Immune response induced by retrovirus-mediated HSV-tk/GCV pharmacogene therapy in patients with glioblastoma multiforme

Cancer biotherapy: review and prospect

Malignant tumors pose a grave threat to the quality of human life. The prevalence of malignant tumors in China is steadily rising. Presently, clinical interventions encompass surgery, radiotherapy, and pharmaceutical therapy in isolation or combination. Nonetheless, these modalities fail to completely eradicate malignant tumor cells, frequently leading to metastasis and recurrence. Conversely, tumor biotherapy has emerged as an encouraging fourth approach in preventing and managing malignant tumors owing to its safety, efficacy, and minimal adverse effects. Currently, a range of tumor biotherapy techniques are employed, including gene therapy, tumor vaccines, monoclonal antibody therapy, cancer stem cell therapy, cytokine therapy, and adoptive cellular immunotherapy. This study aims to comprehensively review the latest developments in biological treatments for malignant tumors.

Combined cytotoxic and immune-stimulatory gene therapy using Ad-TK and Ad-Flt3L: Translational developments from rodents to glioma patients

Gliomas are the most prevalent and devastating primary malignant brain tumors in adults. Despite substantial advances in understanding glioma biology, there have been no regulatory drug approvals in the US since bevacizumab in 2009 and tumor treating fields in 2011. Recent phase III clinical trials have failed to meet their prespecified therapeutic primary endpoints, highlighting the need for novel therapies. The poor prognosis of glioma patients, resistance to chemo-radiotherapy, and the immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment underscore the need for the development of novel therapies. Gene therapy-based immunotherapeutic strategies that couple the ability of the host immune system to specifically kill glioma cells and develop immunological memory have shown remarkable progress. Two adenoviral vectors expressing Ad-HSV1-TK/GCV and Ad-Flt3L have shown promising preclinical data, leading to FDA approval of a non-randomized, phase I open-label, first in human trial to test safety, cytotoxicity, and immune-stimulatory efficiency in high-grade glioma patients (NCT01811992). This review provides a thorough overview of immune-stimulatory gene therapy highlighting recent advancements, potential drawbacks, future directions, and recommendations for future implementation of clinical trials.

Immunotherapy Resistance in Glioblastoma

Glioblastoma is the most common malignant primary brain tumor in adults. Despite treatment consisting of surgical resection followed by radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy, survival remains poor at a rate of 26.5% at 2 years. Recent successes in using immunotherapies to treat a number of solid and hematologic cancers have led to a growing interest in harnessing the immune system to target glioblastoma. Several studies have examined the efficacy of various immunotherapies, including checkpoint inhibitors, vaccines, adoptive transfer of lymphocytes, and oncolytic virotherapy in both pre-clinical and clinical settings. However, these therapies have yielded mixed results at best when applied to glioblastoma. While the initial failures of immunotherapy were thought to reflect the immunoprivileged environment of the brain, more recent studies have revealed immune escape mechanisms created by the tumor itself and adaptive resistance acquired in response to therapy. Several of these resistance mechanisms hijack key signaling pathways within the immune system to create a protumoral microenvironment. In this review, we discuss immunotherapies that have been trialed in glioblastoma, mechanisms of tumor resistance, and strategies to sensitize these tumors to immunotherapies. Insights gained from the studies summarized here may help pave the way for novel therapies to overcome barriers that have thus far limited the success of immunotherapy in glioblastoma.

Soluble PD-1: Predictive, Prognostic, and Therapeutic Value for Cancer Immunotherapy

Programmed death protein 1 (PD-1) interaction with PD-L1 deliver immunosuppressive environment for tumor growth, and its blockade with directed monoclonal antibodies (anti-PD-1/anti-PD-L1) has shown remarkable clinical outcome. Lately, their soluble counterparts, sPD-1 and sPD-L1, have been detected in plasma, and elevated levels have been associated with advanced disease, clinical stages, and worst prognosis for cancer patients. Elevated plasma levels of sPD-L1 have been correlated with worst prognosis in several studies and has displayed a persistent outlook. On the other hand, sPD-1 levels have been inconsistent in their predictive and prognostic ability. Pretherapeutic higher sPD-1 plasma levels have shown to predict advanced disease state and to a lesser extent worst prognosis. Any increase in sPD-1 plasma level post therapeutically have been correlated with improved survival for various cancers. In vitro and in vivo studies have shown sPD-1 ability to bind PD-L1 and PD-L2 and block PD-1/PD-L1 interaction. Local delivery of sPD-1 in cancer tumor microenvironment through local gene therapy have demonstrated an increase in tumor specific CD8+ T cell immunity and tumor growth reduction. It had also exhibited enhancement of T cell immunity induced by vaccination and other gene therapeutic agents. Furthermore, it may also lessen the inhibitory effect of circulating sPD-L1 and enhance the effects of mAb-based immunotherapy. In this review, we highlight various aspects of sPD-1 role in cancer prediction, prognosis, and anti-cancer immunity, as well as, its therapeutic value for local gene therapy or systemic immunotherapy in blocking the PD-1 and PD-L1 checkpoint interactions.

Self-Assembly Protein Superstructures as a Powerful Chemodynamic Therapy Nanoagent for Glioblastoma Treatment

Glioblastoma (GBM) remains a formidable challenge in oncology. Chemodynamic therapy (CDT) that triggers tumor cell death by reactive oxygen species (ROS) could open up a new door for GBM treatment. Herein, we report a novel CDT nanoagent. Hemoglobin (Hb) and glucose oxidase (GOx) were employed as powerful CDT catalysts. Instead of encapsulating the proteins in drug delivery nanocarriers, we formulate multimeric superstructures as self-delivery entities by crosslinking techniques. Red blood cell (RBC) membranes are camouflaged on the protein superstructures to promote the delivery across blood-brain barrier. The as-prepared RBC@Hb@GOx nanoparticles (NPs) offer superior biocompatibility, simplified structure, and high accumulation at the tumor site. We successfully demonstrated that the NPs could efficiently produce toxic ROS to kill U87MG cancer cells in vitro and inhibit the growth of GBM tumor in vivo, suggesting that the new CDT nanoagent holds great promise for treating GBM.

A novel synthetic human insulin super promoter for targeting PDX-1-expressing pancreatic cancer

Our previous studies have shown that a rat insulin promoter II fragment (RIP) was used to effectively target pancreatic adenocarcinoma (PDAC) and insulinoma that over-express pancreatic and duodenal homeobox-1 (PDX-1). To enhance the activity and specificity of the human insulin promoter, we engineered a synthetic human insulin super-promoter (SHIP). Reporter assay demonstrated that SHIP1 was the most powerful promoter among all of the SHIPs and had far greater activity than the endogenous human insulin promoters and RIP in PDAC expressing PDX-1. Over-expression, knockdown and competitive inhibition of PDX-1 expression assay proved that PDX-1 is a critical transcript factor to regulate the activity of SHIP1. SHIP1-driven viral thymidine kinase followed by ganciclovir (SHIP1-TK/GCV) resulted in cytotoxicity to PDAC cells in vitro. Systemic delivery of SHIP1-TK/GCV in PDAC xenograft mice significantly suppressed PANC-1 tumor growth in vivo greater than RIP-TK/GCV and CMV-TK/GCV controls (p < .05). These preclinical data suggest that SHIP1 is a powerful novel promoter that can be used to target human PDAC expressing PDX-1 in clinical trials. Furthermore, this novel strategy of engineering synthetic super-promoters could be used for other cancer targets.

Anti-GD2-ch14.18/CHO coated nanoparticles mediate glioblastoma (GBM)-specific delivery of the aromatase inhibitor, Letrozole, reducing proliferation, migration and chemoresistance in patient-derived GBM tumor cells

Aromatase is a critical enzyme in the irreversible conversion of androgens to oestrogens, with inhibition used clinically in hormone-dependent malignancies. We tested the hypothesis that targeted aromatase inhibition in an aggressive brain cancer called glioblastoma (GBM) may represent a new treatment strategy. In this study, aromatase inhibition was achieved using third generation inhibitor, Letrozole, encapsulated within the core of biodegradable poly lactic-co-glycolic acid (PLGA) nanoparticles (NPs). PLGA-NPs were conjugated to human/mouse chimeric anti-GD2 antibody ch14.18/CHO, enabling specific targeting of GD2-positive GBM cells. Treatment of primary and recurrent patient-derived GBM cells with free-Letrozole (0.1 μM) led to significant decrease in cell proliferation and migration; in addition to reduced spheroid formation. Anti-GD2-ch14.18/CHO-NPs displayed specific targeting of GBM cells in colorectal-glioblastoma co-culture, with subsequent reduction in GBM cell numbers when treated with anti-GD2-ch14.18-PLGA-Let-NPs in combination with temozolomide. As miR-191 is an estrogen responsive microRNA, its expression, fluctuation and role in Letrozole treated GBM cells was evaluated, where treatment with premiR-191 was capable of rescuing the reduced proliferative phenotype induced by aromatase inhibitor. The repurposing and targeted delivery of Letrozole for the treatment of GBM, with the potential role of miR-191 identified, provides novel avenues for target assessment in this aggressive brain cancer.

Reconstructing the immune system with lentiviral vectors

Lentiviral vectors (LVs) developed in the past two decades for research and pre-clinical purposes have entered clinical trials with remarkable safety and efficacy performances. Development and clinical testing of LVs for improvement of human immunity showed major advantages in comparison to other viral vector systems. Robust and persisted transduction efficiency of blood cells with LVs, resulted into a broad range of target cells for immune therapeutic approaches: from hematopoietic stem cells and precursor cells for correction of immune deficiencies, up to effector lymphoid and myeloid cells. T cells engineered for expression of chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) or epitope-specific transgenic T cell receptors (TCRs) are in several cancer immune therapy clinical trials worldwide. Development of engineered dendritic cells is primed for clinical trials for cancer and chronic infections. Technological adaptations for ex vivo cell manipulations are here discussed and presented based on properties and uses of the target cell. For future development of off-shelf immune therapies, direct in vivo administration of lentiviral vectors is warranted and intended. Approaches for lentiviral in vivo targeting to maximize immune therapeutic success are discussed.

Anti-Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor Gene Therapy for Glioblastoma

Glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) is the most common and aggressive primary intracranial brain tumor in adults with a mean survival of 14 to 15 months. Aberrant activation of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) plays a significant role in GBM progression, with amplification or overexpression of EGFR in 60% of GBM tumors. To target EGFR expressed by GBM, we have developed a strategy to deliver the coding sequence for cetuximab, an anti-EGFR antibody, directly to the CNS using an adeno-associated virus serotype rh.10 gene transfer vector. The data demonstrates that single, local delivery of an anti-EGFR antibody by an AAVrh.10 vector coding for cetuximab (AAVrh.10Cetmab) reduces GBM tumor growth and increases survival in xenograft mouse models of a human GBM EGFR-expressing cell line and patient-derived GBM. AAVrh10.CetMab-treated mice displayed a reduction in cachexia, a significant decrease in tumor volume and a prolonged survival following therapy. Adeno-associated-directed delivery of a gene encoding a therapeutic anti-EGFR monoclonal antibody may be an effective strategy to treat GBM.

Glioblastoma multiforme: State of the art and future therapeutics

BACKGROUND

Glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) is the most common and lethal primary malignancy of the central nervous system (CNS). Despite the proven benefit of surgical resection and aggressive treatment with chemo- and radiotherapy, the prognosis remains very poor. Recent advances of our understanding of the biology and pathophysiology of GBM have allowed the development of a wide array of novel therapeutic approaches, which have been developed. These novel approaches include molecularly targeted therapies, immunotherapies, and gene therapy.

METHODS

We offer a brief review of the current standard of care, and a survey of novel therapeutic approaches for treatment of GBM.

RESULTS

Despite promising results in preclinical trials, many of these therapies have demonstrated limited therapeutic efficacy in human clinical trials. Thus, although survival of patients with GBM continues to slowly improve, treatment of GBM remains extremely challenging.

CONCLUSION

Continued research and development of targeted therapies, based on a detailed understanding of molecular pathogenesis can reasonably be expected to yield improved outcomes for patients with GBM.

Prognostic utility of gene therapy with herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase for patients with high-grade malignant gliomas: a systematic review and meta analysis

The aim of this study was to assess the effectiveness of adding viral vector-mediated gene therapy with herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) to standard treatment, in comparison with standard treatment alone to treat patients with high-grade gliomas (HGGs). A literature search of the databases PubMed, Embase, the Cochrane Library, Web of Science, and Chinese biomedicine was performed to identify eligible studies. Three randomized controlled trials (involving a total of 532 patients) were included in this systematic review. A meta-analysis of included studies demonstrated a significant increase in median survival time (MST) in patients who were treated with HSV-tk gene therapy (mean deviation 0.59, 95% CI: 0.41-0.76, p < 0.0001). The results of pooled analysis for different patient groups show that overall survival (OS) for all HGG patients was improved by adding gene therapy [hazard ratio (HR) = 0.91, 95% CI: 0.74-1.13, p = 0.42], while a different result was seen for glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) patients (HR = 1.06, 95% CI: 0.80-1.41, p = 0.70). Furthermore, the combined results for tumor progression implied that standard therapy was superior to gene therapy [odds ratio (OR) = 1.31, p = 0.09]; yet differences in HR and OR between experimental groups and control groups had no statistical significance (p > 0.05). Based on the best available evidence, it appears that adding gene therapy with HSV-tk has some effect in treating HGG patients, especially with respect to MST. However, neither the pooled analysis of OS, nor the combined analysis of tumor progress indicates any significant advantage to adding gene therapy compared with standard treatment alone. More prospective studies are needed to draw solid conclusions about whether gene therapy has significant prognostic advantage.

Engineered drug resistant γδ T cells kill glioblastoma cell lines during a chemotherapy challenge: a strategy for combining chemo- and immunotherapy

Classical approaches to immunotherapy that show promise in some malignancies have generally been disappointing when applied to high-grade brain tumors such as glioblastoma multiforme (GBM). We recently showed that ex vivo expanded/activated γδ T cells recognize NKG2D ligands expressed on malignant glioma and are cytotoxic to glioma cell lines and primary GBM explants. In addition, γδ T cells extend survival and slow tumor progression when administered to immunodeficient mice with intracranial human glioma xenografts. We now show that temozolomide (TMZ), a principal chemotherapeutic agent used to treat GBM, increases the expression of stress-associated NKG2D ligands on TMZ-resistant glioma cells, potentially rendering them vulnerable to γδ T cell recognition and lysis. TMZ is also highly toxic to γδ T cells, however, and to overcome this cytotoxic effect γδ T cells were genetically modified using a lentiviral vector encoding the DNA repair enzyme O(6)-alkylguanine DNA alkyltransferase (AGT) from the O(6)-methylguanine methyltransferase (MGMT) cDNA, which confers resistance to TMZ. Genetic modification of γδ T cells did not alter their phenotype or their cytotoxicity against GBM target cells. Importantly, gene modified γδ T cells showed greater cytotoxicity to two TMZ resistant GBM cell lines, U373(TMZ-R) and SNB-19(TMZ-R) cells, in the presence of TMZ than unmodified cells, suggesting that TMZ exposed more receptors for γδ T cell-targeted lysis. Therefore, TMZ resistant γδ T cells can be generated without impairing their anti-tumor functions in the presence of high concentrations of TMZ. These results provide a mechanistic basis for combining chemotherapy and γδ T cell-based drug resistant cellular immunotherapy to treat GBM.

Gene therapy for brain tumors: basic developments and clinical implementation

Glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) is the most common and deadliest of adult primary brain tumors. Due to its invasive nature and sensitive location, complete resection remains virtually impossible. The resistance of GBM against chemotherapy and radiotherapy necessitate the development of novel therapies. Gene therapy is proposed for the treatment of brain tumors and has demonstrated pre-clinical efficacy in animal models. Here we review the various experimental therapies that have been developed for GBM including both cytotoxic and immune stimulatory approaches. We also review the combined conditional cytotoxic immune stimulatory therapy that our lab has developed which is dependent on the adenovirus mediated expression of the conditional cytotoxic gene, Herpes Simplex Type 1 Thymidine Kinase (TK) and the powerful DC growth factor Fms-like tyrosine kinase 3 ligand (Flt3L). Combined delivery of these vectors elicits tumor cell death and an anti-tumor adaptive immune response that requires TLR2 activation. The implications of our studies indicate that the combined cytotoxic and immunotherapeutic strategies are effective strategies to combat deadly brain tumors and warrant their implementation in human Phase I clinical trials for GBM.

Integration of adenovirus thymidine kinase suicide-gene therapy with surgery and radiation therapy for malignant glioma

Evaluation of: Chiocca EA, Aguilar LK, Bell SD et al. Phase IB study of gene-mediated cytotoxic immunotherapy adjuvant to up-front surgery and intensive timing radiation for malignant glioma. J. Clin. Oncol. 29(27), 3611–3619 (2011). This report of a clinical Phase IB trial uses adenoviral vectors injected in a dose escalation manner during surgical excision of primary gliomas to express thymidine kinase and activate the prodrugvalacyclovir, which is administered so as to overlap in part with a standard radiation therapy schedule. The approach aimed to exploit several mechanisms associated with this form of gene therapy, namely tumor cell suicide, radiosensitization and the antitumor immunotherapeutic response that it can activate. The most novel aspect of the trial was the early start to radiation therapy 1 week after surgery that was designed to allow for radiosensitization by orally administered valacyclovir. In general, the treatment was well tolerated and the overall median survival for patients was 12.4 months with a 3-year survival of 25%. There was evidence of immune cell infiltration in all four resection specimens that were examined but no sign of an importance to viral dose within the range of 3 × 1010–3 × 1011 particles. This was a small trial with only 13 patients but the results warrant the initiation of further clinical trials to investigate what is now a fairly old but still promising strategy.

Gene therapy and targeted toxins for glioma

The most common primary brain tumor in adults is glioblastoma. These tumors are highly invasive and aggressive with a mean survival time of 15-18 months from diagnosis to death. Current treatment modalities are unable to significantly prolong survival in patients diagnosed with glioblastoma. As such, glioma is an attractive target for developing novel therapeutic approaches utilizing gene therapy. This review will examine the available preclinical models for glioma including xenographs, syngeneic and genetic models. Several promising therapeutic targets are currently being pursued in pre-clinical investigations. These targets will be reviewed by mechanism of action, i.e., conditional cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses, tumor suppressors/oncogenes, and immune stimulatory approaches. Preclinical gene therapy paradigms aim to determine which strategies will provide rapid tumor regression and long-term protection from recurrence. While a wide range of potential targets are being investigated preclinically, only the most efficacious are further transitioned into clinical trial paradigms. Clinical trials reported to date are summarized including results from conditionally cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses and oncogene targeting approaches. Clinical trial results have not been as robust as preclinical models predicted; this could be due to the limitations of the GBM models employed. Once this is addressed, and we develop effective gene therapies in models that better replicate the clinical scenario, gene therapy will provide a powerful approach to treat and manage brain tumors.

Gammadelta T cells as immune effectors against high-grade gliomas

Almost all individuals diagnosed with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) will die of their disease as no effective therapies exist. Clearly, novel approaches to this problem are needed. Unlike the adaptive alphabeta T cell-mediated immune response, which requires antigen processing and MHC-restricted peptide display by antigen-presenting cells, gammadelta T cells can broadly recognize and immediately respond to a variety of MHC-like stress-induced self antigens, many of which are expressed on human GBM cells. Until now, there has been little progress toward clinical application, although several investigators have recently published clinically approvable methods for large-scale ex vivo expansion of functional gammadelta T cells for therapeutic purposes. This review discusses the biology of gammadelta T cells with respect to innate immunotherapy of cancer with a focus on GBM, and explores graft engineering techniques in development for the therapeutic use of gammadelta T cells.

Side populations of glioblastoma cells are less sensitive to HSV-TK/GCV suicide gene therapy system than the non-side population

Side populations of glioblastoma cells are resistant to chemotherapy basically due to ABCG2-mediated efflux of small-molecule drugs. The herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase/ganciclovir suicide gene therapy system is one of the best-characterized strategies for malignant tumors including glioblastoma. Since this system involves a small-molecule drug ganciclovir, we wonder if glioblastoma side population cells are able to "pump out" ganciclovir and thus resistant to this suicide gene therapy. By 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-5-(3-carboxymethoxyphenyl)-2-(4-sulfophenyl)-2H-tetrazolium assay, we found that side populations are more resistant to this system than non-side populations. By flow cytometry and competition assay, we found that ganciclovir is a substrate for ABCG2.

Gene therapy for brain cancer: combination therapies provide enhanced efficacy and safety

Glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) is the most common primary brain cancer in adults. Despite significant advances in treatment and intensive research, the prognosis for patients with GBM remains poor. Therapeutic challenges for GBM include its invasive nature, the proximity of the tumor to vital brain structures often preventing total resection, and the resistance of recurrent GBM to conventional radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Gene therapy has been proposed as a useful adjuvant for GBM, to be used in conjunction with current treatment. Work from our laboratory has shown that combination of conditional cytotoxic with immunotherapeutic approaches for the treatment of GBM elicits regression of large intracranial tumor masses and anti-tumor immunological memory in syngeneic rodent models of GBM. In this review we examined the currently available animal models for GBM, including rodent transplantable models, endogenous rodent tumor models and spontaneous GBM in dogs. We discuss non-invasive surrogate end points to assess tumor progression and therapeutic efficacy, such as behavioral tests and circulating biomarkers. Growing preclinical and clinical data contradict the old dogma that cytotoxic anti-cancer therapy would lead to an immune-suppression that would impair the ability of the immune system to mount an anti-tumor response. The implications of the findings reviewed indicate that combination of cytotoxic therapy with immunotherapy will lead to synergistic antitumor efficacy with reduced neurotoxicity and supports the clinical implementation of combined cytotoxic-immunotherapeutic strategies for the treatment of patients with GBM.

Viral strategies for studying the brain, including a replication-restricted self-amplifying delta-G vesicular stomatis virus that rapidly expresses transgenes in brain and can generate a multicolor golgi-like expression

Viruses have substantial value as vehicles for transporting transgenes into neurons. Each virus has its own set of attributes for addressing neuroscience-related questions. Here we review some of the advantages and limitations of herpes, pseudorabies, rabies, adeno-associated, lentivirus, and others to study the brain. We then explore a novel recombinant vesicular stomatitis virus (dG-VSV) with the G-gene deleted and transgenes engineered into the first position of the RNA genome, which replicates only in the first brain cell infected, as corroborated with ultrastructural analysis, eliminating spread of virus. Because of its ability to replicate rapidly and to express multiple mRNA copies and additional templates for more copies, reporter gene expression is amplified substantially, over 500-fold in 6 hours, allowing detailed imaging of dendrites, dendritic spines, axons, and axon terminal fields within a few hours to a few days after inoculation. Green fluorescent protein (GFP) expression is first detected within 1 hour of inoculation. The virus generates a Golgi-like appearance in all neurons or glia of regions of the brain tested. Whole-cell patch-clamp electrophysiology, calcium digital imaging with fura-2, and time-lapse digital imaging showed that neurons appeared physiologically normal after expressing viral transgenes. The virus has a wide range of species applicability, including mouse, rat, hamster, human, and Drosophila cells. By using dG-VSV, we show efferent projections from the suprachiasmatic nucleus terminating in the periventricular region immediately dorsal to the nucleus. DG-VSVs with genes coding for different color reporters allow multicolor visualization of neurons wherever applied.

Characterization and immunotherapeutic potential of gammadelta T-cells in patients with glioblastoma

Classical immunotherapeutic approaches to glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) have shown mixed results, and therapies focused on innate lymphocyte activity against GBM have not been rigorously evaluated. We examined peripheral blood lymphocyte phenotype, gammadelta T-cell number, mitogenic response, and cytotoxicity against GBM cell lines and primary tumor explants from GBM patients at selected time points prior to and during GBM therapy. Healthy volunteers served as controls and were grouped by age. T-cell infiltration of tumors from these patients was assessed by staining for CD3 and T-cell receptor gammadelta. Our findings revealed no differences in counts of mean absolute T-cells, T-cell subsets CD3+CD4+ and CD3+CD8+, and natural killer cells from healthy volunteers and patients prior to and immediately after GBM resection. In contrast, gammadelta T-cell counts and mitogen-stimulated proliferative response of gammadelta T-cells were markedly decreased prior to GBM resection and throughout therapy. Expanded/activated gammadelta T-cells from both patients and healthy volunteers kill GBM cell lines D54, U373, and U251, as well as primary GBM, without cytotoxicity to primary astrocyte cultures. Perivascular T-cell accumulation was noted in paraffin sections, but no organized T-cell invasion of the tumor parenchyma was seen. Taken together, these data suggest that gammadelta T-cell depletion and impaired function occur prior to or concurrent with the growth of the tumor. The significant cytotoxicity of expanded/activated gammadelta T-cells from both healthy controls and selected patients against primary GBM explants may open a previously unexplored approach to cellular immunotherapy of GBM.

HSV-TK/IL-2 gene therapy for glioblastoma multiforme

We performed a clinical trial of gene therapy in patients with recurrent glioblastoma multiforme based on retroviral vector-mediated combined delivery of interleukin-2 and thymidine kinase of herpes simplex virus (HSV)-1. Treatment consisted of intratumor injection of retroviral vector-producing cells, followed by intravenous ganciclovir administration. The primary endpoints of the study were the evaluation of the safety of the treatment and demonstration of transduction of tumor cells. Here, we report details on the clinical protocol and the methods used.

Towards a ligand targeted enzyme prodrug therapy: Single round panning of a β-lactamase scaffold library on human cancer cells

A novel beta-lactamase scaffold library in which the target-binding moiety is built into the enzyme was generated using phage display technology. The binding element is composed of a fully randomized 8 amino acid loop inserted at position between Y34 and K37 on the outer surface of Enterobacter cloacae P99 cephalosporinase (beta-lactamase, E.C. 3.5.2.6) with all library members retaining catalytic activity. The frequency and diversity of amino acids distributions in peptide inserts from library clones were analyzed. The complexity of the randomized loop appears consistent with standards of other types of phage display library systems. The library was panned against SKBR3 human breast cancer cells in 1 round using rolling circle amplification of phage DNA to recover bound phage. Individual beta-lactamase clones, independent of phage, were rapidly assessed for their binding to SKBR3 cells using a simple high throughput screen based on cell-bound beta-lactamase activity. SKBR3 cell-binding beta-lactamase enzymes were also shown to bind specifically using an immunochemical method. Selected beta-lactamase clones were further studied for their protein expression, enzyme activity and binding to nontumor cell-lines. Overall, the approach outlined here offers the opportunity of rapidly selecting targeted beta-lactamase ligands that may have a potential for their use in enzyme prodrug therapy with cephalosporin-based prodrugs. It is expected that a similar approach will be useful in developing tumor-targeting molecules of several other enzyme candidates of cancer prodrug therapy.

Clinical trials of gene therapy, virotherapy, and immunotherapy for malignant gliomas

Despite advances in surgical and adjuvant therapy, the prognosis for malignant gliomas remains dismal. This gloomy scenario has been recently brightened by the increasing understanding of the genetic and biological mechanisms at the basis of brain tumor development. These findings are being translated into innovative therapeutic approaches, including gene therapy, virotherapy, and vaccination, some of which have already been experimented in clinical trials. The advantages and disadvantages of all these different therapeutic modalities for malignant gliomas will be critically discussed, providing perspective for future investigations.

Gene therapy and targeted toxins for glioma

The most common primary brain tumor in adults is glioblastoma. These tumors are highly invasive and aggressive with a mean survival time of nine to twelve months from diagnosis to death. Current treatment modalities are unable to significantly prolong survival in patients diagnosed with glioblastoma. As such, glioma is an attractive target for developing novel therapeutic approaches utilizing gene therapy. This review will examine the available preclinical models for glioma including xenographs, syngeneic and genetic models. Several promising therapeutic targets are currently being pursued in pre-clinical investigations. These targets will be reviewed by mechanism of action, i.e., conditional cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses, tumor suppressors/oncogenes, and immune stimulatory approaches. Preclinical gene therapy paradigms aim to determine which strategies will provide rapid tumor regression and long-term protection from recurrence. While a wide range of potential targets are being investigated preclinically, only the most efficacious are further transitioned into clinical trial paradigms. Clinical trials reported to date are summarized including results from conditionally cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses and oncogene targeting approaches. Clinical trial results have not been as robust as preclinical models predicted, this could be due to the limitations of the GBM models employed. Once this is addressed, and we develop effective gene therapies in models that better replicate the clinical scenario, gene therapy will provide a powerful approach to treat and manage brain tumors.

Combined HSV-TK/IL-2 gene therapy in patients with recurrent glioblastoma multiforme: biological and clinical results

Following our pilot clinical study of combined IL-2/HSV-TK gene therapy for recurrent glioblastoma multiforme (GBM), we extended the protocol to a larger population of patients and evaluated safety, feasibility, and biological activity of treatment. A total of 12 patients received intratumor injection of retroviral vector-producing cells (RVPCs), followed by intravenous ganciclovir (GCV). Treatment was well tolerated with only minor adverse events. Transduction of tumor cells was demonstrated in tumor biopsies. A marked and persistent increase of intratumor and plasma Th1 cytokine levels was demonstrated after RVPC injection. At magnetic resonance imaging evaluation, two patients had a partial response (including a patient showing disappearance of a distant noninjected tumor mass), four had a minor response, four had stable disease, and two had progressive disease. The 6- and 12-month progression-free survival rates were 47 and 14%, respectively. The 6- and 12-month overall survival rates were 58 and 25%, respectively. In conclusion, the results of our clinical protocol of gene therapy for recurrent GBM, based on combined delivery of a suicide and a cytokine gene, demonstrate that intratumor injection of RVPCs was safe, provided effective transduction of the therapeutic genes to target tumor cells, and activated a systemic cytokine cascade, with tumor responses in 50% of cases.

Gene technology based therapies in the brain

Gene therapy potentially represents one of the most important developments in modern medicine. Gene therapy, especially of cancer, has created exciting and elusive areas of therapeutic research in the past decade. In fact, the first gene therapy performed in a human was not against cancer but was performed to a 14 year old child suffering from adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency. In addition to cancer gene therapy there are many other diseases and disorders where gene therapy holds exciting and promising opportunities. These include amongst others gene therapy within the central nervous system and the cardiovascular system. Improvements of the efficiency and safety of gene therapy is the major goal of gene therapy development. After the death of Jesse Gelsinger, the first patient in whom death could be directly linked to the viral vector used for the treatment, ethical doubts were raised about the feasibility of gene therapy in humans. Therefore, the ability to direct gene transfer vectors to specific target cells is also a crucial task to be solved and will be important not only to achieve a therapeutic effect but also to limit potential adverse effects.

Combining cytotoxic and immune-mediated gene therapy to treat brain tumors

Glioblastoma (GBM) is a type of intracranial brain tumor, for which there is no cure. In spite of advances in surgery, chemotherapy and radiotherapy, patients die within a year of diagnosis. Therefore, there is a critical need to develop novel therapeutic approaches for this disease. Gene therapy, which is the use of genes or other nucleic acids as drugs, is a powerful new treatment strategy which can be developed to treat GBM. Several treatment modalities are amenable for gene therapy implementation, e.g. conditional cytotoxic approaches, targeted delivery of toxins into the tumor mass, immune stimulatory strategies, and these will all be the focus of this review. Both conditional cytotoxicity and targeted toxin mediated tumor death, are aimed at eliminating an established tumor mass and preventing further growth. Tumors employ several defensive strategies that suppress and inhibit anti-tumor immune responses. A better understanding of the mechanisms involved in eliciting anti-tumor immune responses has identified promising targets for immunotherapy. Immunotherapy is designed to aid the immune system to recognize and destroy tumor cells in order to eliminate the tumor burden. Also, immune-therapeutic strategies have the added advantage that an activated immune system has the capability of recognizing tumor cells at distant sites from the primary tumor, therefore targeting metastasis distant from the primary tumor locale. Pre-clinical models and clinical trials have demonstrated that in spite of their location within the central nervous system (CNS), a tissue described as 'immune privileged', brain tumors can be effectively targeted by the activated immune system following various immunotherapeutic strategies. This review will highlight recent advances in brain tumor immunotherapy, with particular emphasis on advances made using gene therapy strategies, as well as reviewing other novel therapies that can be used in combination with immunotherapy. Another important aspect of implementing gene therapy in the clinical arena is to be able to image the targeting of the therapeutics to the tumors, treatment effectiveness and progression of disease. We have therefore reviewed the most exciting non-invasive, in vivo imaging techniques which can be used in combination with gene therapy to monitor therapeutic efficacy over time.

Clinical trials with retrovirus mediated gene therapy--what have we learned?

Retrovirus (RV) has been one of the earliest recombinant vectors to be investigated in the context of cancer gene therapy. Experiments in cell culture and in animal brain tumor models have demonstrated the feasibility of RV mediated gene transduction and killing of glioma cells by toxicity generating transgenes. Phase I and II clinical studies in patients with recurrent malignant glioma have shown a favorable safety profile and some efficacy of RV mediated gene therapy. On the other hand, a prospective randomized phase III clinical study of RV gene therapy in primary malignant glioma failed to demonstrate significant extension of the progression-free or overall survival times in RV treated patients. The failure of this RV gene therapy study may be due to the low tumor cell transduction rate observed in vivo. The biological effects of the treatment may also heavily depend on the choice of transgene/prodrug system and on the vector delivery methods. Retrovirus clinical trials in malignant glioma have nevertheless produced a substantial amount of data and have contributed toward the identification of serious shortcomings of the non-replicating virus vector gene therapy strategy. Novel types of therapeutic virus vector systems are currently being designed and new clinical protocols are being created based on the lessons learned from the RV gene therapy trials in patients with malignant brain tumors.

Trafficking of superparamagnetic iron oxide particles (Combidex) from brain to lymph nodes in the rat

Central nervous system (CNS) drainage may occur via connections to the vasculature, but in animal models up to 50% occurs via perivascular, perineural and primitive lymphatic drainage to cervical lymph nodes. We evaluated efflux of particles from the brain to cervical lymph nodes in normal rats, using Combidex iron oxide-based magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) agent. After intracerebral, intraventricular, intracarotid or intravenous injection of Combidex in normal Long Evans rats, particle localization was assessed by MRI and histochemistry for iron and the dextran coat (n = 27). Intraventricular or intracerebral injection, but not intracarotid administration of Combidex (100 micro g), resulted in MRI signal changes in the deep cervical lymph nodes around the carotid artery, and, less strongly, in the superficial cervical nodes. Within 2 h of Combidex administration, iron was histologically localized in cervical lymph nodes, with patched staining of capsule and peripheral sinus consistent with delivery via multiple afferent lymphatic vessels. Lymph node staining in groups receiving CNS Combidex was significantly different from controls (P < 0.0001) and was significantly localized in the deep vs. superficial cervical lymph nodes (P = 0.0003). The trafficking of the superparamagnetic iron particles from the CNS in the rat could be visualized by MRI and histology. Combidex provides a powerful tool to rapidly assess drainage of virus-sized particles from the CNS.

Expression of mutant non-cleavable Fas ligand on retrovirus packaging cells causes apoptosis of immunocompetent cells and improves prodrug activation gene therapy in a malignant glioma model

Recombinant retroviruses (RV) have been widely used as vectors for clinical gene therapy of malignant brain tumors. Because of the very limited stability of these vectors in vivo, RV producing cells (VPC) are routinely used for intratumoral RV release. The host immune system, however, recognizes the intratumorally grafted allogeneic or xenogeneic VPC, and mounts an immune response against them. Humoral and cellular immune responses eventually result in reduction of VPC numbers and in limited success of RV mediated gene therapy approaches. This study presents a non-pharmacological and spatially limited approach for protection of VPC grafted in the CNS against destruction by host immune responses. Murine fibroblast-derived VPC expressing herpes-simplex-virus type I thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) were genetically modified to co-express a human Fas ligand (CD95L) deletion mutant (DeltaFasL) resistant to enzymatic cleavage and shedding. Direct interactions between Fas (CD95) on lymphocytes and DeltaFasL on VPC upon cell-cell contact rapidly caused apoptosis in lymphocytes. In addition, cultured malignant brain tumor cells (U87, LN18, LN229) transduced with DeltaFasL-RV were rendered apoptotic by Fas/DeltaFasL interaction. DeltaFasL-expressing VPC grafted in a 9L rat brain tumor model survived in significantly higher numbers compared with control VPC, and did not cause an increase in neutrophil infiltration of tumors. Gene therapy of tumor bearing animals grafted with the modified DeltaFasL-VPC and given the prodrug Ganciclovir resulted in significantly increased survival rates compared to treatment with control VPC and Ganciclovir. In conclusion, prolonged intratumoral presence of DeltaFasL-VPC seems to be a direct consequence of the expression of the membrane-bound mutant FasL, and may result in increased total RV output and improved tumor transduction with RV.

Human nerve growth factor receptor and cytosine deaminase fusion genes

Cytosine deaminase (CD) converts 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) to the toxic metabolite 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), and has been investigated extensively as a potential tool for selective cellular eradication. In this paper, genetic constructs were designed to express the CD enzyme fused to the transmembrane and extracellular domains of the human nerve growth factor receptor (NGFR), thus allowing for positive identification of transduced cells by flow cytometry and positive selection by magnetic bead technology. Constructs were designed to encode a [Gly(4)Ser](2) flexible linker between the nucleic acid coding sequences for the NGFR and CD genes. Retroviral vectors constructed with wild-type CD and NG/CD fusion genes were used to transduce 3T3 fibroblasts and the human T cell line CEM. The function of CD fusion genes was comparable to that of wild-type genes as determined in cytotoxicity assays. By flow cytometry, the NGFR antigen was detectable after expression of the fusion gene derived from either Escherichia coli (NG/CDe) or Saccharomyces cerevisiae (NG/CDs), but the greatest antigen density was observed in cells transduced with the NG/CDs vector. Similarly, superior 5-FC sensitivity was observed with NG/CDs fusion gene in both murine fibroblasts and human T cells. In addition, CEM cells expressing NG/CDs were more efficiently eliminated in vivo. Engineering of cells utilizing the chimeric NG/CD genes provides a new modality in gene therapy allowing positive and negative selection using a single protein-coding sequence.

Gene therapy for human malignant brain tumors

PURPOSE

Brain tumors were the first human malignancy to be targeted by therapeutic transfer of nucleic acids into somatic cells, a process also known as gene therapy. Malignant brain tumor cells in the adult brain have some unique biologic features, such as high mitotic activity on an essentially postmitotic background and virtually no tumor spread outside of the central nervous system. Brain tumors seem therefore to offer major advantages in the design of tumor-selective gene therapy strategies, and the role of gene therapy in malignant glioma has been investigated since the late 1980s, initially in numerous laboratory studies and later on in clinical trials.

DESIGN

Retrovirus has been one of the earliest recombinant virus vectors used in brain tumors. Experiments in cell culture and in animal models have demonstrated the feasibility of retrovirus-mediated transduction and subsequent killing of glioma cells by toxic transgenes. Phase I and II clinical studies in patients with recurrent malignant glioma have shown a favorable safety profile and some efficacy of retrovirus-mediated gene therapy. However, the only prospective, randomized, phase III clinical study of retrovirus gene therapy in primary malignant glioma failed to demonstrate significant extension of progression-free or overall survival. Adenovirus- and herpes simplex virus type 1-based vectors have been actively investigated along with retrovirus, but their clinical use is still limited, mostly because of safety concerns. To increase efficacy, novel generations of therapeutic adenovirus and herpes simplex virus type 1 rely more on genetically engineered and tumor-selective lytic properties and less on the actual transfer of therapeutic genes.

CONCLUSIONS

The failure of most clinical gene therapy protocols to produce a significant and unequivocal benefitto brain tumor patients seems to be mainly due to the low tumor cell transduction rates observed in vivo, but it may also depend on the respective physical delivery strategy of the vector. Standard radiologic criteria for assessing the efficacy of clinical treatments may also not be fully applicable to the specific metabolic changes and blood-brain barrier permeability phenomena caused in brain tumors by virus-mediated gene therapy. Clinical trials in malignant glioma have nevertheless produced a substantial amount of data and have contributed to the continuous improvement of vector systems, delivery methods, and clinical protocols.

Oncolytic viruses for treatment of malignant brain tumours

Wild type viruses have been known for decades for their capability to destroy malignant tumour cells upon infection and intracellular replication. Genetic engineering of such viruses was, however, only recently done in an attempt to improve their utility as biological anticancer agents. Wild type or recombinant viruses able to selectively destroy tumour cells while sparing normal tissue are known as oncolytic viruses. Most oncolytic viruses currently investigated in clinical trials are derived from adenovirus (AV) or herpes simplex virus type I (HSVI). More than 300 patients with solid tumours were now treated in clinical trials with oncolytic viruses, and in most cases virus was administered directly into the tumour mass. About 10% of the above patients had recurrent malignant glioma. Total intratumoral doses of up to 2 x 10(12) virus particles were well tolerated, and in general no severe side effects resulted from the clinical use of oncolytic AV and HSVI, either in the brain or in the rest of the body. Encouraging anti-tumoral activity was demonstrated in some types of tumours treated locally with oncolytic viruses, and systemic chemotherapy was found to potentiate the anti-tumour effect of virus mediated oncolysis. In malignant glioma, standard gene therapy approaches employing non-replicating virus vectors failed to demonstrate significant benefit in clinical studies. Therapy with oncolytic viruses seems to hold more promise in early clinical trials than gene therapy with non-replicating virus vectors. However, further major advancements in virus designs, application modalities, and understanding of the interactions of the host's immune system with the virus are clearly needed before oncolytic virus therapy of malignant brain tumours can be introduced to clinical practice.

Gene therapy of gliomas

Malignant glioma formation is associated with characteristic genetic alterations, although epigenetic mechanisms may contribute in tumorigenesis. Until recently, our knowledge has mainly been based on chromosomal and molecular studies performed in the last two decades. This has increased tremendously with the advent of new technologies, in particular expression arrays for simultaneous analysis of thousands of genes. Consequently, gene therapy of gliomas may aim at molecular interference with 'gain of function' genes (oncogenes) or replacement of 'loss of function' genes (tumor suppressor genes). Such approaches require transgene expression in whole tumor cell populations (if not other mechanisms come into play) which cannot be achieved with current vector systems. Hence other strategies have been pursued which may be independent of genes actually involved in tumorigenesis. Microbial genes (e.g. herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase) may be transferred into the tumors allowing for prodrug activation (e.g. ganciclovir). Furthermore, cytokines or other immunomodulatory genes may be used for vaccination purposes which frequently involves ex vivo transfection of autologous tumor cells with such genes. These approaches proved promising in preclinical studies performed in cell culture and different inbred rodent models. A considerable number of clinical trials have been initiated based on these approaches. Although most therapeutic strategies proved safe, clinical responses fell short of expectations raised by preclinical results. This, to a large extent, has to be attributed to a lag in the development of efficient vector systems. Although much effort has been put into this area of research, neuro-oncologists are still in await of a vector system allowing for selective and efficient tumor cell transduction. This has led to increased interest in distinct but related strategies, e.g. oncolytic viruses or direct intra-tumoral delivery of anti-sense oligonucleotides.

Viruses in the treatment of brain tumors

The grave outlook for malignant glioma patients in spite of improvements to current modalities has ushered in new approaches to therapy. Viruses have emerged on the scene and gained attention for their ability to play essentially two roles: first, as vectors for therapeutic gene delivery and second, as engineered infectious agents capable of selectively lysing tumor cells. To date, clinical brain tumor trials using viruses for gene delivery have employed retroviral or adenoviral vectors to introduce ganciclovir susceptibility to tumors in the form of the HSV1-TK gene. Clinical oncolytic studies, on the other hand, have evaluated a conditionally replicating HSV as an antineoplastic agent. Despite some promise afforded by these trials, further studies are warranted; the investigation of additional viruses to play these roles is inevitable and is now precedented.

Gene therapy for prostate cancer

Prostate cancer is the most common noncutaneous cancer in man. When confined to the prostate it can be cured by radical prostatectomy or irradiation therapy. However, there are no curative therapies for locally advanced, recurrent or metastatic disease. Prostate cancer gene therapy has recently transition from preclinical studies to clinical trials with the goal of developing novel treatments for prostate cancer. The greatest challenge in treating advanced prostate cancer is therapeutic access to and the elimination of metastases. This review details two aspects of prostate cancer gene therapy, the types of delivery systems under development and specific categories of therapeutic genes available with an emphasis on the mechanism of action of specific gene therapy strategies.

Gene therapy for high grade gliomas

High grade gliomas in adults are devastating diseases, with very poor survival despite their lack of distant metastases. Local treatments, such as surgical resection and stereotactic radiosurgery, have been most successful, whereas systemic therapy (for example, chemotherapy and immunotherapy) have been rather disappointing. Several gene therapy systems have been successful in controlling or eradicating these tumours in animal models and are now being tested as a logical addition to current clinical management. This review describes the gene therapy clinical protocols that have been completed or that are ongoing for human gliomas. These include the prodrug activating system, herpes simplex thymidine kinase (HSVtk)/ganciclovir (GCV), utilising either retrovirus vector producer cells or adenovirus vectors; adenovirus mediated p53 gene transfer; adenovirus mediated IFN-beta gene transfer and oncolytic herpes virus and adenovirus vectors. To date, all of the clinical studies have used direct injection of the vector into the glioma. The Phase I clinical studies have demonstrated low to moderate toxicity and variable levels of gene transfer and in some cases anti-tumour effect. Future directions will rely upon improvements in gene delivery as well as gene therapies and combinations of gene therapy with other treatment modalities.