Complete analysis of the B-cell response to a protein antigen, from in vivo germinal centre formation to 3-D modelling of affinity maturation

Self-reactive B cells in the GALT are actively curtailed to prevent gut inflammation

Immune homeostasis in the gut associated lymphoid tissues (GALT) is critical to prevent the development of inadvertent pathologies. B cells as the producers of antibodies and cytokines plays an important role in maintaining the GALT homeostasis. However, the mechanism by which B cells specifically direct their responses towards non-self-antigens and become ignorant to self-antigens in the GALT is not known. Therefore, we developed a novel mouse model by expressing Duck Egg Lysozyme (DEL) in gut epithelial cells in presence of HEL reactive B cells. Notably, we observed a transient activation and rapid deletion of self-reactive B cells in Peyers Patches and Mesenteric lymph nodes upon self-antigen exposure. The survival of self-reactive B cells upon exposure to their self-antigen was partially rescued by blocking receptor editing but could be completely rescued by stronger survival signal like ectopic expression of BCL2. Importantly, rescuing the self-reactive B cells promoted production of auto-antibodies and gut inflammation. Mechanistically, we identify a specific activation of TGFβ signaling in self-reactive B cells in the gut and a critical role of this pathway in maintaining peripheral tolerance. Collectively, our studies describe functional consequences and fate of self-reactive B cells in GALT and provide novel mechanistic insights governing self-tolerance of B cells in the gut.

HIV-1 Env-specific memory and germinal center B cells in C57BL/6 mice

Continued efforts to define the immunogenic properties of the HIV-1 envelope glycoproteins (Env) are needed to elicit effective antibody (Ab) responses by vaccination. HIV-1 is a highly neutralization-resistant virus due to conformational and glycan shielding of conserved Ab determinants on the virus spike. Elicitation of broadly neutralizing Abs that bind poorly accessible epitope regions on Env is therefore extremely challenging and will likely require selective targeting of specific sub-determinants. To evaluate such approaches there is a pressing need for in vivo studies in both large and small animals, including mice. Currently, most mouse immunization studies are performed in the BALB/c strain; however, the C57BL/6 strain offers improved possibilities for mechanistic studies due to the availability of numerous knock-out strains on this genetic background. Here, we compared Env immunogenicity in BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice and found that the magnitude of the antigen-specific response was somewhat lower in C57BL/6 than in BALB/c mice by ELISA but not significantly different by B cell ELISpot measurements. We then established protocols for the isolation of single Env-specific memory B cells and germinal center (GC) B cells from immunized C57BL/6 mice to facilitate future studies of the elicited response at the monoclonal Ab level. We propose that these protocols can be used to gain an improved understanding of the early recruitment of Env-specific B cells to the GC as well as the archiving of such responses in the memory B cell pool following immunization.

Younger siblings, C-reactive protein, and risk of age-related macular degeneration

In this study, we examined the relationship between exposure to siblings and 1) the risk of age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and 2) C-reactive protein levels. We retrospectively analyzed pooled cross-sectional data from 2 studies: the Cardiovascular Health and Age-Related Maculopathy Study (2001-2002) and the Age-Related Maculopathy Statin Study (2004-2006). Associations between number of siblings and AMD were assessed by using multinomial logistic regression. Associations between number of siblings and C-reactive protein levels were examined by using a generalized linear model for γ distribution. A higher number of younger siblings was associated with significantly lower odds of early AMD in those with a family history of AMD (odds ratio = 0.2, 95% confidence interval: 0.1, 0.8) (P = 0.022) but was unrelated to AMD for those who had no family history of the disease (odds ratio = 1.0, 95% confidence interval: 0.9, 1.2) (P = 0.874). A higher number of younger siblings correlated with lower C-reactive protein levels (β = -0.19, 95% confidence interval: -0.38, -0.01) (P = 0.036). This supports the theory that immune modulation contributes to AMD pathogenesis and suggests that exposure to younger siblings might be protective when there is a family history of AMD.

Monovalent and multivalent ligation of the B cell receptor exhibit differential dependence upon Syk and Src family kinases

The Src and Syk families of kinases are two distinct sets of kinases that play critical roles in initiating membrane-proximal B cell receptor (BCR) signaling. However, unlike in other lymphocytes, such as T cells, the "division of labor" between Src family kinases (SFKs) and Syk in B cells is not well separated because both Syk and SFKs can phosphorylate immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motifs (ITAMs) present in proteins comprising the BCR. To understand why B cells require both SFKs and Syk for activation, we investigated the roles of both families of kinases in BCR signaling with computational modeling and in vitro experiments. Our computational model suggested that positive feedback enabled Syk to substantially compensate for the absence of SFKs when spatial clustering of BCRs was induced by multimeric ligands. We confirmed this prediction experimentally. In contrast, when B cells were stimulated by monomeric ligands that failed to produce BCR clustering, both Syk and SFKs were required for complete and rapid BCR activation. Our data suggest that SFKs could play a pivotal role in increasing BCR sensitivity to monomeric antigens of pathogens and in mediating a rapid response to soluble multimeric antigens of pathogens that can induce spatial BCR clustering.

The ‘hygiene hypothesis’ and the development of multiple sclerosis

SUMMARY We review evidence linking inadequate microbial exposure in early life to the development of multiple sclerosis (MS). There is some supportive, but not conclusive evidence for a role of a hygienic environment in early life and MS. Population-level studies of MS are consistent with the hygiene hypothesis but are limited by methodological issues. Late infection with Epstein–Barr virus (EBV) has been prospectively associated with MS and must be incorporated into any model where the hygiene hypothesis is implicated in the development of MS. One possibility is that inadequate microbial exposure in early life contributes to a dysregulated host immune response to EBV. Two areas of particular interest include the potential role for helminthic infection in biasing the human immune response away from the immune profile associated with MS and also the role of microbial exposure in training the development of the EBV-specific immune response.

Preferential targeting of somatic hypermutation to hotspot motifs and hypermutable sites and generation of mutational clusters in the IgVH alleles of a rheumatoid factor producing lymphoblastoid cell line

Epstein-Barr virus transforms human peripheral B cells into lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL) that secrete specific antibodies. Our previous studies showed that a monoclonal LCL that secretes a rheumatoid factor expressed activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) and displayed an ongoing process of somatic hypermutation (SHM) at a frequency of 1.7×10⁻³ mut/bp in its productively rearranged IgVH gene. The present work shows that SHM similarly affects the nonproductive IgVH allele of the same culture. Sequencing of multiple cDNA clones derived from cellular subclones of the parental culture, showed that both alleles exhibited an ongoing mutational process with mutation rates of 2-3×10⁻⁵ mut/bp×generation with a high preference for C/G transition mutations and lack of a significant strand bias. About 50% of the mutations were targeted to the underlined C/G bases in the WRCH/DGYW and RCY/RGY hotspot motifs, indicating that they were due to the initial phase of AID activity. Mutations were targeted to the VH alleles and not to the Cμ or to the GAPDH genes. Genealogical trees showed a stepwise accumulation of only 1-3 mutations per branch of the tree. Unexpectedly, 27% of all the mutations in the two alleles occurred repeatedly and independently within certain sites (not necessarily the canonical hotspot motifs) in cellular clones belonging to different branches of the lineage tree. Furthermore, some of the mutations seem to arise as recurrent mutational clusters, independently generated in different cellular clones. Statistical analysis showed that it is very unlikely that these clusters were due to random targeting of equally accessible hotspots, indicating the presence of 'hypermutable sites' that generate recurring mutational clusters in the IgVH alleles. Intrinsic hypermutable sites may enhance affinity maturation and generation of effective mutated antibody repertoires against invading pathogens.

Long-lived antibody and B Cell memory responses to the human malaria parasites, Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax

Antibodies constitute a critical component of the naturally acquired immunity that develops following frequent exposure to malaria. However, specific antibody titres have been reported to decline rapidly in the absence of reinfection, supporting the widely perceived notion that malaria infections fail to induce durable immunological memory responses. Currently, direct evidence for the presence or absence of immune memory to malaria is limited. In this study, we analysed the longevity of both antibody and B cell memory responses to malaria antigens among individuals who were living in an area of extremely low malaria transmission in northern Thailand, and who were known either to be malaria naïve or to have had a documented clinical attack of P. falciparum and/or P. vivax in the past 6 years. We found that exposure to malaria results in the generation of relatively avid antigen-specific antibodies and the establishment of populations of antigen-specific memory B cells in a significant proportion of malaria-exposed individuals. Both antibody and memory B cell responses to malaria antigens were stably maintained over time in the absence of reinfection. In a number of cases where antigen-specific antibodies were not detected in plasma, stable frequencies of antigen-specific memory B cells were nonetheless observed, suggesting that circulating memory B cells may be maintained independently of long-lived plasma cells. We conclude that infrequent malaria infections are capable of inducing long-lived antibody and memory B cell responses.

Ongoing somatic hypermutation of the rearranged VH but not of the V-lambda gene in EBV-transformed rheumatoid factor-producing lymphoblastoid cell line

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) transforms human peripheral B cells into lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCLs) that secrete specific antibodies. In contrast to peripheral blood B cells, LCLs express the activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) gene, a key enzyme in the generation of somatic hypermutation (SHM) in immunoglobulin variable genes. We have previously studied an LCL that secretes a rheumatoid factor (RF: an IgM(lambda) anti-IgG antibody) and identified the accumulation of SHM at a frequency of 1.5 x 10(-3)mut/bp in the rearranged variable region heavy chain gene (VH) of its RF sub-culture (i.e., RF-2004). The aim of the present work was to find out whether SHM was initiated as an early event following EBV transformation. Our results show that already the earliest RF-culture (RF-1983) mutates its VH at a somewhat higher frequency of 1.9 x 10(-3). Overall, we detected 17 point mutations in the RF-2004 culture and in 26 cellular clones derived from the RF-1983 and RF-2004 cultures. Most of the mutations were due to C to T or G to A transitions, with preferential targeting to WRCH/DGYW hotspot motifs, indicating that they were due to the initial phase of AID-directed mutations. A genealogical tree demonstrates that mutations were accumulated in a stepwise manner with 1-2 mutations per cell division. However, no mutations were found in the rearranged V-lambda (Vlambda) gene in the same RF-cultures and their subclones (i.e., <1.2 x 10(-4)mut/bp). To our knowledge this is the first reported clonal cell line that generates SHM in the VH, but not in the Vlambda. It may be due to abrogation of a cis-regulatory element(s) in the Vlambda or to a lack of a specific trans-acting factor which differentially direct the SHM machinery to this gene. Out of the 17 point mutations detected in both cell lines there were, 1 stop codon, 3 mutations which obliterated the binding of the RF antibody to its IgG antigen and 1 or 2 mutations which enhanced antigen-binding affinity. These results show that the evolutionary developed germline encoded antibody combining site is highly sensitive to amino acid replacements. Our combined findings that the RF cells accumulate in a stepwise manner up to 1-2 point mutations/sequence per cell division and the generation of high percentage of functionally deleterious mutations, are in accord with the 'multiphase-recycling model' of SHM, which states that B cells in the germinal center are subjected to multiple rounds of somatic mutations interchanged with periods of antigenic selection.

Asthma onset prior to multiple sclerosis and the contribution of sibling exposure in early life

Higher sibling exposure is associated with a reduced risk of asthma and other T helper 2 (Th2)-type disorders, possibly through a beneficial effect of higher infection load. The effect on Th1 disorders such as multiple sclerosis (MS) is less clear. Here we examine the association between asthma and MS, taking into account early life sibling exposure. A population-based case-control study in Tasmania, Australia based on 136 cases of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-confirmed MS and 272 community controls, matched on sex and year of birth. Study measures include cumulative exposure to total, older or younger siblings by age 6 years, history of doctor-diagnosed asthma and serological IgG responses to herpes viruses. MS cases were more likely (P = 0.02) than controls to have asthma which began before age of onset of MS symptoms compared to the corresponding age for controls. The absence of younger sibling exposure by age 6 years potentiated (P = 0.04) the association between asthma and MS. Compared to those with younger sibling exposure and no asthma, the adjusted odds ratio for MS for those with asthma and no younger sibling exposure was 7.22 (95% CI: 2.52, 20.65). Early life sibling exposure was associated with altered IgG serological responses to Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) and herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV1) in adulthood. Reduced early life sibling exposure appeared to contribute to the excess of asthma among MS cases by the time of MS onset. MS development may reflect factors that relate to a general immuno-inflammatory up-regulation of immune activity as well as disease specific factors. The link between early life sibling exposure and the immune response to herpes group viral antigens is consistent with a protective role for early life infections.

Structural Basis of Affinity Maturation of the TEPC15/Vκ45.1 Anti-2-phenyl-5-oxazolone Antibodies

Affinity maturation is a process that leads to the emergence of more efficient antibodies following initial antigen encounter and represents a key strategy of the adaptive immunity of vertebrate organisms. Earlier and detailed sequence studies of the antibody response to a model antigen, the hapten 2-phenyl-5-oxazolone (phOx), define three different classes of antibodies. Class I antibodies use the V(H)Ox1/V(kappa)Ox1 gene pair and dominate the early stages of the anti-phOx response, class II antibodies use the V(kappa)Ox1 gene but a different V(H) segment and are common in the intermediate stages, and class III antibodies use the TEPC15/V(kappa)45.1 genes and play the greatest role in the late stages. Only the crystal structure of one anti-phOx antibody, the class II NQ10/12.5 Fab fragment, has been described. Here we report the crystal structures of the scFv form of the low and high affinity anti-phOx class III antibodies NQ10/1.12 and NQ16/113.8 complexed with the hapten. The two antibodies differ by nine amino acid substitutions, all located in the V(H) domain. Analysis of the two structures shows that affinity maturation results from an increase in surface complementarity, as a consequence of a finely tuned and highly concerted process chaperoned by the somatic mutations, and implies a more efficient hapten-induced fit in the mature antibody. The data also demonstrate that class III antibodies respond in a completely different way to the architectural problem of binding phOx compared to the class II antibody NQ10/12.5.

Genetic and fluorescence studies of affinity maturation in related antibodies

Affinity maturation, the process by which an organism's response to infection becomes more specific and more effective over time, occurs after somatic hypermutation of antibody genes in B-cells. This increase in affinity might be a result of the evolution of either specific interactions between antigen and antibody over time (enthalpic factors) or antibody binding site rigidification (entropic factors) or both. Here, monoclonal antibodies, derived from antibodies elicited at different points in the murine immune response after inoculation with the same diketone hapten, have been characterized both genetically and functionally. Though this hapten has previously been shown to produce the catalytic aldolase antibody 38C2, antibodies described here are not catalytic and unlike 38C2, form no covalent enzyme-substrate complex. Thus, they provide a system in which to assess contributions to the evolution of binding affinity. The genes for these non-catalytic antibodies have been sequenced and analyzed both with regard to their relationships to germ line genes, to each other, and to two commercially available catalytic aldolase antibodies. Consequences of particular mutations for antigen binding behavior are discussed. The protein products of these genes have been expressed, purified, and binding properties measured by two complementary techniques: the hapten-induced quenching of the native antibody fluorescence and the changes in the anisotropy of Prodan (6-propionyl-2-(dimethylamino)naphthalene), a fluorescent hapten analogue. Differences in binding affinity are related back to differences in the lengths and amino acid sequences of the complementary determining region 3 (CDR3) binding loop. Taken together with our earlier results on binding site heterogeneity from tryptophan lifetime analysis [Mohan, G.S., Chiu, P.T., Southern, C.A., O'Hara, P.B., 2004. Steady-state and multifrequency phase fluorometry studies of binding site flexibility in related antibodies. J. Phys. Chem. A 108, 7871-7877], affinity appears to be modulated by a combination of entropic and enthalpic factors, and not dominated by one or the other. Because these antibodies are not related to the same germ line gene, however, these results do not provide evidence for the dominance of enthalpy or entropy in evolving binding affinity in this system.

Dissecting the components of the humoral immune response elicited by DNA vaccines

Although DNA vaccines appear to be efficient at inducing strong cellular immune responses, a number of questions remain regarding their ability to induce humoral immunity. The essential components for generating an antibody response include B and T cell recognition of antigen, subsequent activation, clonal expansion of each lymphocyte type and migration of T cells into B cell follicles to provide help, all leading to germinal centre formation and antibody production. We have employed a double adoptive transfer system based on ovalbumin (OVA)-specific CD4+ DO11.10 T cells and hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-specific MD4 B cells to assess all of these parameters in the context of DNA vaccination in vivo. We find that vaccination with DNA constructs expressing an OVA-HEL gene fusion (encoding contiguous T and B cell epitopes) can induce T cell activation, clonal expansion and migration into B cell follicles accompanied by B cell activation, blastogenesis, expansion and antibody production. These findings show that DNA vaccination can induce all of the components required for humoral immunity and also provide a system for in depth analysis of factors that influence the development of antibody responses. Such strategies may facilitate the rational design of vaccines capable of inducing effective humoral immunity.

A limited number of genes are involved in the differentiation of germinal center B cells

Mature B cells, upon activation, progressively differentiate through centroblasts into centrocytes and finally to plasmacytes that express large amounts of selected immunoglobulins. A significant part of this maturation is thought to involve induction of the unfolded protein response (UPR). We have compared gene expression in normal germinal center centroblasts, centrocytes, lymphoblastoid cells undergoing induced UPR, and the CCL155 plasmacytoma cell line. In the centroblast to centrocyte transition there is a change in the expression of a relatively small number of genes. These include a limited subset of the genes upregulated by a fully activated UPR as well as a small number of other transcription factors, some disulphide isomerases, and other genes. This is consistent with a model in which this transition is mediated by changes in the levels of expression of transcription factor B-lymphocyte-induced maturation protein 1 (Blimp1) (PRDM1), BACH2, X-box binding protein 1 (XBP1), interferon regulatory factor 4 (IRF4), and possibly vitamin D receptor (VDR) expression, together with post-transcriptional changes and a limited induction of aspects of the UPR.

Immunoglobulin variable-region gene mutational lineage tree analysis: application to autoimmune diseases

Lineage trees have frequently been drawn to illustrate diversification, via somatic hypermutation (SHM), of immunoglobulin variable-region (IGV) genes. In order to extract more information from IGV sequences, we developed a novel mathematical method for analyzing the graphical properties of IgV gene lineage trees, allowing quantification of the differences between the dynamics of SHM and antigen-driven selection in different lymphoid tissues, species, and disease situations. Here, we investigated trees generated from published IGV sequence data from B cell clones participating in autoimmune responses in patients with Myasthenia Gravis (MG), Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA), and Sjögren's Syndrome (SS). At present, as no standards exist for cell sampling and sequence extraction methods, data obtained by different research groups from two studies of the same disease often vary considerably. Nevertheless, based on comparisons of data groups within individual studies, we show here that lineage trees from different individual patients are often similar and can be grouped together, as can trees from two different tissues in the same patient, and even from IgG- and IgA-expressing B cell clones. Additionally, lineage trees from most studies reflect the chronic character of autoimmune diseases.

Analysis of VH gene sequences using two web-based immunogenetics resources gives different results, but the affinity maturation status of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia clones as assessed from either of the resulting data sets has no prognostic significance

Some cellular and molecular features of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) cells that are associated with prognosis may reflect the context within which their progenitors encountered antigen. It follows that the nature of antigen drive in CLL could influence the clinical course and we were prompted to assess the impact, if any, of affinity maturation (an antigen-driven process) on prognosis. Statistical models for assessing affinity maturation status are typically applied to V(H) gene sequence data analysed using a web-based resource like IMGT or VBASE. Since these resources differ with respect to some key relevant features, we evaluated a cohort of CLL cases by applying statistical models to V(H) data derived from both IMGT and VBASE. Important differences between the resulting data sets became apparent. These resulted from database variance and because IMGT and VBASE define complementarity-determining and framework regions (CDRs, FRs) in different ways. Thus, the numbers of mutations identified and their distribution between CDRs/FRs varied between the data sets for the majority of clones. Consequently, two different but overlapping sets of cases with evidence of affinity maturation were defined. Notwithstanding their differences, no significant associations of affinity maturation status with CD38 expression, p53 functional status or survival were identifiable in either data set.