Whole-genome doubling drives oncogenic loss of chromatin segregation

Ongoing chromothripsis underpins osteosarcoma genome complexity and clonal evolution

Osteosarcoma is the most common primary cancer of the bone, with a peak incidence in children and young adults. Using multi-region whole-genome sequencing, we find that chromothripsis is an ongoing mutational process, occurring subclonally in 74% of osteosarcomas. Chromothripsis generates highly unstable derivative chromosomes, the ongoing evolution of which drives the acquisition of oncogenic mutations, clonal diversification, and intra-tumor heterogeneity across diverse sarcomas and carcinomas. In addition, we characterize a new mechanism, termed loss-translocation-amplification (LTA) chromothripsis, which mediates punctuated evolution in about half of pediatric and adult high-grade osteosarcomas. LTA chromothripsis occurs when a single double-strand break triggers concomitant TP53 inactivation and oncogene amplification through breakage-fusion-bridge cycles. It is particularly prevalent in osteosarcoma and is not detected in other cancers driven by TP53 mutation. Finally, we identify the level of genome-wide loss of heterozygosity as a strong prognostic indicator for high-grade osteosarcoma.

Nongenetic evolution of the tumor: from challenges to new therapeutic opportunities

The ability of cancer cells to change and adapt poses a critical challenge to identifying curative solutions. Tumor evolution has been extensively studied from a genetic perspective, to guide clinicians in selecting the most appropriate therapeutic option based on a patient's mutational profile. However, several studies reported that tumors can evolve toward more aggressive stages or become resistant to therapies without changing their genetic makeup. Indeed, several cell-intrinsic and cell-extrinsic mechanisms contribute to tumor evolution. In this viewpoint, I focus on how chromatin, epigenetic, and transcriptional changes contribute to tumor evolution, allowing cancer cells to transition to different cell states and bypass response to therapies. Although tumor nongenetic evolution is harder to trace and predict, understanding its principles might open new therapeutic opportunities.

Epigenomic heterogeneity as a source of tumour evolution

In the past decade, remarkable progress in cancer medicine has been achieved by the development of treatments that target DNA sequence variants. However, a purely genetic approach to treatment selection is hampered by the fact that diverse cell states can emerge from the same genotype. In multicellular organisms, cell-state heterogeneity is driven by epigenetic processes that regulate DNA-based functions such as transcription; disruption of these processes is a hallmark of cancer that enables the emergence of defective cell states. Advances in single-cell technologies have unlocked our ability to quantify the epigenomic heterogeneity of tumours and understand its mechanisms, thereby transforming our appreciation of how epigenomic changes drive cancer evolution. This Review explores the idea that epigenomic heterogeneity and plasticity act as a reservoir of cell states and therefore as a source of tumour evolution. Best practices to quantify epigenomic heterogeneity and explore its various causes and consequences are discussed, including epigenomic reprogramming, stochastic changes and lasting memory. The design of new therapeutic approaches to restrict epigenomic heterogeneity, with the long-term objective of limiting cancer development and progression, is also addressed.

Single cell variant to enhancer to gene map for coronary artery disease

Although genome wide association studies (GWAS) in large populations have identified hundreds of variants associated with common diseases such as coronary artery disease (CAD), most disease-associated variants lie within non-coding regions of the genome, rendering it difficult to determine the downstream causal gene and cell type. Here, we performed paired single nucleus gene expression and chromatin accessibility profiling from 44 human coronary arteries. To link disease variants to molecular traits, we developed a meta-map of 88 samples and discovered 11,182 single-cell chromatin accessibility quantitative trait loci (caQTLs). Heritability enrichment analysis and disease variant mapping demonstrated that smooth muscle cells (SMCs) harbor the greatest genetic risk for CAD. To capture the continuum of SMC cell states in disease, we used dynamic single cell caQTL modeling for the first time in tissue to uncover QTLs whose effects are modified by cell state and expand our insight into genetic regulation of heterogenous cell populations. Notably, we identified a variant in the COL4A1/COL4A2 CAD GWAS locus which becomes a caQTL as SMCs de-differentiate by changing a transcription factor binding site for EGR1/2. To unbiasedly prioritize functional candidate genes, we built a genome-wide single cell variant to enhancer to gene (scV2E2G) map for human CAD to link disease variants to causal genes in cell types. Using this approach, we found several hundred genes predicted to be linked to disease variants in different cell types. Next, we performed genome-wide Hi-C in 16 human coronary arteries to build tissue specific maps of chromatin conformation and link disease variants to integrated chromatin hubs and distal target genes. Using this approach, we show that rs4887091 within the ADAMTS7 CAD GWAS locus modulates function of a super chromatin interactome through a change in a CTCF binding site. Finally, we used CRISPR interference to validate a distal gene, AMOTL2, liked to a CAD GWAS locus. Collectively we provide a disease-agnostic framework to translate human genetic findings to identify pathologic cell states and genes driving disease, producing a comprehensive scV2E2G map with genetic and tissue level convergence for future mechanistic and therapeutic studies.

High level of aneuploidy and recurrent loss of chromosome 11 as relevant features of somatotroph pituitary tumors

BACKGROUND

Somatotroph neuroendocrine pituitary tumors (sPitNET) are a subtype of pituitary tumors that commonly cause acromegaly. Our study aimed to determine the spectrum of DNA copy number abnormalities (CNAs) in sPitNETs and their relevance.

METHODS

A landscape of CNAs in sPitNETs was determined using combined whole-genome approaches involving low-pass whole genome sequencing and SNP microarrays. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was used for microscopic validation of CNAs. The tumors were also subjected to transcriptome and DNA methylation analyses with RNAseq and microarrays, respectively.

RESULTS

We observed a wide spectrum of cytogenetic changes ranging from multiple deletions, recurrent chromosome 11 loss, stable genomes, to duplication of the majority of the chromosomes. The identified CNAs were confirmed with FISH. sPitNETs with multiple duplications were characterized by intratumoral heterogeneity in chromosome number variation in individual tumor cells, as determined with FISH. These tumors were separate CNA-related sPitNET subtype in clustering analyses with CNA signature specific for whole genome doubling-related etiology. This subtype encompassed GNAS-wild type, mostly densely granulated tumors with favorable expression level of known prognosis-related genes, notably enriched with POUF1/NR5A1-double positive PitNETs. Chromosomal deletions in sPitNETs are functionally relevant. They occurred in gene-dense DNA regions and were related to genes downregulation and increased DNA methylation in the CpG island and promoter regions in the affected regions. Recurrent loss of chromosome 11 was reflected by lowered MEN1 and AIP. No such unequivocal relevance was found for chromosomal gains. Comparisons of transcriptomes of selected most cytogenetically stable sPitNETs with tumors with recurrent loss of chromosome 11 showed upregulation of processes related to gene dosage compensation mechanism in tumors with deletion. Comparison of stable tumors with those with multiple duplications showed upregulation of processes related to mitotic spindle, DNA repair, and chromatin organization. Both comparisons showed upregulation of the processes related to immune infiltration in cytogenetically stable tumors and deconvolution of DNA methylation data indicated a higher content of specified immune cells and lower tumor purity in these tumors.

CONCLUSIONS

sPitNETs fall into three relevant cytogenetic groups: highly aneuploid tumors characterized by known prognostically favorable features and low aneuploidy tumors including specific subtype with chromosome 11 loss.

Integrating the Study of Polyploidy Across Organisms, Tissues, and Disease

Polyploidy is a cellular state containing more than two complete chromosome sets. It has largely been studied as a discrete phenomenon in either organismal, tissue, or disease contexts. Increasingly, however, investigation of polyploidy across disciplines is coalescing around common principles. For example, the recent Polyploidy Across the Tree of Life meeting considered the contribution of polyploidy both in organismal evolution over millions of years and in tumorigenesis across much shorter timescales. Here, we build on this newfound integration with a unified discussion of polyploidy in organisms, cells, and disease. We highlight how common polyploidy is at multiple biological scales, thus eliminating the outdated mindset of its specialization. Additionally, we discuss rules that are likely common to all instances of polyploidy. With increasing appreciation that polyploidy is pervasive in nature and displays fascinating commonalities across diverse contexts, inquiry related to this important topic is rapidly becoming unified.

WRAD core perturbation impairs DNA replication fidelity promoting immunoediting in pancreatic cancer

It is unclear how cells counteract the potentially harmful effects of uncoordinated DNA replication in the context of oncogenic stress. Here, we identify the WRAD (WDR5/RBBP5/ASH2L/DPY30) core as a modulator of DNA replication in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) models. Molecular analyses demonstrated that the WRAD core interacts with the replisome complex, with disruption of DPY30 resulting in DNA re-replication, DNA damage, and chromosomal instability (CIN) without affecting cancer cell proliferation. Consequently, in immunocompetent models, DPY30 loss induced T cell infiltration and immune-mediated clearance of highly proliferating cancer cells with complex karyotypes, thus improving anti-tumor efficacy upon anti-PD-1 treatment. In PDAC patients, DPY30 expression was associated with high tumor grade, worse prognosis, and limited response to immune checkpoint blockade. Together, our findings indicate that the WRAD core sustains genome stability and suggest that low intratumor DPY30 levels may identify PDAC patients who will benefit from immune checkpoint inhibitors.

Cancer Genomes Sometimes Take the Longest Evolutionary Road

Baker and colleagues developed a new algorithm called "Gain Route Identification and Timing In Cancer" (GRITIC) to uncover the path of chromosomal evolution in a tumor, particularly in the context of whole-genome duplication. Their approach found that tumors with genome doubling frequently take an indirect path from one copy number state to another. In addition, the timing of genome doubling within a tumor's evolution impacts its consequences on downstream chromosomal instability. See related article by Baker et al., p. 1810.

Inferring replication timing and proliferation dynamics from single-cell DNA sequencing data

Dysregulated DNA replication is a cause and a consequence of aneuploidy in cancer, yet the interplay between copy number alterations (CNAs), replication timing (RT) and cell cycle dynamics remain understudied in aneuploid tumors. We developed a probabilistic method, PERT, for simultaneous inference of cell-specific replication and copy number states from single-cell whole genome sequencing (scWGS) data. We used PERT to investigate clone-specific RT and proliferation dynamics in  >50,000 cells obtained from aneuploid and clonally heterogeneous cell lines, xenografts and primary cancers. We observed bidirectional relationships between RT and CNAs, with CNAs affecting X-inactivation producing the largest RT shifts. Additionally, we found that clone-specific S-phase enrichment positively correlated with ground-truth proliferation rates in genomically stable but not unstable cells. Together, these results demonstrate robust computational identification of S-phase cells from scWGS data, and highlight the importance of RT and cell cycle properties in studying the genomic evolution of aneuploid tumors.

Exploration of inhibitors targeting KIF18A with ploidy-specific lethality

Currently, various antimitotic inhibitors applied in tumor therapy. However, these inhibitors exhibit targeted toxicity to some extent. As a motor protein, kinesin family member 18A (KIF18A) is crucial to spindle formation and is associated with tumors exhibiting ploidy-specific characteristics such as chromosomal aneuploidy, whole-genome doubling (WGD), and chromosomal instability (CIN). Differing from traditional antimitotic targets, KIF18A exhibits tumor-specific selectivity. The functional loss or attenuation of KIF18A results in vulnerability of tumor cells with ploidy-specific characteristics, with lesser effects on diploid cells. Research on inhibitors targeting KIF18A with ploidy-specific lethality holds significant importance. This review provides a brief overview of the regulatory mechanisms of the ploidy-specific lethality target KIF18A and the research advancements in its inhibitors, aiming to facilitate the development of KIF18A inhibitors.

An elevated rate of whole-genome duplications in cancers from Black patients

In the United States, Black individuals have higher rates of cancer mortality than any other racial group. Here, we examine chromosome copy number changes in cancers from more than 1800 self-reported Black patients. We find that tumors from self-reported Black patients are significantly more likely to exhibit whole-genome duplications (WGDs), a genomic event that enhances metastasis and aggressive disease, compared to tumors from self-reported white patients. This increase in WGD frequency is observed across multiple cancer types, including breast, endometrial, and lung cancer, and is associated with shorter patient survival. We further demonstrate that combustion byproducts are capable of inducing WGDs in cell culture, and cancers from self-reported Black patients exhibit mutational signatures consistent with exposure to these carcinogens. In total, these findings identify a type of genomic alteration that is associated with environmental exposures and that may influence racial disparities in cancer outcomes.

Unraveling the key role of chromatin structure in cancer development through epigenetic landscape characterization of oral cancer

Epigenetic alterations, such as those in chromatin structure and DNA methylation, have been extensively studied in a number of tumor types. But oral cancer, particularly oral adenocarcinoma, has received far less attention. Here, we combined laser-capture microdissection and muti-omics mini-bulk sequencing to systematically characterize the epigenetic landscape of oral cancer, including chromatin architecture, DNA methylation, H3K27me3 modification, and gene expression. In carcinogenesis, tumor cells exhibit reorganized chromatin spatial structures, including compromised compartment structures and altered gene-gene interaction networks. Notably, some structural alterations are observed in phenotypically non-malignant paracancerous but not in normal cells. We developed transformer models to identify the cancer propensity of individual genome loci, thereby determining the carcinogenic status of each sample. Insights into cancer epigenetic landscapes provide evidence that chromatin reorganization is an important hallmark of oral cancer progression, which is also linked with genomic alterations and DNA methylation reprogramming. In particular, regions of frequent copy number alternations in cancer cells are associated with strong spatial insulation in both cancer and normal samples. Aberrant methylation reprogramming in oral squamous cell carcinomas is closely related to chromatin structure and H3K27me3 signals, which are further influenced by intrinsic sequence properties. Our findings indicate that structural changes are both significant and conserved in two distinct types of oral cancer, closely linked to transcriptomic alterations and cancer development. Notably, the structural changes remain markedly evident in oral adenocarcinoma despite the considerably lower incidence of genomic copy number alterations and lesser extent of methylation alterations compared to squamous cell carcinoma. We expect that the comprehensive analysis of epigenetic reprogramming of different types and subtypes of primary oral tumors can provide additional guidance to the design of novel detection and therapy for oral cancer.

A Functional Survey of the Regulatory Landscape of Estrogen Receptor-Positive Breast Cancer Evolution

Only a handful of somatic alterations have been linked to endocrine therapy resistance in hormone-dependent breast cancer, potentially explaining ∼40% of relapses. If other mechanisms underlie the evolution of hormone-dependent breast cancer under adjuvant therapy is currently unknown. In this work, we employ functional genomics to dissect the contribution of cis-regulatory elements (CRE) to cancer evolution by focusing on 12 megabases of noncoding DNA, including clonal enhancers, gene promoters, and boundaries of topologically associating domains. Parallel epigenetic perturbation (CRISPRi) in vitro reveals context-dependent roles for many of these CREs, with a specific impact on dormancy entrance and endocrine therapy resistance. Profiling of CRE somatic alterations in a unique, longitudinal cohort of patients treated with endocrine therapies identifies a limited set of noncoding changes potentially involved in therapy resistance. Overall, our data uncover how endocrine therapies trigger the emergence of transient features which could ultimately be exploited to hinder the adaptive process. Significance: This study shows that cells adapting to endocrine therapies undergo changes in the usage or regulatory regions. Dormant cells are less vulnerable to regulatory perturbation but gain transient dependencies which can be exploited to decrease the formation of dormant persisters.

Copy number alterations: a catastrophic orchestration of the breast cancer genome

Breast cancer (BCa) is a prevalent malignancy that predominantly affects women around the world. Somatic copy number alterations (CNAs) are tumor-specific amplifications or deletions of DNA segments that often drive BCa development and therapy resistance. Hence, the complex patterns of CNAs complement BCa classification systems. In addition, understanding the precise contributions of CNAs is essential for tailoring personalized treatment approaches. This review highlights how tumor evolution drives the acquisition of CNAs, which in turn shape the genomic landscapes of BCas. It also discusses advanced methodologies for identifying recurrent CNAs, studying CNAs in BCa and their clinical impact.

Ongoing genome doubling promotes evolvability and immune dysregulation in ovarian cancer

Whole-genome doubling (WGD) is a critical driver of tumor development and is linked to drug resistance and metastasis in solid malignancies. Here, we demonstrate that WGD is an ongoing mutational process in tumor evolution. Using single-cell whole-genome sequencing, we measured and modeled how WGD events are distributed across cellular populations within tumors and associated WGD dynamics with properties of genome diversification and phenotypic consequences of innate immunity. We studied WGD evolution in 65 high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC) tissue samples from 40 patients, yielding 29,481 tumor cell genomes. We found near-ubiquitous evidence of WGD as an ongoing mutational process promoting cell-cell diversity, high rates of chromosomal missegregation, and consequent micronucleation. Using a novel mutation-based WGD timing method, doubleTime , we delineated specific modes by which WGD can drive tumor evolution: (i) unitary evolutionary origin followed by significant diversification, (ii) independent WGD events on a pre-existing background of copy number diversity, and (iii) evolutionarily late clonal expansions of WGD populations. Additionally, through integrated single-cell RNA sequencing and high-resolution immunofluorescence microscopy, we found that inflammatory signaling and cGAS-STING pathway activation result from ongoing chromosomal instability and are restricted to tumors that remain predominantly diploid. This contrasted with predominantly WGD tumors, which exhibited significant quiescent and immunosuppressive phenotypic states. Together, these findings establish WGD as an evolutionarily 'active' mutational process that promotes evolvability and dysregulated immunity in late stage ovarian cancer.

Tetraploidy as a metastable state towards malignant cell transformation within a systemic approach of cancer development

Tetraploidy, a condition in which a cell has four homologous sets of chromosomes, may be a natural physiological condition or pathophysiological such as in cancer cells or stress induced tetraploidisation. Its contribution to cancer development is well known. However, among the many models proposed to explain the causes, mechanisms and steps of malignant cell transformation, only few integrate tetraploidization into a systemic multistep approach of carcinogenesis. Therefore, we will i) describe the molecular and cellular characteristics of tetraploidy; ii) assess the contribution of stress-induced tetraploidy in cancer development; iii) situate tetraploidy as a metastable state leading to cancer development in a systemic cell-centered approach; iiii) consider knowledge gaps and future perspectives. The available data shows that stress-induced tetraploidisation/polyploidisation leads to p53 stabilisation, cell cycle arrest, followed by cellular senescence or apoptosis, suppressing the proliferation of tetraploid cells. However, if tetraploid cells escape the G1-tetraploidy checkpoint, it may lead to uncontrolled proliferation of tetraploid cells, micronuclei induction, aneuploidy and deploidisation. In addition, tetraploidization favors 3D-chromatin changes and epigenetic effects. The combined effects of genetic and epigenetic changes allow the expression of oncogenic gene expression and cancer progression. Moreover, since micronuclei are inducing inflammation, which in turn may induce additional tetraploidization, tetraploidy-derived genetic instability leads to a carcinogenic vicious cycle. The concept that polyploid cells are metastable intermediates between diploidy and aneuploidy is not new. Metastability denotes an intermediate energetic state within a dynamic system other than the system's state at least energy. Considering in parallel the genetic/epigenetic changes and the probable entropy levels induced by stress-induced tetraploidisation provides a new systemic approach to describe cancer development.

Long-term Multimodal Recording Reveals Epigenetic Adaptation Routes in Dormant Breast Cancer Cells

Patients with estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer receive adjuvant endocrine therapies (ET) that delay relapse by targeting clinically undetectable micrometastatic deposits. Yet, up to 50% of patients relapse even decades after surgery through unknown mechanisms likely involving dormancy. To investigate genetic and transcriptional changes underlying tumor awakening, we analyzed late relapse patients and longitudinally profiled a rare cohort treated with long-term neoadjuvant ETs until progression. Next, we developed an in vitro evolutionary study to record the adaptive strategies of individual lineages in unperturbed parallel experiments. Our data demonstrate that ETs induce nongenetic cell state transitions into dormancy in a stochastic subset of cells via epigenetic reprogramming. Single lineages with divergent phenotypes awaken unpredictably in the absence of recurrent genetic alterations. Targeting the dormant epigenome shows promising activity against adapting cancer cells. Overall, this study uncovers the contribution of epigenetic adaptation to the evolution of resistance to ETs.

SIGNIFICANCE

This study advances the understanding of therapy-induced dormancy with potential clinical implications for breast cancer. Estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer cells adapt to endocrine treatment by entering a dormant state characterized by strong heterochromatinization with no recurrent genetic changes. Targeting the epigenetic rewiring impairs the adaptation of cancer cells to ETs. See related commentary by Llinas-Bertran et al., p. 704. This article is featured in Selected Articles from This Issue, p. 695.

DNA fragility at topologically associated domain boundaries is promoted by alternative DNA secondary structure and topoisomerase II activity

CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF) binding sites are hotspots of genome instability. Although many factors have been associated with CTCF binding site fragility, no study has integrated all fragility-related factors to understand the mechanism(s) of how they work together. Using an unbiased, genome-wide approach, we found that DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are enriched at strong, but not weak, CTCF binding sites in five human cell types. Energetically favorable alternative DNA secondary structures underlie strong CTCF binding sites. These structures coincided with the location of topoisomerase II (TOP2) cleavage complex, suggesting that DNA secondary structure acts as a recognition sequence for TOP2 binding and cleavage at CTCF binding sites. Furthermore, CTCF knockdown significantly increased DSBs at strong CTCF binding sites and at CTCF sites that are located at topologically associated domain (TAD) boundaries. TAD boundary-associated CTCF sites that lost CTCF upon knockdown displayed increased DSBs when compared to the gained sites, and those lost sites are overrepresented with G-quadruplexes, suggesting that the structures act as boundary insulators in the absence of CTCF, and contribute to increased DSBs. These results model how alternative DNA secondary structures facilitate recruitment of TOP2 to CTCF binding sites, providing mechanistic insight into DNA fragility at CTCF binding sites.

Polyploidy Promotes Hypertranscription, Apoptosis Resistance, and Ciliogenesis in Cancer Cells and Mesenchymal Stem Cells of Various Origins: Comparative Transcriptome In Silico Study

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) attract an increasing amount of attention due to their unique therapeutic properties. Yet, MSC can undergo undesirable genetic and epigenetic changes during their propagation in vitro. In this study, we investigated whether polyploidy can compromise MSC oncological safety and therapeutic properties. For this purpose, we compared the impact of polyploidy on the transcriptome of cancer cells and MSC of various origins (bone marrow, placenta, and heart). First, we identified genes that are consistently ploidy-induced or ploidy-repressed through all comparisons. Then, we selected the master regulators using the protein interaction enrichment analysis (PIEA). The obtained ploidy-related gene signatures were verified using the data gained from polyploid and diploid populations of early cardiomyocytes (CARD) originating from iPSC. The multistep bioinformatic analysis applied to the cancer cells, MSC, and CARD indicated that polyploidy plays a pivotal role in driving the cell into hypertranscription. It was evident from the upregulation of gene modules implicated in housekeeping functions, stemness, unicellularity, DNA repair, and chromatin opening by means of histone acetylation operating via DNA damage associated with the NUA4/TIP60 complex. These features were complemented by the activation of the pathways implicated in centrosome maintenance and ciliogenesis and by the impairment of the pathways related to apoptosis, the circadian clock, and immunity. Overall, our findings suggest that, although polyploidy does not induce oncologic transformation of MSC, it might compromise their therapeutic properties because of global epigenetic changes and alterations in fundamental biological processes. The obtained results can contribute to the development and implementation of approaches enhancing the therapeutic properties of MSC by removing polyploid cells from the cell population.

CINner: modeling and simulation of chromosomal instability in cancer at single-cell resolution

Cancer development is characterized by chromosomal instability, manifesting in frequent occurrences of different genomic alteration mechanisms ranging in extent and impact. Mathematical modeling can help evaluate the role of each mutational process during tumor progression, however existing frameworks can only capture certain aspects of chromosomal instability (CIN). We present CINner, a mathematical framework for modeling genomic diversity and selection during tumor evolution. The main advantage of CINner is its flexibility to incorporate many genomic events that directly impact cellular fitness, from driver gene mutations to copy number alterations (CNAs), including focal amplifications and deletions, missegregations and whole-genome duplication (WGD). We apply CINner to find chromosome-arm selection parameters that drive tumorigenesis in the absence of WGD in chromosomally stable cancer types. We found that the selection parameters predict WGD prevalence among different chromosomally unstable tumors, hinting that the selective advantage of WGD cells hinges on their tolerance for aneuploidy and escape from nullisomy. Direct application of CINner to model the WGD proportion and fraction of genome altered (FGA) further uncovers the increase in CNA probabilities associated with WGD in each cancer type. CINner can also be utilized to study chromosomally stable cancer types, by applying a selection model based on driver gene mutations and focal amplifications or deletions. Finally, we used CINner to analyze the impact of CNA probabilities, chromosome selection parameters, tumor growth dynamics and population size on cancer fitness and heterogeneity. We expect that CINner will provide a powerful modeling tool for the oncology community to quantify the impact of newly uncovered genomic alteration mechanisms on shaping tumor progression and adaptation.

The two sides of chromosomal instability: drivers and brakes in cancer

Chromosomal instability (CIN) is a hallmark of cancer and is associated with tumor cell malignancy. CIN triggers a chain reaction in cells leading to chromosomal abnormalities, including deviations from the normal chromosome number or structural changes in chromosomes. CIN arises from errors in DNA replication and chromosome segregation during cell division, leading to the formation of cells with abnormal number and/or structure of chromosomes. Errors in DNA replication result from abnormal replication licensing as well as replication stress, such as double-strand breaks and stalled replication forks; meanwhile, errors in chromosome segregation stem from defects in chromosome segregation machinery, including centrosome amplification, erroneous microtubule-kinetochore attachments, spindle assembly checkpoint, or defective sister chromatids cohesion. In normal cells, CIN is deleterious and is associated with DNA damage, proteotoxic stress, metabolic alteration, cell cycle arrest, and senescence. Paradoxically, despite these negative consequences, CIN is one of the hallmarks of cancer found in over 90% of solid tumors and in blood cancers. Furthermore, CIN could endow tumors with enhanced adaptation capabilities due to increased intratumor heterogeneity, thereby facilitating adaptive resistance to therapies; however, excessive CIN could induce tumor cells death, leading to the "just-right" model for CIN in tumors. Elucidating the complex nature of CIN is crucial for understanding the dynamics of tumorigenesis and for developing effective anti-tumor treatments. This review provides an overview of causes and consequences of CIN, as well as the paradox of CIN, a phenomenon that continues to perplex researchers. Finally, this review explores the potential of CIN-based anti-tumor therapy.

Whole-genome doubling is a double-edged sword: the heterogeneous role of whole-genome doubling in various cancer types

Whole-genome doubling (WGD), characterized by the duplication of an entire set of chromosomes, is commonly observed in various tumors, occurring in approximately 30-40% of patients with different cancer types. The effect of WGD on tumorigenesis varies depending on the context, either promoting or suppressing tumor progression. Recent advances in genomic technologies and large-scale clinical investigations have led to the identification of the complex patterns of genomic alterations underlying WGD and their functional consequences on tumorigenesis progression and prognosis. Our comprehensive review aims to summarize the causes and effects of WGD on tumorigenesis, highlighting its dualistic influence on cancer cells. We then introduce recent findings on WGD-associated molecular signatures and genetic aberrations and a novel subtype related to WGD. Finally, we discuss the clinical implications of WGD in cancer subtype classification and future therapeutic interventions. Overall, a comprehensive understanding of WGD in cancer biology is crucial to unraveling its complex role in tumorigenesis and identifying novel therapeutic strategies. [BMB Reports 2024; 57(3): 125-134].

Functional consequences of somatic polyploidy in development

Polyploid cells contain multiple genome copies and arise in many animal tissues as a regulated part of development. However, polyploid cells can also arise due to cell division failure, DNA damage or tissue damage. Although polyploidization is crucial for the integrity and function of many tissues, the cellular and tissue-wide consequences of polyploidy can be very diverse. Nonetheless, many polyploid cell types and tissues share a remarkable similarity in function, providing important information about the possible contribution of polyploidy to cell and tissue function. Here, we review studies on polyploid cells in development, underlining parallel functions between different polyploid cell types, as well as differences between developmentally-programmed and stress-induced polyploidy.

Aneuploidy and complex genomic rearrangements in cancer evolution

Mutational processes that alter large genomic regions occur frequently in developing tumors. They range from simple copy number gains and losses to the shattering and reassembly of entire chromosomes. These catastrophic events, such as chromothripsis, chromoplexy and the formation of extrachromosomal DNA, affect the expression of many genes and therefore have a substantial effect on the fitness of the cells in which they arise. In this review, we cover large genomic alterations, the mechanisms that cause them and their effect on tumor development and evolution.

Cell cycle gene alterations associate with a redistribution of mutation risk across chromosomal domains in human cancers

Mutations in human cells exhibit increased burden in heterochromatic, late DNA replication time (RT) chromosomal domains, with variation in mutation rates between tissues mirroring variation in heterochromatin and RT. We observed that regional mutation risk further varies between individual tumors in a manner independent of cell type, identifying three signatures of domain-scale mutagenesis in >4,000 tumor genomes. The major signature reflects remodeling of heterochromatin and of the RT program domains seen across tumors, tissues and cultured cells, and is robustly linked with higher expression of cell proliferation genes. Regional mutagenesis is associated with loss of activity of the tumor-suppressor genes RB1 and TP53, consistent with their roles in cell cycle control, with distinct mutational patterns generated by the two genes. Loss of regional heterogeneity in mutagenesis is associated with deficiencies in various DNA repair pathways. These mutation risk redistribution processes modify the mutation supply towards important genes, diverting the course of somatic evolution.

Cancer Evolution: A Multifaceted Affair

Cancer cells adapt and survive through the acquisition and selection of molecular modifications. This process defines cancer evolution. Building on a theoretical framework based on heritable genetic changes has provided insights into the mechanisms supporting cancer evolution. However, cancer hallmarks also emerge via heritable nongenetic mechanisms, including epigenetic and chromatin topological changes, and interactions between tumor cells and the tumor microenvironment. Recent findings on tumor evolutionary mechanisms draw a multifaceted picture where heterogeneous forces interact and influence each other while shaping tumor progression. A comprehensive characterization of the cancer evolutionary toolkit is required to improve personalized medicine and biomarker discovery.

SIGNIFICANCE

Tumor evolution is fueled by multiple enabling mechanisms. Importantly, genetic instability, epigenetic reprogramming, and interactions with the tumor microenvironment are neither alternative nor independent evolutionary mechanisms. As demonstrated by findings highlighted in this perspective, experimental and theoretical approaches must account for multiple evolutionary mechanisms and their interactions to ultimately understand, predict, and steer tumor evolution.

Whole-genome doubling in tissues and tumors

The overwhelming majority of proliferating somatic human cells are diploid, and this genomic state is typically maintained across successive cell divisions. However, failures in cell division can induce a whole-genome doubling (WGD) event, in which diploid cells transition to a tetraploid state. While some WGDs are developmentally programmed to produce nonproliferative tetraploid cells with specific cellular functions, unscheduled WGDs can be catastrophic: erroneously arising tetraploid cells are ill-equipped to cope with their doubled cellular and chromosomal content and quickly become genomically unstable and tumorigenic. Deciphering the genetics that underlie the genesis, physiology, and evolution of whole-genome doubled (WGD+) cells may therefore reveal therapeutic avenues to selectively eliminate pathological WGD+ cells.

An Emerging Animal Model for Querying the Role of Whole Genome Duplication in Development, Evolution, and Disease

Whole genome duplication (WGD) or polyploidization can occur at the cellular, tissue, and organismal levels. At the cellular level, tetraploidization has been proposed as a driver of aneuploidy and genome instability and correlates strongly with cancer progression, metastasis, and the development of drug resistance. WGD is also a key developmental strategy for regulating cell size, metabolism, and cellular function. In specific tissues, WGD is involved in normal development (e.g., organogenesis), tissue homeostasis, wound healing, and regeneration. At the organismal level, WGD propels evolutionary processes such as adaptation, speciation, and crop domestication. An essential strategy to further our understanding of the mechanisms promoting WGD and its effects is to compare isogenic strains that differ only in their ploidy. Caenorhabditis elegans (C. elegans) is emerging as an animal model for these comparisons, in part because relatively stable and fertile tetraploid strains can be produced rapidly from nearly any diploid strain. Here, we review the use of Caenorhabditis polyploids as tools to understand important developmental processes (e.g., sex determination, dosage compensation, and allometric relationships) and cellular processes (e.g., cell cycle regulation and chromosome dynamics during meiosis). We also discuss how the unique characteristics of the C. elegans WGD model will enable significant advances in our understanding of the mechanisms of polyploidization and its role in development and disease.

Whole-Genome Doubling as a source of cancer: how, when, where, and why?

Chromosome instability is a well-known hallmark of cancer, leading to increased genetic plasticity of tumoral cells, which favors cancer aggressiveness, and poor prognosis. One of the main sources of chromosomal instability are events that lead to a Whole-Genome Duplication (WGD) and the subsequently generated cell polyploidy. In recent years, several studies showed that WGD occurs at the early stages of cell transformation, which allows cells to later become aneuploid, thus leading to cancer progression. On the other hand, other studies convey that polyploidy plays a tumor suppressor role, by inducing cell cycle arrest, cell senescence, apoptosis, and even prompting cell differentiation, depending on the tissue cell type. There is still a gap in understanding how cells that underwent WGD can overcome the deleterious effect on cell fitness and evolve to become tumoral. Some laboratories in the chromosomal instability field recently explored this paradox, finding biomarkers that modulate polyploid cells to become oncogenic. This review brings a historical view of how WGD and polyploidy impact cell fitness and cancer progression, and bring together the last studies that describe the genes helping cells to adapt to polyploidy.