Localized Derepression on the Human Inactive X Chromosone in Mouse-Human Cell Hybrids

The lesser known story of X chromosome reactivation: a closer look into the reprogramming of the inactive X chromosome

X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) is an important mechanism employed by mammalian XX female cells to level X-linked gene expression with that of male XY cells. XCI occurs early in development as the pluripotent cells of the inner cell mass (ICM) in blastocysts successively differentiate into cells of all three germ layers. X-chromosome reactivation (XCR), the reversal of XCI, is critical for germ cell formation as a mechanism to diversify the X-chromosome gene pool. Here we review the characterization of XCR, and further explore its natural occurrence during development and the in vitro models of cellular reprogramming. We also review the key regulators involved in XCI for their role in suppressing the active histone marks and the genes in the active chromosome for their inhibition of X inactivation signals.

A first-generation X-inactivation profile of the human X chromosome

In females, most genes on the X chromosome are generally assumed to be transcriptionally silenced on the inactive X as a result of X inactivation. However, particularly in humans, an increasing number of genes are known to "escape" X inactivation and are expressed from both the active (Xa) and inactive (Xi) X chromosomes; such genes reflect different molecular and epigenetic responses to X inactivation and are candidates for phenotypes associated with X aneuploidy. To identify genes that escape X inactivation and to generate a first-generation X-inactivation profile of the X, we have evaluated the expression of 224 X-linked genes and expressed sequence tags by reverse-transcription-PCR analysis of a panel of multiple independent mouse/human somatic cell hybrids containing a normal human Xi but no Xa. The resulting survey yields an initial X-inactivation profile that is estimated to represent approximately 10% of all X-linked transcripts. Of the 224 transcripts tested here, 34 (three of which are pseudoautosomal) were expressed in as many as nine Xi hybrids and thus appear to escape inactivation. The genes that escape inactivation are distributed nonrandomly along the X; 31 of 34 such transcripts map to Xp, implying that the two arms of the X are epigenetically and/or evolutionarily distinct and suggesting that genetic imbalance of Xp may be more severe clinically than imbalance of Xq. A complete X-inactivation profile will provide information relevant to clinical genetics and genetic counseling and should yield insight into the genomic and epigenetic organization of the X chromosome.

Polymorphic X-chromosome inactivation of the human TIMP1 gene

X inactivation silences most but not all of the genes on one of the two X chromosomes in mammalian females. The human X chromosome preserves its activation status when isolated in rodent/human somatic-cell hybrids, and hybrids retaining either the active or inactive X chromosome have been used to assess the inactivation status of many X-linked genes. Surprisingly, the X-linked gene for human tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases (TIMP1) is expressed in some but not all inactive X-containing somatic-cell hybrids, suggesting that this gene is either prone to reactivation or variable in its inactivation. Since many genes that escape X inactivation are clustered, we examined the expression of four genes (ARAF1, ELK1, ZNF41, and ZNF157) within approximately 100 kb of TIMP1. All four genes were expressed only from the active X chromosome, demonstrating that the factors allowing TIMP1 expression from the inactive X chromosome are specific to the TIMP1 gene. To determine if this variable inactivation of TIMP1 is a function of the hybrid-cell environment or also is observed in human cells, we developed an allele-specific assay to assess TIMP1 expression in human females. Expression of two alleles was detected in some female cells with previously demonstrated extreme skewing of X inactivation, indicating TIMP1 expression from the inactive chromosome. However, in other cells, no expression of TIMP1 was observed from the inactive X chromosome, suggesting that TIMP1 inactivation is polymorphic in human females.

Heterogeneous gene expression from the inactive X chromosome: an X-linked gene that escapes X inactivation in some human cell lines but is inactivated in others

In mammalian females, most genes on one X chromosome are transcriptionally silenced as a result of X chromosome inactivation. Whereas it is well established that some X-linked genes "escape" X inactivation and are expressed from both active (Xa) and inactive (Xi) X chromosomes, most models for the chromosomal control of X-linked gene expression assume that the X inactivation status of a given gene is constant among different females within a population. In this report, we test the expression of human X-linked genes in primary cell lines from females with complete nonrandom X inactivation, by using transcribed polymorphisms to distinguish Xa and Xi expression. Six X-linked genes used to document this assay system showed monoallelic expression in all informative cell lines, consistent with X inactivation. However, a novel pattern of expression was observed for another gene, REP1; monoallelic expression, indicating inactivation, was detected in some lines, whereas biallelic expression, indicating escape from inactivation, was detected in others. Furthermore, levels of Xi expression varied among cell lines that expressed REP1. The cellular basis of Xi expression was examined by expression assays in single cells. These data indicate that REP1 is expressed from the Xi in all cells, but that the level of expression relative to Xa levels is reduced. These findings suggest that Xi gene expression is under a previously unsuspected level of genetic or epigenetic control, likely involving local or regional changes in chromatin organization that determine whether a gene escapes or is subject to X inactivation.

Evidence for uniparental, paternal expression of the human GABAA receptor subunit genes, using microcell-mediated chromosome transfer

We have constructed mouse A9 hybrids containing a single normal human chromosome 15, via microcell-mediated chromosome transfer. Cytogenetic and DNA-polymorphic analyses identified mouse A9 hybrids that contained either a paternal or maternal human chromosome 15. Paternal specific expression of the known imprinted genes SNRPN (small nuclear ribonucleoprotein-associated polypeptide N gene) and IPW (imprinted gene in the Prader-Willi syndrome region) was maintained in the A9 hybrids. Using this system, we first demonstrated that human GABAAreceptor subunit genes, GABRB3 , GABRA5 and GABRG3 , were expressed exclusively from the paternal allele and that E6-AP (E6-associated protein or UBE3A ) was biallelically expressed. Moreover, the 5' portion of the GABRB3 gene was found to be hypermethylated on the paternal allele. Our data imply that GABAAreceptor subunit genes are imprinted and are possible candidates for Prader-Willi syndrome, and that this human monochromosomal hybrid system enables the efficient analysis of imprinted loci.

Expression of genes from the human active and inactive X chromosomes

X-chromosome inactivation results in the cis-limited inactivation of many, but not all, of the genes on one of the pair of X chromosomes in mammalian females. In addition to the genes from the pseudoautosomal region, which have long been anticipated to escape inactivation, genes from several other regions of the human X chromosome have now been shown to escape inactivation and to be expressed from both the active and inactive X chromosomes. The growing number of genes escaping inactivation emphasizes the need for a reliable system for assessing the inactivation status of X-linked genes. Since many features of the active or inactive X chromosome, including transcriptional activity, are maintained in rodent/human somatic-cell hybrids, such hybrids have been used to study the inactivation process and to determine the inactivation status of human X-linked genes. In order to assess the fidelity of inactivation status in such hybrids, we have examined the expression of 33 X-linked genes in eight mouse/human somatic-cell hybrids that contain either the human active (three hybrids) or inactive X (five hybrids) chromosome. Inactivation of nine of these genes had previously been demonstrated biochemically in human cells, and the expression of these genes only in hybrids retaining an active X, but not in those retaining an inactive X, confirms that expression in hybrids reflects expression in human cells. Although the majority of genes tested showed consistent patterns of expression among the active X hybrids or inactive X hybrids, surprisingly, 5 of the 33 genes showed heterogeneous expression among the hybrids, demonstrating a significantly higher rate of variability than previously reported for other genes in either human somatic cells or mouse/human somatic-cell hybrids. These data suggest that at least some X-linked genes may be under additional levels of epigenetic regulation not previously recognized and that somatic-cell hybrids may provide a useful approach for studying these chromosomal phenomena.

Maintenance of X inactivation of the Rps4, Zfx, and Ube1 genes in a mouse in vitro system

Several genes, including RPS4X (ribosomal protein subunit 4), ZFX (zinc finger on the X chromosome), and UBE1 (ubiquitin-activating enzyme), have been shown to be expressed from the inactive X chromosome of cultured human cells. By contrast, these genes are subject to X-chromosome inactivation in tissues from adult mice. We have now examined the inactivation status of these genes in cultured mouse cells to determine whether the differences in X-chromosome inactivation between species is due to an intrinsic difference between human and mouse X-chromosome genes or whether it is a function of gene reactivation in cell culture per se. The expression of three mouse X-chromosome genes, Rps4, Zfx, and Ube1 was examined by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) in heterozygous cultured cells from a cross of a laboratory mouse by Mus spretus, which were selected to uniformly express the X chromosome from the laboratory mouse parent. No expression of the M. spretus alleles of these genes was observed in the cell line (Hobmski), which is consistent with the patterns of expression previously observed in mouse in vivo and indicates that these genes remain stably inactivated in an immortalized mouse cell line. By cytogenetic and RT-PCR analyses the Hobmski cell line was shown to retain a late-replicating X chromosome from M. spretus, which expressed the M. spretus allele of the X (inactive) specific transcript (Xist). The Hobmski cell line will be a useful resource for studying the features that maintain X-chromosome genes inactive.

Directed isolation of human genes that escape X inactivation

Existing methodologies have been combined to produce a directed approach to the isolation of human genes that escape X inactivation. A mouse-human somatic cell hybrid line was established that has an inactive X as its only human chromosome, and nuclear RNA from this cell line was used to construct a cDNA library. Transcribed human sequences were isolated by screening the library with labeled human DNA. The corresponding genomic sequences were isolated in phage or cosmid clones, and exons were identified by detection of transcripts on northern blots. By these means three human loci have been identified that contain genes expressed from an inactive X chromosome. Fluorescence in situ hybridization has been used to map these genes to Xp21.1-22.1, Xp22.1-22.2, and terminal Xp/Yp. One of the three genes (XE45) corresponds to the ZFX gene, while the other two genes (XE7 and XE59) represent novel cloned sequences. Physical and genetic evidence indicate that XE7 is a newly identified pseudoautosomal gene.

Further evidence for the importance of parental source of the Xce allele in X chromosome inactivation

Using mice that were mosaics for both Xce and phosphoglycerate kinase (Pgk-1) alleles, we present further evidence that the parental source of the X chromosome may affect the probability of that X chromosome remaining active. The reciprocal cross differences in PGK-1 activity described here are intermediate between those published previously for other alleles of Xce.

Insights into X chromosome inactivation from studies of species variation, DNA methylation and replication, and vice versa

I am indebted to Mary Lyon as her X-inactivation hypothesis stimulated my mentor, Barton Childs, and in turn, myself, to think about the consequences of X-inactivation in heterozygous females. I often reread her original papers setting forth the single active X hypothesis, and still marvel at the concise and compelling exposition of the hypothesis and the logical predictions which seemed prophetic at my first reading, and have survived the test of time. My contribution to this Festschrift reviews evidence derived from studies of DNA methylation, species variation and DNA replication that reveals an important role for methylated CpG islands and suggests a role for late DNA replication in propagating X inactivation from one cell to its progeny. These studies also show that X inactivation is a powerful research tool for identifying the factors which program and maintain developmental processes.

X chromosome inactivation of the human TIMP gene

X chromosome inactivation results in the cis-limited inactivation of most, but not all, genes on one of the two X chromosomes in mammalian females. The molecular basis for inactivation is unknown. In order to examine the transcriptional activity of human X-linked genes, a series of mouse-human somatic cell hybrids under positive selection for the active or inactive human X chromosome has been created. Northern blot analysis of RNA from these hybrids showed that the human MIC2 gene, which is known to escape X inactivation, was transcribed in hybrids with either the active or inactive X chromosome. In contrast, the human TIMP gene was only transcribed in hybrids with an active human X chromosome. Further analysis using the polymerase chain reaction showed that there was at least one-hundred fold less transcription of the TIMP gene from the inactive X than from the active X chromosome. These findings demonstrate that the human TIMP gene is subject to X inactivation at the level of transcription, and illustrate the usefulness of the polymerase chain reaction to study the extent of X-linked gene repression by the process of X inactivation.

Differential activation of the hprt gene on the inactive X chromosome in primary and transformed Chinese hamster cells

We have investigated the genetic activation of the hprt (hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase) gene located on the inactive X chromosome in primary and transformed female diploid Chinese hamster cells after treatment with the DNA methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine (5azaCR). Mutants deficient in HPRT were first selected by growth in 6-thioguanine from two primary fibroblast cell lines and from transformed lines derived from them. These HPRT- mutants were then treated with 5azaCR and plated in HAT (hypoxanthine-methotrexate-thymidine) medium to select for cells that had reexpressed the hprt gene on the inactive X chromosome. Contrary to previous results with primary human cells, 5azaCR was effective in activating the hprt gene in primary Chinese hamster fibroblasts at a low but reproducible frequency of 2 x 10(-6) to 7 x 10(-6). In comparison, the frequency in independently derived transformed lines varied from 1 x 10(-5) to 5 x 10(-3), consistently higher than in the nontransformed cells. This increase remained significant when the difference in growth rates between the primary and transformed lines was taken into account. Treatment with 5azaCR was also found to induce transformation in the primary cell lines but at a low frequency of 4 x 10(-7) to 8 x 10(-7), inconsistent with a two-step model of transformation followed by gene activation to explain the derepression of hprt in primary cells. Thus, these results indicate that upon transformation, the hprt gene on the inactive Chinese hamster X chromosome is rendered more susceptible to action by 5azaCR, consistent with a generalized DNA demethylation associated with the transformation event or with an increase in the instability of an underlying primary mechanism of X inactivation.

Differential activation of the hprt gene on the inactive X chromosome in primary and transformed Chinese hamster cells

We have investigated the genetic activation of the hprt (hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase) gene located on the inactive X chromosome in primary and transformed female diploid Chinese hamster cells after treatment with the DNA methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine (5azaCR). Mutants deficient in HPRT were first selected by growth in 6-thioguanine from two primary fibroblast cell lines and from transformed lines derived from them. These HPRT- mutants were then treated with 5azaCR and plated in HAT (hypoxanthine-methotrexate-thymidine) medium to select for cells that had reexpressed the hprt gene on the inactive X chromosome. Contrary to previous results with primary human cells, 5azaCR was effective in activating the hprt gene in primary Chinese hamster fibroblasts at a low but reproducible frequency of 2 x 10(-6) to 7 x 10(-6). In comparison, the frequency in independently derived transformed lines varied from 1 x 10(-5) to 5 x 10(-3), consistently higher than in the nontransformed cells. This increase remained significant when the difference in growth rates between the primary and transformed lines was taken into account. Treatment with 5azaCR was also found to induce transformation in the primary cell lines but at a low frequency of 4 x 10(-7) to 8 x 10(-7), inconsistent with a two-step model of transformation followed by gene activation to explain the derepression of hprt in primary cells. Thus, these results indicate that upon transformation, the hprt gene on the inactive Chinese hamster X chromosome is rendered more susceptible to action by 5azaCR, consistent with a generalized DNA demethylation associated with the transformation event or with an increase in the instability of an underlying primary mechanism of X inactivation.

X-chromosome inactivation in cultured cells from human chorionic villi

X-chromosome inactivation was investigated in human chorionic villi in the first trimester of pregnancy and cultured cells established from them. Expression of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) was evaluated in these extraembryonic cells from four females heterozygous for the electrophoretic variants (AB) of G6PD. In each case the uncultured villi as well as derived cultured cells expressed the AB phenotype for G6PD with about equal intensity for the A and B bands. Single-cell-derived clones established from two of the four cases expressed either G6PD A or B. One clone expressing G6PD B was fused with mouse cells, and a hybrid clone retaining the inactive human X chromosome was isolated; there was no evidence of human G6PD expression in this clone retaining an inactive human X. DNA methylation in the first intron of the human gene for hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) was evaluated in the four pairs of cultured villi and fetal cells. No differences were detected between the cultured villi and fetal cells as they all showed bands characteristic of an inactive X from somatic cells. These results show that there is no preferential inactivation of an X in the majority of cells that constitute human tertiary chorionic villi or in cultured cells derived from them. Long-term cultures established from chorionic villi appear to be no different from somatic cells with respect to X-chromosome inactivation.

A-11: cell type-specific and single-active-X transcription controls of newly found gene in cultured human cells

We describe the isolation and characterization of a human X-chromosomal gene that is subject to both single-active-X control and tissue-specific control. The A-11 gene was identified by a cDNA that hydridizes to a 3.2-kb EcoR1 fragment of genomic DNA on the long arm of the human X chromosome. A-11 transcripts are normally present in fibroblasts but not in B- or T-lymphoblasts. However, A-11 transcription was activated in four of 11 independent, gamma ray-induced B-lymphoblastoid HLA antigen-loss mutants. Cell hybrids with a human fibroblast-derived active X contained A-11 transcripts but hybrids carrying the human inactive X did not. Azacytidine, a potent inhibitor of DNA methylation, readily reactivated the A-11 locus on the inactive X in hybrid cells, indicating that differential methylation is likely to be involved in the single-active-X control of A-11 transcription in fibroblasts. Failure of cells to remethylate DNA synthesized to repair gamma ray-induced damage may also have resulted in the activation of A-11 transcription among the lymphoblastoid mutants. The A-11 locus provides an opportunity to study the relationship between two types of transcriptional regulation of a gene.

Comparative study of DNase I sensitivity at the X-linked human HPRT locus

To examine the association between chromatin structure and gene expression at the human hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) locus, DNase I sensitivity of active and inactive genes was analyzed. In a set of human-hamster hybrid lines containing either an active or an inactive human X chromosome, or a derivative of the latter in which the HPRT gene was reactivated by 5-azacytidine treatment, only the promoter region of the gene was found to contain a hypersensitive domain, and its presence was strictly correlated with gene activity. An S1 nuclease-sensitive site was mapped upstream from the DNase I hypersensitive domain using supercoiled plasmids. The overall level of DNase I sensitivity in the interior of the HPRT gene was also assessed by comparing the degradation of polymorphic restriction fragments on active and inactive alleles in both polyclonal and monoclonal lines of female human cells. In these internally controlled experiments, the active X chromosome was found to be approximately twofold more susceptible to DNase I digestion than the inactive X chromosome.

DNase I sensitivity of Microtus agrestis active, inactive and reactivated X chromosomes in mouse-Microtus cell hybrids

We isolated Microtus agrestis-mouse somatic cell hybrid clones which had retained either the active or the inactive M. agrestis X chromosome. In both hybrid clones the X chromosomes retained their original chromatin conformation as studied by the in situ nick translation technique--the active X chromosome retained its high sensitivity to DNase I while the inactive one remained insensitive. A clone in which the hypoxanthine guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) gene had been spontaneously reactivated was isolated from the hybrid containing the inactive X chromosome. The in situ nick translation technique was used to study possible DNA conformation changes in the euchromatin of the inactive X chromosome with special reference to the reactivated HPRT locus. We found that the euchromatin in this X chromosome exhibited the same low sensitivity to DNase I as is characteristic of the inactive X chromosome.

High-frequency reactivation of X-linked genes in Chinese hamster X human hybrid cells

Three genes on the human inactive X chromosome retained in the Chinese hamster X human hybrid cell line X8/6T2 have been reactivated using the demethylating agent, 5-azacytidine (5-aza-CR). Pulse-labeling and histochemical methods permitted detection and measurement of reactivation rates of the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (Hpt) and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6pd) genes within 48 h of treatment. About 50% of the cells became active for these genes, which represents a reactivation rate some 30-fold greater than previously reported in similar systems. The phosphoglycerate kinase (Pgk) gene was not reactivated as frequently as the Hpt or G6pd genes. Segregation analysis of progeny of treated cells showed that enzyme-positive and enzyme-negative cells were produced in proportions supporting the notion that 5-aza-CR causes demethylation by replicative loss and that demethylation leads to reactivation.

Activation of a nonexpressed hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase allele in mutant H23 HeLa cells by agents that inhibit DNA methylation

HeLA H23 cells are a mutant female human tumor cell line harboring defective hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT; IMP-pyrophosphate phosphoribosyltransferase, EC 2.4.2.8) as a result of a mutation that alters the isoelectric point of the enzyme (G. Milman, E. Lee, G. S. Changas, J. R. McLaughlin, and J. George, Jr., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 73:4589-4592, 1976). As shown by Milman et al. and confirmed by us here, rare HAT+ revertants arise spontaneously at 1.9 X 10(-8) frequency and express both mutant and wild-type polypeptides. Thus, the H23 mutant also carries a silent wild-type HPRT allele that is activated in revertants. To test whether the silent allele was activated via hypomethylation of genomic DNA, H23 cells were treated with inhibitors of DNA methylation, and revertants were scored by HAT or azaserine selection. At an optimal dose of 5 microM 5-azacytidine, the reversion frequency was increased about 50-fold when assayed by HAT selection and over 1,000-fold when assayed by azaserine selection. HAT+ and azaserine revertants were heterozygous for HPRT, expressing both wild-type and mutant HPRT polypeptides. Like spontaneous revertants, they contained active HPRT enzyme and were genetically unstable, reverting at about 10(-4) frequency. Similar results were found after treatment with N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, a DNA-alkylating agent and potent inhibitor of mammalian DNA methylation. By contrast, the DNA-ethylating agent, ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), did not increase the HAT+ reversion frequency; it did, however, increase the frequency by which H23 revertants heterozygous for HPRT reverted to 6-thioguanine resistance. Of nine EMS revertants, seven lacked HPRT activity and had a substantially reduced expression of the wild-type polypeptide. These observations support the hypothesis that DNA methylation plays an important role in human X-chromosome inactivation and that EMS can inactivate gene expression by promoting enzymatic methylation of genomic DNA as found previously for the prolactin gene in GH3 rat pituitary tumor cells (R. D. Ivarie and J. A. Morris, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79:2967-2970, 1982; R. D. Ivarie, J. A. Morris, and J. A. Martial, Mol. Cell. Biol. 2:179-189, 1982).

Reactivation of X-linked genes in human fibroblasts transformed by origin-defective SV40

To determine if expression of genes on the inactive X is inducible in human cells, we looked for reactivation events in a clone of fibroblasts transformed with origin-defective SV40. The karyotype of these cells was grossly heteroploid so that the aneuploidy associated with SV40 transformation occurs even in the absence of viral replication. This transformed clone, heterozygous for hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT), lacks HPRT activity, as the mutant allele is on the active X and the normal allele on the inactive X. Reactivation of the HPRT+ allele on the inactive X was observed at a frequency of 6 X 10(-5) per cell and increased approximately eightfold following treatment with the cytidine analogs 5-azacytidine (5azaC) and 5-azadeoxycytidine. The fact that spontaneous reactivation is detectable in some clones, but not all, suggests that the environment of the SV40-transformed cell, although not sufficient to induce generalized derepression, increases the frequency of rare reactivation events. The methylation pattern at the HPRT locus revealed transformation-associated alterations that may have predisposed these cells to reactivation events, spontaneous as well as 5azaC-induced.

Derepression of HPRT locus on inactive X chromosome of human lymphoblastoid cell line

Human XX lymphoblastoid cells with a deletion in the HPRT locus on the active X were exposed to HPRT clone pHPT32. HPRT+ isolates GPT3 and GPT5 lacked pHPT32 DNA, suggesting that their HPRT+ phenotype resulted from expression of a cellular gene. GPT3 mutated to thioguanine resistance at least 100 times more frequently than cells in which the expressed HPRT locus was on the active X. Most GPT3-derived HPRT- had lost one entire X chromosome, indicating that the HPRT+ phenotype of GPT3 resulted from derepression of the HPRT locus on its inactive X. Virtually unchanged G6PD and PGK activities and the presence of a late-replicating X in GPT3 suggest that derepression of the inactive X was not general. Eleven of the GPT3-derived mutants had a tiny centric remnant that may result from a frequently operative mechanism of X chromosome loss. The detection of partial or complete loss of an X by direct selection presents unusual opportunities for genotoxicity detection with human cells.

Complete reactivation of X chromosomes from human chorionic villi with a switch to early DNA replication

Mammalian sex-dosage compensation is mediated by maintaining activity of only one X chromosome. The asynchronous DNA synthesis characterizing the silent human X chromosome is thought to be reversible only during ontogeny of oocytes. We have previously shown that the glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) locus (G6PD) on the allocyclic X chromosome in chorionic villi is partially expressed. We now show that in hybrids derived from a clone of chorionic villi cells (heterozygous for G6PD A) and mouse A9 cells, the loci for G6PD, hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) and phosphoglycerate kinase are expressed on both human X chromosomes; the human X chromosomes carrying either G6PD A or B replicate synchronously with each other and with murine chromosomes. The X chromosome with G6PD A was identified as the original late-replicating X, because methylation in the body of the HPRT gene on this chromosome remained characteristic of the inactive X chromosome. These results indicate that X-chromosome inactivation is completely reversible in cells of trophoblast origin; induction of full transcriptional activity is accompanied by acquisition of isocyclic replication, showing an intimate relationship between these processes. The molecular events responsible for this reversal may be similar to those occurring during maturation of oocytes. Chorionic villi and derivative hybrids provide in vitro models for exploring early events that program the single active X chromosome.

Activation of a nonexpressed hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase allele in mutant H23 HeLa cells by agents that inhibit DNA methylation

HeLA H23 cells are a mutant female human tumor cell line harboring defective hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT; IMP-pyrophosphate phosphoribosyltransferase, EC 2.4.2.8) as a result of a mutation that alters the isoelectric point of the enzyme (G. Milman, E. Lee, G. S. Changas, J. R. McLaughlin, and J. George, Jr., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 73:4589-4592, 1976). As shown by Milman et al. and confirmed by us here, rare HAT+ revertants arise spontaneously at 1.9 X 10(-8) frequency and express both mutant and wild-type polypeptides. Thus, the H23 mutant also carries a silent wild-type HPRT allele that is activated in revertants. To test whether the silent allele was activated via hypomethylation of genomic DNA, H23 cells were treated with inhibitors of DNA methylation, and revertants were scored by HAT or azaserine selection. At an optimal dose of 5 microM 5-azacytidine, the reversion frequency was increased about 50-fold when assayed by HAT selection and over 1,000-fold when assayed by azaserine selection. HAT+ and azaserine revertants were heterozygous for HPRT, expressing both wild-type and mutant HPRT polypeptides. Like spontaneous revertants, they contained active HPRT enzyme and were genetically unstable, reverting at about 10(-4) frequency. Similar results were found after treatment with N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, a DNA-alkylating agent and potent inhibitor of mammalian DNA methylation. By contrast, the DNA-ethylating agent, ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), did not increase the HAT+ reversion frequency; it did, however, increase the frequency by which H23 revertants heterozygous for HPRT reverted to 6-thioguanine resistance. Of nine EMS revertants, seven lacked HPRT activity and had a substantially reduced expression of the wild-type polypeptide. These observations support the hypothesis that DNA methylation plays an important role in human X-chromosome inactivation and that EMS can inactivate gene expression by promoting enzymatic methylation of genomic DNA as found previously for the prolactin gene in GH3 rat pituitary tumor cells (R. D. Ivarie and J. A. Morris, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79:2967-2970, 1982; R. D. Ivarie, J. A. Morris, and J. A. Martial, Mol. Cell. Biol. 2:179-189, 1982).

Differential control of U1 small nuclear RNA expression during mouse development

During normal mouse development the relative amounts of two types of U1 small nuclear RNA's (U1 RNA) change significantly. Fetal tissues have comparable levels of the two major types of mouse U1 RNA's, mU1a and mU1b, whereas most differentiated adult tissues contain only mU1a RNA's. Those adult tissues that also accumulate detectable amounts of embryonic (mU1b) RNA's (for example, testis, spleen, and thymus) contain a significant proportion of stem cells capable of further differentiation. Several strains of mice express minor sequence variants of U1 RNA's that are subject to the same developmental controls as the major types of adult and embryonic U1 RNA. The differential accumulation of embryonic U1 RNA's may influence the pattern of gene expression during early development and differentiation.

Genes controlling gp25/30 cell-surface molecules map to chromosomes X and Y and escape X-inactivation

The monoclonal antibody AbO13 defines a cell-surface antigen that is expressed on most cultured human cells, but not on rodent cells. AbO13 precipitates glycoproteins of 25,000 and 30,000 mol. wt. from lysates of [3H]glucosamine-labeled human cells. Results of the serological typing of a panel of 25 rodent-human somatic cell hybrid clones show that reactivity with AbO13 segregates with the human X and Y chromosomes. The presence of either of these chromosomes is sufficient for O13 expression on the hybrid cell surface. Analysis of hybrid clones containing human X chromosomes with karyotypically defined deletions permitted the regional assignment of the X-linked gene locus controlling the expression of O13 to Xp22-pter. In addition, AbO13 is reactive with Chinese hamster-human hybrids derived from fibroblasts of a 49,XXXXX individual that contained only inactivated copies of the human X chromosome. These results suggest that the X-linked locus determining the expression of O13 is not subject to X-inactivation.

Frequency of reactivation and variability in expression of X-linked enzyme loci

A mouse-human cell hybrid clone retaining an inactive human X chromosome was treated with 5-azacytidine. Following treatment, expression of the X-linked enzyme markers, hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT), glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD), phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK), and alpha-galactosidase A (GLA) was examined. Results presented here show that 45 of the 62 clones positive for human HPRT expressed human GLA, while only four of 68 clones negative for human HPRT expressed human GLA. These results strongly suggest that there is coordinate reactivation of GLA and HPRT. Reactivated expression of G6PD was studied in detail. The studies show that 5-azacytidine can induce heritable changes in the inactive human X chromosome resulting in the expression of G6PD activity at a level lower than that from an active human X chromosome.

Unbalanced X chromosome mosaicism in B cells of mice with X-linked immunodeficiency

The immunodeficiency in CBA/N mice is reflected by abnormal development of a subset of B lymphocytes. However, it is not clear how xid, the mutant gene in CBA/N mice, affects the development of this subset. Specifically, it is not known if the xid gene influences the development of the B cell subset directly or indirectly by providing the improper developmental milieu through effects on other cells. We investigated this question using female mice heterozygous for two x chromosomal genes, xid and Pgk-1 (phosphoglycerate kinase-1). Since females are mosaic because of x chromosome inactivation, their lymphocytes can be studied for the choice of the x chromosome, using the two PGK-1 isoenzymes as the cytological marker. We find that B lymphocytes in the spleen prefer the x chromosome without xid while the remaining splenocytes and cells from other tissues do not. This suggests that xid affects B lymphocytes directly and not through their developmental milieu. Furthermore, our data suggest that the precursors for IgG1- and IgG3-producing cells may be both few and different.

Cytologic and molecular analysis of 46,XXq- cells to identify a DNA segment that might serve as a probe for a putative human X chromosome inactivation center

Cloned human X chromosome-specific DNA segments, derived from a recombinant phage library enriched for the human X and previously localized to different regions of the X, were used as probes in Southern blots to confirm the nature of a deletion of the long arm of the X chromosome as del(X)(q13) in a patient with some features of Turner's syndrome and suspected from cytologic studies to have a 46,XXq- karyotype. Two dimensional scanning densitometry of autoradiograms of the Southern blots was used to quantitate hybridization of the 32P-labeled probes, reinforcing visual analysis and permitting distinction between sequences present at one or two copies per diploid genome. Once thus characterized, DNA from the patient's cells was used in quantitatively analyzed Southern blots to refine the location of an additional DNA segment, previously mapped to somewhere in the proximal part of the long arm of the X chromosome, to the juxtacentromeric region of Xq, which has been hypothesized to be critical for X-inactivation. Cloned DNA probes such as that localized to the juxtacentromeric region of Xq should be useful for evaluating this hypothesis.

Evidence for DNA modification in the maintenance of X-chromosome inactivation of adult mouse tissues

The role of DNA modification in the maintenance of mammalian X-chromosome inactivation was investigated by using the technique of DNA transformation in mammalian cells. The ability of inactive X-chromosome DNA from adult mouse tissues to act in transformation for the X-linked hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase gene (Hprt) could be ascertained by utilizing a recently discovered electrophoretic variant form of the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase enzyme and a previously available X:autosome translocation. Our findings indicate that inactive X-chromosome DNA from several tissues of adult female mice is strikingly inefficient, in comparison to active X-chromosome DNA, in eliciting genetic transformation for hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase. These results provide in vivo evidence that is consistent with DNA modification playing an important role in the maintenance of X-chromosome inactivation.

Derepression of genes on the human inactive X chromosome: evidence for differences in locus-specific rates of derepression and rates of transfer of active and inactive genes after DNA-mediated transformation

Mouse-human hybrid cells that contained an inactive human X chromosome were treated with agents known to alter gene expression and to perturb DNA methylation. 5-Azacytidine greatly increased the rate of derepression of HPRT on the inactive X, while butyrate and dimethyl sulfoxide had smaller effects. Ethionine did not change the rate of derepression. Derepression of two other X-chromosomal loci, PGK and GPD, was also detected. The rate of derepression of PGK was 20-fold higher than the rate for HPRT. Derepression events at the two loci appeared to be independent. Hybrids expressing derepressed X-chromosomal genes had more variable levels of human enzyme activities when compared to control hybrids. HPRT+ clones did not appear after transfer of purified DNA from a cell hybrid containing an inactive human X into HPRT- recipients, but such clones did appear after transfer of DNA from derivative cells in which HPRT had been derepressed.

Studies of X chromosome DNA methylation in normal human cells

Studies of methylation along 28 kilobases of X-chromosome DNA, assayed by Southern blot analysis using cloned X-chromosome-specific probes, indicates that X DNA methylation in normal human cells changes with replication, is not correlated with number of X chromosomes or transcriptional activity, and is less stable and more prevalent than when the human X is in the foreign environment of mouse-human hybrid cells. In contrast with observations of others in heteroploid cells, we observed no derepression of the inactive X in clonal populations of normal human fibroblasts treated with 5-azacytidine. This may reflect the differences in stability of the methylation of the human X in a foreign environment. Our observations preclude ubiquitous methylation differences as the molecular basis for X-chromosome inactivation.

X-autosome translocations: cytogenetic characteristics and their consequences

To define the principal characteristics of X-autosome translocations, the authors present a study of 105 cases, five of which are personal observations. The autosomal pairs 15, 21, and 22 are affected by t(X-Aut) more often than would be expected. The distribution of breakpoints on the X chromosome does not differ significantly from the expected distribution. The analysis of different patterns of inactivation seems to confirm that the inactivation could occur at random, but would be followed by a cellular selection favoring the better genetic balance. An estimate of the incidence of t(X-Aut) is proposed, based upon the conclusions that only one chromosome is susceptible to translocation in meiosis in both males and females and that all affected men will be sterile, as will be 50% of women.

A stem-line model for cellular and chromosomal differentiation in early mouse-development

Differentiation in mouse embryo development is represented formally by means of a stem-line model in which: 1. Individual choices are structured so that only a fraction of the cells of a given population receive a signal to undergo a change of state that results in a departure from the stem line. 2. Development proceeds by a series of restrictions in potency of all the cells in the stem line. 3. The stem line harbours the germ cells. 4. The germ cells are returned to a state of totipotency by some event(s) leading to meiosis.

X chromosome reactivation in oocytes of Mus caroli

Mature mammalian oocytes have both of their X chromosomes active, while somatic cells from the same individual have one of their X chromosomes in an inactive state. We asked whether the X chromosomes of the germ cells never undergo inactivation in their ontogeny or whether inactivation of an X chromosome does occur but is followed by a subsequent reactivation event. Our approach has used an electrophoretic polymorphism for the X-linked enzyme glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) in the mouse species Mus caroli. G6PD is dimeric, and a heterodimer is produced in cells from heterozygous females if and only if both X chromosomes are active. Ovaries from heterozygous fetuses at different gestational ages were dissected and either studied cytologically or pressed between microscopy slides to obtain germ cell-rich and germ cell-poor preparations. No heterodimer band was detected on the 10th day of development in germ cell-rich preparations. On subsequent days, an increasingly intense heterodimer band was detected, which, by the 13th day, was approximately twice as intense as the corresponding homodimer bands. Consideration of (i) the G6PD activity per germ cell and per somatic cell and (ii) the percentage of germ cells in the germ cell-rich preparations indicated that a heterodimer band should have been visible on the 10th day had both X chromosomes been active. Cytological examinations showed that the earliest germ cells enter meiotic prophase on the eleventh day. These results demonstrate that oogonia have a single active X chromosome and that the inactive X chromosome is reactivated at or, more likely, shortly before entry into meiotic prophase.

Undercondensation and localized euchromatinization of the x chromosome in the grasshopper Melanoplus femur-rubrum

In most animals, including grasshoppers, the X chromosome is heterochromatic (heteropycnotic) during prophase I and metaphase I of spermatogenesis. This report describes one grasshopper male in which at these states some of the X chromosomes contained an euchromatic (E) segment. In grasshoppers, the heteropycnotic state of the X is apparently established prior to the formation of the cysts. The spermatocytes containing the E segments, however, did not comprise whole cysts. It was concluded, therefore, that the E segments resulted from a localized euchromatinization rather than a failure to become heteropycnotic. The cytology of this male was unusual in two other respects. In most of the spermatocytes the chromosomes were longer and thinner than those of other males. In addition, in some of the cells undergoing meiosis, the cytoplasm failed to divide during both meiotic divisions and the resulting spermatids failed to differentiate into sperm. Because in this species both the presence of Xs with E segments and undercondensation are very rare and both involve condensation, it is likely that they are in some way related. Evidence for and against the possibility that the E segments were genetically active and that this activity led to the arrest of some of the spermatids is discussed.

Reactivation of an inactive human X chromosome: evidence for X inactivation by DNA methylation

A mouse-human somatic cell hybrid clone, deficient in hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) and containing a structurally normal inactive human X chromosome, was isolated. The hybrid cells were treated with 5-azacytidine and tested for the reactivation and expression of human X-linked genes. The frequency of HPRT-positives clones after 5-azacytidine treatment was 1000-fold greater than that observed in untreated hybrid cells. Fourteen independent HPRT-positive clones were isolated and analyzed for the expression of human X markers. Isoelectric focusing showed that the HPRT expressed in these clones is human. One of the 14 clones expressed human glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase and another expressed human phosphoglycerate kinase. Since 5-azacytidine treatment results in hypomethylation of DNA, DNA methylation may be a mechanism of human X chromosome inactivation.

Inactive X chromosome DNA does not function in DNA-mediated cell transformation for the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase gene

The molecular nature of the X chromosome inactivation process has been investigated by utilizing the techniques of DNA-mediated cell transformation of the X-linked hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) locus. The findings indicate that purified DNA from the inactive X chromosome of a near-euploid mouse cell line is not functional in transformation for HPRT, but the DNA from its "homologous" active X readily elicits transformation for HPRT in the same hamster cell recipient. These findings suggest that there is a difference between the DNA, per se, of the active and inactive X at (or near) the HPRT locus and that this difference could account, at least in part, for its inactivation.

Cytogenetic evidence for the absence of an inactivated X chromosome in a human female (XX) breast carcinoma cell line

Barr body staining procedures were applied directly to the chamber slide cultures of female amniotic cells. WI38 fibroblasts, normal female kidney cells, and a human breast carcinoma cell line, Elco. A high frequency of Barr bodies was found in all the normal female control cells; however, no Barr bodies were observed in the Elco cells. By trypsin G-banding analysis, two normal X chromosomes were identified in all Elco cells. The late DNA replication pattern of the cell line was then studied with the terminal BrdU pulse method. Both X chromosomes in the Elco cell line were found to be euchromatic with a characteristic R-banding pattern; no late-replicating X chromosome was observed. The absence of both a Barr body and a late-replicating heterocyclic X chromosome provides strong cytogenetic evidence that an inactivated X chromosome is absent in the human breast carcinoma cells bearing two X chromosomes.

Nucleotide sequence of immunoglobulin heavy chain joining segments between translocated VH and mu constant regions genes

To investigate the mechanism of recombination of immunoglobulin heavy chain variable and constant region genes, we have determined the nucleotide sequence of a large portion of the recombination region between an active C mu gene and its associated VH gene, isolated from an IgM-secreting mouse plasmacytoma, HPC76. By comparison with the sequence of the mu mRNA, we determined the exact boundaries of the intervening sequence between the VH76 and C mu genes. The rearranged VH76 gene encodes up to amino acid 116 without interruption, the 3' 39 nucleotides (the JH76 region) being derived from an embryonic JH segment (JH315) whose sequence was recently determined [Early, P., Huang, H., Davis, M., Calame, K. & Hood, L. (1980) Cell 195, 981-992]. The active JH76 does not use the first two codons of the embryonic JH315 from which it is derived. This indicates that V-J recombination is important in generating diversity within the third hypervariable region of heavy chains. We have identified another JH segment (JHA4), located 336 nucleotides 3' to the rearranged JH76 segment. This JH segment is expressed in the heavy chains of anti-levan myeloma proteins, which have truncated third hypervariable regions. We propose that the nucleotide sequence 5' to JHA4 is important for generating V region genes with shortened third hypervariable regions.

Genetics of cell surface receptors for bioactive polypeptides: binding of epidermal growth factor is associated with the presence of human chromosome 7 in human-mouse cell hybrids

Mouse A9 cells, L-cell-derived mutants deficient in hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT; IMP:pyrophosphate phosphoribosyltransferase, EC 2.4.2.8) were found to be incapable of binding (125)I-labeled epidermal growth factor (EGF) to the cell surface. The A9 cells were fused with human diploid fibroblasts (WI-38) possessing EGF-binding ability, and human-mouse cell hybrids (TA series) were isolated after hypoxanthine/aminopterin/thymidine/ouabain selection. Analyses of isozyme markers and chromosomes of four representative clones of TA hybrids indicated that the expression of EGF-binding ability is correlated with the presence of human chromosome 7 or 19. Four subclones were isolated from an EGF-binding-positive line, TA-4, and segregation of EGF-binding was found to be concordant with the expression of human mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase (MDHM; L-malate:NAD(+) oxidoreductase, EC 1.1.1.37), a marker for chromosome 7, but not with glucosephosphate isomerase (GPI; D-glucose-6-phosphate ketol-isomerase, EC 5.3.1.9), a marker for chromosome 19. Furthermore, evidence from 27 clones of AUG hybrids that were produced between A9 and another human fibroblast line, GM1696, carrying an X/7 chromosome translocation indicated that EGF-binding ability segregates together with human MDHM and two X-linked markers, HPRT and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD; D-glucose-6-phosphate:NADP(+) 1-oxidoreductase, EC 1.1.1.49), that are located on the translocation chromosome 7p(+). These results permit assignment of the gene, designated EGFS, which is associated with the expression of EGF-binding ability, to human chromosome 7 and its localization to the p22-qter region. Because the EGF receptor is reported to be a glycoprotein the EGFS could be either a structural gene(s) for receptor protein or a gene(s) for modifying the receptor protein through glycosylation.

Autonomous gene expression on the human inactive X chromosome

Local derepression of the hpt locus on the human inactive X chromosome obtained in human female fibroblast x mouse L cell somatic cell hybrids was not correlated with the presence or absence of any specific human chromosome in the hybrids. Loss of the human active X, in particular, did not result in observable derepression of genes on the inactive X. Introduction of an active X, via a second hybridization of human cells having an active X with hybrid cells containing a locally derepressed X chromosome, did not restore repression of the derepressed hpt allele. The rate of hpt locus derepression in hybrid cells was estimated to be 10(-6) per inactive X chromosome per cell generation.