Analysis of genome-wide CAG/CTG repeats, and at SEF2-1B and ERDA1 in schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder

Unstable repeat expansion in major psychiatric disorders: two decades on, is dynamic DNA back on the menu?

For a period in the mid-1990s, soon after the discovery of the involvement of trinucleotide repeat expansions in fragile-X syndrome (both A and E), Huntington's disease, myotonic dystrophy, and a number of hereditary ataxias, there was a clear sense that this new disease mechanism might provide answers for psychiatric disorders. Given the then failures to replicate initial genetic linkage findings for schizophrenia (SCZ) and bipolar disorder (BD), a greater emphasis was placed on the role of complex and non-Mendelian mechanisms, and repeat instability appeared to have the potential to provide adequate explanations for numerous apparently non-Mendelian features such as anticipation, incomplete penetrance, sporadic occurrence, and nonconcordance of monozygotic twins. Initial molecular studies using a ligation-based amplification method (repeat expansion detection) appeared to support the involvement of CAG•CTG repeat expansion in SCZ and BD. However, subsequent studies that dissected the large repeats responsible for much of the positive signal showed that there were three main loci where CAG•CTG repeat expansion was occurring (on 13q21.33, 17q21.33-q22, and 18q21.2). None of the expansions at these loci appeared to segregate with SCZ or BD, and research into repeat expansions in psychiatric illness petered out in the early 2000s. The 13q expansion occurs within a noncoding RNA and appears to be associated with spinocerebellar ataxia 8 (SCA8), but with a still unexplained dichotomy in penetrance - either very high or very low. The 17q expansion occurs within an intron of the carbonic anhydrase-like gene, CA10. The 18q expansion is located within an intron of the TCF4 gene. Mutations in TCF4 are a known cause of Pitt-Hopkins syndrome. Also, pertinently, genome-wide association studies have shown a well-replicated association between TCF4 and SCZ. Two decades on, in 2016, it appears to be an appropriate juncture to reflect on what we have learned, and, with the arrival of newer technologies, whether there is any mileage to be made in revisiting the unstable DNA hypothesis for psychiatric illness.

Hypothesis-driven candidate genes for schizophrenia compared to genome-wide association results

BACKGROUND

Candidate gene studies have been a key approach to the genetics of schizophrenia (SCZ). However, the results of these studies are confusing and no genes have been unequivocally implicated. The hypothesis-driven candidate gene literature can be appraised by comparison with the results of genome-wide association studies (GWAS).

METHOD

We describe the characteristics of hypothesis-driven candidate gene studies from the SZGene database, and use pathway analysis to compare hypothesis-driven candidate genes with GWAS results from the International Schizophrenia Consortium (ISC).

RESULTS

SZGene contained 732 autosomal genes evaluated in 1374 studies. These genes had poor statistical power to detect genetic effects typical for human diseases, assessed only 3.7% of genes in the genome, and had low marker densities per gene. Most genes were assessed once or twice (76.9%), providing minimal ability to evaluate consensus across studies. The ISC studies had 89% power to detect a genetic effect typical for common human diseases and assessed 79% of known autosomal common genetic variation. Pathway analyses did not reveal enrichment of smaller ISC p values in hypothesis-driven candidate genes, nor did a comprehensive evaluation of meta-hypotheses driving candidate gene selection (SCZ as a disease of the synapse or neurodevelopment). The most studied hypothesis-driven candidate genes (COMT, DRD3, DRD2, HTR2A, NRG1, BDNF, DTNBP1 and SLC6A4) had no notable ISC results.

CONCLUSIONS

We did not find support for the idea that the hypothesis-driven candidate genes studied in the literature are enriched for the common genetic variation involved in the etiology of SCZ. Larger samples are required to evaluate this conclusion definitively.

The genetics of bipolar disorder: genome 'hot regions,' genes, new potential candidates and future directions

Bipolar disorder (BP) is a complex disorder caused by a number of liability genes interacting with the environment. In recent years, a large number of linkage and association studies have been conducted producing an extremely large number of findings often not replicated or partially replicated. Further, results from linkage and association studies are not always easily comparable. Unfortunately, at present a comprehensive coverage of available evidence is still lacking. In the present paper, we summarized results obtained from both linkage and association studies in BP. Further, we indicated new potential interesting genes, located in genome 'hot regions' for BP and being expressed in the brain. We reviewed published studies on the subject till December 2007. We precisely localized regions where positive linkage has been found, by the NCBI Map viewer (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/mapview/); further, we identified genes located in interesting areas and expressed in the brain, by the Entrez gene, Unigene databases (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/) and Human Protein Reference Database (http://www.hprd.org); these genes could be of interest in future investigations. The review of association studies gave interesting results, as a number of genes seem to be definitively involved in BP, such as SLC6A4, TPH2, DRD4, SLC6A3, DAOA, DTNBP1, NRG1, DISC1 and BDNF. A number of promising genes, which received independent confirmations, and genes that have to be further investigated in BP, have been also systematically listed. In conclusion, the combination of linkage and association approaches provided a number of liability genes. Nevertheless, other approaches are required to disentangle conflicting findings, such as gene interaction analyses, interaction with psychosocial and environmental factors and, finally, endophenotype investigations.

TGFB-induced factor (TGIF): a candidate gene for psychosis on chromosome 18p

Schizophrenia (SC) and bipolar disorder (BP) share many clinical features, among them psychosis. We previously identified a putative gene locus for psychosis on chromosome 18p in a sample from the Central Valley of Costa Rica (CVCR) population. The present study replicated the association to a specific allele of microsatellite marker D18S63 on 18p11.3, using a newly collected sample from the CVCR. A combined analysis of both samples, plus additional subjects, showed that this specific allele on D18S63, which lies within an intron on the TGFB-induced factor (TGIF) gene, is strongly associated (P-value=0.0005) with psychosis. Eleven additional SNP markers, spanning five genes in the region, were analyzed in the combined sample from the CVCR. Only the four SNPs within the TGIF gene were in strong linkage disequilibrium with D18S63 (D'=1.00). A specific haplotype for all five markers within the TGIF gene showed evidence of association (P-value=0.011) to psychosis. A second, distinct haplotype, containing a newly identified nonsynonymous polymorphism in exon 5 of the TGIF gene, showed a nonsignificant trend towards association to psychosis (P-value=0.077). TGIF is involved in neurodevelopment, neuron survival and controls the expression of dopamine receptors. Altogether, our results point to the possible involvement of TGIF in the pathophysiology of psychotic disorders in the CVCR population.

Family, twin, adoption, and molecular genetic studies of juvenile bipolar disorder

Juvenile bipolar disorder (JBD) has been a subject of significant research and debate. Phenotypic differences between JBD and adult-onset bipolar disorder have led researchers to question whether or not similar neuropathologic mechanisms will be found. While much is known about the genetic and environmental contributions to the adult-onset phenotype, less is known about their contributions to JBD. Here, we review family, twin, adoption, and molecular genetic studies of JBD. Behavioral genetic data suggest both genetic and environmental contributions to JBD, while molecular genetic studies find linkage to age of onset of bipolar disorder to chromosomes 12p, 14q, and 15q. Additionally, changes associated with symptom age of onset have been recently reported in the brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and glycogen synthase kinase 3-beta (GSK3-beta) genes. We contend that further progress in discovering the precise genetic and environmental contributions to JBD may depend on advances in phenotypic refinement, an increased appreciation of comorbid conditions, and more investigation of the longitudinal course of the disorder.

Characterization of CTG/CAG repeats on chromosome 18: a study of bipolar disorder

Anticipation has been frequently found in bipolar families ascertained for linkage studies. An association of polymorphic triplet repeats with the bipolar phenotype in some pedigrees has been proposed. We have previously found linkage to chromosome 18 in a set of families with evidence of anticipation. As part of a search for CAG/CTG motifs on chromosome 18, we screened a genomic chromosome 18 cosmid library and identified 65 loci with trinucleotide repeats. Eleven of 33 genotyped loci were polymorphic, though none of these showed any evidence of instability. We performed genetic analysis of six loci in the Hopkins/Dana bipolar pedigrees ascertained for a genetic linkage study of bipolar disorder and found that the CAG repeat within the AD4D2 clone on 18q21.1 showed nominally significant over-transmission of the rare CAG23 allele (P=0.034). We have characterized all 65 trinucleotide repeats and flanking sequences with GENSCAN analysis and find that 29 were predicted to be in coding regions. These 29 trinucleotide-repeat-containing genes may be involved in functional modulation of their respective proteins, and may be candidates for other diseases or disease mechanisms that map to this region.

Novel CAG/CTG repeat expansion mutations do not contribute to the genetic risk for most cases of bipolar disorder or schizophrenia

The possible presence of anticipation in bipolar affective disorder and schizophrenia has led to the hypothesis that repeat expansion mutations could contribute to the genetic etiology of these diseases. Using the repeat expansion detection (RED) assay, we have systematically examined genomic DNA from 100 unrelated probands with schizophrenia and 68 unrelated probands with bipolar affective disorder for the presence of CAG/CTG repeat expansions. Our results show that 28% of the probands with schizophrenia and 30% of probands with bipolar disorder have a CAG/CTG repeat in the expanded range, but that each expansion could be explained by one of three nonpathogenic repeat expansions known to exist in the general population. We conclude that novel CAG/CTG repeat expansions are not a common genetic risk factor for bipolar disorder or schizophrenia.

Anticipation and repeat expansion in bipolar disorder

Anticipation is the phenomenon whereby a disease becomes more severe and/or presents with earlier onset as it is transmitted down through generations of a family. The only known mechanism for true anticipation is a class of mutations containing repetitive sequences exemplified by the pathogenic trinucleotide repeat. Studies of bipolar disorder (BPD) are consistent with the presence of anticipation and, by inference, the possibility that trinucleotide repeats contribute to this disorder, although it is possible that these data are the result of methodological problems. On the assumption that anticipation in BPD may be real, several surveys of the genome of BPD probands for large trinucleotide repeats have been conducted, as have studies of many repeat-containing candidate genes. No pathogenic triplet repeat has yet been unambiguously implicated.

The unstable trinucleotide repeat story of major psychosis

New hopes for cloning susceptibility genes for schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder followed the discovery of a novel type of DNA mutation, namely unstable DNA. One class of unstable DNA, trinucleotide repeat expansion, is the causal mutation in myotonic dystrophy, fragile X mental retardation, Huntington disease and a number of other rare Mendelian neurological disorders. This finding has led researchers in psychiatric genetics to search for unstable DNA sites as susceptibility factors for schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder. Increased severity and decreased age at onset of disease in successive generations, known as genetic anticipation, was reported for undifferentiated psychiatric diseases and for myotonic dystrophy early in the twentieth century, but was initially dismissed as the consequence of ascertainment bias. Because unstable DNA was demonstrated to be a molecular substrate for genetic anticipation in the majority of trinucleotide repeat diseases including myotonic dystrophy, many recent studies looking for genetic anticipation have been performed for schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder with surprisingly consistent positive results. These studies are reviewed, with particular emphasis placed on relevant sampling and statistical considerations, and concerns are raised regarding the interpretation of such studies. In parallel, molecular genetic investigations looking for evidence of trinucleotide repeat expansion in both schizophrenia and bipolar disorder are reviewed. Initial studies of genome-wide trinucleotide repeats using the repeat expansion detection technique suggested possible association of large CAG/CTG repeat tracts with schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder. More recently, three loci have been identified that contain large, unstable CAG/CTG repeats that occur frequently in the population and seem to account for the majority of large products identified using the repeat expansion detection method. These repeats localize to an intron in transcription factor gene SEF2-1B at 18q21, a site named ERDA1 on 17q21 with no associated coding region, and the 3' end of a gene on 13q21, SCA8, that is believed to be responsible for a form of spinocerebellar ataxia. At present no strong evidence exists that large repeat alleles at either SEF2-1B or ERDA1 are involved in the etiology of schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Preliminary evidence suggests that large repeat alleles at SCA8 that are non-penetrant for ataxia may be a susceptibility factor for major psychosis. A fourth, but much more infrequently unstable CAG/CTG repeat has been identified within the 5' untranslated region of the gene, MAB21L1, on 13q13. A fifth CAG/CTG repeat locus has been identified within the coding region of an ion transporter, KCNN3 (hSKCa3), on 1q21. Although neither large alleles nor instability have been observed at KCNN3, this repeat locus has been extensively analyzed in association and family studies of major psychosis, with conflicting findings. Studies of polyglutamine containing genes in major psychosis have also shown some intriguing results. These findings, reviewed here, suggest that, although a major role for unstable trinucleotides in psychosis is unlikely, involvement at a more modest level in a minority of cases cannot be excluded, and warrants further investigation.

A novel CpG-associated brain-expressed candidate gene for chromosome 18q-linked bipolar disorder

We previously identified 18q21-q22 as a candidate region for bipolar (BP) disorder and constructed a yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) contig map. Here we identified three potential CpG islands using CCG/CGG YAC fragmentation. Analysis of available genomic sequences using bioinformatic tools identified an exon of 3639 bp downstream of a CpG island of 1.2 kb containing a putative transcription initiation site. The exon contained an open reading frame coding for 1212 amino acids with significant homology to the SART-2 protein; weaker homology was found with a series of sulphotransferases. Alignment of cDNA sequences of corresponding ESTs and RT-PCR sequencing predicted a transcript of 9.5 kb which was confirmed by Northern blot analysis. The transcript was expressed in different brain areas as well as in multiple other peripheral tissues. We performed an extensive mutation analysis in 113 BP patients. A total of nine single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were identified. Five SNPs predicted an amino acid change, of which two were present in BP patients but not in 163 control individuals.

European combined analysis of the CTG18.1 and the ERDA1 CAG/CTG repeats in bipolar disorder

Several groups have reported association between large CAG/CTG repeats in the genome and BP disorder using the Repeat Expansion Detection (RED) method. Molecular interpretation studies demonstrated that around 90% of the large CAG/CTG repeats detected by RED can by explained by repeat size at either the CTG18.1 or ERDA-1 locus. In this study we report the findings on a large European BP case-control sample analysed for these two frequently expanded repeats. The frequency of expanded alleles (>40 repeats) at the CTG18.1 locus was significantly higher in the subgroup of patients with a more severe phenotype BPI and a positive first degree family history than in a group of matched controls (9% vs 5%). No difference in ERDA-1 expansion frequency was seen between BP cases and matched controls. We conclude that the ERDA-1 locus is not related to the BP phenotype while expanded alleles at the CTG18.1 locus cannot be excluded as a vulnerability factor for BP disorder.

Triplet repeats and bipolar disorder

Anticipation, the phenomenon of a disease becoming more severe or having earlier onset as it is transmitted down the generations, was originally described in families with psychiatric illness but was thought due to ascertainment bias and became forgotten. Interest was rekindled when a number of neurodegenerative disorders that show this phenomenon, were found to be due to a novel form of mutation--unstable triplet repeats showing intergenerational expansion. Some recent studies of anticipation are consistent with its occurrence in bipolar disorder but are still associated with methodological problems making interpretation difficult. A number of case-control studies employing the repeat expansion detection (RED) technique have found longer repeats in bipolar probands but other studies have found no such association. Despite a large number of studies examining the role of various repeat containing candidate genes, a pathogenic triplet repeat has yet to be found for bipolar disorder. It is likely that the controversy surrounding anticipation and the existence of triplet repeats will only finally be resolved with the demonstration of such a mutation in the aetiology of bipolar disorder.

Genetics of affective disorders

Despite substantial evidence for heritability in affective disorders the contributing genes have proven elusive. Here we discuss the genetic epidemiology of depression, as well as methodological issues and results from molecular genetic studies. There has been rapid advances in genetics, genomics and statistical modelling, facilitating the search for molecular mechanisms underlying affective disorders and several strategies reviewed in this paper hold promise to provide progress in the field. Considering the poorly understood biological basis of vulnerability to affective disorders, the identification of genes involved in the pathophysiology will unravel mechanisms and pathways that could permit more personalized therapeutic strategies and result in new targets for pharmacological intervention.

Trinucleotide repeat expansions: do they contribute to bipolar disorder?

It has long been known that bipolar disorder has a true but complex genetic background. Reports on genetic anticipation in bipolar disorder opened the way to a new approach for genetic studies. Indeed, anticipation, a decreasing age at onset, and/or increasing disease severity in successive generations, were recently explained by an expansion of trinucleotide repeats in monogenic diseases like Huntington's disease and Fragile X syndrome. The involvement of trinucleotide repeat expansions in bipolar disorder received even more support when studies reported association of large CAG/CTG repeats with bipolar disorder. Even though a large number of studies have been conducted, this association is still unexplained. Here, we review the studies investigating the trinucleotide repeat expansion hypothesis in bipolar disorder. Studies on anticipation, on association of anonymous large CAG/CTG repeats and on specific trinucleotide repeats are critically analysed and discussed, showing a field with precipitate conclusions or inconclusive results. The analysis suggests that there are indications, though disputable, supporting the trinucleotide repeat expansion hypothesis in bipolar disorder, but no conclusive evidence has been hitherto provided.

Genetic basis of schizophrenia: trinucleotide repeats. An update

1. Recent developments in technologies permit systematic screening of the entire human genome as a strategy for identification of susceptibility genes of small effect that influence risk to complex traits, like schizophrenia (Schz), inflammatory bowel disease, bipolar affective disorder (BPAD) etc. 2. Schizophrenia is known to have a high heritability and a complex inheritance pattern. Several studies provide evidence that both genes and environment play a role in the etiology of schizophrenia. Linkage studies have observed racial and sex bias in the genetic constitution of schizophrenia. Schizophrenia also manifests clinical anticipation and genomic imprinting. 3. "Dynamic mutations" or "tandem repeat expansions" in DNA, explain a number of observations associated with clinical anticipation and genomic imprinting. In patient populations, the repeat expands well beyond the normal range, altering the biological function of the gene. These sequence are unstable and increase in size between family members in successive generations, giving rise to greater severity of disease. 4. Several workers have reported an association of trinucleotide repeat length with adult- and child-onset schizophrenia. One such expanded allele has been found at the CTG18.1 locus on the 18th chromosome. Other genes known to have similar mutation are SEF2-1, which codes for a helix-loop-helix protein, hSKCa3 gene, which codes for a calcium-activated potassium channel and the transthyretin gene. In schizophrenic patients, significant difference in allele frequency distribution of these genes has been reported. 5. Population based genetic research would not only help identify different subgroups of this of schizophrenia.

Anticipation, imprinting, trinucleotide repeat expansions and psychoses

1. Since 1991, approximately 20 trinucleotide repeat expansion type neurodegenerative disorders have been reported. They are clinically characterized by anticipation, i.e., worsening severity or earlier age at onset with each succeeding generation for an inherited disease, and imprinting, i.e., a process whereby specific genes are differentially marked during parental gametogenesis, resulting in the differential expression of these genes in the embryo and adult. 2. The phenomenon of anticipation in psychoses has been pointed out since the 19th century; however, it was ignored because no one knew the genetic mechanism underlying this type of inheritance pattern at the time, and because of several possible biases. 3. The discovery of trinucleotide repeat expansion diseases has reawakened interest in the phenomenon of anticipation in psychiatric diseases. Anticipation has been confirmed in schizophrenia, mood disorders, and anxiety disorders in much more sophisticated manners, although still not perfectly. 4. Molecular approaches as well as clinical ones have been taken to reveal the involvement of trinucleotide repeat expansion mechanism in psychoses by means of direct analyses of candidate genes, RED and DIRECT. Most efforts have been made for CAG type trinucleotide repeats. So far, direct analyses have failed to reveal pathogenic gene(s). There were several positive RED data at first, however, nowadays there seems to be a tendency of much more negative results. The DIRECT results did not support trinucleotide repeat expansions mechanism in psychoses either. One plausable explanation for the 'false positive' result is the presence of CAG trinucleotide repeats which are highly polymorphic but not associated with an obvious abnormal phenotype. Screening for trinucleotide repeats other than ones of the CAG type remained to be performed.

Allelic distribution of CTG18.1 in Caucasian populations: association studies in bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and ataxia

CTG18.1 is a highly polymorphic and unstable CTG repeat within an intron of the SEF2-1 gene. We tested the CTG18.1 repeat length in affective disorder, schizophrenia, and nonspecific ataxia; these diseases all have shown clinical evidence for anticipation. There was no difference in the allele frequencies comparing the controls and disease groups. The most common allele contains 11 CAGs (35%) followed by alleles with 14-17 CAGs (35%). There was no difference in the distribution of the alleles in the cases vs controls for ataxia (P = 0.11), affective disorders (P = 0.21), or schizophrenia (P = 0.26). The frequency of unstable CTG18.1 alleles was approximately 3% in a population of N. European descent and is not related to the phenotypes tested.

Genetics of bipolar affective disorder

Bipolar affective disorder is a highly heritable condition, as demonstrated in twin, family, and adoption studies. Morbid risk in first degree relatives is four to six times higher than the population prevalence of about 1%. However, the mode of inheritance is complex, and linkage findings have been difficult to replicate. Despite these limitations, consistent linkage findings have emerged on several chromosomes, notably 18p, 18q, 21q, 12q, 4p, and Xq. Two additional areas, 10p and 13q, have shown linkage in regions that appear to overlap with significant linkage findings in schizophrenia. Separate linkage studies in schizophrenia also have targeted the replicated bipolar linkages on 18p and 22q. New methods are being developed for fine mapping and candidate identification. Recent candidate gene studies include some positive results for the serotonin transporter gene on 17q and the catechol-o-methyltransferase gene on 22q. No other candidate gene studies are yet showing replicated results. A convincing demonstration for a susceptibility gene will probably require a mixture of case- control studies, family-based association methods, and pathophysiologic studies.

An unstable trinucleotide-repeat region on chromosome 13 implicated in spinocerebellar ataxia: a common expansion locus

Larger CAG/CTG trinucleotide-repeat tracts in individuals affected with schizophrenia (SCZ) and bipolar affective disorder (BPAD) in comparison with control individuals have previously been reported, implying a possible etiological role for trinucleotide repeats in these diseases. Two unstable CAG/CTG repeats, SEF2-1B and ERDA1, have recently been cloned, and studies indicate that the majority of individuals with large repeats as detected by repeat-expansion detection (RED) have large repeat alleles at these loci. These repeats do not show association of large alleles with either BPAD or SCZ. Using RED, we have identified a BPAD individual with a very large CAG/CTG repeat that is not due to expansion at SEF2-1B or ERDA1. From this individual's DNA, we have cloned a highly polymorphic trinucleotide repeat consisting of (CTA)n (CTG)n, which is very long ( approximately 1,800 bp) in this patient. The repeat region localizes to chromosome 13q21, within 1.2 cM of fragile site FRA13C. Repeat alleles in our sample were unstable in 13 (5.6%) of 231 meioses. Large alleles (>100 repeats) were observed in 14 (1. 25%) of 1,120 patients with psychosis, borderline personality disorder, or juvenile-onset depression and in 5 (.7%) of 710 healthy controls. Very large alleles were also detected for Centre d'Etude Polymorphisme Humaine (CEPH) reference family 1334. This triplet expansion has recently been reported to be the cause of spinocerebellar ataxia type 8 (SCA8); however, none of our large alleles above the disease threshold occurred in individuals either affected by SCA or with known family history of SCA. The high frequency of large alleles at this locus is inconsistent with the much rarer occurrence of SCA8. Thus, it seems unlikely that expansion alone causes SCA8; other genetic mechanisms may be necessary to explain SCA8 etiology.