In Situ Real-Time Atomic Force Microscopy Observation of the Surface Mobility on Each Domain of a Polystyrene-b-poly(methyl methacrylate) Film at High Temperatures

The surface chain movements within the microdomains of a polystyrene-b-poly(methyl methacrylate) (PS-b-PMMA) and corresponding homopolymer films were observed via in situ real-time atomic force microscopy (AFM) at high temperatures and analyzed quantitatively using particle image velocimetry (PIV). At low temperatures, mobility within the PS microdomains resembled that within the PS homopolymer film, but movements in the PMMA microdomains were notably accelerated compared to the PMMA homopolymer. Conversely, at high temperatures, mobility within both PS and PMMA microdomains was considerably suppressed compared to their respective homopolymer films, likely owing to the fixed linkage of the block chains at the microdomain interface. This combination of real-time AFM observation and PIV analysis is an effective method for quantitatively evaluating surface chain mobility in real space.

Chain Movements at the Topmost Surface of Poly(methyl methacrylate) and Polystyrene Films Directly Evaluated by In Situ High-Temperature Atomic Force Microscopy

The surfaces of polymeric materials are thermodynamically unstable, and the glass-transition temperature (Tg) is significantly lower than that in the bulk material. However, the mobility of the chains at the top of the surface has never been directly evaluated. In this study, the movements of the topmost chains of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) and polystyrene (PS) bulk films were observed in situ at high temperatures with atomic force microscopy in tapping mode. PMMA and PS chains started moving at ∼97 and ∼50 °C, respectively, which were slightly and significantly below the values of their bulk Tg (PMMA, 108 °C; PS, 104 °C), respectively. The activation energies of the apparent diffusion constants of PMMA and PS, derived by particle image velocimetry analysis, were 193 and 151 kJ mol-1, respectively, and reasonable for the glass transition. Movements of isolated PMMA chains deposited on a PMMA film by the Langmuir-Blodgett technique were also observed and confirmed to be essentially the same as those on the PMMA film surface.

Decoupling of Glassy Dynamics from Viscosity in Thin Supported Poly(n-butyl methacrylate) Films

We utilized fast scanning calorimetry to characterize the glass transition temperature (T g) and intrinsic molecular mobility of low-molecular-weight poly(n-butyl methacrylate) thin films of varying thicknesses. We found that the T g and intrinsic molecular mobility were coupled, showing no film thickness-dependent variation. We further employed a unique noncontact capillary nanoshearing technique to directly probe layer-resolved gradients in the rheological response of these films. We found that layer-resolved shear mobility was enhanced with a reduction in film thickness, whereas the effective viscosity decreased. Our results highlight the importance of polymer-substrate attractive interactions and free surface-promoted enhanced mobility, establishing a competitive nanoconfinement effect in poly(n-butyl methacrylate) thin films. Moreover, the findings indicate a decoupling in the thickness-dependent variation of T g and intrinsic molecular mobility with the mechanical responses (shear mobility and effective viscosity).

Molecular rotors to probe the local viscosity of a polymer glass

We investigate the local viscosity of a polymer glass around its glass transition temperature using environment-sensitive fluorescent molecular rotors embedded in the polymer matrix. The rotors' fluorescence depends on the local viscosity, and measuring the fluorescence intensity and lifetime of the probe therefore allows to measure the local free volume in the polymer glass when going through the glass transition. This also allows us to study the local viscosity and free volume when the polymer film is put under an external stress. We find that the film does not flow homogeneously, but undergoes shear banding that is visible as a spatially varying free volume and viscosity.

Gradient in refractive index reveals denser near free surface region in thin polymer films

A gradient in refractive index that is linear in magnitude with depth into the film is used to fit ellipsometric data for thin polymer films of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), polystyrene (PS), and poly(2-vinyl pyridine) (P2VP). We find that the linear gradient model fits provide more physically realistic refractive index values for thin films compared with the commonly used homogeneous Cauchy layer model, addressing recent reports of physically unrealistic density increases. Counter to common expectations of a simple free volume correlation between density and dynamics, we find that the direction of refractive index (density) gradient indicates a higher density near the free surface, which we rationalize based on the observed faster free surface dynamics needed to create vapor deposited stable glasses with optimized denser molecular packings. The magnitude of refractive index gradient is observed to be three times larger for PMMA than for PS films, while P2VP films exhibit a more muted response possibly reflective of a decoupling in free surface and substrate dynamics in systems with strong interfacial interactions.

Polymers under nanoconfinement: where are we now in understanding local property changes?

Polymers are increasingly being used in applications with nanostructured morphologies where almost all polymer molecules are within a few tens to hundreds of nanometers from some interface. From nearly three decades of study on polymers in simplified nanoconfined systems such as thin films, we have come to understand property changes in these systems as arising from interfacial effects where local dynamical perturbations are propagated deeper into the material. This review provides a summary of local glass transition temperature T_g changes near interfaces, comparing across different types of interfaces: free surface, substrate, liquid, and polymer-polymer. Local versus film-average properties in thin films are discussed, making connections to other related property changes, while highlighting several historically important studies. By experimental necessity, most studies are on high enough molecule weight chains to be well entangled, although aspects that connect to lower molecule weight materials are described. Emphasis is made to identify observations and open questions that have yet to be fully understood such as the evidence of long-ranged interfacial effects, finite domain size, interfacial breadth, and chain connectivity.

Comparing refractive index and density changes with decreasing film thickness in thin supported films across different polymers

Density changes in thin polymer films have long been considered as a possible explanation for shifts in the thickness-dependent glass transition temperature T_g(h) in such nanoconfined systems, given that the glass transition is fundamentally associated with packing frustration during material densification on cooling. We use ellipsometry to compare the temperature-dependent refractive index with decreasing thickness n(h) for supported films of poly(2-vinyl pyridine) (P2VP), poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), and polystyrene (PS), as these polymers have different silica substrate interactions. We observe similar n(h) trends for all three polymers, with near equivalence of P2VP and PS, characterized by a large apparent increase in refractive index for h ≤ 40 nm-65 nm depending on the polymer. Possible sources of molecular dipole orientation within the film are tested by varying molecular weight, polydispersity, chain conformation, and substrate chemistry. Such film inhomogeneities associated with non-uniform polarizability would invalidate the use of homogeneous layer approximations inherent in most thin film analysis methods, which we believe likely explains recent reports of large unphysical increases in film density with decreasing thickness by a variety of different experimental techniques.

Raising glass transition temperature of polymer nanofilms as a function of negative interface energy

Based on a thermodynamic approach, glass transition temperature (T_g) of substrate-supported polymer nanofilms (s-PNFs) is investigated for carbon-chain polymers, taking the role of the interface energy into consideration.

Enhancing Electroresponsive Electrorheological Effect and Temperature Dependence of Poly(ionic liquid) Particles by Hard Core Confinement

Monodisperse core-shell-structured SiO₂@poly(ionic liquid) (SiO₂@PIL) particles are prepared by the polymerization of ionic liquid monomer on the surface of methacryloxypropyltrimethoxysilane-modified SiO₂ particles. The electroresponsive electrorheological (ER) effect of SiO₂@PIL particles when dispersed in insulating carrier liquid is investigated and compared with that of pure poly(ionic liquid) (PIL) particles based on temperature-modulated rheology under electric fields. It is demonstrated that hard SiO₂ core not only enhances the ER effect of PIL particles but also improves the temperature dependence of ER effect. By dielectric spectroscopy analysis, the mechanism behind the property enhancement was discussed. It indicates that the hard SiO₂ core can not only increase the interfacial polarization strength of SiO₂@PIL particles by core-shell architecture but also restrain the segment relaxation or softening of the PIL shell and influence the ion dynamics above the calorimetric glass transition of PILs by the so called "substrate confinement effect", and this should be responsible for the enhanced electroresponsive ER effect and temperature stability of the SiO₂@PIL particles.

Temperature-Independent Rescaling of the Local Activation Barrier Drives Free Surface Nanoconfinement Effects on Segmental-Scale Translational Dynamics near Tg

Near-interface alterations in dynamics and glass formation behavior have been the subject of extensive study for the past two decades, both because of their practical importance and in the hope of revealing underlying correlation lengths underpinning glass transition more generally. Here we employ molecular dynamics simulations of thick films to demonstrate that these effects emerge, for segmental-scale translational dynamics at low temperature, from a temperature-independent rescaling of the local activation barrier. This rescaling manifests as a fractional power law decoupling relationship of local dynamics relative to the bulk, with a transition from a regime of weak decoupling at high temperatures to a regime of strong decoupling at low temperatures. The range of this effect saturates at low temperatures, with 90% of the surface perturbation in the barrier lost over a range of 12 segmental diameters. These findings reduce the phenomenology of T_g nanoconfinement effects to two properties-a position-dependent, temperature independent, barrier rescaling factor and an onset time scale-while substantially constraining the predictions required from any theoretical explanation of this phenomenon.

Thermal Transitions in Perfluorosulfonated Ionomer Thin-Films

Thin perfluorosulfonated ion-conducting polymers (PFSI ionomers) in energy-conversion devices have limitations in functionality attributed to confinement-driven and surface-dependent interactions. This study highlights the effects of confinement and interface-dependent interactions of PFSI thin-films by exploring thin-film thermal transition temperature (T_T). Change in T_T in polymers is an indicator for chain relaxation and mobility with implications on properties like gas transport. This work demonstrates an increase in T_T with decreasing PFSI film thickness in acid (H⁺) form (from 70 to 130 °C for 400 to 10 nm, respectively). In metal cation (M⁺) exchanged PFSI, T_T remained constant with thickness. Results point to an interplay between increased chain mobility at the free surface and hindered motion near the rigid substrate interface, which is amplified upon further confinement. This balance is additionally impacted by ionomer intermolecular forces, as strong electrostatic networks within the PFSI-M⁺ matrix raises T_T above the mainly hydrogen-bonded PFSI-H⁺ ionomer.

Competing polymer-substrate interactions mitigate random copolymer adsorption

Annealing a supported polymer film in the melt state, a common practice to relieve residual stresses and erase thermal history, can result in the development of an irreversibly adsorbed nanolayer. This layer of polymer chains physically adsorbed to the substrate interface has been shown to influence thin film properties such as viscosity and glass transition temperature. Its growth is attributed to many simultaneous interactions between individual monomer units and the substrate stabilizing chains against desorption. A better understanding of how these specific polymer-substrate interactions influence the growth of the adsorbed layer is needed, particularly given how strongly the properties of geometrically-confined polymeric systems are impacted by interfaces. Here, we use homopolymers and random copolymers of styrene and methyl methacrylate to form adsorbed layers and examine the influence of chemical composition and the resulting polymer-substrate interactions on adsorbed layer growth and structure. Ellipsometric measurements reveal a non-monotonic trend between composition and thickness of the adsorbed layers that is inconsistent with the behavior normally exhibited by random copolymers, being intermediate to their respective homopolymers. We examine this trend in terms of plateau thickness and growth kinetics at two different annealing temperatures and propose a mechanism for how different polymer-substrate interactions combine to influence adsorption when copolymer films are annealed. By introducing compositional heterogeneity, this mechanism extends the study of irreversible adsorption to complex chemistries and provides for a more general understanding of how annealing should be accounted for in the proper selection and processing of polymer thin films for applications in nanotechnology.

Side-group size effects on interfaces and glass formation in supported polymer thin films

Recent studies on glass-forming polymers near interfaces have emphasized the importance of molecular features such as chain stiffness, side-groups, molecular packing, and associated changes in fragility as key factors that govern the magnitude of T_g changes with respect to the bulk in polymer thin films. However, how such molecular features are coupled with substrate and free surface effects on T_g in thin films remains to be fully understood. Here, we employ a chemically specific coarse-grained polymer model for methacrylates to investigate the role of side-group volume on glass formation in bulk polymers and supported thin films. Our results show that bulkier side-groups lead to higher bulk T_g and fragility and are associated with a pronounced free surface effect on overall T_g depression. By probing local T_g within the films, however, we find that the polymers with bulkier side-groups experience a reduced confinement-induced increase in local T_g near a strongly interacting substrate. Further analyses indicate that this is due to the packing frustration of chains near the substrate interface, which lowers the attractive interactions with the substrate and thus lessens the surface-induced reduction in segmental mobility. Our results reveal that the size of the polymer side-group may be a design element that controls the confinement effects induced by the free surface and substrates in supported polymer thin films. Our analyses provide new insights into the factors governing polymer dynamics in bulk and confined environments.

Why we need to look beyond the glass transition temperature to characterize the dynamics of thin supported polymer films

There is significant variation in the reported magnitude and even the sign of [Formula: see text] shifts in thin polymer films with nominally the same chemistry, film thickness, and supporting substrate. The implicit assumption is that methods used to estimate [Formula: see text] in bulk materials are relevant for inferring dynamic changes in thin films. To test the validity of this assumption, we perform molecular simulations of a coarse-grained polymer melt supported on an attractive substrate. As observed in many experiments, we find that [Formula: see text] based on thermodynamic criteria (temperature dependence of film height or enthalpy) decreases with decreasing film thickness, regardless of the polymer-substrate interaction strength ε. In contrast, we find that [Formula: see text] based on a dynamic criterion (relaxation of the dynamic structure factor) also decreases with decreasing thickness when ε is relatively weak, but [Formula: see text] increases when ε exceeds the polymer-polymer interaction strength. We show that these qualitatively different trends in [Formula: see text] reflect differing sensitivities to the mobility gradient across the film. Apparently, the slowly relaxing polymer segments in the substrate region make the largest contribution to the shift of [Formula: see text] in the dynamic measurement, but this part of the film contributes less to the thermodynamic estimate of [Formula: see text] Our results emphasize the limitations of using [Formula: see text] to infer changes in the dynamics of polymer thin films. However, we show that the thermodynamic and dynamic estimates of [Formula: see text] can be combined to predict local changes in [Formula: see text] near the substrate, providing a simple method to infer information about the mobility gradient.

Direct Measurement of the Local Glass Transition in Self-Assembled Copolymers with Nanometer Resolution

Nanoscale compositional heterogeneity in block copolymers can impart synergistic property combinations, such as stiffness and toughness. However, until now, there has been no experimental method to locally probe the dynamics at a specific location within these structured materials. Here, this was achieved by incorporating pyrene-bearing monomers at specific locations along the polymer chain, allowing the labeled monomers' local environment to be interrogated via fluorescence. In lamellar-forming poly(butyl methacrylate-b-methyl methacrylate) diblock copolymers, a strong gradient in glass transition temperature, T_g, of the higher-T_g block, 42 K over 4 nm, was mapped with nanometer resolution. These measurements also revealed a strongly asymmetric influence of the domain interface on T_g, with a much smaller dynamic gradient being observed for the lower-T_g block.

Role of "Hard" and "Soft" Confinement on Polymer Dynamics at the Nanoscale

We investigated the segmental dynamics of asymmetrically confined polymer films and report an unusual phenomenon in which the presence and thickness of a soft confining layer are responsible for significant changes in the segmental dynamics of the confined films. Specifically, the segmental dynamics of poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) thin films asymmetrically confined between hard aluminum (Al), and soft polystyrene (PS) films are shown to shift by as much as half an order of magnitude upon changes in the thicknesses of the confining PS layer. These effects are more significant than those due to symmetric confinement between hard Al substrates or exposure to a free surface. These observations, partially rationalized in terms of recent simulations and theory, implicate the role of the moduli of the confining layers.

Changes in the temperature-dependent specific volume of supported polystyrene films with film thickness

Recent studies have measured or predicted thickness-dependent shifts in density or specific volume of polymer films as a possible means of understanding changes in the glass transition temperature Tg(h) with decreasing film thickness with some experimental works claiming unrealistically large (25%-30%) increases in film density with decreasing thickness. Here we use ellipsometry to measure the temperature-dependent index of refraction of polystyrene (PS) films supported on silicon and investigate the validity of the commonly used Lorentz-Lorenz equation for inferring changes in density or specific volume from very thin films. We find that the density (specific volume) of these supported PS films does not vary by more than ±0.4% of the bulk value for film thicknesses above 30 nm, and that the small variations we do observe are uncorrelated with any free volume explanation for the Tg(h) decrease exhibited by these films. We conclude that the derivation of the Lorentz-Lorenz equation becomes invalid for very thin films as the film thickness approaches ∼20 nm, and that reports of large density changes greater than ±1% of bulk for films thinner than this likely suffer from breakdown in the validity of this equation or in the difficulties associated with accurately measuring the index of refraction of such thin films. For larger film thicknesses, we do observed small variations in the effective specific volume of the films of 0.4 ± 0.2%, outside of our experimental error. These shifts occur simultaneously in both the liquid and glassy regimes uniformly together starting at film thicknesses less than ∼120 nm but appear to be uncorrelated with Tg(h) decreases; possible causes for these variations are discussed.

Glass-Transition and Side-Chain Dynamics in Thin Films: Explaining Dissimilar Free Surface Effects for Polystyrene vs Poly(methyl methacrylate)

Despite having very similar bulk properties such as glass-transition temperature (T_g), density, and fragility, polystyrene (PS) and poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) exhibit characteristically different T_g depression in free-standing ultrathin films due to free surface effects. Here we explain this difference using our recently established chemistry-specific coarse-grained (CG) models for these two polymers. Models capture the dissimilar scaling of T_g with free-standing film thickness as seen in experiments and enable us to quantify the size of the regions near free surfaces over which chain relaxation exhibits differences from bulk. Most interestingly, vibrational density of states (VDOS) analysis uncovers a relationship between the amplitude of side-chain fluctuations, associated with side-chain flexibility and T_g-nanoconfinement. We discover that increasing backbone to side-chain mass ratio in CG models increases the amplitude of side-chain fluctuations and suppresses the free-surface effect on T_g. We show that mass distribution and side-chain flexibility are central to explain dissimilar free surface effects on PS and PMMA. Our model predictions are further corroborated by experimental evidence showing the role of mass distribution in styrene thin films. Our study ascertains the significance of molecular characteristics on nanoconfinement and highlights the ability for chemistry-specific CG models to explore the thermomechanical properties of polymer thin films.

Enhanced diffusion and mobile fronts in a simple lattice model of glass-forming liquids

The diffusion of mobility in bulk and thin film fluids near their glass transition is examined with a kinetic lattice model, and compared to recent experiments on bulk liquids and vapor-deposited thin film glasses. The "limited mobility" (LM) lattice model exhibits dynamic heterogeneity of mobility when the fluid is near its kinetic arrest transition; a finite-parameter second-order critical point in the LM model bearing strong resemblance to the glass transition in real fluids. The spatial heterogeneity of mobility near kinetic arrest leads to dynamics that violate the Stokes-Einstein relation. To make connections with experiment, LM model simulations of self-diffusion constants in fluids near kinetic arrest are compared to those in two organic glass-formers. In addition, simulations of mobility in films that have been temperature-jumped above kinetic arrest (starting from an arrested state) are carried out. The films develop a "front" of mobility at their free surface that progresses into the film interior at a constant rate, thereby mobilising the entire film to fluidity. The velocity of the front scales with the self-diffusion constant for analogous bulk systems-an observation consistent with experiments on vapor-deposited molecular thin films.