Early expression of a T-cell receptor beta-chain transgene suppresses rearrangement of the V gamma 4 gene segment

N6 - Methyladenosine defines a new checkpoint in γδ T cell development

T cells, which are derived from hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs), are the most important components of adaptive immune system. Based on the expression of αβ and γδ receptors, T cells are mainly divided into αβ and γδ T cells. In the thymus, they share common progenitor cells, while undergoing a series of well-characterized and different developmental processes. N⁶ -Methyladenosine (m⁶ A), one of the most abundant modifications in mRNAs, plays critical roles in cell development and maintenance of function. Recently, we have demonstrated that the depletion of m⁶ A demethylase ALKBH5 in lymphocytes specifically induces an expansion of γδ T cells through the regulation of Jag1/Notch2 signaling, but not αβ T cells, indicating a checkpoint role of ALKBH5 and m⁶ A modification in the early development of γδ T cells. Based on previous studies, many key pathway molecules, which exert dominant roles in γδ T cell fate determination, have been identified as the targets regulated by m⁶ A modification. In this review, we mainly summarize the potential regulation between m⁶ A modification and these key signaling molecules in the γδ T cell lineage commitment, to provide new perspectives in the checkpoint of γδ T cell development.

TCR beta feedback signals inhibit the coupling of recombinationally accessible V beta 14 segments with DJ beta complexes

Ag receptor allelic exclusion is thought to occur through monoallelic initiation and subsequent feedback inhibition of recombinational accessibility. However, our previous analysis of mice containing a V(D)J recombination reporter inserted into Vbeta14 (Vbeta14(Rep)) indicated that Vbeta14 chromatin accessibility is biallelic. To determine whether Vbeta14 recombinational accessibility is subject to feedback inhibition, we analyzed TCRbeta rearrangements in Vbeta14(Rep) mice containing a preassembled in-frame transgenic Vbeta8.2Dbeta1Jbeta1.1 or an endogenous Vbeta14Dbeta1Jbeta1.4 rearrangement on the homologous chromosome. Expression of either preassembled VbetaDJbetaC beta-chain accelerated thymocyte development because of enhanced cellular selection, demonstrating that the rate-limiting step in early alphabeta T cell development is the assembly of an in-frame VbetaDJbeta rearrangement. Expression of these preassembled VbetaDJbeta rearrangements inhibited endogenous Vbeta14-to-DJbeta rearrangements as expected. However, in contrast to results predicted by the accepted model of TCRbeta feedback inhibition, we found that expression of these preassembled TCR beta-chains did not downregulate recombinational accessibility of Vbeta14 chromatin. Our findings suggest that TCRbeta-mediated feedback inhibition of Vbeta14 rearrangements depends on inherent properties of Vbeta14, Dbeta, and Jbeta recombination signal sequences.

TCR-beta chains derived from peripheral gammadelta T cells can take part in alphabeta T-cell development

Between 10 and 20% of the peripheral gammadelta T cells express cytoplasmic TCR-beta proteins, but whether such TCR-beta chains can partake in alphabeta T-cell development has never been systematically investigated. Therefore, we reconstituted the T-cell compartment of CD3epsilon-deficient mice with Pax5-TCR-beta deficient proB cells expressing, via a retroviral vector, TCR-beta chains from either peripheral gammadelta or alphabeta T cells. Recipient thymi reconstituted with proB cells containing empty vector were small (<15x10(6) cells), contained few gammadelta T but no alphabeta T cells. In contrast, thymi from mice receiving proB cells containing gammadelta or alphabeta T-cell-derived TCR-beta chains contained 80-130x10(6) cells, and showed a normal CD4, CD8 and alphabeta TCR expression pattern. However, regardless of the source of TCR-beta chain, reconstituted mice rapidly showed signs of autoimmunity dying 5-15 wk following reconstitution. Autoimmune disease induction could be prevented by co-transfer of Treg cells thereby allowing the functionality of the generated T cells to be assessed. Results obtained show that TCR-beta chains from gammadelta T cells can efficiently take part in alphabeta T-cell development. The implications of these findings for gammadelta T-cell development will be discussed.

Molecular mechanisms that control mouse and human TCR-alphabeta and TCR-gammadelta T cell development

Following specification of hematopoietic precursor cells into the T cell lineage, several developmental options remain available to the immature thymocytes. The paradigm is that the outcome of the T cell receptor rearrangements and the corresponding T cell receptor signaling events will be predominant to determine the first of these choices: the alphabeta versus gammadelta T cell pathways. Here, we review the thymus-derived environmental signals, the transcriptional mediators, and other molecular mechanisms that are also involved in this decision in both the mouse and human. We discuss the differences in cellular events between the alphabeta and gammadelta developmental pathways and try to correlate these with a corresponding complexity of the molecular mechanisms that support them.

The thymus chapter in the life of gut-specific intra epithelial lymphocytes

The intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL) represent multi-lineage T cell populations. In addition to a major gammadeltaTCR(+) T cell subset, many IEL express alphabetaTCRs and they can be separated into alphabeta sublineages. Some TCRalphabeta(+)IEL have characteristics in common with conventional TCRalphabeta(+)T cells whereas others share an unconventional phenotype with their TCRgammadelta(+) counterparts. Because the latter are enriched for autoreactive TCRs and can be generated in the absence of a thymus, it has long been postulated that some IEL subsets develop locally in the intestine. Several new data however, indicate that under physiological conditions, IEL require a thymic education that directs lineage commitment and functional differentiation. This review will discuss the contributions of the thymus in shaping the various intestinal IEL sublineages.

A critical lineage-nonspecific role for pTalpha in mediating allelic and isotypic exclusion in TCRbeta-transgenic mice

Although it is well established that early expression of TCRbeta transgenes in the thymus leads to efficient inhibition of both endogenous TCRbeta and TCRgamma rearrangement (also known as allelic and "isotypic" exclusion, respectively) the role of pTalpha in these processes remains controversial. Here, we have systematically re-evaluated this issue using three independent strains of TCRbeta-transgenic mice that differ widely in transgene expression levels, and a sensitive intracellular staining assay that detects endogenous TCRVbeta expression in individual immature thymocytes. In the absence of pTalpha, both allelic and isotypic exclusion were reversed in all three TCRbeta-transgenic strains, clearly demonstrating a general requirement for pre-TCR signaling in the inhibition of endogenous TCRbeta and TCRgamma rearrangement. Both allelic and isotypic exclusion were pTalpha dose dependent when transgenic TCRbeta levels were subphysiological. Moreover, pTalpha-dependent allelic and isotypic exclusion occurred in both alphabeta and gammadelta T cell lineages, indicating that pre-TCR signaling can potentially be functional in gammadelta precursors. Finally, levels of endogenous RAG1 and RAG2 were not down-regulated in TCRbeta-transgenic immature thymocytes undergoing allelic or isotypic exclusion. Collectively, our data reveal a critical but lineage-nonspecific role for pTalpha in mediating both allelic and isotypic exclusion in TCRbeta-transgenic mice.

TCR and Notch synergize in αβ versus γδ lineage choice

At two checkpoints, T cell development is controlled by T cell receptor (TCR) signaling, which determines survival and lineage commitment. At the first of these checkpoints, signaling by the pre-TCR, the gammadeltaTCR or the alphabetaTCR has a major but nonexclusive impact on whether cells will become CD4-CD8- gammadelta or CD4+CD8+ alphabeta lineage cells. Pre-TCR signals synergize with moderate Notch signals to generate alphabeta lineage cells. Relatively strong signals by the gammadeltaTCR (or early expressed alphabetaTCR) in the absence of Notch signaling are sufficient to yield gammadelta lineage cells. However, relatively weak signals of the latter two receptors combined with strong Notch signaling result in the formation of alphabeta lineage cells that generate a diverse alphabetaTCR repertoire in pre-TCR-deficient mice. It remains to be determined whether TCR and/or Notch signals instruct or confirm predetermined lineage fate.

The TCRbeta enhancer is dispensable for the expression of rearranged TCRbeta genes in thymic DN2/DN3 populations but not at later stages

The Ebeta enhancer has been shown to be dispensable for germline transcription of nonrearranged TCRbeta segments but appears to be required for TCRbeta V to DJ rearrangement. Ebeta dependency of the subsequent expression of VDJ-rearranged TCRbeta genes in thymic subpopulations has so far not been analyzed. We generated transgenic mice, using a Vbeta8.2Dbeta1Jbeta1.3-rearranged TCRbeta bacterial artificial chromosome, which lacked Ebeta, and monitored transgene expression by flow cytometry using Vbeta-specific mAbs and an IRES-eGFP reporter. Transgene expression was found in double negative (DN)2 and DN3 but not at later stages of thymopoesis. There was no toxicity associated with the transgene given that apoptosis in DN3, DN4 was not increased, and the number of DN4 cells generated from DN3 cells in reaggregate thymic organ cultures was not diminished. The transgenic TCRbeta gave rise to a pre-TCR, as suggested by its ability to suppress endogenous TCRbeta rearrangement, to facilitate beta-selection on a TCRbeta-deficient background and to inhibit gammadelta T cell lineage development. The results suggest that the Vbeta8.2 promoter is sufficient to drive expression of rearranged TCRbeta VDJ genes Ebeta independently in DN2/DN3 but not at later stages.

Lymphotoxin-mediated regulation of gammadelta cell differentiation by alphabeta T cell progenitors

The thymus gives rise to two T cell lineages, alphabeta and gammadelta, that are thought to develop independently of one another. Hence, double positive (DP) thymocytes expressing CD4 and CD8 coreceptors are usually viewed simply as progenitors of CD4+ and CD8+ alphabeta T cells. Instead we report that DP cells regulate the differentiation of early thymocyte progenitors and gammadelta cells, by a mechanism dependent on the transcription factor RORgt, and the lymphotoxin (LT) beta receptor (LTbetaR). This finding provokes a revised view of the thymus, in which lymphoid tissue induction-type processes coordinate the developmental and functional integration of the two T cell lineages.

Early Expression of a Functional TCRβ Chain Inhibits TCRγ Gene Rearrangements without Altering the Frequency of TCRγδ Lineage Cells

To investigate the consequences of the simultaneous expression in progenitor cells of a TCRgammadelta and a pre-TCR on alphabeta/gammadelta lineage commitment, we have forced expression of functionally rearranged TCRbeta, TCRgamma, and TCRdelta chains by means of transgenes. Mice transgenic for the three TCR chains contain numbers of gammadelta thymocytes comparable to those of mice transgenic for both TCRgamma and TCRdelta chains, and numbers of alphabeta thymocytes similar to those found in mice solely transgenic for a rearranged TCRbeta chain gene. gammadelta T cells from the triple transgenic mice express the transgenic TCRbeta chain, but do not express a TCRalpha chain, and, by a number of phenotypic and molecular parameters, appear to be bona fide gammadelta thymocytes. Our results reveal a remarkable degree of independence in the generation of alphabeta and gammadelta lineage cells from progenitor cells that, in theory, could simultaneously express a TCRgammadelta and a pre-TCR.

Facilitation of beta selection and modification of positive selection in the thymus of PD-1-deficient mice

PD-1 is an immunoglobulin superfamily member bearing an immunoreceptor tyrosine-based inhibitory motif, and disruption of the PD-1 gene results in the development of lupus-like autoimmune diseases. In this study, we examined effects of the PD-1 deficiency on the thymocyte differentiation at the clonal level using T cell receptor (TCR)-beta (Vbeta8) and TCR-alpha/beta (H-Y and 2C) transgenic mice. In these TCR transgenic lines, PD-1 expression in the thymus was variably augmented, but as in the normal mice, confined largely to the CD4(-)CD8(-) thymocytes. The transgenic mice crossed with PD-1(-/)- mice in the neutral genetic backgrounds exhibited selective increase in the CD4(+)CD8(+) (DP) population with little effect on other thymocytes subsets. Similarly, the absence of PD-1 facilitated expansion of DP thymocytes in recombination activating gene (RAG)-2(-/)- mice by anti-CD3epsilon antibody injection. On the other hand, H-Y or 2C transgenic PD-1(-/)- mice with the positively selecting background showed significantly reduced efficiency for the generation of CD8(+) single positive cells bearing the transgenic TCR-alpha/beta in spite of the increased DP population. These results collectively indicate that PD-1 negatively regulates the beta selection and modulates the positive selection, and suggest that PD-1 deficiency may lead to the significant alteration of mature T cell repertoire.

The common cytokine receptor gamma chain and the pre-T cell receptor provide independent but critically overlapping signals in early alpha/beta T cell development

Intracellular signals emanating from cytokine and antigen receptors are integrated during the process of intrathymic development. Still, the relative contributions of cytokine receptor signaling to pre-T cell receptor (TCR) and TCR-mediated differentiation remain undefined. Interleukin (IL)-7 interactions with its cognate receptor complex (IL-7Ralpha coupled to the common cytokine receptor gamma chain, gammac) play a dominant role in early thymopoiesis. However, alpha/beta T cell development in IL-7-, IL-7Ralpha-, and gammac-deficient mice is only partially compromised, suggesting that additional pathways can rescue alpha/beta T lineage cells in these mice. We have investigated the potential interdependence of gammac- and pre-TCR-dependent pathways during intrathymic alpha/beta T cell differentiation. We demonstrate that gammac-dependent cytokines do not appear to be required for normal pre-TCR function, and that the rate-limiting step in alpha/beta T cell development in gammac- mice does not involve TCR-beta chain rearrangements, but rather results from poor maintenance of early thymocytes. Moreover, mice double mutant for both gammac and pre-Talpha show vastly reduced thymic cellularity and a complete arrest of thymocyte differentiation at the CD44(+)CD25(+) cell stage. These observations demonstrate that the pre-TCR provides the gammac-independent signal which allows alpha/beta T cell development in gammac- mice. Thus, a series of overlapping signals derived from cytokine and T cell receptors guide the process of alpha/beta thymocyte development.

On the role of the pre-T cell receptor in alphabeta versus gammadelta T lineage commitment

The role of the pre-T cell receptor (TCR) in lineage commitment to the gammadelta versus alphabeta lineage of T cells was addressed by analyzing TCRbeta chain rearrangements in gammadelta T cells from wild-type and pre-TCR-deficient mice by single cell polymerase chain reaction. Results show that the pre-TCR selects against gammadelta T cells containing rearranged Vbeta genes and that gammadelta T cell precursors but not gammadelta T cells express the pre-TCRalpha protein. Furthermore, pre-TCR-induced proliferation could not be detected in gammadelta T cells. We propose that the pre-TCR commits developing T cells to the alphabeta lineage by an instructive mechanism that has largely replaced an evolutionary more ancient stochastic mechanism of lineage commitment.

Crucial function of the pre-T-cell receptor (TCR) in TCR beta selection, TCR beta allelic exclusion and alpha beta versus gamma delta lineage commitment

The analysis of T-cell receptor (TCR) beta selection, TCR beta allelic exclusion and TCR beta rearrangement in gamma delta T cells from normal and pre-TCR-deficient mice has shown that the pre-TCR has a crucial role in T-lymphocyte development: The pre-TCR is by far the most effective receptor that generates large numbers of CD4+8+ T cells with productive TCR beta rearrangements. In the absence of the pre-TCR, TCR beta rearrangement proceeds in developing cells irrespective of whether they already contain a productive TCR beta gene. The pre-TCR directs developing T cells to the alpha beta lineage because gamma delta T cells from pT alpha-/- mice proceed much further in TCR beta rearrangement than gamma delta T cells from wild-type mice. It is argued that the pre-TCR commits developing T cells to the alpha beta lineage by an instructive mechanism, which has largely replaced an evolutionarily more ancient mechanism that involves stochastic alpha beta lineage commitment.

A TCR alpha chain transgene induces maturation of CD4- CD8- alpha beta+ T cells from gamma delta T cell precursors

The proportion of CD4- CD8- double-negative (DN) alpha beta T cells is increased both in the thymus and in peripheral lymphoid organs of TCR alpha chain-transgenic mice. In this report we have characterized this T cell population to elucidate its relationship to alpha beta and gamma delta T cells. We show that the transgenic DN cells are phenotypically similar to gamma delta T cells but distinct from DN NK T cells. The precursors of DN cells have neither rearranged endogenous TCR alpha genes nor been negatively selected by the MIsa antigen, suggesting that they originate from a differentiation stage before the onset of TCR alpha chain rearrangements and CD4/CD8 gene expression. Neither in-frame V delta D delta J delta nor V gamma J gamma rearrangements are over-represented in this population. However, since peripheral gamma delta T cells with functional TCR beta gene rearrangements have been depleted in the transgenics, we propose that the transgenic DN population, at least partially, originates from the precursors of those cells. The present data lend support to the view that maturation signals to gamma delta lineage-committed precursors can be delivered via TCR alpha beta heterodimers.

Alpha beta lineage-committed thymocytes can be rescued by the gamma delta T cell receptor (TCR) in the absence of TCR beta chain

Commitment of the alpha beta and gamma delta T cell lineages within the thymus has been studied in T cell receptor (TCR)-transgenic and TCR mutant murine strains. TCR gamma delta-transgenic or TCR beta knockout mice, both of which are unable to generate TCR alpha beta-positive T cells, develop phenotypically alpha beta-like thymocytes in significant proportions. We provide evidence that in the absence of functional TCR beta protein, the gamma delta TCR can promote the development of alpha beta-like thymocytes, which, however, do not expand significantly and do not mature into gamma delta T cells. These results show that commitment to the alpha beta lineage can be determined independently of the isotype of the TCR, and suggest that alpha beta versus gamma delta T cell lineage commitment is principally regulated by mechanisms distinct from TCR-mediated selection. To accommodate our data and those reported previously on the effect of TCR gamma and delta gene rearrangements on alpha beta T cell development, we propose a model in which lineage commitment occurs independently of TCR gene rearrangement.

Separately expressed T cell receptor alpha and beta chain transgenes exert opposite effects on T cell differentiation and neoplastic transformation

Two aspects of T cell differentiation in T cell receptor (TCR)-transgenic mice, the generation of an unusual population of CD4-CD8-TCR+ thymocytes and the absence of gamma delta cells, have been the focus of extensive investigation. To examine the basis for these phenomena, we investigated the effects of separate expression of a transgenic TCR alpha chain and a transgenic TCR beta chain on thymocyte differentiation. Our data indicate that expression of a transgenic TCR alpha chain causes thymocytes to differentiate into a CD4-CD8-TCR+ lineage at an early developmental stage, depleting the number of thymocytes that differentiate into the alpha beta lineage. Surprisingly, expression of the TCR alpha chain transgene is also associated with the development of T cell lymphosarcoma. In contrast, expression of the transgenic TCR beta chain causes immature T cells to accelerate differentiation into the alpha beta lineage and thus inhibits the generation of gamma delta cells. Our observations provide a model for understanding T cell differentiation in TCR-transgenic mice.

Prethymic expression of a transgenic TCR beta chain on a precursor of T-cells

Mice carrying a rearranged TCR Vbeta 8.2 transgene express the Vbeta protein on the vast majority of peripheral T-cells. The bone marrow and peripheral blood, as well as other lymphoid organs of both untreated animals and animals depleted of T-cells by neonatal thymectomy and/or injection from birth of monoclonal anti-TCR antibodies, contain a small population of cells that express low levels of the Vbeta transgene product, but no T-cell or other detectable lineage-specific phenotypic markers. When such TG-bearing BM cells are purified and injected directly into the non-TG thymus, they show the phenotypic maturation sequences of intrathymic T-cell development and, subsequently, mature TG-bearing peripheral T-cells. However, this population failed to support long-term recovery from lethal irradiation. Both Vbeta 8.2 TG and CD3delta mRNA transcripts are strongly expressed in the cell population, but no CD3gamma, CD3epsilon, CD3zeta, CD4, CD8beta, pre-Talpha, or RAG-1 transcript was detected. The transgene-encoded TCR component is not bound to the cell membrane exclusively by a phosphatidylinositol linkage. The data show that the fully rearranged TCR transgene and transcripts for at least one of the associated CD3 components, CD3delta, can be expressed on a subpopulation of BM and PBL cells that has not passed through the thymus. The phenotypic characteristics of this cell population resemble those described for the earliest thymocyte described by others. The TG protein molecule in this model may provide a specific developmental marker for a prothymocyte lineage subset that lacks pluripotential properties.

Allelic exclusion in pTalpha-deficient mice: no evidence for cell surface expression of two T cell receptor (TCR)-beta chains, but less efficient inhibition of endogeneous Vbeta--> (D)Jbeta rearrangements in the presence of a functional TCR-beta transgene

Although individual T lymphocytes have the potential to generate two distinct T cell receptor (TCR)-beta chains, they usually express only one allele, a phenomenon termed allelic exclusion. Expression of a functional TCR-beta chain during early T cell development leads to the formation of a pre-T cell receptor (pre-TCR) complex and, at the same developmental stage, arrest of further TCR-beta rearrangements, suggesting a role of the pre-TCR in mediating allelic exclusion. To investigate the potential link between pre-TCR formation and inhibition of further TCR-beta rearrangements, we have studied the efficiency of allelic exclusion in mice lacking the pre-TCR-alpha (pTalpha) chain, a core component of the pre-TCR. Staining of CD3+ thymocytes and lymph node cells with antibodies specific for Vbeta6 or Vbeta8 and a pool of antibodies specific for most other Vbeta elements, did not reveal any violation of allelic exclusion at the level of cell surface expression. This was also true for pTalpha-deficient mice expressing a functionally rearranged TCR-beta transgene. Interestingly, although the transgenic TCR-beta chain significantly influenced thymocyte development even in the absence of pTalpha, it was not able to inhibit fully endogeneous TCR-beta rearrangements either in total thymocytes or in sorted CD25+ pre-T cells of pTalpha-/- mice, clearly indicating an involvement of the pre-TCR in allelic exclusion.

Early alpha beta T cell development in the thymus of normal and genetically altered mice

The vast majority of T lymphocytes, with the exception of gut-associated, intraepithelial lymphocytes, differentiate and mature inside the thymus. Early T cell development is characterized by expansion and differentiation of thymocytes which do not yet express mature TCRs on their cell surface. Important events in early thymocyte development are controlled by a pre-TCR complex consisting of a conventional TCR beta chain and a novel transmembrane protein termed pre-TCR alpha (p T alpha chain) which are noncovalently associated with components of CD3. Recent studies of pre-TCR function have led to a better understanding of the molecular events in early thymocyte development.

The alpha beta T cell receptor can replace the gamma delta receptor in the development of gamma delta lineage cells

In peripheral lymphoid tissues of TCR transgenic mice that express the nominal antigen (HY peptide plus H-2Db MHC) recognized by the transgenic TCR, there exist unusual CD4-CD8- and CD4-CD8low cells bearing the transgenic TCR. Here we show that, unlike TCR alpha beta T cells that are generated in the absence of nominal antigen, these unusual cells do not express endogenous TCR alpha genes, have maintained the TCR delta locus on both chromosomes, and can coexpress TCR alpha beta and TCR gamma delta chains on the cell surface. The latter is also true for CD4-CD8-, HSA+ TCR alpha beta + thymocytes in male and female TCR transgenic mice. The number of TCR alpha beta and TCR gamma delta coexpressing cells is increased in pre-TCR-deficient mice. The data indicate that the TCR alpha beta can replace the TCR gamma delta in the development of gamma delta lineage cells and that the pre-TCR interferes with the generation of gamma delta-expressing cells.

Composition and function of T-cell receptor and B-cell receptor complexes on precursor lymphocytes

The precursor T-cell receptors (TCRs) and B-cell receptors (BCRs) direct lymphocyte development to the mature T-cell and B-cell stage, respectively. Recent genetic and biochemical experiments reveal the striking parallel in structure and function of these receptors. They consist of TCR beta and BCR mu chains paired with surrogate TCR alpha and BCR light chains. Both receptors employ a two-component signal transduction unit: CD3 gamma epsilon for the pre-TCR, and CD79ab for the pre-BCR. Plasma membrane levels of pre-TCR/BCR complexes are kept extremely low, most probably by a mechanism involving specific retention in the endoplasmic reticulum. This mechanism may control the signalling activity of pre-TCR/BCR and therewith the lymphocyte differentiation process.

Evidence that productive rearrangements of TCR gamma genes influence the commitment of progenitor cells to differentiate into alpha beta or gamma delta T cells

Two models have been considered to account for the differentiation of gamma delta and alpha beta T cells from a common hematopoietic progenitor cell. In one model, progenitor cells commit to a lineage before T cell receptor (TCR) rearrangement occurs. In the other model, progenitor cells first undergo rearrangement of TCR gamma, delta, or both genes, and cells that succeed in generating a functional receptor commit to the gamma delta lineage, while those that do not proceed to attempt complete beta and subsequently alpha gene rearrangements. A prediction of the latter model is that TCR gamma rearrangements present in alpha beta T cells will be nonproductive. We tested this hypothesis by examining V gamma 2-J gamma 1C gamma 1 rearrangements, which are commonly found in alpha beta T cells. The results indicate that V gamma 2-J gamma 1C gamma 1 rearrangements in purified alpha beta T cell populations are almost all nonproductive. The low frequency of productive rearrangements of V gamma 2 in alpha beta T cells is apparently not due to a property of the rearrangement machinery, because a transgenic rearrangement substrate, in which the V gamma 2 gene harbored a frame-shift mutation that prevents expression at the protein level, was often rearranged in a productive configuration in alpha beta T cells. The results suggest that progenitor cells which undergo productive rearrangement of their endogenous V gamma 2 gene are selectively excluded from the alpha beta T cell lineage.

Alpha beta and gamma delta T cells can share a late common precursor

BACKGROUND

The subdivision of T cells into alpha beta and gamma delta subtypes is conserved throughout vertebrate development. The respective alpha beta and gamma delta T-cell receptors (TCRs) are encoded by somatically rearranged genes. There has been broad speculation as to whether an individual thymocyte can become either a gamma delta T cell or an alpha beta T cell as a result of stochastic gene rearrangement processes, or whether the two types of T cell are derived from separate lineages. Many of the experimental findings are apparently conflicting, however, and the issue--a basic one in immunology and development--remains unresolved.

RESULTS

To address this issue, we have used the recently developed polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) technique, which allows us to examine quantitatively the status of TCR gamma and delta genes in postnatal alpha beta T cells and their progenitors. Interestingly, such cells are depleted of productively rearranged delta and gamma genes, which can encode delta and gamma TCR polypeptide chains. However, in mice that can rearrange TCR delta gene segments, but in which the TCR delta gene is non-functional in other respects, no such depletion of productive rearrangements is seen.

CONCLUSION

The quantitative data that we have obtained fulfill the predictions of the stochastic hypothesis: that is, a progenitor T cell first attempts to become a gamma delta T cell and, if unsuccessful, then attempts to become an alpha beta T cell. Thus, alpha beta and gamma delta T cells can derive from a common precursor thymocyte. In the simplest case, therefore, lineage-determining factors are the successful rearrangement of both gamma and delta genes before TCR alpha gene rearrangements occur, which lead to deletion of the TCR delta locus and thereby preclude further gamma delta T-cell differentiation. In contrast, successful rearrangement of the TCR beta locus remains compatible with cells becoming either gamma delta or alpha beta T cells.

Analysis and expression of a cloned pre-T cell receptor gene

The T cell antigen receptor (TCR) beta chain regulates early T cell development in the absence of the TCR alpha chain. The developmentally controlled gene described here encodes the pre-TCR alpha (pT alpha) chain, which covalently associates with TCR beta and with the CD3 proteins forms a pre-TCR complex that transduces signals in immature thymocytes. Unlike the lambda 5 pre-B cell receptor protein, the pT alpha chain is a type I transmembrane protein whose cytoplasmic tail contains two potential phosphorylation sites and a Src homology 3 (SH3)-domain binding sequence. Pre-TCR alpha transfection experiments indicated that surface expression of the pre-TCR is controlled by additional developmentally regulated proteins. Identification of the pT alpha gene represents an essential step in the structure-function analysis of the pre-TCR complex.

Costimulation by interleukin-1 of multiple activation responses in a developmentally restricted subset of immature thymocytes

An intriguing feature of thymocyte differentiation is that the competence to express both interleukin-(IL)2 and CD25 is acquired even prior to T cell receptor (TcR) expression. When T cell receptor-independent stimuli are used, immature cells can express IL-2 at levels comparable to mature cells, but unlike the mature cells, immature cells require IL-1 as a costimulus. Here we present evidence that IL-1 affects a variety of responses by members of the CD25+ subset of immature thymocytes. Cells in this population are IL-1 dependent not only for induction of IL-2 expression, but also for high-level maintenance of CD25 expression. CD25 expression is amplified by IL-1 through a mechanism highly sensitive to changes in Ca2+ ionophore concentration. The effects of IL-1 on CD25 maintenance are not mediated by IL-2, because of the divergent effects of cAMP on IL-2 and CD25 expression. IL-1 costimulation also increases RNA accumulation in the cell cycle, and this effect too seems to be separable from the effects on IL-2 and CD25 expression. All these effects of IL-1 are developmentally stage-specific, manifest in the CD25+ subset of immature thymocytes but not in later-stage thymocytes or splenic T cells. Multiparameter cell sorting experiments that dissect the transitional stages between immature and TcR+ thymocytes imply that all immature cells pass through an IL-1 responsive state. Responsiveness to IL-1 costimulation is then lost by these cells, apparently irreversibly, at a stage just prior to detectable cell-surface TcR expression. These results indicate that IL-1 responsiveness is a defining characteristic of the activation physiology of cells in a particularly important developmental stage.

Gld and lpr mice: single gene mutant models for failed self tolerance

Mice homozygous for the gld or lpr mutations develop autoimmunity, and a lymphoproliferative disorder involving accumulation of huge numbers of unusual CD4-CD8-TCR alpha beta lo T cells. Here we review our past work with gld mice, and attempt to explain lymphoproliferation in terms of current models of T cell maturation and self-tolerance induction. The availability of molecular probes to the gene products of lpr and gld should shortly lead to a better understanding of the acquisition of self tolerance during T cell maturation and of autoimmunity.

T cell receptor beta chain dimers on immature thymocytes from normal mice

During T cell development the T cell receptor (TCR) beta chain is expressed before the TCR alpha chain. Experiments in TCR beta transgenic severe combined immune deficiency (SCID) mice have shown that the TCR beta protein can be expressed on the cell surface of immature thymocytes in the absence of the TCR alpha chain and that the TCR beta protein controls T cell development with regard to cell number, CD4/CD8 expression and allelic exclusion of the TCR beta chain. Subsequent experiments have shown that on the surface of thymocytes from TCR beta transgenic SCID mice the TCR beta protein can be expressed in a monomeric and dimeric form whereas only the dimeric form was found on the surface of a TCR beta-transfected, immature T cell line. The results presented here show that normal thymocytes from 16-day-old fetuses likewise express only the dimeric form and that the monomeric form on the surface of thymocytes from transgenic mice results from glycosyl phosphatidylinositol linkage. Our results show for the first time that under physiological conditions a TCR beta dimer can be expressed on the cell surface without the TCR alpha chain.

Mutations in T-cell antigen receptor genes alpha and beta block thymocyte development at different stages

Analysis of mice carrying mutant T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) genes indicates that TCR-beta gene rearrangement or expression is critical for the differentiation of CD4-CD8- thymocytes to CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, as well as for the expansion of the pool of CD4+CD8+ cells. TCR-alpha is irrelevant in these developmental processes. The development of gamma delta T cells does not depend on either TCR-alpha or TCR-beta.

Apoptosis in the development of the immune system: growth factors, clonal selection and bcl-2

The mammalian immune system is essential for surviving challenge infections with a great range of potential pathogens. The protective effect produced is dependent on many different types of cells which require flexible and independent production and regulation. In particular, many important responses are carried out by lymphocytes, which recognise foreign antigen through exquisitely specific receptors: i.e. surface immunoglobulin (sIg) on B lymphocytes and the T cell receptor (TCR) on T lymphocytes. Each lymphocyte displays receptors with a single specificity, allowing cells with particular specificities to be regulated independently. Since millions of different Igs and TCRs are expressed, the precise selection and regulation of each T and B cell population to produce a useful self-tolerant repertoire is a very complex process. Control of cell populations can, in theory, be exercised at a number of levels, including modulation of active cell death by apoptosis. Recent research has demonstrated that regulation of apoptosis is indeed a crucial element in the control of the immune system in general, and in the development of the TCR and Ig repertoires in particular. The molecular analysis of apoptosis now takes a high priority and the proto-oncogene bcl-2 appears to be responsible for specific suppression of apoptosis in several important situations. It is also clear that malfunctions affecting apoptosis, and in particular bcl-2, can result in significant progression towards malignancy.

Inhibition of abnormal T cell development and autoimmunity in gld mice by transgenic T cell receptor beta chain

Mice homozygous for the gld (generalized lymphoproliferative disease) mutation developed systemic autoimmune disease and severe lymphadenopathy due to an age-related accumulation in the peripheral lymphoid organs of polyclonal T cells bearing a unique phenotype (CD4-CD8-TCR alpha beta+B220+). These T cells overexpress T cell receptor (TcR) alpha beta chain RNA, proto-oncogenes c-myb and fyn, and proliferate poorly in response to TcR-mediated stimulation. The origin of these T cells is poorly understood. To study the influence of a functionally rearranged TcR beta chain on the T cell developmental abnormality of the gld mutation and autoimmunity, we have backcrossed TcR V beta 8.1-transgenic mice to C3H-gld/gld to homozygosity (transgenic gld mice). In transgenic gld mice, lymphadenopathy was markedly inhibited and the accumulation of CD4-CD8- T cells did not occur, although the remaining T cells overexpressed c-myb and proliferated poorly in response to TcR occupancy. These features indicate that the pattern of proto-oncogene expression and abnormal function persist in phenotypically normal T cells in transgenic gld mice, and that these characteristics can be dissociated from the accumulation of CD4-CD8- T cells. The hypergammaglobulinemia and anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibody production was partially improved in transgenic gld mice, supporting the critical role of T cells in abnormal B cell activation described in autoimmunity-prone mice. To investigate further the mechanisms underlying the inhibition of CD4-CD8- T cell accumulation in transgenic gld mice, the fetal ontogeny of T cells in transgenic mice was compared with that of non-transgenic mice. In transgenic thymus, development of TcR alpha beta+ cells was accelerated as detected by earlier expression of CD4, CD8 and TcR in fetal thymus. In contrast, the number of TcR gamma delta+ cells was reduced. We suggest that altered T cell development in transgenic mice directly or indirectly inhibits the accumulation of abnormal T cells in gld mice.

The development of functionally responsive T cells

The work reviewed in this article separates T cell development into four phases. First is an expansion phase prior to TCR rearrangement, which appears to be correlated with programming of at least some response genes for inducibility. This phase can occur to some extent outside of the thymus. However, the profound T cell deficit of nude mice indicates that the thymus is by far the most potent site for inducing the expansion per se, even if other sites can induce some response acquisition. Second is a controlled phase of TCR gene rearrangement. The details of the regulatory mechanism that selects particular loci for rearrangement are still not known. It seems that the rearrangement of the TCR gamma loci in the gamma delta lineage may not always take place at a developmental stage strictly equivalent to the rearrangement of TCR beta in the alpha beta lineage, and it is not clear just how early the two lineages diverge. In the TCR alpha beta lineage, however, the final gene rearrangement events are accompanied by rapid proliferation and an interruption in cellular response gene inducibility. The loss of conventional responsiveness is probably caused by alterations at the level of signaling, and may be a manifestation of the physiological state that is a precondition for selection. Third is the complex process of selection. Whereas peripheral T cells can undergo forms of positive selection (by antigen-driven clonal expansion) and negative selection (by abortive stimulation leading to anergy or death), neither is exactly the same phenomenon that occurs in the thymic cortex. Negative selection in the cortex appears to be a suicidal inversion of antigen responsiveness: instead of turning on IL-2 expression, the activated cell destroys its own chromatin. The genes that need to be induced for this response are not yet identified, but it is unquestionably a form of activation. It is interesting that in humans and rats, cortical thymocytes undergoing negative selection can still induce IL-2R alpha expression and even be rescued in vitro, if exogenous IL-2 is provided. Perhaps murine thymocytes are denied this form of rescue because they shut off IL-2R beta chain expression at an earlier stage or because they may be uncommonly Bcl-2 deficient (cf. Sentman et al., 1991; Strasser et al., 1991). Even so, medullary thymocytes remain at least partially susceptible to negative selection even as they continue to mature.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Surface expression of a T cell receptor beta (TCR-beta) chain in the absence of TCR-alpha, -delta, and -gamma proteins

The antigen receptor expressed by mature T cells has been described as a disulfide-linked alpha/beta or gamma/delta heterodimer noncovalently associated with CD3, a complex of transmembrane proteins that communicates signals from the T cell receptor (TCR) to the cell interior. Studies suggest that all component chains must assemble intracellularly before surface expression can be achieved. We described, however, a CD4+/CD8+ transformed murine thymocyte, KKF, that expresses surface TCR-beta chains in the absence of gamma, delta, and alpha proteins; these beta chains are only weakly associated with CD3-epsilon and CD3-zeta. Furthermore, KKF responds differently to stimulation through TCR-beta and CD3-epsilon, a functional dissociation that has been ascribed to a CD4+/CD8+ subpopulation of normal thymocytes. KKF's unique TCR structure may offer an explanation for the functional anomalies observed.

Kinetics of negative and positive selection in the thymus

Recent experiments show that CD4+8+ thymocytes represent the critical stage in T cell development at which the specificity of randomly generated alpha beta T cell receptors is screened. These cells are deleted when the receptor binds to the MHC molecule plus specific peptide presented by bone marrow derived cells but are rescued from cell death and induced to mature if the receptor binds to the MHC molecule on thymic epithelium in the absence of the specific peptide. Different tolerogens delete CD4+8+ thymocytes earlier or later during their lifespan and negative selection can occur prior to positive selection. The specificity of the alpha beta T cell receptor for either class I or class II thymic MHC molecules determines the CD4-8+ and CD4+8- phenotype of mature T cells.

Developmentally regulated fetal thymic and extrathymic T-cell receptor gamma delta gene expression

The gamma delta T-cell receptor (TCR) is the first TCR to be expressed in ontogeny in all vertebrates in which it has been examined thoroughly. Murine gamma delta cell-surface protein is detected by the fourteenth day of gestation. In this work, the activation of gamma delta RNA has been studied. Data indicate that the first TCR protein to appear in the thymus is encoded by gamma genes that are activated after cells colonize the thymus. However, the sequential appearance of different gamma delta TCR proteins during thymic ontogeny cannot be readily explained by differential temporal activation of V gamma genes in the thymus. There are distinct patterns of gamma and delta gene expression during fetal liver development and in the fetal gut (or tissue associated with it). Cells apparent in the liver of mice at birth express gamma delta cell-surface protein, but they disappear from the liver very soon afterward. One V gamma gene is rearranged and expressed prethymically. In addition, gamma gene expression is detectable in the livers of newborn athymic mice. Together, these observations indicate a thymic-independent pathway of activation of TCR genes.

T cell receptor (TcR) beta chain transgenic mice: studies on allelic exclusion and on the TcR+ gamma/delta population

To study allelic exclusion of TcR genes we analyzed two types (I and II) of TcR beta transgenic mice. T cells derived from both types of mice contained similar amounts of transgenic RNA transcripts; however, surface expression of the transgenic beta chain was drastically reduced in type II compared to type I. In type I transgenic mice, productive rearrangements and expression of endogenous TcR beta genes were suppressed whereas on T cells of type II mice, both transgenic and endogenous TcR beta chains were expressed on the surface of the same cell. These findings suggest that allelic exclusion of TcR genes in beta transgenic mice depends on amount and/or onset of transgene expression during thymic development. Furthermore, TcR gamma rearrangements and the population of TcR gamma/delta-bearing double-negative CD4-CD8- thymocytes were reduced fivefold in type I transgenic animals. However, the V gamma usage and the gamma/delta+ dendritic epidermal cell populations appeared normal. RNase protection analysis further revealed low levels of transgenic TcR beta chain transcripts in TcR+ gamma/delta CD4-CD8- thymocytes. These results suggest that the beta transgene only quantitatively influences the gamma/delta T cell compartment, and supports the independence of the gamma/delta population.

Developmental biology of T cell receptors

T cell receptors are the antigen-recognizing elements found on the effector cells of the immune system. Two isotypes have been discovered, TCR-gamma delta and TCR-alpha beta, which appear in that order during ontogeny. The maturation of prothymocytes that colonize the thymic rudiment at defined gestational stages occurs principally within the thymus, although some evidence for extrathymic maturation also exists. The maturation process includes the rearrangement and expression of the T cell receptor genes. Determination of these mechanisms, the lineages of the cells, and the subsequent thymic selection that results in self-tolerance is the central problem in developmental immunology and is important for the understanding of autoimmune diseases.