Functional sensitivity of polar surfaces on transmembrane helix 8 and cytoplasmic loop 8-9 of the Escherichia coli GABA (4-aminobutyrate) transporter encoded by gabP: mutagenic analysis of a consensus amphipathic region found in transporters from bacteria to mammals

Structural basis for selective GABA binding in bacterial pathogens

GABA acts as an intercellular signal in eukaryotes and as an interspecies signal in host-microbe interactions. Structural characteristics of selective eukaryotic GABA receptors and bacterial GABA sensors are unknown. Here, we identified the selective GABA-binding protein, called Atu4243, in the plant pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens. A constructed atu4243 mutant was affected in GABA transport and in expression of the GABA-regulated functions, including aggressiveness on two plant hosts and degradation of the quorum-sensing signal. The GABA-bound Atu4243 structure at 1.28 Å reveals that GABA adopts a conformation never observed so far and interacts with two key residues, Arg(203) and Asp(226) of which the role in GABA binding and GABA signalling in Agrobacterium has been validated using appropriate mutants. The conformational GABA-analogue trans-4-aminocrotonic acid (TACA) antagonizes GABA activity, suggesting structural similarities between the binding sites of the bacterial sensor Atu4243 and mammalian GABA(C) receptors. Exploration of genomic databases reveals Atu4243 orthologues in several pathogenic and symbiotic proteobacteria, such as Rhizobium, Azospirillum, Burkholderia and Pseudomonas. Thus, this study establishes a structural basis for selective GABA sensors and offers opportunities for deciphering the role of the GABA-mediated communication in several host-pathogen interactions.

Modelling and mutational evidence identify the substrate binding site and functional elements in APC amino acid transporters

The Amino acid-Polyamine-Organocation (APC) superfamily is the main family of amino acid transporters found in all domains of life and one of the largest families of secondary transporters. Here, using a sensitive homology threading approach and modelling we show that the predicted structure of APC members is extremely similar to the crystal structures of several prokaryotic transporters belonging to evolutionary distinct protein families with different substrate specificities. All of these proteins, despite having no primary amino acid sequence similarity, share a similar structural core, consisting of two V-shaped domains of five transmembrane domains each, intertwined in an antiparallel topology. Based on this model, we reviewed available data on functional mutations in bacterial, fungal and mammalian APCs and obtained novel mutational data, which provide compelling evidence that the amino acid binding pocket is located in the vicinity of the unwound part of two broken helices, in a nearly identical position to the structures of similar transporters. Our analysis is fully supported by the evolutionary conservation and specific amino acid substitutions in the proposed substrate binding domains. Furthermore, it allows predictions concerning residues that might be crucial in determining the specificity profile of APC members. Finally, we show that two cytoplasmic loops constitute important functional elements in APCs. Our work along with different kinetic and specificity profiles of APC members in easily manipulated bacterial and fungal model systems could form a unique framework for combining genetic, in-silico and structural studies, for understanding the function of one of the most important transporter families.

The "Transport Specificity Ratio": a structure-function tool to search the protein fold for loci that control transition state stability in membrane transport catalysis

Background

In establishing structure-function relationships for membrane transport proteins, the interpretation of phenotypic changes can be problematic, owing to uncertainties in protein expression levels, sub-cellular localization, and protein-folding fidelity. A dual-label competitive transport assay called "Transport Specificity Ratio" (TSR) analysis has been developed that is simple to perform, and circumvents the "expression problem," providing a reliable TSR phenotype (a constant) for comparison to other transporters.

Results

Using the Escherichia coli GABA (4-aminobutyrate) permease (GabP) as a model carrier, it is demonstrated that the TSR phenotype is largely independent of assay conditions, exhibiting: (i) indifference to the particular substrate concentrations used, (ii) indifference to extreme changes (40-fold) in transporter expression level, and within broad limits (iii) indifference to assay duration. The theoretical underpinnings of TSR analysis predict all of the above observations, supporting that TSR has (i) applicability in the analysis of membrane transport, and (ii) particular utility in the face of incomplete information on protein expression levels and initial reaction rate intervals (e.g., in high-throughput screening situations). The TSR was used to identify gab permease (GabP) variants that exhibit relative changes in catalytic specificity (k_cat/K_m) for [¹⁴C]GABA (4-aminobutyrate) versus [³H]NA (nipecotic acid).

Conclusions

The TSR phenotype is an easily measured constant that reflects innate molecular properties of the transition state, and provides a reliable index of the difference in catalytic specificity that a carrier exhibits toward a particular pair of substrates. A change in the TSR phenotype, called a Δ(TSR), represents a specificity shift attributable to underlying changes in the intrinsic substrate binding energy (ΔG_b) that translocation catalysts rely upon to decrease activation energy (). TSR analysis is therefore a structure-function tool that enables parsimonious scanning for positions in the protein fold that couple to the transition state, creating stability and thereby serving as functional determinants of catalytic power (efficiency, or specificity).

Thiol modification of cysteine 327 in the eighth transmembrane domain of the light subunit xCT of the heteromeric cystine/glutamate antiporter suggests close proximity to the substrate binding site/permeation pathway

We measured sensitivity to thiol modification of the heteromeric glutamate/cystine transporter 4F2hc-xCT expressed in Xenopus oocytes. p-Chloromercuribenzoate (pCMB) and p-chloromercuribenzenesulfonate (pCMBS) rapidly blocked transport activity. Cys(327), located in the middle of the eighth transmembrane domain of the light subunit (xCT), was found to be the main target of inactivation. Cysteine, an impermeant reducing reagent, reversed pCMB and pCMBS effects only when applied from the extracellular medium. l-Glutamate and l-cystine, but not l-arginine, protected from the inactivation with an IC(50) similar to the K(m). Protection was not temperature-dependent, suggesting that it did not depend on large substrate-induced conformational changes. Mutation of Cys(327) to Ala and Ser slightly modified the K(m) and a C327L mutant abolished transport function without compromising transporter expression at the plasma membrane. The results indicate that Cys(327) is a functionally important residue accessible to the aqueous extracellular environment and is structurally linked to the permeation pathway and/or the substrate binding site.

The Gap1 general amino acid permease acts as an amino acid sensor for activation of protein kinase A targets in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Addition of a nitrogen source to yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) cells starved for nitrogen on a glucose-containing medium triggers activation of protein kinase A (PKA) targets through a pathway that requires for sustained activation both a fermentable carbon source and a complete growth medium (fermentable growth medium induced or FGM pathway). Trehalase is activated, trehalose and glycogen content as well as heat resistance drop rapidly, STRE-controlled genes are repressed, and ribosomal protein genes are induced. We show that the rapid effect of amino acids on these targets specifically requires the general amino acid permease Gap1. In the gap1Delta strain, transport of high concentrations of l-citrulline occurs at a high rate but without activation of trehalase. Metabolism of the amino acids is not required. Point mutants in Gap1 with reduced or deficient transport also showed reduced or deficient signalling. However, two mutations, S391A and S397A, were identified with a differential effect on transport and signalling for l-glutamate and l-citrulline. Specific truncations of the C-terminus of Gap1 (e.g. last 14 or 26 amino acids) did not reduce transport activity but caused the same phenotype as in strains with constitutively high PKA activity also during growth with ammonium as sole nitrogen source. The overactive PKA phenotype was abolished by mutations in the Tpk1 or Tpk2 catalytic subunits. We conclude that Gap1 acts as an amino acid sensor for rapid activation of the FGM signalling pathway which controls the PKA targets, that transport through Gap1 is connected to signalling and that specific truncations of the C-terminus result in permanently activating Gap1 alleles.

Induction of substrate specificity shifts by placement of alanine insertions within the consensus amphipathic region of the Escherichia coli GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) transporter encoded by gabP

The Escherichia coli GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) permease GabP is a prototypical APC (amine/polyamine/choline) super-family transporter that has a CAR (consensus amphipathic region) containing multiple specificity determinants, ostensibly organized on two helical surfaces, one hydrophobic [SHS (sensitive hydrophobic surface)] and the other hydrophilic [SPS (sensitive polar surface)]. To gauge the functional effects of placing alanine insertions at close intervals across the entire GabP CAR, 64 insertion variants were constructed. Insertions, particularly those in the SHS and the SPS, were highly detrimental to steady-state [(3)H]GABA accumulation. TSR (transport specificity ratio) analysis, employing [(3)H]nipecotic acid and [(14)C]GABA, showed that certain alanine insertions were associated with a specificity shift (i.e. a change in k (cat)/ K (m)). An insertion (INS Ala-269) located N-terminal to the SHS increased specificity for [(3)H]nipecotic acid relative to [(14)C]GABA, whereas an insertion (INS Ala-321) located C-terminal to the SPS had the opposite effect. Overall, the results are consistent with a working hypothesis that the GabP CAR contains extensive functional surfaces that may be manipulated by insertion mutagenesis to alter the specificity ( k (cat)/ K (m)) phenotype. The thermodynamic basis of TSR analysis provides generality, suggesting that amino acid insertions could affect specificity in many other transporters, particularly those such as the E. coli phenylalanine permease PheP [Pi, Chow and Pittard (2002) J. Bacteriol. 184, 5842-5847] that have a functionally significant CAR-like domain.

Use of the transport specificity ratio and cysteine-scanning mutagenesis to detect multiple substrate specificity determinants in the consensus amphipathic region of the Escherichia coli GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) transporter encoded by gabP

The Escherichia coli GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) permease, GabP, and other members of the APC (amine/polyamine/choline) transporter superfamily share a CAR (consensus amphipathic region) that probably contributes to solute translocation. If true, then the CAR should contain structural features that act as determinants of substrate specificity ( k (cat)/ K (m)). In order to address this question, we have developed a novel, expression-independent TSR (transport specificity ratio) analysis, and applied it to a series of 69 cysteine-scanning (single-cysteine) variants. The results indicate that GabP has multiple specificity determinants (i.e. residues at which an amino acid substitution substantially perturbs the TSR). Specificity determinants were found: (i) on a hydrophobic surface of the CAR (from Leu-267 to Ala-285), (ii) on a hydrophilic surface of the CAR (from Ser-299 to Arg-318), and (iii) in a cytoplasmic loop (His-233) between transmembrane segments 6 and 7. Overall, these observations show that (i) structural features within the CAR have a role in substrate discrimination (as might be anticipated for a transport conduit) and, interestingly, (ii) the substrate discrimination task is shared among specificity determinants that appear too widely dispersed across the GabP molecule to be in simultaneous contact with the substrates. We conclude that GabP exhibits behaviour consistent with a broadly applicable specificity delocalization principle, which is demonstrated to follow naturally from the classical notion that translocation occurs synchronously with conformational transitions that change the chemical potential of the bound ligand [Tanford (1982) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 79, 2882-2884].

Study of second-site suppression in the pheP gene for the phenylalanine transporter of Escherichia coli

Site-directed mutagenesis was used to investigate a region of the PheP protein corresponding to the postulated consensus amphipathic region (CAR) in the GabP protein. Whereas some critical residues are conserved in both proteins, there are major differences between the two proteins which may reflect different functions for this region. Replacement of R317, Y313, or P341 by a number of other amino acids destroyed the PheP function. An R317E-E234R double mutant exhibited low levels of PheP transport activity, indicating that there is a possible interaction between these two residues in the wild-type protein. E234 is highly conserved in members of the superfamily of amino acid-polyamine-organocation transporters and also is critical for PheP function in the wild-type protein. Second-site suppressors were isolated for mutants with mutations in E234, Y313, R317, and P341. Most suppressor mutations were found to cluster towards the extracellular face of spans III, IX, and X. Some mutations, such as changes at M116, were able to suppress each of the primary changes at positions E234, Y313, R317, and P341 but were unable to restore function to a number of other primary mutants. The possible implications of these results for the tertiary structure of the protein are discussed.

Monomeric state and ligand binding of recombinant GABA transporter from Escherichia coli

The gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) transporter from Escherichia coli was homologously overexpressed and purified to homogeneity with a yield of 1.0 mg per liter culture. The purification procedure consists of a cobalt affinity column, proteolytic cleavage of His- and myc-tags, and size-exclusion chromatography. The purified transporter exists as a monomer in FOS-Choline 12 detergent, with a Stokes radius of 45 A for the protein-detergent complex. In detergent solution the protein binds substrates, as indicated by tryptophan fluorescence quenching. Its dissociation constants (K(d)) for GABA, muscimol and nipecotic acid are 13.8, 13.3 and 27.9 microM, respectively. This protein preparation provides ideal starting materials for future biochemical, biophysical and structural studies of the GABA transporter.

The amino acid/polyamine/organocation (APC) superfamily of transporters specific for amino acids, polyamines and organocations

In this paper an analysis of 175 currently sequenced transport proteins that comprise the amino acid/polyamine/organocation (APC) superfamily is reported. Members of this superfamily fall into 10 well-defined families that are either prokaryote specific, eukaryote specific or ubiquitous. Most of these proteins exhibit 12 probable transmembrane spanners (TMSs), but members of two of these families deviate from this pattern, exhibiting 10 and 14 TMSs. All members of these families are tabulated, their functional properties are reviewed and phylogenetic/sequence analyses define the evolutionary relationships of the proteins to each other. Evidence is presented that the APC superfamily may include two other currently recognized families that exhibit greater degrees of sequence divergence from APC superfamily members than do the proteins of the 10 established families from each other. At least some of the protein members of these two distantly related families exhibit 11 established TMSs. Altogether, the APC superfamily probably includes 12 currently recognized families with members that exhibit exclusive specificity for amino acids and their derivatives but which can possess 10, 11, 12 or 14 TMSs per polypeptide chain.

The reactivity of the gamma-aminobutyric acid transporter GAT-1 toward sulfhydryl reagents is conformationally sensitive. Identification of a major target residue

The gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) transporter GAT-1 is a prototype of neurotransmitter transporters that maintain low synaptic levels of the transmitter. Transport by GAT-1 is sensitive to the polar sulfhydryl reagent 2-aminoethyl methanethiosulfonate. Following replacement of endogenous cysteines to other residues by site-directed mutagenesis, we have identified cysteine 399 as the major determinant of the sensitivity of the transporter to sulfhydryl modification. Cysteine-399 is located in the intracellular loop connecting putative transmembrane domains eight and nine. Binding of both sodium and chloride leads to a reduced sensitivity to sulfhydryl reagents, whereas subsequent binding of GABA increases it. Strikingly binding of the nontransportable GABA analogue SKF100330A gives rise to a marked protection against sulfhydryl modification. These effects were not observed in C399S transporters. Under standard conditions GAT-1 is almost insensitive toward the impermeant 2-(trimethylammonium)ethyl methanethiosulfonate. However, in a chloride-free medium, addition of SKF100330A renders wild type GAT-1, but not C399S, very sensitive to this impermeant reagent. These observations indicate that the accessibility of cysteine 399 is highly dependent on the conformation of GAT-1. Consequently, topological assignments based on accessibility of endogeneous or engineered cysteines to small polar sulfhydryl reagents need to be interpreted with extreme caution.

Identification of the amine-polyamine-choline transporter superfamily 'consensus amphipathic region' as the target for inactivation of the Escherichia coli GABA transporter GabP by thiol modification reagents. Role of Cys-300 in restoring thiol sensitivity to Gabp lacking Cys

The Escherichia coli gamma-aminobutyric acid transporter GabP (gab permease) contains a functionally significant cysteine residue (Cys-300) within its consensus amphipathic region (CAR), a putative channel-forming structure that extends out of transmembrane helix 8 and into the adjoining cytoplasmic loop 8-9 of transporters from the amine-polyamine-choline (APC) superfamily. Here we show that of the five cysteine residues (positions 158, 251, 291, 300 and 443) in the E. coli GabP, Cys-300 is the one that renders the transport activity sensitive to inhibition by thiol modification reagents: whereas substituting Ala for Cys-300 mimics the inhibitory effect of thiol modification, substituting Ala at position 158, 251, 291 or 443 preserves robust transport activity and confers no resistance to thiol inactivation; and whereas the robustly active Cys-300 single-Cys mutant is fully sensitive to thiol modification, other single-Cys mutants (Cys at 158, 251, 291 or 443) exhibit kinetically compromised transport activities that resist further chemical inactivation by thiol reagents. The present study reveals additionally that Cys-300 exhibits (1) sensitivity to hydrophobic thiol reagents, (2) general resistance to bulky (fluorescein 5-maleimide) and/or charged {2-sulphonatoethyl methanethiosulphonate or [2-(trimethylammonium)ethyl] methanethiosulphonate} thiol reagents and (3) a peculiar sensitivity to p-chloromercuribenzenesulphonate (PCMBS). The accessibility of PCMBS to Cys-300 (located midway through the lipid bilayer) might be related to the structural similarity that it shares with guvacine (1, 2,3,6-tetrahydro-3-pyridinecarboxylic acid), a transported GabP substrate. These structural requirements for thiol sensitivity provide the first chemical evidence consistent with channel-like access to the polar surface of the CAR, a physical configuration that might provide a basis for understanding how this region impacts the function of APC transporters generally [Closs, Lyons, Kelly and Cunningham (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 20796-20800] and the gab permease particularly [Hu and King (1998) Biochem. J. 300, 771-776].

The multiply-regulated gabA gene encoding the GABA permease of Aspergillus nidulans: a score of exons

We describe the cloning, sequence and expression of gabA, encoding the gamma-amino-n-butyrate (GABA) permease of the fungus Aspergillus nidulans. Sequence changes were determined for three up-promoter (gabI ) and six gabA loss-of-function mutations. The predicted protein contains 517 residues and shows 30.3% overall identity with a putative GABA permease of Arabidopsis thaliana, 29.6% identity with the yeast choline transporter and 23.4% identity with the yeast UGA4 GABA permease. Structural predictions favour 11-12 transmembrane domains. Comparison of the genomic and cDNA sequences shows the presence of 19 introns, an unusually large number of introns for, we believe, any fungal gene. In agreement with the wealth of genetic data available, transcript level analyses demonstrate that gabA is subject to carbon catabolite and nitrogen metabolite repression, omega-amino acid induction and regulation in response to ambient pH (being acid-expressed). In agreement with this, we report consensus binding sites 5' to the coding region, six each for CreA and AREA and one for PacC, the transcription factors mediating carbon catabolite and nitrogen metabolite repression and response to ambient pH respectively.

Membrane topology of the Escherichia coli gamma-aminobutyrate transporter: implications on the topography and mechanism of prokaryotic and eukaryotic transporters from the APC superfamily

The Escherichia coli gamma-aminobutyric acid permease (GabP) is a plasma membrane protein from the amine-polyamine-choline (APC) superfamily. On the basis of hydropathy analysis, transporters from this family are thought to contain 12, 13 or 14 transmembrane domains. We have experimentally analysed the topography of GabP by using the cytoplasmically active LacZ (beta-galactosidase) and the periplasmically active PhoA (alkaline phosphatase) as complementary topological sensors. The enzymic activities of 32 GabP-LacZ hybrids and 43 GabP-PhoA hybrids provide mutually reinforcing lines of evidence that the E. coli GabP contains 12 transmembrane segments that traverse the membrane in a zig-zag fashion with both N- and C-termini facing the cytoplasm. Interestingly, the resulting model predicts that the functionally important 'consensus amphipathic region' (CAR) [Hu and King (1998) Biochem. J. 330, 771-776] is at least partly membrane-embedded in many amino acid transporters from bacteria and fungi, in contrast with the apparent situation in mouse cationic amino acid transporters (MCATs), in which this kinetically significant region is thought to be fully cytoplasmic [Sophianopoulou and Diallinas (1995) FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 16, 53-75]. To the extent that conserved domains serve similar functions, the resolution of this topological disparity stands to have family-wide implications on the mechanistic role of the CAR. The consensus transmembrane structure derived from this analysis of GabP provides a foundation for predicting the topological disposition of the CAR and other functionally important domains that are conserved throughout the APC transporter superfamily.

Functional significance of the "signature cysteine" in helix 8 of the Escherichia coli 4-aminobutyrate transporter from the amine-polyamine-choline superfamily. Restoration of Cys-300 to the Cys-less Gabp

gab permease (GabP) is the exclusive mediator of 4-aminobutyrate (GABA) transport across the Escherichia coli plasma membrane. Helix 8 and a portion of the adjoining cytoplasmic region (loop 8-9) constitute the GabP "consensus amphipathic region" (CAR), a potential channel-forming domain that is found to be evolutionarily conserved within the APC (amine-polyamine-choline) transporter superfamily. Upon the polar surface of the CAR, all known gab permeases display a "signature cysteine" not found in other members of the APC superfamily, suggesting that discrete features within the CAR might play a role in imparting specificity (kcat/Km) to the translocation reaction. Here we show that among the five cysteine residues in the E. coli GabP, only Cys-300, the signature cysteine, can restore wild type properties to the Cys-less GabP mutant. We conclude (i) from partial reaction studies (equilibrium exchange, counterflow) that rapid translocation of the GABA binding site from one side of the membrane to the other is greatly facilitated by Cys-300 and (ii) from pharmacological studies that loss of Cys-300 has little effect on the affinity that GabP exhibits for a structurally diverse array (kojic amine, 5-aminovaleric acid, GABA, nipecotic acid, and cis-4-aminocrotonic acid) of competitive ligands. These results raise the possibility that other GABA transporters might rely analogously upon conserved cysteine residues positioned within the amphipathic helix 8 and loop 8-9 regions.

4-Aminobutyrate (GABA) transporters from the amine-polyamine-choline superfamily: substrate specificity and ligand recognition profile of the 4-aminobutyrate permease from Bacillus subtilis

A previous study [Ferson, Wray and Fisher (1996) Mol. Microbiol. 22, 693-701] has shown that transposon-mediated disruption of a protein 47% identical to the Escherichia coli GABA (4-aminobutyrate) transporter abolishes the ability of nitrogen-limited culture conditions to induce expression of a GABA transport activity in Bacillus subtilis. Here it is demonstrated directly that the B. subtilis GABA permease (gabP) gene can complement the transport defect in the gabP-negative E. coli strain. Unexpectedly, the ligand-recognition profile of the B. subtilis GabP was found to differ substantially from that of the highly homologous E. coli GabP. Unlike the E. coli GabP, the B. subtilis GabP: (i) exhibits approx. equal preference for the 3-carbon (beta-alanine, Km=9.6 microM) and the 4-carbon (GABA, Km=37 microM) amino acids, and (ii) resists inhibition by bulky, conformationally constrained compounds (e.g. nipecotic acid, guvacine), which are active against GABA transporters from brain. The present study shows additionally that the B. subtilis GabP can translocate several open-chain GABA analogues (3-aminobutyrate, 3-aminopropanoate, cis-4-aminobutenoate) across the membrane via counterflow against [3H]GABA. Thus, consistent with the idea that the ligand-recognition domain of the B. subtilis GabP is less spacious than that of the close homologue from E. coli, the former exhibits more stringent requirements than the latter for substrate recognition and translocation. These distinct functional characteristics of the E. coli and B. subtilis GABA transporters provide a basis by which to identify ligand-recognition domains within the amine-polyamine-choline transporter superfamily.