Insight into the PrPC-->PrPSc conversion from the structures of antibody-bound ovine prion scrapie-susceptibility variants

Prion-like Proteins in Plants: Key Regulators of Development and Environmental Adaptation via Phase Separation

Prion-like domains (PrLDs), a unique type of low-complexity domain (LCD) or intrinsically disordered region (IDR), have been shown to mediate protein liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). Recent research has increasingly focused on how prion-like proteins (PrLPs) regulate plant growth, development, and stress responses. This review provides a comprehensive overview of plant PrLPs. We analyze the structural features of PrLPs and the mechanisms by which PrLPs undergo LLPS. Through gene ontology (GO) analysis, we highlight the diverse molecular functions of PrLPs and explore how PrLPs influence plant development and stress responses via phase separation. Finally, we address unresolved questions about PrLP regulatory mechanisms, offering prospects for future research.

PrP meets alpha-synuclein: Molecular mechanisms and implications for disease

The discovery of prions has challenged dogmas and has revolutionized our understanding of protein-misfolding diseases. The concept of self-propagation via protein conformational changes, originally discovered for the prion protein (PrP), also applies to other proteins that exhibit similar behavior, such as alpha-synuclein (aSyn), a central player in Parkinson's disease and in other synucleinopathies. aSyn pathology appears to spread from one cell to another during disease progression, and involves the misfolding and aggregation of aSyn. How the transfer of aSyn between cells occurs is still being studied, but one important hypothesis involves receptor-mediated transport. Interestingly, recent studies indicate that the cellular prion protein (PrPC) may play a crucial role in this process. PrPC has been shown to act as a receptor/sensor for protein aggregates in different neurodegenerative disorders, including Alzheimer's disease and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Here, we provide a comprehensive overview of the current state of knowledge regarding the interaction between aSyn and PrPC and discuss its role in synucleinopathies. We examine the properties of PrP and aSyn, including their structure, function, and aggregation. Additionally, we discuss the current understanding of PrPC's role as a receptor/sensor for aSyn aggregates and identify remaining unanswered questions in this area of research. Ultimately, we posit that exploring the interaction between aSyn and PrPC may offer potential treatment options for synucleinopathies.

Sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease: Finding the Needle in the Haystack

Sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (SCJD) is a rare neurodegenerative disease with a very low prevalence. The aetiology is theorised to be genetic. Modern laboratory techniques, such as the real-time quaking-induced conversion (RT-QuIC) assay, have allowed us to diagnose CJD with greater sensitivity and specificity. Previously, the diagnosis rested primarily on a post-mortem brain biopsy. Although advancements in laboratory techniques have allowed earlier diagnosis of CJD, the treatment is still supportive. Research is still ongoing for a curative treatment, but so far, the fatality rate remains at 100%. Early vague symptoms of CJD delay the diagnosis further, as multiple pathologies need to be ruled out before consideration of the diagnosis of CJD. This case report describes a similar case of sporadic CJD diagnosed in an otherwise fit and well patient.

Conversion of Helix 1 into a Loop in Prion Protein Misfolding

Cellular prion protein PrP^C consists of three α-helices, one β-sheet, and an unstructured N-terminal domain. Misfolding of this protein into the scrapie form (PrP^Sc) increases dramatically the β-sheet content. H1 is the most stable helix on PrP^C and contains an unusual number of hydrophilic amino acids. Its fate in PrP^Sc is not clear. We performed replica exchange molecular dynamics simulations on H1 alone, H1 together with an N-terminally flanking H1B1 loop and H1 in complex with other hydrophilic regions of the prion protein. In the presence of the H⁹⁹SQWNKPSKPKTNMK¹¹³ sequence, H1 is almost completely converted to a loop structure stabilized by a network of salt bridges. On the other hand, H1 retains its helical structure alone or together with the other sequences considered in this study. We carried out an additional simulation by restraining the distance between the two ends of H1, mimicking a possible geometric restriction by the rest of the protein. Even though the loop was the major conformation, a significant amount of helical structure was also observed. This suggests that the interaction with H⁹⁹SQWNKPSKPKTNMK¹¹³ is necessary for complete helix-to-loop conversion.

Cellular toxicity of scrapie prions in prion diseases; a biochemical and molecular overview

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) or prion diseases consist of a broad range of fatal neurological disorders affecting humans and animals. Contrary to Watson and Crick's 'central dogma', prion diseases are caused by a protein, devoid of DNA involvement. Herein, we briefly review various cellular and biological aspects of prions and prion pathogenesis focusing mainly on historical milestones, biosynthesis, degradation, structure-function of cellular and scrapie forms of prions .

A Mass Spectrometry-Based Method of Quantifying the Contribution of the Lysine Polymorphism at Position 171 in Sheep PrP

In sheep, the transmissibility and progression of scrapie, a sheep prion (PrPSc) disease, is strongly dependent upon specific amino acid polymorphisms in the natively expressed prion protein (PrPC). Sheep expressing PrPC with lysine (K) polymorphism at position 171 (K171) are partially resistant to oronasal dosing of classical sheep scrapie. In addition, scrapie infected sheep expressing the K171 polymorphism show a longer incubation period compared to sheep homozygous (glutamine (Q)) at position 171. Quantitating the amount of the K171 polymorphism in a sheep scrapie sample can provide important information on the composition of PrPSc. A tryptic peptide, 159R.YPNQVYYRPVDK.Y172, derived from the digestion of 171K recombinant PrP, was identified as an analyte peptide suitable for a multiple reaction monitoring-based analysis. This method, using 15N-labeled analogs and another internal peptide from the proteinase K-resistant core, permits the simultaneous quantitation of the total amount of PrP and the proportion of K171 polymorphism in the sample. Background molecules with similar retention times and transitions were present in samples from scrapie-infected sheep. Proteinase K digestion followed by ultracentrifugation-based isolation or phosphotungstic acid-based isolation were employed to minimize the contribution of those background molecules, making this approach suitable for quantitating the amount of the K171 polymorphism in heterozygous scrapie infected sheep.

Prion assemblies: structural heterogeneity, mechanisms of formation, and role in species barrier

Prions are proteinaceous pathogens responsible for a wide range of neurodegenerative diseases in animal and human. Prions are formed from misfolded, ß-sheet rich, and aggregated conformers (PrPSc) of the host-encoded prion protein (PrPC). Prion replication stems from the capacity of PrPSc to self-replicate by templating PrPC conversion and polymerization. The question then arises about the molecular mechanisms of prion replication, host invasion, and capacity to contaminate other species. Studying these mechanisms has gained in recent years further complexity with evidence that PrPSc is a pleiomorphic protein. There is indeed compelling evidence for PrPSc structural heterogeneity at different scales: (i) within prion susceptible host populations with the existence of different strains with specific biological features due to different PrPSc conformers, (ii) within a single infected host with the co-propagation of different strains, and (iii) within a single strain with evidence for co-propagation of PrPSc assemblies differing in their secondary to quaternary structure. This review summarizes current knowledge of prion assembly heterogeneity, potential mechanisms of formation during the replication process, and importance when crossing the species barrier.

Advances in the understanding of protein misfolding and aggregation through molecular dynamics simulation

Aberrant protein folding known as protein misfolding is counted as one of the striking factors of neurodegenerative diseases. The extensive range of pathologies caused by protein misfolding, aggregation and subsequent accumulation are mainly classified into either gain of function diseases or loss of function diseases. In order to seek for novel strategies for treatment and diagnosis of neurodegenerative diseases, insights into the mechanism of misfolding and aggregation is essential. A comprehensive knowledge on the factors influencing misfolding and aggregation is required as well. An extensive experimental study on protein aggregation is somewhat challenging due to the insoluble and noncrystalline nature of amyloid fibrils. Thus there has been a growing use of computational approaches including Monte Carlo simulation, docking simulation, molecular dynamics simulation in the study of protein misfolding and aggregation. The review presents a discussion on molecular dynamics simulation alone as to how it has emerged as a promising tool in the understanding of protein misfolding and aggregation in general, detailing upon three different aspects considering four misfold prone proteins in particular. It is noticeable that all four proteins considered in this review i.e prion, superoxide dismutase1, huntingtin and amyloid β are linked to chronic neurodegenerative diseases with debilitating effects. Initially the review elaborates on the factors influencing the misfolding and aggregation. Next, it addresses our current understanding of the amyloid structures and the associated aggregation mechanisms, finally, summarizing the contribution of this computational tool in the search for therapeutic strategies against the respective protein-deposition diseases.

Aggregates Sealed by Ions

The chapter draws a line connecting some recent results where the role of ions is found essential in sealing more or less pre-organized assemblies of macromolecules. We draw some dots along the line that starts from the effect of the ionic atmosphere and ends with the chemical bonds formed by multivalent ions acting as bridges between macromolecules. Many of these dots involve structurally disordered peptides and disordered regions of proteins. A broad perspective of the role of multivalent ions in assisting the assembly process, shifting population in polymorphic states, and sealing protein aggregates, is suggested.

Structure of prion β-oligomers as determined by short-distance crosslinking constraint-guided discrete molecular dynamics simulations

The conversion of the native monomeric cellular prion protein (PrP^C ) into an aggregated pathological β-oligomeric form (PrP^β ) and an infectious form (PrP^Sc ) is the central element in the development of prion diseases. The structure of the aggregates and the molecular mechanisms of the conformational changes involved in the conversion are still unknown. We applied mass spectrometry combined with chemical crosslinking, hydrogen/deuterium exchange, limited proteolysis, and surface modification for the differential characterization of the native and the urea+acid-converted prion β-oligomer structures to obtain insights into the mechanisms of conversion and aggregation. For the determination of the structure of the monomer and the dimer unit of the β-oligomer, we applied a recently-developed approach for de novo protein structure determination which is based on the incorporation of zero-length and short-distance crosslinking data as intra- and inter-protein constraints in discrete molecular dynamics simulations (CL-DMD). Based on all of the structural-proteomics experimental data and the computationally predicted structures of the monomer units, we propose the potential mode of assembly of the β-oligomer. The proposed β-oligomer assembly provides a clue on the β-sheet nucleation site, and how template-based conversion of the native prion molecule occurs, growth of the prion aggregates, and maturation into fibrils may occur.

Further Characterization of Glycoform-Selective Prions of Variably Protease-Sensitive Prionopathy

Prion is an infectious protein (PrP^Sc) that is derived from a cellular glycoprotein (PrP^C) through a conformational transition and associated with a group of prion diseases in animals and humans. Characterization of proteinase K (PK)-resistant PrP^Sc by western blotting has been critical to diagnosis and understanding of prion diseases including Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD) and Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker (GSS) disease in humans. However, formation as well as biochemical and biological properties of the glycoform-selective PrP^Sc in variably protease-sensitive prionopathy (VPSPr) remain poorly understood. Here we reveal that formation of the ladder-like PrP^Sc in VPSPr is a PK-dependent two-step process, which is enhanced by basic pH. Two sets of PrP^Sc fragments can be identified with antibodies directed against an intermediate or a C-terminal domain of the protein. Moreover, antibodies directed against specific PrP glycoforms reveal faster electrophoretic migrations of PrP fragments mono-glycosylated at residue 181 and 197 in VPSPr than those in sporadic CJD (sCJD). Finally, RT-QuIC assay indicates that PrP^Sc-seeding activity is lower and its lag time is longer in VPSPr than in sCJD. Our results suggest that the glycoform-selective PrP^Sc in VPSPr is associated with altered glycosylation, resulting in different PK-truncation and aggregation seeding activity compared to PrP^Sc in sCJD.

Electrochemical biosensors for biometal-protein interactions in neurodegenerative diseases

Electrochemical biosensors have been adopted into a wide range of applications in the study of biometal-protein interactions in neurodegenerative diseases. Transition metals such as zinc, copper, and iron that are significant to biological functions have been shown to have strong implications in the progressive neural degeneration in Alzheimer's disease (AD), Parkinson's disease (PD), and prion protein diseases. This review presents a summative examination of the progress made in the design, fabrication, and applications of electrochemical biosensors in recent literature at understanding the metal-protein interactions in neurodegenerative diseases. The focus will be drawn on disease-causing biomarkers such as amyloid-β (Aβ) and tau proteins for AD, α-synuclein (α-syn) for PD, and prion proteins (PrP). Topics such as the use of electrochemical biosensing in monitoring biometal-induced conformational changes, elucidation of complexation motifs, production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) as well as the influence on downstream biomolecular interactions will be discussed. Major results and important concepts presented in these studies will be summarized in the hope to spark inspiration for the next generation of electrochemical sensors.

Cellular prion protein gene polymorphisms linked to differential scrapie susceptibility correlate with distinct residue connectivity between secondary structure elements

The conformational conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) to the misfolded and aggregated isoform, termed scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc), is key to the development of a group of neurodegenerative diseases known as transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs). Although the conversion mechanism is not fully understood, the role of gene polymorphisms in varying susceptibilities to prion diseases is well established. In ovine, specific gene polymorphisms in PrP^C alter prion disease susceptibility: the Valine136-Glutamine171 variant (Susceptible structure) displays high susceptibility to classical scrapie while the Alanine136-Arginine171 variant (Resistant structure) displays reduced susceptibility. The opposite trend has been reported in atypical scrapie. Despite the differentiation between classical and atypical scrapie, a complete understanding of the effect of polymorphisms on the structural dynamics of PrP^C is lacking. From our structural bioinformatics study, we propose that polymorphisms locally modulate the network of residue interactions in the globular C-terminus of the ovine recombinant prion protein while maintaining the overall fold. Although the two variants we examined exhibit a densely connected group of residues that includes both β-sheets, the β2-α2 loop and the N-terminus of α-helix 2, only in the Resistant structure do most residues of α-helix 2 belong to this group. We identify the structural role of Valine136Alanine and Glutamine171Arginine: modulation of residue interaction networks that affect the connectivity between α-helix 2 and α-helix 3. We propose blocking interactions of residue 171 as a potential target for the design of therapeutics to prevent efficient PrP^C misfolding. We discuss our results in the context of initial PrP^C conversion and extrapolate to recently proposed PrP^Sc structures.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Development and structural determination of an anti-PrPC aptamer that blocks pathological conformational conversion of prion protein

Prion diseases comprise a fatal neuropathy caused by the conversion of prion protein from a cellular (PrP^C) to a pathological (PrP^Sc) isoform. Previously, we obtained an RNA aptamer, r(GGAGGAGGAGGA) (R12), that folds into a unique G-quadruplex. The R12 homodimer binds to a PrP^C molecule, inhibiting PrP^C-to-PrP^Sc conversion. Here, we developed a new RNA aptamer, r(GGAGGAGGAGGAGGAGGAGGAGGA) (R24), where two R12s are tandemly connected. The 50% inhibitory concentration for the formation of PrP^Sc (IC₅₀) of R24 in scrapie-infected cell lines was ca. 100 nM, i.e., much lower than that of R12 by two orders. Except for some antibodies, R24 exhibited the lowest recorded IC₅₀ and the highest anti-prion activity. We also developed a related aptamer, r(GGAGGAGGAGGA-A-GGAGGAGGAGGA) (R12-A-R12), IC₅₀ being ca. 500 nM. The structure of a single R12-A-R12 molecule determined by NMR resembled that of the R12 homodimer. The quadruplex structure of either R24 or R12-A-R12 is unimolecular, and therefore the structure could be stably formed when they are administered to a prion-infected cell culture. This may be the reason they can exert high anti-prion activity.

RhoA/ROCK Regulates Prion Pathogenesis by Controlling Connexin 43 Activity

Scrapie infection, which converts cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into the pathological and infectious isoform (PrP^Sc), leads to neuronal cell death, glial cell activation and PrP^Sc accumulation. Previous studies reported that PrP^C regulates RhoA/Rho-associated kinase (ROCK) signaling and that connexin 43 (Cx43) expression is upregulated in in vitro and in vivo prion-infected models. However, whether there is a link between RhoA/ROCK and Cx43 in prion disease pathogenesis is uncertain. Here, we investigated the role of RhoA/ROCK signaling and Cx43 in prion diseases using in vitro and in vivo models. Scrapie infection induced RhoA activation, accompanied by increased phosphorylation of LIM kinase 1/2 (LIMK1/2) at Thr508/Thr505 and cofilin at Ser3 and reduced phosphorylation of RhoA at Ser188 in hippocampal neuronal cells and brains of mice. Scrapie infection-induced RhoA activation also resulted in PrP^Sc accumulation followed by a reduction in the interaction between RhoA and p190RhoGAP (a GTPase-activating protein). Interestingly, scrapie infection significantly enhanced the interaction between RhoA and Cx43. Moreover, RhoA and Cx43 colocalization was more visible in both the membrane and cytoplasm of scrapie-infected hippocampal neuronal cells than in controls. Finally, RhoA and ROCK inhibition reduced PrP^Sc accumulation and the RhoA/Cx43 interaction, leading to decreased Cx43 hemichannel activity in scrapie-infected hippocampal neuronal cells. These findings suggest that RhoA/ROCK regulates Cx43 activity, which may have an important role in the pathogenesis of prion disease.

Deciphering Copper Coordination in the Mammalian Prion Protein Amyloidogenic Domain

Prions are pathological isoforms of the cellular prion protein that is responsible for transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE). Cellular prion protein interacts with copper, Cu(II), through octarepeat and nonoctarepeat (non-OR) binding sites. The molecular details of Cu(II) coordination within the non-OR region are not well characterized yet. By the means of small angle x-ray scattering and x-ray absorption spectroscopic methods, we have investigated the effect of Cu(II) on prion protein folding and its coordination geometries when bound to the non-OR region of recombinant prion proteins (recPrP) from mammalian species considered resistant or susceptible to TSE. As the prion resistant model, we used ovine recPrP (OvPrP) carrying the protective polymorphism at residues A136, R154, and R171, whereas as TSE-susceptible models, we employed OvPrP with V136, R154, and Q171 polymorphism and bank vole recPrP. Our analysis reveals that Cu(II) affects the structural plasticity of the non-OR region, leading to a more compacted conformation. We then identified two Cu(II) coordination geometries: in the type 1 coordination observed in OvPrP at residues A136, R154, and R171, the metal is coordinated by four residues; conversely, the type 2 coordination is present in OvPrP with V136, R154, and Q171 and bank vole recPrP, where Cu(II) is coordinated by three residues and by one water molecule, making the non-OR region more exposed to the solvent. These changes in copper coordination affect the recPrP amyloid aggregation. This study may provide new insights into the molecular mechanisms governing the resistance or susceptibility of certain species to TSE.

Structural evidence for the critical role of the prion protein hydrophobic region in forming an infectious prion

Prion or PrPSc is the proteinaceous infectious agent causing prion diseases in various mammalian species. Despite decades of research, the structural basis for PrPSc formation and prion infectivity remains elusive. To understand the role of the hydrophobic region in forming infectious prion at the molecular level, we report X-ray crystal structures of mouse (Mo) prion protein (PrP) (residues 89-230) in complex with a nanobody (Nb484). Using the recombinant prion propagation system, we show that the binding of Nb484 to the hydrophobic region of MoPrP efficiently inhibits the propagation of proteinase K resistant PrPSc and prion infectivity. In addition, when added to cultured mouse brain slices in high concentrations, Nb484 exhibits no neurotoxicity, which is drastically different from other neurotoxic anti-PrP antibodies, suggesting that the Nb484 can be a potential therapeutic agent against prion disease. In summary, our data provides the first structure-function evidence supporting a crucial role of the hydrophobic region of PrP in forming an infectious prion.

Transition of the prion protein from a structured cellular form (PrPC ) to the infectious scrapie agent (PrPSc )

Prion diseases in mammals are caused by a conformational transition of the cellular prion protein from its native conformation (PrP^C ) to a pathological isoform called "prion protein scrapie" (PrP^Sc ). A molecular level of understanding of this conformational transition will be helpful in unveiling the disease etiology. Experimental structural biological techniques (NMR and X-ray crystallography) have been used to unravel the atomic level structural information for the prion and its binding partners. More than one hundred three-dimensional structures of the mammalian prions have been deposited in the protein databank. Structural studies on the prion protein and its structural transitions will deepen our understanding of the molecular basis of prion pathogenesis and will provide valuable guidance for future structure-based drug discovery endeavors.

Biomechanistic insights into the roles of oxidative stress in generating complex neurological disorders

Neurological diseases like Alzheimer's disease, epilepsy, parkinsonism, depression, Huntington's disease and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis prevailing globally are considered to be deeply influenced by oxidative stress-based changes in the biochemical settings of the organs. The excess oxygen concentration triggers the production of reactive oxygen species, and even the intrinsic antioxidant enzyme system, i.e. SOD, CAT and GSHPx, fails to manage their levels and keep them under desirable limits. This consequently leads to oxidation of protein, lipids and nucleic acids in the brain resulting in apoptosis, proteopathy, proteasomes and mitochondrion dysfunction, glial cell activation as well as neuroinflammation. The present exploration deals with the evidence-based mechanism of oxidative stress towards development of key neurological diseases along with the involved biomechanistics and biomaterials.

Membrane interaction of off-pathway prion oligomers and lipid-induced on-pathway intermediates during prion conversion: A clue for neurotoxicity

Soluble oligomers of prion proteins (PrP), produced during amyloid aggregation, have emerged as the primary neurotoxic species, instead of the fibrillar end-products, in transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. However, whether the membrane is among their direct targets, that mediate the downstream adverse effects, remains a question of debate. Recently, questions arise from the formation of membrane-active oligomeric species generated during the β-aggregation pathway, either in solution, or in lipid environment. In the present study, we characterized membrane interaction of off-pathway oligomers from recombinant prion protein generated along the amyloid aggregation and compared to lipid-induced intermediates produced during lipid-accelerated fibrillation. Using calcein-leakage assay, we show that the soluble prion oligomers are the most potent in producing leakage with negatively charged vesicles. Binding affinities, conformational states, mode of action of the different PrP assemblies were determined by thioflavin T binding-static light scattering experiments on DOPC/DOPS vesicles, as well as by FTIR-ATR spectroscopy and specular neutron reflectivity onto the corresponding supported lipid bilayers. Our results indicate that the off-pathway PrP oligomers interact with lipid membrane via a distinct mechanism, compared to the inserted lipid-induced intermediates. Thus, separate neurotoxic mechanisms could exist following the puzzling intermediates generated in the different cell compartments. These results not only reveal an important regulation of lipid membrane on PrP behavior but may also provide clues for designing stage-specific and prion-targeted therapy.

The cellular and pathologic prion protein

The cellular prion protein, PrP^C, is a small, cell surface glycoprotein with a function that is currently somewhat ill defined. It is also the key molecule involved in the family of neurodegenerative disorders called transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, which are also known as prion diseases. The misfolding of PrP^C to a conformationally altered isoform, designated PrP^TSE, is the main molecular process involved in pathogenesis and appears to precede many other pathologic and clinical manifestations of disease, including neuronal loss, astrogliosis, and cognitive loss. PrP^TSE is also believed to be the major component of the infectious "prion," the agent responsible for disease transmission, and preparations of this protein can cause prion disease when inoculated into a naïve host. Thus, understanding the biochemical and biophysical properties of both PrP^C and PrP^TSE, and ultimately the mechanisms of their interconversion, is critical if we are to understand prion disease biology. Although entire books could be devoted to research pertaining to the protein, herein we briefly review the state of knowledge of prion biochemistry, including consideration of prion protein structure, function, misfolding, and dysfunction.

Antibody-Mediated Catalysis in Infection and Immunity

The existence of catalytic antibodies has been known for decades. Natural antibodies capable of cleaving nucleic acid, protein, and polysaccharide substrates have been described. Although the discovery of catalytic antibodies initially aroused great interest because of their promise for the development of new catalysts, their enzymatic performance has been disappointing due to low reaction rates. However, in the areas of infection and immunity, where processes often occur over much longer times and involve high antibody concentrations, even low catalytic rates have the potential to influence biological outcomes. In this regard, the presence of catalytic antibodies recognizing host antigens has been associated with several autoimmune diseases. Furthermore, naturally occurring catalytic antibodies to microbial determinants have been correlated with resistance to infection. Recently, there has been substantial interest in harnessing the power of antibody-mediated catalysis against microbial antigens for host defense. Additional work is needed, however, to better understand the prevalence, function, and structural basis of catalytic activity in antibodies. Here we review the available information and suggest that antibody-mediated catalysis is a fertile area for study with broad applications in infection and immunity.

Monitoring Conformational Landscape of Ovine Prion Protein Monomer Using Ion Mobility Coupled to Mass Spectrometry

Prion protein is involved in deadly neurodegenerative diseases. Its pathogenicity is linked to its structural conversion (α-helix to β-strand transition). However, recent studies suggest that prion protein can follow a plurality of conversion pathways, which hints towards different conformers that might coexist in solution. To gain insights on the plasticity of the ovine prion protein (PrP) monomer, wild type (A136, R154, Q171), mutants and deletions of ARQ were studied by traveling wave ion mobility experiments coupled to mass spectrometry. In order to perform the analysis of a large body of data sets, we designed and evaluated the performance of a processing pipeline based on Driftscope peak detection and a homemade script for automated peak assignment, annotation, and quantification on specific multiply charged protein data. Using this approach, we showed that in the gas phase, PrPs are represented by at least three conformer families differing in both charge state distribution and collisional cross-section, in agreement with the work of Hilton et al. (2010). We also showed that this plasticity is borne both by the N- and C-terminal domains. Effect of protein concentration, pH and temperature were also assessed, showing that (1) pH does not affect conformer distributions, (2) protein concentration modifies the conformational landscape of one mutant (I208M) only, and (3) heating leads to other unfolded species and to a modification of the conformer intensity ratios. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Mechanism of Unfolding of Human Prion Protein

Misfolding and aggregation of prion proteins are associated with several neurodegenerative diseases. Therefore, understanding the mechanism of the misfolding process is of enormous interest in the scientific community. It has been speculated and widely discussed that the native cellular prion protein (PrP^C) form needs to undergo substantial unfolding to a more stable PrP^C* state, which may further oligomerize into the toxic scrapie (PrP^Sc) form. Here, we have studied the mechanism of the unfolding of the human prion protein (huPrP) using a set of extensive well-tempered metadynamics simulations. Through multiple microsecond-long metadynamics simulations, we find several possible unfolding pathways. We show that each pathway leads to an unfolded state of lower free energy than the native state. Thus, our study may point to the signature of a PrP^C* form that corresponds to a global minimum on the conformational free-energy landscape. Moreover, we find that these global minima states do not involve an increased β-sheet content, as was assumed to be a signature of PrP^Sc formation in previous simulation studies. We have further analyzed the origin of metastability of the PrP^C form through free-energy surfaces of the chopped helical segments to show that the helices, particularly H2 and H3 of the prion protein, have the tendency to form either a random coil or a β-structure. Therefore, the secondary structural elements of the prion protein are only weakly stabilized by tertiary contacts and solvation forces so that relatively weak perturbations induced by temperature, pressure, pH, and so forth can lead to substantial unfolding with characteristics of intrinsically disordered proteins.

The folding mechanism and key metastable state identification of the PrP127–147 monomer studied by molecular dynamics simulations and Markov state model analysis

MD simulation combined with MSM analysis was employed to investigate the structural dynamics and the folding mechanism of the key fragment 127–147 monomer of prion protein.

Conformational selection in amyloid-based immunotherapy: Survey of crystal structures of antibody-amyloid complexes

BACKGROUND

The dominant feature in neurodegenerative diseases is protein aggregations that lead to neuronal loss. Immunotherapies using antibodies or antibody fragments to target the aggregations are a highly perused approach. The molecular mechanisms underlying the amyloid-based immunotherapy are complex. Deciphering the properties of amyloidogenic proteins responsible for these diseases is essential to obtain insights into antibody recognition of the amyloid antigens.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

We systematically explore all available crystal structures of antibody-amyloid complexes related to neurodegenerative diseases, including antibodies that recognize the Aβ peptide, tau protein, prion protein, alpha-synuclein, huntingtin protein (mHTT), and polyglutamine.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

We found that antibodies mostly use the conformational selection mechanism to recognize the highly flexible amyloid antigens. In particular, solanezumab bound to Aβ12-28 tripeptide motif conformation (F19F20A21), which is shared with the Aβ42 fibril. This motif, which is trapped by the antibody, may provide the missing link in amyloid formation. Water molecules often bridge between the antibody and amyloid, contributing to the recognition.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

This paper provides the structural basis for antibody recognition of amyloidogenic proteins. The analysis and discussion of known structures are expected to help in the design and optimization of antibodies in neurodegenerative diseases. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled "System Genetics" Guest Editor: Dr. Yudong Cai and Dr. Tao Huang.

Recent trends in the transdermal delivery of therapeutic agents used for the management of neurodegenerative diseases

With the increasing proportion of the global geriatric population, it becomes obvious that neurodegenerative diseases will become more widespread. From an epidemiological standpoint, it is necessary to develop new therapeutic agents for the management of Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, multiple sclerosis and other neurodegenerative disorders. An important approach in this regard involves the use of the transdermal route. With transdermal drug delivery systems (TDDS), it is possible to modulate the pharmacokinetic profiles of these medications and improve patient compliance. Transdermal drug delivery has also been shown to be useful for drugs with short half-life and low or unpredictable bioavailability. In this review, several transdermal drug delivery enhancement technologies are being discussed in relation to the delivery of medications used for the management of neurodegenerative disorders.

Identification of amino acid variation in the prion protein associated with classical scrapie in Canadian dairy goats

BACKGROUND

A clear association of amino acid variation in the prion protein gene (PRNP) with susceptibility and resistance to classical scrapie exists in sheep, but not in goats. In this study we examined DNA sequence variation in the PRNP of 149 animals from two scrapie-infected herds of Saanen dairy goats, and identified 6 non-synonymous variants in the coding region.

RESULTS

In the larger herd, all of the 54 scrapie-affected goats tested had at least one allele with the arginine (R) codon at position 211, with 52 being homozygous for that variant. No animal homozygous for the glutamine (Q) codon at 211 were affected and only two heterozygotes (R/Q) were affected. A weak association was found at position 146 and no significant associations were found with amino acid variation at the remaining four variant positions (142, 143, 222 and 240), however, the allelic variation was low. Similar patterns were observed in the second scrapie-affected herd.

CONCLUSION

We also evaluated previous studies on goat herds affected with scrapie and this relationship of R susceptibility and Q resistance at 211 was present independent of the genotypes at the other positions including 222. The fact that glutamine at 211 provides a significant protective property to scrapie irrespective of the other positions could be important for breeding strategies aimed at improving herd resistance to scrapie, while maintaining important productivity traits.

Progress towards structural understanding of infectious sheep PrP-amyloid

The still elusive structural difference of non-infectious and infectious amyloid of the mammalian prion protein (PrP) is a major pending milestone in understanding protein-mediated infectivity in neurodegenerative diseases. Preparations of PrP-amyloid proven to be infectious have never been investigated with a high-resolution technique. All available models to date have been based on low-resolution data. Here, we establish protocols for the preparation of infectious samples of full-length recombinant (rec) PrP-amyloid in NMR-sufficient amounts by spontaneous fibrillation and seeded fibril growth from brain extract. We link biological and structural data of infectious recPrP-amyloid, derived from bioassays, atomic force microscopy, and solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Our data indicate a semi-mobile N-terminus, some residues with secondary chemical shifts typical of α-helical secondary structure in the middle part between ∼115 to ∼155, and a distinct β-sheet core C-terminal of residue ∼155. These findings are not in agreement with all current models for PrP-amyloid. We also provide evidence that samples seeded from brain extract may not differ in the overall arrangement of secondary structure elements, but rather in the flexibility of protein segments outside the β-core region. Taken together, our protocols provide an essential basis for the high-resolution characterization of non-infectious and infectious PrP-amyloid in the near future.

Free energy and hidden barriers of the β-sheet structure of prion protein

On-the-fly free-energy parametrization is a new collective variable biasing approach akin to metadynamics with one important distinction: rather than acquiring an accelerated distribution via a history-dependent bias potential, sampling on this distribution is achieved from the beginning of the simulation using temperature-accelerated molecular dynamics. In the present work, we compare the performance of both approaches to compute the free-energy profile along a scalar collective variable measuring the H-bond registry of the β-sheet structure of the mouse Prion protein. Both methods agree on the location of the free-energy minimum, but free-energy profiles from well-tempered metadynamics are subject to a much higher degree of statistical noise due to hidden barriers. The sensitivity of metadynamics to hidden barriers is shown to be a consequence of the history dependence of the bias potential, and we detail the nature of these barriers for the prion β-sheet. In contrast, on-the-fly parametrization is much less sensitive to these barriers and thus displays improved convergence behavior relative to that of metadynamics. While hidden barriers are a frequent and central issue in free-energy methods, on-the-fly free-energy parametrization appears to be a robust and preferable method to confront this issue.

Evaluation of infective property of recombinant prion protein amyloids in cultured cells overexpressing cellular prion protein

Misfolded isoform of prion protein (PrP), termed scrapie PrP (PrP(Sc)), tends to aggregate into various fibril forms. Previously, we reported various conditions that affect aggregation of recombinant PrP into amyloids. Because amyloidogenesis of PrP is closely associated with transmissible spongiform encephalopathies such as Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans, we investigated infectivity of recombinant PrP amyloids generated in vitro. Using cultured cell lines which overexpress cellular PrP of different species, we measured the level of de novo synthesized PrP(Sc) in cells inoculated with recombinant mouse PrP amyloids. While PrP-overexpressing cells were susceptible to mouse-adapted scrapie prions used as the positive control, demonstrating the species barrier effect, infection with amyloids made of truncated recombinant PrP (PrP[89-230]) failed to form and propagate PrP(Sc) even in the cells that express mouse cellular PrP. This suggests that infectivity of PrP amyloids generated in vitro is different from that of natural prions. Recombinant PrP (89-230) amyloids tested in the current study retain no or a minute level, if any, of prion infectivity.

Polymorphisms at amino acid residues 141 and 154 influence conformational variation in ovine PrP

Polymorphisms in ovine PrP at amino acid residues 141 and 154 are associated with susceptibility to ovine prion disease: Leu141Arg154 with classical scrapie and Phe141Arg154 and Leu141His154 with atypical scrapie. Classical scrapie is naturally transmissible between sheep, whereas this may not be the case with atypical scrapie. Critical amino acid residues will determine the range or stability of structural changes within the ovine prion protein or its functional interaction with potential cofactors, during conversion of PrPC to PrPSc in these different forms of scrapie disease. Here we computationally identified that regions of ovine PrP, including those near amino acid residues 141 and 154, displayed more conservation than expected based on local structural environment. Molecular dynamics simulations showed these conserved regions of ovine PrP displayed genotypic differences in conformational repertoire and amino acid side-chain interactions. Significantly, Leu141Arg154 PrP adopted an extended beta sheet arrangement in the N-terminal palindromic region more frequently than the Phe141Arg154 and Leu141His154 variants. We supported these computational observations experimentally using circular dichroism spectroscopy and immunobiochemical studies on ovine recombinant PrP. Collectively, our observations show amino acid residues 141 and 154 influence secondary structure and conformational change in ovine PrP that may correlate with different forms of scrapie.

Structural plasticity of the cellular prion protein and implications in health and disease

Two lines of transgenic mice expressing mouse/elk and mouse/horse prion protein (PrP) hybrids, which both form a well-structured β2-α2 loop in the NMR structures at 20 °C termed rigid-loop cellular prion proteins (RL-PrP(C)), presented with accumulation of the aggregated scrapie form of PrP in brain tissue, and the mouse/elk hybrid has also been shown to develop a spontaneous transmissible spongiform encephalopathy. Independently, there is in vitro evidence for correlations between the amino acid sequence in the β2-α2 loop and the propensity for conformational transitions to disease-related forms of PrP. To further contribute to the structural basis for these observations, this paper presents a detailed characterization of RL-PrP(C) conformations in solution. A dynamic local conformational polymorphism involving the β2-α2 loop was found to be evolutionarily preserved among all mammalian species, including those species for which the WT PrP forms an RL-PrP(C). The interconversion between two ensembles of PrP(C) conformers that contain, respectively, a 310-helix turn or a type I β-turn structure of the β2-α2 loop, exposes two different surface epitopes, which are analyzed for their possible roles in the still evasive function of PrP(C) in healthy organisms and/or at the onset of a transmissible spongiform encephalopathy.

Immunotherapeutic approaches in prion disease: progress, challenges and potential directions

Therapeutic trials utilizing animal models of prion disease have explored a variety of compounds and a number of approaches with varying success, including several immunotherapeutic strategies, such as passive immunization through the delivery of viruses carrying nucleic acid inserts encoding prion protein-specific immunoglobulin. Targeted, organ-specific cellular production of therapeutic proteins is a relatively unexplored approach in the treatment of neurodegeneration despite many successful experimental outcomes in animal models and human trials of other diseases of the CNS. Emphasizing studies utilizing mouse models of disease, this review outlines developments and limitations of immunological approaches to the treatment of prion diseases. In addition, the authors discuss the potential of an experimental therapeutic strategy, utilizing hybridoma cells injected directly into the CNS to establish long-term production of anti-prion antibodies in vivo within the organ associated with the greatest pathogenic change in prion disease, the brain.

Mammalian prions: tolerance to sequence changes-how far?

Upon prion infection, abnormal prion protein (PrP (Sc) ) self-perpetuate by conformational conversion of α-helix-rich PrP (C) into β sheet enriched form, leading to formation and deposition of PrP (Sc) aggregates in affected brains. However the process remains poorly understood at the molecular level and the regions of PrP critical for conversion are still debated. Minimal amino acid substitutions can impair prion replication at many places in PrP. Conversely, we recently showed that bona fide prions could be generated after introduction of eight and up to 16 additional amino acids in the H2-H3 inter-helix loop of PrP. Prion replication also accommodated the insertions of an octapeptide at different places in the last turns of H2. This reverse genetic approach reveals an unexpected tolerance of prions to substantial sequence changes in the protease-resistant part which is associated with infectivity. It also demonstrates that conversion does not require the presence of a specific sequence in the middle of the H2-H3 area. We discuss the implications of our findings according to different structural models proposed for PrP (Sc) and questioned the postulated existence of an N- or C-terminal prion domain in the protease-resistant region.

Structural studies on the folded domain of the human prion protein bound to the Fab fragment of the antibody POM1

Prion diseases are neurodegenerative diseases characterized by the conversion of the cellular prion protein PrP(c) into a pathogenic isoform PrP(sc). Passive immunization with antiprion monoclonal antibodies can arrest the progression of prion diseases. Here, the crystal structure of the Fab fragment of an antiprion monoclonal antibody, POM1, in complex with human prion protein (huPrP(c)) has been determined to 2.4 Å resolution. The prion epitope of POM1 is in close proximity to the epitope recognized by the purportedly therapeutic antibody fragment ICSM18 Fab in complex with huPrP(c). POM1 Fab forms a 1:1 complex with huPrP(c) and the measured K(d) of 4.5 × 10(-7) M reveals moderately strong binding between them. Structural comparisons have been made among three prion-antibody complexes: POM1 Fab-huPrP(c), ICSM18 Fab-huPrP(c) and VRQ14 Fab-ovPrP(c). The prion epitopes recognized by ICSM18 Fab and VRQ14 Fab are adjacent to a prion glycosylation site, indicating possible steric hindrance and/or an altered binding mode to the glycosylated prion protein in vivo. However, both of the glycosylation sites on huPrP(c) are positioned away from the POM1 Fab binding epitope; thus, the binding mode observed in this crystal structure and the binding affinity measured for this antibody are most likely to be the same as those for the native prion protein in vivo.

Structural analysis of a protective epitope of the Francisella tularensis O-polysaccharide

Francisella tularensis (Ft), the Gram-negative facultative intracellular bacterium that causes tularemia, is considered a biothreat because of its high infectivity and the high mortality rate of respiratory disease. The Ft lipopolysaccharide (Ft LPS) is thought to be a main protective antigen in mice and humans, and we have previously demonstrated the protective effect of the Ft LPS-specific monoclonal antibody Ab52 in a mouse model of respiratory tularemia. Immunochemical characterization has shown that the epitope recognized by Ab52 is contained within two internal repeat units of the O-polysaccharide [O-antigen (OAg)] of Ft LPS. To further localize the Ab52 epitope and understand the molecular interactions between the antibody and the saccharide, we determined the X-ray crystal structure of the Fab fragment of Ab52 and derived an antibody-antigen complex using molecular docking. The docked complex, refined through energy minimization, reveals an antigen binding site in the shape of a large canyon with a central pocket that accommodates a V-shaped epitope consisting of six sugar residues, α-D-GalpNAcAN(1→4)-α-D-GalpNAcAN(1→3)-β-D-QuipNAc(1→2)-β-D-Quip4NFm(1→4)-α-D-GalpNAcAN(1→4)-α-D-GalpNAcAN. These results inform the development of vaccines and immunotherapeutic/immunoprophylactic antibodies against Ft by suggesting a desired topology for binding of the antibody to internal epitopes of Ft LPS. This is the first report of an X-ray crystal structure of a monoclonal antibody that targets a protective Ft B cell epitope.

Exploring the essential collective dynamics of interacting proteins: application to prion protein dimers

Essential collective dynamics is a promising and robust approach for analysing the slow motions of macromolecules from short molecular dynamics trajectories. In this study, an extension of the method to treat a collection of interacting protein molecules is presented. The extension is applied to investigate the effects of dimerization on the collective dynamics of ovine prion protein molecules in two different arrangements. Examination of the structural plasticity shows that aggregation has a restricting effect on the local mobility of the prion protein molecules in the interfacial regions. Domain motions of the two dimeric ovine prion protein conformations are distinctly different and can be related to interatomic correlations at the interface. Correlated motions are among the slow collective modes extensively analysed by considering both main-chain and side-chain atoms. Correlation maps reveal the existence of a vast network of dynamically correlated side groups, which extends beyond individual subunits via interfacial interconnections. The network is formed by a core of hydrophobic side chains surrounded by hydrophilic groups at the periphery. The relevance of these findings are discussed in the context of mutations associated with prion diseases. The binding free energy of the dimeric conformations is evaluated to probe their thermodynamic stability. The descriptions afforded by the analysis of the essential collective dynamics of the prion dimers are consistent with their binding free energies. The agreement validates the extension of the methodology and provides a means of interpreting the collective dynamics in terms of the thermodynamic stability of ovine prion proteins.

Integrity of helix 2-helix 3 domain of the PrP protein is not mandatory for prion replication

The process of prion conversion is not yet well understood at the molecular level. The regions critical for the conformational change of PrP remain mostly debated and the extent of sequence change acceptable for prion conversion is poorly documented. To achieve progress on these issues, we applied a reverse genetic approach using the Rov cell system. This allowed us to test the susceptibility of a number of insertion mutants to conversion into prion in the absence of wild-type PrP molecules. We were able to propagate several prions with 8 to 16 extra amino acids, including a polyglycine stretch and His or FLAG tags, inserted in the middle of the protease-resistant fragment. These results demonstrate the possibility to increase the length of the loop between helices H2 and H3 up to 4-fold, without preventing prion replication. They also indicate that this loop probably remains unstructured in PrP(Sc). We also showed that bona fide prions can be produced following insertion of octapeptides in the two C-terminal turns of H2. These insertions do not interfere with the overall fold of the H2-H3 domain indicating that the highly conserved sequence of the terminal part of H2 is not critical for the conversion. Altogether these data showed that the amplitude of modifications acceptable for prion conversion in the core of the globular domain of PrP is much greater than one might have assumed. These observations should help to refine structural models of PrP(Sc) and elucidate the conformational changes underlying prions generation.

Disruption of the X-loop turn of the prion protein linked to scrapie resistance

The prion diseases are a class of neurodegenerative diseases caused by the misfolding and aggregation of the prion protein (PrP(C)) into toxic and infectious oligomers (PrP(Sc)). These oligomers are critical to understanding and combating these diseases. Differences in the sequence of PrP affect disease susceptibility, likely by shifting the tolerance of the protein for adaptation to PrP(Sc) conformations and/or the recognition event between PrP(Sc) and PrP(C) prior to conversion of the PrP(C). We selected two sets of PrP(Sc)-resistant mutant sequences for solvated atomistic molecular dynamics simulation to investigate the structural basis of resistance. The first group involved mutation in the X-loop (residues 164-171) resulting from selective breeding of sheep. The second group included eight mutants in mice identified by random mutagenesis targeting helix C followed by screening in cell cultures. Multiple simulations were performed of 14 different mutant and control constructs under different pH conditions for a total of 3.6 μs of simulation time. The X-loop formed a stable turn at neutral pH in wild-type PrP from both species. PrP(Sc)-resistant mutations disrupted this turn even though only one of the mutants is in the X-loop. The X-loop is compact and buried in our previously described spiral models of PrP(Sc)-like oligomers. On the basis of the findings presented here and in the context of the spiral oligomer model, we propose that expansion of the X-loop disrupts protofibril packing, providing a structural basis for resistance.

Characterization of spontaneously generated prion-like conformers in cultured cells

A distinct conformational transition from the α-helix-rich cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into its β-sheet-rich pathological isoform (PrP^Sc) is the hallmark of prion diseases, a group of fatal transmissible encephalopathies that includes spontaneous and acquired forms. Recently, a PrP^Sc-like intermediate form characterized by the formation of insoluble aggregates and protease-resistant PrP species termed insoluble PrP^C (iPrP^C) has been identified in uninfected mammalian brains and cultured neuronal cells, providing new insights into the molecular mechanism(s) of these diseases. Here, we explore the molecular characteristics of the spontaneously formed iPrP^C in cultured neuroblastoma cells expressing wild-type or mutant human PrP linked to two familial prion diseases. We observed that although PrP mutation at either residue 183 from Thr to Ala (PrP^T183A) or at residue 198 from Phe to Ser (PrP^F198S) affects glycosylation at both N-linked glycosylation sites, the T183A mutation that results in intracellular retention significantly increased the formation of iPrP^C. Moreover, while autophagy is increased in F198S cells, it was significantly decreased in T183A cells. Our results indicate that iPrP^C may be formed more readily in an intracellular compartment and that a significant increase in PrP^T183A aggregation may be attributable to the inhibition of autophagy.

Microsecond unfolding kinetics of sheep prion protein reveals an intermediate that correlates with susceptibility to classical scrapie

The microsecond folding and unfolding kinetics of ovine prion proteins (ovPrP) were measured under various solution conditions. A fragment comprising residues 94-233 of the full-length ovPrP was studied for four variants with differing susceptibilities to classical scrapie in sheep. The observed biexponential unfolding kinetics of ovPrP provides evidence for an intermediate species. However, in contrast to previous results for human PrP, there is no evidence for an intermediate under refolding conditions. Global analysis of the kinetic data, based on a sequential three-state mechanism, quantitatively accounts for all folding and unfolding data as a function of denaturant concentration. The simulations predict that an intermediate accumulates under both folding and unfolding conditions, but is observable only in unfolding experiments because the intermediate is optically indistinguishable from the native state. The relative population of intermediates in two ovPrP variants, both transiently and under destabilizing equilibrium conditions, correlates with their propensities for classical scrapie. The variant susceptible to classical scrapie has a larger population of the intermediate state than the resistant variant. Thus, the susceptible variant should be favored to undergo the PrP(C) to PrP(Sc) conversion and oligomerization.

Prion protein self-interaction in prion disease therapy approaches

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) or prion diseases are unique disorders that are not caused by infectious micro-organisms (bacteria or fungi), viruses or parasites, but rather seem to be the result of an infectious protein. TSEs are comprised of fatal neurodegenerative disorders affecting both human and animals. Prion diseases cause sponge-like degeneration of neuronal tissue and include (among others) Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease in humans, bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in cattle and scrapie in sheep. TSEs are characterized by the formation and accumulation of transmissible (infectious) disease-associated protease-resistant prion protein (PrP(Sc)), mainly in tissues of the central nervous system. The exact molecular processes behind the conversion of PrP(C) into PrP(Sc) are not clearly understood. Correlations between prion protein polymorphisms and disease have been found, however in what way these polymorphisms influence the conversion processes remains an enigma; is stabilization or destabilization of the prion protein the basis for a higher conversion propensity? Apart from the disease-associated polymorphisms of the prion protein, the molecular processes underlying conversion are not understood. There are some notions as to which regions of the prion protein are involved in refolding of PrP(C) into PrP(Sc) and where the most drastic structural changes take place. Direct interactions between PrP(C) molecules and/or PrP(Sc) are likely at the basis of conversion, however which specific amino acid domains are involved and to what extent these domains contribute to conversion resistance/sensitivity of the prion protein or the species barrier is still unknown.