Caring for maltreated children: a challenge for health care education

A qualitative description of how Ghanaian radiographers identify suspected child physical abuse

INTRODUCTION

Child physical abuse is intentionally inflicted injury of a child and presents a challenging diagnosis to clinicians mostly as a result of doubts about whether the findings were perpetrated by carers of these children. Suspected child physical abuse cannot be reported without its initial identification, substantiation and reporting. Imaging findings is one way of providing evidence of abuse in court.

METHODS

A qualitative design was used to gather data. Twenty (20) radiographers were recruited using purposive criterion sampling to share their experiences of mode of identification of suspected child physical abuse. Semi-structured interviews were conducted to gain deeper insight into their experiences.

RESULTS

Radiographers' suspicion or identification of child physical abuse was based on four (4) constructs: pre-radiographic observation; child's physical signs; caregiver secrecy and imaging findings. These observations provoked further investigations through questioning of the child (if of verbal age), parent or both. Their initial suspicion through assessment of cases was sometimes strengthened by the imaging findings.

CONCLUSION

Radiographers suspected child physical abuse using several approaches some of which were found to be unacceptable although it led to other important information, such as additional imaging performed by the radiographers without doctor consultation. However, being able to identify child physical abuse is important in child protection activities.

IMPLICATION FOR PRACTICE

Identification and reporting of suspected abuse to the appropriate child protection authorities are imperative for child protection. The possibility that some experienced radiographers may fail to deal with serious instances of child abuse exist. A radiographer's inability to identify such cases, could that the victim would miss the required protection from the professional.

Kindeswohlgefährdung – Ausweitung des Hellfeldes durch Neukonzeption der klinischen Kinderschutzarbeit

Hintergrund

Das Erkennen von Kindesmisshandlungen und der Umgang damit sind Herausforderungen im ärztlichen Alltag. Die Dunkelziffer bei Misshandlungen und Vernachlässigungen ist hoch.

Ziel der Arbeit

Das Ziel der Arbeit war, die Effektivität des neu strukturierten Kinderschutzprogrammes einer großen deutschen Kinderklinik zu untersuchen und durch die Präsentation der Vorteile der neuen Struktur die Verbesserung von Programmen für Kinder und Mediziner in anderen Kliniken anzuregen.

Methode

Es wurden retrospektiv alle Kinderschutzfälle im Altonaer Kinderkrankenhaus vor und nach Neukonzeption der Kinderschutzarbeit über einen Zeitraum von jeweils 2 Jahren untersucht und miteinander verglichen. Die Kinderschutzgruppe war neu strukturiert worden und wurde nachfolgend von einer hauptamtlichen Kinderschutzkoordinatorin geleitet.

Ergebnis

Die Prävalenz der Verdachtsfälle und der erhärteten Fälle von Kindeswohlgefährdung ist im Untersuchungszeitraum nach Neukonzeption hoch signifikant erhöht. Im Zeitraum vor der Neukonzeption wurden 24 Fälle mit dem Verdacht auf Kindswohlgefährdung untersucht, 23 erhärtet, danach 124 Fälle untersucht, 89 erhärtet. Eine Stigmatisierung der Familien bei der Abklärung wurde trotz des signifikanten Anstiegs falsch-positiver Verdachtsfälle durch sensibles Vorgehen und eine Konfrontation erst bei Erhärtung des Verdachtes vermieden.

Schlussfolgerung

Das vorgestellte Konzept zum medizinischen Kinderschutz in Kinderkliniken scheint das Hellfeld bei Kindeswohlgefährdung effektiv auszuweiten. Sowohl die Reduktion nichtdetektierter Fälle mit der Verhinderung potenzieller Eskalation mit prolongiertem Leidensweg als auch die Verminderung der immensen gesellschaftlichen Folgekosten rechtfertigen die personellen Investitionen.

An exploratory study investigating perceptions, opinions and experiences of safeguarding education in pre-registration children's nursing curricula

AIM

To explore perceptions, opinions and experiences of safeguarding education within pre-registration children's nursing curricula.

METHODS

Using a qualitative research method, an online questionnaire was developed and disseminated to pre-registration children's nursing students to complete via a weblink added to their programme's virtual learning environment.

FINDINGS

This study highlighted the need to integrate other pedagogies in safeguarding education. These include implementing more practical-based workshops such as completing safeguarding referrals to social care and undertaking case vignettes from a multi-professional perspective.

CONCLUSION

The recommendations from this study for future safeguarding education in pre-registration children's nursing curricula include incorporating a hybrid experiential learning approach, through problem-solving and simulation-based learning, to bridge the theory-to-practice divide and ensure practitioners are fit for practice.

The Knowledge Level and Opinions of Physicians about the Medical and Legal Procedures Related to Physical Child Abuse

Background:

In order to diagnose child abuse, physicians need to consider the possibility of abuse in every child they encounter, have sufficient information about the topic and manage the cases according to current law.

Aims:

To determine the knowledge level of physicians on child abuse and to learn their opinions about the procedures when they suspect child abuse.

Study Design:

A questionnaire (cross-sectional) study.

Methods:

A detailed questionnaire was applied to 390 physicians of whom 233 were general practitioners. The first part of the questionnaire included demographic variables (age, gender, occupational experience) and the frequency of child physical abuse cases encountered, since that is the most easily diagnosed and proven form of abuse. The second part consisted of 32 questions about diagnosis of physical child abuse and procedures during the follow-up of the cases. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS version 18.0.

Results:

Of the participating physicians, 47.4% (n=185) were female and only 13.1% of the physicians had some kind of postgraduate training on child abuse. The correct response rate of specialists compared to general practitioners was significantly higher. A total of 263 (72.3%) physicians thought that there was a specific law on physical child abuse in the Turkish Republic. More than two-thirds of physicians thought that reporting should only be addressed to Social Services and physicians should not be obliged to report to law enforcement.

Conclusion:

The results of the present study adds to the already known necessity for better training of physicians about physical child abuse and the need to refresh their knowledge through postgraduate courses. According to current regulations, it is obligatory to report abuse cases to the public prosecutor and/or police, therefore physicians also need training in respect of the legal status and medico-legal approach to these cases.

Pediatric Inpatient Nurses' Perceptions of Child Maltreatment

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to explore the perceptions of child maltreatment among inpatient pediatric nurses.

DESIGN AND METHODS

A cross-sectional survey was used to obtain responses to an online survey designed to examine perceptions of child maltreatment from inpatient pediatric nurses.

RESULTS

Many nurses surveyed (41.25%) indicated that they had not received adequate training or had never received training on child maltreatment identification and many (40%) also indicated they were not familiar with the applicable reporting laws.

CONCLUSIONS

Due to the serious immediate and long term effects of child maltreatment, it is imperative that pediatric inpatient nurses have adequate training on how to identify potential abuse and neglect cases, as well as legal reporting requirements, since they are in a unique position to identify potential cases of maltreatment.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

There is a continuing need for training on child maltreatment identification and reporting laws for inpatient pediatric nurses.

Psychoneuroimmunology and the pediatric surgeon

The mind-body connection is receiving increasing scrutiny in a large number of clinical settings, although research has lagged in the pediatric specialties. Psychoneuroimmunology (PNI) is a novel interdisciplinary scientific field that examines the relationship of the mind to the patient's neurologic, endocrine, and immune systems by examining critical parameters such as the effects of mental stress on wound healing and infection rates. Techniques that modify a patient's emotional and mental responses to illness and surgery have positive effects on their physiology resulting in improved recoveries and higher patient satisfaction rates. In the appropriate clinical settings, an awareness of PNI can enhance outcomes for pediatric surgical patients.

Factors affecting medical and nursing staff reporting of child abuse

AIM

The purpose of the current research was to examine whether the theory of planned behaviour (TPB) succeeds in predicting nursing and medical staff reporting of suspected child abuse.

BACKGROUND

Despite the rising incidence of child abuse in Israel, medical and nursing staff reports of suspected child abuse remain low.

METHODS

This descriptive, correlational, cross-sectional study was based on TPB. The Child Abuse Report Intention Scale questionnaire was administered to 143 nurses and 42 doctors who work with children in various departments of a central Israeli hospital and in a large affiliated community-based clinic. Descriptive, correlational and linear regression statistics were calculated.

RESULTS

Objection to child abuse, views of professional responsibility on this issue, degree of self-control and subjective beliefs, affect reporting of suspected child abuse. Differences in reporting are evident between doctors and nurses and also between medical and nursing staff from the Arab and Jewish sectors. Doctors report more than nurses and Jewish staff members report more than their Arab colleagues. Medical and nursing staff's number of own children has a direct effect on their inclination to report child abuse.

CONCLUSIONS

The TPB model succeeds in partly predicting medical and nursing staff reporting of suspected child abuse. This model can serve as a basis for intervention plans aimed at developing medical and nursing simulations of coping with conflict issues involving child abuse in an attempt to eradicate and treat inadequate reporting.

Paediatric nurses' identification of violence against children

AIM

This paper is a report of an evaluation of paediatric nurses' assessment and diagnostic skills and interventions used for child maltreatment.

BACKGROUND

The use of violence against children occurs in all environments worldwide. Therefore, broader theoretical and practical knowledge related to this issue is needed in health care to facilitate more accurate identification of child maltreatment in order to instigate implementation of appropriate care for these children.

METHODS

The study was based on cross-sectional data obtained with a convenience sample of 160 Registered Nurses employed at paediatric wards at two large cities in Poland (response rate 80%). Data collection took place between December 2005 and March 2006. The research tool was a questionnaire form designed on the basis of international literature concerning battered child syndrome.

RESULTS

Battered child syndrome seems to be a relatively common phenomenon, as a great majority of participants (86·25%) had encountered it in their practice. The form of child maltreatment which was most often mentioned (by 30·00% of participants) was neglect. Almost three-quarters of the nurses (61·25%; n = 98) said that they had been involved in providing care for a maltreated child.

CONCLUSION

Nurses should work with maltreated children on an individualized basis, combined with interdisciplinary cooperation with specialists from related disciplines concerned with the issue. There appears to be a need for specialized training for nurses to increase their competence in working with maltreated children and their families.

Am I sure I want to go down this road? Hesitations in the reporting of child maltreatment by nurses

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to explore the process of mandated reporting of child maltreatment by pediatric nurses.

DESIGN & METHODS

Qualitative description using a grounded theory lens was used with a cross-section of pediatric nurses.

RESULTS

A point of divergence in the reporting process appears to occur at the first of three moderating points. When nurses hesitate at this first point, decision-making becomes complex and delays the reporting process, giving rise to two themes: "It's the law" and "The ones that haunt you."

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

Increasing educational efforts focused on the recognition of child maltreatment may impact nurses' low rate of reporting.

Violência física contra menores de 15 anos: estudo epidemiológico em cidade do sul do Brasil

OBJETIVO: apresentar o perfil de casos notificados de violência física contra menores de 15 anos em Londrina, Paraná, no ano de 2006. MÉTODO: Estudo transversal, com coleta retrospectiva nos prontuários dos Conselhos Tutelares e serviços de atendimento do município. Os dados foram processados e tabulados pelo programa Epi Info. RESULTADOS: Foram estudados 479 casos de violência por força corporal e 9 casos de violência por outros meios (7 por instrumentos, 1 por objeto cortante e 1 por substância corrosiva). Na violência por força corporal, predominaram vítimas do sexo feminino (53,4%) e maior risco na idade de seis anos (12,2 por 1.000). O pai foi o agressor mais frequente (48,8%) e o alcoolismo esteve presente em 64,0% dos casos. A violência por instrumentos foi praticada através de cinta (42,9%), fio (28,6%), ferro (14,3%) e instrumento de cozinha (14,3%), com vítimas do sexo feminino (85,7%), na faixa etária de doze anos (33,3%), sendo o pai (71,4%) e a mãe (28,6%) os únicos agressores, com o alcoolismo presente em 57,1% destas situações. A vítima de violência por objeto cortante era do sexo masculino, 13 anos e o agressor, desconhecido, tinha de 15 a 19 anos. A violência por substância corrosiva teve como vítima um adolescente de 13 anos, do sexo masculino, cujo agressor foi o pai, sendo o alcoolismo a situação presente. CONCLUSÕES: Os resultados apontam para a importância epidemiológica do abuso físico contra crianças e adolescentes e podem contribuir para a elaboração de estratégias de prevenção e acompanhamento das vítimas.

Nurse Reporting of Known and Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect Cases in Taiwan

Despite the frontline role of taking care of children, nurses in Taiwan have been reluctant to report known and suspected cases of child abuse and neglect (CAN). This problem threatens the success of legislation aimed at reducing CAN cases in Taiwan. The purpose of this study was to examine the influence of nurses' perceptions, attitudes, and knowledge on suspecting and reporting CAN cases in health care settings in Taiwan. Two hundred and thirty-eight nurses were surveyed using structured questionnaires with a return rate of 79.3%. Health care settings surveyed in this study included emergency units, pediatric units, and community centers from eight hospitals in southern Taiwan. Almost 3/4 (70%) of the sample of nurses thought they needed more training courses on CAN. Correlation analysis showed a significant relationship between suspecting and reporting CAN with perception, attitude, and knowledge. Stepwise multiple regression analysis revealed that perception (beta = 0.475), knowledge (beta = 0.265), and attitude (beta = 0.246) accounted for 60% of the variance in suspecting and reporting CAN. The focus and scope of training programs for nurses in Taiwan should take these findings into consideration.

Recognizing and reporting child physical abuse: a survey of primary healthcare professionals

AIM

This paper reports a study of the self-reported ability and behaviours of primary healthcare professionals in Northern Ireland to recognise child physical abuse. A secondary aim was to assess the educational and training needs of these professionals.

BACKGROUND

In the United Kingdom, 7% of children suffer serious physical abuse by a parent or carer, and two children aged under 15 years die from abuse each week. Recognizing child physical abuse depends on the knowledge and skills of a variety of healthcare professionals.

METHODS

A stratified random sample of 979 nurses, doctors, and dentists working in primary care in Northern Ireland were sent a postal questionnaire; 419 responded, giving a 43% response rate. The data were collected in 2002-2003.

FINDINGS

In their working lives 60% (251) said that they had seen a suspicious child physical abuse case; however, only 47% (201) had reported a suspicious case to the authorities, leaving a 13% gap in reporting. Although 74% (310) of respondents were aware of some of the mechanisms for reporting child physical abuse, 79% (332) requested further education on this topic. Ability to recognize and willingness to report abuse cases discriminated between the three professional groups. Compared with doctors or dentists, community nurses were statistically significantly more likely to recognize and report suspicions of child physical abuse, and were the group most aware of child abuse issues and the most willing to become involved in abuse cases.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings suggest that professional fears and anxieties and lack of knowledge act as barriers to recognizing and reporting abuse and that more specific education and support for primary care professionals is required.

Nurses' intention to report child abuse in Taiwan: a test of the theory of planned behavior

The purposes of this study were to identify factors associated with nurses' intention to report suspected child abuse in Taiwan, and to determine the empirical adequacy of the extended theory of planned behavior (TPB) to explain nurses' intention to report child abuse. A stratified quota sampling technique was used to select registered nurses in emergency rooms, psychiatric units, and pediatric units in Taiwan. A total of 1,362 questionnaires from 1,617 nurses were used for the analyses. Structural equation modeling demonstrated that nurses' attitudes toward reporting child abuse, perceived behavioral control, subjective norms, and knowledge of the child abuse and reporting law explained 85% to 91% of the variance in nurses' intention to report child abuse for the less severe and severe child abuse cases in vignettes, respectively. The findings support the use of the extended TPB in identifying factors associated with nurses' intention to report child abuse in Taiwan.

Factors associated with nurses' intention to report child abuse: a national survey of Taiwanese nurses

OBJECTIVE

The objectives were to determine the experiences of Taiwanese nurses with a new child abuse reporting law and to assess attitudinal correlates of nurses' intention to report.

METHOD

A stratified quota sampling technique was used to select registered nurses working in pediatric, psychiatric and emergency care units in Taiwan. A total of 1400 (return rate 88%) questionnaires from 1617 nurses were used. The questionnaire includes demographic information, attitudes toward and knowledge of child abuse and reporting laws, and eight vignettes of child abuse.

RESULTS

Most nurses (86%) said they had never reported a child abuse case; 21% said they had failed to report a suspected case of child abuse. Most (80%) had never had any child abuse education. About 75% felt their nursing education and in-service training was inadequate or absent. Most had an inadequate knowledge of the reporting law (mean score: 60% correct). Nurses only answered 17-43% of the law-related questions correctly. The majority accepted the professional responsibility to report. There were some differences among pediatric, psychiatric and emergency care nurses. In general, these Taiwanese nurses had negative attitudes toward corporal punishment and toward parents who abuse their children. The study also identified a variety of attitudes related to intention to report relevant to the Theory of Planned Behavior.

CONCLUSIONS

Nurses accept responsibility for reporting but they believe their professional preparation for reporting is inadequate. There is a strong need for in-service and pre-service education about child abuse among nurses in Taiwan.

Child physical abuse: health professionals' perceptions, diagnosis and responses

The objectives of this cross-sectional survey were to assess primary health professionals' perceptions of and ability to recognize child physical abuse in their practice. A random sample was taken of 979 nurses, doctors, and dentists working in primary care in Northern Ireland. The response rate was 44%, and the results showed that 59% of respondents had seen a suspicious case of child physical abuse, of which 47% (n = 201) had reported it. Ability and willingness to recognize and report abuse varied across the three professions. The findings suggest a professional reluctance to engage in recognizing and reporting abuse. The barriers could be reduced by providing multi-professional and inter-agency training, support for the primary health professionals in practice, as well as higher education programmes at undergraduate and postgraduate levels for nursing, dentistry and medicine.