Requirements for Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen 1 (EBNA1)-induced permanganate sensitivity of the epstein-barr virus latent origin of DNA replication

Structural and Functional Basis for an EBNA1 Hexameric Ring in Epstein-Barr Virus Episome Maintenance

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) establishes a stable latent infection that can persist for the life of the host. EBNA1 is required for the replication, maintenance, and segregation of the latent episome, but the structural features of EBNA1 that confer each of these functions are not completely understood. Here, we have solved the X-ray crystal structure of an EBNA1 DNA-binding domain (DBD) and discovered a novel hexameric ring oligomeric form. The oligomeric interface pivoted around residue T585 as a joint that links and stabilizes higher-order EBNA1 complexes. Substitution mutations around the interface destabilized higher-order complex formation and altered the cooperative DNA-binding properties of EBNA1. Mutations had both positive and negative effects on EBNA1-dependent DNA replication and episome maintenance with OriP. We found that one naturally occurring polymorphism in the oligomer interface (T585P) had greater cooperative DNA binding in vitro, minor defects in DNA replication, and pronounced defects in episome maintenance. The T585P mutant was compromised for binding to OriP in vivo as well as for assembling the origin recognition complex subunit 2 (ORC2) and trimethylated histone 3 lysine 4 (H3K4me3) at OriP. The T585P mutant was also compromised for forming stable subnuclear foci in living cells. These findings reveal a novel oligomeric structure of EBNA1 with an interface subject to naturally occurring polymorphisms that modulate EBNA1 functional properties. We propose that EBNA1 dimers can assemble into higher-order oligomeric structures important for diverse functions of EBNA1.IMPORTANCE Epstein-Barr virus is a human gammaherpesvirus that is causally associated with various cancers. Carcinogenic properties are linked to the ability of the virus to persist in the latent form for the lifetime of the host. EBNA1 is a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein that is consistently expressed in EBV tumors and is the only viral protein required to maintain the viral episome during latency. The structural and biochemical mechanisms by which EBNA1 allows the long-term persistence of the EBV genome are currently unclear. Here, we have solved the crystal structure of an EBNA1 hexameric ring and characterized key residues in the interface required for higher-order complex formation and long-term plasmid maintenance.

EBNA1

Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen 1 (EBNA1) plays multiple important roles in EBV latent infection and has also been shown to impact EBV lytic infection. EBNA1 is required for the stable persistence of the EBV genomes in latent infection and activates the expression of other EBV latency genes through interactions with specific DNA sequences in the viral episomes. EBNA1 also interacts with several cellular proteins to modulate the activities of multiple cellular pathways important for viral persistence and cell survival. These cellular effects are also implicated in oncogenesis, suggesting a direct role of EBNA1 in the development of EBV-associated tumors.

EBNA1 and host factors in Epstein-Barr virus latent DNA replication

Epstein-Barr virus episomes (EBV) replicate once per cell cycle during latent infection from the latent origin, oriP. This replication requires the viral EBNA1 protein, which specifically recognizes sequences in oriP and recruits cellular proteins to this origin. Replication from oriP requires the cellular origin recognition and MCM helicase complexes and also involves telomeric factors (including TRF2) that associate with repeated nonameric sequences at the origin. Replication from oriP occurs late in S-phase and this timing appears to be important for efficient replication. Replication from oriP has proven to be a valuable system for elucidating cellular proteins and mechanisms of origin activation.

The Epstein-Barr Virus EBNA1 Protein

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) is a widespread human herpes virus that immortalizes cells as part of its latent infection and is a causative agent in the development of several types of lymphomas and carcinomas. Replication and stable persistence of the EBV genomes in latent infection require the viral EBNA1 protein, which binds specific DNA sequences in the viral DNA. While the roles of EBNA1 were initially thought to be limited to effects on the viral genomes, more recently EBNA1 has been found to have multiple effects on cellular proteins and pathways that may also be important for viral persistence. In addition, a role for EBNA1 in lytic infection has been recently identified. The multiple roles of EBNA1 in EBV infection are the subject of this paper.

EBNA1 efficiently assembles on chromatin containing the Epstein-Barr virus latent origin of replication

The Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) protein, EBNA1, activates the replication of latent EBV episomes and the transcription of EBV latency genes by binding to recognition sites in the DS and FR elements of oriP. Since EBV episomes exist as chromatin, we have examined the interaction of EBNA1 with oriP templates assembled with physiologically spaced nucleosomes. We show that EBNA1 retains the ability to efficiently bind its recognition sites within the DS and FR elements in oriP chromatin and that this property is intrinsic to the EBNA1 DNA binding domain. The efficient assembly of EBNA1 on oriP chromatin does not require ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factors and does not cause the precise positioning of nucleosomes within or adjacent to the FR and DS elements. Thus EBNA1 belongs to a select group of proteins that can efficiently access their recognition sites within nucleosomes without the need for additional chromatin remodeling factors.

Amino acid substitution analyses of the DNA contact region, two amphipathic alpha-helices and a recognition-helix-like helix outside the dimeric beta-barrel of Epstein-Barr virus nuclear antigen 1

OBJECTIVES AND METHODS

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) nuclear antigen 1 (EBNA-1), which is essential for EBV latency, homodimerizes and binds to the EBV replication origin, oriP. We analyzed the dimerization/DNA-binding domain of EBNA-1 by random and site-directed amino acid substitution.

RESULTS

Random point mutations that resulted in reduced DNA binding clustered in the DNA contact region (a.a. 461-473) and at or near the termini of alpha-helix II (514-527). Three substitutions of Gly in the DNA contact region each greatly reduced binding to a single binding site oligonucleotide. Substitutions at and near the termini of alpha-helix II diminished DNA binding. A helix-deforming substitution in alpha-helix I (477-489) blocked DNA binding. A helix-deforming substitution in alpha-helix III (568-582) abolished dimerization and DNA binding. Similarities in surface electrostatic properties and conserved amino acids were found between alpha-helix II and recognition helices of papillomavirus E2 proteins.

CONCLUSIONS

The basic DNA contact region is crucial for the specific interaction of EBNA-1 with a single binding site. Alpha-helix I477 is indispensable for oriP binding, and alpha-helix III568 contributes to the homodimeric structure of EBNA-1. Alpha-helix II514 contributes to oriP binding, perhaps changing its alignment with DNA.

Double-stranded RNA as a not-self alarm signal: to evade, most viruses purine-load their RNAs, but some (HTLV-1, Epstein-Barr) pyrimidine-load

For double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) to signal the presence of foreign (non-self) nucleic acid, self-RNA-self-RNA interactions should be minimized. Indeed, self-RNAs appear to have been fine-tuned over evolutionary time by the introduction of purines in clusters in the loop regions of stem-loop structures. This adaptation should militate against the "kissing" interactions which initiate formation of dsRNA. Our analyses of virus base compositions suggest that, to avoid triggering the host cell's dsRNA surveillance mechanism, most viruses purine-load their RNAs to resemble host RNAs ("stealth" strategy). However, some GC-rich latent viruses (HTLV-1, EBV) pyrimidine-load their RNAs. It is suggested that when virus production begins, these RNAs suddenly increase in concentration and impair host mRNA function by virtue of an excess of complementary "kissing" interactions ("surprise" strategy). Remarkably, the only mRNA expressed in the most fundamental form of EBV latency (the "EBNA-1 program") is purine-loaded. This apparent stealth strategy is reinforced by a simple sequence repeat which prefers purine-rich codons. During latent infection the EBNA-1 protein may evade recognition by cytotoxic T-cells, not by virtue of containing a simple sequence amino acid repeat as has been proposed, but by virtue of the encoding mRNA being purine-loaded to prevent interactions with host RNAs of either genic or non-genic origin.

Two domains of the epstein-barr virus origin DNA-binding protein, EBNA1, orchestrate sequence-specific DNA binding

The EBNA1 (for Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen 1) protein of Epstein-Barr virus governs the replication and partitioning of the viral genomes during latent infection by binding to specific recognition sites in the viral origin of DNA replication. The crystal structure of the DNA binding portion of the EBNA1 protein revealed that this region comprises two structural motifs; a core domain, which mediates protein dimerization and is structurally homologous to the DNA binding domain of the papillomavirus E2 protein, and a flanking domain, which mediated all the observed sequence-specific contacts. To test the possibility that the EBNA1 core domain plays a role in sequence-specific DNA binding not revealed in the crystal structure, we examined the effects of point mutations in potential hydrogen bond donors located in an alpha-helix of the EBNA1 core domain whose structural homologue in E2 mediates sequence-specific DNA binding. We show that these mutations severely reduce the affinity of EBNA1 for its recognition site, and that the core domain, when expressed in the absence of the flanking domain, has sequence-specific DNA binding activity. Flanking domain residues were also found to contribute to the DNA binding activity of EBNA1. Thus, both the core and flanking domains of EBNA1 play direct roles in DNA recognition.

Functional analyses of the EBNA1 origin DNA binding protein of Epstein-Barr virus

The EBNA1 protein of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) governs the replication and segregation of the viral episomes in latently infected cells and transactivates the expression of other EBV latency proteins through direct interactions with DNA sequences in the EBV latent origin of replication, oriP. To better understand how EBNA1 controls these processes, we have assessed the contribution of various EBNA1 sequences to its replication, segregation, and transactivation functions. Here we show that EBNA1 residues 325 to 376 are responsible for the transactivation activity of EBNA1. This region coincides with the DNA looping domain previously shown to mediate interactions at a distance between DNA-bound EBNA1 molecules. The same residues mediate DNA segregation but have no apparent role in DNA replication, indicating that the replication and transcription activation activities of EBNA1 are distinct. The acidic C-terminal tail of EBNA1 was not found to contribute to replication, transactivation, or segregation. We have also investigated the functional significance of two structural motifs within the DNA binding and dimerization domains of EBNA1, the proline loop and the WF motif. Although the amino acids in these motifs do not directly contact the DNA, both of these motifs were found to contribute to EBNA1 functions by increasing the DNA-binding ability of EBNA1. Mechanisms by which DNA binding is stimulated by these motifs are discussed.

The minimal replicator of Epstein-Barr virus oriP

oriP is a 1.7-kb region of the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) chromosome that supports the replication and stable maintenance of plasmids in human cells. oriP contains two essential components, called the DS and the FR, both of which contain multiple binding sites for the EBV-encoded protein, EBNA-1. The DS appears to function as the replicator of oriP, while the FR acts in conjunction with EBNA-1 to prevent the loss of plasmids from proliferating cells. Because of EBNA-1's role in stabilizing plasmids through the FR, it has not been entirely clear to what extent EBNA-1 might be required for replication from oriP per se, and a recent study has questioned whether EBNA-1 has any direct role in replication. In the present study we found that plasmids carrying oriP required EBNA-1 to replicate efficiently even when assayed only 2 days after plasmids were introduced into the cell lines 143B and 293. Significantly, using 293 cells it was demonstrated that the plasmid-retention function of EBNA-1 and the FR did not contribute significantly to the accumulation of replicated plasmids, and the DS supported efficient EBNA-1-dependent replication in the absence of the FR. The DS contains two pairs of closely spaced EBNA-1 binding sites, and a previous study had shown that both sites within either pair are required for activity. However, it was unclear from previous work what additional sequences within the DS might be required. We found that each "half" of the DS, including a pair of closely spaced EBNA-1 binding sites, had significant replicator activity when the other half had been deleted. The only significant DNA sequences that the two halves of the DS share in common, other than EBNA-1 binding sites, is a 9-bp sequence that is present twice in the "left half" and once in the "right half." These nonamer repeats, while not essential for activity, contributed significantly to the activity of each half of the DS. Two thymines occur at unique positions within EBNA-1 binding sites 1 and 4 at the DS and become sensitive to oxidation by permanganate when EBNA-1 binds, but mutation of each to the consensus base, adenine, actually improved the activity of each half of the DS slightly. In conclusion, the DS of oriP is an EBNA-1-dependent replicator, and its minimal active core appears to be simply two properly spaced EBNA-1 binding sites.

De novo DNA methylation at nonrandom founder sites 5' from an unmethylated minimal origin of DNA replication in latent Epstein-Barr virus genomes

Latent episomal genomes of Epstein-Barr virus, a human gammaherpesvirus, represent a suitable model system for studying replication and methylation of chromosomal DNA in mammals. We analyzed the methylation patterns of CpG dinucleotides in the latent origin of DNA replication of Epstein-Barr virus using automated fluorescent genomic sequencing of bisulfite-modified DNA samples. We observed that the minimal origin of DNA replication was unmethylated in 8 well-characterized human cell lines or clones carrying latent Epstein-Barr virus genomes as well as in a prototype virus producer marmoset cell line. This observation suggests that unmethylated DNA domains can function as initiation sites or zones of DNA replication in human cells. Furthermore, 5' from this unmethylated region we observed focal points of de novo DNA methylation in nonrandom positions in the majority of Burkitt's lymphoma cell lines and clones studied while the corresponding CpG dinucleotides in viral genomes carried by lymphoblastoid cell lines and marmoset cells were completely unmethylated. Clustering of highly methylated CpG dinucleotides suggests that de novo methylation of unmethylated double-stranded episomal viral genomes starts at discrete founder sites in vivo. This is the first comparative high-resolution methylation analysis of a latent viral origin of DNA replication in human cells.

DNA distortion as a factor in nucleosome positioning

In a previous report we constructed a synthetic DNA sequence that directed the deposition of histone octamers to a single site, and it was proposed that DNA distortion was involved in the positioning effect. In the present study we utilized the chemical probe potassium permanganate to identify sites of DNA distortion in the synthetic positioning sequence. A permanganate hypersite was identified 15 bp from the nucleosome pseudo-dyad at a site known to display DNA distortion in the mature nucleosome. The sequence of the site contained a TA step flanked by an oligo-pyrimidine tract. A series of substitutions were made in the region of the permanganate hypersite and the resulting constructs tested for affinity for histone octamers and translational positioning in in vitro studies. The results revealed that either a single base substitution at the TA step or in the adjacent homopolymeric tract dramatically affected affinity and positioning activity. The rotational orientation of the permanganate-sensitive sequence was shown to be important for functions, since altering the orientation of the site in a positioning fragment reduced positioning activity and octamer affinity, while altering the rotational orientation of the sequence in a non-positioning fragment had the opposite effects. A reconstituted 5 S rDNA positioning sequence from Lytechinus variegatus was also shown to display a permanganate hypersite 16 bp from its pseudo-dyad.

The 2.2 A structure of a permanganate-sensitive DNA site bound by the Epstein-Barr virus origin binding protein, EBNA1

Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen 1 (EBNA1) binds to four recognition sites in the minimal origin of latent DNA replication of Epstein-Barr virus and activates latent-phase replication of the viral genomes. Two of these EBNA1 binding sites become sensitive to permanganate oxidation when bound by the DNA binding and dimerization domains of EBNA1. We have previously solved the co-crystal structure of this EBNA1 fragment bound to a consensus recognition site that is not sensitive to permanganate oxidation (CS). To understand the structural difference that underlies the permanganate sensitivity of EBNA1 binding sites, we have now solved the crystal structure of the EBNA1 DNA-binding and dimerization domains bound to a permanganate-sensitive site (CSA/T). Comparisons of permanganate-sensitive and insensitive EBNA1-DNA complexes have revealed only minor differences in protein and DNA structures. In the EBNA1-CSA/T structure, interstrand H-bonds for three consecutive base-pairs centered over the permanganate-sensitive thymine base are lengthened relative to the corresponding bonds in the EBNA1-CS complex, and three potential intrastrand H-bonds were observed between adjacent bases. We also observed that both the CS and CSA/T sequences are overwound by EBNA1 in the vicinity of the permanganate-sensitive thymine base. Finally, we show that the permanganate-sensitive thymine base in the CSA/T-EBNA1 complex is more accessible to solvent than the corresponding T in the EBNA-CS complex.

Origin DNA-binding proteins

The first step in DNA replication involves the recognition of origin DNA sequences by origin-binding proteins. The three-dimensional structures of three different origin DNA-binding proteins have recently been solved. These proteins form a structural class distinct from other DNA-binding proteins. One of the origin-binding proteins, Epstein-Barr virus nuclear antigen 1, most likely has two modes of DNA binding; the sequential use of these modes may be important for the initiation of DNA replication.