Bonding and Acidity of the Formal Hydride in the Prototypical Au9 (PPh3 )8 H2+ Nanocluster

The role of hydrogen atoms as surface ligands on metal nanoclusters is of profound importance but remains difficult to directly study. While hydrogen atoms often appear to be incorporated formally as hydrides, evidence suggests that they donate electrons to the cluster's delocalized superatomic orbitals and may consequently behave as acidic protons that play key roles in synthetic or catalytic mechanisms. Here we directly test this assertion for the prototypical Au9 (PPh3 )8 H2+ nanocluster, formed by addition of a hydride to the well-characterized Au9 (PPh3 )8 3+ . Using gas-phase infrared spectroscopy, we were able to unambiguously isolate Au9 (PPh3 )8 H2+ and Au9 (PPh3 )8 D2+ , revealing an Au-H stretching mode at 1528 cm-1 that shifts to 1038 cm-1 upon deuteration. This shift is greater than the maximum expected for a typical harmonic potential, suggesting a potential governing cluster-H bonding that has some square-well character consistent with the hydrogen nucleus behaving as a metal atom in the cluster core. Complexing this cluster with very weak bases reveals a redshift of 37 cm-1 in the Au-H vibration, consistent with those typically seen for moderately acidic groups in gas phase molecules and providing an estimate of the acidity of Au9 (PPh3 )8 H2+ , at least with regard to its surface reactivity.

Chloride Ligands on DNA-Stabilized Silver Nanoclusters

DNA-stabilized silver nanoclusters (Ag_N-DNAs) are known to have one or two DNA oligomer ligands per nanocluster. Here, we present the first evidence that Ag_N-DNA species can possess additional chloride ligands that lead to increased stability in biologically relevant concentrations of chloride. Mass spectrometry of five chromatographically isolated near-infrared (NIR)-emissive Ag_N-DNA species with previously reported X-ray crystal structures determines their molecular formulas to be (DNA)₂[Ag₁₆Cl₂]⁸⁺. Chloride ligands can be exchanged for bromides, which red-shift the optical spectra of these emitters. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the 6-electron nanocluster show that the two newly identified chloride ligands were previously assigned as low-occupancy silvers by X-ray crystallography. DFT also confirms the stability of chloride in the crystallographic structure, yields qualitative agreement between computed and measured UV-vis absorption spectra, and provides interpretation of the ³⁵Cl-nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of (DNA)₂[Ag₁₆Cl₂]⁸⁺. A reanalysis of the X-ray crystal structure confirms that the two previously assigned low-occupancy silvers are, in fact, chlorides, yielding (DNA)₂[Ag₁₆Cl₂]⁸⁺. Using the unusual stability of (DNA)₂[Ag₁₆Cl₂]⁸⁺ in biologically relevant saline solutions as a possible indicator of other chloride-containing Ag_N-DNAs, we identified an additional Ag_N-DNA with a chloride ligand by high-throughput screening. Inclusion of chlorides on Ag_N-DNAs presents a promising new route to expand the diversity of Ag_N-DNA structure-property relationships and to imbue these emitters with favorable stability for biophotonics applications.

Poly-Hydride [AuI 7 (PPh3 )7 H5 ](SbF6 )2 cluster complex: Structure, Transformation, and Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction Properties

Hydride Au^I bonds are labile due to the mismatch in electric potential of an oxidizing metal and reducing ligand, and therefore the structure and structure-activity relationships of nanoclusters that contain them are seldom studied. Herein, we report the synthesis and characterization of [Au₇ (PPh₃ )₇ H₅ ](SbF₆ )₂ (abbrev. Au₇ H₅ ²⁺ ), an Au cluster complex containing five hydride ligands, which decomposed to give [Au₈ (PPh₃ )₇ ]²⁺ (abbrev. Au₈ ²⁺ ) upon exposure to light (300 to 450 nm). The valence state of Au^I and H^- was verified by density functional theory (DFT) calculations, NMR, UV/Vis and XPS. The two nanoclusters behaved differently in the electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂ RR): Au₇ H₅ ²⁺ exhibited 98.2 % selectivity for H₂ , whereas Au₈ ²⁺ was selective for CO (73.5 %). Further DFT calculations showed that the H^- ligand inhibited the CO₂ RR process compared with the electron-donor H.

Synthesis and Stability of Mixed-Diphosphine Ligated Gold Clusters

Sub-nanometer gold clusters are promising size- and composition-tunable materials that may be used for advanced technological applications such as catalysis, energy generation, and microelectronics. Synthesis and characterization of phosphine ligated gold clusters containing different ligands provide insight into how steric and electronic effects resulting from changes in chemical functionality influence cluster size, stability, and formation in solution. Herein, we demonstrate that synthesizing gold clusters using two different diphosphines in solution at the same time results in a broad distribution of novel mixed-ligand clusters. In comparison, adding a second diphosphine to a solution of gold clusters presynthesized with another diphosphine does not result in extensive formation of mixed-ligand species. Utilizing high-mass resolution electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, we determined novel cluster compositions and observed size-dependent trends in gold clusters that undergo ligand exchange forming mixed diphosphine species. Adjacent peaks in the mass spectra, separated by characteristic mass-to-charge ratios, provide evidence for multiple 1,3-bis(diphenylphosphino)propane (L³) and 1,5-bis(diphenylphosphino)pentane (L⁵) ligands on cationic clusters containing 8, 10, 11, and 22 gold atoms. Energy-resolved collision-induced dissociation experiments provide qualitative insight into how different diphosphine ligands affect the relative stability of specific size gold clusters. Our results indicate that mixed-ligand clusters containing both L³ and L⁵ are generally more stable than their single ligand counterparts containing either L³ or L⁵. These molecular-level insights will facilitate the rational and scalable synthesis of gold clusters for targeted applications.

A Review of State of the Art in Phosphine Ligated Gold Clusters and Application in Catalysis

Atomically precise gold clusters are highly desirable due to their well-defined structure which allows the study of structure-property relationships. In addition, they have potential in technological applications such as nanoscale catalysis. The structural, chemical, electronic, and optical properties of ligated gold clusters are strongly defined by the metal-ligand interaction and type of ligands. This critical feature renders gold-phosphine clusters unique and distinct from other ligand-protected gold clusters. The use of multidentate phosphines enables preparation of varying core sizes and exotic structures beyond regular polyhedrons. Weak gold-phosphorous (Au-P) bonding is advantageous for ligand exchange and removal for specific applications, such as catalysis, without agglomeration. The aim of this review is to provide a unified view of gold-phosphine clusters and to present an in-depth discussion on recent advances and key developments for these clusters. This review features the unique chemistry, structural, electronic, and optical properties of gold-phosphine clusters. Advanced characterization techniques, including synchrotron-based spectroscopy, have unraveled substantial effects of Au-P interaction on the composition-, structure-, and size-dependent properties. State-of-the-art theoretical calculations that reveal insights into experimental findings are also discussed. Finally, a discussion of the application of gold-phosphine clusters in catalysis is presented.

Synthesis and solution isomerization of water-soluble Au9 nanoclusters prepared by nuclearity conversion of [Au11(PPh3)8Cl2]Cl

Water-soluble gold nanoclusters (AuNCs) are popular in biomedical applications such as bioimaging, labelling, drug delivery, and biosensing. Despite their widespread applications, the synthesis of water-soluble phosphine-capped AuNCs is not as straightforward as their organic-soluble equivalents. Organic soluble phosphine-passivated [Au₉(L)₈]³⁺ are 6-electron closed-shell AuNCs that are generally prepared via the reduction of a phosphine-Au(I) complex by NaBH₄. A similar approach attempted for the water-soluble ligand triphenylphosphine monosulfonate (TPPMS) using [AuTPPMS]Cl resulted in a mixture of cluster sizes that required gel electrophoresis or fractional precipitation to isolate the Au₉ product. In this work, we report the synthesis of water-soluble [Au₉(L)₈]³⁺ nanoclusters in high yield through the biphasic ligand exchange of [Au₁₁(PPh₃)₈Cl₂]Cl with water-soluble phosphines such as TPPMS and 4-(diphenylphosphino)benzoic acid (DPPBA). The small molecule byproducts can be completely removed by size-based separation methods, like size exclusion chromatography or dialysis, as confirmed by ³¹P and ¹H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) as well as diffusion ordered spectroscopy (DOSY). Furthermore, [Au₉(DPPBA)₈]Cl₃ underwent a visible pH- and temperature-induced isomerization in ethanol between the 'crown' and 'butterfly' isomers of [Au₉(L)₈]³⁺ which has not been previously reported. Cytotoxicity evaluation of these water-soluble nanoclusters gave CC₅₀ values of 36 μg mL^-1 and 70 μg mL^-1 against A549 human alveolar epithelial cells, and 30 μg mL^-1 and 40 μg mL^-1 against NIH/3T3 mouse fibroblast cells for [Au₉(TPPMS)₈]Cl₃ and [Au₉(DPPBA)₈]Cl₃, respectively. For comparison, auranofin, an FDA-approved gold drug, is more than an order of magnitude more toxic with a CC₅₀ value of 7.7 μg mL^-1 against A549 cells.

Hydride- and halide-substituted Au9(PH3)83+ nanoclusters: similar absorption spectra disguise distinct geometries and electronic structures

Ligands dramatically affect the electronic structure of gold nanoclusters (NCs) and provide a useful handle to tune the properties required for nanomaterials that have high performance for important functions like catalysis. Recently, questions have arisen about the nature of the interactions of hydride and halide ligands with Au NCs: hydride and halide ligands have similar effects on the absorption spectra of Au₉ NCs, which suggested that the interactions of the two classes of ligands with the Au core may be similar. Here, we elucidate the interactions of halide and hydride ligands with phosphine-protected gold clusters via theoretical investigations. The computed absorption spectra using time-dependent density functional theory are in reasonable agreement with the experimental spectra, confirming that the computational methods are capturing the ligand-metal interactions accurately. Despite the similarities in the absorption spectra, the hydride and halide ligands have distinct geometric and electronic effects. The hydride ligand behaves as a metal dopant and contributes its two electrons to the number of superatomic electrons, while the halides act as electron-withdrawing ligands and do not change the number of superatomic electrons. Clarifying the binding modes of these ligands will aid in future efforts to use ligand derivatization as a powerful tool to rationally design Au NCs for use in functional materials.

The synthesis and characterization of a new diphosphine-protected gold hydride nanocluster

Gold is the most inert metal and does not form a bulk hydride. However, gold becomes chemically active in the nanometer scale and gold nanoparticles have been found to exhibit important catalytic properties. Here, we report the synthesis and characterization of a highly stable ligand-protected gold hydride nanocluster, [Au₂₂H₃(dppee)₇]³⁺ [dppee = bis(2-diphenylphosphino) ethyl ether]. A synthetic method is developed to obtain high purity samples of the gold trihydride nanocluster with good yields. The properties of the new hydride cluster are characterized with different experimental techniques, as well as theoretical calculations. Solid samples of [Au₂₂H₃(dppee)₇]³⁺ are found to be stable under ambient conditions. Both experimental evidence and theoretical evidence suggest that the Au₂₂H₃ core of the [Au₂₂H₃(dppee)₇]³⁺ hydride nanocluster consists of two Au₁₁ units bonded via two triangular faces, creating six uncoordinated Au sites at the interface. The three H atoms bridge the six uncoordinated Au atoms at the interface. The Au₁₁ unit behaves as an eight-electron trivalent superatom, forming a superatom triple bond (Au₁₁ ≡ Au₁₁) in the [Au₂₂H₃(dppee)₇]³⁺ trihydride nanocluster assisted by the three bridging H atoms.

Toward quantitative electronic structure in small gold nanoclusters

Ligand-protected gold nanoclusters (AuNCs) feature a dense but finite electronic structure that can be rationalized using qualitative descriptions such as the well-known superatomic model and predicted using quantum chemical calculations. However, the lack of well-resolved experimental probes of a AuNC electronic structure has made the task of evaluating the accuracy of electronic structure descriptions challenging. We compare electronic absorption spectra computed using time-dependent density functional theory to recently collected high resolution experimental spectra of Au₉(PPh₃)₈ ³⁺ and Au₈(PPh₃)₇ ²⁺ AuNCs with strikingly similar features. After applying a simple scaling correction, the computed spectrum of Au₈(PPh₃)₇ ²⁺ yields a suitable match, allowing us to assign low-energy metal-metal transitions in the experimental spectrum. No similar match is obtained after following the same procedure for two previously reported isomers for Au₉(PPh₃)₈ ³⁺, suggesting either a deficiency in the calculations or the presence of an additional isomer. Instead, we propose assignments for Au₉(PPh₃)₈ ³⁺ based off of similarities Au₈(PPh₃)₇ ²⁺. We further model these clusters using a simple particle-in-a-box analysis for an asymmetrical ellipsoidal superatomic core, which allows us to reproduce the same transitions and extract an effective core size and shape that agrees well with that expected from crystal structures. This suggests that the superatomic model, which is typically employed to explain the qualitative features of nanocluster electronic structures, remains valid even for small AuNCs with highly aspherical cores.

Cubic aromaticity in ligand-stabilized doped Au superatoms

The magnetic response of valence electrons in doped gold-based M@Au₈L₈ ^q superatoms (M = Pd, Pt, Ag, Au, Cd, Hg, Ir, and Rh; L = PPh₃; and q = 0, +1, +2) is studied by calculating the gauge including magnetically induced currents (GIMIC) in the framework of the auxiliary density functional theory. The studied systems include 24 different combinations of the dopant, total cluster charge, and cluster structure (cubic-like or oblate). The magnetically induced currents (both diatropic and paratropic) are shown to be sensitive to the atomic structure of clusters, the number of superatomic electrons, and the chemical nature of the dopant metal. Among the cubic-like structures, the strongest aromaticity is observed in Pd- and Pt-doped M@Au₈L₈ ⁰ clusters. Interestingly, Pd- and Pt-doping increases the aromaticity as compared to a similar all-gold eight-electron system Au₉L₈ ⁺¹. With the recent implementation of the GIMIC in the deMon2k code, we investigated the aromaticity in the cubic and butterfly-like M@Au₈ core structures, doped with a single M atom from periods 5 and 6 of groups IX-XII. Surprisingly, the doping with Pd and Pt in the cubic structure increases the aromaticity compared to the pure Au case not only near the central atom but encompassing the whole metallic core, following the aromatic trend Pd > Pt > Au. These doped (Pd, Pt)@Au₈ nanoclusters show a closed shell 1S²1P⁶ superatom electronic structure corresponding to the cubic aromaticity rule 6n + 2.

Ion Mobility Spectrometry Characterization of the Intermediate Hydrogen-Containing Gold Cluster Au7(PPh3)7H52

We employ ion mobility spectrometry and density functional theory to determine the structure of Au₇(PPh₃)₇H₅²⁺ (PPh₃ = triphenylphosphine), which was recently identified by high mass resolution mass spectrometry. Experimental ion-neutral collision cross sections represent the momentum transfer between the ionic clusters and gas molecules averaged over the relative thermal velocities of the colliding pair, thereby providing structural insights. Theoretical calculations indicate the geometry of Au₇(PPh₃)₇H₅²⁺ is similar to Au₇(PPh₃)₇⁺, with three hydrogen atoms bridging two gold atoms and two hydrogen atoms forming single Au-H bonds. Collision-induced dissociation products observed during IMS experiments reveal that smaller hydrogen-containing clusters may be produced through fragmentation of Au₇(PPh₃)₇H₅²⁺. Our findings indicate that hydrogen-containing species like Au₇(PPh₃)₇H₅²⁺ act as intermediates in the formation of larger phosphine ligated gold clusters. These results advance the understanding and ability to control the mechanisms of size-selective cluster formation, which is necessary for scalable synthesis of clusters with tailored properties.

ESI-MS Identification of the Cationic Phosphine-Ligated Gold Clusters Au1-22: Insight into the Gold-Ligand Ratio and Abundance of Larger Clusters

Triphenylphosphine (PPh₃)-ligated gold nanoclusters are valuable for a number of potential applications due to their relative ease of synthesis and usefulness in forming advanced cluster architectures. While previous studies have reported cationic PPh₃-ligated gold clusters with core sizes of Au_1-4, Au_6-11, and Au_13-14, there has not been definitive identification by mass spectrometry of many larger clusters in the Au_12-25 range. Herein, we survey a polydisperse solution of cationic PPh₃-ligated gold clusters using high-mass-resolution (M/ΔM = 60,000) electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). To improve the sensitivity and mass resolution of larger clusters for unambiguous identification, we increased the number of scan averages and reduced the range of mass collection windows to 200 m/z, thereby mitigating potential mass and ion abundance bias resulting from smaller "building block" gold clusters that are present in much higher abundance in solution. In addition to the previously reported clusters, we identify several new species including Au₅(PPh₃)₅⁺, Au₁₂(PPh₃)₉HCl²⁺, Au₁₅(PPh₃)₉Cl²⁺, Au₁₆(PPh₃)₁₀Cl₂²⁺, Au₁₇(PPh₃)₁₁³⁺, Au₁₈(PPh₃)₁₀²⁺, Au₁₉(PPh₃)₁₀Cl²⁺, Au₂₀(PPh₃)₁₂H₃³⁺, Au₂₁(PPh₃)₁₀Cl²⁺, and Au₂₂(PPh₃)₁₀Cl₂²⁺, indicating that a full range of clusters between Au_1-22 may be observed in a single polydisperse solution. Considering all of the clusters observed, our findings provide evidence that the Au_12-14 size range is a critical transition point in cluster nucleation. While smaller clusters exhibit a 1:1 gold-to-ligand ratio, larger clusters (beginning Au_12-14) feature additional gold atoms without an equal number of accompanying ligands. Our results support previous evidence in the literature indicating that the "magic number" icosahedral Au₁₃ geometry is the smallest cluster size where a ligand-less central gold atom is coordinated by a complete shell of 12 surrounding ligated gold atoms, thereby creating a stable "one-shell" cluster. Furthermore, our findings reinforce growing evidence that ligands may be used to actively direct gold cluster size and abundance during synthesis. While for PPh₃-ligated systems the most abundant species are Au_6-9 clusters, we find that for related methyldiphenylphosphine (PPh₂Me) and dimethylphenylphosphine (PPhMe₂)-ligated systems the most abundant cluster sizes are Au_10-11 and Au_12-14, respectively. Together, we demonstrate that reducing the range of m/z collection windows and increasing the number of scan averages dramatically improves instrument sensitivity for cationic gold clusters, enabling thorough characterization of polydisperse solutions that is not possible using conventional techniques.

Ligand-protected gold/silver superatoms: current status and emerging trends

Monolayer-protected gold/silver clusters have attracted much interest as nano-scale building units for novel functional materials owing to their nonbulk-like structures and size-specific properties. They can be viewed as ligand-protected superatoms because their magic stabilities and fundamental properties are well explained in the framework of the jellium model. In the last decade, the number of ligand-protected superatoms with atomically-defined structures has been increasing rapidly thanks to the well-established synthesis and structural determination by X-ray crystallography. This perspective summarizes the current status and emerging trends in synthesis and characterization of superatoms. The topics related to synthesis include (1) development of targeted synthesis based on transformation, (2) enhancement of robustness and synthetic yield for practical applications, and (3) development of controlled fusion and assembly of well-defined superatoms to create new properties. New characterization approaches are also introduced such as (1) mass spectrometry and laser spectroscopies in the gas phase, (2) determination of static and dynamic structures, and (3) computational analysis by machine learning. Finally, future challenges and prospects are discussed for further promotion and development of materials science of superatoms.

This perspective summarizes the current status and emerging trends in synthesis and characterization of ligand-protected gold/silver superatoms.

Ultrastable hydrido gold nanoclusters with the protection of phosphines

Two phosphine-protected gold nanoclusters with an unprecedented hetero superatomic Au₂₀ core have been isolated. The presence of hydrides is evidenced by mass spectrometry and NMR spectroscopy.