Synthesis and properties of 8-CN-flavin nucleotide analogs and studies with flavoproteins

Retuning the potential of the electrochemical leaf

The electrochemical leaf enables the electrification and control of multi-enzyme cascades by exploiting two discoveries: (i) the ability to electrify the photosynthetic enzyme ferredoxin NADP+ reductase (FNR), driving it to catalyse the interconversion of NADP+/NADPH whilst it is entrapped in a highly porous, metal oxide electrode, and (ii) the evidence that additional enzymes can be co-entrapped in the electrode pores where, through one NADP(H)-dependent enzyme, extended cascades can be driven by electrical connection to FNR, via NADP(H) recycling. By changing a critical active-site tyrosine to serine, FNR's exclusivity for NADP(H) is swapped for unphosphorylated NAD(H). Here we present an electrochemical study of this variant FNR, and show that in addition to the intended inversion of cofactor preference, this change to the active site has altered FNR's tuning of the flavin reduction potential, making it less reductive. Exploiting the ability to monitor the variant's activity with NADP(H) as a function of potential has revealed a trapped intermediate state, relieved only by applying a negative overpotential, which allows catalysis to proceed. Inhibition by NADP+ (very tightly bound) with respect to NAD(H) turnover was also revealed and interestingly, this inhibition changes depending on the applied potential. These findings are of critical importance for future exploitation of the electrochemical leaf.

A Redox-Reversible Switch of DNA Hydrogen Bonding and Structure

Modulating molecular structure and function at the nanoscale drives innovation across wide-ranging technologies. Electrical control of the bonding of individual DNA base pairs endows DNA with precise nanoscale structural reconfigurability, benefiting efforts in DNA origami and actuation. Here, alloxazine DNA base surrogates were synthesized and incorporated into DNA duplexes to function as a redox-active switch of hydrogen bonding. Circular dichroism (CD) revealed that 24-mer DNA duplexes containing one or two alloxazines exhibited CD spectra and melting transitions similar to DNA with only canonical bases, indicating that the constructs adopt a B-form conformation. However, duplexes were not formed when four or more alloxazines were incorporated into a 24-mer strand. Thiolated duplexes incorporating alloxazines were self-assembled onto multiplexed gold electrodes and probed electrochemically. Square-wave voltammetry (SWV) revealed a substantial reduction peak centered at -0.272 V vs Ag/AgCl reference. Alternating between alloxazine oxidizing and reducing conditions modulated the SWV peak in a manner consistent with the formation and loss of hydrogen bonding, which disrupts the base pair stacking and redox efficiency of the DNA construct. These alternating signals support the assertion that alloxazine can function as a redox-active switch of hydrogen bonding, useful in controlling DNA and bioinspired assemblies.

Derivatives of Natural Organocatalytic Cofactors and Artificial Organocatalytic Cofactors as Catalysts in Enzymes

Catalytically active non-metal cofactors in enzymes carry out a variety of different reactions. The efforts to develop derivatives of naturally occurring cofactors such as flavins or pyridoxal phosphate and the advances to design new, non-natural cofactors are reviewed here. We report the status quo for enzymes harboring organocatalysts as derivatives of natural cofactors or as artificial ones and their application in the asymmetric synthesis of various compounds.

Tuning the Quantum Chemical Properties of Flavins via Modification at C8

Flavins are central to countless enzymes but display different reactivities depending on their environments. This is understood to reflect modulation of the flavin electronic structure. To understand changes in orbital natures, energies, and correlation over the ring system, we begin by comparing seven flavin variants differing at C8, exploiting their different electronic spectra to validate quantum chemical calculations. Ground state calculations replicate a Hammett trend and reveal the significance of the flavin π-system. Comparison of higher-level theories establishes CC2 and ACD(2) as methods of choice for characterization of electronic transitions. Charge transfer character and electron correlation prove responsive to the identity of the substituent at C8. Indeed, bond length alternation analysis demonstrates extensive conjugation and delocalization from the C8 position throughout the ring system. Moreover, we succeed in replicating a particularly challenging UV/Vis spectrum by implementing hybrid QM/MM in explicit solvents. Our calculations reveal that the presence of nonbonding lone pairs correlates with the change in the UV/Vis spectrum observed when the 8-methyl is replaced by NH₂, OH, or SH. Thus, our computations offer routes to understanding the spectra of flavins with different modifications. This is a first step toward understanding how the same is accomplished by different binding environments.

Electron flow between the worlds of Marcus and Warburg

Living organisms are characterized by the ability to process energy (all release heat). Redox reactions play a central role in biology, from energy transduction (photosynthesis, respiratory chains) to highly selective catalyzed transformations of complex molecules. Distance and scale are important: electrons transfer on a 1 nm scale, hydrogen nuclei transfer between molecules on a 0.1 nm scale, and extended catalytic processes (cascades) operate most efficiently when the different enzymes are under nanoconfinement (10 nm-100 nm scale). Dynamic electrochemistry experiments (defined broadly within the term "protein film electrochemistry," PFE) reveal details that are usually hidden in conventional kinetic experiments. In PFE, the enzyme is attached to an electrode, often in an innovative way, and electron-transfer reactions, individual or within steady-state catalytic flow, can be analyzed in terms of precise potentials, proton coupling, cooperativity, driving-force dependence of rates, and reversibility (a mark of efficiency). The electrochemical experiments reveal subtle factors that would have played an essential role in molecular evolution. This article describes how PFE is used to visualize and analyze different aspects of biological redox chemistry, from long-range directional electron transfer to electron/hydride (NADPH) interconversion by a flavoenzyme and finally to NADPH recycling in a nanoconfined enzyme cascade.

Asymmetric redox-neutral radical cyclization catalysed by flavin-dependent 'ene'-reductases

Flavin-dependent 'ene'-reductases (EREDs) are exquisite catalysts for effecting stereoselective reductions. Although these reactions typically proceed through a hydride transfer mechanism, we recently found that EREDs can also catalyse reductive dehalogenations and cyclizations via single electron transfer mechanisms. Here, we demonstrate that these enzymes can catalyse redox-neutral radical cyclizations to produce enantioenriched oxindoles from α-haloamides. This transformation is a C-C bond-forming reaction currently unknown in nature and one for which there are no catalytic asymmetric examples. Mechanistic studies indicate the reaction proceeds via the flavin semiquinone/quinone redox couple, where ground-state flavin semiquinone provides the electron for substrate reduction and flavin quinone oxidizes the vinylogous α-amido radical formed after cyclization. This mechanistic manifold was previously unknown for this enzyme family, highlighting the versatility of EREDs in asymmetric synthesis.

Interaction between NADH and electron-transferring flavoprotein from Megasphaera elsdenii

Electron-transferring flavoprotein (ETF) from the anaerobic bacterium Megasphaera elsdenii is a heterodimer containing two FAD cofactors. Isolated ETF contains only one FAD molecule, FAD-1, because the other, FAD-2, is lost during purification. FAD-2 is recovered by adding FAD to the isolated ETF. The two FAD molecules in holoETF were characterized using NADH. Spectrophotometric titration of isolated ETF with NADH showed a two-electron reduction of FAD-1 according to a monophasic profile indicating that FAD-1 receives electrons from NADH without involvement of FAD-2. When holoETF was titrated with NADH, FAD-2 was reduced to an anionic semiquinone and then was fully reduced before the reduction of FAD-1. The midpoint potential values at pH 7 were +81, -136 and -279 mV for the reduction of oxidized FAD-2 to semiquinone, semiquinone to the fully reduced FAD-2 and the two-electron reduction of FAD-1, respectively. Both FAD-1 and FAD-2 in holoETF were reduced by excess NADH very rapidly. The reduction of FAD-2 was slowed by replacement of FAD-1 with 8-cyano-FAD indicating that FAD-2 receives electrons from FAD-1 but not from NADH directly. The present results suggest that FAD-2 is the counterpart of the FAD in human ETF, which contains one FAD and one AMP.

Crystal structure of the bacterial luciferase/flavin complex provides insight into the function of the beta subunit

Bacterial luciferase from Vibrio harveyi is a heterodimer composed of a catalytic alpha subunit and a homologous but noncatalytic beta subunit. Despite decades of enzymological investigation, structural evidence defining the active center has been elusive. We report here the crystal structure of V. harveyi luciferase bound to flavin mononucleotide (FMN) at 2.3 A. The isoalloxazine ring is coordinated by an unusual cis-Ala-Ala peptide bond. The reactive sulfhydryl group of Cys106 projects toward position C-4a, the site of flavin oxygenation. This structure also provides the first data specifying the conformations of a mobile loop that is crystallographically disordered in both prior crystal structures [(1995) Biochemistry 34, 6581-6586; (1996) J. Biol. Chem. 271, 21956 21968]. This loop appears to be a boundary between solvent and the active center. Within this portion of the protein, a single contact was observed between Phe272 of the alpha subunit, not seen in the previous structures, and Tyr151 of the beta subunit. Substitutions at position 151 on the beta subunit caused reductions in activity and total quantum yield. Several of these mutants were found to have decreased affinity for reduced flavin mononucleotide (FMNH(2)). These findings partially address the long-standing question of how the beta subunit stabilizes the active conformation of the alpha subunit, thereby participating in the catalytic mechanism.

Influence of FAD structure on its binding and activity with the C406A mutant of recombinant human liver monoamine oxidase A

The FAD binding site of human liver monoamine oxidase A (MAO A) has been investigated by mutagenesis of the amino acid site of covalent FAD attachment (Cys-406) to an alanyl residue. Expression of the C406A mutant in Saccharomyces cerevisiae results in the formation of an active enzyme, as found previously with the rat liver enzyme. The activity of this mutant enzyme is labile to solubilization, thus requiring all experiments to be done with membrane preparations. C406A MAO A was expressed in a rib 5(-) strain of S. cerevisiae in the presence of 16 different riboflavin analogues. Inactive apoC406A MAO A is formed by induction of the enzyme in the absence of riboflavin. FAD but not FMN or riboflavin restores catalytic activity with an apparent K(d) of 62 +/- 5 nm. The results from both in vivo and in vitro reconstitution experiments show increased activity levels (up to approximately 7-fold higher) with those analogues exhibiting higher oxidation-reduction potentials than normal flavin and decreased activity levels with analogues exhibiting lower potentials. Analogues with substituents on the pyrimidine ring bind to C406A MAO A more weakly than normal FAD, suggesting specific interactions with the N(3) and N(1) positions. Analogues with substituents in the 7 and 8 positions bind to C406A MAO A with affinities comparable with that of normal FAD. These results are discussed in regard to functional significance of 8alpha-covalent binding of flavins to proteins.

The role of threonine 37 in flavin reactivity of the old yellow enzyme

Threonine 37 is conserved among all the members of the old yellow enzyme (OYE) family. The hydroxyl group of this residue forms a hydrogen bond with the C-4 oxygen atom of the FMN reaction center of the enzyme [Fox, K. M. & Karplus, P. A. (1994) Structure 2, 1089-1105]. The position of Thr-37 and its interaction with flavin allow for speculations about its role in enzyme activity. This residue was mutated to alanine and the mutant enzyme was studied and compared with the wild-type OYE1 to evaluate its mechanistic function. The mutation has different effects on the two separate half-reactions of the enzyme. The mutant enzyme has enhanced activity in the oxidative half-reaction but the reductive half-reaction is slowed down by more than one order of magnitude. The peaks of the absorption spectra for enzyme bound with phenolic compounds are shifted toward shorter wavelengths than those of wild-type OYE1, consistent with its lower redox potential. It is suggested that Thr-37 in the wild-type OYE1 increases the redox potential of the enzyme by stabilizing the negative charge of the reduced flavin through hydrogen bonding with it.

Role of the flavin midpoint potential and NAD binding in determining NAD versus oxygen reactivity of xanthine oxidoreductase

Xanthine oxidoreductase from bovine milk can be prepared in two interconvertible forms, xanthine oxidase (XO) and xanthine dehydrogenase (XDH), depending on the number of protein cysteines versus cystines. Enzyme forms differ in respect to their oxidizing substrates; XDH prefers NAD to molecular oxygen, whereas XO only reacts significantly with oxygen. The preference for oxidizing substrate is partially explained by thermodynamics. Unlike XDH, the midpoint potential of the FAD, the center at which oxygen and NAD react, is too high in XO to efficiently reduce NAD (Hunt, J., Massey, V., Dunham, W.R., and Sands, R.H. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 18685-18691). To distinguish between changes in thermodynamics and in substrate binding, samples of both XO and XDH have been prepared in which the native FAD has been replaced with an FAD analog of different redox potential, 1-deaza-FAD or 8-CN-FAD. Reductive titrations indicate that both 1-deaza-XO and 1-deaza-XDH have a flavin midpoint potential similar to native XDH and that 8-CN-XO and 8-CN-XDH each have a flavin potential higher than XO. Both the low potential 1-deaza-XO and the high potential 8-CN-XDH contain essentially no xanthine/NAD activity. However, 1-deaza-XDH does exhibit xanthine/NAD activity, and 8-CN-XO has normal xanthine/oxygen activity. The binding of NAD to oxidized XO and XDH was investigated by ultrafiltration and isothermal titration calorimetry. The Kd for the binding of NAD to XDH was determined to be 280 +/- 145 microM by ultrafiltration and 160 +/- 40 microM by isothermal titration calorimetry. No evidence for the binding of NAD to XO by either method could be obtained. A low flavin midpoint potential is necessary but not sufficient for dehydrogenase activity.