Acetylcholine-receptor-mediated ion flux in electroplax membrane microsacs (vesicles): change in mechanism produced by asymmetrical distribution of sodium and potassium ions

On the mechanism of the gamma-aminobutyric acid receptor in the mammalian (mouse) cerebral cortex. Chemical kinetic investigations with a 10-ms time resolution adapted to measurements of neuronal receptor function in single cells

The gamma-aminobutyric acidA (GABA) receptor belongs to a superfamily of proteins involved in chemical reactions that regulate signal transmission between cells of the nervous system and is the target of some of the agents most frequently used in medicine to control disorders of the central nervous system. In contrast to the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor, which initiates signal transmission and is the best characterized member of the superfamily, the GABA receptor forms anion-specific transmembrane channels and inhibits signal transmission. The chemical kinetic experiments described here, in which fast chemical reaction techniques were used, indicate that both receptor proteins may operate by the same mechanism. Also described is the use of a chemical kinetic technique with a 10-ms time resolution that we have developed for making measurements with single cells isolated from specific areas of the nervous system, in this case the cerebral cortex of embryonic mice. A flow device was used to equilibrate receptors on the cell surface with GABA, and the concentration of open transmembrane channels in the cells was then measured by recording the whole-cell currents at pH 7.2, 21-23 degrees C, and a transmembrane voltage of -70 mV. Two different receptor forms, A alpha and A beta, were detected in cerebral cortical cells. Although the ratio of A alpha to A beta varied from cell to cell, on average 35% and 65% of the receptor-controlled current was associated with receptor forms A alpha and A beta, respectively. At saturating concentrations of GABA, the rate coefficients of desensitization, alpha and beta, associated with these two forms have maximal values of 4.4 and 0.7 s-1, respectively. The constants of a mechanism that accounts for the open transmembrane channels of both receptor forms were evaluated over a 50-fold range of GABA concentration. The dissociation constant of the site controlling channel opening was 40 microM for A alpha and 320 microM for A beta. The channel-opening equilibrium constant, phi-1, was 3.5 for A alpha and 20 for A beta. The evaluated constants allow one to calculate Po, the conditional probability that at a given concentration of GABA the receptor-channel is open. Po could also be determined in the presence of 100 microM GABA by an independent method in which different assumptions are made in the interpretation of the experimental results, the single-channel current-recording technique. The value of Po obtained (0.56) was in good agreement with the Po value (0.61) calculated for receptor form A alpha from chemical kinetic measurements at 100 microM GABA.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Transmembrane flux and receptor desensitization measured with membrane vesicles. Homogeneity of vesicles investigated by computer simulation

The use of membrane vesicles to make quantitative studies of transmembrane transport and exchange processes involves an assumption of homogeneity of the membrane vesicles. In studies of 86Rb+ exchange mediated by acetylcholine receptor from the electric organ of Electrophorus electricus and of 36Cl- exchange mediated by GABA receptor from rat brain, measurements of ion exchange and receptor desensitization precisely followed first order kinetics in support of this assumption. In other measurements a biphasic decay of receptor activity was seen. To elucidate the molecular properties of receptors from such measurements it is important to appreciate what the requirements of vesicle monodispersity are for meaningful results and what the effect of vesicle heterogeneity would be. The experiments were simulated with single vesicle populations with variable defined size distributions as well as with mixtures of different populations of vesicles. The properties of the receptors and their density in the membrane could be varied. Different receptors could be present on the same or different membrane vesicles. The simulated measurements were not very sensitive to size dispersity. A very broad size distribution of a single vesicle population was necessary to give rise to detectable deviations from first order kinetics or errors in the determined kinetic constants. Errors could become significant with mixtures of different vesicle populations, where the dispersity in initial ion exchange rate constant, proportional to the receptor concentration per internal volume, became large. In this case the apparent rate of receptor desensitization would diverge in opposite directions from the input value when measured by two different methods, suggesting an experimental test for such kinetic heterogeneity. A biphasic decrease of receptor activity could not be attributed to vesicle heterogeneity and must be due to desensitization processes with different rates. Significant errors would not arise from the size dispersity apparent in subpopulations of vesicles seen by imaging techniques in membrane preparations.

Chemical kinetic measurements of a mammalian acetylcholine receptor by a fast-reaction technique

In the presence of acetylcholine, the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor undergoes two rapid conformational changes: one in the 1-ms time region, leading to the formation of a transmembrane channel and signal transmission between cells, and the other in the 100-ms time region, leading to an inactive "desensitized" form with altered ligand-binding properties. To determine the properties of the receptor that are relevant for channel opening and signal transmission, we have developed a cell-flow technique that allows measurements to be made with cells prior to receptor desensitization. Here we illustrate the usefulness of the technique. A wide concentration range of both a ligand that controls the opening of receptor channels (carbamoylcholine) and a receptor inhibitor (procaine) was used to measure the dissociation constant of the receptor site controlling channel opening (2.4 X 10(-4) M), the channel-opening equilibrium constant (5.5), the inhibition constant for procaine (5.8 X 10(-5) M), and the rate coefficients for two desensitization processes of 5 s-1 and 0.2 s-1. The cell-flow technique illustrated here is of interest because, by rapid-reaction techniques, it extends the chemical kinetic approach from investigations of reactions in solutions to investigations of many different receptors that exist in membranes of central nervous system cells and whose properties are not well known.

Acetylcholine receptor: channel-opening kinetics evaluated by rapid chemical kinetic and single-channel current measurements

A combination of rapid chemical kinetic (quench-flow) and single-channel current measurements was used to evaluate kinetic parameters governing the opening of acetylcholine-receptor channels in the electric organ (electroplax) of Electrophorus electricus. Chemical kinetic measurements made on membrane vesicles, prepared from the E. electricus electroplax, using carbamoylcholine (200 microM-20 mM) at 12 degrees C, pH 7.0, and in the absence of a transmembrane voltage, yielded values for K1 (dissociation constant for receptor activation), phi (channel closing equilibrium constant), J (specific reaction rate for ion flux), and alpha max (maximum inactivation rate constant) of 1 mM, 3.4, 4 x 10(7) M-1 s-1, and 12 s-1, respectively. The single-channel current recordings were made with cells also from the E. electricus electroplax, at the same temperature and pH as the chemical kinetic measurements, using carbamoylcholine (50 microM-2 mM), acetylcholine (500 nM), or suberyldicholine (20 nM). Single-channel current measurements indicated the presence of a single, unique open-channel state of the E. electricus receptor, in concurrence with previous, less extensive measurements. The rate constant for channel closing (kc) obtained from the mean open time of the receptor channel is 1,100 s-1 for carbamoylcholine, 1,200 s-1 for acetylcholine, and 360 s-1 for suberyldicholine at zero membrane potential; and it decreases e-fold for an 80 mV decrease in transmembrane voltage in each case. The decrease in mean open times of the receptor channel that is associated with increasing the carbamoylcholine concentration is interpreted to be due to carbamoylcholine binding to the regulatory (inhibitory) site on the receptor. An analysis of data obtained with carbamoylcholine showed that the closed times within a burst of channel activity fit a two-exponential distribution, with a concentration-independent time constant considered to be the time constant for carbamoylcholine to dissociate from the regulatory site, and a carbamoylcholine concentration-dependent, but voltage-independent, time constant interpreted to represent the rate constant for channel opening (k0). An analysis of the mean closed time data on the basis of the minimum model gives values for K1 and k0 of 0.6 mM and 440 s-1, respectively, with carbamoylcholine as the activating ligand. The values obtained for K1, phi (= kc/k0), J, and alpha from the single-channel current measurements using electroplax are in good agreement with the values obtained from the chemical kinetic measurements using receptor-rich vesicles prepared from the same cells. These results confirm the assumed basic agreement between two entirely different methodologies and underlie the strategy of using the two techniques to obtain complementary information in time and ligand-concentration regions where only one or the other technique can be used. This agreement between results allows estimates to be made of the ko values, for both acetylcholine and suberyldicholine, from the phi values obtained from the chemical kinetic measurements and the kc values obtained in single-channel current measurements.

Cocaine and phencyclidine inhibition of the acetylcholine receptor: analysis of the mechanisms of action based on measurements of ion flux in the millisecond-to-minute time region

The effects of cocaine and of phencyclidine and procaine on acetylcholine receptor-controlled ion flux were measured in the millisecond-to-minute time region. Chemical kinetic measurements of ion flux were made in membrane vesicles prepared from the electric organ of Electrophorus electricus and in PC-12 cells, a sympathetic neuronal cell line. A quench-flow technique was used to measure ion flux in the millisecond-to-second range in membrane vesicles. Cocaine and phencyclidine both inhibit acetylcholine receptor-controlled ion flux, but by different mechanisms. Both compounds decrease the initial rate of ion flux, an effect observed with the local anesthetic procaine. This inhibition cannot be prevented by saturating concentrations of acetylcholine (1 mM). These results from chemical kinetic experiments are consistent with electrophysiological measurements which indicate that local anesthetics act by interfering with the movement of ions through receptor-formed channels. The chemical kinetic experiments, however, give additional information about the action of phencyclidine. They indicate that phencyclidine also increases the rate of receptor inactivation (desensitization) and changes the equilibrium between active and inactive receptor conformations, effects not observed in the presence of cocaine or procaine.

Comparison of acetylcholine receptor-controlled cation flux in membrane vesicles from Torpedo californica and Electrophorus electricus: chemical kinetic measurements in the millisecond region

In earlier studies with the acetylcholine receptor (AcChoR) of Electrophorus electricus the rate and equilibrium constants for a model that relates the ligand binding to ion translocation were determined, and the dependence of these constants on the concentrations of carbamoylcholine and acetylcholine, over a 200- and 5000-fold range, respectively, could be predicted. AcChoR-controlled cation flux has now been measured in Torpedo californica vesicles by using a pulsed-quench-flow technique with a 2-msec time resolution. Torpedo vesicles on a weight basis may contain several hundred times more receptor sites than do E. electricus vesicles. Techniques have been developed to (i) correct for the kinetic heterogeneity of the vesicle population; (ii) use the inactivation of the receptor by its natural ligand to reduce influx rates at high ligand concentrations to a measurable level (this permitted J(A), the influx rate coefficient before the onset of inactivation, to be measured); and (iii) determine the rate coefficients of two processes that lead to successive inactivations (desensitization) of the receptor and occur in different time regions. An extension of a model proposed for the E. electricus receptor accommodates the ion translocation in T. californica vesicles. The features in common are: (i) A rapid initial flux rate [J(A)(max) for T. californica is 310 sec(-1); for E. electricus it is 7.5 sec(-1)]. These differences in flux rates are consistent with a difference in AcChoR density. (ii) A rapid inactivation process [alpha(max) for T. californica is 2 sec(-1); for E. electricus it is 7 sec(-1)]. (iii) A slow AcChoR-controlled flux that continues after the rapid inactivation [J(I)(max) for T. californica is 1.3 sec(-1); for E. electricus it is 0.015 sec(-1)]. The main difference between the flux in the two types of vesicle is the existence of a second, slower, inactivation process in T. californica with a rate coefficient, beta, of 0.12 sec(-1). The second process leads to undetectable flux activity during the time of observation (30 sec in 10 mM carbamoylcholine). These studies are also significant because fundamental differences may exist between the mechanism of AcChoR-controlled ion flux in synaptic (Torpedo) and conducting (E. electricus) membranes.

Comparison of the interactions of a specific neurotoxin (alpha-bungarotoxin) with the acetylcholine receptor in Torpedo californica and Electrophorus electricus membrane preparations

alpha-Bungarotoxin, a snake neurotoxin, binds irreversibly and specifically to the acetylcholine receptor isolated from the electroplax of Electrophorus electricus and Torpedo species and has been an important tool in the study of the receptor-ligand binding mechanism. Two distinct kinetic processes have been observed in studies with membranes from E. electricus. A minimum mechanism for the toxin reaction involves (i) the reversible binding of two toxin molecules to the receptor prior to the irreversible formation of toxin receptor complexes and (ii) a toxin-induced conformational change of the receptor which leads to an increase in the affinity of the receptor binding sites for toxin [Hess, G. P., Bulger, J. E., Fu, J.-j. L., Hindy, E. F., & Silberstein, R. J. (1975) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 64, 1018-1027]. Only one process has been detected in Torpedo membranes. Here, we determine whether the receptors in Torpedo californica and E. electricus membranes have different properties or whether the measurements and their interpretation were responsible for the different results. Two methods which are frequently used in binding studies to separate free and bound toxin, a CM-52 cellulose minicolumn assay and DE-81 filter disk assay, have been compared. The results obtained indicate that the interaction of toxin with receptor from T. californica is similar to that observed with receptor from E. electricus. The apparent differences which have been reported in the literature are shown to have arisen from the design of the experiments in which T. californica membranes were used.

Mechanism of inactivation (desensitization) of acetylcholine receptor. Investigations by fast reaction techniques with membrane vesicles

Exposure of the acetylcholine receptor to acetylcholine, or its stable analogue carbamylcholine, inactivates (desensitizes) the receptor. Inactivation of receptor-controlled ion (86Rb+) flux in the presence of different concentrations of carbamylcholine (12.5 microM to 28 mM) was measured in the millisecond to minute time region, using a quench flow technique and membrane vesicles prepared from the electric organ of Electrophorus electricus. Three different kinetic measurements were made to establish the relationship between carbamylcholine concentration and the ion translocation process: (i) the rate of inactivation of the ion translocation process; (ii) the rate of recovery of the inactivated receptor upon removal of carbamylcholine; and (iii) the rate of the ion flux mediated by equilibrium mixtures of active and inactive receptor forms. The kinetics of these three processes follow single-exponential rate laws, and simple analytical expressions for their ligand concentration dependence could be used. Therefore, it was possible to determine the value of the rate constants in a scheme relating the ligand binding steps to ion translocation, and to predict the dependence of these rate constants on carbamylcholine concentration over the 200-fold range investigated.

Acetylcholine-induced cation translocation across cell membranes and inactivation of the acetylcholine receptor: chemical kinetic measurements in the millisecond time region

Acetylcholine-induced flux of inorganic ions across membranes and inactivation of the acetylcholine receptor were measured at pH 7.0, 1 degrees C, over a 5000-fold concentration range of acetylcholine. Receptor-containing electroplax membrane vesicles prepared from Electrophorus electricus and a quench-flow technique were used, allowing flux to be measured in the 2-msec to 1-min time region. Five different measurements were made: (i) rate of ion translocation with the active state of the receptor, (ii) rate of the slower ion translocation after equilibration of active and inactive receptor states, (iii) rate of inactivation, (iv) equilibrium between active and inactive forms of the receptor, and (v) reactivation of inactivated receptor. The kinetics of the steps in the receptor-controlled ion flux follow single-exponential rate laws, and simple analytical expressions for their ligand concentration dependence can be used. Thus, the rate and equilibrium constants in a scheme that relates the ligand binding steps to ion translocation could be evaluated. It was found that the dependence of the receptor-controlled ion translocation over the concentration range investigated obeys the integrated rate equation based on the proposed mechanism. The flux rate before inactivation was approximately 10(7) ions sec-1 per receptor, which is comparable with that measured electrophysiologically in muscle cells. The half-time of inactivation is approximately 100 msec when the receptor is saturated with acetylcholine. The specific reaction rate of the ion translocation (J) is 3 X 10(7) M-1 sec-1. The results support a minimum reaction mechanism previously proposed on the basis of experiments in which carbamylcholine was used.

Specific reaction rate of acetylcholine receptor-controlled ion translocation: a comparison of measurements with membrane vesicles and with muscle cells

The specific reaction rate (J) of the acetylcholine receptor-controlled ion translocation has been determined. In eel Ringer's solution (pH 7.0) at 1 degrees C, J = 3 X 10(7) M-1 sec-1. J is an intrinsic constant that is characteristic of the receptor and independent of other properties of a receptor-containing cell that also determine the rates of ion translocation. Membrane vesicles (prepared from the electric organ of Electrophorus electricus) and a flow-quench technique that has a millisecond time resolution were used to measure the receptor-controlled ion translocation. Using the value of J and the molar concentrations of receptor sites and inorganic ions, we calculated that 6 X 10(3) ions are translocated per msec per receptor. Analysis of electrical noise in frog muscle cells at temperatures above 8 degrees C [Nether, E. & Stevens, C. F. (1977) Annu. Rev. Biophys. Bioeng. 6, 345-381] gave a value of about 1 X 10(4) ions msec-1 per channel. Thus, each technique gives essentially the same result. It is now possible, therefore, to correlate the results obtained when receptor function is measured in two different ways in membrane vesicles and in muscle cells: (i) chemical kinetic measurements, using membrane vesicles, which relate the ligand binding and ion translocation processes and (ii) analysis of acetylcholine noise in muscle cells [Katz, B. & Miledi, R. (1972) J. Physiol. (London) 224, 665-699], which allows one to measure elementary steps in the formation of ion channels through the cell membrane.

Acetylcholine receptor-controlled ion flux in electroplax membrane vesicles: identification and characterization of membrane properties that affect ion flux measurements

Several intrinsic properties of acetylcholine receptor-rich membrane vesicles prepared from Electrophorus electricus, which need to be considered in measurements of receptor-mediated ion flux, have been identified. One of these properties is a slow exchange of inorganic ions in the vesicles. The slow exchange of ions is not related to the receptor-mediated flux of ions and accounts for 30-35% of the efflux observed. A method to separate this process from the receptor-controlled flux has been developed. It has also been shown, using a light-scattering method, that aggregation-disaggregation of the vesicles can interfere with the efflux measurements, and a method to overcome this problem has been developed. The difference in the amplitude of effluxes induced by saturating amounts of carbamylcholine and gramicidin has been investigated and has been shown not to be due to a receptor-controlled process; therefore, the amplitude difference does not need to be considered in understanding the receptor-controlled process.

Inactivation (desensitization) of the acetylcholine receptor in Electrophorus electricus membrane vesicles by carbamylcholine: comparison between ion flux and alpha-bungarotoxin binding

The inactivation (desensitization) of the acetylcholine receptor by carbamylcholine, a stable analogue of acetylcholine, has been investigated in eel Ringer's solution, pH 7.0, 0 degrees C, by measurements of (i) ion flux and (ii) the kinetics of the reaction of [125I]-alpha-bungarotoxin with the receptor. The effect of preincubation with carbamylcholine is significantly different in the two types of measurement. In both the receptor-controlled flux of inorganic ions and the toxin-binding kinetics a biphasic process has been observed (Hess, G.P., Lipkowitz, S., Struve, G.E., 1978, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 75:1703; Hess, G.P. et al., 1975, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 64:1018; Bulger, J.E. et al., 1977, Biochemistry 16:684), only the initial fast phase of which is inhibited and the subsequent slow phase persists. However, preincubation with carbamylcholine per se has no effect on the toxin reaction. The results obtained are consistent with the proposal of Katz and Thesleff (Katz, B., Thesleff, S., 1957, J. Physiol. (London) 138:65) that the active form of the receptor is converted to an inactive form in the presence of acetylcholine receptor ligands, and with our previous experiments (Hess et al., 1978) which indicated that one receptor form is responsible for the initial fast phase of both the receptor-controlled ion flux and the toxin binding reaction, and that its conversion to the other form results in the slow phases in these two measurements.

Direct spectroscopic studies of cation translocation by Torpedo acetylcholine receptor on a time scale of physiological relevance

The kinetics of carbamoylcholine-mediated cation transport across the membrane of vesicles containing acetylcholine receptor have been measured on the physiologically relevant time scale of a few milliseconds. The stopped-flow spectroscopic approach utilizes thallium(I) as the cation transported into sealed vesicles containing a water-soluble fluorophore. Upon entry of thallium(I), fluorescence quenching occurs by a heavy atom effect. Rapid thallium translocation into the vesicles is mediated by cholinergic agonists and is blocked by antagonists and neurotoxins and by desensitization. The kinetics of thallium transport are used to demonstrate that the four polypeptides known to comprise the receptor are the only protein components necessary for cation translocation. The kinetics of thallium(I) transport at saturating agonist concentrations are also used to calculate the apparent ion transport rate for a single receptor. The minimal value obtained is close to that for a single activated channel determined in vivo. This demonstrates that the physiological receptor has been isolated in intact form.

Activation, inactivation, and desensitization of acetylcholine receptor channel complex detected by binding of perhydrohistrionicotoxin

The effects of receptor activation were studied on the interaction of perhydrohistrionicotoxin (H(12)-HTX) with the ionic channel of the nicotinic acetylcholine (AcCho) receptor in membranes from the electric organ of Torpedo ocellata and with the endplate region of the soleus muscle of the rat. In Torpedo membranes, the initial rate (i.e., within 30 sec) of [(3)H]H(12)-HTX bindings to the ionic channel of the AcCho receptor was accelerated 10(2)- to 10(3)-fold in the presence of carbamoylcholine (Carb). H(12)-HTX also inhibited Carb-activated (22)Na(+) influx, over 95% inhibition at 10 muM H(12)-HTX. At this concentration H(12)-HTX did not inhibit [(3)H]AcCho binding to the AcCho-receptor sites. There was good correspondence between the degree of acceleration of [(3)H]H(12)-HTX binding and the stimulation of (22)Na(+) influx over a wide range of Carb concentrations (up to 100 muM). Preincubation of Torpedo membranes with Carb decreased the initial rate of [(3)H]H(12)-HTX binding, as well as the rate of (22)Na(+) influx, which may reflect desensitization of the AcCho-receptor. d-Tubocurarine inhibited the agonist-mediated acceleration of [(3)H]H(12)-HTX binding and (22)Na(+) influx. In the soleus muscle endplate, H(12)-HTX inhibited the transient depolarization induced by microiontophoretic application of AcCho; the more receptors activated and channels opened, the stronger was the inhibition by H(12)-HTX. These findings suggest that H(12)-HTX binds to closed and open ionic channels, with a preference for the latter conformation. It is also suggested that the conformational changes associated with activation or desensitization of the receptor can be monitored by studying binding of [(3)H]H(12)-HTX to the ionic channel sites as well as by the AcCho-receptor-regulated (22)Na(+) influx.

Molecular mechanism of acetylcholine receptor-controlled ion translocation across cell membranes

Two molecular processes, the binding of acetylcholine to the membrane-bound acetylcholine receptor protein and the receptor-controlled flux rates of specific inorganic ions, are essential in determining the electrical membrane potential of nerve and muscle cells. The measurements reported establish the relationship between the two processes: the acetylcholine receptor-controlled transmembrane ion flux of (86)Rb(+) and the concentration of carbamoylcholine, a stable analog of acetylcholine. A 200-fold concentration range of carbamoylcholine was used. The flux was measured in the millisecond-to-minute time region by using a quench flow technique with membrane vesicles prepared from the electric organ of Electrophorus electricus in eel Ringer's solution at pH 7.0 and 1 degrees C. The technique makes possible the study of the transmembrane transport of specific ions, with variable known internal and external ion concentrations, in a system in which a determinable number of receptors is exposed to a known concentration of ligand. The response curve of ion flux to ligand was sigmoidal with an average maximum rate of 84 sec(-1). Carbamoylcholine induced inactivation of the receptor with a maximum rate of 2.7 sec(-1) and a different ligand dependence so that it was fast relative to ion flux at low ligand concentration but slow relative to ion flux at high ligand concentration. The simplest model that fits the data consists of receptor in the active and inactive states in ligand-controlled equilibria. Receptor inactivation occurs with one or two ligand molecules bound. For channel opening, two ligand molecules bound to the active state are required, and cooperativity results from the channel opening process itself. With carbamoylcholine, apparently, the equilibrium position for the channel opening step is only one-fourth open. The integrated rate equation, based on the model, predicts the time dependence of receptor-controlled ion flux over the concentration range of carbamoylcholine investigated. The values of the constants in the rate equation form the basis for predicting receptor-controlled changes in the transmembrane potential of cells and the conditions leading to transmission of signals between cells.

Purification and characterization of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors from muscle

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor was purified from normal and denervated rat skeletal muscle. The purification protocol included alpha-cobratoxin biospecific adsorption, ion exchange chromatography, and gel filtration steps. The highest specific activity achieved was 7.5 pmol of 125I-alpha-bungarotoxin binding sites per microgram protein. Sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis of purified AChR revealed subunits with molecular weights of 42,000 and 66,000 daltons and a minor component with a molecular weight of 52,000 daltons. Normal muscle AChR is comprised of one toxin binding component. Upon denervation a second component appears, but both components are increased as a consequence of denervation. A dissociation constant of 1.5 x 10(-8)M was determined for d-tubocurarine from receptor from both normal and denervated muscle. A dissociation constant of 1 x 10(-7)M for acetylcholine, perhaps analogous to the high affinity acetylcholine binding observed in electric fish receptor, was determined.