Kinetic partitioning. Poising SecB to favor association with a rapidly folding ligand

Redefining Molecular Chaperones as Chaotropes

Molecular chaperones are the key instruments of bacterial protein homeostasis. Chaperones not only facilitate folding of client proteins, but also transport them, prevent their aggregation, dissolve aggregates and resolve misfolded states. Despite this seemingly large variety, single chaperones can perform several of these functions even on multiple different clients, thus suggesting a single biophysical mechanism underlying. Numerous recently elucidated structures of bacterial chaperone–client complexes show that dynamic interactions between chaperones and their client proteins stabilize conformationally flexible non-native client states, which results in client protein denaturation. Based on these findings, we propose chaotropicity as a suitable biophysical concept to rationalize the generic activity of chaperones. We discuss the consequences of applying this concept in the context of ATP-dependent and -independent chaperones and their functional regulation.

Position-dependent effects of polylysine on Sec protein transport

The bacterial Sec protein translocation system catalyzes the transport of unfolded precursor proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane. Using a recently developed real time fluorescence-based transport assay, the effects of the number and distribution of positive charges on the transport time and transport efficiency of proOmpA were examined. As expected, an increase in the number of lysine residues generally increased transport time and decreased transport efficiency. However, the observed effects were highly dependent on the polylysine position in the mature domain. In addition, a string of consecutive positive charges generally had a more significant effect on transport time and efficiency than separating the charges into two or more charged segments. Thirty positive charges distributed throughout the mature domain resulted in effects similar to 10 consecutive charges near the N terminus of the mature domain. These data support a model in which the local effects of positive charge on the translocation kinetics dominate over total thermodynamic constraints. The rapid translocation kinetics of some highly charged proOmpA mutants suggest that the charge is partially shielded from the electric field gradient during transport, possibly by the co-migration of counter ions. The transport times of precursors with multiple positively charged sequences, or "pause sites," were fairly well predicted by a local effect model. However, the kinetic profile predicted by this local effect model was not observed. Instead, the transport kinetics observed for precursors with multiple polylysine segments support a model in which translocation through the SecYEG pore is not the rate-limiting step of transport.

Lon protease quality control of presecretory proteins in Escherichia coli and its dependence on the SecB and DnaJ (Hsp40) chaperones

Various environmental insults result in irreversible damage to proteins and protein complexes. To cope, cells have evolved dedicated protein quality control mechanisms involving molecular chaperones and proteases. Here, we provide both genetic and biochemical evidence that the Lon protease and the SecB and DnaJ/Hsp40 chaperones are involved in the quality control of presecretory proteins in Escherichia coli. We showed that mutations in the lon gene alleviate the cold-sensitive phenotype of a secB mutant. Such suppression was not observed with either clpP or clpQ protease mutants. In comparison to the respective single mutants, the double secB lon mutant strongly accumulates aggregates of SecB substrates at physiological temperatures, suggesting that the chaperone and the protease share substrates. These observations were extended in vitro by showing that the main substrates identified in secB lon aggregates, namely proOmpF and proOmpC, are highly sensitive to specific degradation by Lon. In contrast, both substrates are significantly protected from Lon degradation by SecB. Interestingly, the chaperone DnaJ by itself protects substrates better from Lon degradation than SecB or the complete DnaK/DnaJ/GrpE chaperone machinery. In agreement with this finding, a DnaJ mutant protein that does not functionally interact in vivo with DnaK efficiently suppresses the SecB cold-sensitive phenotype, highlighting the role of DnaJ in assisting presecretory proteins. Taken together, our data suggest that when the Sec secretion pathway is compromised, a pool of presecretory proteins is transiently maintained in a translocation-competent state and, thus, protected from Lon degradation by either the SecB or DnaJ chaperones.

The structure of SecB/OmpA as visualized by electron microscopy: The mature region of the precursor protein binds asymmetrically to SecB

SecB, a molecular chaperone in Escherichia coli, binds a subset of precursor proteins that are exported across the plasma membrane via the Sec pathway. Previous studies showed that SecB bound directly to the mature region rather than to the signal sequence of the precursor protein. To determine the binding pattern of SecB and the mature region of the preprotein, here, we visualized the structure of the SecB/OmpA complex by electron microscopy. This complex is composed by two parts: the main density represents one SecB tetramer and the unfolded part of OmpA wrapping round it; the elongated smaller density represents the rest of OmpA. Each SecB protomer makes a different contribution to the binding of SecB with OmpA. The binding pattern between SecB tetramer and OmpA is asymmetric.

Export chaperone SecB uses one surface of interaction for diverse unfolded polypeptide ligands

SecB, a remarkable chaperone involved in protein export, binds diverse ligands rapidly with high affinity and low specificity. Site-directed spin labeling and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy were used to investigate the surface of interaction on the export chaperone SecB. We examined SecB in complex with the unfolded precursor form of outer membrane protein OmpA as well as with a truncated version of OmpA that includes the transmembrane domain and lacks both the signal peptide and the periplasmic domain. In addition, we studied the binding of SecB to the unfolded mature form of galactose-binding protein, a soluble periplasmic protein. We have previously used the same strategy to map the binding surface for the precursor of galactose-binding protein. We show that for all ligands tested the patterns of contact are the same.

SecB-mediated protein export need not occur via kinetic partitioning

In Escherichia coli, the cytosolic chaperone SecB is responsible for the selective entry of a subset of precursor proteins into the Sec pathway. In vitro, SecB binds to a variety of unfolded substrates without apparent sequence specificity, but not native proteins. Selectivity has therefore been suggested to occur by kinetic partitioning of substrates between protein folding and SecB association. Evidence for kinetic partitioning is based on earlier observations that SecB blocks the refolding of the precursor form of maltose-binding protein (preMBP)(5) and slow-folding maltose-binding protein (MBP) mutants, but not faster-folding mature wild-type MBP. In order to quantitatively validate the kinetic partitioning model, we have independently measured each of the rate constants involved in the interaction of SecB with refolding preMBP (a physiological substrate of SecB) and mature MBP. The measured rate constants correctly predict substrate folding kinetics over a wide range of SecB, MBP, and preMBP concentrations. Analysis of the data reveals that, for many substrates, kinetic partitioning is unlikely to be responsible for SecB-mediated protein export. Instead, the ability of SecB-bound substrates to continue folding while bound to SecB and their ability to interact with other components of the secretory machinery such as SecA may be key opposing determinants that inhibit and promote protein export, respectively.

Folding of conotoxins: formation of the native disulfide bridges during chemical synthesis and biosynthesis of Conus peptides

Conopeptides from >700 species of predatory marine Conus snails provide an impressive molecular diversity of cysteine-rich peptides. Most of the estimated 50,000-100,000 distinct conopeptides range in size from 10 to 50 amino acid residues, often with multiple posttranslational modifications. The great majority contain from two to four disulfide bridges. As the biosynthetic and chemical production of this impressive repertoire of disulfide-rich peptides has been investigated, particularly the formation of native disulfide bridges, differences between in vivo and in vitro oxidative folding have become increasingly evident. In this article, we provide an overview of the molecular diversity of conotoxins with an emphasis on the cysteine patterns and disulfide frameworks. The conotoxin folding studies reviewed include regioselective and direct oxidation strategies, recombinant expression, optimization of folding methods, mechanisms of in vitro folding, and preliminary data on the biosynthesis of conotoxins in venom ducts. Despite these studies, how the cone snails efficiently produce properly folded conotoxins remains unanswered. As chemists continue to master oxidative folding techniques, insights gleaned from how conotoxins are folded in vivo will likely lead to the development of the new folding methods, as well as shed some light on fundamental mechanisms relevant to the protein folding problem.

The structural view of bacterial translocation-specific chaperone SecB: implications for function

SecB is a molecular chaperone that functions in bacterial post-translational protein translocation pathway. It maintains newly synthesized precursor polypeptide chains in a translocation-competent state and guides them to the translocon via its high-affinity binding to the ligand as well as to the membrane-embedded ATPase SecA. Recent advances in elucidating the structures of SecB have enabled the examination of protein function in the structural context. Structures of SecB from both Haemophilus influenzae and Escherichia coli support the early two-subsite polypeptide-binding model. In addition, the detailed molecular interaction between SecB and SecA was revealed by a structure of SecB in complex with the C-terminal zinc-containing domain of SecA. These observations explain the dual role of SecB plays in the translocation pathway, as a molecular chaperone and a specific targeting factor. A model of SecB-SecA complex suggests that the binding of SecA to SecB changes the conformation of the polypeptide binding sites in the chaperone, enabling transfer of precursor polypeptides from SecB to SecA. Recent studies also show the presence of a second zinc-independent SecB binding site in SecA and the new interaction might contribute to the function of SecB.

Sites of interaction between SecA and the chaperone SecB, two proteins involved in export

SecB, a small tetrameric cytosolic chaperone in Escherichia coli, facilitates the export of precursor poly-peptides by maintaining them in a nonnative conformation and passing them to SecA, which is a peripheral member of the membrane-bound translocation apparatus. It has been proposed by several laboratories that as SecA interacts with various components along the export pathway, it undergoes conformational changes that are crucial to its function. Here we report details of molecular interactions between SecA and SecB, which may serve as conformational switches. One site of interaction involves the final C-terminal 21 amino acids of SecA, which are positively charged and contain zinc. The C terminus of each subunit of the SecA dimer makes contact with the flat beta-sheet that is formed by each dimer of the SecB tetramer. Here we demonstrate that a second interaction exists between the extreme C-terminal alpha-helix of SecB and a site on SecA, as yet undefined but different from the C terminus of SecA. We investigated the energetics of the interactions by titration calorimetry and characterized the hydrodynamic properties of complexes stabilized by both interactions or each interaction singly using sedimentation velocity centrifugation.

Zinc binding drives the folding and association of the homo‐trimeric γ‐carbonic anhydrase from Methanosarcina thermophila

Carbonic anhydrase from the archeon Methanosarcina thermophila (Cam) is a homo-trimeric enzyme, the left-handed beta-helical subunits of which bind three catalytic Zn(2+) ions at symmetry-related subunit interfaces. The observation of activity for holo-Cam at nanomolar concentrations provides a minimal estimated free energy of folding and assembly of the trimeric holo-complex of approximately 70 kcal (mol trimer)(-1) at standard state. Although the direct measurement of stability by chemical denaturation was precluded by the irreversible unfolding of the holo-enzyme, the reversible unfolding of metal-free apo-Cam is well described by a three-state model involving the folded apo-trimer, the folded monomer and the unfolded monomer. The monomer is estimated to have a stability of 4.0 +/- 0.3 kcal (mol monomer)(-1). The association to form apo-trimer contributes 13.2 +/- 0.4 kcal (mol trimer)(-1), a value confirmed by analytical ultracentrifugation measurements. Far- and near-UV circular dichroism data show a progressive increase in secondary and tertiary structure as the apo-monomer is converted to holo-trimer. The literature value for the free energy of binding of one Zn(2+) ion to a canonical active site, 16.4 kcal mol(-1), is consistent with the presumption that the >45 kcal (mol trimer)(-1) generated by the binding of three ions represents the major contribution to the stability of the holo-trimeric Cam.

Antifolding activity of the SecB chaperone is essential for secretion of HasA, a quickly folding ABC pathway substrate

We have previously shown that SecB, the ATP-independent chaperone of the Sec pathway, is required for the secretion of the HasA hemophore from Serratia marcescens via its type I secretion pathway, both in the reconstituted system in Escherichia coli and in the original host. The refolding of apo-HasA after denaturation with guanidine HCl was followed by stopped-flow measurements of fluorescence of its single tryptophan, both in the absence and presence of SecB. In the absence of SecB, HasA folds very quickly with one main phase (45 s(-1)) accounting for 92% of the signal. SecB considerably slows down HasA folding. At stoichiometric amounts of SecB and HasA, a single phase (0.014 s(-1)) of refolding is observed. Two double point mutants of HasA were made, abolishing two hydrogen bonds between N-terminal and C-terminal side chain residues. In both cases, the mutants essentially maintained the same secondary and tertiary structure as wild-type HasA and were fully functional. Refolding of both mutants was much slower than that of wild-type HasA and they were secreted essentially independently of SecB. We conclude that SecB has mainly an antifolding function in the HasA ABC secretion pathway.

SecB modulates the nucleotide-bound state of SecA and stimulates ATPase activity

In Escherichia coli, the formation of SecA-SecB complexes has a direct effect on SecA ATPase activity. The mechanism of this interaction was evaluated and defined using controlled trypsinolysis, equilibrium dialysis at low temperature, and kinetic analyses of the SecA ATPase reaction. The proteolysis data indicate that SecB and the nonhydrolyzable ATP analogue AMP-P-C-P induce similar conformational changes in SecA which result in a more open or extended structure that is suggestive of the ATP-bound form. The effect is synergistic and concentration-dependent, and requires the occupation of both the high- and low-affinity nucleotide binding sites for maximum effect. The equilibrium dialysis experiments and kinetic data support the observation that the SecB-enhanced SecA ATPase activity is the result of an increased rate of ATP hydrolysis rather than an increase in the affinity of ATP for SecA and that the high-affinity nucleotide binding site is conformationally regulated by SecB. It appears that SecB may function as an intermolecular regulator of ATP hydrolysis by promoting the ATP-bound state of SecA. The inhibition of SecA ATPase activity by sodium azide in the presence of IMVs and a functional signal peptide further indicates that SecB promotes the ATP-bound form of SecA.

Evidence that SecB enhances the activity of SecA

In Escherichia coli, SecA is a critical component of the protein transport machinery which powers the translocation process by hydrolyzing ATP and recognizing signal peptides which are the earmark of secretory proteins. In contrast, SecB is utilized by only a subset of preproteins to prevent their premature folding and chaperone them to membrane-bound SecA. Using purified components and synthetic signal peptides, we have studied the interaction of SecB with SecA and with SecA-signal peptide complexes in vitro. Using a chemical cross-linking approach, we find that the formation of SecA-SecB complexes is accompanied by a decrease in the level of cross-linking of SecA dimers, suggesting that SecB induces a conformational change in SecA. Furthermore, functional signal peptides, but not dysfunctional ones, promote the formation of SecA-SecB complexes. SecB is also shown to directly enhance the ATPase activity of SecA in a concentration-dependent and saturable manner. To determine the biological consequence of this finding, the influence of SecB on the signal peptide-stimulated SecA/lipid ATPase was studied using synthetic peptides of varying hydrophobicity. Interestingly, the presence of SecB can sufficiently boost the response of signal peptides with moderate hydrophobicity such that it is comparable to the activity generated by a more hydrophobic peptide in the absence of SecB. The results suggest that SecB directly enhances the activity of SecA and provide a biochemical basis for the enhanced transport efficiency of preproteins in the presence of SecB in vivo.

Direct demonstration that homotetrameric chaperone SecB undergoes a dynamic dimer-tetramer equilibrium

We have shown here that the cytosolic bacterial chaperone SecB is a structural dimer of dimers that undergoes a dynamic equilibrium between dimer and tetramer in the native state. We demonstrated this equilibrium by mixing two tetrameric species of SecB that can be distinguished by size. We showed that the homotetrameric species exchanged dimers, because when the mixture was analyzed both by size exclusion chromatography and native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis a third hybrid tetrameric species was detected. Furthermore, treatment of SecB with 5,5'-dithiobis-(2-nitrobenzoic acid), which modifies the sulfhydryl group on cysteines, caused irreversible dissociation to a dimer indicating that cysteine must be involved in the stabilizing interactions at the dimer interface. It is clear that the two dimer-dimer interfaces of the SecB tetramer are differentially stable. Dissociation at one interface allows for a dynamic dimer-tetramer equilibrium. Because only dimers were exchanged it is clear that the other interface between dimers is significantly more stable, otherwise oligomers should have formed with a random distribution of monomers.

SecB dependence of an exported protein is a continuum influenced by the characteristics of the signal peptide or early mature region

We have used Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase to show the interplay among the characteristics of two amino-terminal domains in the preprotein (the signal peptide and the early mature region), the efficiency with which this protein is transported, and its requirement for SecB to accomplish the transport process. The results suggest that although alkaline phosphatase does not normally require SecB for transport, it is inherently able to utilize SecB, and it does so when its ability to interface with the transport machinery is compromised.

Thermodynamics of substrate binding to the chaperone SecB

The thermodynamics of binding of unfolded polypeptides to the chaperone SecB was investigated in vitro by isothermal titration calorimetry and fluorescence spectroscopy. The substrates were reduced and carboxamidomethylated forms of RNase A, BPTI, and alpha-lactalbumin. SecB binds both fully unfolded RNase A and BPTI as well as compact, partially folded disulfide intermediates of alpha-lactalbumin, which have 40-60% of native secondary structure. The heat capacity changes observed on binding the reduced and carboxamidomethylated forms of alpha-lactalbumin, BPTI, and RNase A were found to be -0.10, -0.29, and -0.41 kcal mol(-1) K(-1), respectively, and suggest that between 7 and 29 residues are buried upon substrate binding to SecB. In all cases, binding occurs with a stoichiometry of one polypeptide chain per monomer of SecB. There is no evidence for two separate types of binding sites for positively charged and hydrophobic ligands. Spectroscopic and proteolysis protection studies of the binding of SecB to poly-L-Lys show that binding of highly positively charged peptide ligands to negatively charged SecB leads to charge neutralization and subsequent aggregation of SecB. The data are consistent with a model where SecB binds substrate molecules at an exposed hydrophobic cleft. SecB aggregation in the absence of substrate is prevented by electrostatic repulsion between negatively charged SecB tetramers.

A highly mobile C-terminal tail of the Escherichia coli protein export chaperone SecB

The Escherichia coli export chaperone SecB binds nascent precursors of certain periplasmic and outer membrane proteins and prevents them from folding or aggregating in the cytoplasm. In this study, we demonstrate that the C-terminal 13 residues of SecB were highly mobile using (1)H NMR spectroscopy. A protein lacking the C-terminal 13 amino acids of wild-type SecB was found to retain the ability to bind unfolded maltose-binding protein (MBP) in vitro but to interfere with the normal kinetics of pre-MBP export when overexpressed in vivo. The defect in export was reversed by overproduction of the peripheral membrane ATPase SecA. Therefore, deletion of the mobile region of SecB may alter the interactions of SecB with SecA.

Effects of pre-protein overexpression on SecB synthesis in Escherichia coli

Protein translocation through the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli involves cytosolic chaperones. The export-dedicated chaperone SecB mediates targeting of a subset of pre-proteins. In this report, synthesis of SecB in response to plasmid-mediated overexpression of pre-proteins was studied. Overexpression of SecB-dependent pre-proteins stimulated synthesis of SecB under conditions where the cellular export capacity was saturated or uncomplexed SecB was trapped. On the contrary, overexpression of SecB-independent pre-beta-lactamase reduced the promoter activity of secB. The results suggest that uncomplexed SecB can be sequestered by synthesis of SecB-dependent pre-proteins. Furthermore, these data demonstrate the distinct action of the SecB- and signal recognition particle-dependent protein targeting pathways.

Protein targeting to the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane

Proteins that perform their activity within the cytoplasmic membrane or outside this cell boundary must be targeted to the translocation site prior to their insertion and/or translocation. In bacteria, several targeting routes are known; the SecB- and the signal recognition particle-dependent pathways are the best characterized. Recently, evidence for the existence of a third major route, the twin-Arg pathway, was gathered. Proteins that use either one of these three different pathways possess special features that enable their specific interaction with the components of the targeting routes. Such targeting information is often contained in an N-terminal extension, the signal sequence, but can also be found within the mature domain of the targeted protein. Once the nascent chain starts to emerge from the ribosome, competition for the protein between different targeting factors begins. After recognition and binding, the targeting factor delivers the protein to the translocation sites at the cytoplasmic membrane. Only by means of a specific interaction between the targeting component and its receptor is the cargo released for further processing and translocation. This mechanism ensures the high-fidelity targeting of premembrane and membrane proteins to the translocation site.

Probing conserved surfaces on PapD

PapD is the periplasmic chaperone required for the assembly of P pili in pyelonephritic strains of Escherichia coli. It consists of two immunoglobulin-like domains bisected by a subunit binding cleft. PapD is the prototype member of a super family of immunoglobulin-like chaperones that work in concert with their respective ushers to assemble a plethora of adhesive organelles including pilus- and non-pilus-associated adhesins. Three highly conserved residue clusters have been shown to play critical roles in the structure and function of PapD, as determined by site-directed mutagenesis. The in vivo stability of the chaperone depended on the formation of a buried salt bridge within the cleft. Residues along the G1 beta strand were required for efficient binding of subunits consistent with the crystal structure of PapD-peptide complexes. Finally, Thr-53, a residue that is part of a conserved band of residues located on the amino-terminal domain surface opposite the subunit binding cleft, was also found to be critical for pilus assembly, but mutations at Thr-53 did not interfere with chaperone-subunit complex formation.

The observation of chaperone-ligand noncovalent complexes with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FTICR-MS) was applied for the study of noncovalent chaperone SecB-ligand complexes produced in solution and examined in the gas phase with the aid of electrospray ionization (ESI). Since chaperone proteins are believed to recognize and bind only with ligands with nonnative tertiary structure, this work required careful unfolding of the ligand and subsequent reaction with the intact chaperone (the noncovalent tetrameric protein, SecB). A high denaturant concentration was employed to produce nonnative structures of the OppA, and microdialysis of the resulting solutions containing the chaperone-ligand complexes was carried out to rapidly remove the denaturant prior to analysis. Multistage mass spectrometry was essential to the successful study of these complexes since the initial mass spectra indicated extensive adduction that precluded mass measurements, even after microdialysis. However, low energy collisional activation of the ions in the FTICR trap proved useful for adduct removal, and careful control of excitation level preserved the intact complexes of interest, revealing a 1:1 SecB:OppA stoichiometry. To our knowledge, these results present the first direct observation of chaperone-ligand noncovalent complexes and the highest molecular weight heterogeneous noncovalent complex observed to date by mass spectrometry. Furthermore, these results highlight the capabilities of FTICR for the study of such complex systems, and the development of a greater understanding of chaperone interactions in protein export.