase activity. The insertion in the anticodon loop of tRNA(Gln) gene identified in our patient may provide a unique tool to study protein synthesis in human mitochondria.

A novel heteroplasmic point mutation in the mitochondrial tRNA(Lys) gene in a sporadic case of mitochondrial encephalomyopathy: de novo mutation and no transmission to the offspring

We have identified a new mutation in the tRNA(Lys) gene of mtDNA, in a 49-year-old patient with mitochondrial encephalomyopathy. The mutation is a heteroplasmic G-->A transition at position 8328, which affects the anticodon stem loop at a conserved site. The mutation was neither found in 100 controls nor in the maternal relatives of the patient. The level of mutated mtDNA was 57% in muscle, 13% in fibroblasts, and 10% in lymphocytes. Histochemistry of muscle tissue revealed cytochrome c oxidase-deficient fibers with abnormal accumulation of mitochondria. Biochemistry of muscle mitochondria showed slight cytochrome c oxidase deficiency. The mean ratio of mutant mtDNA to normal mtDNA in cytochrome c oxidase-positive muscle fibers was 59%, whereas a mean ratio of 95% was found in cytochrome c oxidase-negative fibers. The difference between cytochrome c oxidase-positive and cytochrome c oxidase-negative fibers was highly significant (P < 0.001). The mutation was not found in muscle or lymphocytes of the mother and daughter of the proband. This is the first report of a de novo point mutation in the tRNA(Lys) gene in an individual expressing disease and the first report of lack of transmission of the mutation to the offspring of a patient expressing a mitochondrial encephalomyopathy caused by a point mutation in mtDNA.

Exercise intolerance due to mutations in the cytochrome b gene of mitochondrial DNA

BACKGROUND

The mitochondrial myopathies typically affect many organ systems and are associated with mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) that are maternally inherited. However, there is also a sporadic form of mitochondrial myopathy in which exercise intolerance is the predominant symptom. We studied the biochemical and molecular characteristics of this sporadic myopathy.

METHODS

We sequenced the mtDNA cytochrome b gene in blood and muscle specimens from five patients with severe exercise intolerance, lactic acidosis in the resting state (in four patients), and biochemical evidence of complex III deficiency. We compared the clinical and molecular features of these patients with those previously described in four other patients with mutations in the cytochrome b gene.

RESULTS

We found a total of three different nonsense mutations (G15084A, G15168A, and G15723A), one missense mutation (G14846A), and a 24-bp deletion (from nucleotide 15498 to 15521) in the cytochrome b gene in the five patients. Each of these mutations impairs the enzymatic function of the cytochrome b protein. In these patients and those previously described, the clinical manifestations included progressive exercise intolerance, proximal limb weakness, and in some cases, attacks of myoglobinuria. There was no maternal inheritance and there were no mutations in tissues other than muscle. The absence of these findings suggests that the disorder is due to somatic mutations in myogenic stem cells after germ-layer differentiation. All the point mutations involved the substitution of adenine for guanine, but all were in different locations.

CONCLUSIONS

The sporadic form of mitochondrial myopathy is associated with somatic mutations in the cytochrome b gene of mtDNA. This myopathy is one cause of the common and often elusive syndrome of exercise intolerance.

Skeletal muscle mitochondrial defects in nonspecific neurologic disorders

A group of 25 children (5 months to 20 years of age) presenting with intractable seizures, developmental delay, and severe hypotonia, who did not fall into the known categories of mitochondrial encephalomyopathies, underwent muscle biopsy for evaluation of mitochondrial function and were compared with age-matched control subjects. Biopsied skeletal muscle was analyzed for six mitochondrial enzyme-specific activities, mitochondrial DNA point mutations and deletions, and mitochondrial DNA levels. The data reveal a high incidence of specific mitochondrial enzyme activity defects. Reduced activity levels were evident in complex I (11 patients), III (24 patients), IV (nine patients), and V (10 patients). Two patients also exhibited pronounced reduction in mitochondrial DNA levels (80% reduction compared with control subjects). Two patients manifested increased levels of 5-kb and 7.4-kb mitochondrial DNA deletions. Pathogenic mutations previously described in association with mitochondrial encephalomyopathies were not evident. The data suggest that mitochondrial dysfunction, including extensive defects in specific enzyme activities, may be frequently present in children with seizures, developmental delay, and hypotonia that do not fall within the known mitochondrial encephalomyopathies. These mitochondrial deficiencies can be primarily ascertained by biochemical analysis and are rarely accompanied by mitochondrial ultrastructural changes. The molecular basis of these defects, their role in these disorders, and potential treatment warrant further study.

Exercise intolerance due to a nonsense mutation in the mtDNA ND4 gene

We report the first molecular defect in an NADH-dehydrogenase gene presenting as isolated myopathy. The proband had lifelong exercise intolerance but no weakness. A muscle biopsy showed cytochrome c oxidase (COX)-positive ragged-red fibers (RRFs), and analysis of the mitochondrial enzymes revealed complex I deficiency. Sequence analysis of the mitochondrial genes encoding the seven NADH-dehydrogenase subunits showed a G-to-A transition at nucleotide 11832 in the subunit 4 (ND4) gene, which changed an encoded tryptophan to a stop codon. The mutation was heteroplasmic (54%) in muscle DNA. Defects in mitochondrially encoded complex I subunits should be added to the differential diagnosis of mitochondrial myopathies.

A new mitochondrial DNA mutation (A3288G) in the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene associated with familial myopathy

We describe a family with a maternally inherited mitochondrial myopathy and an A3288G mutation in the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene. The proband had muscle cramping and mild weakness while her brother had long-standing limb and respiratory muscle weakness and her daughter had elevated serum CK. The mutation, which was nearly homoplasmic in muscle and heteroplasmic in blood, affects the TpsiC loop at a conserved site and was not found in 107 controls. This report confirms the frequent association of tRNA(Leu(UUR)) mutations with respiratory muscle involvement and bolsters the concept that tRNA(Leu(UUR)) is a hotspot for mtDNA mutations.

Mitochondrial encephalomyopathies: the enigma of genotype versus phenotype

Over the past decade a large body of evidence has accumulated implicating defects of human mitochondrial DNA in the pathogenesis of a group of disorders known collectively as the mitochondrial encephalomyopathies. Although impaired oxidative phosphorylation is likely to represent the final common pathway leading to cellular dysfunction in these diseases, fundamental issues still remain elusive. Perhaps the most challenging of these is to understand the mechanisms which underlie the complex relationship between genotype and phenotype. Here we examine this relationship and discuss some of the factors which are likely to be involved.

Mitochondrial dysfunction in skeletal muscle of children with cardiomyopathy

OBJECTIVES

This study sought to examine skeletal muscle of children with cardiomyopathy (CM) for changes in mitochondrial enzyme activities and in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA).

BACKGROUND

Heart mitochondrial enzymatic activity defects have been often found in dilated and hypertrophic CM. The defects primarily involve the activities of the electron transport system and oxidative phosphorylation pathway including respiratory complexes I, III, IV, and V.

METHODS

Skeletal muscle biopsies of 8 children with CM were examined for specific mitochondrial enzyme activities, mtDNA copy number and the presence of pathogenic mutations and deletions in mtDNA.

RESULTS

A marked deficiency in specific mitochondrial enzyme activities was found in 6 of 8 patients in skeletal muscle as well as in 2 of 3 hearts of those in whom cardiac tissue was available. Specific activity defects were found in complex I (2 cases), complex III (5 cases), complex IV (3 cases), and complex V (4 cases). Complex II and citrate synthase activities were unaffected. None of the previously reported pathogenic mutations associated with CM were detected, nor was there any evidence of mtDNA depletion. The incidence of defective respiratory complex activities in skeletal muscle was similar to the incidence of defective complex activities previously reported in cardiac tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

Mitochondrial analysis of skeletal muscle is warranted in the overall clinical evaluation of children with CM, and particularly before consideration for cardiac transplantation.