Formation and properties of hybrid photosynthetic F1-ATPases. Demonstration of different structural requirements for stimulation and inhibition by tentoxin

Energetic cost of protein import across the envelope membranes of chloroplasts

Chloroplasts are the organelles of green plants in which light energy is transduced into chemical energy, forming ATP and reduced carbon compounds upon which all life depends. The expenditure of this energy is one of the central issues of cellular metabolism. Chloroplasts contain ~3,000 proteins, among which less than 100 are typically encoded in the plastid genome. The rest are encoded in the nuclear genome, synthesized in the cytosol, and posttranslationally imported into the organelle in an energy-dependent process. We report here a measurement of the amount of ATP hydrolyzed to import a protein across the chloroplast envelope membranes--only the second complete accounting of the cost in Gibbs free energy of protein transport to be undertaken. Using two different precursors prepared by three distinct techniques, we show that the import of a precursor protein into chloroplasts is accompanied by the hydrolysis of ~650 ATP molecules. This translates to a ΔG(protein) (transport) of some 27,300 kJ/mol protein imported. We estimate that protein import across the plastid envelope membranes consumes ~0.6% of the total light-saturated energy output of the organelle.

Two free radical pathways mediate chemical hypoxia-induced glutamate release in synaptosomes from the prefrontal cortex

It has been known that the inhibition of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase is one of the earliest events occurring under hypoxia and this inhibition can lead to neuronal damages. Thus, the cytochrome c oxidase inhibitor sodium cyanide (NaCN) is widely used to produce a model of chemical hypoxia by inhibiting this enzyme. However, the downstream signaling pathways of the inhibition of the cytochrome c oxidase remain to be studied. In the present paper, we used sodium cyanide to mimic the inhibition of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase and studied its effect on glutamate release in synaptosomes from the prefrontal cortex using on-line fluorimetry. We also further investigated the mechanisms underlying the enhancing effect of sodium cyanide on glutamate release using pharmacological approaches combined with other techniques. The results showed that sodium cyanide significantly increased glutamate release from synaptosomes of prefrontal cortex; the broad-spectrum free radical scavenger MnTBAP and melatonin completely abolished the effect of sodium cyanide on glutamate release; the H2O2-NMDA receptor pathway mediated one part, whereas the lipid peroxyl radicals-ATP synthase pathway mediated another part of the sodium cyanide-induced glutamate release; scavenging H2O2 and enhancing ATP synthase activity could completely abolish the sodium cyanide-induced glutamate release.

The role of specific beta-gamma subunit interactions in oxyanion stimulation of the MgATP hydrolysis of a hybrid photosynthetic F1-ATPase

Pairs of cysteine residues were introduced into the twisted N- and C-terminal helices of the gamma subunit of the chloroplast F1-ATPase to test, via disulfide cross-linking, potential inter-helical movements involved in catalysis of ATP hydrolysis. The extent of disulfide cross-linking was determined by estimating the amount of free sulfhydryl available for labeling with fluoresceinyl maleimide before and after cross-linking. Significant disulfide formation (50-75%) was observed between cysteines introduced at positions 30 and 31 in the N-terminal helix and 276 and 278 in the C-terminal helix. Cross-linking had no apparent effect on catalysis, therefore eliminating the involvement of large-scale inter-helical movements within this region of the gamma subunit in cooperative ATP hydrolysis. However, the presence of the two cysteines together in the gammaV31C/A276C double mutant, irrespective of whether or not they were cross-linked together, lowered the MgATPase activity by more than 70% and completely eliminated the well-known activating effect of the oxyanion sulfite. The CaATPase activity was unaffected. Similar but less pronounced effects were seen with the gammaK30C/A276C double mutant. The results indicate that residues at or near positions 31 and 276 within the twisted helical pair of the gamma subunit are required to overcome Mg2+ inhibition of ATP hydrolysis. These residues are likely to be involved in forming a point of contact between the gamma and beta subunits that is responsible for this effect.

C-Terminal mutations in the chloroplast ATP synthase gamma subunit impair ATP synthesis and stimulate ATP hydrolysis

Two highly conserved amino acid residues, an arginine and a glutamine, located near the C-terminal end of the gamma subunit, form a "catch" by hydrogen bonding with residues in an anionic loop on one of the three catalytic beta subunits of the bovine mitochondrial F1-ATPase [Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628]. The catch is considered to play a critical role in the binding change mechanism whereby binding of ATP to one catalytic site releases the catch and induces a partial rotation of the gamma subunit. This role is supported by the observation that mutation of the equivalent arginine and glutamine residues in the Escherichia coli F1 gamma subunit drastically reduced all ATP-dependent catalytic activities of the enzyme [Greene, M. D., and Frasch, W. D. (2003) J. Biol. Chem. 278, 5194-5198]. In this study, we show that simultaneous substitution of the equivalent residues in the chloroplast F1 gamma subunit, arginine 304 and glutamine 305, with alanine decreased the level of proton-coupled ATP synthesis by more than 80%. Both the Mg2+-dependent and Ca2+-dependent ATP hydrolysis activities increased by more than 3-fold as a result of these mutations; however, the sulfite-stimulated activity decreased by more than 60%. The Mg2+-dependent, but not the Ca2+-dependent, ATPase activity of the double mutant was insensitive to inhibition by the phytotoxic inhibitor tentoxin, indicating selective loss of catalytic cooperativity in the presence of Mg2+ ions. The results indicate that the catch residues are required for efficient proton coupling and for activation of multisite catalysis when MgATP is the substrate. The catch is not, however, required for CaATP-driven multisite catalysis or, therefore, for rotation of the gamma subunit.

Mutations within the C-terminus of the gamma subunit of the photosynthetic F1-ATPase activate MgATP hydrolysis and attenuate the stimulatory oxyanion effect

Two highly conserved amino acid residues near the C-terminus within the gamma subunit of the mitochondrial ATP synthase form a "catch" with an anionic loop on one of the three beta subunits within the catalytic alphabeta hexamer of the F1 segment [Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G. W., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628]. Forming the catch is considered to be an essential step in cooperative nucleotide binding leading to gamma subunit rotation. The analogous residues, Arg304 and Gln305, in the chloroplast F1 gamma subunit were changed to leucine and alanine, respectively. Each mutant gamma was assembled together with alpha and beta subunits from Rhodospirillum rubrum F1 into a hybrid photosynthetic F1 that carries out both MgATPase and CaATPase activities and ATP-dependent gamma rotation [Tucker, W. C., Schwarcz, A., Levine, T., Du, Z., Gromet-Elhanan, Z., Richter, M. L. and Haran, G. (2004) J. Biol. Chem. 279, 47415-47418]. Surprisingly, changing Arg304 to leucine resulted in a more than 2-fold increase in the kcat for MgATP hydrolysis. In contrast, changing Gln305 to alanine had little effect on the kcat but completely abolished the well-known stimulatory effect of the oxyanion sulfite on MgATP hydrolysis. The MgATPase activities of combined mutants with both residues substituted were strongly inhibited, whereas the CaATPase activities were inhibited, but to a lesser extent. The results indicate that the C-terminus of the photosynthetic F1 gamma subunit, like its mitochondrial counterpart, forms a catch with the alpha and beta subunits that modulates the nucleotide binding properties of the catalytic site(s). The catch is likely to be part of an activation mechanism, overcoming inhibition by free mg2+ ions, but is not essential for cooperative nucleotide exchange.

Structural Analysis of the Regulatory Dithiol-containing Domain of the Chloroplast ATP Synthase γ Subunit

The gamma subunit of the F1 portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase contains a critically placed dithiol that provides a redox switch converting the enzyme from a latent to an active ATPase. The switch prevents depletion of intracellular ATP pools in the dark when photophosphorylation is inactive. The dithiol is located in a special regulatory segment of about 40 amino acids that is absent from the gamma subunits of the eubacterial and mitochondrial enzymes. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to probe the relationship between the structure of the gamma regulatory segment and its function in ATPase regulation via its interaction with the inhibitory epsilon subunit. Mutations were designed using a homology model of the chloroplast gamma subunit based on the analogous structures of the bacterial and mitochondrial homologues. The mutations included (a) substituting both of the disulfide-forming cysteines (Cys199 and Cys205) for alanines, (b) deleting nine residues containing the dithiol, (c) deleting the region distal to the dithiol (residues 224-240), and (d) deleting the entire segment between residues 196 and 241 with the exception of a small spacer element, and (e) deleting pieces from a small loop segment predicted by the model to interact with the dithiol domain. Deletions within the dithiol domain and within parts of the loop segment resulted in loss of redox control of the ATPase activity of the F1 enzyme. Deleting the distal segment, the whole regulatory domain, or parts of the loop segment had the additional effect of reducing the maximum extent of inhibition obtained upon adding the epsilon subunit but did not abolish epsilon binding. The results suggest a mechanism by which the gamma and epsilon subunits interact with each other to induce the latent state of the enzyme.

Observation of calcium-dependent unidirectional rotational motion in recombinant photosynthetic F1-ATPase molecules

ATP hydrolysis and synthesis by the F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase are coupled to proton translocation across the membrane in the presence of magnesium. Calcium is known, however, to disrupt this coupling in the photosynthetic enzyme in a unique way: it does not support ATP synthesis, and CaATP hydrolysis is decoupled from any proton translocation, but the membrane does not become leaky to protons. Understanding the molecular basis of these calcium-dependent effects can shed light on the as yet unclear mechanism of coupling between proton transport and rotational catalysis. We show here, using an actin filament gamma-rotation assay, that CaATP is capable of sustaining rotational motion in a highly active hybrid photosynthetic F(1)-ATPase consisting of alpha and beta subunits from Rhodospirillum rubrum and gamma subunit from spinach chloroplasts (alpha(R)(3)beta(R)(3)gamma(C)). The rotation was found to be similar to that induced by MgATP in Escherichia coli F(1)-ATPase molecules. Our results suggest a possible long range pathway that enables the bound CaATP to induce full rotational motion of gamma but might block transmission of this rotational motion into proton translocation by the F(0) part of the ATP synthase.

Significance of the epsilon subunit in the thiol modulation of chloroplast ATP synthase

To understand the regulatory function of the gamma and epsilon subunits of chloroplast ATP synthase in the membrane integrated complex, we constructed a chimeric FoF1 complex of thermophilic bacteria. When a part of the chloroplast F1 gamma subunit was introduced into the bacterial FoF1 complex, the inverted membrane vesicles with this chimeric FoF1 did not exhibit the redox sensitive ATP hydrolysis activity, which is a common property of the chloroplast ATP synthase. However, when the whole part or the C-terminal alpha-helices region of the epsilon subunit was substituted with the corresponding region from CF1-epsilon together with the mutation of gamma, the redox regulation property emerged. In contrast, ATP synthesis activity did not become redox sensitive even if both the regulatory region of CF1-gamma and the entire epsilon subunit from CF1 were introduced. These results provide important features for the regulation of FoF1 by these subunits: (1) the interaction between gamma and epsilon is important for the redox regulation of FoF1 complex by the gamma subunit, and (2) a certain structural matching between these regulatory subunits and the catalytic core of the enzyme must be required to confer the complete redox regulation mechanism to the bacterial FoF1. In addition, a structural requirement for the redox regulation of ATP hydrolysis activity might be different from that for the ATP synthesis activity.

Complete inhibition and partial Re-activation of single F1-ATPase molecules by tentoxin: new properties of the re-activated enzyme

During hydrolysis of ATP, the gamma subunit of the rotary motor protein F(1)-ATPase rotates within a ring of alpha(3)beta(3) subunits. Tentoxin is a phyto-pathogenic cyclic tetrapeptide, which influences F(1)-ATPase activity of sensitive species. At low concentrations, tentoxin inhibits ATP hydrolysis of ensembles of F(1) molecules in solution. At higher concentrations, however, ATP hydrolysis recovers. Here we have examined how tentoxin acts on individual molecules of engineered F(1)-ATPase from the thermophilic Bacillus PS3 (Groth, G., Hisabori, T., Lill, H., and Bald, D. (2002) J. Biol. Chem. 277, 20117-20119). We found that inhibition by tentoxin caused a virtually complete stop of rotation, which was partially relieved at higher tentoxin concentrations. Re-activation, however, was not simply a reversal of inhibition; while the torque appears unaffected as compared with the situation without tentoxin, F(1) under re-activating conditions was less susceptible to inhibitory ADP binding but displayed a large number of short pauses, indicating infringed energy conversion.

Complete inhibition of the tentoxin-resistant F1-ATPase from Escherichia coli by the phytopathogenic inhibitor tentoxin after substitution of critical residues in the alpha - and beta -subunit

Substitution of critical residues in the alpha- and beta-subunit can turn the typically resistant ATP synthase from the bacterium Escherichia coli into an enzyme showing high sensitivity to the phytopathogenic inhibitor tentoxin, which usually affects only certain sensitive plant species. In contrast to recent results obtained with the thermophilic F(1) (Groth, G., Hisabori, T., Lill, H., and Bald, D. (2002) J. Biol. Chem. 277, 20117-20119), substitution of a critical serine in the beta-subunit (betaSer(59)), which is supposed to provide an important intermolecular hydrogen bond in the binding site, was not sufficient on its own for conferring tentoxin sensitivity to the E. coli F(1) complex. Superimposition of the chloroplast F(1)-tentoxin inhibitor complex on a homology model of the E. coli F(1) complex provided detailed information on the critical residues in the alpha-subunit of the binding cleft and allowed us to model the binding site according to the steric requirements of the inhibitor. Substitution of the highly conserved residue alphaLeu(64) seems to be most important for allowing access of the inhibitor to the binding site. Combining this substitution with either additional replacements in the alpha-subunit (Q49A, L95A, E96Q, I273M) or the replacement of Ser(59) in the beta-subunit enhanced the sensitivity to the inhibitor and resulted in a complete inhibition of the E. coli F(1)-ATPase by the plant-specific inhibitor tentoxin.

Rebuilt 3D structure of the chloroplast f1 ATPase-tentoxin complex

The F1 part of the chloroplast H+ adenosine triphosphate (ATP)-synthase (CF1) strongly interacts with tentoxin, a natural fungous cyclic tetrapeptide known to inhibit the chloroplast enzyme and not the mammalian mitochondrial enzyme. Whereas the synthesis or the hydrolysis of ATP requires the stepwise rotation of the protein rotor gamma within the (alphabeta)3 crown, only one molecule of tentoxin is needed to fully inhibit the complex. With the help of an original homology modeling technique, based on robust distance geometry protocols, we built a tridimensional model of the alpha3beta3gamma CF1) subcomplex (3200 esidues), in which we introduced three different nucleotide occupancies to check their possible influence on the tentoxin binding site. Simultaneous comparison of three available high-resolution X-ray structures of F1, performed with a local structural alignment search tool, led to characterizing common structural blocks and the distorsions experienced by the complex during the catalytic turnover. The common structural blocks were used as a starting point of the spinach CF1 structure rebuilding. Finally, tentoxin was docked into its putative binding site of the reconstructed structure. The docking method was initially validated in the mitochondrial enzyme by its ability to relocate nucleotides into their original position in the crystal. Tentoxin binding was found possible to the two alpha/beta interfaces associated with the empty and adenosine diphosphate (ADP)-loaded catalytic sites, but not to the one associated with the ATP-loaded site. These results suggest a mechanism of CF1 inhibition by one molecule of tentoxin, by the impossibility of the alpha/beta interface bearing tentoxin to pass through the ATP-loaded state.

Substitution of a single amino acid switches the tentoxin-resistant thermophilic F1-ATPase into a tentoxin-sensitive enzyme

In contrast to the homologous bacterial and mitochondrial enzymes the chloroplast F(1)-ATPase (CF(1)) is strongly affected by the phytopathogenic inhibitor tentoxin. Based on structural information obtained from crystals of a CF(1)-tentoxin co-complex (Groth, G. (2002) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 99, 3464-3468) we have replaced residues betaSer(66) and alphaArg(132) in the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma subcomplex of the thermophilic F(1)-ATPase from Bacillus PS3 by the corresponding residues of the chloroplast ATPase to confer tentoxin sensitivity to the thermophilic enzyme. The mutation alphaArg(132) --> Pro, proposed to relieve steric constraints on tentoxin binding, did not have any significant effect. However, mutation betaSer(66) --> Ala, predicted to provide a crucial hydrogen bond with the inhibitor, resulted in tentoxin inhibition of ATP hydrolysis comparable with the situation found with the chloroplast enzyme.

An insight into the mechanism of inhibition and reactivation of the F(1)-ATPases by tentoxin

The mechanism of inhibition and reactivation of chloroplast ATP-synthase by the fungal cyclotetrapeptide tentoxin was investigated by photolabeling experiments, binding studies, and kinetic analysis using synthetic analogues of tentoxin. The alpha-subunit of chloroplast F(1)-ATPase (CF(1)) was specifically labeled by a photoactivatable tentoxin derivative, providing the first direct evidence of tentoxin binding to the alpha-subunit, and 3D homology modeling was used to locate tentoxin in its putative binding site at the alpha/beta interface. The non-photosynthetic F(1)-ATPase from thermophilic bacterium (TF(1)) proved to be also tentoxin-sensitive, and enzyme turnover dramatically increased the rate of tentoxin binding to its inhibitory site, contrary to what was previously observed with epsilon-depleted CF(1) [Santolini, J., Haraux, F., Sigalat, C., Moal, G., and André, F. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 849-858]. We propose that tentoxin preferentially binds to an ADP-loaded alpha beta pair, and mechanically blocks the catalytic cycle, perhaps by the impossibility of converting this alpha beta pair into an ATP-loaded alpha beta pair. Using (14)C-tentoxin and selected synthetic analogues, we found that toxin binding to the tight inhibitory site of CF(1) exerts some cooperative effect on the loose reactivatory site, but that no reciprocal effect exists. When the two tentoxin-binding sites are filled in reactivated F(1)-ATPase, they do not exchange their role during catalytic turnover, indicating an impairment between nucleotide occupancy and the shape of tentoxin-binding pocket. This analysis provides a mechanical interpretation of the inhibition of F(1)-ATPase by tentoxin and a clue for understanding the reactivation process.

Role of the ATP synthase alpha-subunit in conferring sensitivity to tentoxin

Tentoxin, produced by phytopathogenic fungi, selectively affects the function of the ATP synthase enzymes of certain sensitive plant species. Binding of tentoxin to a high affinity (K(i) approximately 10 nM) site on the chloroplast F(1) (CF(1)) strongly inhibits catalytic function, whereas binding to a second, lower affinity site (K(d) > 10 microM) leads to restoration and even stimulation of catalytic activity. Sensitivity to tentoxin has been shown to be due, in part, to the nature of the amino acid residue at position 83 on the catalytic beta subunit of CF(1). An aspartate in this position is required, but is not sufficient, for tentoxin inhibition. By comparison with the solved structure of mitochondrial F(1) [Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G. W., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628], Asp83 is probably located at an interface between alpha and beta subunits on CF(1) where residues on the alpha subunit could also participate in tentoxin binding. A hybrid core F(1) enzyme assembled with beta and gamma subunits of the tentoxin-sensitive spinach CF(1), and an alpha subunit of the tentoxin-insensitive photosynthetic bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum F(1) (RrF(1)), was stimulated but not inhibited by tentoxin [Tucker, W. C., Du, Z., Gromet-Elhanan, Z. and Richter, M. L. (2001) Eur. J. Biochem. 268, 2179-2186]. In this study, chimeric alpha subunits were prepared by introducing short segments of the spinach CF(1) alpha subunit from a poorly conserved region which is immediately adjacent to beta-Asp83 in the crystal structure, into equivalent positions in the RrF(1) alpha subunit using oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. Hybrid enzymes containing these chimeric alpha subunits had both the high affinity inhibitory tentoxin binding site and the lower affinity stimulatory site. Changing beta-Asp83 to leucine resulted in loss of both inhibition and stimulation by tentoxin in the chimeras. The results indicate that tentoxin inhibition requires additional alpha residues that are not present on the RrF(1) alpha subunit. A structural model of a putative inhibitory tentoxin binding pocket is presented.