A chemist's overview of surface electron spins

Resonant Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy of a Single-Molecule Kondo System

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) under ultrahigh vacuum and cryogenic conditions enables exploration of the relations between the adsorption geometry, electronic state, and vibrational fingerprints of individual molecules. TERS capability of reflecting spin states in open-shell molecular configurations is yet unexplored. Here, we use the tip of a scanning probe microscope to lift a perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic dianhydride (PTCDA) molecule from a metal surface to bring it into an open-shell spin one-half anionic state. We reveal a correlation between the appearance of a Kondo resonance in differential conductance spectroscopy and concurrent characteristic changes captured by the TERS measurements. Through a detailed investigation of various adsorbed and tip-contacted PTCDA scenarios, we infer that the Raman scattering on suspended PTCDA is resonant with a higher excited state. Theoretical simulation of the vibrational spectra enables a precise assignment of the individual TERS peaks to high-symmetry Ag modes, including the fingerprints of the observed spin state. These findings highlight the potential of TERS in capturing complex interactions between charge, spin, and photophysical properties in nanoscale molecular systems and suggest a pathway for designing single-molecule spin-optical devices.

Local decomposition of hybridization functions: Chemical insight into correlated molecular adsorbates

Hybridization functions are an established tool for investigating the coupling between a correlated subsystem (often a single transition metal atom) and its uncorrelated environment (the substrate and any ligands present). The hybridization function can provide valuable insight into why and how strong correlation features such as the Kondo effect can be chemically controlled in certain molecular adsorbates. To deepen this insight, we introduce a local decomposition of the hybridization function, based on a truncated cluster approach, enabling us to study individual effects on this function coming from specific parts of the systems (e.g., the surface, ligands, or parts of larger ligands). It is shown that a truncated-cluster approach can reproduce the Co 3d and Mn 3d hybridization functions from periodic boundary conditions in Co(CO)₄/Cu(001) and MnPc/Ag(001) qualitatively well. By locally decomposing the hybridization functions, it is demonstrated at which energies the transition metal atoms are mainly hybridized with the substrate or with the ligand. For the Kondo-active 3d_x²-y² orbital in Co(CO)₄/Cu(001), the hybridization function at the Fermi energy is substrate-dominated, so we can assign its enhancement compared with ligand-free Co to an indirect effect of ligand-substrate interactions. In MnPc/Ag(001), the same is true for the Kondo-active orbital, but for two other orbitals, there are both direct and indirect effects of the ligand, together resulting in such strong screening that their potential Kondo activity is suppressed. A local decomposition of hybridization functions could also be useful in other areas, such as analyzing the electrode self-energies in molecular junctions.

Synthesis and Thin Films of Thermally Robust Quartet (S = 3/2) Ground State Triradical

High-spin (S = 3/2) organic triradicals may offer enhanced properties with respect to several emerging technologies, but those synthesized to date typically exhibit small doublet quartet energy gaps and/or possess limited thermal stability and processability. We report a quartet ground state triradical 3, synthesized by a Pd(0)-catalyzed radical-radical cross-coupling reaction, which possesses two doublet-quartet energy gaps, ΔE_DQ ≈ 0.2-0.3 kcal mol^-1 and ΔE_DQ2 ≈ 1.2-1.8 kcal mol^-1. The triradical has a 70+% population of the quartet ground state at room temperature and good thermal stability with onset of decomposition at >160 °C under an inert atmosphere. Magnetic properties of 3 are characterized by SQUID magnetometry in polystyrene glass and by quantitative EPR spectroscopy. Triradical 3 is evaporated under ultrahigh vacuum to form thin films of intact triradicals on silicon substrate, as confirmed by high-resolution X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. AFM and SEM images of the ∼1 nm thick films indicate that the triradical molecules form islands on the substrate. The films are stable under ultrahigh vacuum for at least 17 h but show onset of decomposition after 4 h at ambient conditions. The drop-cast films are less prone to degradation in air and have a longer lifetime.

Manipulation of Molecular Spin State on Surfaces Studied by Scanning Tunneling Microscopy

The adsorbed magnetic molecules with tunable spin states have drawn wide attention for their immense potential in the emerging fields of molecular spintronics and quantum computing. One of the key issues toward their application is the efficient controlling of their spin state. This review briefly summarizes the recent progress in the field of molecular spin state manipulation on surfaces. We focus on the molecular spins originated from the unpaired electrons of which the Kondo effect and spin excitation can be detected by scanning tunneling microscopy and spectroscopy (STM and STS). Studies of the molecular spin-carriers in three categories are overviewed, i.e., the ones solely composed of main group elements, the ones comprising 3d-metals, and the ones comprising 4f-metals. Several frequently used strategies for tuning molecular spin state are exemplified, including chemical reactions, reversible atomic/molecular chemisorption, and STM-tip manipulations. The summary of the successful case studies of molecular spin state manipulation may not only facilitate the fundamental understanding of molecular magnetism and spintronics but also inspire the design of the molecule-based spintronic devices and materials.

Structural, Electronic, and Magnetic Properties of Cobalt Tetrakis (Thiadiazole) Porphyrazine Molecule Films on Au(111)

We investigated the structural and electronic/spin configurations of a film of the Co tetrakis(1,2,5-thiadiazole) porphyrazine (CoTTDPz) molecule adsorbed on the Au(111) surface by a scanning tunneling microscope (STM). CoTTDPz has a structure similar to that of the Co phthalocyanine molecule, but the benzene ring of the isoindole of the phthalocyanine molecule is replaced by the pentagon moiety of 1,2,5-thiadiazoles that has an S atom at the apex. We find an ordered molecular lattice with a threefold symmetry where a nearest-neighbor distance of 1.30 nm was measured, which is significantly smaller than that observed for the metal Pc molecule. The unit cell of the lattice contains two molecules that are rotated by 60° relative to each other. With the configuration achieved by this rotation, the neighboring molecules can form a stronger interaction through bonding between the S atom at the apex of one molecule and the N atom of the other (the N atom that is bridging the thiadiazoles). The strong interaction between the molecule and the substrate appears in the spin state examined by the detection of the Kondo resonance, which is formed by the screening of an isolated spin by the conduction electron. Even though the existence of the spin was confirmed for the bulk and thick films of this molecule, no Kondo features are detected for the molecules in the first, second, and third layers of the films. However, the isolated molecule in the third layer showed an intriguing combination of the Kondo feature and an inelastic excitation feature caused by a spin-flip process.

Zn+-O- Dual-Spin Surface State Formation by Modification of ZnO Nanoparticles with Diboron Compounds

ZnO semiconductor oxides are versatile functional materials that are used in photoelectronics, catalysis, sensing, etc. The Zn⁺-O^- surface electronic states of semiconductor oxides were formed on the ZnO surface by Zn 4s and O 2p orbital coupling with the diboron compound's B 2p orbitals. The formation of spin-coupled surface states was based on the spin-orbit interaction on the interface, which has not been reported before. This shows that the semiconductor oxide's spin surface states can be modulated by regulating surface orbital energy. The Zn⁺-O^- surface electronic states were confirmed by electron spin resonance results, which may help in expanding the fundamental research on spintronics modulation and quantum transport.

On Controllability and Applicability of Surface Molecular Self-Assemblies

Molecular self-assembly (MSA) refers to spontaneous arrangement of molecular building blocks into ordered structures governed by weak interactions. Due to its high versatility and reversibility, MSA has been widely employed as a robust bottom-up approach to fabricating low-dimensional functional nanostructures, which are used in various applications in nanoscience and technology. To date, tremendous effort has been devoted to constructing various MSAs at surfaces, ranging from self-assembled monolayers and two-dimensional (2D) nanoporous networks to complex 2D quasicrystals and Sierpiński triangle fractals. However, precise control of the assembled structures and efficient achievement of their full applicability remain two major challenges in the MSA field. As another widely employed bottom-up approach to fabricating nanostructures, on-surface reaction (OSR) refers to a reaction that occurs on the surface and is two-dimensionally confined. OSR offers the possibility to synthesize compounds that may not be feasibly achieved in solution chemistry. Compared with MSA based on weak intermolecular interactions, OSR-based structures possess high thermal and chemical stabilities due to internal strong covalent bonds. In this Account, we briefly overview recent achievements of MSAs on single crystal metal surfaces with a focus on their controllability and applicability in tweaking the properties of the molecular building blocks involved. Emphasis will be particularly placed upon mediation of OSRs with the MSA strategy. To explore surface MSAs, on the one hand, scanning tunneling microscopy and spectroscopy have been routinely employed as the experimental tools to probe the intermolecular interactions as well as geometric and electronic structures of the assemblies at the atomic and molecular levels. On the other hand, density functional theory and molecular dynamics have been theoretically applied to model and calculate the assembling systems, furthering our understanding of the experimental results. In principle, MSA is primarily balanced by molecule-molecule and molecule-substrate interactions under vacuum conditions. In terms of the assembling methodologies, people have been attempting to achieve rational design, accurate prediction, and controllable construction of assembled molecular nanostructures, namely, tentative design of specific backbones and functional groups of the molecular building blocks, and careful control of the assembling parameters including substrate lattice, temperature, coverage, and external environment as well. An obvious goal for the development of these methodologies lies in the ultimate applications of these MSAs. MSA can retrospectively affect the properties of the assembling molecules. For instance, self-assembled structures not only can serve as secondary templates to host guest molecules but also can stabilize surface metal adatoms. In fact, the electronics, magnetism, and optics of MSAs have been successfully explored. In surface chemistry, the MSA strategy can be further applied to mediate OSRs in at least three aspects: tweaking reaction selectivity, changing reaction pathway, and restricting reaction site. The governing principle lies in that the self-assembled molecules are confined in the assemblies so that the pre-exponential factors and the energy barriers in the Arrhenius equation of the involved reactions could be substantially varied because the subtle reaction mechanisms may change upon assembling. In this sense, the MSA strategy can be efficiently exploited to tune the properties of the assembling molecules and mediate OSRs in surface chemistry.

Thermally and Magnetically Robust Triplet Ground State Diradical

High spin ( S = 1) organic diradicals may offer enhanced properties with respect to several emerging technologies, but typically exhibit low singlet triplet energy gaps and possess limited thermal stability. We report triplet ground state diradical 2 with a large singlet-triplet energy gap, Δ E_ST ≥ 1.7 kcal mol^-1, leading to nearly exclusive population of triplet ground state at room temperature, and good thermal stability with onset of decomposition at ∼160 °C under inert atmosphere. Magnetic properties of 2 and the previously prepared diradical 1 are characterized by SQUID magnetometry of polycrystalline powders, in polystyrene glass, and in other matrices. Polycrystalline diradical 2 forms a novel one-dimensional (1D) spin-1 ( S = 1) chain of organic radicals with intrachain antiferromagnetic coupling of J'/ k = -14 K, which is associated with the N···N and N···O intermolecular contacts. The intrachain antiferromagnetic coupling in 2 is by far strongest among all studied 1D S = 1 chains of organic radicals, which also makes 1D S = 1 chains of 2 most isotropic, and therefore an excellent system for studies of low-dimensional magnetism. In polystyrene glass and in frozen benzene or dibutyl phthalate solution, both 1 and 2 are monomeric. Diradical 2 is thermally robust and is evaporated under ultrahigh vacuum to form thin films of intact diradicals on silicon substrate, as demonstrated by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. Based on C-K NEXAFS spectra and AFM images of the ∼1.5 nm thick films, the diradical molecules form islands on the substrate with molecules stacked approximately along the crystallographic a-axis. The films are stable under ultrahigh vacuum for at least 60 h but show signs of decomposition when exposed to ambient conditions for 7 h.

Nanoscale Studies of Organic Radicals: Surface, Interface, and Spinterface

In the last decade technology has brought significant changes to our lives, including new habits and a new view on social relationships. These technological innovations are based on several factors, one of which is miniaturization. This was made possible also due to the discovery and synthesis of new materials with characteristics at the nanoscale that are designed for specific purposes. This "on purpose" approach, joined to the development of preparation and growth methods, has led to use of thin films rather than bulk materials in devices. Using thin films makes devices easier to produce, and using films for coating protects the devices and gives specific properties to surfaces. For several decades thin films, surfaces, and interfaces have been intensively investigated. Indeed, device performances rely on the optimized match of thin films of different natures, such as organic and inorganic semiconductors and metals for contacts. Surprisingly, in comparison, little attention has been devoted to the deposition of organic radicals on a substrate. This might be because these materials are considered not stable enough for evaporation. In this work, we demonstrate that it is possible to evaporate and deposit organic radicals onto well-defined surfaces under controlled conditions, without degradation. Using soft X-ray spectroscopies, performed also at synchrotrons, we investigate thin film processes, surfaces, and interfaces at the nanoscale, when organic radicals are deposited on metal and metal oxide surfaces. We suggest how to design organic radicals bearing in mind the thermodynamic factors that govern thin film stability, with the purpose of obtaining not only a chemically stable radical, but also stable thin films. We investigate the thermal and air stability of the deposited films, and we explore the influence of the surface/radical chemical bond and the role of surface defects on the magnetic moment at the interface. We find that organic radicals are physisorbed and keep their magnetic moment on inert and passivated surfaces such as Au(111) and Al₂O₃(112̅0) single crystals, SiO₂, and ideal TiO₂(110) single crystals, while defective sites such as oxygen vacancies or the presence of OH groups lead to chemisorption of the organic radicals on the surface with quenching of their magnetic moment. Our work shows that the use of X-ray based techniques represents a powerful approach to reveal the mechanisms governing complex interfaces, such as radical/metal and radical/metal-oxide, where it is important to describe both charge and spin behavior (spinterfaces). It also makes it possible to conceive new experiments to investigate the magnetic character of the thin films versus their structural properties, toward tuning the arrangement of the molecules in films. Controlling the molecular arrangement will give the opportunity to tune the mutual position and orientation of the molecules, that is, of the single magnetic moments in the films, "imprinting" their magnetic properties. A deep understanding of stable radical/inorganic spinterfaces may open the way to use radicals in solid state devices or as quantum bits with dedicated configurations, as proposed for other molecular quantum bits, and in spin-based electronics.

Steering on-surface reactions with self-assembly strategy

The control of assembly structures that subsequently help achieve viable functionalities has been one of the key motivations for the exploration of surface molecular assembly. In terms of its functionality and applicability, the assembly is explored as a strategy to steer on-surface reactions primarily by two methods: assembly-assisted and assembly-involved reactions. The functions of the self-assembly strategy are threefold: tweaking reaction selectivities, steering reaction pathways, and directing reaction sites. The governing principle herein is that the assembly strategy can apply a surface confinement effect that affects the energy barrier and pre-exponential factor of the Arrhenius equation for the dynamics of the target reaction. Development of such a strategy may reveal new routes to steer on-surface reactions and even single molecule properties in surface chemistry.

Magnetic-Field-Induced Superconductivity in Ultrathin Pb Films with Magnetic Impurities

It is well known that external magnetic fields and magnetic moments of impurities both suppress superconductivity. Here, we demonstrate that their combined effect enhances the superconductivity of a few atomic layer thick Pb films grown on a cleaved GaAs(110) surface. A Ce-doped film, where superconductivity is totally suppressed at a zero field, actually turns superconducting when an external magnetic field is applied parallel to the conducting plane. For films with Mn adatoms, the screening of the magnetic moment by conduction electrons, i.e., the Kondo singlet formation, becomes important. We found that the degree of screening can be reduced by capping the Pb film with a Au layer, and observed the positive magnetic field dependence of the superconducting transition temperature.