Induction of complement attack on human cells by Gal(alpha1,3)Gal xenoantigen expression as a gene therapy approach to cancer

Complement networks in gene-edited pig xenotransplantation: enhancing transplant success and addressing organ shortage

The shortage of organs for transplantation emphasizes the urgent need for alternative solutions. Xenotransplantation has emerged as a promising option due to the greater availability of donor organs. However, significant hurdles such as hyperacute rejection and organ ischemia-reperfusion injury pose major challenges, largely orchestrated by the complement system, and activated immune responses. The complement system, a pivotal component of innate immunity, acts as a natural barrier for xenotransplantation. To address the challenges of immune rejection, gene-edited pigs have become a focal point, aiming to shield donor organs from human immune responses and enhance the overall success of xenotransplantation. This comprehensive review aims to illuminate strategies for regulating complement networks to optimize the efficacy of gene-edited pig xenotransplantation. We begin by exploring the impact of the complement system on the effectiveness of xenotransplantation. Subsequently, we delve into the evaluation of key complement regulators specific to gene-edited pigs. To further understand the status of xenotransplantation, we discuss preclinical studies that utilize gene-edited pigs as a viable source of organs. These investigations provide valuable insights into the feasibility and potential success of xenotransplantation, offering a bridge between scientific advancements and clinical application.

Effect of membrane-bound complement regulatory proteins on tumor cell sensitivity to complement-dependent cytolysis triggered by heterologous expression of the α-gal xenoantigen

Engineering malignant cells to express a heterologous α-gal antigen can induce heterograft hyperacute rejection, resulting in complement-dependent cytolysis (CDC) of tumor cells, which has been considered as a novel strategy for antitumor therapy. A549 cells engineered to express Galα1-3Galβ1-4GlcNAc-R (α-gal) epitope exhibited strong resistance to CDC treated by normal human serum (NHS) in a previous study. We hypothesized that the expression of membrane-bound complement regulatory proteins (mCRPs) decay accelerating factor (CD55) and protectin (CD59) influenced the efficacy of the α-gal/NHS-mediated antitumor effect to tumor cells in vitro. The present study confirmed that A549 cells expressed high levels of CD55 and CD59, whereas Lovo cells expressed relatively low levels of these proteins. A549 and Lovo cells transfected with plasmids containing or lacking the α-gal epitope were evaluated for their susceptibility to CDC by NHS and detected using a trypan blue exclusion assay. α-gal-expressing Lovo (Lovo-GT) cells were almost completely killed by α-gal-mediated CDC following incubation with 50% NHS, whereas no cytolysis was observed in α-gal expressing A549 (A549-GT) cells. Abrogating CD55 and CD59 function from A549-GT cells by various concentrations of phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PI-PLC) or blocking antibodies increased the susceptibility of cells to CDC, and the survival rate decreased significantly comparing to the controls (P<0.05). The findings of the present study indicated that using the α-gal/NHS system to eliminate tumor cells via inducing the complement cascade reaction might represent a feasible approach for the treatment of cancer. However, high levels of mCRP expression may limit the efficacy of this approach. Therefore, an improved efficacy of cancer cell killing may be achieved by combining strategies of heterologous α-gal expression and mCRP downregulation.

CD55 limits sensitivity to complement-dependent cytolysis triggered by heterologous expression of α-gal xenoantigen in colon tumor cells

Engineering cancer cells to express heterologous antigen α-gal and induce the destruction of tumor cells depending on the complement cascade may be a promising strategy of tumor therapy. However, the feasibility and effect of using α-gal to induce colorectal adenocarcinoma cell line cytolysis is not yet known. In this study, we evaluated α-gal expression's ability to sensitize human colorectal adenocarcinoma cell lines to complement attack in cell lines LoVo, SW620, and Ls-174T. Nearly all α-gal-expressing LoVo and SW620 cells were killed by normal human serum (NHS), but α-gal-expressing Ls-174T cells showed no significant lysis. We analyzed the expression levels of membrane-bound complement regulatory proteins (mCRPs) on the three cell lines, and their protective role in α-gal-mediated activation of the complement. LoVo showed no expression of any of the three proteins. CD59 was strongly expressed by SW620 and Ls-174T. CD46 and CD55 varied between the two cell lines. CD46 on SW620 was only half the intensity of CD46 on Ls-174T. Ls-174T showed a notable expression of CD55, while expression of CD55 on SW620 was not detected. The sensitivity of Ls-174T expressing α-gal to NHS greatly increased following the downregulation of CD46 and CD55 with short hairpin RNA (shRNA). However, there is no increase in cell killing when CD59 expression was diminished. Our findings suggest that the use of α-gal as antigen to induce tumor cell killing may be a potential therapeutic strategy in colon cancer and that CD55 plays a primary role in conferring resistance to lysis.

Virus recognition by specific natural antibodies and complement results in MHC I cross-presentation

Natural antibodies (NAb) and complement (C’) are important regulators of immune system activation. We have shown previously that the galactosyl‐α1,3‐galactosyl (Galα1,3Gal) xenoantigen and the similar ABO histo‐blood group antigens are transferred onto virus from the producer cell, resulting in sensitisation of the virus to the respective NAb in a C’‐dependent manner. Here we show that measles virus (Mv) that expresses Galα1,3Gal termini can drive the proliferation of human T cells in the presence of serum and autologous DC, whereas without such targets, measles, as expected, suppress T cell reactivity. The use of affinity‐purified NAb to Galα1,3Gal and rabbit C’ demonstrated the components in human serum responsible for this effect. Proteasome inhibition and blocking of antigen presentation showed that the increased T cell proliferation was mediated by MHC class I cross‐presentation of immune complexes. These results lend further support to the idea that polymorphic carbohydrates of the Galα1,3Gal/ABO type serve as important targets for NAb and C’ and that their expression on virus has influenced their evolution by contributing to protection against viral transmission within as well as between species. The adjuvance effect of this recognition, acting as a bridge between the natural innate and adaptive immune systems, also has important implications for vaccine development.

Glycoengineering of alphaGal xenoantigen on recombinant peptide bearing the J28 pancreatic oncofetal glycotope

In human pancreatic adenocarcinoma, alterations of glycosylation processes leads to the expression of tumor-associated carbohydrate antigens, representing potential targets for cancer immunotherapy. Among these pancreatic tumor-associated carbohydrate antigens, the J28 glycotope located within the O-glycosylated mucin-like C-terminal domain of the fetoacinar pancreatic protein (FAPP) and expressed at the surface of human tumoral tissues, can be a good target for anticancer therapeutic vaccines. However, the oncodevelopmental self character of the J28 glycotope associated with the low immunogenicity of tumor-associated carbohydrate antigens may be a major obstacle to effective anti-tumor vaccine therapy. In this study, we have investigated a method to increase the immunogenicity of the recombinant pancreatic oncofetal J28 glycotope by glycoengineering Galalpha1,3Galss1,4GlcNAc-R (alphaGal epitope) which may be recognized by natural anti-alphaGal antibody present in humans. For this purpose, we have developed a stable Chinese hamster ovary cell clone expressing the alphaGal epitope by transfecting the cDNA encoding the alpha1,3galactosyltransferase. These cells have been previously equipped to produce the recombinant O-glycosylated C-terminal domain of FAPP carrying the J28 glycotope. As a consequence, the C-terminal domain of FAPP produced by these cells carries the alphaGal epitope on oligosaccharide structures associated with the J28 glycotope. Furthermore, we show that this recombinant "alpha1,3galactosyl and J28 glycotope" may not only be targeted by human natural anti-alphaGal antibodies but also by the mAbJ28, suggesting that the J28 glycotope remains accessible to the immune system as vaccinating agent. This approach may be used for many identified tumor-associated carbohydrate antigens which can be glycoengineered to carry a alphaGal epitope to increase their immunogenicity and to develop therapeutic vaccines.

Selective tumor cell targeting using low-affinity, multivalent interactions

This report highlights the advantages of low-affinity, multivalent interactions to recognize one cell type over another. Our goal was to devise a strategy to mediate selective killing of tumor cells, which are often distinguished from normal cells by their higher levels of particular cell surface receptors. To test whether multivalent interactions could lead to highly specific cell targeting, we used a chemically synthesized small-molecule ligand composed of two distinct motifs: (1) an Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) peptidomimetic that binds tightly (Kd approximately 10(-9)M) to alphavbeta3 integrins and (2) the galactosyl-alpha(1-3)galactose (alpha-Gal epitope), which is recognized by human anti-alpha-galactosyl antibodies (anti-Gal). Importantly, anti-Gal binding requires a multivalent presentation of carbohydrate residues; anti-Gal antibodies interact weakly with the monovalent oligosaccharide (Kd approximately 10(-5)M) but bind tightly (Kd approximately 10(-11) M) to multivalent displays of alpha-Gal epitopes. Such a display is generated when the bifunctional conjugate decorates a cell possessing a high level of alphavbeta3 integrin; the resulting cell surface, which presents many alpha-Gal epitopes, can recruit anti-Gal, thereby triggering complement-mediated lysis. Only those cells with high levels of the integrin receptor are killed. In contrast, doxorubicin tethered to the RGD-based ligand affords indiscriminate cell death. These results highlight the advantages of exploiting the type of the multivalent recognition processes used by physiological systems to discriminate between cells. The selectivity of this strategy is superior to traditional, abiotic, high-affinity targeting methods. Our results have implications for the treatment of cancer and other diseases characterized by the presence of deleterious cells.

Complement insufficiency limits efficacy in a xenograft model of hyperacute rejection for cancer therapy

Hyperacute rejection (HAR) is a rapid immunological response to an organ xenotransplant caused by recognition of endothelial galactose(alpha1,3)galactose (alphaGal) epitopes and complement-mediated cell lysis by host anti-alphaGal antibody ('natural antibody'). The alphaGal epitope is synthesised by a galactosyl transferase ((alpha1,3)GT) which humans lack. Because human cells transduced with (alpha1,3)GT are sensitised to natural antibody/complement-mediated lysis in human serum, delivery of (alpha1,3)GT to tumour vasculature in patients is a potential therapeutic strategy, by mimicking the pathophysiology of organ rejection. We therefore sought to develop an animal model of HAR for cancer therapy. Nude/(alpha1,3)GT knock-out mice allowed the growth of human tumour xenografts and the use of ecotropic retrovirus producer cells to generate expression of alphaGal on tumour vasculature. Lysis of alphaGal-positive murine endothelial cells with rabbit complement in conjunction with murine anti-alphaGal antibody in vitro was used to define the conditions necessary for HAR. However, tumour growth retardation and destruction of alphaGal-positive tumour endothelium were minimal after their administration, despite sera retaining post hoc cytolytic activity with fresh complement. The major limitation of this experimental system, of relevance to other therapeutic approaches, results from the use of a xenograft, in which additional xenoreactivities lead to complement insufficiency. Development of a tractable preclinical model in which to evaluate HAR for cancer therapy requires a syngeneic experimental system.

Co-expression of alpha(1,3)galactosyltransferase and Bacillus thuringiensis PIPLC enhances hyperacute rejection of tumor cells

The use of alpha(1,3)galactosyltransferase (alphaGT) as a method of inducing hyperacute rejection of tumors has been gaining interest recently. However, the approach is based in part on the sensitivity of each tumor line to the effects of complement lysis. Tumors expressing complement resistance factors such as membrane cofactor (CD46), decay accelerating factor (CD55) and protectin (CD59) have been shown to be more resistant to complement mediated lysis. Anchored to the membrane by a glycosylphosphoinositol moiety (GPI-anchored), CD55 and CD59 can be cleaved by Bacillus thuringiensis phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PIPLC). Complement resistant A549 human lung carcinoma cells were engineered to express both the murine alphaGT gene and the B. thuringiensis PIPLC gene to alleviate complement resistance and enhance alphagal-mediated cancer killing. The PIPLC native signal sequence was replaced with the human epidermal growth factor signal sequence, EGFssPIPLC, to induce secretion from A549. Expression of EGFssPIPLC resulted in complete removal of CD55 and CD59 while sparing the non-GPI-anchored CD46. Results demonstrated that A549 cells transduced with two recombinant retroviral vectors carrying the alphaGT and EGFssPIPLC genes expressed high levels of alphagal epitope and exhibited a 5-fold increase in sensitivity to anti-alphagal mediated complement lysis.

Ablation of undifferentiated human embryonic stem cells: exploiting innate immunity against the Gal alpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc-R (alpha-Gal) epitope

Although undifferentiated human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) are tumorigenic, this capacity is lost after differentiation, and hESCs are being widely investigated for applications in regenerative medicine. To engineer protection against the unintentional transplantation of undifferentiated cells, we generated hESCs carrying a construct in which the alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase (GalT) open reading frame was transcribed from the hTERT promoter (pmGT). Because the endogenous GalT gene is inactive, GalT expression was limited to undifferentiated cells. A second chimeric construct (pmfGT) differed by replacement of the GalT leader sequence for that of the fucosyltransferase gene. Two subclones containing stable integrations of pmGT and pmfGT (M2 and F11, respectively) were assessed for their response to human serum containing antibodies to the Galalpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc-R (alpha-gal) epitope. The low-variegation line, M2, and to a lesser extent the more variegated line F11, were sensitive to human serum when exposed in the undifferentiated state. However, M2 cells were largely insensitive after differentiation and retained both a normal karyotype and the ability to differentiate into derivatives of the three germ layers in severe combined immunodeficient mice. These data exemplify a method of protection against residual, undifferentiated hESCs prior to engraftment and may provide ongoing immune surveillance after engraftment against dedifferentiation or against de novo tumorigenesis involving hTERT reactivation. Untransfected H9 cells were not sensitive to the human serum used in this study. Hence, in our system, interactions of hESCs with other circulating antibodies, such as anti-Neu5Gc, were not observed.

Anti-alphaGal-dependent complement-mediated cytotoxicity in metastatic melanoma

Antibodies to the cell surface disaccharide galactose(alpha1,3)galactose (alphaGal) are the most prevalent natural antibodies in human serum. The anti-alphaGal immunoglobulin M-dependent activation of complement causes hyperacute rejection of organ transplants from discordant species by human recipients. It has been shown in vitro that human tumour cells transduced with the gene that synthesizes alphaGal become sensitive to human serum. A prerequisite for anti-alphaGal antibody-based therapeutic strategies is that patients with cancer have adequate serum levels of anti-alphaGal immunoglobulins and complement. The objective of this work was to measure the levels and function of anti-alphaGal immunoglobulins and complement in the serum of patients with metastatic melanoma and healthy volunteers. Serum complement levels were assayed by radial immunodiffusion. Anti-alphaGal immunoglobulin G and immunoglobulin M titres were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Disaccharide sugar blocking was used to investigate antibody specificity. The functional integrity of anti-alphaGal antibodies and complement was investigated in cell lysis assays. It was found that the levels of the complement components C1q, C3 and C4 and the function of the classical complement pathway were normal in metastatic melanoma patients. Anti-alphaGal antibody titres were as variable in metastatic melanoma patients as in healthy controls, and the lysis of alphaGal-expressing cells correlated with anti-alphaGal immunoglobulin M titre (P < 0.0001). Anti-alphaGal antibody titres, complement levels and overall cytolytic function in the serum of patients with metastatic melanoma were indistinguishable from those of healthy controls. There is thus nothing intrinsic to the disease that will limit anti-alphaGal-based therapeutic strategies for enhanced antigen presentation or induced cell lysis, including the mimicry of hyperacute rejection.

Mice are unsuitable for modelling ABO discordance despite strain-specific A cross-reactive natural IgM

ABO blood group antigens are immunodominant cell surface oligosaccharides. The function of the ABO system is clinically important in blood transfusion and solid organ transplantation but there is no small animal model of ABO discordance. The present study demonstrated A glycoconjugate-reactive IgM in the serum of CBA/Ca mice by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay but showed with sugar blocking that the specificity of this IgM was different from that of human anti-A IgM. Furthermore, immunisation of CBA/Ca mice with the A antigen did not increase reactive IgM titre. In contrast, knock-out mice for the related carbohydrate antigen galactose(alpha1,3)galactose mounted a serum IgM response when immunised with the non-self galactose(alpha1,3)galactose antigen, which was shown to be T cell-dependent using a nude/knock-out animal. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction identified transcripts for the enzyme likely to be responsible for the synthesis of the A antigen in organs from CBA/Ca mice although the A antigen was not detected in the same organs by immunohistochemistry. We conclude that CBA/Ca mice possess natural serum IgM with different characteristics to human anti-A IgM and that CBA/Ca mice may also express the A antigen. As a result, these mice are not suitable for use as a small animal model of ABO discordance.

In vivo targeting of vaccinating tumor cells to antigen-presenting cells by a gene therapy method with adenovirus containing the α1,3galactosyltransferase gene

Poor uptake by antigen-presenting cells (APC) is a major reason for low immunogenicity of autologous tumor vaccines. This immunogenicity may be increased by exploiting the natural anti-Gal antibody that is present in humans as approximately 1% of circulating IgG. Anti-Gal binds to alpha-gal epitopes (Galalpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc-R) on vaccinating tumor cells and opsonizes them for effective uptake by APC. This epitope is synthesized in human tumor cells by transduction with AdalphaGT- a replication deficient adenovirus containing the alpha1,3galactosyltransferase (alpha1,3GT) gene. Protection against tumors by immunization with AdalphaGT-transduced tumor cells was studied in alpha1,3GT knockout (KO) mice, challenged with the highly tumorigenic BL6 melanoma cells. These mice lack alpha-gal epitopes and can produce anti-Gal. Immunization of KO mice with AdalphaGT-transduced BL6 cells protects many of the mice against challenge with live BL6 cells lacking alpha-gal epitopes. Immunization with AdalphaGT transduced autologous tumor cells may serve as adjuvant immunotherapy delivered after completion of standard therapy. This method may complement another gene therapy method in which GM-CSF-secreting vaccinating tumor cells recruit APC to vaccination sites. Anti-Gal-opsonized vaccinating tumor cells will be effectively internalized by GM-CSF recruited APC and transported to draining lymph nodes for processing and presentation of tumor antigens. Alternatively, injection of AdalphaGT directly into solid tumor masses of cancer patients may result in anti-Gal-mediated destruction of the transduced tumor cells in a manner similar to xenograft rejection. The subsequent uptake of anti-Gal-opsonized tumor membranes by APC results in their effective transportation to lymph nodes where processed tumor antigens may elicit a protective antitumor immune response.

Relationship between ?Gal epitope expression and decrease of tumorigenicity in pancreatic adenocarcinoma model

The alphaGal epitope is a carbohydrate structure, Galalpha1,3Galbeta1,4GlcNAc-R, synthesized on glycoconjugates in many mammals by alpha1,3galactosyltransferase. Humans do not express this epitope and present in serum large amounts of naturally occuring antibodies, which recognize the alphaGal epitopes and participate in the hyperacute rejection of xenograft. Studies indicated that the fundamental mechanism of hyperacute rejection involving the alphaGal epitope expression can be used in cancer therapy. We have previously suggested that the alphaGal epitope expression by human pancreatic tumoral cells could decrease the tumorigenic behavior of these cells. To determine whether the expression of the alphaGal epitope can modify the tumorigenicity of pancreatic cancer cells, we used a Syrian golden hamster pancreatic adenocarcinoma experimental model. The expression of alphaGal epitopes in the Syrian golden hamster pancreatic cancer cell line HaP-T1 was obtained by selecting stable cell clones transfected with murine alpha1,3galactosyltransferase gene. The alphaGal epitope expression resulted in a delay in the tumoral development of HaP-T1 cells in vivo after allograft transplantation of Syrian golden hamsters (2.5-fold, P < 0.05) and of nude mice. This result is associated with an 100% increase in survival time of nude mice bearing tumors expressing the alphaGal epitope. Our results confirm that the cell surface expression of alphaGal epitope decreases the tumorigenic behavior of pancreatic cancer cells. This novel property may be useful for the development of cancer gene immunotherapy strategy.

Decrease of human pancreatic cancer cell tumorigenicity by alpha1,3galactosyltransferase gene transfer

The enzyme alpha1,3galactosyltransferase synthesizes the alphaGal epitope, a carbohydrate structure (Galalpha1,3Galbeta1,4GlcNAc-R), on glycoconjugates in lower mammals. The enzyme is absent in humans but large amounts of natural antibodies that recognize alphaGal epitopes are present in human serum. It is likely that these antibodies contribute to the host defense and participate in the hyperacute rejection of xenograft. Previous studies indicated that the glycosyltransferase gene transfer into tumoral cells can modify the structure of glycoconjugates at the cell surface and, as a consequence, modulates the metastatic and tumorigenic behaviors of these cells. The aim of our study was to determine whether the expression of alphaGal epitope can modify the tumorigenicity of human pancreatic cancer cells. The expression of alphaGal epitopes in the human pancreatic cancer cell lines BxPC-3 and Panc-1 was obtained by selecting stable cell clones transfected with murine alpha1,3galactosyltransferase gene. The expression of the enzyme activity in BxPC-3 and Panc-1 cells resulted in the formation at the cell surface of alphaGal epitopes that are recognized by human anti-alphaGal antibodies. alphaGal epitope expression at the surface of pancreatic cancer cells was associated with the fixation of complement 1q to human anti-alphaGal antibodies. The alphaGal epitope expression also resulted in a delay in the tumoral development of BxPC-3 and Panc-1 cells in vivo after xenograft transplantation of nude mice. In addition to the impairment of the metastatic potential of murine tumor cell lines and the activation of immune response, our study provides evidence that the cell surface expression of alphaGal epitopes also modulates the tumorigenic behavior of human pancreatic cancer cells.