Is end-to-side neurorrhaphy effective? A study of axonal sprouting stimulated from intact nerves

Stem cells in end-to-side neurorrhaphy. Experimental study in rats

Purpose:

To evaluate the influence of mesenchymal stem cells from adipose tissue in the end-to-side neurorrhaphy, focusing in the nerve regeneration and the muscle reinnervation in acute trauma.

Methods:

140 animals were randomly divided in seven groups: control, denervated, end-to-side neurorrhaphy between distal stump of common peroneal nerve and tibial nerve (ESN), ESN wrapped in fascia, ESN wrapped in fascia and platelet gel, ESN wrapped in platelet gel, ESN wrapped in fascia and platelet gel within stem cells (without culture) removed from the adipose tissue. Mass measurements of the animal and of cranial tibial muscles, electromyography, walking track analysis tests and histological examinations of the nerves and muscles after 180 days was performed.

Results:

In the groups where the ESN was performed, the results were always better when compared to the denervated group, showing reinnervation in all ESN groups. The most sensitive methods were walking track and histological analysis. Only the group with stem cells showed values similar to the control group, as well as the functional indices of peroneal nerve and the number of nerve fibers in the peroneal nerve.

Conclusions:

Stem cells were effective in ESN according with the functional index of the peroneal nerve, evaluated by walking track analysis and the number of nerve fibers in the peroneal nerve.

Epineurial Window Is More Efficient in Attracting Axons than Simple Coaptation in a Sutureless (Cyanoacrylate-Bound) Model of End-to-Side Nerve Repair in the Rat Upper Limb: Functional and Morphometric Evidences and Review of the Literature

End-to-side nerve coaptation brings regenerating axons from the donor to the recipient nerve. Several techniques have been used to perform coaptation: microsurgical sutures with and without opening a window into the epi(peri)neurial connective tissue; among these, window techniques have been proven more effective in inducing axonal regeneration. The authors developed a sutureless model of end-to-side coaptation in the rat upper limb. In 19 adult Wistar rats, the median and the ulnar nerves of the left arm were approached from the axillary region, the median nerve transected and the proximal stump sutured to the pectoral muscle to prevent regeneration. Animals were then randomly divided in two experimental groups (7 animals each, 5 animals acting as control): Group 1: the distal stump of the transected median nerve was fixed to the ulnar nerve by applying cyanoacrylate solution; Group 2: a small epineurial window was opened into the epineurium of the ulnar nerve, caring to avoid damage to the nerve fibres; the distal stump of the transected median nerve was then fixed to the ulnar nerve by applying cyanoacrylate solution. The grasping test for functional evaluation was repeated every 10-11 weeks starting from week-15, up to the sacrifice (week 36). At week 36, the animals were sacrificed and the regenerated nerves harvested and processed for morphological investigations (high-resolution light microscopy as well as stereological and morphometrical analysis). This study shows that a) cyanoacrylate in end-to-side coaptation produces scarless axon regeneration without toxic effects; b) axonal regeneration and myelination occur even without opening an epineurial window, but c) the window is related to a larger number of regenerating fibres, especially myelinated and mature, and better functional outcomes.

Morphometric and Functional Analysis of Axonal Regeneration after End-to-end and End-to-side Neurorrhaphy in Rats

Supplemental Digital Content is available in the text.

Background:

End-to-side neurorrhaphy is controversial in the literature and has sparked debate over its degree of recovery. In this study, nerve regeneration was assessed in rats after end-to-side neurorrhaphy by morphometric analysis, electromyography, electron microscopy, and retrograde horseradish peroxidase (HRP) and Fluoro-Gold (FG; Fluorochrome Inc., Denver, Colo.) transport and then compared to end-to-end neurorrhaphy and sham operation.

Methods:

Thirty-seven animals were operated on and divided randomly into 4 groups: group 1, sham; group 2, end-to-end neurorrhaphy; group 3, end-to-side neurorrhaphy with an epineural window; and group 4, end-to-side neurorrhaphy without an epineural window. Three months after surgery, HRP was injected into the peroneal muscles. After 48 hours, nerve segments and lumbar spine segments were collected. Electromyography data were compared between groups, and FG uptake was compared in 20 other animals. Analysis of variance with Tukey-Kramer correction was used for group comparison.

Results:

The fiber count after end-to-end neurorrhaphy was higher than after end-to-side neurorrhaphy with an epineural window (q = 5.243 and P < 0.01) or without an epineural window (q = 4.951 and P < 0.01). HRP labeling showed a difference between group 2 and end-to-side neurorrhaphy with an epineural window (q = 5.291 and P < 0.01) and without an epineural window (q = 5.617 and P < 0.01). There was also a difference in mean area labeled with FG. Furthermore, the amplitudes of the action potentials were significantly higher in groups 1 and 2.

Conclusions:

There was nerve regeneration in all groups studied. However, the end-to-end neurorrhaphy group had better reinnervation than the end-to-side neurorrhaphy groups.

Clinical applications of end-to-side neurorrhaphy: an update

End-to-side neurorrhaphy constitutes an interesting option to regain nerve function after damage in selected cases, in which conventional techniques are not feasible. In the last twenty years, many experimental and clinical studies have been conducted in order to understand the biological mechanisms and to test the effectiveness of this technique, with contrasting results. In this updated review, we consider the state of the art about end-to-side coaptation, focusing on all the current clinical applications, such as sensory and mixed nerve repair, treatment of facial palsy, and brachial plexus injuries and painful neuromas management.

The rabbit brachial plexus as an experimental model – anatomy and surgical approach

The aim of our study was to analyze the anatomy and surgical approach of the rabbit brachial plexus. The research included 18 rabbits. The rabbit seems to be a good experimental model for spinal nerves injury, especially for the C5 and C6 segments. The anatomical structure of the rabbit’s brachial plexus is similar to the human brachial plexus. The structure of the rabbit C5 and C6 segments is analogous to the human structure. The spinal nerves of the C5 and C6 segments in the rabbit are wide and long enough for microsurgical procedures

End-to-side nerve repair in a large animal model: how does it compare with conventional methods of nerve repair?

A large animal (sheep) model was used to compare nerve axon regeneration and return of muscle function after a median-to-ulnar nerve end-to-side neurorrhaphy technique with conventional, clinically established, methods of nerve repair and untreated controls. Three groups of sheep were allocated to end-to-side repair (12 animals), a conventional method of nerve repair (18 animals), or a control group (eight animals). After a year nerve repairs were assessed electrophysiologically and histologically, and the muscles supplied by the repaired nerves were assessed physiologically. There were no significant differences in the outcomes of nerve repair between different conventional techniques. Half of the end-to-side nerve repairs supported nerve regeneration. The functional outcomes of the end-to-side repairs were inferior to conventional techniques which were, in turn, inferior to controls. End-to-side neurorrhaphy supported nerve regeneration, but the reliability of this technique is called into question and its use as a clinical tool can only be recommended as a salvage procedure.

Single versus double end-to-side nerve grafts in rats

PURPOSE

Although the end-to-side nerve repair technique has been used clinically, it has not yet produced consistent motor and sensory recovery in patients. The aim of this study was to investigate whether end-to-side double nerve grafts display more axonal regeneration compared with a single nerve graft in a rat lower limb preparation.

METHODS

The lower limbs of 96 Wister rats were used in experiments comparing single and double end-to-side nerve grafts. Left peroneal nerves were harvested and grafted between the right peroneal and tibial nerves. A single graft was attached end-to-side to the peroneal and tibial nerves through an epineural window (single graft group, n = 24). Two grafts were performed in the same manner in the double graft group (n = 24). The peroneal nerve was exposed in positive controls (n = 24) and no graft was performed in negative controls (n = 24). We recorded action potentials and moist weights of the left tibialis anterior muscle at each time point. Fluoro-Gold-labeled (Fluorochrome, Denver, CO) dorsal root ganglion neurons from L1 to L6 were counted using fluorescence microscopy and compared among the 4 groups.

RESULTS

In both single and double groups, the amplitude and the tibialis anterior muscle weight increased significantly compared with negative controls but remained lower than those measured in positive controls. There was no significant difference between single and double groups. In Fluoro-Gold-labeled neurons, there was also no significant difference between single and double groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The study showed that regeneration of motor and sensory nerve fibers was possible using 2 end-to-side nerve grafts. However, there was no significant difference between single and double grafts. This might suggest a therapeutic limitation of nerve transplants using 2 end-to-side nerve grafts.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Double end-to-side repair attracts both motor and sensory axons, and this results in a medium degree of recovery of function; however, double end-to-side nerve grafting does not appear to offer any advantage over a single end-to-side graft.

Histomorphometric changes in repaired mouse sciatic nerves are unaffected by the application of a scar-reducing agent

Microsurgical repair of transected peripheral nerves is compromised by the formation of scar tissue and the development of a neuroma, thereby limiting the success of regeneration. The aim of this study was to quantify histomorphometrically the structural changes in neural tissue that result from repair, and determine the effect of mannose-6-phosphate (M6P), a scar-reducing agent previously shown to enhance regeneration. In anaesthetised C57-black-6 mice, the left sciatic nerve was sectioned and repaired using four epineurial sutures. Either 100 μL of 600 mm M6P (five animals) or 100 μL of phosphate-buffered saline (placebo controls, five animals) was injected into and around the nerve repair site. A further group acted as sham-operated controls. After recovery for 6 weeks, the nerve was harvested for analysis using light and electron microscopy. Analysis revealed that when compared with sham controls, myelinated axons had smaller diameters both proximal and distal to the repair. Myelinated axon counts, axonal density and size all decreased across the repair site. There were normal numbers and densities of non-myelinated axons both proximal and distal to the repair. However, there were more Remak bundles distal to the repair site, and fewer non-myelinated axons per Remak bundle. Application of M6P did not affect any of these parameters.

End-to-side coaptation--controversial research issue or important tool in human patients

End-to-side coaptation is still a controversial procedure. Many authors reported surprisingly good results; others showed mediocre results only. There are also reports of complete failures. Apparently all authors are right. According to our experience the results depend on the level of end-to-side coaptation and on the nerve fiber composition. End-to-side coaptation between mixed nerves do have very poor expectations. The chances are much better if e.g. a small denervated pure motor nerve is coapted to a functioning small pure motor nerve. The same procedure may produce opposite results according to the circumstances. In our experience end-to-side coaptation is a reliable procedure of great use in selected cases. Main field of application are thin nerves with a well defined function and synergistic terminal motor branches.

Avaliação histológica da neurorrafia término-lateral: estudo experimental em ratos

OBJETIVO: Realizar estudo histológico comparando o crescimento axonal após neurorrafia término-lateral com e sem epineurectomia. MÉTODOS: foram utilizados vinte ratos Wistar, machos, divididos em dois grupos de 10 ratos cada. Um segmento de 1,0cm do nervo tibial e, foi transposto para o lado contralateral, sendo suturado no nervo ciático D. No grupo I, a sutura foi realizada diretamente no epineuro, enquanto que no grupo II foi realizado epineurectomia. Após 4 semanas foi realizado avaliação histológica do segmento transposto e no nervo ciático D, no sitio distal à lesão. RESULTADOS: demonstrou-se baixa quantidade de fibras remielinizadas, variando de 7 a 51 fibras no Grupo I e de 10 a 91 fibras no Grupo II. Utilizou-se o teste U de Mann-Whitney, com p=0,31, demonstrando que não há diferença estatisticamente significante entre os dois grupos. Não há relação positiva entre o número de fibras remielinizadas no enxerto e no sitio distal à lesão do ciático. CONCLUSÃO: A neurorrafia término-lateral, com e sem janela epineural, não promove remielinização eficiente. Nivel de evidência: Nível II: Estudo prospectivo comparativo

Facial--hypoglossal nerve end-to-side neurorrhaphy: anatomical study in rats

End-to-side neurorrhaphy (ESN) is presented as a sort of surgical technique for nerve repair that has the aim to obtain a good reinnervation of the recipient nerve and function preservation of the donor nerve. Several problems regarding this technique remain to be solved. Even if ESN could find some indications in particular cases of peripheral nerve surgery, we do not think that this technique can be first choice surgery for repairing a damaged facial nerve because of the complexity of the function of facial muscles and the necessity to offer an adequate number of motoneurons from the donor nerve for reinnervation of the recipient nerve.So, despite some reports about the clinical use of facial-hypoglossal nerve ESN, we studied experimentally such technique in the rat, having as recipient the facial nerve and as donor the hypoglossus. The purpose was to establish the number of motoneurons with which the donor hypoglossal nerve innervates the recipient facial nerve, and to compare the result with that obtained after facial-hypoglossus end-to-end neurorrhaphy (EEN). Beside other interesting findings, the key point of the obtained results was that motoneuron contribution given from the donor hypoglossus to the innervation of the recipient facial nerve was limited in ESN as compared to the classic EEN.

Contribution of the proximal nerve stump in end-to-side nerve repair: in a rat model

Background

The aim of this study was to evaluate the contribution of the proximal nerve stump, in end-to-side nerve repair, to functional recovery, by modifying the classic end-to-side neurorrhaphy and suturing the proximal nerve stump to a donor nerve in a rat model of a severed median nerve.

Methods

Three experimental groups were studied: a modified end-to-side neurorrhaphy with suturing of the proximal nerve stump (double end-to-side neurorrhaphy, Group I), a classic end-to-side neurorrhaphy (Group II) and a control group without neurorrhaphy (Group III). Twenty weeks after surgery, grasping testing, muscle contractility testing, and histological studies were performed.

Results

The grasping strength, muscle contraction force and nerve fiber count were significantly higher in group I than in group II, and there was no evidence of nerve recovery in group III.

Conclusions

The contribution from the proximal nerve stump in double end-to-side nerve repair might improve axonal sprouting from the donor nerve and help achieve a better functional recovery in an end-to-side coaptation model.

Chapter 8: Current techniques and concepts in peripheral nerve repair

Despite the progress in understanding the pathophysiology of peripheral nervous system injury and regeneration, as well as advancements in microsurgical techniques, peripheral nerve injuries are still a major challenge for reconstructive surgeons. Thorough knowledge of anatomy, pathophysiology, and surgical reconstruction is a prerequisite of proper peripheral nerve injury management. This chapter reviews the currently available surgical treatment options for different types of nerve injuries in clinical conditions. In overview of direct nerve repair, various end-to-end coaptation techniques and the role of end-to-side repair for proximal nerve injuries is described. When primary repair cannot be performed without undue tension, nerve grafting or tubulization techniques are required. Current gold standard for bridging nerve gaps is nerve autografting. However, disadvantages of this approach, such as donor site morbidity and limited length of available graft material encouraged the search for alternative means of nerve gap reconstruction. Nerve allografting was introduced for repair of extensive nerve injuries. Tubulization techniques with natural or artificial conduits are applicable as an alternative for bridging short nerve defects without the morbidities associated with harvesting of autologous nerve grafts. Achieving better outcomes depends both on the advancements in microsurgical techniques and introduction of molecular biology discoveries into clinical practice. The field of peripheral nerve research is dynamically developing and concentrates on more sophisticated approaches tested at the basic science level. Future directions in peripheral nerve reconstruction including, tolerance induction and minimal immunosuppression for nerve allografting, cell based supportive therapies and bioengineering of nerve conduits are also reviewed in this chapter.

End-to-side nerve repair: review of the literature and clinical indications

End-to-side (ETS) nerve repair, in which the distal stump of a transected nerve is coapted to the side of an uninjured donor nerve, has been suggested as a technique for repair of peripheral nerve injuries where the proximal nerve stump is unavailable or a significant nerve gap exists. Full review of the ETS literature suggests that sensory recovery after ETS repair results in some, but not robust, regeneration. Sensory axons will sprout without deliberate injury. However, motor axons only regenerate after deliberate nerve injury. Experimental and clinical experience with ETS neurorrhaphy has rendered mixed results. Continued research into ETS nerve repair is warranted. ETS techniques should not yet replace safer and more reliable techniques of nerve repair except when some, but not good, sensory recovery is appropriate and a deliberate injury to the donor motor nerve is made.

RESULTS OF END-TO-SIDE NERVE COAPTATION IN SEVERE OBSTETRIC BRACHIAL PLEXUS LESIONS

OBJECTIVE

Options for nerve repair are limited in brachial plexus lesions with multiple root avulsions because an insufficient number of proximal nerve stumps are available to serve as lead-out for nerve grafts. End-to-side nerve repair might be an alternative surgical technique for repair of such severe lesions. In this technique, an epineurial window is created in a healthy nerve, and the distal stump of the injured nerve is coapted to this site. Inconsistent results of end-to-side nerve repairs in traumatic nerve lesions in adults have been reported in small series. This article evaluates the results of end-to-side nerve repair in obstetric brachial plexus lesions and reviews the literature.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was performed of 20 end-to-side repairs in 12 infants. Evaluation of functional recovery of the target muscle was performed after at least 2 years of follow up (mean, 33 mo).

RESULTS

Five repairs failed (25%). Seven times (35%) good function (Medical Research Council at least 3) of the target muscle occurred in addition to eight partial recoveries (40%). In the majority of patients, however, the observed recovery cannot be exclusively attributed to the end-to-side repair. The reinnervation may be based on axonal outgrowth through grafted or neurolyzed adjacent nerves. It seems likely that recovery was solely based on the end-to-side repair in only two patients. No deficits occurred in donor nerve function.

CONCLUSION

This study does not convincingly show that the end-to-side nerve repair in infants with an obstetric brachial plexus lesion is effective. Its use cannot be recommended as standard therapy.

Ingrowth of sensory axons into an end-to-side coapted nerve stump after donor nerve crush in the rat

BACKGROUND

Target innervation through an end-to-side (ETS) nerve coaptation depends on axonal sprouting from the donor nerve. Terminal axonal sprouting in a partially denervated target tissue is more extensive from a crushed donor nerve than from an intact donor nerve. We hypothesized that axonal sprouting into an ETS coapted recipient nerve could be stimulated by crushing the donor nerve.

METHOD

Twenty-seven rats were randomised into 3 groups. In all, the distal stump of the transected peroneal nerve was sutured to the side of the sural nerve in place of the epineural window. The control group received no additional treatment. In the experimental groups, the sural donor nerve was crushed either 8 mm proximal (proximal crush group) or 8 mm distal to the coaptation site (distal crush group). Sixteen weeks after the surgery, histomorphometric analysis of the recipient peroneal nerve stump 4 mm distal to the coaptation site was performed.

FINDINGS

The number of myelinated axons in the recipient peroneal nerve stump was 758 +/- 247 in the control group, 503 +/- 246 in the distal crush group and 211 +/- 96 in the proximal crush group. The differences between the groups were statistically significant (p < 0.05). The majority of myelinated axons were thin myelinated axons and the frequency distribution of their cross-sectional areas was similar in all groups.

CONCLUSION

Contrary to our expectations, a significantly lower number of myelinated axons were present in recipient nerves in the proximal and distal crush groups than in the control group. This suggests that sensory axon ingrowth into an ETS coapted nerve cannot be enhanced by crushing the donor nerve.

Motor neuron regeneration through end-to-side repairs is a function of donor nerve axotomy

BACKGROUND

Over the past decade, a growing body of literature has emerged supporting the use of end-to-side (terminolateral) neurorrhaphy for the treatment of selected peripheral nerve injuries. It remains unclear, however, whether injury to the donor nerve is necessary to achieve significant regeneration through such repairs.

METHODS

End-to-side repair was studied in a rodent model in which the terminal limb of a transected peroneal nerve was sutured to the lateral aspect of the tibial nerve. Twenty-eight Lewis rats were randomized to four groups of seven animals each corresponding to incrementally greater donor nerve injuries as follows: group 1, conventional end-to-side neurorrhaphy; group 2, end-to-side neurorrhaphy with proximal crush injury; group 3, end-to-side neurorrhaphy with neurotomy; and group 4, end-to-end repair of transected peroneal nerve (positive control).

RESULTS

At 12 weeks, retrograde labeling of cell bodies of the ventral horn demonstrated significant differences between experimental groups, with mean counts in group 4 (1237 +/- 171) > group 3 (522 +/- 204) > group 2 (210 +/- 132) > or = group 1 (126 +/- 146). This association between nerve injury and motor neuron counts was closely mirrored in quantitative assessments of peripheral nerve regeneration and normalized wet muscle masses.

CONCLUSIONS

These data support the hypothesis that donor nerve injury is a prerequisite for significant motor neuronal regeneration across end-to-side repairs. Motor neuron regeneration through end-to-side repairs is optimized by deliberate transection of donor nerve axons.

Maximum Number of Collaterals Developed by One Axon during Peripheral Nerve Regeneration and the Influence of That Number on Reinnervation Effects

This study investigated the maximum number of collaterals that can be maintained by 1 axon during regeneration of rat peripheral nerve. The tibial nerve was transected, the proximal residual, with its variable number of axons, was fixed to the distal stump and served as the donor nerve. The number of myelinated axons was calculated after 12 weeks. An increasing ratio of distal stump axon numbers to proximal donor nerve axon numbers of 1.0, 1.83, 3.64 and 7.97 yielded ratios of regenerative myelinated axon numbers to proximal donor axon numbers of 0.98, 1.51, 2.39, 2.89, respectively, with an estimated maximum value of approximately 3.3 using the Hill function. The tibial function indexes and nerve conduction velocities of the regenerated tibial nerve were -44.1 +/- 5.1 and 43.2 +/- 5.3 m/s, -57.5 +/- 4.7 and 18.6 +/- 4.3 m/s, -80.2 +/- 7.1 and 12.7 +/- 3.7 m/s, and -85.4 +/- 5.7 and 10.5 +/- 3.9 m/s, respectively. It has been suggested that 1 axon can regenerate and maintain up to 3 or 4 collaterals in regenerated rat peripheral nerve.

End-to-Side Nerve Repair in Peripheral Nerve Injury

In peripheral nerve injury, end-to-side neurorrhaphy has been reported as an alternative in cases that the proximal nerve stump is not accessible. Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain peripheral nerve regeneration after end-to-side neurorrhaphy. Recent evidence suggests that nerve regeneration occurs by collateral sprouting. Although a great number of humoral factors have been identified, molecular mechanism of nerve regeneration after end-to-side neurorrhaphy has not been completely clarified yet. The goal of this technique is to provide satisfactory functional recovery for the recipient nerve, without any deterioration of the donor nerve function. End-to-side technique has been investigated in detail in both experimental and clinical studies. Only a limited number of reported cases in clinical practice, until today, can reveal that end-to-side technique may become a viable means of repairing peripheral nerves in certain clinical situations.

Quantitative Characterization of Regenerating Axons after End-to-Side and End-to-End Coaptation in a Rat Brachial Plexus Model: A Retrograde Tracer Study

The efficacy of end-to-side repair as a method of nerve reconstruction has been questioned, and most studies that characterize the mode of re-innervation are marred by inappropriate experimental design and lack quantitative analysis. This makes characterization of re-innervating neurons confusing and consequently controversy remains as to the extent and source of reinnervating axons. In an experimental brachial plexus rat model, we transected the musculocutaneous nerve, labeled its neuron pool with Fast-Blue and joined the distal stump to the side of the intact ulnar nerve, or to the proximal stump of the divided ulnar nerve, to characterize neurons that reinnervate the recipient nerve. Tetramethyl-rhodamine dextran (TMRD) or fluoro-gold was used to map the reinnervating motor and sensory neurons at 12 weeks post-transection. No neurons originally labeled from musculocutaneous nerve were subsequently labeled with TMRD or fluoro-gold, showing that this original neuron pool does not contribute to re-innervation of the distal musculocutaneous nerve, but that reinnervation occurs solely by ulnar nerve motor and sensory axons. In the end-to-side group, 16.4% of the motor and 7% of the sensory donor ulnar nerve neurons re-innervated the musculocutaneous nerve exclusively, and a further 10% motor and 11.6% sensory innervated the musculocutaneous nerve by collateral sprouting of their axons. This compared to re-innervation by 62.6% of motor and 70.4% of ulnar nerve sensory neurons in the positive control that underwent end-to-end repair. Our results confirm the concept of collateral sprouting and support the use of end-to-side repair.

The role of microsurgery in nerve repair and nerve grafting

Advances in the field of microsurgery have improved the results after peripheral nerve surgery and have extended the types of nerve repair that can be accomplished. Innovative techniques using microsurgical dissection, such as nerve transfers and end-to-side repairs are direct consequences of these advances.

End-to-side (terminolateral) nerve regeneration: a challenge for neuroscientists coming from an intriguing nerve repair concept

The last 15 years have seen a growing interest regarding a technique for nerve repair named end-to-side (terminolateral) neurorrhaphy. This technique is based on the concept that nerve fiber regeneration along the distal stump of a transected nerve, the proximal stump of which was lost, can be obtained by just suturing the proximal end of its distal stump to the epinerium of a neighbor healthy and undamaged donor nerve. A large body of experimental studies have shown that end-to-side neurorrhaphy, in fact, is able to induce collateral sprouting from donor nerve's axons which is at the basis of the massive repopulation of the distal nerve stump. The regenerating nerve fibers eventually reinnervate the periphery of the severed nerve leading to a recovery of the lost function the degree of which varies depending on factors that still have to be elucidated. Surprisingly, this puzzling concept of nerve regeneration has attracted very little attention from basic neuroscientists so far and, thus, the present paper is intended to call for more biological research on it by overviewing the relevant literature and indicating the several unanswered questions that this concept asks to the neuroscience community.

Influence of Aging on Regeneration in End-to-Side Neurorrhaphy

Aging profoundly affects the structural and functional characteristics of the peripheral nervous system. Although several experiments have investigated the effect of aging on nerve regeneration after crush and transection nerve injuries, little is known about the influence of age on end-to-side nerve repairs. It was hypothesized that decreased terminal and collateral sprouting in older animals would be associated with less robust regeneration through end-to-side nerve repairs. In this study, 27 Lewis rats underwent end-to-side repair at ages 2 weeks, 3 months, or 1 year. Histomorphometric assessments at 12 weeks demonstrated increased fiber width, percent neural tissue, and neural density in animals undergoing nerve reconstruction at the age of 2 weeks (P < 0.05). A trend toward further decline in regeneration was noted at ages 1 year versus 3 months. After end-to-side nerve repair, younger animals exhibit a more robust regenerative response, consistent with prior experience in other nerve injury models.

Use of an intact sensory nerve to bridge a motor nerve defect: an experimental study

Object

End-to-side neurorrhaphy has recently became popular for peripheral nerve repair. Although this method is mainly indicated in nerve defects in which there is an absent proximal nerve stump, bridging a motor nerve defect by coapting the proximal and distal ends of the defect to a neighboring mixed nerve in an end-to-side fashion has been another experimental use of this method. In this situation, however, the source of the regenerating axons is unclear because the axons in both the proximal end of the defect and the bridging intact nerve have the capacity for regeneration. The goal of this study was to identify the source of the regenerating axons.

Methods

In this experimental study, the authors used a sensory nerve to bridge a motor nerve defect so that they could elucidate the source of the regenerating motor axons in the distal part of the motor nerve. One advantage of using a sensory nerve was that it eradicated the risk of damaging another motor nerve. Tests used in the analysis included gait evaluation, electrophysiological tests, and histological assessment.

Conclusions

Results of this study showed that, in the rat model, a sensory nerve can be used to bridge a motor nerve defect, thereby eliminating the need for nerve grafting.

Regenerating Axons Emerge Far Proximal to the Coaptation Site in End-to-Side Nerve Coaptation without a Perineurial Window Using a T-Shaped Chamber

BACKGROUND

Considerable controversy exists concerning the mechanism of axonal regeneration in end-to-side neurorrhaphy. The authors studied the mode of axonal regeneration in end-to-side neurorrhaphy without a perineurial window using a rat sciatic nerve model.

METHODS

Twenty-seven rats were used. A 10-mm segment of peroneal nerve was harvested and coapted to the ipsilateral tibial nerve in end-to-side fashion using a T-shaped silicone chamber to minimize the tibial nerve damaged by surgery. To explain the role of nerve damage on axonal regeneration in end-to-side neurorrhaphy, we also used an isogenic nerve transplantation model in which the peroneal nerve remained intact. The mode of axonal regeneration was studied with electron microscopy, morphometric analysis, immunofluorescence, and immunohistochemistry.

RESULTS

Both morphometric analysis and immunolabeling of neurofilaments demonstrated that regenerating axons emerge at sites far proximal to the coaptation site, travel within the tibial nerve, traverse the perineurium circumferentially around the coaptation site, and then invade into the peroneal nerve. Electron microscopy and a double-labeled immunofluorescence study with antibodies against neurofilament and tenascin-C confirmed large-scale axonal penetration into the perineurium around the coaptation site. Immunofluorescence with antibody against NG2, a marker of axonal regeneration, prevented the possibility of collateral sprouting at the coaptation site. In addition, an end-to-side neurorrhaphy model with an isogenic peroneal nerve clearly demonstrated that nerve damage is a prerequisite for axonal regeneration through end-to-side neurorrhaphy.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors could not locate the site of axonal sprouting in end-to-side neurorrhaphy without a perineurial window; however, this study cast doubts on current hypothesis on the mode of axonal regeneration in end-to-side neurorrhaphy.

Simultaneous end-to-side coaptations of two severed nerves to a single healthy nerve in rats

Object

This experimental study was designed to evaluate functional and sensory outcomes and morphological features observed after simultaneous end-to-side coaptations of distal stumps of two nerves to a single neighboring nerve. Studies were performed using both parallel and end-to-side coaptation (PEC) and serial end-to-side coaptation (SEC) methods in a rat model.

Methods

In the PEC group, distal stumps of the sural and common fibular nerves were coapted to the intact tibial nerve 1 cm apart from each other in an end-to-side fashion. In the SEC group, identical surgical procedures apart from the coaptation method were conducted. For the coaptation method in this group, the distal stump of the common fibular nerve was first coapted to the side of the intact tibial nerve, and then the distal stump of the sural nerve was coapted to the side of the common fibular nerve 1 cm apart from the first coaptation site.

Nonoperated contralateral sides were used as controls. Nerve regeneration in both groups was evaluated functionally, electrophysiologically, and histomorphometrically.

Conclusions

When there is a need for two end-to-side coaptations of two severed nerves, PEC is the recommended method of choice to obtain better axonal regeneration into both nerves.

End-to-Side Nerve Coaptation

The aim of this experimental study was to evaluate the effects of end-to-side coaptation of the proximal end of a severed nerve to the same intact nerve, in addition to traditional end-to-side coaptation of the distal end, with an aim to use the intact nerve as a nerve conduit in a rat model and to compare the functional and histologic results of this modality to those obtained after nerve grafting and traditional end-to-side nerve coaptation. In group A, a peroneal nerve defect measuring 1 cm was created in the left hind limb, and a nerve graft 1 cm long was used to bridge the defect. In group B, only the distal stump of the peroneal nerve was coapted to the intact tibial nerve. In group C, both ends of the peroneal nerve defect were coapted to the intact tibial nerve in an end-to-side fashion 1.5 cm apart from each other, and in group D, the peroneal nerve defect was left unrepaired. Group E was consisted of nonoperated peroneal nerves that were used to obtain normative data. Although significantly higher myelinated axon densities were observed in groups B and C compared with group A and group E, total number of the myelinated axons was significantly higher only in group C. Peroneal functional index assessments demonstrated that nerve recovery in the peroneal nerve was similar in groups A and C, and both were better than those observed in groups B and D. Collectively, these results suggest that end-to-side coaptation of both ends of a severed nerve to an intact nerve, in case of a nerve defect in this length, may serve as an alternative for nerve grafting.

Repair of brachial plexus lesions by end-to-side side-to-side grafting neurorrhaphy: experience based on 11 cases

Eleven brachial plexus lesions were repaired using end-to-side side-to-side grafting neurorrhaphy in root ruptures, in phrenic and spinal accessory nerve neurotizations, in contralateral C7 neurotization, and in neurotization using intact interplexus roots or cords. The main aim was to approximate donor and recipient nerves and promote regeneration through them. Another indication was to augment the recipient nerve, when it had been neurotized or grafted to donors of dubious integrity, when it was not completely denervated, when it had been neurotized to a nerve with a suboptimal number of fibers, when it had been neurotized to distant donors delaying its regeneration, and when it had been neurotized to a donor supplying many recipients. In interplexus neurotization, the main indication was to preserve the integrity of the interplexus donors, as they were not sacrificeable. The principles of end-to-side neurorrhaphy were followed. The epineurium was removed. Axonal sprouting was induced by longitudinally slitting and partially transecting the donor and recipient nerves, by increasing the contact area between both of them and the nerve grafts, and by embedding the grafts into the split predegenerated injured nerve segments. Agonistic donors were used for root ruptures and for phrenic and spinal accessory neurotization, but not for contralateral C7 or interplexus neurotization. Single-donor single-recipient neurotization was successfully followed in phrenic neurotization of the suprascapular (3 cases) and axillary (1 case) nerves, spinal accessory neurotization of the suprascapular nerve (1 case), and dorsal part of contralateral C7 neurotization of the axillary nerve (2 cases). Apart from this, recipient augmentation necessitated many donor to single-recipient neurotizations. This was successfully performed using phrenic-interplexus root to suprascapular transfers (2 cases), phrenic-contralateral C7 to suprascapular transfer (1 case), and spinal accessory-interplexus root to musculocutaneous transfer (1 case). Both recipient augmentation and increasing the contact area between grafts and recipients necessitated single or multiple donor to many recipient neurotizations. This was applied in root ruptures (3 cases), with results comparable to those obtained in classical nerve-grafting techniques. It was also applied in ventral C7 transfer to the lateral or medial cords (3 cases) with functional recovery occurring in the biceps and pronator teres muscles, but not in dorsal C7 transfer to the axillary and radial nerves (3 cases) with functional recovery occurring in the deltoid and triceps muscles, and in whole C7 transfer to C5, 6, 7, 8T1 roots with functional recovery occurring in the deltoid (M4), biceps (M4), pronator teres (M4), and triceps (M3) (3 cases), and less so in the flexor carpi ulnaris and FDP (M3) (1 case) and the extensor digitorum longus (M3) (1 case). Contralateral C7 transfer to the lateral and posterior cords (4 cases) was followed by cocontractions that took 1 year to improve and that involved the rotator cuff, deltoid, biceps, and pronator teres (all agonists). Functional recovery in the triceps muscle was less than in the above muscles. Contralateral C7 transfer to C5-7 (1 case) was followed by cocontractions that took 1 year to resolve and that occurred between the deltoid, biceps, and flexor digitorum profundus. Interplexus root neurotization was done only in conjunction with other neurotization techniques, and so its role is difficult to judge. Though the same applies to regenerated lateral cord transfer to the posterior cord (2 cases), the successful results obtained from medial cord neurotization to the axillary, musculocutaneous, and radial nerves (1 case), and from ulnar and median nerve neurotization to the radial nerve (1 case), show that neurotization at the interplexus cord level may play a role in brachial plexus regeneration and may even be used to neurotize nerves and muscles distal to the elbow. The timing of repair was within 6 months after injury, except for 2 cases. In the first case, contralateral C7 transfer was successfully performed more than 1 year after injury. The second case was an obstetric palsy operated upon at age 8. Deterioration in motor power of the donor muscles that improved in 6 months was observed in 2 cases of interplexus neurotization at the cord level, because of looping the sural nerve grafts tightly around the donor nerves. Deterioration in donor-muscle motor power as a consequence of end-to-side neurorrhaphy was noted in the obstetric palsy case, when the flexor carpi radialis (donor) became grade 3 instead of grade 4. This was associated with cocontractions between it and the extensors. It took nearly 1 year to improve.

Low-power laser biostimulation enhances nerve repair after end-to-side neurorrhaphy: a double-blind randomized study in the rat median nerve model

Previous studies have shown that low-power laser biostimulation (lasertherapy) promotes posttraumatic nerve regeneration. The objective of the present study was to investigate the effects of postoperative lasertherapy on nerve regeneration after end-to-side neurorrhaphy, an innovative technique for peripheral nerve repair. After complete transection, the left median nerve was repaired by end-to-side neurorrhaphy on the ulnar "donor" nerve. The animals were then divided into four groups: one placebo group, and three laser-treated groups that received lasertherapy three times a week for 3 weeks starting from postoperative day 1. Three different types of laser emission were used: continuous (808 nm), pulsed (905 nm), and a combination of the two. Functional testing was carried out every 2 weeks after surgery by means of the grasping test. At the time of withdrawal 16 weeks postoperatively, muscle mass recovery was assessed by weighing the muscles innervated by the median nerve. Finally, the repaired nerves were withdrawn, embedded in resin and analyzed by light and electron microscopy. Results showed that laser biostimulation induces: (1) a statistically significant faster recovery of the lesioned function; (2) a statistically significant faster recovery of muscle mass; (3) a statistically significant faster myelination of the regenerated nerve fibers. From comparison of the three different types of laser emissions, it turned out that the best functional outcome was obtained by means of pulsed-continuous-combined laser biostimulation. Taken together, the results of the present study confirm previous experimental data on the effectiveness of lasertherapy for the promotion of peripheral nerve regeneration and suggest that early postoperative lasertherapy should be considered as a very promising physiotherapeutic tool for rehabilitation after end-to-side neurorrhaphy.

Collateral sprouting occurs following end-to-side neurorrhaphy

Recent evidence supports the use of end-to-side neurorrhaphy for the treatment of certain peripheral nerve disorders. However, the mechanism by which nerves regenerate following this procedure is still unclear. To address this question, the authors designed a new end-to-side coaptation model in rats in which the donor nerves were uninjured. The regenerated axons at the coaptation site were observed directly using fluorescent dye as the neural tracer. The sciatic nerve from adult Wistar rats was transplanted between the left and right median nerves. Fifteen rats were divided into three groups. In group I, the donor (right median) nerve was sutured end to side to the divided grafted nerve using a noninjury technique. In group II, the aponeurosis of the spinal muscles was harvested and the sciatic and right median nerves were coapted end to side noninjuriously by wrapping them in the excised aponeurosis. In group III, a perineurial window was created and a partial neurectomy was carried out at the suture site, after which the sciatic and right median nerves were sutured end to side. Sixty days after the operation, nerve regeneration was evaluated by recording action potentials in the grafted nerve, by performing electromyography in the flexor muscles in the forearm, and by histological examination. The grafted nerves were fixed and sectioned, the number of regenerated nerve fibers was counted, and axonal diameters were measured. Fluorescent dye crystal was used, in conjunction with confocal microscopy, to observe the regenerated axons at the co-aptation site. The results showed that nerve regeneration had occurred in the animals, as determined electrophysiologically and histologically. Both the right and left flexor muscles of the forearm contracted simultaneously as a result of indirect electric stimulation of the grafted nerve, which suggests that the regenerated nerve was physiologically connected with the donor nerve. Nerve fiber counts did not show any differences among groups (p > 0.05), but axonal diameters were significantly greater in group III than in the other two groups. Fluorescent dye staining revealed the presence of regenerated nerve fibers beyond the coaptation site. In group III, the regenerating nerves were observed within the whole section of the coaptation site and collateral sprouting was found to occur even at a site distal to the suture. From these results, the authors conclude that in end-to-side neurorrhaphy, nerve regeneration occurs by collateral sprouting from the donor nerve.

The use of end-to-side nerve grafts to reinnervate the paralyzed orbicularis oculi muscle

Facial paralysis is a serious neurologic disorder, particularly when it affects the eye. Loss of the protective blink reflex may lead to corneal ulceration and, possibly, visual loss. The purpose of this study was to compare different nerve-grafting techniques to reanimate the paralyzed eyelid. Sixteen adult dogs (25 kg each) were allocated into four groups. Denervation of the left hemi-face was performed in all cases. One dog served as a control animal (group I). Group II dogs (n = 5) underwent end-to-side coaptation of the nerve graft to the intact palpebral branch and end-to-end coaptation to the denervated palpebral branch. Group III dogs (n = 5) underwent end-to-end coaptation of the nerve graft to the intact palpebral branch and end-to-end coaptation to the denervated palpebral branch. Group IV dogs (n = 5) underwent end-to-side coaptation of the nerve graft to the intact and denervated palpebral branches. The animals were monitored for 9 months after the surgical procedures, to allow adequate time for reinnervation. The dogs were postoperatively monitored with clinical observation, electrophysiologic testing, video motion analysis, and histologic assessments. Clinical observation and electrophysiologic testing demonstrated the production of an eye blink in the denervated hemi-face in all experimental groups. There was a trend toward increased speed of reinnervation for group III animals (end-to-end coaptations). It was concluded that end-to-side coaptation can produce a contralateral synchronous eye blink in a clinically relevant, large-animal model.

A modified end-to-side method for peripheral nerve repair: large epineurial window helicoid technique versus small epineurial window standard end-to-side technique

This study evaluated 2 end-to-side nerve repair techniques for ability to induce nerve sprouting and muscular recovery. Twenty-four rats underwent identical surgeries. The helicoid method of neurorrhaphy was used on the left (large epineurial window) side and the standard end-to-side (small epineurial window) repair on the right side of each rat to repair the peroneal nerve. The helicoid configuration markedly increases the area from which axons can sprout into the recipient nerve. At 11 months after surgery, axons were counted in donor and recipient nerves, and muscle moist weight of the extensor digitorum longus (EDL) and tetanic force were measured. Muscle volume, tetanic force, and moist weight of EDL muscles were significantly higher on the left side (helicoid) than on the right (end-to-side). Histologic analysis and nerve axon counting of the recipient peroneal nerve showed significantly more regenerative nerves on the left than on the right. There were no significant differences between sites above and below the repair site in the donor tibial nerve in regard to mean number of nerve fibers. Helicoid nerve repair can entice more nerve fiber sprouts from the intact donor nerve, improve muscular recovery, and maintain donor nerve health.

Physiologic and morphologic aspects of nerve regeneration after end-to-end or end-to-side coaptation in a rat model of brachial plexus injury

The results of repairing a transected rat musculocutaneous nerve by suturing the distal stump, end to side or end to end, to the ipsilateral ulnar nerve were assessed at 3 months by retrograde labeling and morphologic and physiologic analysis. Unlike most other models of end-to-side repair in which the injured recipient and donor reinnervating nerves have overlapping neuron pools in the spinal cord, in this model the neurons of the injured musculocutaneous and the reinnervating ulnar nerves are located in mutually exclusive segments of the spinal cord. Using retrograde labeling we show that the reinnervating fibers are derived solely from the ulnar nerve pool. Both end-to-side and end-to-end coaptation resulted in reinnervation of the distal musculocutaneous nerve and significant functional reinnervation of its dependent biceps brachii muscle. Although end-to-end coaptation resulted in better axon morphology and muscle function, it resulted in total loss of donor nerve function. By contrast, end-to-side coaptation resulted in good recovery with only minimal donor nerve deficit. These results show that significant functional reinnervation of biceps brachii muscle can occur solely on the basis of collateral sprouting of intact axons from the adjacent ulnar nerve.

Axonal regeneration stimulated by the combination of nerve growth factor and ciliary neurotrophic factor in an end-to-side model

The aim of this study was to investigate the potential for stimulating axonal regeneration in the context of end-to-side coaptation using a combination of nerve growth factor and ciliary neurotrophic factor in the rat sciatic nerve model. Four experimental groups (n = 8) were used: end-to-side coaptation only, end-to-side coaptation plus growth factor injection, primary repair, and nontransferred gap control. Twenty weeks after surgery histologic analysis showed that the ratio of axon density was significantly increased for the growth factor injection group. Histologic evidence suggested contamination from the proximal peroneal stump. Electrical stimulation and muscle weights showed that the target muscles had been reinnervated in all groups except the nontransferred gap control group. These data support the conclusion that the use of nerve growth factor and ciliary neurotrophic factor in combination may enhance regeneration in the peripheral nervous system. This is consistent with previous reports on the central nervous system and suggests a potential application in future studies aimed at improving peripheral nerve regeneration. Another conclusion is that contamination from the proximal peroneal stump may explain the regeneration observed in the end-to-side model. Further study using retrograde labeling is needed to establish the origin of the regenerating axons. Finally, evidence suggests that regenerating axons can use the epineurium of an intact nerve to bridge a gap in continuity.

Using intact nerve to bridge peripheral nerve defects: an alternative to the use of nerve grafts

This preliminary study was conducted to determine whether a regenerating peripheral nerve in a rat model can use the epineurium of an intact nerve to bridge a nerve gap defect. To create the intact nerve bridge a 1-cm segment of the peroneal nerve is resected leaving a gap defect. The proximal and distal peroneal nerve stumps are sutured 1-cm apart, in an end-to-side fashion, to the epineurium of the intact tibial nerve. The following experimental groups were used (n = 12): group A, immediate primary repair of resected segment; group B, intact nerve bridge technique; group C, nerve autograft; and group D, gap in situ control. Evaluation 12 weeks after surgery included measurement of the tibialis anterior muscle contraction force, axonal counting, wet weight of the tibialis anterior muscle, and histologic examination. The results of this animal study support 3 main conclusions: regenerating axons can use the epineurium of an intact nerve to bridge a gap in nerve continuity; when using functional recovery to assess regeneration, there is no significant difference between standard nerve autografts and the intact nerve bridge technique; and based on histologic examination, the intact nerve bridge technique does not injure the intact tibial nerve used to bridge the gap defect. Taken together, the results of this preliminary animal study suggest that the intact nerve bridge technique may be a potential alternative to standard nerve autografts in appropriate circumstances. Further investigation in a higher animal model is warranted before considering clinical application of the intact nerve bridge technique.