Electronic structure of strongly correlated systems: recent developments in multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory and multiconfiguration nonclassical-energy functional theory

Quantum fundaments of catalysis: true electronic potential energy

Catalysis is a quantum phenomenon enthalpically driven by electronic correlations with many-particle effects in all of its branches, including electro-photo-catalysis and electron transfer. This means that only probability amplitudes provide a complete relationship between the state of catalysis and observations. Thus, in any atomic system material), competing space-time electronic interactions coexist to define its (related) properties such as stability, (super)conductivity, magnetism (spin-orbital ordering), chemisorption and catalysis. Catalysts, reactants, and chemisorbed and transition states have the possibility of optimizing quantum correlations to improve reaction kinetics. Active sites with closed-shell orbital configurations share a maximum number of spin-paired electrons, mainly optimizing coulombic attractions and covalency and defining weakly correlated closed-shell (WCCS) structures. However, in compositions with open-shell orbital configurations, at least, quantum spin exchange interactions (QSEIopenshells) arise, stabilising unpaired electrons in less covalent bonds and differentiating non-weakly (or strongly) correlated open-shell (NWCOS) systems. In NWCOS catalysts, electronic ground states can have bonds with diverse and rival spin-orbital orderings as well as ferro-, ferri- and multiple antiferro-magnetic textures, which deeply define their activities. Particularly in inter-atomic ferromagnetic (FM) bonds, the increase in relevance of non-classical quantum potentials can significantly optimize chemisorption energies, transition states (TSs), activation energies (overpotential) and spin-dependent electron transfer (conductivity), overall implying the need for explaining the thermodynamic and kinetic origin of catalysis from its true quantum electronic energy. To do so, we use the connection between the Born-Oppenheimer approximation and Virial theorem in the treatment of electronic kinetic and potential energies. Thus, the exact fundamental interactions that decompose TSs appear. The possibility of increasing the stabilization of TSs, due to quantum correlations on NWCO catalysts, opens the possibility of simultaneously reducing chemisorption enthalpies and activation barriers of reaction mechanisms, which implies the anticipation and explanation of positive deviations from the Brønsted-Evans-Polanyi principle.

Electronic Structure Methods for Simulating Flavin's Spectroscopy and Photophysics: Comparison of Multi-reference, TD-DFT, and Single-Reference Wave Function Methods

The use of flavins and flavoproteins in photocatalytic, sensing, and biotechnological applications has led to a growing interest in computationally modeling the excited-state electronic structure and photophysics of flavin. However, there is limited consensus regarding which computational methods are appropriate for modeling flavin's photophysics. We compare the energies of low-lying excited states of flavin computed with time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT), equation-of-motion coupled cluster (EOM-EE-CCSD), scaled opposite-spin configuration interaction [SOS-CIS(D)], multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory (MC-PDFT), and several multireference perturbation theory (MR-PT2) methods. In the first part, we focus on excitation energies of the first singlet excited state (S1) of five different redox and protonation states of flavin, with the goal of finding a suitable active space for MR-PT2 calculations. In the second part, we construct two sets of one-dimensional potential energy surfaces connecting the S0 and S1 equilibrium geometries (S0-S1 path) and the S1 (π,π*) and S2 (n,π*) equilibrium geometries (S1-S2 path). The first path therefore follows a Franck-Condon active mode of flavin while the second path maps crossings points between low-lying singlet and triplet states in flavin. We discuss the similarities and differences in the TD-DFT, EOM-EE-CCSD, SOS-CIS(D), MC-PDFT and MR-PT2 energy profiles along these paths. We find that (TD-)DFT methods are suitable for applications such as simulating the spectra of flavins but are inconsistent with several other methods when used for some geometry optimizations and when describing the energetics of dark (n,π*) states. MR-PT2 methods show promise for the simulation of flavin's low-lying excited states, but the selection of orbitals for the active space and the number of roots used for state averaging must be done carefully to avoid artifacts. Some properties, such as the intersystem crossing geometry and energy between the S1 (π,π*) and T2 (n,π*) states, may require additional benchmarking before they can be determined quantitatively.

Combined Multireference-Multiscale Approach to the Description of Photosynthetic Reaction Centers

A first-principles description of the primary photochemical processes that drive photosynthesis and sustain life on our planet remains one of the grand challenges of modern science. Recent research established that explicit incorporation of protein electrostatics in excited-state calculations of photosynthetic pigments, achieved for example with quantum-mechanics/molecular-mechanics (QM/MM) approaches, is essential for a meaningful description of the properties and function of pigment-protein complexes. Although time-dependent density functional theory has been used productively so far in QM/MM approaches for the study of such systems, this methodology has limitations. Here we pursue for the first time a QM/MM description of the reaction center in the principal enzyme of oxygenic photosynthesis, Photosystem II, using multireference wave function theory for the high-level QM region. We identify best practices and establish guidelines regarding the rational choice of active space and appropriate state-averaging for the efficient and reliable use of complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) and the N-electron valence state perturbation theory (NEVPT2) in the prediction of low-lying excited states of chlorophyll and pheophytin pigments. Given that the Gouterman orbitals are inadequate as a minimal active space, we define specific minimal and extended active spaces for the NEVPT2 description of electronic states that fall within the Q and B bands. Subsequently, we apply our multireference-QM/MM protocol to the description of all pigments in the reaction center of Photosystem II. The calculations reproduce the electrochromic shifts induced by the protein matrix and the ordering of site energies consistent with the identity of the primary donor (ChlD1) and the experimentally known asymmetric and directional electron transfer. The optimized protocol sets the stage for future multireference treatments of multiple pigments, and hence for multireference studies of charge separation, while it is transferable to the study of any photoactive embedded tetrapyrrole system.

Toward the Next Generation of Density Functionals: Escaping the Zero-Sum Game by Using the Exact-Exchange Energy Density

ConspectusKohn-Sham density functional theory (KS DFT) is arguably the most widely applied electronic-structure method with tens of thousands of publications each year in a wide variety of fields. Its importance and usefulness can thus hardly be overstated. The central quantity that determines the accuracy of KS DFT calculations is the exchange-correlation functional. Its exact form is unknown, or better "unknowable", and therefore the derivation of ever more accurate yet efficiently applicable approximate functionals is the "holy grail" in the field. In this context, the simultaneous minimization of so-called delocalization errors and static correlation errors is the greatest challenge that needs to be overcome as we move toward more accurate yet computationally efficient methods. In many cases, an improvement on one of these two aspects (also often termed fractional-charge and fractional-spin errors, respectively) generates a deterioration in the other one. Here we report on recent notable progress in escaping this so-called "zero-sum-game" by constructing new functionals based on the exact-exchange energy density. In particular, local hybrid and range-separated local hybrid functionals are discussed that incorporate additional terms that deal with static correlation as well as with delocalization errors. Taking hints from other coordinate-space models of nondynamical and strong electron correlations (the B13 and KP16/B13 models), position-dependent functions that cover these aspects in real space have been devised and incorporated into the local-mixing functions determining the position-dependence of exact-exchange admixture of local hybrids as well as into the treatment of range separation in range-separated local hybrids. While initial functionals followed closely the B13 and KP16/B13 frameworks, meanwhile simpler real-space functions based on ratios of semilocal and exact-exchange energy densities have been found, providing a basis for relatively simple and numerically convenient functionals. Notably, the correction terms can either increase or decrease exact-exchange admixture locally in real space (and in interelectronic-distance space), leading even to regions with negative admixture in cases of particularly strong static correlations. Efficient implementations into a fast computer code (Turbomole) using seminumerical integration techniques make such local hybrid and range-separated local hybrid functionals promising new tools for complicated composite systems in many research areas, where simultaneously small delocalization errors and static correlation errors are crucial. First real-world application examples of the new functionals are provided, including stretched bonds, symmetry-breaking and hyperfine coupling in open-shell transition-metal complexes, as well as a reduction of static correlation errors in the computation of nuclear shieldings and magnetizabilities. The newest versions of range-separated local hybrids (e.g., ωLH23tdE) retain the excellent frontier-orbital energies and correct asymptotic exchange-correlation potential of the underlying ωLH22t functional while improving substantially on strong-correlation cases. The form of these functionals can be further linked to the performance of the recent impactful deep-neural-network "black-box" functional DM21, which itself may be viewed as a range-separated local hybrid.

Analytic Nuclear Gradients for Complete Active Space Linearized Pair-Density Functional Theory

Accurately modeling photochemical reactions is difficult due to the presence of conical intersections and locally avoided crossings, as well as the inherently multiconfigurational character of excited states. As such, one needs a multistate method that incorporates state interaction in order to accurately model the potential energy surface at all nuclear coordinates. The recently developed linearized pair-density functional theory (L-PDFT) is a multistate extension of multiconfiguration PDFT, and it has been shown to be a cost-effective post-MCSCF method (as compared to more traditional and expensive multireference many-body perturbation methods or multireference configuration interaction methods) that can accurately model potential energy surfaces in regions of strong nuclear-electronic coupling in addition to accurately predicting Franck-Condon vertical excitations. In this paper, we report the derivation of analytic gradients for L-PDFT and their implementation in the PySCF-forge software, and we illustrate the utility of these gradients for predicting ground- and excited-state equilibrium geometries and adiabatic excitation energies for formaldehyde, s-trans-butadiene, phenol, and cytosine.

Minimum-Energy Conical Intersections by Compressed Multistate Pair-Density Functional Theory

Compressed multistate pair-density functional theory (CMS-PDFT) is a multistate version of multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory that can capture the correct topology of coupled potential energy surfaces (PESs) around conical intersections. In this work, we develop interstate coupling vectors (ISCs) for CMS-PDFT in the OpenMolcas and PySCF/mrh electronic structure packages. Yet, the main focus of this work is using ISCs to calculate minimum-energy conical intersections (MECIs) by CMS-PDFT. This is performed using the projected constrained optimization method in OpenMolcas, which uses ISCs to restrain the iterations to the conical intersection seam. We optimize the S1/S0 MECIs for ethylene, butadiene, and benzene and show that CMS-PDFT gives smooth PESs in the vicinities of the MECIs. Furthermore, the CMS-PDFT MECIs are in good agreement with the MECI calculated by the more expensive XMS-CASPT2 method.

Hybrid Density Functional Valence Bond Method with Multistate Treatment

Recently, a hybrid density functional valence bond (VB) method, λ-DFVB(U), has been proposed and shown to give accuracy that is comparable to that of CASPT2 in calculations of atomization energies, atomic excitation energies, and reaction barriers, while its computational cost is approximately the same as the valence bond self-consistent-field (VBSCF) method. However, the interaction between electronic states is not included in λ-DFVB(U) since the last step of λ-DFVB(U) is not a diagonalization of the Hamiltonian matrix on the electronic state basis. Therefore, λ-DFVB(U) gives the wrong topology of the potential energy surfaces (PESs) near the conical intersection region. In the present paper, we propose a novel hybrid density functional VB method with multistate treatment, named λ-DFVB(MS), in which an effective Hamiltonian matrix is constructed on the basis of the diabatic states obtained by the valence-bond-based compression approach for the diabatization scheme, and the interaction between electronic states can be included through the diagonalization of the effective Hamiltonian matrix. Test calculations show that λ-DFVB(MS) gives the correct topology of the PESs near the conical intersection region. We also show that the VBSCF wave function with selected VB structures can be applied as a reference in λ-DFVB(MS).

Small-Occupation Density Functional Correlation Energy Correction to Wave Function Approximations

In this work, we introduce a novel hybrid approach, termed WFT-soDFT, designed to seamlessly incorporate DFT correlation into wave function ansatzes. This is achieved through a partitioning of the orbital space, distinguishing between large and small natural occupation numbers associated with wave function theory (WFT) and DFT correlation, respectively. The method uses a novel criterion for partitioning the orbital space and mapping the electron density in natural orbitals with a small occupation with the correlation energy of fast electrons within the homogeneous electron gas. Central to our approach is the introduction of a separation parameter ν, the choice of the WFT approach, and the correlation functional. Here, we combine the RASCI wave function with hole and particle truncation with a local density correlation functional to only account for small-occupation correlation energy. We investigate the performance of the method in the study of small but challenging chemical systems, for which WFT-soDFT demonstrates notable improvements over pristine wave function calculations. These findings collectively highlight the potential of the WFT-soDFT approach as a computationally affordable strategy to improve the accuracy of WFT electronic structure calculations.

Variational Active Space Selection with Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory

The selection of an adequate set of active orbitals for modeling strongly correlated electronic states is difficult to automate because it is highly dependent on the states and molecule of interest. Although many approaches have shown some success, no single approach has worked well in all cases. In light of this, we present the "discrete variational selection" (DVS) approach to active space selection, in which one generates multiple trial wave functions from a diverse set of systematically constructed active spaces and then selects between these wave functions variationally. We apply this DVS approach to 207 vertical excitations of small-to-medium-sized organic and inorganic molecules (with 3 to 18 atoms) in the QUESTDB database by (i) constructing various sets of active space orbitals through diagonalization of parametrized operators and (ii) choosing the result with the lowest average energy among the states of interest. This approach proves ineffective when variationally selecting between wave functions using the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) or complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) energy but is able to provide good results when variationally selecting between wave functions using the energy of the translated PBE (tPBE) functional from multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory (MC-PDFT). Applying this DVS-tPBE approach to selection among state-averaged DMRG wave functions, we obtain a mean unsigned error of only 0.17 eV using hybrid MC-PDFT. This result matches that of our previous benchmark without the need to filter out poor active spaces and with no further orbital optimization following active space selection of the SA-DMRG wave functions. Furthermore, we find that DVS-tPBE is able to robustly and effectively select between the new SA-DMRG wave functions and our previous SA-CASSCF results.

Linearized Pair-Density Functional Theory for Vertical Excitation Energies

Multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory (MC-PDFT) is a computationally efficient method that computes the energies of electronic states in a state specific or state average framework via an on-top functional. However, MC-PDFT does not include state interaction among these states since the final energies do not come from the diagonalization of an effective model-space Hamiltonian. Recently, multistate extensions such as linearized PDFT (L-PDFT) have been developed to accurately model the potentials near conical intersections and avoided crossings. However, there has not been any systematic study evaluating their performance for predicting vertical excitations at the equilibrium geometry of a molecule, when the excited states are generally well separated. In this paper, we report the performance of L-PDFT on the extensive QUESTDB data set of vertical excitations using a database of automatically selected active spaces. We show that L-PDFT performs well on all these excitations and successfully reproduces the performance of MC-PDFT. These results further demonstrate the potential of L-PDFT, as its scaling is constant with the number of states included in the state-average manifold, whereas MC-PDFT scales linearly in this regard.

Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory for Vertical Excitation Energies in Actinide Molecules

Modeling actinides with electronic structure theories is challenging because these systems present a strong ligand field and metal-ligand covalency. We systematically investigate the effectiveness of pair-density functional theory (PDFT) for the calculation of vertical excitation energies in An(III), [AnIIICl6]3-, and [AnVIO2]2+ (An = U, Np, Pu, and Am). We compare the performance of PDFT, hybrid PDFT, and multistate PDFT with traditional active-space methods followed by perturbation theory, like multistate CASPT2, and with experimental data. Overall, multistate PDFT gives quantitative agreement with multistate CASPT2 at a significantly reduced computational cost.

Galván I, Alavi A, Aleotti F, Aquilante F, Autschbach J, Avagliano D, Baiardi A, Bao JJ, Battaglia S, Birnoschi L, Blanco-González A, Bokarev SI, Broer R, Cacciari R, Calio PB, Carlson RK, Carvalho Couto R, Cerdán L, Chibotaru LF, Chilton NF, Church JR, Conti I, Coriani S, Cuéllar-Zuquin J, Daoud RE, Dattani N, Decleva P, de Graaf C, Delcey M, De Vico L, Dobrautz W, Dong SS, Feng R, Ferré N, Filatov(Gulak) M, Gagliardi L, Garavelli M, González L, Guan Y, Guo M, Hennefarth MR, Hermes MR, Hoyer CE, Huix-Rotllant M, Jaiswal VK, Kaiser A, Kaliakin DS, Khamesian M, King DS, Kochetov V, Krośnicki M, Kumaar AA, Larsson ED, Lehtola S, Lepetit MB, Lischka H, López Ríos P, Lundberg M, Ma D, Mai S, Marquetand P, Merritt ICD, Montorsi F, Mörchen M, Nenov A, Nguyen VHA, Nishimoto Y, Oakley MS, Olivucci M, Oppel M, Padula D, Pandharkar R, Phung QM, Plasser F, Raggi G, Rebolini E, Reiher M, Rivalta I, Roca-Sanjuán D, Romig T, Safari AA, Sánchez-Mansilla A, Sand AM, Schapiro I, Scott TR, Segarra-Martí J, Segatta F, Sergentu DC, Sharma P, Shepard R, Shu Y, Staab JK, Straatsma TP, Sørensen LK, Tenorio BNC, Truhlar DG, Ungur L, Vacher M, Veryazov V, Voß TA, Weser O, Wu D, Yang X, Yarkony D, Zhou C, Zobel JP, Lindh R. The OpenMolcas Web: A Community-Driven Approach to Advancing Computational Chemistry

The developments of the open-source OpenMolcas chemistry software environment since spring 2020 are described, with a focus on novel functionalities accessible in the stable branch of the package or via interfaces with other packages. These developments span a wide range of topics in computational chemistry and are presented in thematic sections: electronic structure theory, electronic spectroscopy simulations, analytic gradients and molecular structure optimizations, ab initio molecular dynamics, and other new features. This report offers an overview of the chemical phenomena and processes OpenMolcas can address, while showing that OpenMolcas is an attractive platform for state-of-the-art atomistic computer simulations.

Understanding Antiferromagnetic and Ligand Field Effects on Spin Crossover in a Triple-Decker Dimeric Cr(II) Complex

Two possible explanations for the temperature dependence of spin-crossover (SCO) behavior in the dimeric triple-decker Cr(II) complex ([(η5-C5Me5)Cr(μ2:η5-P5)Cr(η5-C5Me5)]+) have been offered. One invokes variations in antiferromagnetic interactions between the two Cr(II) ions, whereas the other posits the development of a strong ligand-field effect favoring the low-spin ground state. We perform multireference electronic structure calculations based on the multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory to resolve these effects. We find quintet, triplet, and singlet electronic ground states, respectively, for the experimental geometries at high, intermediate, and low temperatures. The ground-state transition from quintet to triplet at an intermediate temperature derives from increased antiferromagnetic interactions between the two Cr(II) ions. By contrast, the ground-state transition from triplet to singlet at low temperature can be attributed to increased ligand-field effects, which dominate with continued variations in antiferromagnetic coupling. This study provides quantitative detail for the degree to which these two effects can act in concert for the observed SCO behavior in this complex and others subject to temperature-dependent variations in geometry.

An Accurate Density Coherence Functional for Hybrid Multiconfiguration Density Coherence Functional Theory

We present hybrid multiconfiguration density coherence functional theory (HMC-DCFT), and we optimize a density coherence functional by parametrization against a diverse data set of 59 bond energies and 60 barrier heights. We compare the results to calculations on the same data set by CASSCF, CASPT2, six Kohn-Sham and hybrid Kohn-Sham exchange-correlation functionals, and three on-top functionals for pair-density functional theory (PDFT) and hybrid PDFT. The new functional has better accuracy than all compared methods.

Predicting Magnetic Coupling and Spin-Polarization Energy in Triangulene Analogues

Triangulene and its analogue metal-free magnetic systems have garnered increasing attention since their discovery. Predicting the magnetic coupling and spin-polarization energy with quantitative accuracy is beyond the predictive power of today's density functional theory (DFT) due to their intrinsic multireference character. Herein, we create a benchmark dataset of 25 magnetic systems with nonlocal spin densities, including the triangulene monomer, dimer, and their analogues. We calculate the magnetic coupling (J) and spin-polarization energy (ΔE_spin) of these systems using complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) and coupled-cluster methods as high-quality reference values. This reference data is then used to benchmark 22 DFT functionals commonly used in material science. Our results show that, while some functionals consistently correctly predict the qualitative character of the ground state, achieving quantitative accuracy with small relative errors is currently not feasible. PBE0, M06-2X, and MN15 are predicting the correct electronic ground state for all systems investigated here and also have the lowest mean absolute error for predicting both ΔE_spin (0.34, 0.32, and 0.31 eV) and J (11.74, 12.66, and 10.64 meV). They may therefore also serve as starting points for higher-level methods such as the GW or the random phase approximation. As other functionals fail for the prediction of the ground state, they cannot be recommended for metal-free magnetic systems.

Global Potential Energy Surfaces by Compressed-State Multistate Pair-Density Functional Theory: The Lowest Doublet States Responsible for the N(4Su) + C2(a 3Πu) → CN(X 2Σ+) + C(3Pg) Reaction

Global potential energy surfaces (PESs) for the 1 ²A' and 1 ²A″ states of the C₂N system responsible for the N(⁴S_u) + C₂(a ³Π_u) → CN(X ²Σ⁺) + C(³P_g) reaction are mapped using compressed-state multistate pair-density functional theory (CMS-PDFT), which is a multi-state version of multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory (MC-PDFT). Calculations are also performed at selected geometries by explicitly correlated multireference configuration interaction with quadruple corrections, MRCI-F12+Q, and the comparison of the two sets of calculations shows that CMS-PDFT describes the globally reactive PESs well, including the bond-breaking asymptotes. We conclude that CMS-PDFT is an efficient method for constructing PESs for strongly correlated reactive systems. The PESs for producing CN + C are found to be barrierless and proceed through intermediate complexes. The CMS-PDFT PESs were fitted with a neural network method, and quasiclassical trajectories were computed on the resulting analytic PESs. These trajectories predict that the reaction produces vibrationally excited CN.

Efficient Multiconfigurational Quantum Chemistry Approach to Single-Ion Magnets Based on Density Matrix Embedding Theory

Density matrix embedding theory (DMET) provides a systematic framework to combine low-level (e.g., Hartree-Fock approximation) and high-level correlated quantum chemistry methods to treat strongly correlated systems. In this work, we propose an efficient quantum embedding approach that combines DMET with the complete active space self-consistent field and subsequent state interaction treatment of spin-orbit coupling (CASSI-SO) and apply it to a theoretical description of single-ion magnets (SIMs). We have developed a novel regularized direct inversion of iterative subspace (R-DIIS) technique that ensures restricted open-shell Hartree-Fock converging to a physically correct ground state, which is found to be crucial for the efficacy of subsequent CASSI-SO calculation. The DMET+CASSI-SO approach can produce reliable zero-field splitting parameters in typical 3d-SIMs with dramatically reduced computational cost compared to its all-electron counterpart. This work therefore demonstrates the great potential of DMET-based multiconfigurational approaches for efficient ab initio study of magneto-structural correlations in complex molecular magnetic systems.

Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory for Chromium(IV) Molecular Qubits

Pseudotetrahedral organometallic complexes containing chromium(IV) and aryl ligands have been experimentally identified as promising molecular qubit candidates. Here we present a computational protocol based on multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory for computing singlet-triplet gaps and zero-field splitting (ZFS) parameters in Cr(IV) aryl complexes. We find that two multireference methods, multistate complete active space second-order perturbation theory (MS-CASPT2) and hybrid multistate pair-density functional theory (HMS-PDFT), perform better than Kohn-Sham density functional theory for singlet-triplet gaps. Despite the very small values of the ZFS parameters, both multireference methods performed qualitatively well. MS-CASPT2 and HMS-PDFT performed particularly well for predicting the trend in the ratio of the rhombic and axial ZFS parameters, |E/D|. We have also investigated the dependence and sensitivity of the calculated ZFS parameters on the active space and the molecular geometry. The methodologies outlined here can guide future prediction of ZFS parameters in molecular qubit candidates.