Differences in the molecular structure of c-myc-activating recombinations in murine plasmacytomas and precursor cells

Germline Risk Contribution to Genomic Instability in Multiple Myeloma

Genomic instability, a well-established hallmark of human cancer, is also a driving force in the natural history of multiple myeloma (MM) - a difficult to treat and in most cases fatal neoplasm of immunoglobulin producing plasma cells that reside in the hematopoietic bone marrow. Long recognized manifestations of genomic instability in myeloma at the cytogenetic level include abnormal chromosome numbers (aneuploidy) caused by trisomy of odd-numbered chromosomes; recurrent oncogene-activating chromosomal translocations that involve immunoglobulin loci; and large-scale amplifications, inversions, and insertions/deletions (indels) of genetic material. Catastrophic genetic rearrangements that either shatter and illegitimately reassemble a single chromosome (chromotripsis) or lead to disordered segmental rearrangements of multiple chromosomes (chromoplexy) also occur. Genomic instability at the nucleotide level results in base substitution mutations and small indels that affect both the coding and non-coding genome. Sometimes this generates a distinctive signature of somatic mutations that can be attributed to defects in DNA repair pathways, the DNA damage response (DDR) or aberrant activity of mutator genes including members of the APOBEC family. In addition to myeloma development and progression, genomic instability promotes acquisition of drug resistance in patients with myeloma. Here we review recent findings on the genetic predisposition to myeloma, including newly identified candidate genes suggesting linkage of germline risk and compromised genomic stability control. The role of ethnic and familial risk factors for myeloma is highlighted. We address current research gaps that concern the lack of studies on the mechanism by which germline risk alleles promote genomic instability in myeloma, including the open question whether genetic modifiers of myeloma development act in tumor cells, the tumor microenvironment (TME), or in both. We conclude with a brief proposition for future research directions, which concentrate on the biological function of myeloma risk and genetic instability alleles, the potential links between the germline genome and somatic changes in myeloma, and the need to elucidate genetic modifiers in the TME.

Myc translocations in B cell and plasma cell neoplasms

Chromosomal translocations that join the cellular oncogene Myc (c-myc) with immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy-chain (Igh) or light-chain (Igk, Igl) loci are widely believed to be the crucial initiating oncogenic events in the development of B cell and plasma cell neoplasms in three mammalian species: Burkitt lymphoma (BL) in human beings, plasmacytoma (PCT) in mice, and immunocytoma in rats. Among the Myc-Ig translocations found in these neoplasms, mouse PCT T(12;15)(Igh-Myc) is of special interest because it affords a uniquely useful model system to study the fundamental outstanding questions on the mechanisms, genetics, and biological consequences of Myc translocations. Mouse T(12;15) is the direct counterpart of the human BL t(8;14)(q24;q32) translocation and thus of great relevance for human cancer. Mouse T(12;15) is the only cancer-associated translocation in mice that occurs with high incidence, spontaneity, and cell-type specificity. Due to the development of PCR methods for the detection of the underlying reciprocal Myc-Igh junction fragments, it is now known that mouse T(12;15) can be a dynamic process that begins with the genetic exchange of Myc and the Igh switch mu region (Smu), progresses by class switch recombination (CSR) just 3' of the translocation break site, and then undergoes further clonal diversification by micro-deletions in the junction flanks. The molecular pathway that subverts CSR to mediate trans-chromosomal joining of Myc and Smu (translocation origin) and secondary modification of Myc-Igh junctions (translocation "remodeling") has not been elucidated, but recent evidence indicates that it includes CSR factors, such as the activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), that may also be involved in the ongoing neoplastic progression of the translocation-bearing tumor precursor. Transgenic mouse models of T(12;15)/t(8;14), including newly developed "iMyc" gene-insertion mice, will be useful in elucidating the role of these CSR factors in the progression of Myc-induced B cell tumors.

E mu/S mu transposition into Myc is sometimes a precursor for T(12;15) translocation in mouse B cells

Misguided immunoglobulin (Ig) class switch recombination (CSR) has been implicated in the origin of Myc-activating chromosomal translocations, T(12;15), in BALB/c mouse plasmacytomas (PCTs). CSR has also been involved in the progression of T(12;15); for example, the approximation of Myc to the 3'-C alpha enhancer. This study provides evidence for an additional mechanism by which aberrant CSR may facilitate T(12;15): transposition of Ig heavy-chain (IgH) sequences to Myc. Five IgH transposons containing the intronic heavy-chain enhancer, E mu, and a truncated switch mu region, S mu, were found in the first intron of Myc in lymph node cells of IL-6 transgenic BALB/c mice. In two cases E mu/S mu transposition primed Myc to get involved in apparent trans-chromosomal CSR to C gamma 1, presumably leading to T(12;15). Translocations preceded by E mu/S mu transposition can sometimes be distinguished from de novo translocations by molecular fingerprints in translocation breakpoint regions (Ig switch region [S] inversions and unusual gene orders in composite S regions). The presence of such fingerprints in some PCTs suggests that the tumors sometimes evolve from transposition-bearing precursors. We propose that E mu/S mu transposition to Myc may facilitate plasmacytomagenesis by sensitizing Myc to undergo T(12;15) translocation. T(12;15), in turn, juxtaposes Myc to the 3'-C alpha enhancer, which appears to be required for deregulating Myc in a manner that is conducive to PCT development.

Lymphoma- and leukemia-associated chromosomal translocations in healthy individuals

Chromosomal translocations (CTs) are hallmark mutations of hematopoietic malignancy that result in the deregulated expression of oncogenes or the generation of novel fusion genes. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) can be used to detect illegitimate recombinations of genomic DNA sequences as a more sensitive assay than cytogenetics for determining the presence of CTs. Both direct DNA-PCR and reverse transcriptase-PCR were used to examine healthy individuals for lymphoma- and leukemia-associated CTs. Two oncogene-activating CTs [t(14;18)(q32;q21) and t(8;14)(q24;q32)] and one fusion-gene CT [t(2;5)(p23;q35)] from lymphomas and five fusion-gene CTs from leukemia [t(9;22)(q34;q11), t(4;11)(q21;q23), t(15;17)(q22;q11), t(12;21)(p13;q22), t(8;21)(q22;q22)] were detected in such studies. The biological implication is that CTs associated with malignant tumors may also be found in cells that are not neoplastic. CTs are characteristic attributes of neoplastic clones but are by themselves insufficient to cause malignant transformation. A better understanding of the special biology of non-neoplastic CT-bearing cells will provide insight into their putative role as tumor precursors. Prospective epidemiological studies are needed to determine whether such cells in healthy individuals may, in some instances, become clonogenic founders of lymphoma or leukemia.

IL-6 transgenic mouse model for extraosseous plasmacytoma

Plasma cell neoplasms in humans comprise plasma cell myeloma, otherwise known as multiple myeloma, Ig deposition and heavy chain diseases, and plasmacytoma (PCT). A subset of PCT, designated extramedullary PCT, is distinguished from multiple myeloma and solitary PCT of bone by its distribution among various tissue sites but not the bone marrow. Extramedullary (extraosseus) PCT are rare spontaneous neoplasms of mice but are readily induced in a susceptible strain, BALB/c, by treatment with pristane. The tumors develop in peritoneal granulomas and are characterized by Myc-activating T(12;15) chromosomal translocations and, most frequently, by secretion of IgA. A uniting feature of human and mouse plasma cell neoplasms is the critical role played by IL-6, a B cell growth, differentiation, and survival factor. To directly test the contribution of IL-6 to PCT development, we generated BALB/c mice carrying a widely expressed IL-6 transgene. All mice exhibited lymphoproliferation and plasmacytosis. By 18 months of age, over half developed readily transplantable PCT in lymph nodes, Peyer's patches, and sometimes spleen. These neoplasms also had T(12;15) translocations, but remarkably, none expressed IgA. Unexpectedly, approximately 30% of the mice developed follicular and diffuse large cell B cell lymphomas that often coexisted with PCT. These findings provide a unique model of extramedullary PCT for studies on pathogenesis and treatment and suggest a previously unappreciated role for IL-6 in the genesis of germinal center-derived lymphomas.

Translocation remodeling in the primary BALB/c plasmacytoma TEPC 3610

Myc-activating chromosomal 12;15 translocations, the hallmark mutations of inflammation-induced BALB/c plasmacytomas, have recently been shown to undergo remodeling by isotype switch-like genetic recombinations that remove approximately 180 kb of immunoglobulin heavy-chain sequence in the vicinity of the rearranged, expressed Myc gene. Here we combine cytogenetic data on the 12;15 translocation (SKY and FISH) with the molecular analysis of key junction sites (long-range PCR followed by DNA sequencing) to demonstrate that translocation remodeling occurred as an infrequent, stepwise, and disomic tumor progression event in the tetraploid, fully transformed, and transplantable plasmacytoma TEPC 3610. This result was used, in conjunction with previously obtained molecular data on five other primary plasmacytomas, to devise a hypothesis that predicts that the selective pressure to undergo translocation remodeling may be predetermined by the location of the break site in Myc. The pressure may be low if the break occurs 5' of the normal promoter region of Myc, but it may be considerably stronger if the break occurs 3' of the Myc promoter. Published 2001 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

Inducible mutagenesis in TEPC 2372, a mouse plasmacytoma cell line that harbors the transgenic shuttle vector lambdaLIZ

The plasmacytoma cell line, TEPC 2372, was derived from a malignant plasma cell tumor that developed in the peritoneal cavity of a BALB/c mouse that harbored the transgenic shuttle vector for the assessment of mutagenesis in vivo, lambdaLIZ. TEPC 2372 was found to display the typical features of a BALB/c plasmacytoma. It consisted of pleomorphic plasma cells that secreted a monoclonal immunoglobulin (IgG2b/lambda), was initially dependent on the presence of IL-6 to grow in cell culture, contained a hyperdiploid chromosome complement with a tendency to undergo tetraploidization, and harbored a constitutively active c-myc gene by virtue of a T(6;15) chromosomal translocation. TEPC 2372 was further characterized by the ability to respond to in vitro exposure with 4-NQO (4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide), an oxidative model mutagen, with a vigorous dose-dependent increase in mutagenesis that peaked at a 7.85-fold elevation of mutant rates in lambdaLIZ when compared to background mutant rates in untreated controls. Cotreatment with 4-NQO and BSO (buthionine sulfoximine), a glutathione-depleting compound that causes endogenous oxidative stress, resulted in a 9.03-fold increase in the mutant frequency in lambdaLIZ. These results demonstrated that TEPC 2372, the malignant plasma cell counterpart of the lambdaLIZ-based in vivo mutagenesis assay, may be useful as an in vitro reference point for the further elucidation of oxidative mutagenesis in lymphoid tissues.

Burkitt lymphoma in the mouse

Chromosomal translocations juxtaposing the MYC protooncogene with regulatory sequences of immunoglobulin (Ig) H chain or kappa (Ig kappa) or lambda (Ig lambda) L chain genes and effecting deregulated expression of MYC are the hallmarks of human Burkitt lymphoma (BL). Here we report that lymphomas with striking similarities to BL develop in mice bearing a mutated human MYC gene controlled by a reconstructed Ig lambda locus encompassing all the elements required for establishment of locus control in vitro. Diffusely infiltrating lymphomas with a typical starry sky appearance occurred in multiple founders and an established line, indicating independence from positional effects. Monoclonal IgM(+)CD5(-)CD23(-) tumors developed from an initially polyclonal population of B cells. These results demonstrate that the phenotype of B lineage lymphomas induced by MYC dysregulation is highly dependent on cooperativity among the regulatory elements that govern expression of the protooncogene and provide a new system for studying the pathogenesis of BL.

Lymph nodes and Peyer's patches of IL-6 transgenic BALB/c mice harbor T(12;15) translocated plasma cells that contain illegitimate exchanges between the immunoglobulin heavy-chain mu locus and c-myc

Hyperplastic plasmacytotic lymph nodes and Peyer's patches of 12 of 25 (48%) BALB/c mice that carried a human IL-6 transgene under the transcriptional control of the histocompatibility H-2L(D) promoter (BALB/c.IL-6 mice) were found to harbor 15 cell clones that contained in their T(12;15) translocation breakpoint regions illegitimate genetic recombinations between the upstream flank of the immunoglobulin heavy-chain C mu locus (5'-C mu) and c-myc (5'-C mu/c-myc+ clones). Similar 5'-C mu/c-myc+ clones were also detected in pristane-induced peritoneal granulomata (a significant source of IL-6 in situ) of three of 13 (13%) conventional BALB/c mice, but not in lymphoid tissues of pristane-treated BALB/c mice, nor in any tissue of untreated BALB/c mice. These findings provided strong evidence that IL-6 may be able to promote the growth and/or survival of clones that contained rearrangements between 5'-C mu and c-myc. Taken in conjunction with our previous observation that 5'-C mu/c-myc+ clones are the precursors for pristane-induced BALB/c plasmacytomas, the findings further suggested that IL-6 may play a pivotal role in the early stage of plasmacytoma development, by promoting tumor precursor cells. The BALB/c.IL-6 model of plasmacytomagenesis may be superior to the conventional BALA/c model because the putative plasmacytoma precursors appear to be more prevalent and in their development independent of treating the mice with inflammation-inducing plasmacytomagenic agents, such as pristane or silicone polymers.

Clonal diversification of primary BALB/c plasmacytomas harboring T(12;15) chromosomal translocations

DNA sequence analysis of PCR amplified Igh/c-myc junction fragments of T(12;15) chromosome translocations and immunohistochemical determination of immunoglobulin isotype production were employed to study the clonal diversification of neoplastic translocated plasma cells that resided in peritoneal inflammatory granulomas of BALB/c mice harboring primary plasmacytomas. The diversity of plasma cells was found to take two major forms when the fine structure of the T(12;15) translocation was used as the clonotypic marker. First, mosaics of clones containing translocations that were apparently unrelated to each other were detected in nine out of 17 (53%) mice. Second, subclones derived from common T(12;15)+ progenitors by either secondary deletions in translocation breakpoint regions or aberrant isotype switching near translocation breaksites were found in five of 17 (29.5%) mice. When Ig expression was utilized as the clonotypic marker, clonal mosaics were shown to occur in all mice. This was demonstrated by the finding that the prevalent IgA- or IgG-producing plasmacytoma clone was invariably accompanied by smaller clones of IgG- or IgA-expressing neoplastic plasma cells, respectively. These results provided new insights into the clonal diversification at the terminal stage of plasmacytomagenesis. In addition, they suggested that BALB/c plasmacytomas may be uniquely useful for studying clonal diversity during B cell oncogenesis, since clonal evolution can be evaluated in a pool of tumor and tumor precursor cells that is clearly defined by the T(12;15) chromosomal translocation and the production of monoclonal immunoglobulin.

Diverse karyotypic abnormalities of the c-myc locus associated with c-myc dysregulation and tumor progression in multiple myeloma

Translocations involving c-myc and an Ig locus have been reported rarely in human multiple myeloma (MM). Using specific fluorescence in situ hybridization probes, we show complex karyotypic abnormalities of the c-myc or L-myc locus in 19 of 20 MM cell lines and approximately 50% of advanced primary MM tumors. These abnormalities include unusual and complex translocations and insertions that often juxtapose myc with an IgH or IgL locus. For two advanced primary MM tumors, some tumor cells contain a karyotypic abnormality of the c-myc locus, whereas other tumor cells do not, indicating that this karyotypic abnormality of c-myc occurs as a late event. All informative MM cell lines show monoallelic expression of c-myc. For Burkitt's lymphoma and mouse plasmacytoma tumors, balanced translocation that juxtaposes c-myc with one of the Ig loci is an early, invariant event that is mediated by B cell-specific DNA modification mechanisms. By contrast, for MM, dysregulation of c-myc apparently is caused principally by complex genomic rearrangements that occur during late stages of MM progression and do not involve B cell-specific DNA modification mechanisms.

Recurrent non-reciprocal translocations of chromosome 5 in primary T(12;15)-positive BALB/c plasmacytomas

The majority of inflammation-induced peritoneal BALB/c plasmacytomas (approximately 90%) harbor a balanced T(12;15) chromosomal translocation that deregulates the expression of the proto-oncogene c-myc. Recent evidence suggests that the T(12;15) is an initiating tumorigenic mutation that occurs in early plasmacytoma precursor cells. However, plasmacytomas take a long time to develop (average tumor latency approximately 220 days), which suggests that additional tumor progression events may be required to complete oncogenesis. We hypothesized that such tumor progression events may take the form of secondary chromosomal aberrations that can be detected by spectral karyotyping (SKY). We screened the entire chromosome complement of 18 primary BALB/c plasmacytomas carrying the T(12;15) and found in nine tumors (50% recurrence) secondary cytogenetic aberrations that involved bands D, E and F chromosome (Chr) 5. The Chr 5D-F rearrangements were manifested predominantly as unbalanced translocations with various partner chromosomes. This finding led us to propose the existence of an important plasmacytoma progression locus in the central region of Chr 5, which presumably becomes involved in peritoneal plasmacytoma development by promiscuous chromosomal translocations.

Cloning and sequencing of ISC1041 from the archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus MT-4, a new member of the IS30 family of insertion elements

A genomic fragment containing the insertion sequence ISC1041 has been cloned by PCR from the archaeon Sulfolobus solfaricus MT-4, an extremophilic microorganism which grows at 87 degrees C. The 1038 bp ISC1041 element contains an imperfect 18 nt repeat and a long open reading frame which encodes a polypeptide of 311 amino acid residues. The translated amino acid sequence shows a significant similarity to IS30-like transposases. Structural analysis indicates that ISC1041 is a novel member of the IS30 family and displays the DDE motif not previously seen in Archaea. This motif is believed to be involved in the integration mechanism of many mobile elements. As this motif is present in several integrases and transposases which, despite the lack of overall protein homologies, share topological homologies to the DDE motif, a common ancestor has been proposed. The finding of an IS30-like transposase in the archaeal kingdom may have relevance for horizontal gene transfer.

Indomethacin Is a Potent Inhibitor of Pristane and Plastic Disc Induced Plasmacytomagenesis in a Hypersusceptible BALB/c Congenic Strain

Continuous indomethacin (INDO) administration in the drinking water (10 to 20 μg/mL) profoundly inhibited plasmacytoma (PCT) development initiated by three 0.2- or 0.5-mL intraperitoneal (i.p.) injections of pristane in hypersusceptible BALB/c.DBA/2-Idh1-Pep3 congenic mice. The most effective inhibitions were obtained with continuous INDO treatment. When treatment was delayed until 50 to 60 days after the first pristane injection, there was approximately a 50% reduction in PCT incidence. The primary action of pristane is the induction of a chronic inflammation in the peritoneal connective tissues and the formation of a microenvironment where PCTs develop. INDO, a powerful inhibitor of prostaglandin synthases (cyclooxygenases 1 and 2), did not inhibit the formation of mesenteric oil granuloma nor the appearance of cells in this chronic inflammatory tissue carrying c-myc illegitimately joined to an Ig heavy chain switch region, ie, the t(12; 15) chromosomal translocation. INDO inhibited PCT induction by the i.p. implantation of 21 × 2 mm polycarbonate discs. These solid objects predominantly induce the formation of a patchy fibroplastic tissue on contacting peritoneal surfaces. These and previous data indicate that indomethacin inhibits an intermediate stage in PCT development after the arrival of cells bearing the T(12; 15) translocation in the oil granuloma and before these cells acquire transplantability to a pristane-conditioned host. The biological mechanism that explains how INDO inhibits PCT development is not yet established but appears to result from decreased production of prostaglandins in chronic inflammatory tissues (oil granuloma, fibroplasia), suggesting that prostaglandins play an active role in oil and solid plastic induced PCT formation.

Indomethacin Is a Potent Inhibitor of Pristane and Plastic Disc Induced Plasmacytomagenesis in a Hypersusceptible BALB/c Congenic Strain

Continuous indomethacin (INDO) administration in the drinking water (10 to 20 μg/mL) profoundly inhibited plasmacytoma (PCT) development initiated by three 0.2- or 0.5-mL intraperitoneal (i.p.) injections of pristane in hypersusceptible BALB/c.DBA/2-Idh1-Pep3 congenic mice. The most effective inhibitions were obtained with continuous INDO treatment. When treatment was delayed until 50 to 60 days after the first pristane injection, there was approximately a 50% reduction in PCT incidence. The primary action of pristane is the induction of a chronic inflammation in the peritoneal connective tissues and the formation of a microenvironment where PCTs develop. INDO, a powerful inhibitor of prostaglandin synthases (cyclooxygenases 1 and 2), did not inhibit the formation of mesenteric oil granuloma nor the appearance of cells in this chronic inflammatory tissue carrying c-myc illegitimately joined to an Ig heavy chain switch region, ie, the t(12; 15) chromosomal translocation. INDO inhibited PCT induction by the i.p. implantation of 21 × 2 mm polycarbonate discs. These solid objects predominantly induce the formation of a patchy fibroplastic tissue on contacting peritoneal surfaces. These and previous data indicate that indomethacin inhibits an intermediate stage in PCT development after the arrival of cells bearing the T(12; 15) translocation in the oil granuloma and before these cells acquire transplantability to a pristane-conditioned host. The biological mechanism that explains how INDO inhibits PCT development is not yet established but appears to result from decreased production of prostaglandins in chronic inflammatory tissues (oil granuloma, fibroplasia), suggesting that prostaglandins play an active role in oil and solid plastic induced PCT formation.

Experimental plasmacytomagenesis in mice

This article discusses some of the mechanistic aspects of plasma cell tumor development. Plasmacytomagenesis, much like other forms of neoplastic development, is a highly complex process that develops in the B cell differentiation lineage. As more is learned about the molecular genetics of multiple myeloma and PCTs in mice, a unifying concept will emerge that possibly can explain the phenotypic differences in the two neoplastic cell processes as variants of a common process.

Migration of Cells With Immunoglobulin/c-myc Recombinations in Lymphoid Tissues of Mice

Recombinations between c-myc and immunoglobulin (Ig) sequences that typically occur in pristane-induced mouse plasmacytomas were detected in secondary lymphoid tissues from normal mice, chiefly in the gut-associated lymphoid tissue. Based on the analysis of recombination sequences as clonotypic markers, migration of c-myc recombination-positive cells was observed between Peyer's patches and into the intestine. Treatment of plasmacytoma-susceptible BALB/cAn mice with pristane induced proliferation and migration of these cells into mesenteric lymph node, spleen, and oil granuloma within 7 days. Plasmacytoma-resistant strains of mice (DBA/2N, C3H/HeJ, C57BL/6) differed in that (1) they harbored fewer clones (Ig/c-myc recombinations were detected in 33% of resistant mice versus 91% of BALB/cAn mice after pristane treatment); (2) Ig/c-myc-positive cells were rarely detected in the oil granuloma, and (3) c-myc recombined predominantly with the Ig α locus in BALB/cAn mice (72%), but with the Igμ locus in DBA/2N and in C57BL/6 (67%). The results demonstrate that normal mice generate a large number of lymphocytes with aberrant c-myc in intestinal tissues without developing tumors.

Migration of Cells With Immunoglobulin/c-myc Recombinations in Lymphoid Tissues of Mice

Recombinations between c-myc and immunoglobulin (Ig) sequences that typically occur in pristane-induced mouse plasmacytomas were detected in secondary lymphoid tissues from normal mice, chiefly in the gut-associated lymphoid tissue. Based on the analysis of recombination sequences as clonotypic markers, migration of c-myc recombination-positive cells was observed between Peyer's patches and into the intestine. Treatment of plasmacytoma-susceptible BALB/cAn mice with pristane induced proliferation and migration of these cells into mesenteric lymph node, spleen, and oil granuloma within 7 days. Plasmacytoma-resistant strains of mice (DBA/2N, C3H/HeJ, C57BL/6) differed in that (1) they harbored fewer clones (Ig/c-myc recombinations were detected in 33% of resistant mice versus 91% of BALB/cAn mice after pristane treatment); (2) Ig/c-myc-positive cells were rarely detected in the oil granuloma, and (3) c-myc recombined predominantly with the Ig α locus in BALB/cAn mice (72%), but with the Igμ locus in DBA/2N and in C57BL/6 (67%). The results demonstrate that normal mice generate a large number of lymphocytes with aberrant c-myc in intestinal tissues without developing tumors.

Plasmacytoma development in mice injected with silicone gels

Silicone gels derived from commercially obtained implants induce plasmacytomas in 60-70% of highly susceptible BALB/cAn.DBA/2-Idh1-Pep3 congenic mice. In contrast, dimethylpolysiloxane (DMPS) silicone oils with viscosities of 5, 1000 and 12,500 cs fail to elicit these tumors. 1000 cs vinylmethylpolysiloxane is also inactive. Silicone gels, in contrast to the oils, induce a highly inflammatory silicone granuloma. Silicone gels contain chemical components not found in the oils. The chemical component responsible for inducing the permissive environment for plasmacytoma formation has not yet been identified. Silicone gels are well tolerated for long periods of time in mice without adverse effects other than plasmacytoma formation. The response to different gel preparations varies; some are associated with relatively rapid formation of plasmacytomas resembling that seen with pristane, while in others the plasmacytoma formation is extended nearly over a two year period.