Boronic acid and diol-containing polymers: how to choose the correct couple to form "strong" hydrogels at physiological pH

Boronate Ester Hydrogels for Biomedical Applications: Challenges and Opportunities

Boronate ester (BE) hydrogels are increasingly used for biomedical applications. The dynamic nature of these molecular networks enables bond rearrangement, which is associated with viscoelasticity, injectability, printability, and self-healing, among other properties. BEs are also sensitive to pH, redox reactions, and the presence of sugars, which is useful for the design of stimuli-responsive materials. Together, BE hydrogels are interesting scaffolds for use in drug delivery, 3D cell culture, and biofabrication. However, designing stable BE hydrogels at physiological pH (≈7.4) remains a challenge, which is hindering their development and biomedical application. In this context, advanced chemical insights into BE chemistry are being used to design new molecular solutions for material fabrication. This review article summarizes the state of the art in BE hydrogel design for biomedical applications with a focus on the materials chemistry of this class of materials. First, we discuss updated knowledge in BE chemistry including details on the molecular mechanisms associated with BE formation and breakage. Then, we discuss BE hydrogel formation at physiological pH, with an overview of the main systems reported to date along with new perspectives. A last section covers several prominent biomedical applications of BE hydrogels, including drug delivery, 3D cell culture, and bioprinting, with critical insights on the design relevance, limitations and potential.

Effect of different crosslinking agents on hybrid chitosan/collagen hydrogels for potential tissue engineering applications

Tissue engineering (TE) demands scaffolds that have the necessary resistance to withstand the mechanical stresses once implanted in our body, as well as excellent biocompatibility. Hydrogels are postulated as interesting materials for this purpose, especially those made from biopolymers. In this study, the microstructure and rheological performance, as well as functional and biological properties of chitosan and collagen hydrogels (CH/CG) crosslinked with different coupling agents, both natural such as d-Fructose (F), genipin (G) and transglutaminase (T) and synthetic, using a combination of 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide hydrochloride with N-hydroxysuccinimide (EDC/NHS) will be assessed. FTIR tests were carried out to determine if the proposed crosslinking reactions for each crosslinking agent occurred as expected, obtaining positive results in this aspect. Regarding the characterization of the properties of each system, two main trends were observed, from which it could be established that crosslinking with G and EDC-NHS turned out to be more effective and beneficial than with the other two crosslinking agents, producing significant improvements with respect to the base CH/CG hydrogel. In addition, in vitro tests demonstrated the potential application in TE of these systems, especially for those crosslinked with G, T and EDC-NHS.

Phenylboronate-salicylate ester cross-linked self-healing hydrogel composed of modified hyaluronan at physiological pH

Several hydrogels with boronate/diol ester cross-linking have been reported. However, multiple synthetic steps or expensive reagents are required to modify some diol moieties into polymers. Therefore, diol-modified polymers, which are easily and inexpensively prepared via a single-step process, are required for the formation of boronate esters. This study reports a novel hydrogel composed of phenylboronic acid-modified hyaluronic acid and salicylic acid-modified hyaluronic acid. This hydrogel is injectable, can self-heal at physiological pH, and can be easily and inexpensively prepared. The polymer system behaved as a sol at pH 12.0 and a weak gel at pH 9.4 and 11.2, whereas it behaved as a gel over a wide pH range of 4.0-8.2. The viscoelasticity of the system decreased in response to sugar at pH 7.3. Thus, salicylic acid can be considered a promising diol moiety for hydrogel formation via boronate ester cross-linking.

Divergent Deborah number-dependent transition from homogeneity to heterogeneity

Heterogeneous structures are ubiquitous in natural organisms. Native heterogeneous structures inspire many artificial structures that are playing important roles in modern society, while it is challenging to identify the relevant factors in forming these structures due to the complexity of living systems. Here, hybrid hydrogels consisting of flexible polymer networks with embedded stiff cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) are considered an open system to simulate the generalized formation of heterogeneous core-sheath structures. As the result of the modified air drying process of hybrid hydrogels, the formation of heterogeneous core-sheath structure is found to be correlated to the relative evaporation speed. Specifically, the formation of such heterogeneity in xerogel fibers is found to be correlated with the divergence of Deborah number (De). During the transition of De from large to small values with accompanying morphologies, the turning point is around De = 1. The mechanism can be considered a relative humidity-dependent glass transition behavior. These unique heterogeneous structures play a key role in tuning water permeation and water sorption capacity. Insights into these aspects can prospectively contribute to a better understanding of the native heterogeneous structures for bionics design.

Benzoxaborole-grafted high molecular weight chitosan from prawn: Synthesis, characterization, target recognition and antibacterial properties

Boronated polymers are in the focus of dynamic functional materials due to the versatility of the B-O interactions and accessibility of precursors. Polysaccharides are highly biocompatible, and therefore, an attractive platform for anchoring boronic acid groups for further bioconjugation of cis-diol containing molecules. We report for the first time the introduction of benzoxaborole by amidation of the amino groups of chitosan improving solubility and introducing cis-diol recognition at physiological pH. The chemical structures and physical properties of the novel chitosan-benzoxaborole (CS-Bx) as well as two phenylboronic derivatives synthesized for comparison, were characterized by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), dynamic light scattering (DLS), rheology and optical spectroscopic methods. The novel benzoxaborole grafted chitosan was perfectly solubilized in an aqueous buffer at physiological pH, extending the possibilities of boronated materials derived from polysaccharides. The dynamic covalent interaction between boronated chitosan and model affinity ligands, was studied by means of spectroscopy methods. A glycopolymer derived from poly(isobutylene-alt-anhydride) was also synthesized to study the formation of dynamic assemblies with benzoxaborole-grafted chitosan. A first approximation to apply fluorescence microscale thermophoresis for the interactions of the modified polysaccharide is also discussed. Additionally, the activity of CSBx against bacterial adhesion was studied.

Ring Opening Copolymerization of Boron-Containing Anhydride with Epoxides as a Controlled Platform to Functional Polyesters

Boron-functionalized polymers are used in opto-electronics, biology, and medicine. Methods to produce boron-functionalized and degradable polyesters remain exceedingly rare but relevant where (bio)dissipation is required, for example, in self-assembled nanostructures, dynamic polymer networks, and bio-imaging. Here, a boronic ester-phthalic anhydride and various epoxides (cyclohexene oxide, vinyl-cyclohexene oxide, propene oxide, allyl glycidyl ether) undergo controlled ring-opening copolymerization (ROCOP), catalyzed by organometallic complexes [Zn(II)Mg(II) or Al(III)K(I)] or a phosphazene organobase. The polymerizations are well controlled allowing for the modulation of the polyester structures (e.g., by epoxide selection, AB, or ABA blocks), molar masses (9.4 < M_n < 40 kg/mol), and uptake of boron functionalities (esters, acids, "ates", boroxines, and fluorescent groups) in the polymer. The boronic ester-functionalized polymers are amorphous, with high glass transition temperatures (81 < T_g < 224 °C) and good thermal stability (285 < T_d < 322 °C). The boronic ester-polyesters are deprotected to yield boronic acid- and borate-polyesters; the ionic polymers are water soluble and degradable under alkaline conditions. Using a hydrophilic macro-initiator in alternating epoxide/anhydride ROCOP, and lactone ring opening polymerization, produces amphiphilic AB and ABC copolyesters. Alternatively, the boron-functionalities are subjected to Pd(II)-catalyzed cross-couplings to install fluorescent groups (BODIPY). The utility of this new monomer as a platform to construct specialized polyesters materials is exemplified here in the synthesis of fluorescent spherical nanoparticles that self-assemble in water (D_h = 40 nm). The selective copolymerization, variable structural composition, and adjustable boron loading represent a versatile technology for future explorations of degradable, well-defined, and functional polymers.

Hyaluronic acid-based multifunctional carriers for applications in regenerative medicine: A review

Hyaluronic acid (HA) is an important type of naturally derived carbohydrate polymer with specific polysaccharide macromolecular structures and multifaceted biological functions, including biocompatibility, low immunogenicity, biodegradability, and bioactivity. Specifically, HA hydrogels in a microscopic scale have been widely used for biomedical applications, such as drug delivery, tissue engineering, and medical cosmetology, considering their superior properties outperforming the more conventional monolithic hydrogels in network homogeneity, degradation profile, permeability, and injectability. Herein, we reviewed the recent progress in the preparation and applications of HA microgels in biomedical fields. We first summarized the fabrication of HA microgels by focusing on the different crosslinking/polymerization schemes for HA gelation and the miniaturized fabrication techniques for producing HA-based microparticles. We then highlighted the use of HA-based microgels for different applications in regenerative medicine, including cartilage repair, bioactive delivery, diagnostic imaging, modular tissue engineering. Finally, we discussed the challenges and future perspectives in bridging the translational gap in the utilization of HA-based microgels in regenerative medicine.

A new boronate ester-based crosslinking strategy allows the design of nonswelling and long-term stable dynamic covalent hydrogels

Dynamic hydrogels are viscoelastic materials that can be designed to be self-healing, malleable, and injectable, making them particularly interesting for a variety of biomedical applications. To design dynamic hydrogels, dynamic covalent crosslinking reactions are attracting increasing attention. However, dynamic covalent hydrogels tend to swell, and often lack stability. Boronate ester-based hydrogels, which result from the dynamic covalent reaction between a phenylboronic acid (PBA) derivative and a diol, are based on stable precursors, and can therefore address these limitations. Yet, boronate ester formation hardly occurs at physiological pH. To produce dynamic covalent hydrogels at physiological pH, we performed a molecular screening of PBA derivatives in association with a variety of diols, using hyaluronic acid as a polymer of interest. The combination of Wulff-type PBA (wPBA) and glucamine stood out as a unique couple to obtain the desired hydrogels. We showed that optimized wPBA/glucamine hydrogels are minimally- to non-swelling, stable long term (over months), tunable in terms of mechanical properties, and cytocompatible. We further characterized their viscoelastic and self-healing properties, highlighting their potential for biomedical applications.

Cross-Linking of Sugar-Derived Polyethers and Boronic Acids for Renewable, Self-Healing, and Single-Ion Conducting Organogel Polymer Electrolytes

This report describes the synthesis and characterization of organogels by reaction of a diol-containing polyether, derived from the sugar d-xylose, with 1,4-phenylenediboronic acid (PDBA). The cross-linked materials were analyzed by infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA), scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM), and rheology. The rheological material properties could be tuned: gel or viscoelastic behavior depended on the concentration of polymer, and mechanical stiffness increased with the amount of PDBA cross-linker. Organogels demonstrated self-healing capabilities and recovered their storage and loss moduli instantaneously after application and subsequent strain release. Lithiated organogels were synthesized through incorporation of lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (LiTFSI) into the cross-linked matrix. These lithium-borate polymer gels showed a high ionic conductivity value of up to 3.71 × 10^-3 S cm^-1 at 25 °C, high lithium transference numbers (t ₊ = 0.88-0.92), and electrochemical stability (4.51 V). The gels were compatible with lithium-metal electrodes, showing stable polarization profiles in plating/stripping tests. This system provides a promising platform for the production of self-healing gel polymer electrolytes (GPEs) derived from renewable feedstocks for battery applications.

Dynameric G-quadruplex-dextran hydrogels for cell growth applications

Hybrid dextran-G-quartet produces tunable biocompatible three-dimensional thixotropic hydrogels, able to support cell growth.

Self-Healing Alginate Hydrogel Formed by Dynamic Benzoxaborolate Chemistry Protects Retinal Pigment Epithelium Cells against Oxidative Damage

Oxidative stress is considered as a major factor causing retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) dysfunction and finally leading to retinal diseases such as age-related macular degeneration (AMD). Developing hydrogels for RPE cell delivery, especially those with antioxidant feature, is emerging as a promising approach for AMD treatment. Herein, a readily prepared antioxidant alginate-based hydrogel was developed to serve as a cytoprotective agent for RPE cells against oxidative damage. Alg-BOB was synthesized via conjugation of benzoxaborole (BOB) to the polysaccharide backbone. Hydrogels were formed through self-crosslinking of Alg-BOB based on benzoxaborole-diol complexation. The resulting hydrogel showed porous micro-structure, pH dependent mechanical strength and excellent self-healing, remolding, and injectable properties. Moreover, the hydrogel exhibited excellent cytocompatibility and could efficiently scavenge reactive oxygen species (ROS) to achieve an enhanced viability of ARPE-19 cells under oxidative condition. Altogether, our study reveals that the antioxidant Alg-BOB hydrogel represents an eligible candidate for RPE delivery and AMD treatment.

Internal and External Catalysis in Boronic Ester Networks

In dynamic materials, the reversible condensation between boronic acids and diols provides adaptability, self-healing ability, and responsiveness to small molecules and pH. The thermodynamics and kinetics of bond exchange determine the mechanical properties of dynamic polymer networks. Here, we investigate the effects of diol structure and salt additives on the rate of boronic acid-diol bond exchange, binding affinity, and the mechanical properties of the corresponding polymer networks. We find that proximal amides used to conjugate diols to polymers and buffering anions induce significant rate acceleration, consistent with an internal and external catalysis, respectively. This rate acceleration is reflected in the stress relaxation of the gels. These findings contribute to the fundamental understanding of the boronic ester dynamic bond and offer molecular strategies to tune the macromolecular properties of dynamic materials.

Connecting the Dynamics and Reactivity of Arylboronic Acids to Emergent and Stimuli-Responsive Material Properties

Over the past two decades, arylboronic acid-functionalized biomaterials have been used in a variety of sensing and stimuli-responsive scaffolds. Their diverse applications result from the diverse reactivity of arylboronic acids,...

N-Terminal Modification of Gly-His-Tagged Proteins with Azidogluconolactone

Site-specific protein modifications are vital for biopharmaceutical drug development. Gluconoylation is a non-enzymatic, post-translational modification of N-terminal HisTags. We report high-yield, site-selective in vitro α-aminoacylation of peptides, glycoproteins, antibodies, and virus-like particles (VLPs) with azidogluconolactone at pH 7.5 in 1 h. Conjugates slowly hydrolyse, but diol-masking with borate esters inhibits reversibility. In an example, we multimerise azidogluconoylated SARS-CoV-2 receptor-binding domain (RBD) onto VLPs via click-chemistry, to give a COVID-19 vaccine. Compared to yeast antigen, HEK-derived RBD was immunologically superior, likely due to observed differences in glycosylation. We show the benefits of ordered over randomly oriented multimeric antigen display, by demonstrating single-shot seroconversion and best virus-neutralizing antibodies. Azidogluconoylation is simple, fast and robust chemistry, and should accelerate research and development.

Hyaluronic Acid Hydrogels Crosslinked in Physiological Conditions: Synthesis and Biomedical Applications

Hyaluronic acid (HA) hydrogels display a wide variety of biomedical applications ranging from tissue engineering to drug vehiculization and controlled release. To date, most of the commercially available hyaluronic acid hydrogel formulations are produced under conditions that are not compatible with physiological ones. This review compiles the currently used approaches for the development of hyaluronic acid hydrogels under physiological/mild conditions. These methods include dynamic covalent processes such as boronic ester and Schiff-base formation and click chemistry mediated reactions such as thiol chemistry processes, azide-alkyne, or Diels Alder cycloaddition. Thermoreversible gelation of HA hydrogels at physiological temperature is also discussed. Finally, the most outstanding biomedical applications are indicated for each of the HA hydrogel generation approaches.

Serially pH-Modulated Hydrogels Based on Boronate Ester and Polydopamine Linkages for Local Cancer Therapy

Elaborately and serially pH-modulated hydrogels possessing optimized viscoelastic natures for short gelation time and single syringe injection were designed for peritumoral injection of an anticancer agent. Boronate ester bonds between phenylboronic acid (PBA) (installed in HA-PBA (HP)) and dopamine (included in HA-dopamine (HD)) along with self-polymerization of dopamine (via interactions between HD conjugates) were introduced as the main cross-linking strategies of a hyaluronic acid (HA) hydrogel. Considering pK_a values (8.0-9.5) of PBA and dopamine, the pH of each polymer dispersion was controlled elaborately for injection through a single syringe, and the final pH was tuned nearby the physiological pH (pH 7.8). The shear-thinning behavior, self-healing property, and single syringe injectability of a designed hydrogel cross-linked nearby physiological pH may provide its convenient application to peritumoral injection and prolonged retention in local cancer therapy. Erlotinib (ERT) was encapsulated in a microsphere (MS), and it was further embedded in an HP/HD-based hydrogel for sustained and locoregional delivery. A rheologically tuned hydrogel containing an ERT MS exhibited superior tumor-suppressive efficiencies compared to the other groups in A549 tumor-bearing mice. A designed injectable hydrogel through a single syringe system may be efficiently applied to local cancer therapy with lower toxicities to healthy organs.

Linking Molecular Behavior to Macroscopic Properties in Ideal Dynamic Covalent Networks

Dynamic covalent networks (DCvNs) are increasingly used in advanced materials design with applications ranging from recyclable thermosets to self-healing hydrogels. However, the relationship between the underlying chemistry at the junctions of DCvNs and their macroscopic properties is still not fully understood. In this work, we constructed a robust framework to predict how complex network behavior in DCvNs emerges from the chemical landscape of the dynamic chemistry at the junction. Ideal dynamic covalent boronic ester-based hydrogels were used as model DCvNs. We developed physical models that describe how viscoelastic properties, as measured by shear rheometry, are linked to the molecular behavior of the dynamic junction, quantified via fluorescence and NMR spectroscopy and DFT calculations. Additionally, shear rheometry was combined with Transition State Theory to quantify the kinetics and thermodynamics of network rearrangements, enabling a mechanistic understanding including preferred reaction pathways for dynamic covalent chemistries. We applied this approach to corroborate the "loose-bolt" postulate for the reaction mechanism in Wulff-type boronic acids. These findings, grounded in molecular principles, advance our understanding and rational design of dynamic polymer networks, improving our ability to predict, design, and leverage their unique properties for future applications.

Boronate-ester crosslinked hyaluronic acid hydrogels for dihydrocaffeic acid delivery and fibroblasts protection against UVB irradiation

Herein, we exploit the dynamic nature and pH dependence of complexes between phenylboronic acid and diol-containing molecules to control the release of an anti-photoaging agent, dihydrocaffeic acid (DHCA), from a dynamic covalent hydrogel (HG). The HG is prepared by reversible formation of boronate ester crosslinks between hyaluronic acid (HA) modified with saccharide (GLU) residues and HA functionalized with 3-aminophenylboronic acid (APBA), part of which is involved in complexation with DHCA. The hydrogel exhibited increased dynamic moduli and a lower relaxation time at pH 7.4 in comparison to pH 6, and greater amount of DHCA was incorporated at pH 7.4. Moreover, this hydrogel prolonged DHCA release at pH 7.4 through drug reversible complexation/decomplexation, while the rate of release was fastest in acidic (skin) conditions. Very interestingly, the incorporation of DHCA into the network enhances its protection against UVB-induced L929 fibroblast death. Therefore, this smart hydrogel can contribute to photoaging prevention.