Idiotypic immunization induces immunity to mutated p53 and tumor rejection

Anti-p21 autoantibodies detected in colorectal cancer patients: A proof of concept study

Whereas the presence of autoantibodies in cancer patients has been acknowledged, their diagnostic or therapeutic significance has yet to be established. This is due, at least in part, to the lack of robust screening techniques to detect and characterize such antibodies for further assessment. In this study, we screened colorectal cancer (CRC) patient sera for antibodies specifically targeting the key cell cycle inhibitory factor p21 encoded by the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor 1A (CDKN1A). Anti-p21 antibody titers were higher in CRC patient samples versus controls, correlating with a more advanced disease stage and lymph node involvement. Further, we isolated for the first time a specific human antibody fragment against p21, which could potentially be useful as a tool to study tumorigenicity in CRC patients.

Abagovomab: an anti-idiotypic CA-125 targeted immunotherapeutic agent for ovarian cancer

Ovarian cancer remains the leading cause of death due to gynecologic malignancies. Most patients present with advanced disease at the time of diagnosis. Although many have a good initial response to surgical debulking and platinum-based chemotherapy, relapse is common, with the eventual development of chemotherapy resistance. Innovative treatments are needed in the remission setting to prolong the disease-free interval or prevent recurrence. Abagovomab is a murine monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody (molecular weight: 165-175 kDa) that functionally imitates the tumor-associated antigen, CA-125. It has been shown to be well tolerated and to induce a sustained immune response in initial Phase I and II clinical trials. An ongoing, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multicenter, Phase III trial (MIMOSA) completed its double-blind period in December 2010 and will compare abagovomab maintenance therapy to placebo, which will definitively determine the efficacy of this immunotherapeutic approach in patients with ovarian cancer.

Allergen IgE-isotype-specific suppression by maternally derived monoclonal anti-IgG-idiotype

BACKGROUND

The dramatic increase of IgE-mediated allergic diseases in western countries demonstrates the urgent need for new therapeutic or prophylactic approaches. In mice, a prophylactic long-lasting allergen-specific suppression of IgE responsiveness is induced by maternal IgG antibodies to allergens like ovalbumin, phospholipase A(2) (bvPLA(2)) or ovomucoid. As neonatal application or maternally derived pathogen-reactive antibodies (idiotypes) as well as corresponding anti-idiotypes can induce anti-microbial protection, we probed the transgenerational IgE-suppressive mechanism with a syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody.

METHODS

The monoclonal bee-venom-phospholipase A(2) (bvPLA(2))-reactive IgG antibody MS613 (idiotype) or the corresponding syngeneic anti-idiotype II/2-19 were injected during the first 2 days postpartum to the dams. Immunization of offspring with minute doses of IgE-inducing bvPLA(2) was started at an adult age of 3(1/2) months.

RESULTS

The postnatal transfer of the anti-bvPLA(2) idiotype MS613 or the corresponding anti-idiotype II/2-19 induced long-lasting allergen-specific IgE suppression in a dose-dependent manner, while the IgG response to the allergen developed normally. Quantitatively, the anti-idiotype was more effective than idiotype. Molecular modeling of the idiotype-anti-idiotype complex and its comparison with the bvPLA(2) structure revealed that the anti-idiotype does not mimic bvPLA(2) epitopes and thus can not be regarded as an internal image antibody and, consequently, does not function as a surrogate antigen.

CONCLUSIONS

Idiotypic network reactivity is at least one major factor for induction of transgenerational IgE suppression by maternal IgG antibodies. If applicable to humans, these data suggest the possibility of a prophylactic and possibly therapeutic treatment of IgE-mediated allergic diseases with anti-idiotypic antibodies.

An MVA vaccine overcomes tolerance to human p53 in mice and humans

BACKGROUND

The cellular regulatory protein p53 is overexpressed by almost 50% of all malignancies making it an attractive target for a vaccine approach to cancer. A number of immunotherapy approaches targeting p53 have been evaluated successfully in murine models, but translation of these preclinical findings to the clinic has been unsuccessful. Prior studies in our laboratory employing murine models demonstrated that a modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) vaccine expressing murine p53 could stimulate p53 specific immunity. Systemic administration of the MVA vaccine was able to effect the rejection of established tumors. To better understand the immunologic mechanisms that underlie the vaccine function of human p53, we utilized a murine model in which the murine germ line copy of p53 was replaced with a modified human one. These mice, referred to as Hupki, were evaluated as a tolerant model to explore the capacity of MVA expressing human p53 to overcome tolerance and reject human p53-expressing tumors.

RESULTS

MVAp53 immunization of Hupki mice resulted in the generation of p53-specific CD8(+) T cells and the rejection of a highly aggressive murine mammary carcinoma cell line 4T1(H-2d) transfected with human p53 (4T1p53). An immunologic correlate of tumor protection was evaluated utilizing an overlapping peptide library spanning the full length of human p53. This reagent was also used in combination with MVAp53 to stimulate p53-specific CD8(+) T cell responses in cancer patients.

CONCLUSION

These studies demonstrate the potential of MVAp53 to overcome tolerance to p53 for cancer immunotherapy.

Human leukocyte antigen-A2-restricted CTL responses to mutated BRAF peptides in melanoma patients

Mutated BRAF (BRAF(V600E)) is a potential immunotherapeutic target for melanoma because of its tumor specificity and expression in the majority of these lesions derived from different patients. BRAF(V600E) is expressed intracellularly and not on the cell surface, therefore providing a target for T cells but not B cells. Demonstration of patients' T cell responses to BRAF(V600E) would suggest the feasibility of active specific immunotherapy targeting the mutation in these patients. In the present study, BRAF(V600E) peptides with putative binding sites for human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A2 were used to stimulate T lymphocytes of HLA-A2-positive melanoma patients. Four of five patients with BRAF(V600E)-positive lesions showed lymphoproliferative responses to BRAF(V600E) peptide stimulation. These responses were specific for the mutated epitope and HLA-A2 was restricted in three patients. Lymphocytes from these three patients were cytotoxic against HLA-A2-matched BRAF(V600E)-positive melanoma cells. None of the four patients with BRAF(V600E)-negative lesions and none of five healthy donors had lymphoproliferative responses specific for the mutated epitope. The high prevalence (approximately 50%) of HLA-A2 among melanoma patients renders HLA-A2-restricted BRAF(V600E) peptides attractive candidate vaccines for these patients.

Human High Molecular Weight Melanoma-Associated Antigen Mimicry by Mouse Anti-Idiotypic Monoclonal Antibody MK2-23: Enhancement of Immunogenicity of Anti-Idiotypic Monoclonal Antibody MK2-23 by Fusion with Interleukin 2

To overcome unresponsiveness to the self-high molecular weight melanoma-associated antigen (HMW-MAA) in hosts with constitutive HMW-MAA expression, we have used as immunogen the anti-idiotypic monoclonal antibody (mAb) MK2-23, which mimics the antigenic determinant recognized by the anti-HMW-MAA mAb 763.74. In a phase I/II clinical trial, anti-idiotypic mAb MK2-23, conjugated to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) as a carrier and given with Bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) as an adjuvant, elicited HMW-MAA-specific antibodies in about 60% of the immunized melanoma patients. The immune response was associated with survival prolongation. However, safety and standardization issues associated with the use of KLH and BCG in the clinical setting have prompted us to develop alternative immunization strategies. Conjugation of human interleukin 2 (IL-2) to mAb MK2-23 variable regions covalently linked to human immunoglobulin constant regions enhanced mAb MK2-23 immunogenicity in BALB/c mice to an extent similar to that induced by mAb MK2-23 conjugated to KLH and given with Freund's adjuvant. As determined by the level of serum antibodies and delayed-type hypersensitivity responses to HMW-MAA-bearing melanoma cells, immunization of mice with the MK2-23-IL-2 fusion protein elicited more robust humoral and cellular responses, respectively, than immunization with KLH-conjugated mAb MK2-23 and separate administration of IL-2. The immunogenicity of the fusion protein is dependent on IL-2 conjugation, because immunization of mice with either mAb MK2-23 or chimeric mAb MK2-23, in combination with IL-2, was not as effective in eliciting HMW-MAA-specific immune responses. These results suggest that the MK2-23-IL-2 fusion protein represents a useful immunogen to implement active specific immunotherapy in patients with melanoma, because it bypasses the requirement for KLH conjugation and adjuvant administration.

Using antibodies in tumour immunotherapy

The role of antibodies as therapeutic cancer vaccines includes two distinct approaches, which are summarised in this review, namely anti-idiotypic vaccines and antigen-antibody complex therapies. Bispecific antibodies directed against T cells or antigen-presenting cells are also referenced. The report focuses on theoretical issues, laboratory data on the mechanism of action, examples of humoral and cellular immune induction, and novel therapeutic advances in vaccine development. The biology of antigen processing and recent advances in the field of dendritic cell biology are critical to understanding the potent immune response induction. Future directions include combination therapies to manipulate immune regulatory mechanisms and to enhance clinical effects. Additional applications of antibodies targeting costimulatory or regulatory receptors on antigen-presenting cells and T cells, neutralising immune suppressive cytokines, and depleting T regulatory cells hold promise for future mono- and particularly combination therapies.

Autoantigen complementarity: a new theory implicating complementary proteins as initiators of autoimmune disease

Autoimmune diseases affect approximately 1 in 21 persons in the United States. Treatment often requires long-term cytotoxic therapy. How and why these deleterious diseases occur is unclear. A serendipitous finding in our laboratory using serum from patients with autoimmune vasculitis led us to develop the theory of autoantigen complementarity, a novel concept that may elucidate the etiological and pathogenetic mechanisms underlying autoimmune disease in general. The theory proposes that the inciting immunogen that elicits a cascade of immunological events is not the self-antigen (the autoantigen) or its mimic but rather a protein that is complementary in surface structure to the autoantigen; that is, a protein homologous or identical to the amino acid sequence of translated antisense RNA from the noncoding strand of the autoantigen gene. The cascade begins when this complementary protein initiates the production of antibodies that in turn elicit an anti-antibody or anti-idiotypic response. These anti-idiotypic antibodies can now react with the autoantigen. Strikingly, homology search of complementary proteins yields microbial and fungal proteins, thus indicating that invading micro-organisms can deliver the inciting immunogen. Curiously, approximately 50% of our patients transcribe the complementary protein's antisense RNA. If it transpires that these aberrant RNAs are translated, the complementary protein would be produced by the individual. Here we review published research investigating complementary proteins, anti-idiotypic immune responses, and antisense transcripts, all of which support complementary proteins as initiators of autoimmune disease. In addition, we provide possible microbial and/or fungal organisms that may incite some of the most studied autoimmune diseases. Lastly, we propose mechanisms by which cell-mediated autoimmunity can be triggered by autoantigen complementarity. Based on our data and the contributions of the researchers described in this review, identification of proteins complementary to autoantigens is likely to be informative in most autoimmune diseases. This vein of study is in the early phases; however, we expect "autoantigen complementarity" is an underlying mechanism in many autoimmune diseases.

A New Set of Monoclonal Antibodies Directed to Proline-Rich and Central Regions of p53

The p53 protein can adopt several conformations in cells--"latent," "active," or mutant--depending on cellular stress or mutations of the TP53 gene. Today, only a few antibodies discriminating these conformations are available. We produced three new anti-p53 monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) directed against epitopes of human p53. The H53C1 MAb recognizes an epitope located at the N-terminal part of the central region of p53 and can discriminate mutant from wild-type conformation. The H53C2 and H53C3 MAbs are against different epitopes within the proline-rich region of p53. Moreover, the H53C2 epitope is located in the second negative regulatory domain of p53 between residues 80 and 93. These MAbs can be used as new tools to study and modulate the cellular functions of p53.

A novel CEA vaccine stimulates T cell proliferation, γIFN secretion and CEA specific CTL responses

Carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) is a cell surface protein over-expressed by a wide range of tumours. The mouse anti-idiotypic antibody, 708, mimics CEA and can induce both antibody and T cell responses that specifically recognise this antigen. Sequence analysis of 708 revealed homology with a previously identified HLA-A3 T cell epitope in CEA but not to other closely related molecules. 708 was chimerised to a human IgG1 to allow Fc targeting of APCs and was deimmunised to remove unwanted T cell epitopes. The chimerised and deimmunised, but not the mouse 708, could stimulate CTL, proliferation and gammaIFN responses in vitro in normal (HLA-A3, DR1) individuals. Furthermore, the CTLs killed tumour cells expressing CEA suggesting that this deimmunised antibody could be a useful vaccine for solid tumours.

Immunotherapy of malignant diseases. Challenges and strategies

In recent years, there has been growing interest in the application of immunotherapy as an alternative to chemotherapy and radiotherapy for the treatment of malignant diseases. This interest is due to a variety of factors, including revival of the immunosurveillance theory, availability of well-defined and structurally characterized human tumor-associated antigens (TAAs), progress in our understanding of the molecular pathways required for induction and maintenance of an immune response, and advances in methodologies to generate TAA-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) as immunological probes. However, contrary to the positive results obtained with TAA-specific immunotherapy in animal model systems, the clinical response in patients has been disappointing. Frequently, the immune responses do not correlate with the clinical responses. Analysis of the underlying mechanisms of this dichotomy have identified the low immunogenicity of TAAs, the lack of immunological markers to predict clinical outcomes, and the ability of tumors to escape immune recognition and destruction as challenges to the development and application of immunotherapy. In this paper, we have reviewed the mechanisms underlying immune unresponsiveness to TAAs and strategies to overcome this unresponsiveness in the humoral and cellular immune responses, highlighting findings from different antigenic systems to prove the validity of these strategies. Additionally, we have addressed limitations to TAA-targeting immunotherapy as a result of the genetic instability of tumor cells, and have discussed strategies to overcome this limitation by targeting immunotherapy to molecules implicated in tumor-associated angiogenesis. Lastly, we have concluded by indicating the need to refine the implementation of clinical trials of immunotherapy, and to emphasize combination therapies to counteract the multiple tumor escape mechanisms.

Phase I clinical trial of a human idiotypic p53 vaccine in patients with advanced malignancy

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to induce immunity to p53 by using an idiotypic vaccine, composed of a pool of eight peptides derived from the complimentarity determining regions (CDRs) of human anti-p53 antibodies.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Subjects with advanced malignancy received up to four, monthly intradermal injections of pooled peptides (500 microg of each) admixed with granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF; 100 microg). In addition, two sheep and two rabbits were also vaccinated with the pooled peptides.

RESULTS

Fourteen subjects were enrolled into the study and six of these completed the vaccination schedule. The vaccine was well tolerated by all subjects and no major adverse events were attributable to the vaccine. All subjects mounted in vivo delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses to two or more of the individual vaccine peptides. Vaccine-induced antibodies specific for peptides 2, 5 or 8 were detected in four of six subjects, and two of these had vaccine-specific, cell-mediated responses. Increasing titers of p53-specific antibodies were found in one patient. No T-cell response to p53 was observed in any of the subjects. All animals developed humoral immunity to the peptides and one of the sheep developed rising serum titers of anti-p53 antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

Vaccination with human antibody CDR regions represents a novel method for inducing human antibodies, which may in turn serve as immunological mimics of p53.

The murine telomerase catalytic subunit shares the PAb-240 mutant specific epitope of the p53 protein

Many tumorigenic p53 mutants gain a common antigenic epitope that is recognized by the PAb-240 antibody. Database search identified the presence of this epitope in several other proteins, including several antibodies and the catalytic subunit of mouse telomerase, mTERT. These antibodies may represent a part of the previously demonstrated anti-idiotypic network built around p53. In the present study we demonstrate that the PAb-240 antibody was able to inhibit telomerase activity in extracts from both mouse and human tumor cells. The recognition of mTERT by PAb-240 is demonstrated by Western blotting and by using blocking peptides derived from mTERT. The existence of a shared epitope between mutant p53 and telomerase may suggest that the two proteins contribute to malignant transformation through a common pathway.

CTLA-4 blockade enhances the therapeutic effect of an attenuated poxvirus vaccine targeting p53 in an established murine tumor model

p53 is overexpressed by half of all cancers, and is an attractive target for a vaccine approach to immunotherapy. p53 overexpression is frequently the result of point mutations, which leaves the majority of the protein in its wild-type form. Therefore, the majority of p53 sequence is wild type, making it a self-protein for which tolerance plays a role in limiting immune responses. To overcome tolerance to p53, we have expressed wild-type murine p53 in the nonpathogenic attenuated poxvirus, modified vaccinia virus Ankara (recombinant modified vaccinia virus Ankara expressing wild-type murine p53 (rMVAp53)). Mice immunized with rMVAp53 vaccine developed vigorous p53-specific CTL responses. rMVAp53 vaccine was evaluated for its ability to inhibit the outgrowth of the syngeneic murine sarcoma Meth A, which overexpresses mutant p53. Mice were inoculated with a lethal dose (5 x 10(5) cells injected s.c.) of Meth A tumor cells and vaccinated by i.p. injection 3 days later with 5 x 10(7) PFU of rMVAp53. The majority of mice remained tumor free and resistant to rechallenge with Meth A tumor cells. We wished to determine whether rMVAp53 immunization could effect the rejection of an established, palpable Meth A tumor. In subsequent experiments, mice were injected with 10(6) Meth A tumor cells, and treated 6 days later with anti-CTLA-4 Ab (9H10) and rMVAp53. The majority of treated mice had complete tumor regression along with lasting tumor immunity. In vivo Ab depletion confirmed that the antitumor effect was primarily CD8 and to a lesser extent CD4 dependent. These experiments demonstrate the potential of a novel cell-free vaccine targeting p53 in malignancy.

Patterns in randomly evolving networks: idiotypic networks

We present a model for the evolution of networks of occupied sites on undirected regular graphs. At every iteration step in a parallel update, I randomly chosen empty sites are occupied and occupied sites having occupied neighbor degree outside of a given interval (t(l),t(u)) are set empty. Depending on the influx I and the values of both lower threshold and upper threshold of the occupied neighbor degree, different kinds of behavior can be observed. In certain regimes stable long-living patterns appear. We distinguish two types of patterns: static patterns arising on graphs with low connectivity and dynamic patterns found on high connectivity graphs. Increasing I patterns become unstable and transitions between almost stable patterns, interrupted by disordered phases, occur. For still larger I the lifetime of occupied sites becomes very small and network structures are dominated by randomness. We develop methods to analyze the nature and dynamics of these network patterns, give a statistical description of defects and fluctuations around them, and elucidate the transitions between different patterns. Results and methods presented can be applied to a variety of problems in different fields and a broad class of graphs. Aiming chiefly at the modeling of functional networks of interacting antibodies and B cells of the immune system (idiotypic networks), we focus on a class of graphs constructed by bit chains. The biological relevance of the patterns and possible operational modes of idiotypic networks are discussed.

Anti-idiotype antibody vaccine therapy for cancer

The use of anti-idiotype (Id) antibodies as vaccines to stimulate antitumour immunity is one of several promising immunologic approaches to the therapy of cancer. Extensive studies in animal tumour models have demonstrated the efficacy of anti-Id vaccines in preventing tumour growth and curing mice with established tumours. A number of monoclonal anti-Id antibodies that mimic distinct human tumour-associated antigens (TAAs) have been developed and tested in the clinic, and demonstrate encouraging results. In general, the antigen mimicry by anti-Id antibodies has reflected structural homology in the majority of the cases, and amino acid sequence homology in a few of them. The greatest challenge of immunotherapy by means of anti-Id vaccines is to identify the optimal anti-Id antibody that will function as a true surrogate antigen for a TAA system, and ideally will generate both humoral and cellular immune responses. Although several clinical studies have shown enhanced survival of patients receiving anti-Id vaccines, the efficacy of these vaccines will depend on the results of several randomised Phase III clinical trials that are currently planned or ongoing.

Generalization of single immunological experiences by idiotypically mediated clonal connections

Clonal interactions of B cells by idiotope-specific mutual recognition of their antigen receptors with the participation of T cells were assumed to form a web of unknown density, referred to as the idiotypic network. Although these clonal connections were proposed to fulfill important internal regulatory functions, their biological significance, especially in relation to antigen-induced immune responses, remained a mystery. In view of this, we postulate that the basic function of the idiotypic internal connection between B and T cell antigen receptors is to transform antigen-induced cellular activations, by idiotypic crossreactivity, into the regulation of cell clones with different antigen specificities. This process leads not only to the suppression of major clones but also to the activation of minor ones. The latter activating property may allow the generalization of single antigenic experiences, so that the immune system in its entirety benefits in its battle against environmental microbes. Such idiotypic clonal interactions are particularly effective in early ontogeny. During a short neonatal imprinting period, maternal immunological knowledge in the form of somatically mutated, high-affinity IgG antibodies, acquired through a continuous encounter with external antigens, guides the initial ontogenetic development of the immune system and so exerts long-lasting transgenerational advantageous effects in the offspring.

The concept of idiotypic vaccination against factor VIII inhibitors in haemophilia A

Idiotypic vaccination has proven successful in several animal models and human trials. Here we suggest that the expression of cross-reactive idiotypes on factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors of patients with haemophilia A, patients with anti-FVIII autoimmune disease and natural anti-FVIII antibodies of healthy individuals, together with the ability of anti-idiotypic reagents to neutralize anti-FVIII antibodies, provides a rationale for designing a vaccine strategy aimed at preventing the occurrence of or suppressing inhibitors, based on the induction of protective anti-idiotypes. Here we discuss the rationale supporting the concept of using idiotypic vaccination to prevent the occurrence of FVIII inhibitors in patients with haemophilia A.

An evolutionary-game model of tumour-cell interactions: possible relevance to gene therapy

Evolutionary games have been applied as simple mathematical models of populations where interactions between individuals control the dynamics. Recently, it has been proposed to use this type of model to describe the evolution of tumour cell populations with interactions between cells. We extent the analysis to allow for synergistic effects between cells. A mathematical model of a tumour cell population is presented in which population-level synergy is assumed to originate through the interaction of triplets of cells. A threshold of two cooperating cells is assumed to be required to produce a proliferative advantage. The mathematical behaviour of this model is explored. Even this simple synergism (minor clustering effect) is sufficient to generate qualitatively different cell-population dynamics from the models published previously. The most notable feature of the model is the existence of an unstable internal equilibrium separating two stable equilibria. Thus, cells of a malignant phenotype can exist in a stable polymorphism, but may be driven to extinction by relatively modest perturbations of their relative frequency. The proposed model has some features that may be of interest to biological interpretations of gene therapy. Two prototypical strategies for gene therapy are suggested, both of them leading to extinction of the malignant phenotype: one approach would be to reduce the relative proportion of the cooperating malignant cell type below a certain critical value. Another approach would be to increase the critical threshold value without reducing the relative frequency of cells of the malignant phenotype.

Autoimmunity to the p53 protein is a feature of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) related to anti-DNA antibodies

The induction of anti-DNA autoantibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients is problematic because mammalian DNA is poorly immunogenic at best. Here we demonstrate a chain of connected antibodies in SLE patient sera that could account for the induction of anti-DNA antibody, and possibly for some of the pathogenic features of SLE. We now report that SLE patients, in addition to anti-DNA, produce antibodies to the carboxy-terminal domain of the tumour suppressor molecule p53; this p53 domain recognizes damaged DNA. Hence, these anti-p53 antibodies could mimic damaged DNA immunologically. Indeed, SLE sera do contain anti-idiotypic antibodies to a prototypic anti-p53 antibody. Moreover, SLE anti-DNA antibodies also recognize this type of anti-p53 antibody. Indeed, binding of affinity-purified anti-DNA both to DNA and to the anti-p53 antibody could be blocked by a p53 peptide derived from the DNA-binding domain. This mimicry of the p53 DNA-binding domain by the SLE anti-DNA antibodies is functional: activation of the p53 molecule could be inhibited by such anti-DNA antibodies. Thus, anti-DNA antibodies may arise in SLE patients by a chain of idiotypic autoimmunity centered around p53 autoimmunity. The SLE anti-DNA and anti-p53 antibodies can functionally block p53 activation, and so could affect apoptosis.

Architecture of idiotypic networks: percolation and scaling behavior

We investigate a model where idiotypes (characterizing B lymphocytes and antibodies of an immune system) and anti-idiotypes are represented by complementary bit strings of a given length d allowing for a number of mismatches (matching rules). In this model, the vertices of the hypercube in dimension d represent the potential repertoire of idiotypes. A random set of (with probability p) occupied vertices corresponds to the expressed repertoire of idiotypes at a given moment. Vertices of this set linked by the above matching rules build random clusters. We give a structural and statistical characterization of these clusters, or in other words of the architecture of the idiotypic network. Increasing the probability p one finds at a critical p a percolation transition where for the first time a large connected graph occurs with probability 1. Increasing p further, there is a second transition above which the repertoire is complete in the sense that any newly introduced idiotype finds a complementary anti-idiotype. We introduce structural characteristics such as the mass distribution and the fragmentation rate for random clusters, and determine the scaling behavior of the cluster size distribution near the percolation transition, including finite size corrections. We find that slightly above the percolation transition the large connected cluster (the central part of the idiotypic network) consists typically of one highly connected part and a number of weakly connected constituents and coexists with a number of small, isolated clusters. This is in accordance with the picture of a central and a peripheral part of the idiotypic network and gives some support to idealized architectures of the central part used in recent dynamical mean field models.

Human anti-idiotypic antibodies can be good immunogens as they target FC receptors on antigen-presenting cells allowing efficient stimulation of both helper and cytotoxic T-cell responses

Anti-idiotypic antibodies that mimic tumour-associated antigens can stimulate anti-tumour T-cell responses. In this article, we have studied the role of Fc in the presentation of T-cell epitopes by 2 anti-idiotypic antibodies, 105AD7 and 708. The human monoclonal antibody 105AD7, which mimics CD55, stimulated strong in vitro T-cell proliferation, gammaIFN secretion and redirected cytotoxicity in unprimed T cells from healthy donors. However, removal of the Fc region of the anti-idiotype reduced the sensitivity of the assay 1,000-fold, as did inhibiting Fc uptake of the anti-idiotype by an excess of human IgG. The mouse anti-idiotype 708, which mimics CEA, failed to stimulate in vitro T-cell responses on unprimed T cells from healthy donors. However, when a human IgG1 Fc region replaced its mouse Fc region, the anti-idiotype induced T-cell proliferation, gammaIFN secretion and redirected cytotoxicity in lymphocytes from unimmunised donors. Human anti-idiotypes are therefore good immunogens since they target Fc receptors on antigen-presenting cells, allowing efficient stimulation of both helper and cytotoxic T-cell responses. The immunogenicity of other anti-idiotypes may therefore be enhanced by human Fc targeting of antigen-presenting cells.

Immunotherapy for colorectal cancer

Immunologic approaches to therapy for colorectal cancer have evolved substantially. In the past, patients were treated with nonspecific immune stimulants such as bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG). The current focus lies in targeting tumor-associated antigens. This is done either through passive immune therapy, with antibodies targeted directly to tumor cells, or by active immune therapy through vaccination with tumor cells, tumor cell lysates, peptides, carbohydrates, gene constructs encoding proteins, or anti-idiotype antibodies that mimic tumor-associated antigens. These different approaches to immunotherapy are reviewed.

A transgenic mouse model for tumour immunotherapy: induction of an anti-idiotype response to human MUC1

MUC1 is a membrane bound, polymorphic epithelial mucin expressed at the luminal surface of glandular epithelium. It is highly expressed in an underglycosylated form on carcinomas and metastatic lesions and is, therefore, a potential target for immunotherapy of cancer. The monoclonal antibody HMFG1 binds the linear core protein sequence, PDTR, contained within the immunodominant domain of the tandem repeat of MUC1. The efficacy of murine and humanized HMFG1 (Ab1) used as an anti-idiotypic vaccine was examined in mice transgenic for human MUC1 (MUC1.Tg) challenged with murine epithelial tumour cells transfected with human MUC1. Humoral idiotypic cascade through Ab2 and Ab3 antibodies was observed in MUC1.Tg mice following multiple antibody inoculations in the presence of adjuvant. Impaired tumour growth at day 35 and highest Ab3 levels were found in mice that had received mHMFG1 with RAS adjuvant. However, comparison of Ab3 levels in individual mice with tumour size in all treatment groups did not show a correlation between smaller tumours and increased levels of anti-idiotype antibody. This suggests that the anti-tumour effects of anti-idiotype vaccination are not solely related to the induction of idiotypic antibody cascades and probably involve other mechanisms.

Use of the anti-idiotype antibody vaccine TriAb after autologous stem cell transplantation in patients with metastatic breast cancer

Between April 1997 and March 1998 we evaluated the immune response and outcome in 11 chemosensitive patients who were treated with the anti-idiotype antibody vaccine TriAb after recovery from intensive therapy and autologous stem cell transplant (ASCT). Triab was commenced after recovery from the acute effects of ASCT; a minimum interval of 1 month was required from completion of consolidation radiotherapy, if given. Nine patients (82%) manifest anti-anti-idiotype antibody (Ab3) responses post ASCT. The maximal Ab3 response was seen after a median of 10 doses (range 5-20), which corresponded to a median of 14 months (range 5-19) post ASCT. Evidence of a T cell proliferative response was seen in eight patients; the response was modest in most of these. At a median follow-up of 24 months (range 22-33) after ASCT, four patients are alive without evidence of disease progression. All four of these patients were in the subgroup with more vigorous immune responses. Subsequent efforts have been directed toward the achievement of higher levels of immune responses more rapidly post ASCT. Bone Marrow Transplantation (2000) 26, 729-735.

A therapeutic human anti-idiotypic antibody mimics CD55 in three distinct regions

The human anti-idiotypic antibody 105AD7 was isolated from a colorectal cancer patient receiving the anti-tumor antibody 791T/36 for radioimmuno-scintigraphy of liver metastases. We have mapped the binding site of 791T/36 to the first two small consensus repeat (SCR) domains of the complement regulatory protein (CD55) that is overexpressed by a wide range of solid tumors. Cloning of both antigen and anti-idiotype has identified the molecular basis of their mimicry. Amino acid homology has been identified between three complementarity-determining regions of 105AD7 and three regions of CD55 within the first two SCR domains. 791T/36 and anti-anti-idiotypic (Ab3) polyclonal antibodies raised against 105AD7 showed specific binding to these peptides. The antibodies were also found to bind synergistically to combinations of these peptides, indicating cooperativity between the peptides in stabilizing antibody binding. This also implies that the contact face on both CD55 antigen and 105AD7 is generated by the cooperation of several peptides positioned on two domains in each protein. Thus a human monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody generated by a cancer patient is able to show both amino acid and structural homology with the complement regulatory protein CD55. These findings help identify the mechanism by which a human anti-idiotypic antibody is able to mimic a tumor-associated antigen and stimulate anti-tumor B and T cell responses.

Anti-idiotype vaccine against cancer

Immunization with anti-idiotype (Id) antibodies represents a novel new approach to active immunotherapy. Extensive studies in animal tumor models have demonstrated the efficacy of anti-Id vaccines in preventing tumor growth and curing mice with established tumor. We have developed and characterized several murine monoclonal anti-Id antibodies (Ab2) which mimic distinct human tumor-associated antigens (TAA) and can be used as surrogate antigens for triggering active anti-tumor immunity in cancer patients. Encouraging results have been obtained in recent clinical trials. In this article, we will review the existing literature and summarize our own findings showing the potential of this approach for various human cancers. We will also discuss where anti-Id vaccines may perform better than traditional antigen vaccines.

p53: a potential target antigen for immunotherapy of cancer

Approximately 50% of all human malignancies exhibit mutation and aberrant expression of p53, making this protein an interesting candidate target for immunotherapy of cancer. Mutations in p53 are highly diverse. Therefore, targeting of determinants within the wild-type p53 sequence appears most practical. Despite the fact that p53 is ubiquitously expressed, adoptive immunotherapy of tumor-bearing mice with p53-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) results in eradication of p53-overexpressing tumors in the absence of immunopathological damage to normal tissues. These CTL also eliminate tumors that do not show greatly enhanced expression of p53, indicating that the sensitivity of these tumors for p53-specific CTL is determined by the efficiency by which p53-derived peptides are processed into class I MHC, rather than by the steady state levels of p53. Of note, although p53-specific CTL can readily be isolated from p53-/- mice, tolerance for this self antigen may prevent induction of similarly effective CTL in p53+/+ subjects. The T helper (Th) branch of the p53-specific immune response does not seem to be profoundly affected by tolerance. In addition, more and more evidence is obtained for the pivotal role of tumor-specific Th cells in the induction and effector phases of the antitumor response, also against tumors that lack class II MHC expression. The efficacy of Th cells, specific for a recently identified class II MHC-restricted p53 peptide, against p53-overexpressing tumors is currently being investigated. In addition, natural and induced Th responses are analyzed both in a murine tumor model and in a phase I clinical trial involving p53-specific vaccination of colon cancer patients.

Dissection of an antibody paratope into peptides discloses the idiotope recognized by the cognate anti-idiotypic antibody

Using methods of parallel synthesis, the complete amino acid sequence of an Ab 1 antibody (Tg 10, an anti-human thyroglobulin monoclonal antibody) was made in the form of a set of 100 synthetic overlapping peptides. This set of immobilized peptides was allowed to react with the cognate Ab2 (AI 10, a highly purified rabbit anti-idiotypic polyclonal antibody to Tg 10). A dominant peptide idiotope, INTFSGVPTYA, was thus mapped, which corresponds mainly to the CDR2 region from the V(H) domain of the Tg 10 mAb. A synthetic peptide replica of this idiotope was found to bind to AI 10 with an affinity (K(D) in the 10(-8) M range, as measured using BIACORE technology) which represents a significant part of the affinity of the complete Tg 10 antibody (K(D) in the 10(-9) M range). The synthetic peptide also elicited anti-idiotypic antibodies in rabbits that recognized specifically the Ab1 antibody in an Ab1- and antigen-inhibitable manner. The peptide idiotope was further characterized chemically by the identification of residues important for binding to the Ab2 and by modelization of its structure. Our approach makes it readily possible to map and characterize functional, continuous-type idiotopes that could be further used to manipulate the immune response by peptide technologies.

Is there a maternally induced immunological imprinting phase à la Konrad Lorenz?

In mammals, IgG antibodies are transferred from mothers to the offspring. Since these maternal antibodies result mainly from thymus-dependent immune responses which have undergone immune maturation through somatic hypermutations, they represent the highest quality of the collective maternal immunological experience. Maternal antibodies not only confer passive immunity as long as the newborn's immune system has not fully developed, but also exert an active stimulation as indicated by their regulatory influence on isotype expression, long-term idiotypic alterations, determination of the adult B and T cell repertoire, induction of antigen reactive IgM as well as an affinity enhancement of a proportion of early primary antibodies. The fact that several of these features can only be induced during limited sensitive periods shortly after birth is reminiscent of the behavioural imprinting as defined by Konrad Lorenz. We therefore propose that during early ontogeny there is an immunological imprinting phase with characteristics analogous to behavioural imprinting: (i) the internal imprinting effect is induced by external signals, (ii) in contrast to normal learning, immunological imprinting is also only possible during certain development phases and (iii) it is characterised by an (almost) irreversible result. Hence, if particular immunological experiences are only possible during such sensitive phases, maternal immunoglobulins and consequently the mother's immunological experience is of prime importance for the start of the ontogenetic development of the immune system.

Generation of Anti-p53 Fab Fragments from Individuals with Colorectal Cancer Using Phage Display

Although many individuals with malignancy develop Abs against p53, little is currently known of the structural features, V gene usage, and degree of somatic mutation of these Abs. Such information is critical to any meaningful understanding of the nature and significance of this humoral immune response to p53. We have constructed phage display libraries from six individuals with colorectal cancer and a demonstrable serum immune response against p53. Following panning with recombinant p53, a total of 43 binding Fab were identified. Four of these Abs bound with high affinity to wild-type denatured p53 (1.19 × 10−8 − 1.57 × 10−8), as determined by BIAcore analysis, and were highly specific for both recombinant and cell line-derived p53, as determined by ELISA and immunoprecipitation. Epitope mapping showed they were reactive with the N terminus of human p53 between residues 27 and 44. Sequence analysis showed that the heavy chains were derived from the VH1 gene family, and the light chains from VL4. The pattern of replacement and silent mutations in the Fab sequence indicated that negative selection had occurred in the framework regions of all the VH genes. We show that lymphocytes from individuals with cancer represent a valuable source of high affinity human Abs against p53. This approach provides an opportunity to examine the genetic structure of these naturally occurring Abs, and to draw inferences regarding the nature of the immune response that produced them. Abs identified in this way have a number of potential therapeutic applications.

Neonatal Exposure to Idiotype Induces Schistosoma mansoni Egg Antigen-Specific Cellular and Humoral Immune Responses

Exposure of neonatal mice to appropriate, cross-reactive Id (CRI) preparations alters immune responsiveness, ameliorates pathology, and prolongs survival of animals upon subsequent Schistosoma mansoni infection. However, because schistosome infections profoundly affect host immunobiology, which responses are effected by neonatal Id exposure alone and which responses are influenced by infection is unclear. To directly examine the schistosome soluble egg Ag (SEA)-specific immune responses altered by CRI exposure, neonatal mice were injected with CRI-expressing (CRI+) SEA-specific Ab preparations, SEA-specific Abs that did not express CRI (CRI−), or normal mouse Ig. At 9 wk of age, only mice that were neonatally exposed to CRI+ anti-SEA Abs displayed significant SEA-specific IgG serum levels and spleen cell proliferative responses. SEA-stimulated spleen cells from these CRI+-exposed mice also produced IFN-γ, although not at significantly higher levels than mice receiving CRI− Id or normal mouse Ig. If CRI+-exposed mice were also injected with SEA at 8 wk of age, the 9-wk IFN-γ responses were significantly higher than those of the other neonatal injection groups. The presence of both CRI and anti-CRI in the sera of animals neonatally injected with CRI, but receiving no exposure to S. mansoni Ags or infection, suggested a functional idiotypic network led to these responses. These data demonstrate that appropriate idiotypic exposure induces B and T cell responsiveness to the Ag recognized by the Id and support the hypothesis that neonatal idiotypic exposure can be an important immunoregulatory factor in schistosomiasis.

Cancer vaccines

It has been more than 100 years since the first reported attempts to activate a patient's immune system to eradicate developing cancers. Although a few of the subsequent vaccine studies demonstrated clinically significant treatment effects, active immunotherapy has not yet become an established cancer treatment modality. Two recent advances have allowed the design of more specific cancer vaccine approaches: improved molecular biology techniques and a greater understanding of the mechanisms involved in the activation of T cells. These advances have resulted in improved systemic antitumor immune responses in animal models. Because most tumor antigens recognized by T cells are still not known, the tumor cell itself is the best source of immunizing antigens. For this reason, most vaccine approaches currently being tested in the clinics use whole cancer cells that have been genetically modified to express genes that are now known to be critical mediators of immune system activation. In the future, the molecular definition of tumor-specific antigens that are recognized by activated T cells will allow the development of targeted antigen-specific vaccines for the treatment of patients with cancer.

p53-oriented cancer therapies: current progress

Nearly twenty years after the initial discovery of p53, we are now in an ideal position to exploit our vast knowledge of p53 biology in the creation of novel cancer therapies. Disruption of p53 function through mutation, or other means, occurs very frequently in human cancer. Loss of p53 function has been linked with unfavourable prognosis in a large number of tumour types, as indicated by more aggressive tumours, early metastasis and decreased survival rates. Many different avenues of research have converged upon p53 to highlight this protein as being one of the foremost cellular responders to stress, in particular to DNA damage. Huge advances have been made in understanding the complex role p53 plays in the regulation of apoptosis and cell cycle arrest. This review is not meant to be a comprehensive description of p53 biology, but rather serves to highlight current progress in the development of p53-oriented cancer therapies. These may be categorised into three basic strategies: gene replacement therapy using wild-type p53, restoration of p53 function by other means and, finally, targeting of the p53 dysfunction itself. Rapid progress is expected to be made regarding the identification of conventional pharmaceutical agents which either work in a p53-independent manner or act preferentially in p53 defective cells. Gene replacement therapy with wild-type p53 also holds considerable potential for obtaining clinically relevant results quickly. The other forms of cancer therapies based around p53 are much further behind in the developmental process, but may prove to more efficacious in the long run, especially in terms of specificity. As with many other fields, the innovation of successful p53-oriented cancer therapies is only limited by our understanding of p53 biology and the creative use of such knowledge.