Effective treatment of aquaculture wastewater with mussel/microalgae/bacteria complex ecosystem: a pilot study

Ammonia transformation by potential consortium in the aquatic system

In the present research, the removal of high concentration of ammonia, nitrite and nitrate was determined by using the efficient ammonia-oxidizing bacterial isolates (AOB AMS 1, AOB AMS 2, AOB AMS 5 and AOB AMSS 1) along with the consortium of all four bacterial isolates from the aquaculture both in lab-scale as well as in-situ at bioreactor level. It was found that the highest percentage of ammonia was degrade by AOB AMS 2 (99.64%± 5) followed by AOB AMS 5 (99.51%± 4.6), AOB AMSS 1 (99.38%± 5) and AOB AMS 1 (89.66%± 3.5) from an initial concentration of 30 mg/L whereas from an initial concentration of 60 mg/L, the removal rate of each strain was AOB AMS 5 (99.36%± 5), AOB AMSS 1 (99.15%± 5.60), AOB AMS 2 (98.78%± 5.3) and AOB AMS 1 (88.36%± 3.2) and their consortium removes (99.97%± 5.20)at 60 mg/L. Further, in-situ transformation was carried out in the river water with 5% of inoculum. Their growth was monitored (initial and final) by observing the colony forming unit (CFU) and transformation of ammonia and nitrite was also observed and it was found that (100 ± 2%)of ammonia was removed. The growth of consortium was 3 × 102CFU/ml on 1st day, 2.5 × 104 CFU/ml on 5th day and 4.2 × 105 CFU/ml on 10th day. This study proved that the bacterial consortium of AOB AMS 1, AOB AMS 2, AOB AMS 5 and AOB AMSS 1 was highly efficient for the removal of ammonia, nitrite and nitrate from the aquatic system to reduce the toxic level from aquaculture environment.Currently we observed the transformation efficiency at lab-scaleand in-situ level.

Innovative microalgae technologies for mariculture wastewater treatment: Single and combined microalgae treatment mechanisms, challenges and future prospects

The discharge of aquaculture wastewater, comprising nitrogen, phosphorus, heavy metals, and antibiotics from large-scale aquaculture, poses a significant threat to marine ecosystems and human health. Consequently, addressing the treatment of marine aquaculture wastewater is imperative. Conventional physicochemical treatment methods have various limitations, whereas microalgae-based biological treatment technologies have gained increasing attention in the field of water purification due to their ability to efficiently absorb organic matter from mariculture wastewater and convert CO₂ into biomass products. Microalgae offer potential for highly efficient and cost-effective mariculture wastewater treatment, with particularly noteworthy advancements in the application of combined microalgae technologies. This paper explores the research hotspots in this field through bibliometric analysis and systematically discusses the following aspects: (1) summarizing the current pollution status of mariculture wastewater, including the types and sources of pollutants in various forms of mariculture wastewater, treatment methods, and associated treatment efficiencies; (2) analyzing the factors contributing to the gradual replacement of single microalgae technology with combined microalgae technology, highlighting its synergistic effects, enhanced pollutant removal efficiencies, resource recovery potential, and alignment with sustainable development goals; (3) exploring the mechanisms of pollutant removal by combined microalgae technologies, focusing on their technical advantages in bacterial-algal coupling, immobilized microalgae systems, and microalgal biofilm technologies; (4) discussing the challenges faced by the three main categories of combined microalgae technologies and proposing future improvement strategies to further enhance their application effectiveness. In conclusion, this paper offers a detailed analysis of these emerging technologies, providing a forward-looking perspective on the future development of microalgae-based mariculture wastewater treatment solutions.

Utility of integrated papyrus-bivalve for bioremediation of aquaculture wastewater

Aquaculture generates substantial amount of residual feeds and faecal matter that accumulate in the culture environment and pollute effluent-receiving water, diminishing its ecological functioning. To devise means of treating nutrient-rich aquaculture wastewater, the efficiency of integrated papyrus-bivalve mesocosms in removing nutrients was evaluated. The mesocosms were fed on water (6600 L) from one brood-stock pond and allowed to settle for 2 weeks. Physico-chemical parameters, including nutrient level in influent and effluent of mesocosms, were analysed fortnightly using standard methods. The integrated papyrus-bivalve mesocosms had the highest removal of 69.5, 52.9, and 70.5% for total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), and total dissolved solids (TDS), respectively, from the aquaculture wastewater. The removal efficiency of TN and TDS by the mesocosms followed the order: integrated papyrus-bivalve ˃ papyrus ˃ bivalves ˃ control, and removal efficiency for TP followed a similar trend, albeit integrated papyrus-bivalve≈papyrus. The nutrient retention (g/DMm2) in papyrus biomass was 24.09 and 2.93 in integrated papyrus-bivalve mesocosm and 20.77 and 3.81 in papyrus mesocosms for nitrogen and phosphorus, respectively. Meanwhile, the nutrient retention in bivalve biomass was 3.06 and 0.44 in integrated papyrus-bivalve and 1.95 and 0.34 in bivalve mesocosm, for nitrogen and phosphorus, respectively. The study confirms the synergistic functionality of papyrus and bivalves in treating aquaculture wastewater. Papyrus and bivalves in the mesocosms contributed to the bioremediation of wastewater through physical and biochemical processes, including filtration, nutrient uptake, and attachment surfaces for microorganisms. Therefore, we recommend integrated papyrus-bivalve bioremediation technology to fish farmers and policy makers.

Using ozone nanobubbles, and microalgae to promote the removal of nutrients from aquaculture wastewater: Insights from the changes of microbiomes

Integrated aquaculture wastewater treatment systems (IAWTSs) are widely used in treating aquaculture wastewater with the aeration-microalgae unit serving as an important component. In this study, we artificially constructed an IAWTS and applied two aeration-microalgae methods: ordinary aeration or ozone nanobubbles (ONBs) with microalgae (Nannochloropsis oculata). The impact of N.oculata and ONBs on the removal performance of nutrients and the underlying micro-ecological mechanisms were investigated using 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing. The results demonstrated that the combined use of ONBs and N.oculata exhibited superior purification effects with 78.25%, 76.59% and 86.71% removal of CODMn, TN and TP. N.oculata played a pivotal role as the primary element in wastewater purification, while ONBs influenced nutrient dynamics by affecting both N.oculata and bacterial communities. N.oculata actively shaped bacterial communities, with a specific focus on nitrogen and phosphorus cycling in the micro-environment remodeled by ONBs. Rare bacterial communities displayed heightened activity in response to the changes in N.oculata, ONBs, and nutrient levels. These findings provide a novel approach to improve the technological processes the IAWTS, contributing to the advancement of sustainable aquaculture practices by offering valuable insights into wastewater purification efficiency and micro-ecological mechanisms.

Role of Nitrifiers Associated with Mangrove clam Polymesoda Erosa in Bioremediation

Polymesoda erosa is a mangrove clam known for its water filtration ability. This clam was investigated for its bioremediation potential and growth in synthetic wastewater during 40 days of incubation. Variation in the nutrient composition of water, biochemical composition of the clams, and metagenomic analysis of the microorganisms associated with clam tissue were carried out. Significant differences in the concentration of ammonia (p ≤ 0.01), nitrite (p ≤ 0.001), and nitrate (p ≤ 0.05) in the wastewater were observed between day 0 and day 40. A reduction of approximately 89% in ammonia concentration at the end of the experiment was recorded indicating nitrification activity. However, biochemical parameters showed negligible differences before and after the incubation experiment. Thus suggesting that the chemosynthetic-based nutrition aids in the survival of the clam as no organic matter was added to the medium. The substantial decline in levels of ammonia in the presence of clams as compared to its absence suggests the significant role of clams in improving the water quality. Furthermore, the metagenomic analysis of the gill tissue of P. erosa revealed ~ 50% of the microbial population to consist of nitrifiers. The study highlights the contribution by the nitrifers associated with the clams not only to its growth and resilience but also to bioremediation.

Biodegradability and bioavailability of dissolved substances in aquaculture effluent: Performance of indigenous bacteria, cyanobacteria, and green microalgae

Aquaculture is a controlled aquatic farming sector and one of the most important human food sources. Fish farming is one of the predominant, fast-growing sectors that supply seafood products worldwide. Along with its benefits, aquaculture practices can discharge large quantities of nutrients into the environment through non-treated or poorly treated wastewater. This study aims to understand the nutrient composition of fish wastewater and the use of indigenous bacteria, cyanobacteria, and microalgae as an alternative biological treatment method. Wastewater samples from a local fish farming facility were collected and treated using six different species of cyanobacteria and microalgae include Chroococcus minutus, Porphyridium cruentum, Chlorella vulgaris, Microcystis aeruginosa, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, and Fischerella muscicola. All the samples were incubated for 21 days, and the following parameters were measured weekly: Chemical oxygen demand (COD), phosphate, total dissolved nitrogen, and dissolved inorganic nitrogen. In addition, dissolved organic nitrogen (DON), bioavailable DON (ABDON), and biodegradable DON (BDON) were calculated from the mass-balance equations. Colorimetric and digestive methods were used for the parameter measurements. The results showed that C. reinhardtii reduced the soluble COD concentration by 74.6 %, DON by 94.3 %, and phosphorous by more than 99 %. Moreover, M. aeruginosa, and C. minutus significantly reduced inorganic nitrogen species (>99 %). This alternative fish wastewater treatment method was explored to gain insight into fish wastewater nutrient composition and to create a sustainable alternative to conventional fish wastewater treatment methods.

Insights of microalgal municipal wastewater treatment at low temperatures: Performance, microbiota patterns, and cold-adaptation of tubular and aeration column photobioreactors

In order to refine the treatment of microalgae consortium (MC) for municipal wastewater (MWW) during the winter, this study investigated the effectiveness of tubular and aeration column photobioreactors (TPBR and APBR) in wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) during winter by two start-up modes: microalgae/microalgae-activated sludge (AS). The operation results showed that under 5.7-13.1 °C, TPBR enhanced the assimilation of N and P pollutant by microalgal accumulation, meeting the Chinese discharge standard within 24 h (NH4+-N, TP, and COD ≤8.0, 0.5, and 50 mg·L-1). The microbial community profiles were identified and showed that inoculating AS under low-temperature still promoted bacterial interspecific association, but influenced by the inhibition of microbial diversity by the homogeneous circulation of TPBR, the nitrogen transfer function of MC was lower than that of APBR at low temperatures, except nitrogen fixation (K02588), nitrosification (K10944, K10945, and K10946), assimilatory nitrate reduction (K00366), and ammonification (K01915 and K05601). And the intermittent aeration in the APBR was still beneficial in increasing microbial diversity, which was more beneficial for reducing COD through microbial collaboration. In the treatment, the cryotolerant MGPM were Delftia, Romboutsia, Rhizobiales, and Bacillus, and the cold stress-related genes that were highly up-regulated were defense signaling molecules (K03671 and K00384), cold shock protein gene (K03704), and cellular protector (K01784) were present in both PBRs. This study provided a reference for the feasibility of the low temperature treatment of MC with the different types of PBR, which improved the application of wastewater treatment in more climatic environments.

Spatiotemporal variation of phytoplankton communities and water quality among seaweed, shellfish and cage fish culture systems

Various marine aquaculture systems have different impacts on the environment, but few assessments were focused on the environmental impact by different systems in the same region. To study the effects of various aquaculture systems on phytoplankton community structure and water properties, 5 surveys were carried out in seaweed (Gracilaria lemaneiformis, GL), shellfish (Mytilus coruscus, MC) and cage fish (Larimichthys crocea, LC) mariculture areas in Dongji island, Zhejiang, China from June to September 2020. Significant differences were observed in some environmental parameters and phytoplankton communities among three aquaculture systems. The dissolved oxygen concentrations and Secchi depth in the surface waters in GL area were relatively higher than in the blank and other areas. As for nutrients concentration, LC and MC areas had higher concentrations than blank area, while GL area was the lowest. Though Chlorophyll-a concentration displayed fluctuations, relatively lower concentrations were found in GL area. Shannon diversity index was found to be relatively constant and higher in GL area. The Non-metric multidimensional scaling results revealed that phytoplankton composition had a distinct pattern among sampling times. The correlations and Redundancy analysis showed that total nitrogen, salinity and transparency were primary environmental factors associated with phytoplankton composition. Our study confirmed that different marine aquaculture systems can cause environmental fluctuations. Among the three systems, seaweed cultivation can bring multiple positive effects by improving surrounding water quality and increasing the phytoplankton composition. G. lemaneiformis culture in summer has great positive impact on seawater environment as it can maintain the ecological balance and reduce the risk of harmful algal blooms (HABs), and therefore, it is strongly recommended more G. lemaneiformis cultivation in this region in summer.

Microalgae systems - environmental agents for wastewater treatment and further potential biomass valorisation

Water is the most valuable resource on the planet. However, massive anthropogenic activities generate threatening levels of biological, organic, and inorganic pollutants that are not efficiently removed in conventional wastewater treatment systems. High levels of conventional pollutants (carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus), emerging chemical contaminants such as antibiotics, and pathogens (namely antibiotic-resistant ones and related genes) jeopardize ecosystems and human health. Conventional wastewater treatment systems entail several environmental issues: (i) high energy consumption; (ii) high CO₂ emissions; and (iii) the use of chemicals or the generation of harmful by-products. Hence, the use of microalgal systems (entailing one or several microalgae species, and in consortium with bacteria) as environmental agents towards wastewater treatment has been seen as an environmentally friendly solution to remove conventional pollutants, antibiotics, coliforms and antibiotic resistance genes. In recent years, several authors have evaluated the use of microalgal systems for the treatment of different types of wastewater, such as agricultural, municipal, and industrial. Generally, microalgal systems can provide high removal efficiencies of: (i) conventional pollutants, up to 99%, 99%, and 90% of total nitrogen, total phosphorus, and/or organic carbon, respectively, through uptake mechanisms, and (ii) antibiotics frequently found in wastewaters, such as sulfamethoxazole, ciprofloxacin, trimethoprim and azithromycin at 86%, 65%, 42% and 93%, respectively, through the most desirable microalgal mechanism, biodegradation. Although pathogens removal by microalgal species is complex and very strain-specific, it is also possible to attain total coliform and Escherichia coli removal of 99.4% and 98.6%, respectively. However, microalgal systems' effectiveness strongly relies on biotic and abiotic conditions, thus the selection of operational conditions is critical. While the combination of selected species (microalgae and bacteria), ratios and inoculum concentration allow the efficient removal of conventional pollutants and generation of high amounts of biomass (that can be further converted into valuable products such as biofuels and biofertilisers), abiotic factors such as pH, hydraulic retention time, light intensity and CO₂/O₂ supply also have a crucial role in conventional pollutants and antibiotics removal, and wastewater disinfection. However, some rationale must be considered according to the purpose. While alkaline pH induces the hydrolysis of some antibiotics and the removal of faecal coliforms, it also decreases phosphates solubility and induces the formation of ammonium from ammonia. Also, while CO₂ supply increases the removal of E. coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, as well as the microalgal growth (and thus the conventional pollutants uptake), it decreases Enterococcus faecalis removal. Therefore, this review aims to provide a critical review of recent studies towards the application of microalgal systems for the efficient removal of conventional pollutants, antibiotics, and pathogens; discussing the feasibility, highlighting the advantages and challenges of the implementation of such process, and presenting current case-studies of different applications of microalgal systems.

Waste mitigation and resource recovery from food industry wastewater employing microalgae-bacterial consortium

Wastewater generated by the food industry is rich in nitrogen and phosphorus with possible presence of heavy metals. Physical and chemical methods of treatment, although effective, are expensive and may cause secondary environmental pollution damaging aquatic and human life. Traditional biological methods are eco-friendly and cost-effective but involve standalone microorganisms that pose risk of contamination and are not as effective. This review discusses the application of novel microalgal-bacterial consortium as a solution for the resource recovery and treatment of dairy, starch and aquaculture wastewater. Use of biofilm reactors containing anaerobic and aerobic sludge has shown 80-90% and > 90% COD and nutrient removal efficiency in treatment of dairy and starch processing wastewater, respectively. The treatment of aquaculture processing wastewater can be challenging due to high sality and requires salt-tolerant bacteria-microalgae consortium. In this regard, the identification of dominant microalgae and bacteria using 16S rRNA and 18S rRNA genes is recommended.