Mutants of single chain interleukin 5 show asymmetric recruitment of receptor alpha and betac subunits

The GM-CSF/IL-3/IL-5 cytokine receptor family: from ligand recognition to initiation of signaling

Granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), interleukin-3 (IL-3), and IL-5 are members of a discrete family of cytokines that regulates the growth, differentiation, migration and effector function activities of many hematopoietic cells and immunocytes. These cytokines are involved in normal responses to infectious agents, bridging innate and adaptive immunity. However, in certain cases, the overexpression of these cytokines or their receptors can lead to excessive or aberrant initiation of signaling resulting in pathological conditions, with chronic inflammatory diseases and myeloid leukemias the most notable examples. Recent crystal structures of the GM-CSF receptor ternary complex and the IL-5 binary complex have revealed new paradigms of cytokine receptor activation. Together with a wealth of associated structure-function studies, they have significantly enhanced our understanding of how these receptors recognize cytokines and initiate signals across cell membranes. Importantly, these structures provide opportunities for structure-based approaches for the discovery of novel and disease-specific therapeutics. In addition, recent biochemical evidence has suggested that the GM-CSF/IL-3/IL-5 receptor family is capable of interacting productively with other membrane proteins at the cell surface. Such interactions may afford additional or unique biological activities and might be harnessed for selective modulation of the function of these receptors in disease.

Structure analysis of the IL-5 ligand-receptor complex reveals a wrench-like architecture for IL-5Rα

Interleukin-5 (IL-5) is the key mediator for the function of eosinophil granulocytes, whose deregulation is characteristic of hypereosinophilic diseases and presumably contributes to allergic asthma. IL-5 signaling involves two transmembrane receptors, IL-5Rα and the common β chain, which upon formation of the ternary complex activate the JAK/STAT signaling cascade. To investigate the mechanism underlying ligand-receptor recognition, we determined the structure of IL-5 bound to the extracellular domain of IL-5Rα. IL-5 makes contact with all three fibronectin III-like domains of IL-5Rα, with the receptor architecture resembling a wrench. Mutagenesis data provide evidence that this wrench-like architecture is likely preformed. The structure demonstrates that for steric reasons, homodimeric IL-5 can bind only one receptor molecule, even though two equivalent receptor-binding sites exist. In regard to strong efforts being made to develop IL-5 antagonists for treating asthma and hypereosinophilic diseases, the advances in molecular understanding provided by this structure are of greatest value.

Cytokine recognition by human interleukin 5 receptor

The activation of interleukin 5 (IL-5) receptor is a dynamic process that depends on specific interaction of IL-5 with IL-5 receptor alpha, the formation of oligomeric receptor complexes with receptor beta, and the initiation of cytoplasmic phosphorylation events. These steps culminate in the triggering of a cellular response. Important advances have been made recently in understanding the molecular mechanisms of cytokine recognition, receptor assembly, and signal triggering. Cytokine recognition can be envisioned by relating structure to function in IL-5 and IL-5 receptor alpha. A pair of charge-complementary regions plays an essential role in the specific interaction between IL-5 receptor alpha and IL-5. Moreover, peptide library methodology has led to the discovery of IL-5 receptor alpha antagonists that mimic key elements in IL-5 receptor recognition. Because IL-5 has been implicated in the pathology of eosinophil-related inflammatory diseases, revealing the key recognition elements of IL-5, IL-5 mimetic peptides, and IL-5 receptor alpha could help drive the design of new compounds for therapeutic treatment against allergic inflammatory diseases such as asthma.

Cyclic peptide interleukin 5 antagonists mimic CD turn recognition epitope for receptor ?

The cyclic peptide AF17121 (Ac-VDECWRIIASHTWFCAEE) that inhibits interleukin 5 (IL-5) function and IL-5 receptor alpha-chain (IL-5Ralpha) binding has been derived from recombinant random peptide library screening and follow-up synthetic variation. To better understand the structural basis of its antagonist activity, AF17121 and a series of analogs of the parent peptide were prepared by solid phase peptide synthesis. Sequence variation was focused on the charged residues Asp(2), Glu(3), Arg(6), Glu(17), and Glu(18). Two of those residues, Glu(3) and Arg(6), form an EXXR motif that was found to be common among library-derived IL-5 antagonists. The E and R in the EXXR motif have a proximity similar to charged residues in a previously identified receptor alpha binding region, the beta-strand between the C- and D-helices of human IL-5. Optical biosensor interaction kinetics and cell proliferation assays were used to evaluate the antagonist activities of the purified synthetic peptides, by measuring competition with the highly active single chain IL-5. Analogs in which acidic residues (Asp(2), Glu(3), Glu(17), and Glu(18)) were replaced individually by Ala retained substantial competition activity, with multiple replacements in these residues leading to fractional loss of potency at most. In contrast, R6A analogs had strongly reduced competition activity. The results reveal that the arginine residue is crucial for the IL-5Ralpha binding of AF17121, while the acidic residues are not essential though likely complex-stabilizing particularly in the Asp(2)-Glu(3) region. By CD, AF17121 exhibited mostly disordered structure with evidence for a small beta-sheet content, and replacement of the arginine had no influence on the observed secondary structure of the peptides. The dominance of Arg(6) in AF17121 activity corresponds to previous findings of dominance of the positive charge balance in the antiparallel beta-sheet of IL-5 composed of (88)EERRR(92) in one strand of the CD turn region of IL-5 and with Arg(32) in the neighboring beta-strand. These results argue that AF17121 and related library-derived peptides function by mimicking the CD turn receptor alpha recognition epitope in IL-5 and open the way to small molecule antagonist design.

Revealing and utilizing receptor recognition mechanisms in a high-throughput world

Recent genomic mapping promises to identify essentially all of the proteins that underpin normal and aberrant biology in humans. What genomics leaves undone is to determine how these proteins interact and integrate into molecular pathways in health and disease. Specific molecular interactions provide the fundamental mechanism for selectivity in virtually every aspect of biological structure and function. The convergence of structural and mutational studies makes it possible to define what parts of a protein are important for recognition. Still, knowing what is important does not necessarily foretell how binding epitopes actually function. We have applied the approach of epitope randomization on phage to explore how structural elements in such receptor recruitment systems as interleukin-5 (IL-5) and HIV-1 function in receptor recognition. This work has led in the IL-5 case to differentiation of recognition and activation epitopes, and this in turn has potential to help in the design of non-activating mimetics that could stimulate development of therapeutic antagonists for allergic inflammations such as asthma. Whether it is possible to differentiate recognition and activation in designing inhibitors in cases such as HIV-1 cell attachment and infection remains a tantalizing, but unsolved goal at present. Overall, these studies portray advances as well as limitations in the effort to decipher protein recognition mechanisms and utilize the wisdom gained for mechanism-based antagonist design in an increasingly high throughput world stimulated by the advent of genomics and proteomics.

Neutralizing monoclonal antibodies can potentiate IL-5 signaling

IL-5 is a major determinant in the survival, differentiation and effector-functions of eosinophils. It mediates its effect upon binding and activation of a membrane bound receptor (R), composed of a ligand-specific alpha-chain and a beta-chain, shared with the receptors for IL-3 and granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor. We have generated and mapped the epitopes of three monoclonal antibodies (mAb) directed against this cytokine: the strong neutralizing mAb 5A5 and 1E1, and the very weak neutralizing mAb H30. We found that H30 as well as 5A5 can increase proliferation above the level induced by human (h)IL-5 alone, in a JAK-2-dependent manner, and at every sub-optimal hIL-5 concentration analyzed. This effect is dependent on mAb-mediated cross-linking of IL-5R complexes, and is only observed on cell lines expressing a hybrid human/mouse IL-5Ralpha-chain. We discuss these findings in view of the stoichiometric and topological requirements for an activated IL-5R. Since humanized anti-IL-5 mAb are currently in clinical testing, our findings imply that such mAb should be carefully evaluated for their potentiating effects.

Epitope randomization redefines the functional role of glutamic acid 110 in interleukin-5 receptor activation

Sequence randomization through functional phage display of single chain human interleukin (IL)-5 was used to investigate the limits of replaceability of the Glu(110) residues that form a part of the receptor-binding epitope. Mutational analysis revealed unexpected affinity for IL-5 receptor alpha chain with variants containing E110W or E110Y. Escherichia coli-expressed Glu(110) variants containing E110W in the otherwise sequence-intact N-terminal half, including a variant with an E110A replacement in the sequence-disabled C-terminal half, were shown by their CD spectra to be folded into secondary structures similar to that of single chain human IL-5 (scIL-5). Biosensor kinetics analysis revealed that (E110W/A5)scIL-5 and (E110W/A6)scIL-5 had receptor alpha chain binding affinities similar to that of (wt/A5)scIL-5. However, (E110W/A6)scIL-5 had a significantly reduced bioactivity in TF-1 cell proliferation compared with both (wt/A5)scIL-5 and (E110W/A5)scIL-5, and this activity reduction was disproportionately greater than the much smaller effect of Glu(110) mutation on receptor binding affinity. The marked and disproportionate decrease in TF-1 proliferation observed with (E110W/A6)scIL-5 suggests a role for Glu(110) in the biological activity mediated by the signal transducing receptor betac subunit of the IL-5 receptor. This is also consistent with the lack of stimulation of JAK2 phosphorylation by the (E110W/A6)scIL-5 mutant in recombinant 293T cells, as compared with the concentration-dependent stimulation seen for scIL-5. The results reveal the dispensability of charge in the Glu(110) locus of IL-5 for receptor alpha chain binding and, in contrast, its heretofore underappreciated importance for receptor activation.

Expression and in vitro properties of guinea pig IL-5: comparison to human and murine orthologs

Interleukin-5 (IL-5) is a key mediator of eosinophilic inflammation. The biological role of this cytokine in an allergic airway inflammatory response has been widely demonstrated in guinea pigs, yet the interaction of guinea pig IL-5 (gpIL-5) with its receptor has not been studied. Experiments were performed to quantitate the interaction of gpIL-5 with gpIL-5r and to compare this affinity with that of hIL-5 and mIL-5 and their cognate receptors. The cross-species affinity and agonist efficacy were evaluated to see if gpIL-5r had a restricted species reactivity (as is the case with mIL-5r) or did not distinguish between IL-5 orthologs (similar to hIL-5r). gpIL-5 was cloned using mRNA isolated from cells obtained by bronchoalveolar lavage. Recombinant gpIL-5 was expressed in T. ni insect cells and purified from spent media. Binding assays were performed using insect cells expressing hIL-5ralphabeta or gpIL-5ralphabeta1 as previously described (Cytokine, 12:858-866, 2000) or using B13 cells which express mIL-5r. The agonist potency and efficacy properties of each IL-5 ortholog were evaluated by quantitating the proliferative response of human TF-1 cells and murine B13 cells. gpIL-5 bound with high affinity to recombinant gpIL-5r as demonstrated by displacing [125I]hIL-5 (Ki = 160 pM). gpIL-5 also bound to hIL-5r with high affinity (Ki = 750 pM). hIL-5 and mIL-5 showed similar, high-affinity binding profiles to both gpIL-5r and hIL-5r. In contrast, gpIL-5 and hIL-5 did not bind to the mIL-5r as demonstrated by an inability to displace [125I]mIL-5, even at 1000-fold molar excess. These differences in affinity for IL-5r orthologs correlated with bioassay results: human TF-1 cells showed roughly comparable proliferative responses to guinea pig, human and murine IL-5 whereas murine B13 cells showed a strong preference for murine over guinea pig and human IL-5 (EC50 = 1.9, 2200 and 720 pM, respectively). Recombinant gpIL-5 binds to the gpIL-5r with high affinity, similar to that seen with the human ligand-receptor pair. gpIL-5r and hIL-5r do not distinguish between the three IL-5 orthologs whereas mIL-5r has restricted specificity for its cognate ligand.

Exploring biomolecular recognition using optical biosensors

Understanding the basic forces that determine molecular recognition helps to elucidate mechanisms of biological processes and facilitates discovery of innovative biotechnological methods and materials for therapeutics, diagnostics, and separation science. The ability to measure interaction properties of biological macromolecules quantitatively across a wide range of affinity, size, and purity is a growing need of studies aimed at characterizing biomolecular interactions and the structural elements that drive them. Optical biosensors have provided an increasingly impactful technology for such biomolecular interaction analyses. These biosensors record the binding and dissociation of macromolecules in real time by transducing the accumulation of mass of an analyte molecule at the sensor surface coated with ligand molecule into an optical signal. Interactions of analytes and ligands can be analyzed at a microscale and without the need to label either interactant. Sensors enable the detection of bimolecular interaction as well as multimolecular assembly. Most notably, the method is quantitative and kinetic, enabling determination of both steady-state and dynamic parameters of interaction. This article describes the basic methodology of optical biosensors and presents several examples of its use to investigate such biomolecular systems as cytokine growth factor-receptor recognition, coagulation factor assembly, and virus-cell docking.

Randomization of the receptor alpha chain recruitment epitope reveals a functional interleukin-5 with charge depletion in the CD loop

We report the functional phage display of single chain human interleukin-5 (scIL-5) and its use for receptor-binding epitope randomization. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays and optical biosensor analyses verified expression of scIL-5 on the phage surface and binding of scIL-5 phage to interleukin-5 receptor alpha chain. Furthermore, an asymmetrically disabled but functional scIL-5 mutant, (wt/A5)scIL-5, was displayed on phage. (wt/A5)scIL-5 was constructed from an N-terminal half containing the original five charged residues (88EERRR92) in the CD loop, including the Glu89 and Arg91 believed key in the alpha chain recognition site, combined with a C-terminal half containing a disabled CD loop sequence (88AAAAA92) missing the key recognition residues. This asymmetric variant was used as a starting point to generate an scIL-5 library in which the intact 88-92 N-terminal CD loop was randomized. From this epitope library, a receptor-binding variant of IL-5 was detected, (SLRGG/A5)scIL-5, in which the only charged residue in the CD loop is an Arg at position 90. Characterization of this variant expressed as a soluble protein in E. coli shows that the IL-5 pharmacophore for receptor alpha chain binding can function with a single positive charge in the CD loop. Charge-depleted CD loop mimetics of IL-5 suggest the importance of charge distribution in functional IL-5 receptor recruitment.

JAK2 and JAK1 Constitutively Associate With an Interleukin-5 (IL-5) Receptor α and βc Subunit, Respectively, and Are Activated Upon IL-5 Stimulation

The human interleukin-5 receptor (hIL-5R) consists of a unique α subunit (hIL-5Rα) and a common β subunit (βc) that activate two Janus kinases (JAK1 and JAK2) and a signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT5). The precise stoichiometry of the hIL-5R subunits and the role of JAK kinases used in IL-5 signaling were investigated. We analyzed the interaction between hIL-5Rα and βc by immunoprecipitation using anti–hIL-5Rα and anti-βc monoclonal antibodies. The binding of JAK1 and JAK2 to each hIL-5R subunit was also evaluated in the hIL-5–responsive cell line, TF-h5Rα. It was observed that IL-5 stimulation induced the recruitment of βc to hIL-5Rα, although in the absence of IL-5 the subunits remain independent. In the absence of IL-5, JAK2 and JAK1 were associated with hIL-5Rα and βc, respectively. IL-5 stimulation resulted in tyrosine phosphorylation of JAK2, JAK1, βc, and STAT5. Moreover, IL-5–induced dimerization of IL-5R subunits caused JAK2 activation and βc phosphorylation even in the absence of JAK1 activation. Furthermore, tyrosine phosphorylation of JAK1 was dependent on the activation of JAK2. Detailed study of the C-terminal truncated cytoplasmic domain of hIL-5Rα revealed that the cytoplasmic stretch at position 346-387, containing the proline-rich region, is necessary for JAK2 binding. These observations suggest that activation of hIL-5Rα–associated JAK2 is indispensable for the IL-5 signaling event.

JAK2 and JAK1 Constitutively Associate With an Interleukin-5 (IL-5) Receptor α and βc Subunit, Respectively, and Are Activated Upon IL-5 Stimulation

The human interleukin-5 receptor (hIL-5R) consists of a unique α subunit (hIL-5Rα) and a common β subunit (βc) that activate two Janus kinases (JAK1 and JAK2) and a signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT5). The precise stoichiometry of the hIL-5R subunits and the role of JAK kinases used in IL-5 signaling were investigated. We analyzed the interaction between hIL-5Rα and βc by immunoprecipitation using anti–hIL-5Rα and anti-βc monoclonal antibodies. The binding of JAK1 and JAK2 to each hIL-5R subunit was also evaluated in the hIL-5–responsive cell line, TF-h5Rα. It was observed that IL-5 stimulation induced the recruitment of βc to hIL-5Rα, although in the absence of IL-5 the subunits remain independent. In the absence of IL-5, JAK2 and JAK1 were associated with hIL-5Rα and βc, respectively. IL-5 stimulation resulted in tyrosine phosphorylation of JAK2, JAK1, βc, and STAT5. Moreover, IL-5–induced dimerization of IL-5R subunits caused JAK2 activation and βc phosphorylation even in the absence of JAK1 activation. Furthermore, tyrosine phosphorylation of JAK1 was dependent on the activation of JAK2. Detailed study of the C-terminal truncated cytoplasmic domain of hIL-5Rα revealed that the cytoplasmic stretch at position 346-387, containing the proline-rich region, is necessary for JAK2 binding. These observations suggest that activation of hIL-5Rα–associated JAK2 is indispensable for the IL-5 signaling event.

Analysis of three human interleukin 5 structures suggests a possible receptor binding mechanism

We compared three crystal structures of human interleukin 5 (hIL5) expressed in either E. coli (hIL5E.coli), Sf9 cells (hIL5sf9) or Drosophila cells (hIL5Drosophila). The dimeric hIL5 structures show subtle but significant conformational differences which are probably a consequence of the different crystallization conditions trapping this protein into one of two states. We refer to these two distinct conformations as the 'open' and 'tight' state, according to the packing around the cleft between the two subunits. We hypothesize that these two stable conformational states reflect the structure of the free or receptor bound hIL5.

Interleukin 5 and B cell differentiation

Interleukin-5 (IL-5) stimulates proliferation and differentiation of B cells and eosinophils. IL-5 receptor (IL-5R) comprises alpha and (beta)c chains. IL-5 specifically binds to IL-5Ralpha and induces the recruitment of (beta)c to IL-5Ralpha. JAK2 and JAK1 tyrosine kinases are constitutively associated with hIL-5Ralpha and (beta)c, respectively and activated upon IL-5 stimulation. IL-5 induces tyrosine phosphorylations of cellular proteins including (beta)c and STAT5 and activates Btk. X-linked immunodeficient mice have B-cell-specific defects due to missense mutation of the btk gene. The cytoplasmic proline-rich regions of both IL-5Ralpha and (beta)c are essential for the IL-5 signalling. IL-5 appears to play a critical role in hypereosinophilic syndromes and atopic diseases. The treatment of animals with anti-IL-5 mAb can decrease the enhanced bronchial responsiveness induced by allergen sensitization. Clinical studies provide a strong impetus for investigating the means of modulating IL-5 effects.

Biosensors in immunology: the story so far

In conclusion, biosensors are versatile tools with a range of applications. With a thorough knowledge of possible artefacts and limitations, it possible to perform assays that were heretofore not practicable in immunology.

Spatial orientation of the alpha and betac receptor chain binding sites on monomeric human interleukin-5 constructs

Interleukin-5 (IL-5), a disulfide-linked homodimer, can be induced to fold as a biological active monomer by extending the loop between its third and fourth helices (Dickason, R. R., and Huston, D. P. (1996) Nature 379, 652-655). We have designed eight monomeric IL-5 proteins to optimize biological activity and stability of the monomer. This was achieved by (i) inserting the joining loop at three different positions, (ii) by introducing an additional intramolecular disulfide bridge onto these backbones, and (iii) by creating circular permutations to fix the position of the carboxyl-terminal helix relative to the three other helices. The proteins dimerize with Kd values ranging from 20 to 200 microM and are therefore monomeric at the picomolar concentrations where they are biologically active. Introduction of a second disulfide confers increased stability, but this increased rigidity results in lower activity of the protein. Contrary to wild type IL-5, mutation of the betac contact residue on the first helix, Glu12, to Lys, into the circularly permutated constructs, did not abolish TF-1 proliferative and eosinophil activation activities. These results indicate that activation of the IL-5 receptor complex is not mediated solely by Glu12 on the first helix, and alternative mechanisms are discussed.

Monomeric isomers of human interleukin 5 show that 1:1 receptor recruitment is sufficient for function

The normally dimeric human interleukin 5 (IL-5) was re-engineered into two monomeric isomer forms to investigate mechanistic features of receptor recognition. One form, denoted GM1-IL-5, is a CD-loop expanded form, in which an 8-residue linker designed for flexibility was inserted between residues 85 and 86. The second, denoted DABC-IL-5, is a circularly permuted form of human IL-5 in which a chain discontinuity was introduced in the CD loop and the two consequent chain fragments were joined at the normal N and C termini by a di-glycyl linker. Both IL-5 isomers folded into stable monomers in solution as shown by sedimentation equilibrium and CD and formed an intrachain disulfide bond predicted from the structure of wild type IL-5. From titration microcalorimetry and optical biosensor analyses, both monomers were shown to interact with the IL-5 receptor alpha chain with 1:1 stoichiometry and affinities 30- to 40-fold weaker than for the dimeric wild type protein. And both monomers stimulated cell proliferation of human IL-5 receptor positive cells with a concentration dependence close to that of wild type. The data show that both monomeric and dimeric forms of IL-5 function through similar 1:1 receptor alpha chain recruitment processes and that it is the helical packing of the monomeric four-helix bundle unit in IL-5, rather than the helical connectivity itself, that appears to play the major role in presenting structural epitopes to trigger functional receptor activation.