Induction of cytidine to uridine editing on cytoplasmic apolipoprotein B mRNA by overexpressing APOBEC-1

Conquering new grounds: plant organellar C-to-U RNA editing factors can be functional in the plant cytosol

Plant mitochondrial and chloroplast transcripts are subject to numerous events of specific cytidine-to-uridine (C-to-U) RNA editing to correct genetic information. Key protein factors for this process are specific RNA-binding pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins, which are encoded in the nucleus and post-translationally imported into the two endosymbiotic organelles. Despite hundreds of C-to-U editing sites in the plant organelles, no comparable editing has been found for nucleo-cytosolic mRNAs raising the question why plant RNA editing is restricted to chloroplasts and mitochondria. Here, we addressed this issue in the model moss Physcomitrium patens, where all PPR-type RNA editing factors comprise specific RNA-binding and cytidine deamination functionalities in single proteins. To explore whether organelle-type RNA editing can principally also take place in the plant cytosol, we expressed PPR56, PPR65 and PPR78, three editing factors recently shown to also function in a bacterial setup, together with cytosolic co-transcribed native targets in Physcomitrium. While we obtained unsatisfying results upon their constitutive expression, we found strong cytosolic RNA editing under hormone-inducible expression. Moreover, RNA-Seq analyses revealed varying numbers of up to more than 900 off-targets in other cytosolic transcripts. We conclude that PPR-mediated C-to-U RNA editing is not per se incompatible with the plant cytosol but that its limited target specificity has restricted its occurrence to the much less complex transcriptomes of mitochondria and chloroplast in the course of evolution.

APOBEC1 cytosine deaminase activity on single-stranded DNA is suppressed by replication protein A

Many APOBEC cytidine deaminase members are known to induce ‘off-target’ cytidine deaminations in 5′TC motifs in genomic DNA that contribute to cancer evolution. In this report, we characterized APOBEC1, which is a possible cancer related APOBEC since APOBEC1 mRNA is highly expressed in certain types of tumors, such as lung adenocarcinoma. We found a low level of APOBEC1-induced DNA damage, as measured by γH2AX foci, in genomic DNA of a lung cancer cell line that correlated to its inability to compete in vitro with replication protein A (RPA) for ssDNA. This suggests that RPA can act as a defense against off-target deamination for some APOBEC enzymes. Overall, the data support the model that the ability of an APOBEC to compete with RPA can better predict genomic damage than combined analysis of mRNA expression levels in tumors and analysis of mutation signatures.

Flow-cytometric visualization of C>U mRNA editing reveals the dynamics of the process in live cells

APOBEC1 is the catalytic subunit of the complex that edits ApolipoproteinB (ApoB) mRNA, which specifically deaminates cytidine 6666 to uracil in the human transcript. The editing leads to the generation of a stop codon, resulting in the synthesis of a truncated form of ApoB. We have developed a method to quantitatively assay ApoB RNA editing in live cells by using a double fluorescent mCherry-EGFP chimera containing a ∼300bp fragment encompassing the region of ApoB subject to RNA editing. Coexpression of APOBEC1 together with this chimera causes specific RNA editing of the ApoB fragment. The insertion of a stop codon between the mCherry and EGFP thus induces the loss of EGFP fluorescence. Using this method we analyze the dynamics of APOBEC1-dependent RNA editing under various conditions. Namely we show the interplay of APOBEC1 with known interactors (ACF, hnRNP-C1, GRY-RBP) in cells that are RNA editing-proficient (HuH-7) or -deficient (HEK-293T), and the effects of restricted cellular localization of APOBEC1 on the efficiency of the editing. Furthermore, our approach is effective in assaying the induction of RNA editing in Caco-2, a cellular model physiologically capable of ApoB RNA editing.

Associations between activation-induced cytidine deaminase/apolipoprotein B mRNA editing enzyme, catalytic polypeptide-like cytidine deaminase expression, hepatitis B virus (HBV) replication and HBV-associated liver disease (Review)

The hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection is a major risk factor in the development of chronic hepatitis (CH) and hepa-tocellular carcinoma (HCC). The activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID)/apolipoprotein B mRNA editing enzyme, catalytic polypeptide-like (APOBEC) family of cytidine deaminases is significant in innate immunity, as it restricts numerous viruses, including HBV, through hypermutation-dependent and -independent mechanisms. It is important to induce covalently closed circular (ccc)DNA degradation by interferon-α without causing side effects in the infected host cell. Furthermore, organisms possess multiple mechanisms to regulate the expression of AID/APOBECs, control their enzymatic activity and restrict their access to DNA or RNA substrates. Therefore, the AID/APOBECs present promising targets for preventing and treating viral infections. In addition, gene polymorphisms of the AID/APOBEC family may alter host susceptibility to HBV acquisition and CH disease progression. Through G-to-A hypermutation, AID/APOBECs also edit HBV DNA and facilitate the mutation of HBV DNA, which may assist the virus to evolve and potentially escape from the immune responses. The AID/APOBEC family and their associated editing patterns may also exert oncogenic activity. Understanding the effects of cytidine deaminases in CH virus-induced hepatocarcinogenesis may aid with developing efficient prophylactic and therapeutic strategies against HCC.

Reassessment of murine APOBEC1 as a retrovirus restriction factor in vivo

APOBEC1 is a cytidine deaminase involved in cholesterol metabolism that has been linked to retrovirus restriction, analogous to the evolutionarily-related APOBEC3 proteins. In particular, murine APOBEC1 was shown to inhibit Friend retrovirus (FV) in vitro, generating high levels of C-to-T and G-to-A mutations. These observations raised the possibility that FV infection might be altered in APOBEC1-null mice. To examine this question directly, we infected wild-type and APOBEC1-null mice with FV complex and evaluated acute infection levels. Surprisingly, APOBEC1-null mice exhibited similar cellular infection levels and plasma viremia relative to wild-type mice. Moreover, next-generation sequencing analyses revealed that in contrast to APOBEC3, APOBEC1 did not enhance retroviral C-to-T and G-to-A mutational frequencies in genomic DNA. Thus, APOBEC1 neither inhibited nor significantly drove the molecular evolution of FV in vivo. Our findings reinforce that not all retrovirus restriction factors characterized as potent in vitro may be functionally relevant in vivo.

Functions and regulation of the APOBEC family of proteins

APOBEC1 is a cytidine deaminase that edits messenger RNAs and was the first enzyme in the APOBEC family to be functionally characterized. Under appropriate conditions APOBEC1 also deaminates deoxycytidine in single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). The other ten members of the APOBEC family have not been fully characterized however several have deoxycytidine deaminase activity on ssDNAs. Despite the nucleic acid substrate preferences of different APOBEC proteins, a common feature appears to be their intrinsic ability to bind to RNA as well as to ssDNA. RNA binding to APOBEC proteins together with protein-protein interactions, post-translation modifications and subcellular localization serve as biological modulators controlling the DNA mutagenic activity of these potentially genotoxic proteins.

Acquisition of Genetic Aberrations by Activation-Induced Cytidine Deaminase (AID) during Inflammation-Associated Carcinogenesis

Genetic abnormalities such as nucleotide alterations and chromosomal disorders that accumulate in various tumor-related genes have an important role in cancer development. The precise mechanism of the acquisition of genetic aberrations, however, remains unclear. Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), a nucleotide editing enzyme, is essential for the diversification of antibody production. AID is expressed only in activated B lymphocytes under physiologic conditions and induces somatic hypermutation and class switch recombination in immunoglobulin genes. Inflammation leads to aberrant AID expression in various gastrointestinal organs and increased AID expression contributes to cancer development by inducing genetic alterations in epithelial cells. Studies of how AID induces genetic disorders are expected to elucidate the mechanism of inflammation-associated carcinogenesis.

Recapture of hepatic apolipoprotein B mRNA editing may be a promising strategy to relieve nephrotic dyslipidemia

A high total plasma cholesterol concentration is the most common abnormality found in patients with kidney disease, which may be associated with the increased hepatic synthesis of apoB containing lipoproteins. ApoB mRNA editing plays an important physiological role in mammalian lipid metabolism by modifying the distribution of apoB-100 and apoB-48. However, it is regretful that apoB mRNA editing cannot be found in human liver because of the absence of apobec-1 expression. In this context, we hypothesize that the recapture of hepatic apoB mRNA editing may be a promising strategy to relieve nephrotic dyslipidemia. The data presented below focus on those which support this hypothesis with regards to evidence in vitro and in vivo. (1) Human wild-type apoB mRNA can be edited only when both apobec-1 and ACF proteins are presented simultaneously in vitro. (2) Adenoviral vectors can produce short-term expression of exogenous apobec-1 in the livers and lower plasma apoB-100 and LDL levels transiently. (3) Apobec-1 transgenic animals exhibit massive hepatic editing of apoB mRNA and fundamental decreased plasma levels of apoB-100 and LDL, but are exposed to high risk of liver dysplasia and hepatocellular carcinomas. In summary, taking into account the therapeutic security, we put forward that apobec-1 recombinant adenoviral vectors can be used for the recapture of hepatic apoB mRNA editing with a transient low-level manner and may achieve satisfactory lipid-lowing effect in nephropathic animals.

C to U editing at position 32 of the anticodon loop precedes tRNA 5' leader removal in trypanosomatids

In all organisms, precursor tRNAs are processed into mature functional units by post-transcriptional changes. These involve 5′ and 3′ end trimming as well as the addition of a significant number of chemical modifications, including RNA editing. The only known example of non-organellar C to U editing of tRNAs occurs in trypanosomatids. In this system, editing at position 32 of the anticodon loop of tRNA^Thr(AGU) stimulates, but is not required for, the subsequent formation of inosine at position 34. In the present work, we expand the number of C to U edited tRNAs to include all the threonyl tRNA isoacceptors. Notably, the absence of a naturally encoded adenosine, at position 34, in two of these isoacceptors demonstrates that A to I is not required for C to U editing. We also show that C to U editing is a nuclear event while A to I is cytoplasmic, where C to U editing at position 32 occurs in the precursor tRNA prior to 5′ leader removal. Our data supports the view that C to U editing is more widespread than previously thought and is part of a stepwise process in the maturation of tRNAs in these organisms.

Measuring editing activity and identifying cytidine-to-uridine mRNA editing factors in cells and biochemical isolates

Cytidine deaminases with the capacity to act on nucleic acids play a critical role in regulating the proteome through diversification of expressed sequence beyond that encoded in the genome. A family of these enzymes, known as the APOBEC family of cytidine deaminases, has been identified in mammalian cells. APOBEC-1 edits messenger RNA, whereas other family members affect mRNA coding capacity by editing single-stranded DNA in expressed regions of the genomes. Biochemical isolation and analysis of APOBEC proteins and their interacting factors have led to an understanding of the diverse cellular processes including lipoprotein metabolism, antibody production, viral infectivity, and cancer. Practical approaches will be described for the measurement of editing activity and the analysis of proteins involved in C-to-U and dC-to-dU editing.

Antiviral protein APOBEC3G localizes to ribonucleoprotein complexes found in P bodies and stress granules

Members of the APOBEC (apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing enzyme catalytic polypeptide 1-like) family of cytidine deaminases inhibit host cell genome invasion by exogenous retroviruses and endogenous retrotransposons. Because these enzymes can edit DNA or RNA and potentially mutate cellular targets, their activities are presumably regulated; for instance, APOBEC3G (A3G) recruitment into high-molecular-weight ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complexes has been shown to suppress its enzymatic activity. We used tandem affinity purification together with mass spectrometry (MS) to identify protein components within A3G-containing RNPs. We report that numerous cellular RNA-binding proteins with diverse roles in RNA function, metabolism, and fate determination are present in A3G RNPs but that most interactions with A3G are mediated via binding to shared RNAs. Confocal microscopy demonstrated that substantial quantities of A3G localize to cytoplasmic microdomains that are known as P bodies and stress granules (SGs) and are established sites of RNA storage and metabolism. Indeed, subjecting cells to stress induces the rapid redistribution of A3G and a number of P-body proteins to SGs. Among these proteins are Argonaute 1 (Ago1) and Argonaute 2 (Ago2), factors that are important for RNA silencing and whose interactions with A3G are resistant to RNase treatment. Together, these findings reveal that A3G associates with RNPs that are found throughout the cytosol as well as in discrete microdomains. We also speculate that the interplay between A3G, RNA-silencing pathways, and cellular sites of RNA metabolism may contribute to A3G's role as an inhibitor of retroelement mobility and as a possible regulator of cellular RNA function.

Metabolic regulation of apoB mRNA editing is associated with phosphorylation of APOBEC-1 complementation factor

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing is a nuclear event that minimally requires the RNA substrate, APOBEC-1 and APOBEC-1 Complementation Factor (ACF). The co-localization of these macro-molecules within the nucleus and the modulation of hepatic apoB mRNA editing activity have been described following a variety of metabolic perturbations, but the mechanism that regulates editosome assembly is unknown. APOBEC-1 was effectively co-immunoprecipitated with ACF from nuclear, but not cytoplasmic extracts. Moreover, alkaline phosphatase treatment of nuclear extracts reduced the amount of APOBEC-1 co-immunoprecipitated with ACF and inhibited in vitro editing activity. Ethanol stimulated apoB mRNA editing was associated with a 2- to 3-fold increase in ACF phosphorylation relative to that in control primary hepatocytes. Significantly, phosphorylated ACF was restricted to nuclear extracts where it co-sedimented with 27S editing competent complexes. Two-dimensional phosphoamino acid analysis of ACF immunopurified from hepatocyte nuclear extracts demonstrated phosphorylation of serine residues that was increased by ethanol treatment. Inhibition of protein phosphatase I, but not PPIIA or IIB, stimulated apoB mRNA editing activity coincident with enhanced ACF phosphorylation in vivo. These data demonstrate that ACF is a metabolically regulated phosphoprotein and suggest that this post-translational modification increases hepatic apoB mRNA editing activity by enhancing ACF nuclear localization/retention, facilitating the interaction of ACF with APOBEC-1 and thereby increasing the probability of editosome assembly and activity.

Regulated production and anti-HIV type 1 activities of cytidine deaminases APOBEC3B, 3F, and 3G

APOBEC3G and 3F (A3G and A3F) cytidine deaminases incorporate into retroviral cores where they lethally hypermutate nascent DNA reverse transcripts. As substantiated here, the viral infectivity factor (Vif) encoded by human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) binds A3G and A3F and induces their degradation, thereby precluding their incorporation into viral progeny. Previous evidence suggested that A3G is expressed in H9 and other nonpermissive cells that contain this antiviral defense but not in several permissive cells, and that overexpression of A3G or A3F makes permissive cells nonpermissive. Using a broader panel of cell lines, we confirmed a correlation between A3G and cellular abilities to inactivate HIV-1(Deltavif). However, there was a quantitative discrepancy because several cells with weak antiviral activities had similar amounts of wild-type A3G mRNA and protein compared to H9 cells. Antiviral activity of H9 cells was also attenuated in some conditions. These quantitative discrepancies could not be explained by the presence of A3F or other A3G paralogs in some of the cell lines. Thus, A3A, A3B, and A3C had weak but significant anti-HIV-1 activities and did not dominantly interfere with A3G or A3F antiviral functions. Control of A3G synthesis by the protein kinase C/mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase/extracellular signal-regulated kinase pathway was also similar in permissive and nonpermissive cells. A3G in highly permissive cells is degraded by Vif, suggesting that it is not in a sequestered site, and is specifically incorporated in low amounts into HIV-1(Deltavif). Although A3G and/or A3F inactivate HIV-1(Deltavif) and are neutralized by Vif, the antiviral properties of cell lines are also influenced by other cellular and viral factors.

Recent insights into HIV-1 Vif

The lentiviruses, including HIV-1 (but excluding equine infectious anemia virus), encode a viral infectivity factor (Vif) protein. Circumstantial evidence suggested that Vif acts to neutralize an inhibitory host defense mechanism, but progress in the field was limited because the identity of the cellular target was unknown. The recent identification of the elusive host cell factor let loose a flood of advances. These findings have revealed a novel innate defense mechanism against retroviruses. In infected cells, the cellular cytidine deaminase APOBEC3G, a relative of the activation-induced deaminase (AID), is encapsidated into assembling virions. The enzyme lies in the virion, waiting to wreak havoc on the viral genome in the next round of virus replication--unless it is first caught by Vif.

Single-strand specificity of APOBEC3G accounts for minus-strand deamination of the HIV genome

HIV-1 deleted for the vif accessory gene encapsidates the cellular cytidine deaminase APOBEC3G. Upon infection, the encapsidated APOBEC3G induces G-->A mutations in the viral reverse transcripts. The G-->A mutations result either from C-->U deamination of the minus strand or deamination of both strands followed by repair of the plus strand. We report here that minus-strand deamination occurred over the length of the virus genome, preferentially at CCCA sequences, with a graded frequency in the 5'-->3' direction. APOBEC3G induced previously undetected C-->T mutations in the 5' U3 and the primer-binding site, both of which become transiently single-stranded during reverse transcription. In vitro, APOBEC3G bound and deaminated single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) but not double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) or DNA-RNA hybrids. We propose that the requirement for ssDNA accounts for the minus-strand mutations, the 5'-->3' graded frequency of deamination and the rare C-->T mutations.

A single amino acid of APOBEC3G controls its species-specific interaction with virion infectivity factor (Vif)

The virion infectivity factor (Vif) accessory protein of HIV-1 forms a complex with the cellular cytidine deaminase APOBEC3G (apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing enzyme, catalytic polypeptide-like 3G) to block its antiviral activity. The antiviral property of APOBEC3G is conserved in several mammalian species, but the ability of Vif to block this activity is species-specific. HIV-1 Vif blocks human APOBEC3G but does not block the mouse or African green monkey (AGM) enzyme. Conversely, SIV(AGM) Vif blocks the antiviral activity of AGM but not human APOBEC3G. We demonstrate that the species specificity is caused by a single amino acid difference in APOBEC3G. Replacement of Asp-128 in human APOBEC3G with the Lys-128 of AGM APOBEC3G caused the enzyme to switch its interaction, becoming sensitive to SIV(AGM) Vif and resistant to HIV-1 Vif. Conversely, the reciprocal Lys to Asp switch in AGM APOBEC3G reversed its specificity for Vif. The reversal of biological activity was accompanied by the corresponding switch in the species specificity with which the enzyme physically associated with Vif and was excluded from virions. The charge of the amino acid at position 128 was a critical determinant of species specificity. Based on the crystal structure of the distantly related Escherichia coli cytidine deaminase, we propose that this amino acid is positioned on a solvent-exposed loop of APOBEC3G on the same face of the protein as the catalytic site.

Identification of novel alternative splice variants of APOBEC-1 complementation factor with different capacities to support apolipoprotein B mRNA editing

Two novel mRNA transcripts have been identified that result from species- and tissue-specific, alternative polyadenylation and splicing of the pre-mRNA encoding the apolipoprotein B (apoB) editing catalytic subunit 1 (APOBEC-1) complementation factor (ACF) family of related proteins. The alternatively processed mRNAs encode 43- and 45-kDa proteins that are components of the previously identified p44 cluster of apoB RNA binding, editosomal proteins. Recombinant ACF45 displaced ACF64 and ACF43 in mooring sequence RNA binding but did not demonstrate strong binding to APOBEC-1. In contrast, ACF43 bound strongly to APOBEC-1 but demonstrated weak binding to mooring sequence RNA. Consequently ACF45/43 complemented APOBEC-1 in apoB mRNA editing with less efficiency than full-length ACF64. These data, together with the finding that all ACF variants were co-expressed in rat liver nuclei (the site of apoB mRNA editing), suggested that ACF variants might compete with one another for APOBEC-1 and apoB mRNA binding and thereby contribute to the regulation of apoB mRNA editing. In support for this hypothesis, the ratio of nuclear ACF65/64 to ACF45/43 decreased when hepatic editing was inhibited by fasting and increased when editing was re-stimulated by refeeding. These findings suggested a new model for the regulation of apoB mRNA editing in which the catalytic potential of editosomes is modulated at the level of their assembly by alterations in the relative abundance of multiple related RNA-binding auxiliary proteins and the expression level of APOBEC-1.

Involvement of a chaperone regulator, Bcl2-associated athanogene-4, in apolipoprotein B mRNA editing

Apobec-1 is the catalytic subunit of a multicomponent editosome complex that mediates apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing. We isolated a novel apobec-1-interacting protein by yeast two-hybrid cloning and identified the protein as BAG-4. BAG-4, a chaperone-regulating protein, also known as SODD (silencer of death domains), is a member of the BAG family of proteins. In this report, we found that apobec-1 is localized in the perinucleolar compartment in HepG2 cells and rat liver MCR-RH7777 cells. BAG-4 binds to apobec-1 via its N-terminal region independent of the BAG domain. It is ubiquitously expressed with predominant occurrence in human pancreas, heart, brain, and placenta. Immunoprecipitation experiments confirmed that BAG-4 interacts with Hsc70/Hsp90 in HepG2 cells. BAG-4 tagged with green fluorescent protein (GFP) or FLAG was localized both in cytoplasm of mouse BNLCL.2 liver cells and human liver hepatoma HepG2 cells. After heat shock, GFP-BAG-4 co-localizes with Hsc70 in the nucleus in HepG2 cells, whereas GFP-BAG-4 mutants lacking the BAG domain remain perinuclear. BAG-4 has no effects on apoB mRNA editing in vitro. However, unlike other apobec-1 complementation factors studied to date, antisense knockdown of BAG-4 in BNLCL.2 cells and in MCR-RH7777 cells increases rather than decreases endogenous apoB mRNA editing. Overexpression of BAG-4 in MCR-RH7777 cells also suppresses apoB mRNA editing. ApoB-48 production also increases with antisense BAG-4 expression in MCR-RH7777 cells. We previously showed that apoB mRNA editing is an intranuclear event (Lau, P. P., Xiong, W. J., Zhu, H. J., Chen, S. H., and Chan, L. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 20550-20554). Thus, BAG-4 overexpression down-regulates apoB mRNA editing by shuttling apobec-1 from the intranuclear perinucleolar compartment to the cytoplasm. We propose that BAG-4 functions as a negative regulator for apobec-1-mediated apoB mRNA editing through its ability to suppress the Hsp/Hsc70 chaperone activity and thereby editosome formation and, as a consequence, prevents nuclear localization of the apobec-1 editosome.

Regulation of human apolipoprotein B gene expression at multiple levels

Apolipoprotein B is a large, amphipathic protein that plays a central role in lipoprotein metabolism. Because its overproduction and deficiency leads to metabolic and pathologic disorders, much effort has been paid to investigate the mechanisms of how its homeostasis is achieved. Earlier and recent studies have showed that apoB gene locus might reside in different chromatin domains in the hepatic and intestinal cells, and two sets of very distinct regulatory elements operate to control its transcription. Posttranscriptional modification of apoB mRNA is performed by a multicomponent enzyme complex, several possible pathways regulate the editing efficiency. Understanding of the mechanism responsible for apoB mRNA editing will provide the basis for C-to-U editing in gene therapy. In addition to apoB mRNA abundance and stability, its translation can be also regulated at the steps of elongation. The translocation of apoB into the ER is an important and complicated process that is less understood. Successful transport and correct folding of apoB may lead to its final secretion, otherwise subject to intracellular degradation, which is accomplished by proteasomal and nonproteasomal pathways at multiple levels and may differ among cell types.

Species-specific exclusion of APOBEC3G from HIV-1 virions by Vif

The HIV-1 accessory protein Vif (virion infectivity factor) is required for the production of infectious virions by CD4(+) lymphocytes. Vif facilitates particle infectivity by blocking the inhibitory activity of APOBEC3G (CEM15), a virion-encapsidated cellular protein that deaminates minus-strand reverse transcript cytosines to uracils. We report that HIV-1 Vif forms a complex with human APOBEC3G that prevents its virion encapsidation. HIV-1 Vif did not efficiently form a complex with mouse APOBEC3G. Vif dramatically reduced the amount of human APOBEC3G encapsidated in HIV-1 virions but did not prevent encapsidation of mouse or AGM APOBEC3G. As a result, these enzymes are potent inhibitors of wild-type HIV-1 replication. The species-specificity of this interaction may play a role in restricting HIV-1 infection to humans. Together these findings suggest that therapeutic intervention that either induced APOBEC3G or blocked its interaction with Vif could be clinically beneficial.

Messenger RNA editing in mammals: new members of the APOBEC family seeking roles in the family business

Alteration of mRNA sequence through base modification mRNA editing frequently generates protein diversity. Several proteins have been identified as being similar to C-to-U mRNA editing enzymes based on their structural domains and the occurrence of a catalytic domain characteristic of cytidine deaminases. In light of the hypothesis that these proteins might represent novel mRNA editing systems that could affect proteome diversity, we consider their structure, expression and relevance to biomedically significant processes or pathologies.

Regulatable liver expression of the rabbit apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing enzyme catalytic polypeptide 1 (APOBEC-1) in mice lacking endogenous APOBEC-1 leads to aberrant hyperediting

Apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA editing is the deamination of C(6666) to uridine, which results in translation of the apoB-48 protein instead of the genomically encoded apoB-100. ApoB-48-containing lipoproteins are cleared more rapidly from plasma and are less atherogenic than apoB-100-containing low-density lipoproteins (LDLs). In humans, the intestine predominantly produces apoB-48 whereas the liver secretes apoB-100 only. To evaluate a potential therapeutic use for liver-induced apoB mRNA editing in humans, we investigated the efficiency and safety of transgenic expression of apoB mRNA-editing enzyme catalytic polypeptide 1 (APOBEC-1) in the absence of endogenous editing in the mouse model. Here we show that regulatable tetO-mediated APOBEC-1 expression in the livers of gene-targeted mice lacking endogenous APOBEC-1 results in 30% apoB mRNA editing. In a time-course experiment, the expression of tetO-APOBEC-1 mRNA was suppressed within 2 days after mice were fed doxycycline and apoB mRNA editing and apoB-48 formation were suppressed within 4 days. However, tetO-APOBEC-1 expression resulted in regulatable aberrant hyperediting of several cytidines downstream of C(6666) in apoB mRNA and in novel APOBEC-1 target 1 (NAT1) mRNA. Several of the cytidines in apoB mRNA were hyperedited to a level similar to that of C(6666), although editing at C(6666) was lower than that in wild-type mice. These results demonstrate that even moderate APOBEC-1 expression can lead to hyperediting, limiting the single-gene approach for gene therapy with APOBEC-1.

Molecular regulation, evolutionary, and functional adaptations associated with C to U editing of mammalian apolipoproteinB mRNA

RNA editing encompasses an important class of co- or posttranscriptional nucleic acid modification that has expanded our understanding of the range of mechanisms that facilitate genetic plasticity. Since the initial description of RNA editing in trypanosome mitochondria, a model of gene regulation has emerged that now encompasses a diverse range of biochemical and genetic mechanisms by which nuclear, mitochondrial, and t-RNA sequences are modified from templated versions encoded in the genome. RNA editing is genetically and biochemically distinct from other RNA modifications such as splicing, capping, and polyadenylation although, as discussed in Section I, these modifications may have relevance to the regulation of certain types of mammalian RNA editing. This review will focus on C to U RNA editing, in particular, the biochemical and genetic mechanisms that regulate this process in mammals. These mechanisms will be examined in the context of the prototype model of C to U RNA editing, namely the posttranscriptional cytidine deamination targeting a single nucleotide in mammalian apolipoproteinB (apoB). Other examples of C to U RNA editing will be discussed and the molecular mechanisms--where known--contrasted with those regulating apoB RNA editing.

AID-GFP chimeric protein increases hypermutation of Ig genes with no evidence of nuclear localization

Somatic hypermutation generates variants of antibody genes and underpins the affinity maturation of antibodies. It is restricted to the V-gene segments, and although it decays exponentially toward the 3'end, it includes recognizable hot spots. Although the detailed mechanism of hypermutation remains elusive, the process may take place in two separate stages, preferentially targeting G/Cs in the first and A/Ts in the second stage. It seems that MSH2 is involved in the second stage, and that activation induced deaminase (AID) is implicated in the control of hypermutation. The constitutively hypermutating cell line Ramos expresses AID, and we have prepared transfectants that express a chimeric AID-green fluorescent protein. The fluorescence is strongly detected in the cytoplasm but not in the nucleus. Yet, the chimeric protein increases the hypermutation rate either directly or, more likely, indirectly, by favoring the transport of AID into the nucleus. Thus, in Ramos, AID seems to be rate limiting. Unexpectedly, the proportion of deletions also is increased. The increase in mutation rate detected by a fast cytofluorimetric method based on the accumulation of sIgM-loss mutants correlates with the increase measured by mutations defined by sequence analysis. The higher mutation rate is largely explained by the higher proportion of mutated clones, indicating that AID controls the number of cells that undergo hypermutation but not the number of mutations that are incorporated in each mutation round.

Two proteins essential for apolipoprotein B mRNA editing are expressed from a single gene through alternative splicing

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing involves site-specific deamination of cytidine to form uridine, resulting in the production of an in-frame stop codon. Protein translated from edited mRNA is associated with a reduced risk of atherosclerosis, and hence the protein factors that regulate hepatic apoB mRNA editing are of interest. A human protein essential for apoB mRNA editing and an eight-amino acid-longer variant of no known function have been recently cloned. We report that both proteins, henceforth referred to as ACF64 and ACF65, supported APOBEC-1 (the catalytic subunit of the editosome) equivalently in editing of apoB mRNA. They are encoded by a single 82-kb gene on chromosome 10. The transcripts are encoded by 15 exons that are expressed from a tissue-specific promoter minimally contained within the -0.33-kb DNA sequence. ACF64 and ACF65 mRNAs are expressed in both liver and intestinal cells in an approximate 1:4 ratio. Exon 11 is alternatively spliced to include or exclude 24 nucleotides of exon 12, thereby encoding ACF65 and ACF64, respectively. Recognition motifs for the serine/arginine-rich (SR) proteins SC35, SRp40, SRp55, and SF2/ASF involved in alternative RNA splicing were predicted in exon 12. Overexpression of these SR proteins in liver cells demonstrated that alternative splicing of a minigene-derived transcript to express ACF65 was enhanced 6-fold by SRp40. The data account for the expression of two editing factors and provide a possible explanation for their different levels of expression.

Two new isotype-specific switching activities detected for Ig class switching

Ig class switch recombination (CSR) occurs by an intrachromosomal deletional process between switch (S) regions in B cells. To facilitate the study of CSR, we derived a new B cell line, 1.B4.B6, which is uniquely capable of mu --> gamma3, mu --> epsilon, and mu --> alpha, but not mu --> gamma1 CSR at its endogenous loci. The 1.B4.B6 cell line was used in combination with plasmid-based isotype-specific S substrates in transient transfection assays to test for the presence of trans-acting switching activities. The 1.B4.B6 cell line supports mu --> gamma3, but not mu --> gamma1 recombination, on S substrates. In contrast, normal splenic B cells activated with LPS and IL-4 are capable of plasmid-based mu --> gamma1 CSR and demonstrate that this S plasmid is active. Activation-induced deaminase (AID) was used as a marker to identify existing B cell lines as possible candidates for supporting CSR. The M12 and A20 cell lines were identified as AID positive and, following activation with CD40L and other activators, were found to differentially support mu --> epsilon and mu --> alpha plasmid-based CSR. These studies provide evidence for two new switching activities for mu --> gamma1 and mu --> epsilon CSR, which are distinct from mu --> gamma3 and mu --> alpha switching activities previously described. AID is expressed in all the B cell lines capable of CSR, but cannot account for the isotype specificity defined by the S plasmid assay. These results are consistent with a model in which isotype-specific switching factors are either isotype-specific recombinases or DNA binding proteins with sequence specificity for S DNA.

The editosome for cytidine to uridine mRNA editing has a native complexity of 27S: identification of intracellular domains containing active and inactive editing factors

Apolipoprotein B mRNA cytidine to uridine editing requires the assembly of a multiprotein editosome comprised minimally of the catalytic subunit,apolipoprotein B mRNA editing catalytic subunit 1 (APOBEC-1), and an RNA-binding protein, APOBEC-1 complementation factor (ACF). A rat homolog has been cloned with 93.5% identity to human ACF (huACF). Peptide-specific antibodies prepared against huACF immunoprecipitated a rat protein of similar mass as huACF bound to apolipoprotein B (apoB) RNA in UV cross-linking reactions, thereby providing evidence that the p66, mooring sequence-selective, RNA-binding protein identified previously in rat liver by UV cross-linking and implicated in editosome assembly is a functional homolog of huACF. The rat protein (p66/ACF) was distributed in both the nucleus and cytoplasm of rat primary hepatocytes. Within a thin section, a significant amount of total cellular p66/ACF was cytoplasmic, with a concentration at the outer surface of the endoplasmic reticulum. Native APOBEC-1 co-fractionated with p66/ACF in the cytoplasm as 60S complexes. In the nucleus, the biological site of apoB mRNA editing, native p66/ACF, was localized to heterochromatin and fractionated with APOBEC-1 as 27S editosomes. When apoB mRNA editing was stimulated in rat primary hepatocytes with ethanol or insulin, the abundance of p66/ACF in the nucleus markedly increased. It is proposed that the heterogeneity in size of complexes containing editing factors is functionally significant and reflects functionally engaged editosomes in the nucleus and an inactive cytoplasmic pool of factors.

Apolipoprotein B mRNA editing and the reduction in synthesis and secretion of the atherogenic risk factor, apolipoprotein B100 can be effectively targeted through TAT-mediated protein transduction

Hepatic very-low-density lipoprotein particles (VLDL) containing full-length apolipoprotein B100 are metabolized in the blood stream to low-density lipoprotein (LDL) particles, whose elevated levels increase the risk of atherosclerosis. Statins and bile-acid sequestrants are effective LDL-lowering therapies for many patients. Development of alternative therapies remains important for patients with adverse reactions to conventional therapy, with defects in the LDL receptor-dependent lipoprotein uptake pathway and for intervention in children. Editing of apoB mRNA by the enzyme APOBEC-1 changes a glutamine codon to a stop codon, leading to the synthesis and secretion of apoB48-containing VLDL, which are rapidly cleared before they can be metabolized to LDL. Human liver does not edit apoB mRNA because it does not express APOBEC-1. Although initially promising, enthusiasm for apobec-1 gene therapy for hypercholesterolemia was blunted by the finding that uncontrolled transgenic expression of APOBEC-1 led to nonspecific editing of mRNAs and pathology. We demonstrate that APOBEC-1 fused to TAT entered primary hepatocytes, where it induced a transient increase in mRNA editing activity and enhanced synthesis and secretion of VLDL containing apoB48. Protein transduction of APOBEC-1 transiently stimulated high levels of apoB mRNA editing in a dose-dependent manner without loss of fidelity. These results suggested that apoB mRNA editing should be re-evaluated as a LDL-lowering therapeutic target in the new context of protein transduction therapy.

Ethanol stimulates apolipoprotein B mRNA editing in the absence of de novo RNA or protein synthesis

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing involves a site-specific modification of cytidine to form uridine. The reaction is catalyzed in the nucleus by a multi-protein editosome. Rat hepatic editing is regulated during development, metabolically and in response to ethanol. Ethanol stimulated editing in hepatocytes within minutes of exposure. In the present study, we show that ethanol stimulated apoB mRNA synthesis and apoB mRNA editing. Significantly, the proportion of edited apoB mRNA also increased following ethanol treatment of transcription or translation arrested cells. These data suggested that ethanol could regulate editing activity using pre-existing editosomal proteins. In addition, the presence of a suppressor of apoB mRNA editing activity was suggested by the finding that inhibition of mRNA or protein synthesis alone was sufficient to increase the proportion of edited RNA. It is proposed that the level of editing activity observed in hepatocytes may be the end result of positive and negative regulatory proteins.

Novel role for RNA-binding protein CUGBP2 in mammalian RNA editing. CUGBP2 modulates C to U editing of apolipoprotein B mRNA by interacting with apobec-1 and ACF, the apobec-1 complementation factor

Mammalian apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing is mediated by a multicomponent holoenzyme containing apobec-1 and ACF. We have now identified CUGBP2, a 54-kDa RNA-binding protein, as a component of this holoenzyme. CUGBP2 and ACF co-fractionate in bovine liver S-100 extracts, and addition of recombinant apobec-1 leads to assembly of a holoenzyme. Immunodepletion of CUGBP2 co-precipitates ACF, and these proteins co-localize the nucleus of transfected cells, suggesting that CUGBP2 and ACF are bound in vivo. CUGBP2 binds apoB RNA, specifically an AU-rich sequence located immediately upstream of the edited cytidine. ApoB RNA from McA cells, bound to CUGBP2, was more extensively edited than the unbound fraction. However, addition of recombinant CUGBP2 to a reconstituted system demonstrated a dose-dependent inhibition of C to U RNA editing, which was rescued with either apobec-1 or ACF. Antisense CUGBP2 knockout increased endogenous apoB RNA editing, whereas antisense knockout of either apobec-1 or ACF expression eliminated apoB RNA editing, establishing the absolute requirement of these components of the core enzyme. These data suggest that CUGBP2 plays a role in apoB mRNA editing by forming a regulatory complex with the three components of the minimal editing enzyme, apobec-1, ACF, and apoB RNA.

Mutagenesis of apobec-1 complementation factor reveals distinct domains that modulate RNA binding, protein-protein interaction with apobec-1, and complementation of C to U RNA-editing activity

C to U editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) RNA requires a multicomponent holoenzyme complex in which minimal constituents include apobec-1 and apobec-1 complementation factor (ACF). We have examined the predicted functional domains in ACF in binding apoB RNA, interaction with apobec-1, and complementation of RNA editing. We demonstrate that apoB RNA binding and apobec-1-interacting domains are defined by two partially overlapping regions containing the NH(2)-terminal RNA recognition motifs of ACF. Both apoB RNA binding and apobec-1 interaction are required for editing complementation activity. ACF is a nuclear protein that upon cotransfection with apobec-1 results in nuclear colocalization and redistribution of apobec-1 from the cytoplasm. ACF constructs with deletions or mutations in the putative nuclear localization signal (NLS) still localize in the nucleus of transfected cells but do not colocalize with apobec-1, the latter remaining predominantly cytoplasmic. These observations suggest that the putative NLS motif in ACF is not responsible for its nucleo-cytoplasmic trafficking. By contrast, protein-protein interaction is important for the nuclear import of apobec-1. Taken together, these data suggest that functional complementation of C to U RNA editing by apobec-1 involves the NH(2)-terminal 380 residues of ACF.

Commitment of apolipoprotein B RNA to the splicing pathway regulates cytidine-to-uridine editing-site utilization

A tripartite motif located in the centre of the 7.5 kb exon 26 of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA directs editosome assembly and site-specific cytidine-to-uridine editing at nucleotide 6666. apoB mRNA editing is a post-transcriptional event, occurring primarily at the time exon 26 is spliced or at a time after splicing, but before nuclear export. We show, through reporter RNA constructs, that RNA splice sites suppress editing of precursor RNAs when placed proximal or distal to the editing site. Processed RNAs were edited more efficiently than precursor RNAs. Mutation of both the splice donor and acceptor sites was necessary for RNAs to be edited efficiently. The results suggested that commitment of pre-mRNA to the splicing and/or nuclear-export pathways may play a role in regulating editing-site utilization. The HIV-1 Rev-Rev response element ('RRE') interaction was utilized to uncouple the commitment of precursor RNAs to the spliceosome assembly pathway and associated nuclear-export pathway. Under these conditions, unspliced reporter RNAs were edited efficiently. We propose that pre-mRNA passage through the temporal or spatial restriction point where they become committed to spliceosome assembly contributes regulatory information for subsequent editosome activity.

Phosphorylation is a regulatory mechanism in apolipoprotein B mRNA editing

The editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA is under tissue-specific, developmental and metabolic regulation. We found that multiple protein kinase inhibitors or activators increased apoB mRNA editing up to 2.5-fold in Caco-2 cells and 3-8-fold in McA7777 and FAO rat cells respectively. The phosphorylation-agent-induced modulation is independent of the apolipoprotein B editing catalytic subunit 1 (APOBEC-1) and of apoB mRNA expression levels, indicating the involvement of a protein modification, such as phosphorylation, regulating the cellular editing of apoB mRNA. Transient expression of protein kinase C-θ more than doubled apoB mRNA editing in FAO cells. Chronic exposure to ethanol, a treatment known to increase the expression of protein kinases and to change protein phosphorylation status, increased apoB mRNA editing in FAO cells up to 2.5-fold without increasing the mRNA abundance of APOBEC-1. The elimination of potential phosphorylation sites 47 and 72 of human APOBEC-1 decreased its activity to approx. one-eighth of control levels by a Ser(47)-->Ala mutation, but more than doubled the activity by a Ser(72)-->Ala mutation. The activity modulation was reversed by a Ser-->Asp mutation at sites 47 and 72, which introduced a phosphorylation-like carbonic acid group. Both human APOBEC-1 dephosphorylated by alkaline phosphase and the Ser(47,72)-to-alanine double mutant protein demonstrated a shifted isoelectric focusing pattern compared with the wild type, indicating phosphorylation at these sites. Taken together, these results suggest that phosphorylation might be an important mechanism in the regulation of apoB mRNA editing.

Intracellular trafficking determinants in APOBEC-1, the catalytic subunit for cytidine to uridine editing of apolipoprotein B mRNA

The posttranscriptional deamination editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA catalyzed by APOBEC-1 (apoB mRNA editing catalytic subunit 1) is a nuclear process. The signals in APOBEC-1 responsible for its dual cytoplasmic/nuclear distribution have been evaluated. Residues 97-172 in the middle of APOBEC-1 together with its N-terminal 56 residues affect nuclear localization. Mutagenesis studies however revealed no discrete nuclear localization signal in APOBEC-1. Fifteen amino acids (Leu 173-Leu 187) within the previously identified C-terminal domain of APOBEC-1 were sufficient as a determinant for cytoplasmic distribution in that context. These residues failed to demonstrate nuclear export function in a reporter assay. Further, the distribution of APOBEC-1 in the cytoplasm did not respond to leptomycin B, suggesting that APOBEC-1 did not have nuclear export activity. The data suggested that there are at least three regions in APOBEC-1 that participate in its distribution in both the nucleus and the cytoplasm of editing competent cells; however, none of these meet the functional criteria of nuclear localization or nuclear export signals. The findings are discussed in terms of their implications in the regulation of nuclear editing activity and the possibility that interactions with chaperones may play a role in the cellular distribution of APOBEC-1.

Identification of the yeast cytidine deaminase CDD1 as an orphan C-->U RNA editase

Yeast co-expressing rat APOBEC-1 and a fragment of human apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA assembled functional editosomes and deaminated C6666 to U in a mooring sequence-dependent fashion. The occurrence of APOBEC-1-complementing proteins suggested a naturally occurring mRNA editing mechanism in yeast. Previously, a hidden Markov model identified seven yeast genes encoding proteins possessing putative zinc-dependent deaminase motifs. Here, only CDD1, a cytidine deaminase, is shown to have the capacity to carry out C-->U editing on a reporter mRNA. This is only the second report of a cytidine deaminase that can use mRNA as a substrate. CDD1-dependent editing was growth phase regulated and demonstrated mooring sequence-dependent editing activity. Candidate yeast mRNA substrates were identified based on their homology with the mooring sequence-containing tripartite motif at the editing site of apoB mRNA and their ability to be edited by ectopically expressed APOBEC-1. Naturally occurring yeast mRNAs edited to a significant extent by CDD1 were, however, not detected. We propose that CDD1 be designated an orphan C-->U editase until its native RNA substrate, if any, can be identified and that it be added to the CDAR (cytidine deaminase acting on RNA) family of editing enzymes.

Molecular mechanisms of apolipoprotein B mRNA editing

A site-specific post-transcriptional cytidine to uridine deamination reaction is responsible for the production of apolipoprotein B48 in the mammalian small intestine. The molecular machinery responsible for apolipoprotein B RNA editing consists of apobec-1, an RNA-specific cytidine deaminase that functions in conjunction with a recently identified protein referred to as ACF/ASP. These proteins together represent the minimal editing enzyme, although other proteins may associate with the enzyme complex. Apobec-1 is a member of a supergene family of cytidine deaminases, with several homologs recently identified in the human genome. ACF/ASP is novel, and emerging information reveals interesting clues to its role in the apolipoprotein B RNA editing enzyme complex.

Identification of GRY-RBP as an apolipoprotein B RNA-binding protein that interacts with both apobec-1 and apobec-1 complementation factor to modulate C to U editing

C to U editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA involves the interaction of a multicomponent editing enzyme complex with a requisite RNA sequence embedded within an AU-rich context. This enzyme complex includes apobec-1, an RNA-specific cytidine deaminase, and apobec-1 complementation factor (ACF), a novel 65-kDa RNA-binding protein, that together represent the minimal core of the editing enzyme complex. The precise composition of the holo-enzyme, however, remains unknown. We have previously isolated an enriched fraction of S100 extracts, prepared from chicken intestinal cells, that displays apoB RNA binding and which, following supplementation with apobec-1, permits efficient C to U editing. Peptide sequencing of this most active fraction reveals the presence of ACF as well as GRY-RBP, an RNA-binding protein with approximately 50% homology to ACF. GRY-RBP was independently isolated from a two-hybrid screen of chicken intestinal cDNA. GRY-RBP binds to ACF, to apobec-1, and also binds apoB RNA. Experiments using recombinant proteins demonstrate that GRY-RBP binds to ACF and inhibits both the binding of ACF to apoB RNA and C to U RNA editing. This competitive inhibition is rescued by addition of ACF, suggesting that GRY-RBP binds to and sequesters ACF. As further evidence of the role of GRY-RBP, rat hepatoma cells treated with an antisense oligonucleotide to GRY-RBP demonstrated an increase in C to U editing of endogenous apoB RNA. ACF and GRY-RBP colocalize in the nucleus of transfected cells and, in cotransfection experiments with apobec-1, each appears to colocalize in a predominantly nuclear distribution. Taken together, the results indicate that GRY-RBP is a member of the ACF gene family that may function to modulate C to U RNA editing through binding either to ACF or to apobec-1 or, alternatively, to the target RNA itself.