The orientation of the three haems of the 'in situ' ubiquinol oxidase, cytochrome bd, of Escherichia coli

Homologous bd oxidases share the same architecture but differ in mechanism

Cytochrome bd oxidases are terminal reductases of bacterial and archaeal respiratory chains. The enzyme couples the oxidation of ubiquinol or menaquinol with the reduction of dioxygen to water, thus contributing to the generation of the protonmotive force. Here, we determine the structure of the Escherichia coli bd oxidase treated with the specific inhibitor aurachin by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The major subunits CydA and CydB are related by a pseudo two fold symmetry. The heme b and d cofactors are found in CydA, while ubiquinone-8 is bound at the homologous positions in CydB to stabilize its structure. The architecture of the E. coli enzyme is highly similar to that of Geobacillus thermodenitrificans, however, the positions of heme b₅₉₅ and d are interchanged, and a common oxygen channel is blocked by a fourth subunit and substituted by a more narrow, alternative channel. Thus, with the same overall fold, the homologous enzymes exhibit a different mechanism.

Cytochrome bd oxidases couple quinol oxidation and the release of protons to the periplasmic side with proton uptake from the cytoplasmic side to reduce dioxygen to water and they are the terminal reductases in bacterial and archaeal respiratory chains. Here the authors present the cryo-EM structure of Escherichia coli bd oxidase and discuss mechanistic implications.

Five decades of research on mitochondrial NADH-quinone oxidoreductase (complex I)

NADH-quinone oxidoreductase (complex I) is the largest and most complicated enzyme complex of the mitochondrial respiratory chain. It is the entry site into the respiratory chain for most of the reducing equivalents generated during metabolism, coupling electron transfer from NADH to quinone to proton translocation, which in turn drives ATP synthesis. Dysfunction of complex I is associated with neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s, and it is proposed to be involved in aging. Complex I has one non-covalently bound FMN, eight to 10 iron-sulfur clusters, and protein-associated quinone molecules as electron transport components. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) has previously been the most informative technique, especially in membrane in situ analysis. The structure of complex 1 has now been resolved from a number of species, but the mechanisms by which electron transfer is coupled to transmembrane proton pumping remains unresolved. Ubiquinone-10, the terminal electron acceptor of complex I, is detectable by EPR in its one electron reduced, semiquinone (SQ) state. In the aerobic steady state of respiration the semi-ubiquinone anion has been observed and studied in detail. Two distinct protein-associated fast and slow relaxing, SQ signals have been resolved which were designated SQNf and SQNs. This review covers a five decade personal journey through the field leading to a focus on the unresolved questions of the role of the SQ radicals and their possible part in proton pumping.

Oxygen as Acceptor

Like most bacteria, Escherichia coli has a flexible and branched respiratory chain that enables the prokaryote to live under a variety of environmental conditions, from highly aerobic to completely anaerobic. In general, the bacterial respiratory chain is composed of dehydrogenases, a quinone pool, and reductases. Substrate-specific dehydrogenases transfer reducing equivalents from various donor substrates (NADH, succinate, glycerophosphate, formate, hydrogen, pyruvate, and lactate) to a quinone pool (menaquinone, ubiquinone, and dimethylmenoquinone). Then electrons from reduced quinones (quinols) are transferred by terminal reductases to different electron acceptors. Under aerobic growth conditions, the terminal electron acceptor is molecular oxygen. A transfer of electrons from quinol to O₂ is served by two major oxidoreductases (oxidases), cytochrome bo₃ encoded by cyoABCDE and cytochrome bd encoded by cydABX. Terminal oxidases of aerobic respiratory chains of bacteria, which use O₂ as the final electron acceptor, can oxidize one of two alternative electron donors, either cytochrome c or quinol. This review compares the effects of different inhibitors on the respiratory activities of cytochrome bo₃ and cytochrome bd in E. coli. It also presents a discussion on the genetics and the prosthetic groups of cytochrome bo₃ and cytochrome bd. The E. coli membrane contains three types of quinones that all have an octaprenyl side chain (C₄₀). It has been proposed that the bo₃ oxidase can have two ubiquinone-binding sites with different affinities. "WHAT'S NEW" IN THE REVISED ARTICLE: The revised article comprises additional information about subunit composition of cytochrome bd and its role in bacterial resistance to nitrosative and oxidative stresses. Also, we present the novel data on the electrogenic function of appBCX-encoded cytochrome bd-II, a second bd-type oxidase that had been thought not to contribute to generation of a proton motive force in E. coli, although its spectral properties closely resemble those of cydABX-encoded cytochrome bd.

Oxoferryl-porphyrin radical catalytic intermediate in cytochrome bd oxidases protects cells from formation of reactive oxygen species

The quinol-linked cytochrome bd oxidases are terminal oxidases in respiration. These oxidases harbor a low spin heme b(558) that donates electrons to a binuclear heme b(595)/heme d center. The reaction with O(2) and subsequent catalytic steps of the Escherichia coli cytochrome bd-I oxidase were investigated by means of ultra-fast freeze-quench trapping followed by EPR and UV-visible spectroscopy. After the initial binding of O(2), the O-O bond is heterolytically cleaved to yield a kinetically competent heme d oxoferryl porphyrin π-cation radical intermediate (compound I) magnetically interacting with heme b(595). Compound I accumulates to 0.75-0.85 per enzyme in agreement with its much higher rate of formation (~20,000 s(-1)) compared with its rate of decay (~1,900 s(-1)). Compound I is next converted to a short lived heme d oxoferryl intermediate (compound II) in a phase kinetically matched to the oxidation of heme b(558) before completion of the reaction. The results indicate that cytochrome bd oxidases like the heme-copper oxidases break the O-O bond in a single four-electron transfer without a peroxide intermediate. However, in cytochrome bd oxidases, the fourth electron is donated by the porphyrin moiety rather than by a nearby amino acid. The production of reactive oxygen species by the cytochrome bd oxidase was below the detection level of 1 per 1000 turnovers. We propose that the two classes of terminal oxidases have mechanistically converged to enzymes in which the O-O bond is broken in a single four-electron transfer reaction to safeguard the cell from the formation of reactive oxygen species.

The cytochrome bd respiratory oxygen reductases

Cytochrome bd is a respiratory quinol: O₂ oxidoreductase found in many prokaryotes, including a number of pathogens. The main bioenergetic function of the enzyme is the production of a proton motive force by the vectorial charge transfer of protons. The sequences of cytochromes bd are not homologous to those of the other respiratory oxygen reductases, i.e., the heme-copper oxygen reductases or alternative oxidases (AOX). Generally, cytochromes bd are noteworthy for their high affinity for O₂ and resistance to inhibition by cyanide. In E. coli, for example, cytochrome bd (specifically, cytochrome bd-I) is expressed under O₂-limited conditions. Among the members of the bd-family are the so-called cyanide-insensitive quinol oxidases (CIO) which often have a low content of the eponymous heme d but, instead, have heme b in place of heme d in at least a majority of the enzyme population. However, at this point, no sequence motif has been identified to distinguish cytochrome bd (with a stoichiometric complement of heme d) from an enzyme designated as CIO. Members of the bd-family can be subdivided into those which contain either a long or a short hydrophilic connection between transmembrane helices 6 and 7 in subunit I, designated as the Q-loop. However, it is not clear whether there is a functional consequence of this difference. This review summarizes current knowledge on the physiological functions, genetics, structural and catalytic properties of cytochromes bd. Included in this review are descriptions of the intermediates of the catalytic cycle, the proposed site for the reduction of O₂, evidence for a proton channel connecting this active site to the bacterial cytoplasm, and the molecular mechanism by which a membrane potential is generated.

Oxygen as Acceptor

Like most bacteria, Escherichia coli has a flexible and branched respiratory chain that enables the prokaryote to live under a variety of environmental conditions, from highly aerobic to completely anaerobic. In general, the bacterial respiratory chain is composed of dehydrogenases, a quinone pool, and reductases. Substrate specific dehydrogenases transfer reducing equivalents from various donor substrates (NADH, succinate, glycerophoshate, formate, hydrogen, pyruvate, and lactate) to a quinone pool (menaquinone, ubiquinone, and demethylmenoquinone). Then electrons from reduced quinones (quinols) are transferred by terminal reductases to different electron acceptors. Under aerobic growth conditions, the terminal electron acceptor is molecular oxygen. A transfer of electrons from quinol to O2 is served by two major oxidoreductases (oxidases), cytochrome bo3 and cytochrome bd. Terminal oxidases of aerobic respiratory chains of bacteria, which use O2 as the final electron acceptor, can oxidize one of two alternative electron donors, either cytochrome c or quinol. This review compares the effects of different inhibitors on the respiratory activities of cytochrome bo3 and cytochrome bd in E. coli. It also presents a discussion on the genetics and the prosthetic groups of cytochrome bo3 and cytochrome bd. The E. coli membrane contains three types of quinones which all have an octaprenyl side chain (C40). It has been proposed that the bo3 oxidase can have two ubiquinone-binding sites with different affinities. The spectral properties of cytochrome bd-II closely resemble those of cydAB-encoded cytochrome bd.

Glutamates 99 and 107 in Transmembrane Helix III of Subunit I of Cytochrome bd Are Critical for Binding of the Heme b595-d Binuclear Center and Enzyme Activity

Cytochrome bd is a quinol oxidase of Escherichia coli under microaerophilic growth conditions. Coupling of the release of protons to the periplasm by quinol oxidation to the uptake of protons from the cytoplasm for dioxygen reduction generates a proton motive force. On the basis of sequence analysis, glutamates 99 and 107 conserved in transmembrane helix III of subunit I have been proposed to convey protons from the cytoplasm to heme d at the periplasmic side. To probe a putative proton channel present in subunit I of E. coli cytochrome bd, we substituted a total of 10 hydrophilic residues and two glycines conserved in helices I and III-V and examined effects of amino acid substitutions on the oxidase activity and bound hemes. We found that Ala or Leu mutants of Arg9 and Thr15 in helix I, Gly93 and Gly100 in helix III, and Ser190 and Thr194 in helix V exhibited the wild-type phenotypes, while Ala and Gln mutants of His126 in helix IV retained all hemes but partially lost the activity. In contrast, substitutions of Thr26 in helix I, Glu99 and Glu107 in helix III, Ser140 in helix IV, and Thr187 in helix V resulted in the concomitant loss of bound heme b558 (T187L) or b595-d (T26L, E99L/A/D, E107L/A/D, and S140A) and the activity. Glu99 and Glu107 mutants except E107L completely lost the heme b595-d center, as reported for heme b595 ligand (His19) mutants. On the basis of this study and previous studies, we propose arrangement of transmembrane helices in subunit I, which may explain possible roles of conserved hydrophilic residues within the membrane.

Proton NMR study of the heme environment in bacterial quinol oxidases

The heme environment and ligand binding properties of two relatively large membrane proteins containing multiple paramagnetic metal centers, cytochrome bo3 and bd quinol oxidases, have been studied by high field proton nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The oxidized bo3 enzyme displays well-resolved hyperfine-shifted 1H NMR resonance assignable to the low-spin heme b center. The observed spectral changes induced by addition of cyanide to the protein were attributed to the structural perturbations on the low-spin heme (heme b) center by cyanide ligation to the nearby high-spin heme (heme o) of the protein. The oxidized hd oxidase shows extremely broad signals in the spectral region where protons near high-spin heme centers resonate. Addition of cyanide to the oxidized bd enzyme induced no detectable perturbations on the observed hyperfine signals, indicating the insensitive nature of this heme center toward cyanide. The proton signals near the low-spin heme b558 center are only observed in the presence of 20% formamide, consistent with a critical role of viscosity in detecting NMR signals of large membrane proteins. The reduced bd protein also displays hyperfine-shifted 1H NMR signals, indicating that the high-spin heme centers (hemes b595 and d) remain high-spin upon chemical reduction. The results presented here demonstrate that structural changes of one metal center can significantly influence the structural properties of other nearby metal center(s) in large membrane paramagnetic metalloproteins.

Interactions between heme d and heme b595 in quinol oxidase bd from Escherichia coli: a photoselection study using femtosecond spectroscopy

Femtosecond spectroscopy was performed on CO-liganded (fully reduced and mixed-valence states) and O(2)-liganded quinol oxidase bd from Escherichia coli. Substantial polarization effects, unprecedented for optical studies of heme proteins, were observed in the CO photodissociation spectra, implying interactions between heme d (the chlorin ligand binding site) and the close-lying heme b(595) on the picosecond time scale; this general result is fully consistent with previous work [Vos, M. H., Borisov, V. B., Liebl, U., Martin, J.-L., and Konstantinov, A. A. (2000) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 97, 1554-1559]. Analysis of the data obtained under isotropic and anisotropic polarization conditions and additional flash photolysis nanosecond experiments on a mutant of cytochrome bd mostly lacking heme b(595) allow to attribute the features in the well-known but unusual CO dissociation spectrum of cytochrome bd to individual heme d and heme b(595) transitions. This renders it possible to compare the spectra of CO dissociation from reduced and mixed-valence cytochrome bd under static conditions and on a picosecond time scale in much more detail than previously possible. CO binding/dissociation from heme d is shown to perturb ferrous heme b(595), causing induction/loss of an absorption band centered at 435 nm. In addition, the CO photodissociation-induced absorption changes at 50 ps reveal a bathochromic shift of ferrous heme b(595) relative to the static spectrum. No evidence for transient binding of CO to heme b(595) after dissociation from heme d is found in the picosecond time range. The yield of CO photodissociation from heme d on a time scale of < 15 ps is found to be diminished more than 3-fold when heme b(595) is oxidized rather than reduced. In contrast to other known heme proteins, molecular oxygen cannot be photodissociated from the mixed-valence cytochrome bd at all, indicating a unique structural and electronic configuration of the diheme active site in the enzyme.

Femtosecond resolution of ligand-heme interactions in the high-affinity quinol oxidase bd: A di-heme active site?

Interaction of the two high-spin hemes in the oxygen reduction site of the bd-type quinol oxidase from Escherichia coli has been studied by femtosecond multicolor transient absorption spectroscopy. The previously unidentified Soret band of ferrous heme b(595) was determined to be centered around 440 nm by selective excitation of the fully reduced unliganded or CO-bound cytochrome bd in the alpha-band of heme b(595). The redox state of the b-type hemes strongly affects both the line shape and the kinetics of the absorption changes induced by photodissociation of CO from heme d. In the reduced enzyme, CO photodissociation from heme d perturbs the spectrum of ferrous cytochrome b(595) within a few ps, pointing to a direct interaction between hemes b(595) and d. Whereas in the reduced enzyme no heme d-CO geminate recombination is observed, in the mixed-valence CO-liganded complex with heme b(595) initially oxidized, a significant part of photodissociated CO does not leave the protein and recombines with heme d within a few hundred ps. This caging effect may indicate that ferrous heme b(595) provides a transient binding site for carbon monoxide within one of the routes by which the dissociated ligand leaves the protein. Taken together, the data indicate physical proximity of the hemes d and b(595) and corroborate the possibility of a functional cooperation between the two hemes in the dioxygen-reducing center of cytochrome bd.

Sequence analysis of cytochrome bd oxidase suggests a revised topology for subunit I

Numerous sequences of the cytochrome bd quinol oxidase (cytochrome bd) have recently become available for analysis. The analysis has revealed a small number of conserved residues, a new topology for subunit I and a phylogenetic tree involving extensive horizontal gene transfer. There are 20 conserved residues in subunit I and two in subunit II. Algorithms utilizing multiple sequence alignments predicted a revised topology for cytochrome bd, adding two transmembrane helices to subunit I to the seven that were previously indicated by the analysis of the sequence of the oxidase from E. coli. This revised topology has the effect of relocating the N-terminus and C-terminus to the periplasmic and cytoplasmic sides of the membrane, respectively. The new topology repositions I-H19, the putative ligand for heme b595, close to the periplasmic edge of the membrane, which suggests that the heme b595/heme d active site of the oxidase is located near the outer (periplasmic) surface of the membrane. The most highly conserved region of the sequence of subunit I contains the sequence GRQPW and is located in a predicted periplasmic loop connecting the eighth and ninth transmembrane helices. The potential importance of this region of the protein was previously unsuspected, and it may participate in the binding of either quinol or heme d. There are two very highly conserved glutamates in subunit I, E99 and E107, within the third transmembrane helix (E. coli cytochrome bd-I numbering). It is speculated that these glutamates may be part of a proton channel leading from the cytoplasmic side of the membrane to the heme d oxygen-reactive site, now placed near the periplasmic surface. The revised topology and newly revealed conserved residues provide a clear basis for further experimental tests of these hypotheses. Phylogenetic analysis of the new sequences of cytochrome bd reveals considerable deviation from the 16sRNA tree, suggesting that a large amount of horizontal gene transfer has occurred in the evolution of cytochrome bd.

Angular dependence of electron paramagnetic resonances of an azide-NO complex of cytochrome c oxidase: orientation of the haem-copper axis in cytochrome aa3 from ox heart

The orientation dependence of the EPR signals arising from the azide-nitric oxide complex of cytochrome oxidase was investigated using oriented multilayers of mitochondrial membranes from ox heart. Variations in line shape of the DeltaMS=1 signal of the triplet state were apparent, whilst the DeltaMS=2 transitions between g=4.7 and 3.9 varied in intensity as the angle of the applied magnetic field was varied. These half-field signals were maximal with the field parallel to the membrane plane. A model of the bi-liganded azide-nitric oxide complex has been constructed, in which the nitric oxide is bound to the high-spin haem in a bent configuration, with the Fe-N=O plane at 60-90 degrees to the membrane plane and the azide bound to the copper, distal from the haem. In addition, angular variations of the signals at g'=11 and g' around 3.5, derived from an integer-spin complex, were also observed.

Cyanide-binding site of bd-type ubiquinol oxidase from Escherichia coli

We extended our investigation on the structure of the redox centers of bd-type ubiquinol oxidase from Escherichia coli using cyanide as a monitoring probe. We found that addition of cyanide to the air-oxidized O2-bound enzyme caused appearance of an infrared C-N stretching band at 2161 cm-1 and concomitant disappearance of the 647 nm absorption band of the cytochrome d (Fe2+)-O2 species. Addition of cyanide to the air-oxidized CO-bound enzyme also resulted in disappearance of the 635 nm absorption band and the 1983.4 cm-1 C-O infrared band of the cytochrome d (Fe2+)-CO species. The resulting species had a derivative-shaped electron paramagnetic resonance signal at g = 3.15. Upon partial reduction with sodium dithionite, this species was converted partly to a transient heme d (Fe3+)-C = N species having an electron paramagnetic resonance signal at gz = 2.96 and a C-N infrared band at 2138 cm-1. These observations suggest that the active site of the enzyme has a heme-heme binuclear metal center distinct from that of the heme-copper terminal oxidase and that the treatment of the air-oxidized enzyme with cyanide resulted in a cyanide-bridging species with "heme d(Fe3+)-C = N-heme b595(Fe3+)" structure.

Transmembrane topology and axial ligands to hemes in the cytochrome b subunit of Bacillus subtilis succinate:menaquinone reductase

The membrane-anchoring subunit of Bacillus subtilis succinate:menaquinone reductase is a protein of 202 residues containing two protoheme IX groups with bis-histidine axial ligation. Residues His13, His28, His70, His113, and His155 are the possible heme ligands. The transmembrane topology of this cytochrome was analyzed using fusions to alkaline phosphatase. The results support a proposed model with five transmembrane polypeptide segments and the N-terminus exposed to the cytoplasm. Mutant B. subtilis cytochromes containing a His13-->Tyr, a His28-->Tyr, and a His113-->Tyr mutation, respectively, were produced in Escherichia coli, partially purified, and analyzed. In addition, succinate: menaquinone reductase containing the His13-->Tyr mutation in the anchor subunit was overproduced in B. subtilis, purified, and characterized. The data demonstrate that His13 is not an axial heme ligand. Thermodynamic and spectroscopic properties of the cytochrome are, however, affected by the His13-->Tyr mutation; compared to wild type, the redox potentials of both hemes are negatively shifted and the gmax signal in the EPR spectrum of the high-potential heme is shifted from 3.68 to 3.50. From the combined results we conclude that His28 and His113 function as axial ligands to the low-potential heme, which is located in the membrane near the outer surface of the cytoplasmic membrane. Residues His70 and His155 ligate the high-potential heme, which is positioned close to His13 in the protein, near the inner surface of the membrane.

Cytochrome bd oxidase from Azotobacter vinelandii. Purification and quantitation of ligand binding to the oxygen reduction site

Cytochrome bd has been purified from Azotobacter vinelandii by a new simplified procedure. The heme and total iron content has been measured, as has the number of high affinity CO and NO binding sites. Spectral changes indicate high affinity binding of CO and NO to heme d only, with a stoichiometry of 1 molecule of gas per 2 molecules of heme b or per 3 atoms of iron. The results clearly define a stoichiometry of one heme d per complex. Low affinity binding of CO and NO to heme b595 also occurs at higher ligand concentrations. EPR heme-nitrosyl signals are seen with NO bound to both hemes b595 and d but with no indication of spin exchange coupling. Exposure of the air-oxidized complex to alkaline pH results in removal of molecular oxygen from heme d and a change in line shape of the high spin region of the EPR spectrum. Cyanide binds to both heme d and heme b595 in the air-oxidized complex, displacing molecular oxygen from heme d. The rate of cyanide binding to heme d as assessed by spectral changes at 650 nm does not correlate with the rate of binding to heme b595 as assessed by the loss of the high spin EPR signal. In addition, the cyanide binding rate in the presence of reductant is only 3 times that of the rate of binding to the air-oxidized enzyme, in contrast to the copper-containing oxidases where strong redox cooperativity makes these two rates differ by a factor of at least 10(6). The results do not support the idea of the presence of two strongly interacting hemes in a binuclear center.

Spectroscopic evidence for a heme-heme binuclear center in the cytochrome bd ubiquinol oxidase from Escherichia coli

The cytochrome bd complex is a ubiquinol oxidase, which is part of the aerobic respiratory chain of Escherichia coli. This enzyme is structurally unrelated to the heme-Cu oxidases such as cytochrome c oxidase. While the cytochrome bd complex contains no copper, it does have three heme prosthetic groups: heme b558, heme b595, and heme d (a chlorin). Heme b558 appears to be involved in the oxidation of quinol, and heme d is known to be the site where oxygen binds and is reduced to water. The role of heme b595, which is high spin, is not known. In this paper, CO is used to probe the oxygen-binding site by use of Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy to monitor the stretching frequency of CO bound to the enzyme. Photodissociation at low temperature (e.g., 20 K) of the CO-heme d adduct results in CO associated with the protein within the heme binding pocket. This photodissociated CO can subsequently relax to form a kinetically trapped CO-heme b595 adduct. The data clearly show that heme d and heme b595 must reside within a common binding pocket in the enzyme. The catalytic active site where oxygen is reduced to water is, thus, properly considered to be a heme d-heme b595 binuclear center. This is analogous to the heme alpha 3-Cu(B) binuclear center in the heme-Cu oxidases. Heme b595 may play roles analogous to those proposed for the Cu(B) component of cytochrome c oxidase.