Overcrowded 14,14'-Bidibenzo[a,j]anthracenes: Challenges in Syntheses and Atypical Property of Lacking Symmetry-Breaking Charge Transfer (SBCT)

14,14'-Bidibenzo[a,j]anthracenes (BDBAs) were prepared by iridium-catalyzed annulation of 5,5'-biterphenylene with alkynes. The molecular geometries of overcrowded BDBAs were verified by X-ray crystallography. The two dibenzo[a,j]anthryl moieties are connected through the sterically hindered 14 positions, resulting in highly distorted molecular halves. The conformation with a small twist angle between two molecular halves can minimize steric conflicts between the substituents at 1 and 13 positions and the carbon atoms of the central axis, as well as steric clashes between those substituents. One such example is octafluoro-substituted BDBA, where the interplanar angle between two anthryl moieties is approximately 31° (currently the lowest reported value, cf. 81° in 9,9'-bianthracene). The intramolecular interactions and electronic couplings between two molecular halves resulted in upfield 1H NMR signals, redshifted absorption and emission bands, and a reduced HOMO-LUMO gap. Photodynamic investigations on BDBAs indicated that the formation of the conventional symmetry-breaking charge transfer (SBCT) state was suspended by restricted rocking around the central C-C bond. Such a mechanism associated with this highly constrained conformation was examined for the first time.

Ultrafast symmetry-breaking charge separation in Perylenemonoimide-embedded multichromophores: impact of regioisomerism

Symmetry-breaking charge separation (SB-CS) has recently evolved as an emerging concept offering its potential to the latest generation of organic photovoltaics. However there are several concerns that need to be addressed to reach the state-of-the-art in SB-CS chemistry, for instance, the desirable molecular geometry, interchromophoric distance and extent of electronic coupling. To shed light on those features, it is reported herein, that ortho-functionalized perylene monoimide (PMI) constituted regioisomeric dimer and trimer derivatives with varied molecular twisting and electronic conjugation have been synthesized. In steady-state photophysical studies, all the dimers and trimer derivatives exhibit a larger bathochromic shift in the emission spectra and a significant reduction of fluorescence quantum yield in polar DMF. Among the series of multichromophores, ortho- and self-coupled dimers display the strikingly different optical feature of SB-CS with a very fast charge separation rate (τCS = 80.2 ps) upon photoexcitation in DMF, which is unveiled by femtosecond transient absorption (fs-TA) studies. The SB-CS for two dimers is well-supported by the formation of PMI˙+ and PMI˙- bands in the fs-TA spectra. Further analysis of fs-TA data revealed that, among the other multichromophores the trimer also exhibits a clear charge separation, whereas SB-CS signatures are less prominent, but can not be completely disregarded, for the meta- and para-dimers. Additionally, the charge separation dynamics of those above-mentioned PMI derivatives are devoid of a kinetically favorable excimer or triplet formation. The evidence of a profound charge transfer phenomenon in the ortho-dimer is characterized by density functional theory (DFT) calculations on excited state electronic structures. The excitonic communications in the excited state electronic arrangements unravel the key role of dihedral twisting in SB-CS. The thermodynamic feasibility of CS (ΔGCS) and activation barrier (ΔG≠) of the derivatives in DMF are established from the Rehm-Weller equation and Marcus's theory, respectively. This work is an in-depth study of the effect of mutual orientation of PMIs and regioisomerism in determining sustainable guidelines for using SB-CS.

Symmetry-Breaking Charge Transfer in Metal-Organic Frameworks

High quantum-yield charge carrier generation from the initially prepared excitons defines a key step in the light-harvesting and conversion scheme. Photoinduced charge transfer in molecular electron donor-acceptor assemblies is driven by a sizable ΔG0, which compromises the potential of the generated carriers. Reminiscent of the special pair at the reaction center of the natural light-harvesting complex, symmetry-breaking charge transfer (SBCT) within a pair of identical struts of metal-organic framework (MOF) will facilitate the efficient generation of long-lived charge carriers with maximized potentials without incorporating any foreign redox species. We report SBCT in pyrene-based zirconium metal-organic framework (MOF) NU-1000 that leads to efficient generation of radical ions in a polar solvent and bound CT states in a low-polar solvent. The probe unveils the role of the low-lying non-Franck-Condon excitonic states as intermediates in the formation of the SBCT state from the initially prepared Franck-Condon S1 states. Ultrafast and transient spectroscopy─probed over 200 fs-30 μs time scale─evinces a kSBCT = (110 ps)-1 in polar media (εs = 37.5) forming solvated radical ions with recombination rate kCR = (∼45 ns)-1. A slower rate with kSBCT = (203 ps)-1 was recorded in low-polar (εs = 7.0) solvent manifesting a bound [TBAPy•+ TBAPy•-] state with kCR ≈ (17 μs)-1. This discovery, along with other unique photophysical features relevant to light harvesting, should define a MOF-based platform for developing heterogeneous artificial photon energy conversion systems.

Ultrafast Charge Separation Driven by Torsional Motion in Orthogonal Boron Dipyrromethene Dimer

In this work, the photoinduced charge separation (CS) via symmetry breaking in an orthogonal meso-β-linked boron dipyrromethene (BODIPY) dimer was investigated by polarized transient absorption spectroscopy. The time constant about 0.76 ps of the CS reaction determined in dimethyl sulfoxide is much faster than the solvation dynamics. The observed transient anisotropy of the BODIPY anion band implies that both hole and electron transfers occur with similar probabilities. The bidirectional charge transfer processes suggest that the locally excited state is weakly coupled to the polar solvent, and the solvation coupled excited-state structural relaxation within the BODIPY monomeric unit is rather limited. In combination with the electronic excitation analysis based on time-dependent density-functional theory calculations, we deduced that the CS in the orthogonal BODIPY dimer is enabled via the torsional motion associated with covalently connected BODIPY units, promoting the electronic coupling, and irrelevant to the dynamic solvent relaxation.

Solvent Tuning Excited State Structural Dynamics in a Novel Bianthryl

Symmetry breaking charge separation (SBCS) is central to photochemical energy conversion. The widely studied 9,9-bianthryl (9,9'BA) is the prototype, but the role of bianthryl structure is hardly investigated. Here we investigate excited state structural dynamics in a bianthryl of reduced symmetry, 1,9-bianthryl (1,9'BA), through ultrafast electronic and vibrational spectroscopy. Resonance selective Raman in polar solvents reveals a Franck-Condon state mode that disappears concomitant with the rise of ring breathing modes of radical species. Solvent-dependent dynamics show that CS is driven by solvent orientational motion, as in 9,9'BA. In nonpolar solvents the excited state undergoes multistep structural relaxation, including subpicosecond Franck-Condon state decay and biexponential diffusion-controlled structural evolution to a distorted slightly polar state. These data suggest two possible routes to SBCS; the established solvent driven pathway in rapidly relaxing polar solvents and, in slowly relaxing media, initial intramolecular reorganization to a polar structure which drives solvent orientational relaxation.

On the Cooperative Origin of Solvent-Enhanced Symmetry-Breaking Charge Transfer in a Covalently Bound Tetracene Dimer Leading to Singlet Fission

Singlet fission in covalently bound acene dimers in solution is driven by the interplay of excitonic and singlet correlated triplet ¹(TT) states with intermediate charge-transfer states, a process which depends sensitively on the solvent environment. We use high-level electronic structure methods to explore this singlet fission process in a linked tetracene dimer, with emphasis on the symmetry-breaking mechanism for the charge-transfer (CT) states induced by low-frequency antisymmetric vibrations and polar/polarizable solvents. A combination of the second-order algebraic diagrammatic construction (ADC(2)) and density functional theory/multireference configuration interaction (DFT/MRCI) methods are employed, along with a state-specific conductor-like screening model (COSMO) solvation model in the former case. This work quantifies, for the first time, an earlier mechanistic proposal [Alvertis et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2019, 141, 17558] according to which solvent-induced symmetry breaking leads to a high-energy CT state which interacts with the correlated triplet state, resulting in singlet fission. An approximate assessment of the nonadiabatic interactions between the different electronic states underscores that the CT states are essential in facilitating the transition from the bright excitonic state to the ¹(TT) state leading to singlet fission. We show that several types of symmetry-breaking inter- and intra-fragment vibrations play a crucial role in a concerted mechanism with the solvent environment and with the symmetric inter-fragment torsion, which tunes the admixture of excitonic and CT states. This offers a new perspective on how solvent-induced symmetry-breaking CT can be understood and how it cooperates with intramolecular mechanisms in singlet fission.

Controlling Symmetry Breaking Charge Transfer in BODIPY Pairs

ConspectusSymmetry breaking charge transfer (SBCT) is a process in which a pair of identical chromophores absorb a photon and use its energy to transfer an electron from one chromophore to the other, breaking the symmetry of the chromophore pair. This excited state phenomenon is observed in photosynthetic organisms where it enables efficient formation of separated charges that ultimately catalyze biosynthesis. SBCT has also been proposed as a means for developing photovoltaics and photocatalytic systems that operate with minimal energy loss. It is known that SBCT in both biological and artificial systems is in part made possible by the local environment in which it occurs, which can move to stabilize the asymmetric SBCT state. However, how environmental degrees of freedom act in concert with steric and structural constraints placed on a chromophore pair to dictate its ability to generate long-lived charge pairs via SBCT remain open topics of investigation.In this Account, we compare a broad series of dipyrrin dimers that are linked by distinct bridging groups to discern how the spatial separation and mutual orientation of linked chromophores and the structural flexibility of their linker each impact SBCT efficiency. Across this material set, we observe a general trend that SBCT is accelerated as the spatial separation between dimer chromophores decreases, consistent with the expectation that the electronic coupling between these units varies exponentially with their separation. However, one key observation is that the rate of charge recombination following SBCT was found to slow with decreasing interchromophore separation, rather than speed up. This stems from an enhancement of the dimer's structural rigidity due to increasing steric repulsion as the length of their linker shrinks. This rigidity further inhibits charge recombination in systems where symmetry has already enforced zero HOMO-LUMO overlap. Additionally, for the forward transfer, the active torsion is shown to increase LUMO-LUMO coupling, allowing for faster SBCT within bridging groups.By understanding trends for how rates of SBCT and charge recombination depend on a dimer's internal structure and its environment, we identify design guidelines for creating artificial systems for driving sustained light-induced charge separation. Such systems can find application in solar energy technologies and photocatalytic applications and can serve as a model for light-induced charge separation in biological systems.

Quantum dynamics of the photoinduced charge separation in a symmetric donor–acceptor–donor triad: The role of vibronic couplings, symmetry and temperature

The photoinduced charge separation in a symmetric donor–acceptor–donor (D–A–D) triad is studied quantum mechanically using a realistic diabatic vibronic coupling model. The model includes a locally excited DA*D state and two charge-transfer states D+A−D and DA−D+ and is constructed according to a procedure generally applicable to semirigid D–A–D structures and based on energies, forces, and force constants obtained by quantum chemical calculations. In this case, the electronic structure is described by time-dependent density functional theory, and the corrected linear response is used in conjunction with the polarizable continuum model to account for state-specific solvent effects. The multimode dynamics following the photoexcitation to the locally excited state are simulated by the hybrid Gaussian-multiconfigurational time-dependent Hartree method, and temperature effects are included using thermo field theory. The dynamics are connected to the transient absorption spectrum obtained in recent experiments, which is simulated and fully assigned from first principles. It is found that the charge separation is mediated by symmetry-breaking vibrations of relatively low frequency, which implies that temperature should be accounted for to obtain reliable estimates of the charge transfer rate.

Enhancing the Operability of Photoexcitation-Controlled Aggregation-Induced Emissive Molecules in the Organic Phase

Controllable aggregation-induced emission luminogens (AIEgens) by photoexcitation can be conducted within a single solvent, thus opening new opportunities for preparing and processing smart materials. However, undesired side-reactions like photooxidation that can easily occur in the organic phase remain, limiting their applications. To enhance the operability of photoexcitation-controlled AIEgens (to specifically produce a phosphorescence characteristic) in the organic phase, in this work, we employ a typical prototype, hexathiobenzene, usually as the specific phosphorescent group, and investigate a series of physical and chemical factors, such as light intensity, dissolved oxygen content, and solvent polarity, to explore ways to control the photoexcitation-controllable AIEgens against the impurities from side-reactions. An organogel strategy was also developed to minimize interference factors and improve the practical application ability. We believe that the presented results provide new insights into the further development of the photoexcitation-based functional materials and the promotion of their practical usage.

Ultrafast Excimer Formation and Solvent Controlled Symmetry Breaking Charge Separation in the Excitonically Coupled Subphthalocyanine Dimer

Knowledge of the factors controlling excited state dynamics in excitonically coupled dimers and higher aggregates is critical for understanding natural and artificial solar energy conversion. In this work, we report ultrafast solvent polarity dependent excited state dynamics of the structurally well‐defined subphthalocyanine dimer, μ‐OSubPc₂. Stationary electronic spectra demonstrate strong exciton coupling in μ‐OSubPc₂. Femtosecond transient absorption measurements reveal ultrafast excimer formation from the initially excited exciton, mediated by intramolecular structural evolution. In polar solvents the excimer state decays directly through symmetry breaking charge transfer to form a charge separated state. Charge separation occurs under control of solvent orientational relaxation.

Efficient simulation of time- and frequency-resolved four-wave-mixing signals with a multiconfigurational Ehrenfest approach

We have extended the multiconfigurational Ehrenfest approach to the simulation of four-wave-mixing signals of systems involving multiple electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom. As an illustration, we calculate signals of three widely used spectroscopic techniques, time- and frequency-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy, transient absorption spectroscopy, and two-dimensional (2D) electronic spectroscopy, for a two-electronic-state, twenty-four vibrational-mode conical intersection model. It has been shown that all these three spectroscopic signals characterize fast population transfer from the higher excited electronic state to the lower excited electronic state. While the time- and frequency-resolved spectrum maps the wave packet propagation exclusively on the electronically excited states, the transient absorption and 2D electronic spectra reflect the wave packet dynamics on both electronically excited states and the electronic ground state. Combining trajectory-guided Gaussian basis functions and the nonlinear response function formalism, the present approach provides a promising general technique for the applications of various Gaussian basis methods to the calculations of four-wave-mixing spectra of polyatomic molecules.

Ultrafast structural dynamics of in-cage isomerization of diiodomethane in solution

Despite extensive studies on the isomer species formed by photodissociation of haloalkanes in solution, the molecular structure of the precursor of the isomer, which is often assumed to be a vibrationally hot isomer formed from the radical pair, and its in-cage isomerization mechanism remain elusive. Here, the structural dynamics of CH₂I₂ upon 267 nm photoexcitation in methanol were probed with femtosecond X-ray solution scattering at an X-ray free-electron laser. The determined molecular structure of the transiently formed species that converts to the CH₂I–I isomer has the I–I distance of 4.17 Å, which is longer than that of the isomer (3.15 Å) by more than 1.0 Å and the mean-squared displacement of 0.45 Ų, which is about 100 times larger than those of typical regular chemical bonds. These unusual structural characteristics are consistent with either a vibrationally hot form of the CH₂I–I isomer or the loosely-bound radical pair (CH₂I˙⋯I˙).

The structural dynamics of in-cage isomerization of CH₂I₂ and the unusual structure of the loosely-bound isomer precursor were unveiled with femtosecond X-ray liquidography (solution scattering).

Monitoring the evolution of intersite and interexciton coherence in electronic excitation transfer via wave-packet interferometry

We detail an experimental strategy for tracking the generation and time-development of electronic coherence within the singly excited manifold of an energy-transfer dimer. The technique requires that the two monomers have nonparallel electronic transition-dipole moments and that these possess fixed orientations in space. It makes use of two-dimensional wave-packet interferometry (WPI or whoopee) measurements in which the A, B, C, and D pulses have respective polarizations e, e, e, and e'. In the case of energy-transfer coupling that is weak or strong compared to electronic-nuclear interactions, it is convenient to follow the evolution of intersite or interexciton coherence, respectively. Under weak coupling, e could be perpendicular to the acceptor chromophore's transition dipole moment and the unit vector e' would be perpendicular to the donor's transition dipole. Under strong coupling, e could be perpendicular to the ground-to-excited transition dipole to the lower exciton level and e' would be perpendicular to the ground-to-excited transition dipole to the upper exciton level. If the required spatial orientation can be realized for an entire ensemble, experiments of the kind proposed could be performed by either conventional four-wave-mixing or fluorescence-detected WPI methods. Alternatively, fluorescence-detected whoopee experiments of this kind could be carried out on a single energy-transfer dimer of fixed orientation. We exhibit detailed theoretical expressions for the desired WPI signal, explain the physical origin of electronic coherence detection, and show calculated observed-coherence signals for model dimers with one, two, or three internal vibrational modes per monomer and both weak and strong energy-transfer coupling.

Electron-donating strength dependent symmetry breaking charge transfer dynamics of quadrupolar molecules

The solvent induced excited state symmetry breaking processes of donor–acceptor–donor quadrupolar dyes are successfully tracked in real-time.