In-depth analysis of Bacillus subtilis proteome identifies new ORFs and traces the evolutionary history of modified proteins

Molecular characterization of an endophytic strain of Bacillus subtilis with plant growth-promoting properties from a wild relative of papaya

AIM

Bacillus subtilis is usually found in soil, and their biocontrol and plant growth-promoting capabilities are being explored more recently than ever. However, knowledge about metabolite production and genome composition of endophytic B. subtilis from seeds is limited. In the present study, B. subtilis EVCu15 strain isolated from the seeds of Vasconcellea cundinamarcensis (mountain papaya) was subjected to whole genome sequencing and detailed molecular and functional characterization.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Whole genome sequencing and sequence analysis of the endophytic bacterium from mountain papaya seed revealed that the bacterium was B. subtilis, strain EVCu15. The genomic sequence had more than 98% nucleotide similarity with two published whole genome sequences of B. subtilis strains. Some of the important secondary metabolite gene clusters involved in production of bioactive compounds such as surfactin, fengycin, plipastatin, bacillibactin, bacillaene, subtilomycin, subtilosin A, and bacilysin were identified from the whole genome sequence analysis. Genes encoding several plant growth-promoting metabolites, mostly involved in the nutrient metabolism, were identified in the bacterial genome. These included factors coding for nitrogen, phosphorus, iron, sulfur, potassium, and trehalose metabolism. Genes involved in auxin, riboflavin, acetoin biosynthesis, ACC deaminase activity, and xylan degradation were also identified. Proteomic analysis confirmed the biosynthesis and release of several bioactive secondary metabolites in the endophytic B. subtilis strain EVCu15. Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry-based profiling for hormones and vitamins identified extracellular secretion of several important plant growth-promoting compounds such as IAA, salicylic acid, zeatin, vitamin D1, D2, E, K1, and pyridoxine. The in vitro and in vivo studies with the endophytic B. subtilis against various plant pathogenic fungi showed moderate to high levels of resistance. The B. subtilis EVCu15 compared to B. amyloliquefaciens showed better control over the root-knot nematode Meloidogyne incognita, in terms of egg hatching inhibition and the mortality of J2 juveniles.

CONCLUSION

Overall, this study underscores the biocontrol and plant growth-promoting potential of B. subtilis EVCu15, an endophyte isolated from mountain papaya seeds. Genomic analysis revealed a significant proportion of genes linked to biocontrol and plant growth promotion, corroborating its efficacy against M. incognita and various plant pathogens in vitro and in greenhouse studies. Furthermore, the bacterium's ability to produce diverse bioactive compounds, including proteins, hormones, and vitamins, was confirmed, highlighting its complex interactions within the plant system.

Comparative Proteomics of Bacteria Under Stress Conditions

Bacteria are unicellular organisms with the ability to exist in the harshest of climate and cope with sub-optimal fluctuating environmental conditions. They accomplish this by modification of their internal cellular environment. When external conditions are varied, change in the cell is triggered at the transcriptional level, which usually leads to proteolysis and rewiring of the proteome. Changes in cellular homeostasis, modifications in proteome, and dynamics of such survival mechanisms can be studied using various scientific techniques. Our focus in this chapter would be on comparative proteomics of bacteria under stress conditions using approaches like 2D electrophoresis accompanied by N-terminal sequencing and recently, mass spectrometry. More than 170 such studies on bacteria have been accomplished till to date and involve analysis of whole cells as well as that of cellular fractions, i.e., outer membrane, inner membrane, cell envelope, cytoplasm, thylakoid, lipid bodies, etc. Similar studies conducted on gram-negative and gram-positive model organism, i.e., Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis, respectively, have been summarized. Vital information, hypothesis about conservation of stress-specific proteome, and conclusions are also presented in the light of research conducted over the last decades.

Acetylomics reveals an extensive acetylation diversity within Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Bacteria employ a myriad of regulatory mechanisms to adapt to the continuously changing environments that they face. They can, for example, use post-translational modifications, such as Nε-lysine acetylation, to alter enzyme activity. Although a lot of progress has been made, the extent and role of lysine acetylation in many bacterial strains remains uncharted. Here, we applied stable isotope labeling by amino acids in cell culture (SILAC) in combination with the immunoprecipitation of acetylated peptides and LC-MS/MS to measure the first Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 acetylome, revealing 1076 unique acetylation sites in 508 proteins. Next, we assessed interstrain acetylome differences within P. aeruginosa by comparing our PAO1 acetylome with two publicly available PA14 acetylomes, and postulate that the overall acetylation patterns are not driven by strain-specific factors. In addition, the comparison of the P. aeruginosa acetylome to 30 other bacterial acetylomes revealed that a high percentage of transcription related proteins are acetylated in the majority of bacterial species. This conservation could help prioritize the characterization of functional consequences of individual acetylation sites.

Whole proteome analysis of germinating and outgrowing Bacillus subtilis 168

In this study, we present a high-resolution dataset and bioinformatic analysis of the proteome of Bacillus subtilis 168 trp+ (BSB1) during germination and spore outgrowth. Samples were collected at 14 different time points (ranging from 0 to 130 min) in three biological replicates after spore inoculation into germination medium. A total of 2191 proteins were identified and categorized based on their expression kinetics. We observed four distinct clusters that were analyzed for functional categories and KEGG pathways annotations. The examination of newly synthesized proteins between successive time points revealed significant changes, particularly within the first 50 min. The dataset provides an information base that can be used for modeling purposes and inspire the design of new experiments.

Recent Contributions of Proteomics to Our Understanding of Reversible Nε-Lysine Acylation in Bacteria

Post-translational modifications (PTMs) have been extensively studied in both eukaryotes and prokaryotes. Lysine acetylation, originally thought to be a rare occurrence in bacteria, is now recognized as a prevalent and important PTM in more than 50 species. This expansion in interest in bacterial PTMs became possible with the advancement of mass spectrometry technology and improved reagents such as acyl-modification specific antibodies. In this Review, we discuss how mass spectrometry-based proteomic studies of lysine acetylation and other acyl modifications have contributed to our understanding of bacterial physiology, focusing on recently published studies from 2018 to 2023. We begin with a discussion of approaches used to study bacterial PTMs. Next, we discuss newly characterized acylomes, including acetylomes, succinylomes, and malonylomes, in different bacterial species. In addition, we examine proteomic contributions to our understanding of bacterial virulence and biofilm formation. Finally, we discuss the contributions of mass spectrometry to our understanding of the mechanisms of acetylation, both enzymatic and nonenzymatic. We end with a discussion of the current state of the field and possible future research avenues to explore.

Lysine Phoshoglycerylation Is Widespread in Bacteria and Overlaps with Acylation

Phosphoglycerylation is a non-enzymatic protein modification in which a phosphoglyceryl moiety is covalently bound to the ε-amino group of lysine. It is enriched in glycolytic enzymes from humans and mice and is thought to provide a feedback mechanism for regulating glycolytic flux. We report the first proteomic analysis of this post-translational modification in bacteria by profiling phosphoglyceryl-lysine during the growth of Streptococcus pyogenes in different culture media. The identity of phosphoglyceryl-lysine was confirmed by a previously unknown diagnostic cyclic immonium ion generated during MS/MS. We identified 370 lysine phosphoglycerylation sites in 123 proteins of S. pyogenes. Growth in a defined medium on 1% fructose caused a significant accumulation of phosphoglycerylation compared to growth in a rich medium containing 0.2% glucose. Re-analysis of phosphoproteomes from 14 bacterial species revealed that phosphoglycerylation is generally widespread in bacteria. Many phosphoglycerylation sites were conserved in several bacteria, including S. pyogenes. There was considerable overlap between phosphoglycerylation, acetylation, succinylation, and other acylations on the same lysine residues. Despite some exceptions, most lysine phosphoglycerylations in S. pyogenes occurred with low stoichiometry. Such modifications may be meaningless, but it is also conceivable that phosphoglycerylation, acetylation, and other acylations jointly contribute to the overall regulation of metabolism.

Exploring Bacillus subtilis: Ecology, biotechnological applications, and future prospects

From its early identification by Christian Gottfried Ehrenberg to its current prominence in scientific research, Bacillus subtilis (B. subtilis) has emerged as a foundational model organism in microbiology. This comprehensive review delves deep into its genetic, physiological, and biochemical intricacies, revealing a sophisticated cellular blueprint. With the incorporation of advanced techniques such as clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats/CRISPR-associated protein 9 and integrative computational methodologies, the potential applications of B. subtilis span diverse sectors. These encompass its significant contributions to biotechnology, agriculture, and medical fields and its potential for aiding environmental cleanup efforts. Yet, as we move forward, we must grapple with concerns related to safety, ethics, and the practical implementation of our lab findings in everyday scenarios. As our understanding of B. subtilis deepens, it is evident that its contributions will be central to pioneering sustainable solutions for global challenges in the years to come.

Giving a signal: how protein phosphorylation helps Bacillus navigate through different life stages

Protein phosphorylation is a universal mechanism regulating a wide range of cellular responses across all domains of life. The antagonistic activities of kinases and phosphatases can orchestrate the life cycle of an organism. The availability of bacterial genome sequences, particularly Bacillus species, followed by proteomics and functional studies have aided in the identification of putative protein kinases and protein phosphatases, and their downstream substrates. Several studies have established the role of phosphorylation in different physiological states of Bacillus species as they pass through various life stages such as sporulation, germination, and biofilm formation. The most common phosphorylation sites in Bacillus proteins are histidine, aspartate, tyrosine, serine, threonine, and arginine residues. Protein phosphorylation can alter protein activity, structural conformation, and protein-protein interactions, ultimately affecting the downstream pathways. In this review, we summarize the knowledge available in the field of Bacillus signaling, with a focus on the role of protein phosphorylation in its physiological processes.

Deep Proteogenomics of a Photosynthetic Cyanobacterium

Cyanobacteria, the evolutionary ancestors of plant chloroplasts, contribute substantially to the Earth's biogeochemical cycles and are of great interest for a sustainable economy. Knowledge of protein expression is the key to understanding cyanobacterial metabolism; however, proteome studies in cyanobacteria are limited and cover only a fraction of the theoretical proteome. Here, we performed a comprehensive proteogenomic analysis of the model cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 to characterize the expressed (phospho)proteome, re-annotate known and discover novel open reading frames (ORFs). By mapping extensive shotgun mass spectrometry proteomics data onto a six-frame translation of the Synechocystis genome, we refined the genomic annotation of 64 ORFs, including eight completely novel ORFs. Our study presents the largest reported (phospho)proteome dataset for a unicellular cyanobacterium, covering the expression of about 80% of the theoretical proteome under various cultivation conditions, such as nitrogen or carbon limitation. We report 568 phosphorylated S/T/Y sites that are present on numerous regulatory proteins, including the transcriptional regulators cyAbrB1 and cyAbrB2. We also catalogue the proteins that have never been detected under laboratory conditions and found that a large portion of them is plasmid-encoded. This dataset will serve as a resource, providing dedicated information on growth condition-dependent protein expression and phosphorylation.

Taxonomically Restricted Genes in Bacillus may Form Clusters of Homologs and Can be Traced to a Large Reservoir of Noncoding Sequences

Taxonomically restricted genes (TRGs) are unique for a defined group of organisms and may act as potential genetic determinants of lineage-specific, biological properties. Here, we explore the TRGs of highly diverse and economically important Bacillus bacteria by examining commonly used TRG identification parameters and data sources. We show the significant effects of sequence similarity thresholds, composition, and the size of the reference database in the identification process. Subsequently, we applied stringent TRG search parameters and expanded the identification procedure by incorporating an analysis of noncoding and non-syntenic regions of non-Bacillus genomes. A multiplex annotation procedure minimized the number of false-positive TRG predictions and showed nearly one-third of the alleged TRGs could be mapped to genes missed in genome annotations. We traced the putative origin of TRGs by identifying homologous, noncoding genomic regions in non-Bacillus species and detected sequence changes that could transform these regions into protein-coding genes. In addition, our analysis indicated that Bacillus TRGs represent a specific group of genes mostly showing intermediate sequence properties between genes that are conserved across multiple taxa and nonannotated peptides encoded by open reading frames.

Growth rate is modulated by monitoring cell wall precursors in Bacillus subtilis

How bacteria link their growth rate to external nutrient conditions is unknown. To investigate how Bacillus subtilis cells alter the rate at which they expand their cell walls as they grow, we compared single-cell growth rates of cells grown under agar pads with the density of moving MreB filaments under a variety of growth conditions. MreB filament density increases proportionally with growth rate. We show that both MreB filament density and growth rate depend on the abundance of Lipid II and murAA, the first gene in the biosynthetic pathway creating the cell wall precursor Lipid II. Lipid II is sensed by the serine/threonine kinase PrkC, which phosphorylates RodZ and other proteins. We show that phosphorylated RodZ increases MreB filament density, which in turn increases cell growth rate. We also show that increasing the activity of this pathway in nutrient-poor media results in cells that elongate faster than wild-type cells, which means that B. subtilis contains spare 'growth capacity'. We conclude that PrkC functions as a cellular rheostat, enabling fine-tuning of cell growth rates in response to Lipid II in different nutrient conditions.

Sterilization effects of UV laser irradiation on Bacillus atrophaeus spore viability, structure, and proteins

Bacillus spores are highly resistant to toxic chemicals and extreme environments. Because some Bacillus species threaten public health, spore inactivation techniques have been intensively investigated. We exposed Bacillus atrophaeus spores to a 266 nm Nd:YVO₄ laser at a laser power of 1 W and various numbers of scans. As a result, the UV laser reduced the viability of Bacillus atrophaeus spores. Although the outer coat of spores remained intact after UV laser irradiation of 720 scans, damage inside the spores was observed. Spore proteins were identified by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry during the course of UV laser irradiation. Photochemical and photothermal processes are believed to be involved in the UV laser sterilization of Bacillus spores. Our findings suggest that a UV laser is capable of sterilizing Bacillus atrophaeus spores.

Modular and Single-Cell Sensors of Bacterial Ser/Thr Kinase Activity

At the single-cell level, protein kinase activity is typically inferred from downstream transcriptional reporters. However, promoters are often coregulated by several pathways, making the activity of a specific kinase difficult to deconvolve. Here, we present modular, direct, and specific sensors of bacterial kinase activity, including FRET-based sensors, as well as a synthetic transcription factor based on the lactose repressor (LacI) that has been engineered to respond to phosphorylation. We demonstrate the utility of these sensors in measuring the activity of PrkC, a conserved bacterial Ser/Thr kinase, in different growth conditions from single cells to colonies. We also show that PrkC activity increases in response to a cell-wall active antibiotic that blocks the late steps in peptidoglycan synthesis (cefotaxime), but not the early steps (fosfomycin). These sensors have a modular design that should generalize to other bacterial signaling systems in the future.

Engineering of Multiple Modules to Improve Amorphadiene Production in Bacillus subtilis Using CRISPR-Cas9

Engineering strategies to improve terpenoids' production in Bacillus subtilis mainly focus on 2C-methyl-d-erythritol-4-phosphate (MEP) pathway overexpression. To systematically engineer the chassis strain for higher amorphadiene (precursor of artemisinin) production, a clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat-Cas9 (CRISPR-Cas9) system was established in B. subtilis to facilitate precise and efficient genome editing. Then, this system was employed to engineer three more modules to improve amorphadiene production, including the terpene synthase module, the branch pathway module, and the central metabolic pathway module. Finally, our combination of all of the useful strategies within one strain significantly increased extracellular amorphadiene production from 81 to 116 mg/L after 48 h flask fermentation without medium optimization. For the first time, we attenuated the FPP-derived competing pathway to improve amorphadiene biosynthesis and investigated how the TCA cycle affects amorphadiene production in B. subtilis. Overall, this study provides a universal strategy for further increasing terpenoids' production in B. subtilis by comprehensive and systematic metabolic engineering.

Evolutionary Analysis of the Bacillus subtilis Genome Reveals New Genes Involved in Sporulation

Bacilli can form dormant, highly resistant, and metabolically inactive spores to cope with extreme environmental challenges. In this study, we examined the evolutionary age of Bacillus subtilis sporulation genes using the approach known as genomic phylostratigraphy. We found that B. subtilis sporulation genes cluster in several groups that emerged at distant evolutionary time-points, suggesting that the sporulation process underwent several stages of expansion. Next, we asked whether such evolutionary stratification of the genome could be used to predict involvement in sporulation of presently uncharacterized genes (y-genes). We individually inactivated a representative sample of uncharacterized genes that arose during the same evolutionary periods as the known sporulation genes and tested the resulting strains for sporulation phenotypes. Sporulation was significantly affected in 16 out of 37 (43%) tested strains. In addition to expanding the knowledge base on B. subtilis sporulation, our findings suggest that evolutionary age could be used to help with genome mining.

Comparison of Proteomic Responses as Global Approach to Antibiotic Mechanism of Action Elucidation

New antibiotics are urgently needed to address the mounting resistance challenge. In early drug discovery, one of the bottlenecks is the elucidation of targets and mechanisms. To accelerate antibiotic research, we provide a proteomic approach for the rapid classification of compounds into those with precedented and unprecedented modes of action. We established a proteomic response library of Bacillus subtilis covering 91 antibiotics and comparator compounds, and a mathematical approach was developed to aid data analysis.

New antibiotics are urgently needed to address the mounting resistance challenge. In early drug discovery, one of the bottlenecks is the elucidation of targets and mechanisms. To accelerate antibiotic research, we provide a proteomic approach for the rapid classification of compounds into those with precedented and unprecedented modes of action. We established a proteomic response library of Bacillus subtilis covering 91 antibiotics and comparator compounds, and a mathematical approach was developed to aid data analysis. Comparison of proteomic responses (CoPR) allows the rapid identification of antibiotics with dual mechanisms of action as shown for atypical tetracyclines. It also aids in generating hypotheses on mechanisms of action as presented for salvarsan (arsphenamine) and the antirheumatic agent auranofin, which is under consideration for repurposing. Proteomic profiling also provides insights into the impact of antibiotics on bacterial physiology through analysis of marker proteins indicative of the impairment of cellular processes and structures. As demonstrated for trans-translation, a promising target not yet exploited clinically, proteomic profiling supports chemical biology approaches to investigating bacterial physiology.

Henriques A. A protein phosphorylation module patterns the Bacillus subtilis spore outer coat

Assembly of the Bacillus subtilis spore coat involves over 80 proteins which self-organize into a basal layer, a lamellar inner coat, a striated electrodense outer coat and a more external crust. CotB is an abundant component of the outer coat. The C-terminal moiety of CotB, SKRB , formed by serine-rich repeats, is polyphosphorylated by the Ser/Thr kinase CotH. We show that another coat protein, CotG, with a central serine-repeat region, SKRG , interacts with the C-terminal moiety of CotB and promotes its phosphorylation by CotH in vivo and in a heterologous system. CotG itself is phosphorylated by CotH but phosphorylation is enhanced in the absence of CotB. Spores of a strain producing an inactive form of CotH, like those formed by a cotG deletion mutant, lack the pattern of electrondense outer coat striations, but retain the crust. In contrast, deletion of the SKRB region, has no major impact on outer coat structure. Thus, phosphorylation of CotG by CotH is a key factor establishing the structure of the outer coat. The presence of the cotB/cotH/cotG cluster in several species closely related to B. subtilis hints at the importance of this protein phosphorylation module in the morphogenesis of the spore surface layers.

Integrative characterization of the near-minimal bacterium Mesoplasma florum

The near-minimal bacterium Mesoplasma florum is an interesting model for synthetic genomics and systems biology due to its small genome (~ 800 kb), fast growth rate, and lack of pathogenic potential. However, fundamental aspects of its biology remain largely unexplored. Here, we report a broad yet remarkably detailed characterization of M. florum by combining a wide variety of experimental approaches. We investigated several physical and physiological parameters of this bacterium, including cell size, growth kinetics, and biomass composition of the cell. We also performed the first genome-wide analysis of its transcriptome and proteome, notably revealing a conserved promoter motif, the organization of transcription units, and the transcription and protein expression levels of all protein-coding sequences. We converted gene transcription and expression levels into absolute molecular abundances using biomass quantification results, generating an unprecedented view of the M. florum cellular composition and functions. These characterization efforts provide a strong experimental foundation for the development of a genome-scale model for M. florum and will guide future genome engineering endeavors in this simple organism.

Regulation of RNA processing and degradation in bacteria

Messenger RNA processing and decay is a key mechanism to control gene expression at the post-transcriptional level in response to ever-changing environmental conditions. In this review chapter, we discuss the main ribonucleases involved in these processes in bacteria, with a particular but non-exclusive emphasis on the two best-studied paradigms of Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria, E. coli and B. subtilis, respectively. We provide examples of how the activity and specificity of these enzymes can be modulated at the protein level, by co-factor binding and by post-translational modifications, and how they can be influenced by specific properties of their mRNA substrates, such as 5' protective 'caps', nucleotide modifications, secondary structures and translation. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: RNA and gene control in bacteria edited by Dr. M. Guillier and F. Repoila.

Combination of Proteogenomics with Peptide De Novo Sequencing Identifies New Genes and Hidden Posttranscriptional Modifications

Next-generation sequencing techniques have considerably increased the number of completely sequenced eukaryotic genomes. These genomes are mostly automatically annotated, and ab initio gene prediction is commonly combined with homology-based search approaches and often supported by transcriptomic data. The latter in particular improve the prediction of intron splice sites and untranslated regions. However, correct prediction of translation initiation sites (TIS), alternative splice junctions, and protein-coding potential remains challenging. Here, we present an advanced proteogenomics approach, namely, the combination of proteogenomics and de novo peptide sequencing analysis, in conjunction with Blast2GO and phylostratigraphy. Using the model fungus Sordaria macrospora as an example, we provide a comprehensive view of the proteome that not only increases the functional understanding of this multicellular organism at different developmental stages but also immensely enhances the genome annotation quality.

Proteogenomics combines proteomics, genomics, and transcriptomics and has considerably improved genome annotation in poorly investigated phylogenetic groups for which homology information is lacking. Furthermore, it can be advantageous when reinvestigating well-annotated genomes. Here, we applied an advanced proteogenomics approach, combining standard proteogenomics with peptide de novo sequencing, to refine annotation of the well-studied model fungus Sordaria macrospora. We investigated samples from different developmental and physiological conditions, resulting in the detection of 104 so-far hidden proteins and annotation changes in 575 genes, including 389 splice site refinements. Significantly, our approach provides peptide-level evidence for 113 single-amino-acid variations and 15 C-terminal protein elongations originating from A-to-I RNA editing, a phenomenon recently detected in fungi. Coexpression and phylostratigraphic analysis of the refined proteome suggest that new functions in evolutionarily young genes correlate with distinct developmental stages. In conclusion, our advanced proteogenomics approach supports and promotes functional studies of fungal model systems.

Mechanisms, Detection, and Relevance of Protein Acetylation in Prokaryotes

Posttranslational modification of a protein, either alone or in combination with other modifications, can control properties of that protein, such as enzymatic activity, localization, stability, or interactions with other molecules. N-ε-Lysine acetylation is one such modification that has gained attention in recent years, with a prevalence and significance that rival those of phosphorylation. This review will discuss the current state of the field in bacteria and some of the work in archaea, focusing on both mechanisms of N-ε-lysine acetylation and methods to identify, quantify, and characterize specific acetyllysines. Bacterial N-ε-lysine acetylation depends on both enzymatic and nonenzymatic mechanisms of acetylation, and recent work has shed light into the regulation of both mechanisms. Technological advances in mass spectrometry have allowed researchers to gain insight with greater biological context by both (i) analyzing samples either with stable isotope labeling workflows or using label-free protocols and (ii) determining the true extent of acetylation on a protein population through stoichiometry measurements. Identification of acetylated lysines through these methods has led to studies that probe the biological significance of acetylation. General and diverse approaches used to determine the effect of acetylation on a specific lysine will be covered.