Stable isotopic evidence of nitrogen sources and C4 metabolism driving the world's largest macroalgal green tides in the Yellow Sea

A new set of N isotopic reference values for monitoring Ulva green tides in coral reef ecosystems

Green tides occurrence has increased in coral reefs, yet few reference values have been documented to support bloom management in these ecosystems. Here, we took advantage of recent Ulva green tides that occurred in New Caledonia to (i) identify the elements limiting the growth of Ulva spp. during these blooms; and (ii) validate the use of isotopic markers for identifying sources of nutrients that generated blooms. N/P ratios highlighted a stronger limitation of algae by phosphorus than by nitrogen on sites under oceanic influence, while the proportions of N and P were optimal for algal growth at sites where green tides occurred. Macroalgae highly exposed to sewage water was characterized by higher δ15N than macroalgae collected in areas exposed to synthetic inorganic fertilizers. From these results, we established a new set of threshold values for using δ15N in Ulva species as an indicator of nitrogen source type in coral reefs.

Estimating Ulva prolifera green tides of the Yellow Sea through ConvLSTM data fusion

Green tides, a worldwide problem, are harmful to aquaculture, tourism, marine ecosystems, and maritime traffic. Currently, green tide detection relies on remote sensing (RS) images, which are often missing or unusable. Thus, the observation and detection of green tides cannot be performed daily, which makes it difficult to improve environmental quality and ecological health. To address this problem, this study proposed a novel green tide estimation framework (GTEF) through convolutional long short-term memory, which learned the historical spatial-temporal seasonal and trend patterns of green tides from 2008 to 2021 and fused the previously observed or estimated data and biological (optional) and physical (optional) data over the preceding seven days when RS images were absent or unusable for daily observation and detection tasks. The results showed that the overall accuracy (OA), false-alarm rating (FAR), and missing-alarm rating (MAR) of the GTEF were 0.9592 ± 0.0375, 0.0885 ± 0.1877 and 0.4315 ± 0.2848, respectively. The estimated results described the green tides in terms of attributes, geometry and position features. Especially in the latitudinal features, the Pearson correlation coefficient of the predicted data and observed data were over 0.8 (P < 0.05), which showed a strong correlation. In addition, this study also discussed the role of biological and physical factors in the GTEF. Sea surface salinity may be the dominant factor in the early stages of green tides; in the late stage, solar irradiance may be the dominant factor. Sea surface winds and sea surface currents also played a significant role in green tide estimation. Results showed the OA, FAR and MAR of the GTEF which, with physical factors but without biological factors, were 0.9556 ± 0.0389, 0.1311 ± 0.3338 and 0.4297 ± 0.3180, respectively. In short, the proposed approach could generate a daily map of green tides, even if RS images were missing or unusable.

The drifting and spreading mechanism of floating Ulva mass in the waterways of Subei shoal, the Yellow Sea of China - Application for abating the world's largest green tides

The large-scale green tides have been prevailing in the Yellow Sea over a decade. Prevention and control techniques in the source region (Subei Shoal) are urgently needed to minimize its adverse ecological and social impacts. Drifting and spreading mechanism of Ulva mass was investigated in the Subei Shoal in order to develop the early containment measures. The multidisciplinary surveys suggested twelve major waterways transporting the initial Ulva mass which was closely related to the basin topology and water circulation in the shoal. The epiphytic algal mass from the northern and eastern raft regions contributed 82.7 % of the initial floating biomass, and moved out in 4-6 days with an average drifting velocity of 0.28 m s^-1. Accordingly, two series of algae-blocking lines were proposed to remove floating mass from the shoal. And the primary field trial in 2018 confirmed the feasibility of this strategy to abate the green tides.

Dead molluscan shells from multiple trophic groups as archives of nitrogen isotopic evidence of wastewater gradients in estuaries

Increased coastal urbanization worldwide has resulted in increased nitrogen inputs to ecosystems, leading to eutrophication and other negative effects. We assessed δ¹⁵N in the dead-collected shells of three molluscan species in two estuaries in order to evaluate their ability to identify known gradients in wastewater nitrogen input, namely from private septic systems feeding directly into Waquoit Bay and from a groundwater plume reflecting wastewater injection at a municipal treatment plant in West Falmouth Harbor, Massachusetts, USA. Shells of a suspension-feeder (Geukensia demissa), a micro-algal grazer (Littorina littorea), and an omnivore (Nassarius obsoletus) were collected from lower intertidal sediments near the taxon's life habitat. We found that δ¹⁵N in dead-collected shells decreased significantly along the gradients of wastewater pollution in both estuaries, with similar results across all three trophic groups. These positive results demonstrate the potential of dead-shell assemblages for detecting spatial gradients of wastewater pollution.

Activated abscisic acid pathway and C4 pathway, inhibited cell cycle progression, responses of Ulva prolifera to short term high temperature elucidated by multi-omics

The annual outbreak of green tides since 2007 has destroyed coastal waters' ecological environment and caused substantial economic losses. Ulva prolifera, known as the dominant species of green tides, is influenced by temperatures. Omics-based technology was used to analyze U. prolifera under 12 h of treatment at 30 °C in the work. High temperature has the following advantages, e.g., activating the abscisic acid signaling pathway, improving the heat tolerance of U. prolifera, up-regulating metabolites such as glycolipids, glyceroyl, and glutamic acid to maintain the stability and fluidity of cells, and reducing the stimulatory effect of external stress on cells. The key genes and proteins of the tricarboxylic acid cycle, glycolysis, and pentose phosphorylation pathways were inhibited; however, the key enzyme pyruvate phospho-dikinase of the C4 pathway was up-regulated. The C4 pathway was activated in U. prolifera in response to high-temperature stress and may play a key role in photosynthesis. Besides, U. prolifera metabolizing amino acids was active. High temperature inhibited genes and proteins related to DNA replication and cell cycle in the transcriptome and proteome as well as the growth and reproduction of U. prolifera.

Assessment of global habitat suitability and risk of ocean green tides

Green tides, which are widespread problems, are harmful issues that affect the protection of ocean ecosystems and natural resources. Scientific assessment and prevention of the green tides are essential for sustainable planning and the utilization of maritime traffic, tourism, and industry. However, the suitable or risk habitats and their dominant factors of green tides from global perspective are unknown. Here, this study proposed a novel framework to show the habitat suitability and risk of ocean green tides by considering marine environmental factors (i.e., sea surface temperature, sea surface salinity, solar irradiance, chlorophyll-a concentration, and sea surface wind). Through global remote sensing images and marine environmental factor data, this study found that (1) suitable and at-risk green tides areas are located in the north and south temperate zones; (2) marine physical factors are expected to weaken the green tide risk globally and enhance the green tide risk in coastal areas; (3) the green tides in the North Atlantic Ocean and the West Pacific Ocean are dominated by environmental factors and physical factors, respectively; and (4) when reducing carbon to promote sustainability, more potentially suitable green tide areas may appear at high latitudes. The results demonstrate the at-risk location and future trend of green tides, which are helpful for sustainable planning of ocean ecosystems.

Ulva macroalgae within local aquaculture ponds along the estuary of Dagu River, Jiaozhou Bay, Qingdao

Green macroalgal blooms caused by Ulva species have influenced the Shandong Province for 15 consecutive years since 2007, leading to serious damage to the marine environment. Great biomasses of attached Ulva prolifera on Neopyropia aquaculture rafts in the Yellow Sea were considered as sources of blooms. However, it is still unclear whether U. prolifera could survive and settle in the Qingdao coastal environment, Shandong, thus leading to local Ulva blooms in the future. In this research, sampling of Ulva macroalgae in seven Portunus trituberculatus aquaculture ponds along the coast of Qingdao was conducted on August 21, 2019. In total, 24 samples collected from the ponds were analyzed through methods of molecular biological identification (ITS, 5S, and rps2-trnL sequences) and genetic analysis. All the aquaculture ponds contained large amounts of floating Ulva macroalgae, which consisted of three species: U. prolifera, Ulva meridionalis, and Ulva pertusa. Among these species, U. meridionalis, which is usually found in southern Japan, also causes the green tide. In addition, all Ulva macroalgae floated on the surfaces of aquaculture ponds, and were discarded into the local coastal area by aquaculturist. This research raised our awareness of the importance of controlling the spread of the green tide related macroalgae.

Assessing Herbivorous Impacts of Apohale sp. on the Ulva prolifera Green Tide in China

An epiphytic gammarid species, Apohyale sp. , was abundant in the floating Ulva prolifera (U. prolifera), which forms large-scale green tides in the Yellow Sea (YSGT). Field observation and laboratory experiments were subsequently conducted to study the species identity, abundance, and grazing effects on the floating algal biomass. The abundance of Apohyale sp. showed great spatial variation and varied from 0.03 to 1.47 inds g^-1 in the YSGT. In average, each gram of Apohyale sp. body mass can consume 0.43 and 0.60 g algal mass of U. prolifera per day, and the grazing rates varied among the algae cultured with different nutritional seawaters. It was estimated that grazing of Apohale sp. could efficiently reduce ~0.4 and 16.6% of the algal growth rates in Rudong and Qingdao, respectively. The U. prolifera fragments resulting from gnawing of Apohyale sp. had a higher growth rate and similar photosynthetic activities compared to the floating algae, indicating probably positive feedback on the floating algal biomass. This research corroborated the significant impact of Apohyale sp. on the floating algal mass of YSGT through the top-down control. However, further research is needed to understand the population dynamics of these primary predators and hence their correlation with the expansion or decline of YSGT, especially under the complex food webs in the southern Yellow Sea.

Harmful macroalgal blooms (HMBs) in China's coastal water: Green and golden tides

Harmful macroalgal blooms (HMBs) have been increasing along China's coasts, causing significant social impacts and economic losses. Besides extensive eutrophication sustaining coastal seaweed tides, the stimuli and dynamics of macroalgal blooms in China are quite complex and require comprehensive studies. This review summarizes the distinct genesis, development and drifting patterns of three HMBs that have persistently occurred in China's coastal waters during recent years: transregional green tides of drifting Ulva prolifera in the Yellow Sea (YS), local green tides of multiple suspended seaweeds in the Bohai Sea and large-scale golden tides of pelagic Sargassum horneri in the YS and East China Sea. While specific containment measures have been developed and implemented to effectively suppress large-scale green tides in the YS, the origin and blooming mechanism of golden tides remain unclear due to lack of field research. With the broad occurrence of HMBs and their increased accumulation on beaches and coastal waters, it is necessary to investigate the blooming mechanism and ecological impacts of these HMBs, especially with the growing stresses of climate change and anthropogenic disturbances.

Evaluating bloom potential of the green-tide forming alga Ulva ohnoi under ocean acidification and warming

The occurrence of green-tides, whose bloom potential may be increased by various human activities and biogeochemical process, results in enormous economic losses and ecosystem collapse. In this study, we investigated the ecophysiology of the subtropical green-tide forming alga, Ulva ohnoi complex (hereafter: U. ohnoi), under simulated future ocean conditions in order to predict its bloom potential using photosynthesis and growth measurements, and stable isotope analyses. Our mesocosm system included four experimental conditions that simulated the individual and combined effects of elevated CO₂ and temperature, namely control (450 μatm CO₂ & 20 °C), acidification (900 μatm CO₂ & 20 °C), warming (450 μatm CO₂ & 25 °C), and greenhouse (900 μatm CO₂ & 25 °C). Photosynthetic electron transport rates (rETR) increased significantly under acidification conditions, but net photosynthesis and growth were not affected. In contrast, rETR, net photosynthesis, and growth all decreased significantly under elevated temperature conditions (i.e. both warming and greenhouse). These results represent the imbalance of energy metabolism between electron transport and O₂ production that may be expected under ocean acidification conditions. This imbalance appears to be related to carbon and nitrogen assimilation by U. ohnoi. In particular, ¹³C and ¹⁵N discrimination data suggest U. ohnoi prefers CO₂ and NH₄⁺ over HCO₃^- and NO₃^- as sources of carbon and nitrogen, respectively, and this results in increased N content in the thallus under ocean acidification conditions. Together, our results suggest a trade-off in which the bloom potential of U. ohnoi could increase under ocean acidification due to greater N accumulation and through the saving of energy during carbon and nitrogen metabolism, but that elevated temperatures could decrease U. ohnoi's bloom potential through a decrease in photosynthesis and growth.

Effects of salinity and nutrients on metabolism and growth of Ulva lactuca: Implications for bioremediation of coastal watersheds

We studied Ulva lactuca to determine its potential for bioremediation of coastal watersheds. We cultured Ulva in orthogonal combinations of two salinities and three nutrient concentrations for six weeks, and then measured its growth, photosynthesis, chlorophyll fluorescence, nitrogen, carbon and phosphorus tissue concentrations, and carbon and nitrogen uptake pathways. Our findings show that Ulva was negatively affected by decreased salinity but these effects were ameliorated by the addition of nutrients to the water, such as would be expected from freshwater runoff during heavy rain events. Also, increased nutrients resulted in altered nitrogen (NH₄⁺ vs. NO₃^-) and carbon (HCO₃^- vs. CO₂) uptake pathways, which can allow Ulva to retain its bloom potential even under reduced salinities. Together, our study suggests that Ulva is an ideal species to grow for the purpose of bioremediation of coastal bays and estuaries, even during storms that freshen the surface waters and increase nutrients.

Nitrogen enrichment mediates the effects of high temperature on the growth, photosynthesis, and biochemical constituents of Gracilaria blodgettii and Gracilaria lemaneiformis

Gracilaria blodgettii and Gracilaria lemaneiformis are often adopted as tools to purify aquaculture tail water. However, there has been such phenomenon that high temperature in summer restricts the process of aquaculture. To explore the adaptive capacity of G. blodgettii and G. lemaneiformis, we experimented them and cultured for 12 days under three temperatures (20, 25, and 30 °C) and three levels of multiple nitrogen sources (0.12, 0.6 and 4.4 mg L-1). Their growth, photosynthetic characteristics, and biochemical compositions including the contents of pigments and soluble protein were determined to investigate the single and interactive effects of temperatures and nitrogen levels on these two species. The results showed that in terms of G. blodgettii, the higher growth rate and more pigment (chlorophyll a and carotenoids) contents were observed at 25 and 30 °C in comparison to 20 °C, and the pigments showed maximum contents at 25 °C. More nitrogen improved the growth rate, net photosynthetic rate (Pn) at 25 and 30 °C, Fv/Fm at 20 °C, maximal photosynthetic electron transfer rate (ETRm), as well as soluble protein content at 20 and 25 °C. Additionally, the growth rate, Pn, and ETRm of G. lemaneiformis all showed a decline as increasing temperature; analogously high nitrogen concentration increased the growth rate at 25 and 30 °C, Fv/Fm at each temperature, ETRm, and pigments contents at 20 °C, as well as soluble protein content at 20 and 25 °C. Conclusions indicated that high temperature restricted the growth rate, inhibited photosynthetic characteristics, and decreased the soluble protein content of G. lemaneiformis. The reduced photosynthetic performance, pigments, and soluble protein contents of G. blodgettii were noted under similar conditions. However, nitrogen enrichment induced the greater resistant level to high temperature, and G. blodgettii showed better response. These findings suggested that these two Gracilaria species possessed a certain adaptability to tail water from aquaculture at high temperature and G. blodgettii can resist more to. Therefore, it seems to be an alternative and workable scheme to adopt some suitable macroalgae to optimize the solution to present purification of aquaculture wastewater or eutrophic waters under high temperature.

Photosynthetic responses of Halimeda scabra (Chlorophyta, Bryopsidales) to interactive effects of temperature, pH, and nutrients and its carbon pathways

In this study, we evaluated the interactive effects of temperature, pH, and nutrients on photosynthetic performance in the calcareous tropical macroalga Halimeda scabra. A significant interaction among these factors on gross photosynthesis (P_gross) was found. The highest values of P_gross were reached at the highest temperature, pH, and nutrient enrichment tested and similarly in the control treatment (no added nutrients) at 33 °C at the lowest pH. The Q₁₀P_gross values confirmed the effect of temperature only under nutrient enrichment scenarios. Besides the above, bicarbonate (HCO₃⁻) absorption was assessed by the content of carbon stable isotope (δ¹³C) in algae tissue and by its incorporation into photosynthetic products, as well as by carbonic anhydrase (CA) inhibitors (Acetazolamide, AZ and Ethoxyzolamide, EZ) assays. The labeling of δ¹³C revealed this species uses both, CO₂ and HCO₃⁻ forms of C_i relying on a CO₂ Concentration Mechanism (CCM). These results were validated by the EZ-AZ inhibition assays in which photosynthesis inhibition was observed, indicating the action of internal CA, whereas AZ inhibitor did not affect maximum photosynthesis (P_max). The incorporation of ¹³C isotope into aspartate in light and dark treatments also confirmed photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic the HCO₃⁻uptake.

Role of C4 carbon fixation in Ulva prolifera, the macroalga responsible for the world's largest green tides

Most marine algae preferentially assimilate CO₂ via the Calvin-Benson Cycle (C₃) and catalyze HCO₃⁻ dehydration via carbonic anhydrase (CA) as a CO₂-compensatory mechanism, but certain species utilize the Hatch-Slack Cycle (C₄) to enhance photosynthesis. The occurrence and importance of the C₄ pathway remains uncertain, however. Here, we demonstrate that carbon fixation in Ulva prolifera, a species responsible for massive green tides, involves a combination of C₃ and C₄ pathways_, and a CA-supported HCO₃⁻ mechanism. Analysis of CA and key C₃ and C₄ enzymes, and subsequent analysis of δ¹³C photosynthetic products showed that the species assimilates CO₂ predominately via the C₃ pathway, uses HCO₃⁻ via the CA mechanism at low CO₂ levels, and takes advantage of high irradiance using the C₄ pathway. This active and multi-faceted carbon acquisition strategy is advantageous for the formation of massive blooms, as thick floating mats are subject to intense surface irradiance and CO₂ limitation.

Liu et al. present evidence that carbon fixation in Ulva prolifera takes place via a combination of C₃ and C₄ pathways in combination with the enzyme carbonic anhydrase. The active and multi-faceted carbon acquisition strategy in U. prolifera is advantageous for the formation of massive blooms as the thick floating mats are subject to intense surface irradiance and CO₂ limitation.

An anomalous bi-macroalgal bloom caused by Ulva and Sargassum seaweeds during spring to summer of 2017 in the western Yellow Sea, China

An unprecedented bi-macroalgal bloom caused by Ulva prolifera and Sargassum horneri occurred from spring to summer of 2017 in the western Yellow Sea (YS) of China, where annual large-scale green tides have prevailed for a decade. The distinct genesis and blooming dynamics of the two seaweed species were detected and described. Unlike the consistent raft-origin of the floating Ulva biomass, the massive pelagic S. horneri was derived from multiple sources (residual seaweeds from the previous winter bloom and those drifting from offshore water in the south). The scale of the green tide in 2017 was found smaller than the previous four years. We then discussed a number of hypotheses attributing to this reduction, including reduced epiphytic green algae from aquaculture rafts and the influences of the massive pelagic S. horneri. However, further research is needed to identify the origin of the pelagic S. horneri in the western YS and any affiliations with the benthic populations, and to elucidate the interactions of this species with the annual green tides and the ensuing consequences.

Salinity mediates the effects of nitrogen enrichment on the growth, photosynthesis, and biochemical composition of Ulva prolifera

To study the combined effects of multiple nitrogen (N) sources and salinity on the growth and physiology on macroalgae, we cultured Ulva prolifera under three N levels (N₀, 0.1235 mg L^-1; N₁, 0.6 mg L^-1; and N₂, 4.4 mg L^-1; the ratios were 18:74:8 for NH₄-N, NO₃-N, and NO₂-N, respectively) and three salinity conditions (15, 25, and 35). Then, the growth, pigment content, photosynthetic performance, superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity, and contents of soluble protein and carbohydrates were measured. The results showed the following: (1) Compared to that grown at salinity 25, the growth of U. prolifera decreased under salinity 35, especially under the N₀ and N₂ levels, but there were no significant effects of salinity 15 under any of the N levels. (2) There were no significant effects of salinity on the chlorophyll a (Chla) content, but compared to the content at salinity 25, the chlorophyll b (Chlb) content was enhanced by salinity 15 and 35; lower ratio values between Chla and carotenoids (Car) occurred under the salinity 25 treatment. Under each salinity condition, the pigments were enhanced by a high N level. (3) A relatively higher salinity level decreased the photosynthetic oxygen evolution rate, while a higher N level increased this value. Compared to the rate at salinity 25, the dark respiration rate (R_d) significantly increased at salinity 15 under the N₀ condition. (4) SOD activity was enhanced by a high N level, but no significant effects of salinity were observed. (5) The carbohydrate content was enhanced at salinity 35 under the N₀ and N₁ levels, and under salinity 15, this value increased with increasing N levels. In conclusion, although the growth of U. prolifera decreased at high N levels under high salinity conditions, a high N level induced an increase in photosynthesis, while no significant decrease in growth occurred. These findings indicate that low salinity and high N levels may be nonnegligible reasons why this species thrives, and low salinity was the better choice when this species was used for wastewater treatment.

Eutrophication in a semi-desert coastal ecosystem promotes increases in N and C isotopic signatures and changes in primary sources

Using C and N isotopic signatures of food web components, we evaluated the land-marine coupling through nutrient flows and the likely changes in the food web structure in tidal channels with contrasting anthropogenic nutrient inputs at a semi desert-macrotidal coastal system (northern Argentine Patagonia). The results showed an increase in the δ¹³C signatures of primary producers and in the δ¹⁵N signatures in all levels of the benthic food web, from primary producers to predators, with possible changes in the relative contribution of primary food sources for consumer in the tidal channel with high anthropogenic N input. This is an example on the extent of the distribution of anthropogenic N into natural systems, flowing through the food web from terrestrial origin to coastal marine components.