Cononsolvency of thermoresponsive polymers: where we are now and where we are going

Asymmetry in Polymer-Solvent Interactions Yields Complex Thermoresponsive Behavior

We introduce a lattice framework that incorporates elements of Flory-Huggins solution theory and the q-state Potts model to study the phase behavior of polymer solutions and single-chain conformational characteristics. Without empirically introducing temperature-dependent interaction parameters, standard Flory-Huggins theory describes systems that are either homogeneous across temperatures or exhibit upper critical solution temperatures. The proposed Flory-Huggins-Potts framework extends these capabilities by predicting lower critical solution temperatures, miscibility loops, and hourglass-shaped spinodal curves. We particularly show that including orientation-dependent interactions, specifically between monomer segments and solvent particles, is alone sufficient to observe such phase behavior. Signatures of emergent phase behavior are found in single-chain Monte Carlo simulations, which display heating- and cooling-induced coil-globule transitions linked to energy fluctuations. The framework also capably describes a range of experimental systems. Importantly, and by contrast to many prior theoretical approaches, the framework does not employ any temperature- or composition-dependent parameters. This work provides new insights regarding the microscopic physics that underpin complex thermoresponsive behavior in polymers.

Mechanism of poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) cononsolvency in aqueous methanol solutions explored via oxygen K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy

The cononsolvency mechanism of poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM), dissolving in pure methanol (MeOH) and water (H2O) but being insoluble in MeOH-H2O mixtures, was investigated by O K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS). The cononsolvency emerges from the aggregation of PNIPAM with MeOH clusters, leading to the collapse of the hydrophobic hydration of PNIPAM.

Cosolvent incorporation modulates the thermal and structural response of PNIPAM/silyl methacrylate copolymers

Polymers functionalized with inorganic silane groups have been used in wide-ranging applications due to the silane reactivity, which enables formation of covalently-crosslinked polymeric structures. Utilizing stimuli-responsive polymers in these hybrid systems can lead to smart and tunable behavior for sensing, drug delivery, and optical coatings. Previously, the thermoresponsive polymer poly(N-isopropyl acrylamide) (PNIPAM) functionalized with 3-(trimethoxysilyl)propyl methacrylate (TMA) demonstrated unique aqueous self-assembly and optical responses following temperature elevation. Here, we investigate how cosolvent addition, particularly ethanol and N,N-dimethyl formamide (DMF), impacts these transition temperatures, optical clouding, and structure formation in NIPAM/TMA copolymers. Versus purely aqueous systems, these solvent mixtures can introduce additional phase transitions and can alter the two-phase region boundaries based on temperature and solvent composition. Interestingly, TMA incorporation strongly alters phase boundaries in the water-rich regime for DMF-containing systems but not for ethanol-containing systems. Cosolvent species and content also alter the aggregation and assembly of NIPAM/TMA copolymers, but these effects depend on polymer architecture. For example, localizing the TMA towards one chain end in 'blocky' domains leads to formation of uniform micelles with narrow dispersities above the cloud point for certain solvent compositions. In contrast, polydisperse aggregates form in random copolymer and PNIPAM homopolymer solutions - the size of which depends on solvent composition. The resulting optical responses and thermoreversibility also depend strongly on cosolvent content and copolymer architecture. Cosolvent incorporation thus increases the versatility of inorganic-functionalized responsive polymers for diverse applications by providing a simple way to tune the structure size and optical response.

Tuning Local Order in Starch Nanoparticles Exploiting Nonsolvency with "Green" Solvents

Starch is a renewable biopolymer that can be sourced from agricultural waste and used to produce nanoparticles (SNPs). In particular, amorphous SNPs have potential application in numerous fields, including the consolidation of weakened paintings in the cultural heritage preservation. Starch dissolution followed by nanoprecipitation in nonsolvents is an advantageous synthetic route, but new methodologies are needed to feasibly control the physicochemical properties of the SNPs. Here, we explored nanoprecipitation by nonsolvency using a set of "green" solvents to obtain amorphous SNPs, rather than starch nanocrystals already reported in the literature. The effect of the nonsolvent on the ordering of polymer chains in the obtained SNPs was studied. The recovery of local order (e.g., isolated V-type helices) after dissolution was shown to depend on the type of solvents used in the dissolution and precipitation steps, while long-range order (extended arrays of helices) is lost. Aqueous dispersions of the SNPs provided effective consolidation of powdery painted layers, showing that the selection of particle synthetic routes can be dictated by sustainability and scalability criteria. These "green" formulations are candidates as new consolidants in art preservation, and the possibility of tuning local order in amorphous starch assemblies might also impact fields like food chemistry, pharmaceutics, and nanocomposites, where SNPs with tunable amorphousness are more advantageous than nanocrystals.

Porous Anisometric PNIPAM Microgels: Tailored Porous Structure and Thermal Response

The porous structure of microgels significantly influences their properties and, thus, their suitability for various applications, in particular as building blocks for tissue scaffolds. Porosity is one of the crucial features for microgel-cell interactions and significantly increases the cells' accumulation and proliferation. Consequently, tailoring the porosity of microgels in an effortless way is important but still challenging, especially for nonspherical microgels. This work presents a straightforward procedure to fabricate complex-shaped poly(N-isopropyl acrylamide) (PNIPAM) microgels with tuned porous structures using the so-called cononsolvency effect during microgel polymerization. Therefore, the classical solvent in the reaction solution is exchanged from water to water-methanol mixtures in a stop-flow lithography process. For cylindrical microgels with a higher methanol content during fabrication, a greater degree of collapsing is observed, and their aspect ratio increases. Furthermore, the collapsing and swelling velocities change with the methanol content, indicating a modified porous structure, which is confirmed by electron microscopy micrographs. Furthermore, swelling patterns of the microgel variants occur during cooling, revealing their thermal response as a highly heterogeneous process. These results show a novel procedure to fabricate PNIPAM microgels of any elongated 2D shape with tailored porous structure and thermoresponsiveness by introducing the cononsolvency effect during stop-flow lithography polymerization.

Thermoresponsive Polymers under Pressure with a Focus on Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM)

Pressure is a key variable in the phase behavior of responsive polymers, both for applications and from a fundamental point of view. In this feature article, we review recent developments, particularly applications of neutron techniques such as small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) and quasi-elastic neutron scattering (QENS), across the temperature-pressure phase diagram. These are complemented by kinetic SANS experiments following pressure jumps. In the prototype system poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM), QENS revealed the pressure-dependent characteristics of hydration water around the lower critical solution temperature transition. The size, water content, and inner structure of the mesoglobules formed in the two-phase region depend strongly on pressure, as shown by SANS. Beside these changes at the phase transition, the mesoglobule formation at low pressure is determined by kinetic factors, namely the formation of a polymer-rich, rigid shell, which hampers further growth by coalescence. At high pressure, in contrast, the growth proceeds by diffusion-limited coalescence without any kinetic hindrance. The disintegration of the mesoglobules evolves either via chain release from their surface or via swelling, depending on the osmotic pressure of the water. Moreover, we report on the profound influence of pressure on the cononsolvency effect. In the temperature-pressure frame, the one-phase region is hugely expanded upon the addition of the cosolvent methanol. SANS experiments unveil the enthalpic and entropic contributions to the effective Flory-Huggins interaction parameter between the segments and the solvent mixture. QENS experiments demonstrate an increase in polymer associated water with pressure, whereas methanol is released. Correspondingly, the solvent phase becomes enriched in methanol, providing a mechanism for the breakdown of cononsolvency at a high pressure. Finally, we outline future opportunities for high-pressure studies of thermoresponsive polymers, with a focus on neutron methods.

The Colloidal Stability of Apolar Nanoparticles in Solvent Mixtures

Solvent engineering is a powerful and versatile method to tune colloidal stability. Here, we link the molecular structure of apolar ligand shells on gold nanoparticles with their colloidal stability in solvent mixtures. The agglomeration temperature of the particles was measured with small-angle X-ray scattering. It depended on solvent composition and changed linearly for hexane-hexadecane mixtures, but nonlinearly for cyclohexane-hexadecane and hexanol-hexadecane mixtures. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations indicate that agglomeration is dominated by temperature-dependent ligand order in the alkane mixtures and that the temperature at which the ligand shell orders depends on the solvent composition near the ligands, which can differ substantially from the bulk composition. Small-angle neutron scattering confirmed that, at intermediate solvent compositions above the agglomeration temperature, the fraction of cyclohexane near the ligands was larger than in the bulk. The enrichment of cyclohexane near the ligands stabilized their disordered state, which, consequently, led to the experimentally observed nonlinear trend of the agglomeration temperature. In contrast, hexanol was depleted from the ligand shell at all temperatures. This again stabilized the disordered state. Furthermore, we found that agglomeration at high hexanol fractions was driven by a solvophobic effect that exceeded the influence of ligand order. The results show that strong nonlinearities in the colloidal stability of nanoparticle dispersions in solvent mixtures are directly linked to the molecular details of ligand-solvent and solvent-solvent interactions, which can be used to precisely tune stability.

Thermoresponsive and co-nonsolvency behavior of poly(N-vinyl isobutyramide) and poly(N-isopropyl methacrylamide) as poly(N-isopropyl acrylamide) analogs in aqueous media

Sets of the nonionic polymers poly(N-vinyl isobutyramide) (pNVIBAm) and poly(N-isopropyl methacrylamide) (pNIPMAm) are synthesized by radical polymerization covering the molar mass range from about 20,000 to 150,000 kg mol−1, and their thermoresponsive and solvent-responsive behaviors in aqueous solution are studied. Both polymers feature a lower critical solution temperature (LCST) apparently of the rare so-called type II, as characteristic for their well-studied analogue poly(N-isopropyl acrylamide) (pNIPAm). Moreover, in analogy to pNIPAm, both polymers exhibit co-nonsolvency behavior in mixtures of water with several co-solvents, including short-chain alcohols as well as a range of polar aprotic solvents. While the cloud points of the aqueous solutions are a few degrees higher than those for pNIPAm and increase in the order pNIPAm < pNVIBAm < pNIPMAm, the co-nonsolvency behavior becomes less pronounced in the order pNIPAm > pNVIBAm > pNIPMAm. Exceptionally, pNIPMAm does not show co-nonsolvency in mixtures of water and N,N-dimethylformamide.

Graphical Abstract

Swift Janitor: Efficient Absorption of a Minor Component from the Mixtures of Immiscible Liquids by Thermoresponsive Macroscopic and Microscopic Hydrogels

Polymer hydrogels are known to be efficient absorbents of various aqueous solutions. Along with the hydrophilicity of the polymer network, the presence of specific functional groups is required for the absorption of respective solutes. Alternatively, a selective uptake can be realized without any specific attraction of solutes to the network, which is shown in this paper. By combining experimental and simulation approaches, we demonstrated that thermoresponsive poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) gels and microgels in compositionally strongly asymmetric water/1-octanol mixtures selectively uptake the minor (1-octanol) component. Initially swollen in water, the gels substitute water by the organic solvent upon the addition of its small fraction into aqueous solution. In turn, for microgels, it was shown that the single particles could absorb the amount of the organic liquid more than two times higher than their mass while preserving the colloidal stability. At the same time, the accumulation of 1-octanol in the networks "switches off" the temperature response. The mesoscopic computer simulations revealed a physical reason and molecular picture of the phenomenon. Absorption of the minor component by the gels is caused by the decrease in water/1-octanol interfacial tension due to the formation of the dense polymer layer at the interface. The simulations allowed tracking the evolution of the size and the internal structure of the single microgels with changing 1-octanol concentration.

Distinctly different solvation behaviors of poly(N,N-diethylacrylamide) gels in water/acetone and water/DMSO mixtures

The solvation behaviors and intermolecular interactions of a poly(N,N-diethylacrylamide) (PDEA) gel network in water/DMSO and water/acetone mixtures have been investigated by variable-temperature high-resolution ¹H MAS NMR. Unlike decreasing volume phase transition temperature (VPTT) of the typical thermosensitive poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) gel induced by both acetone and DMSO in a water-rich region, distinct phase transition behaviors are revealed for the PDEA gel. That is, acetone is found to increase the VPTT of PDEA directly in the water-rich region while DMSO is also found to increase the VPTT of PDEA at a very low concentration but then decrease the VPTT as the concentration further increases. The above distinctly different VPTT shifts of PDEA are attributed to the different polymer-cosolvent interactions in water/acetone and water/DMSO systems. DMSO molecules with a strong water affinity are preferentially excluded by the PDEA gel network, and can promote the volume phase transition by favoring the collapse of the PDEA gel network, while acetone molecules preferentially adsorbed on the polymer interact with PDEA via non-specific van der Waals interaction, which favors the swollen state of the PDEA gel.

Cononsolvency of the responsive polymer poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) in water/methanol mixtures: a dynamic light scattering study of the effect of pressure on the collective dynamics

The collective dynamics of 25 wt% poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) solutions in water or an 80:20 v/v water/methanol mixture are investigated in the one-phase region in dependence on pressure and temperature using dynamic light scattering. Throughout, two dynamic modes are observed, the fast one corresponding to the relaxation of the chain segments within the polymer blobs and the slow one to the relaxation of the blobs. A pressure scan in the one-phase region on an aqueous solution at 34.0 °C, i.e., slightly below the maximum of the coexistence line, reveals that the dynamic correlation length of the fast mode increases when the left and the right branch of the coexistence line are approached. Thus, the chains are rather swollen far away from the coexistence line, but contracted near the phase transition. Temperature scans of solutions in neat H2O or in H2O/CD3OD at 0.1, 130, and 200 MPa reveal that the dynamic correlation length of the fast mode shows critical behavior. However, the critical exponents are significantly larger than the value predicted by mean-field theory for the static correlation length, ν = 0.5, and the exponent is significantly larger for the solution in the H2O/CD3OD mixture than in neat H2O.