Mortality in Surgically Treated Adrenocortical Tumors

Adrenocortical carcinoma: what the surgeon needs to know. Case report and literature review

Adrenocortical carcinoma is a rare and aggressive cancer and its prognosis is frequently unsatisfactory. Due to its rarity there's a lack of prospective randomized studies. Without experience in the approach of this kind of tumor, managing becomes challenging and, moreover, we have only few recommendations, based on weak evidence. We report a case that has some peculiarities and is an excellent food for thought. Then we deal with a literature review to highlight and summarize most significant aspects of epidemiology, clinic, diagnosis, therapy and prognosis in an exquisitely surgical point of view.

Adrenocortical carcinoma: past, present, and future

Adrenocortical carcinoma (ACC) is a rare endocrine malignancy. Due to its rarity, heterogeneity, and a lack of a comprehensive understanding of the pathogenesis, little progress has been made in treatment and outcomes. The current review explores the past, present, and future of the understanding and treatment of this disease process.

Mutational analysis of StAR gene in adrenal tumors

Adrenal adenomas and carcinomas are mostly monoclonal, suggesting that a genetic alteration in a progenitor cell may contribute to their development. However, the molecular pathogenesis of these tumors still remains unclear. It has been already excluded that activating mutations of the ACTH receptor or of G protein stimulator alpha sub-units, affecting cAMP pathway, is involved in the tumorigenesis. Therefore, this work has been focused on post-transductional (ACTH) signal alterations and in particular on the mutational analysis of the Steroid Acute Regulatory protein (StAR) gene to verify whether somatic mutations or genomic polymorphisms of this gene may be correlated with adrenal tumorigenesis. Tissue DNA was extracted from 40 functional and non-functional adrenocortical tumors that were removed from patients aged between 17 and 72 years (mean 43 +/- 4). Blood DNA was obtained from 24 patients (aged between 26 and 70 years) affected by adrenal tumors and from 100 healthy subjects without radiological and clinical evidence of adrenal masses, aged between 25-35 years (90 Caucasians and 10 Africans). The DNA was used as the template for the amplification of the StAR gene using the polymerase chain reaction. The amplified DNA of each exon of the StAR gene was purified and sequenced in automatic sequenciator. With the exception of exon 5 showing in codon 203 an homozygous missense mutation, the sequence of the other exons of the StAR gene resulted normal in all tumors studied. The same homozygous mutation (Asp203Ala) was observed in the sequence of exon 5 performed on genomic DNA of the 24 affected patients and in the control subjects. The homozygosity of the mutation observed in all patients (either in tissue or blood samples) and in control subjects, independently of their ethnic origin, led us to suggest that the Asp203Ala cannot be considered as mutation or as polymorphism, but that it must be considered as a mistake in the sequence entered in the Genbank, which needs to be modified accordingly. These data, and those up to now reported in the literature, allow us to suggest that mutations of the gene coding for the protein involved in the initial step of the steroidogenesis could not be considered as a possible cause for the development of adrenal tumors.

Adrenal cortical carcinoma. Epidemiology and treatment with mitotane and a review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Adrenal cortical carcinoma is rare; the authors have treated only eight patients with the disease at Good Samaritan Regional Medical Center since 1974. No exhaustive collection of cases of this cancer has been done since 1952.

METHODS

The authors retrospectively reviewed the medical records of their eight patients with adrenal cortical carcinoma. They also searched the English literature from 1952 to 1992 for reports of patients with the disease. They treated each report as a series if two or more previously unreported patients were reported. They paid special attention to patients for whom stage of disease was noted at diagnosis, treatment with mitotane (o,p'-DDD) was used, and the outcome was reported.

RESULTS

Five were male and three were female patients. Five had nonfunctional tumors. None were pediatric. The authors found 1891 cases in the English literature. Adrenal cortical carcinomas are more common in women (58.6%) than in men (41.4%). The age distribution of tumors is bimodal, with peaks in the first and fifth decades. Tumors in children are more commonly functional (83.5% in female patients, 85.6% in male patients), although nonfunctional tumors are more common in older patients (84.7%). Most (68%) of these tumors are diagnosed late in disease when surgery is no longer curative. Only 35% of patients treated with mitotane had a clinical response.

CONCLUSIONS

Adrenal cortical carcinomas are diagnosed most often in children because of functionality and older men because of mass effect. Most tumors are discovered too late for curative resection. Treatment of metastatic disease with mitotane has limited success.

Adrenocortical tumors in childhood: a report of four cases

In the last 10 years, four children with adrenocortical tumors were treated in our hospital. Three of them had symptoms of adrenogenital virilizing syndrome, and another, nonfunctional, was found during a routine examination. A diagnosis of adrenocortical tumor was established given the symptoms, hormonal tests, and radiologic studies. Two of the tumors were located in the left side, and the histologic diagnosis was pleomorphic cortical adenoma; the ones that affected the right side were adenocarcinomas. All the patients were treated by surgery and none received chemotherapy. At both presurgical and postsurgical stages, the patients were treated with cortisol. All four children have had a favorable course, with normal growth and the disappearance of public hair and hirsutism; however, macrogenitals still persist.

Comparison of adrenal cortical tumors in children and adults

Morphologic features (abnormal mitoses, necrosis, vascular and capsular invasion, broad fibrous bands, cellular pleomorphism, size) previously suggested to be predictors of malignant behavior in adrenal cortical tumors were assessed individually in 23 (17 benign, 6 malignant) pediatric and 42 (29 benign, 13 malignant) adult tumors. Of these features, size was the only predictor of malignancy in pediatric tumors. All pediatric tumors weighing more than 500 g were malignant and all but one weighing less than 500 g were benign. The remaining features were present in both benign and malignant pediatric tumors, and pediatric benign tumors were significantly more likely to have mitoses (P less than 0.01), necrosis (P less than 0.001), broad fibrous bands (P less than 0.005), and moderate to severe pleomorphism (P less than 0.01) than were adult benign tumors. The authors conclude that pediatric tumors are more likely to be benign than previously thought, and that size is the only morphologic predictor of their biologic behavior.

Adrenal adenocarcinomas: histologic grading and survival

Thirty-eight patients with adrenal adenocarcinoma were reviewed. Two of 23 males and 8 of 15 females had a functioning tumor (P less than 0.005). The most striking finding in this review was the variation in survival according to histologic grade. The median survival from histologic diagnosis was for grade I tumors 54 months, for grade II tumors 26 months, for grade III tumors 1 month. The difference in survival between patients with grade I or II tumors and those with grade III tumors was significant (P less than 0.001). The majority of the patients with grade III tumors were admitted with clinical evidence of disseminated disease and died within 1 month. Among the patients with well-differentiated tumors, five who received surgical treatment of their recurrence had a median survival of 51 months, whereas seven patients who received no surgical treatment had median survival of 20 months following first recurrence (0.05 less than P less than 0.10).

Primary aldosteronism due to adrenal carcinomas

In the present study two patients with aldosterone-producing adrenal carcinomas are reported. The clinical features were characterized by hypertension and severe hypokalemia with muscular weakness, flaccid paralysis of arms and legs, diarrhea and polyuria. In both cases excessively high plasma aldosterone levels and suppressed plasma renin activity were found. In contrast to most other cases with aldosterone-secreting tumours plasma cortisol, urinary free cortisol excretion, 17-hydroxy- and 17-ketosteroids were in the normal range. There was no clinical evidence of oversecretion of sex hormones. After adrenalectomy blood pressure and serum potassium normalized and the clinical symptoms disappeared. Plasma aldosterone and urinary aldosterone secretion returned to normal, while plasma renin activity remained low. Three and a half and 6 months later primary aldosteronism and the associated clinical symptoms reappeared due to hormonally active metastases. After introducing the antitumour drug o,p'-DDD in patient 1 aldosterone secretion normalized and the clinical status of the patient markedly improved. However, 10 months after diagnosis the patient died due to a haemorrhage from a liver metastasis. In patient 2 tumour-invaded regional lymph nodes were surgically removed with only minor changes in the hormone pattern.

Experimental evidence for biosynthesis of steroids in metastatic tissue originating from a primitive adrenocortical carcinoma

1. Cortisol, cortisone, 11-deoxycortisol and deoxycorticosterone were synthesized in large amounts in vitro by a metastatic tissue from an adrenocortical carcinoma. 2. Both 11 beta- and 21-hydroxylase were very active. 3. A secreting metastasis can be thus responsible for a biological relapse. 4. A metastasis originating from another secreting adrenocortical carcinoma was found to be non-secreting.

Clinical and laboratory findings and results of therapy in 58 patients with adrenocortical tumors admitted to a single medical center (1951 to 1978)

We reviewed 150 findings in 58 patients (14 males and 44 females) with adrenocortical tumors (26 with adenoma and 32 with carcinoma) admitted to Vanderbilt Hospital during 28 years. In general, our findings agree with those reported by others in multi-institutional series or literature reviews. Adenomas took longer to diagnose than carcinomas. Adenomas usually caused Cushing's syndrome, but two caused virilization and three caused no endocrine syndrome. There was no difference in time required for diagnosis of carcinoma in men or women or in those with Cushing's syndrome, virilization or no endocrine syndrome. Urinary 17-hydroxycorticoid (17-OHCS) levels were similar in those with adenoma and those with carcinoma, but 17-ketosteroid (17-KS) levels were usually less than 20 mg per day in patients with adenoma and greater than 20 mg per day in patients with carcinoma. Adenomas were uniformly independent of endogenous ACTH stimulation, but frequently responded to exogenous ACTH. As with adenomas, no carcinoma demonstrated normal suppression with dexamethasone or normal response to metyrapone, but only one responded to exogenous ACTH. Some patients had no clinical Cushing's syndrome despite high levels of plasma cortisol and urine 17-OHCS. "Nonfunctional" tumors probably merely secreted insufficient steroids to cause signs and symptoms. Patients with adenoma were uniformly cured by surgical tumor resection. Occasional patients with carcinoma enjoyed long survival despite incomplete resection of their tumors, but most patients died of recurrent of metastatic carcinoma within seven years, often within a year of two. Small tumor size and benign histologic features were insufficient to predict benign clinical behavior. The adrenocorticolytic drug, o,p'DDD, offered objective remission for only an occasional patient.

Natural history of adrenal cortical carcinoma: a clinicopathologic study of 42 patients

To study the biologic behavior and natural history of this rare but challenging tumor faced by oncologists, a clinicopathologic study of 42 patients with histologically proven adrenal cortical carcinoma from Roswell Park Memorial Institute (1929--1977) was done. These constituted .04% of all cancer cases and 0.2% of all autopsy cases. Age range was 3--74 years with median of 53 years; female to male ratio was 1.5 to 1. Clinical manifestations were: abdominal mass (36%), metastatic disease (30%), hormonal excess (17%) and weakness with lethargy (17%). Nine of ten functioning tumors were seen in female patients. Tumors arose in left adrenal in 26 patients, right adrenal in 12, and in four the site could not be determined because of bilateral presence of cancer. Median duration of symptoms was six months. At diagnosis, 52% had distant metastases, 41% had locally advanced tumor and 7% had tumor confined to adrenal. Sixteen patients underwent "curative" resection. Tumor diameter ranged from 1--30 cm with median of 10 cm. Of 28 patients who received different chemotherapeutic regimens, three (11%) had objective response; four of ten patients had objective response to radiation therapy. Overall median and five-year survival rates were 14 months and 24%. Prolonged survival (P less than .05) was noted in women, patients who had "curative" resection, a disease-free interval of more than 12 months, and tumor size greater than 10 cm diameter. Patients with functional tumors had longer median survival than those with non-functional ones (28 vs. 12), but P value was greater than .05. A second primary cancer was noted in 22.4% of cases, breast and lymphoma being the most common. At autopsy in 31 patients, the most common metastatic sites were retroperitoneal lymph nodes 68%, lung 71%, liver 42%, and bone 26%. To improve survival, an aggressive surgical approach is recommended to extirpate the tumor with involved organs and retroperitoneal lymph nodes. Adrenal carcinoma should be suspected in patients with metastatic cancer with an occult primary.

Adrenal adenocarcinomas: diagnosis and management

Thirty-two patients with adrenal adenocarcinoma are reviewed. Eleven of them had symptoms suggestive of a hormonally functional tumor. The median survival in 17 patients who had the primary tumor removed was 13.5 months from the time of surgery, with one patient surviving disease-free 19 years later. The median survival of 11 patients who did not have surgery owing to delays in diagnosis was 7.5 months from the onset of symptoms. Of six patients given O,P'DDD, two patients had objective regression, one partial, one complete. Early diagnosis may improve survival and curability of this malignant tumor.

Late functioning adrenocortical carcinoma in a 5-year-old girl

A 5-year-old with adrenocortical carcinoma presented with acute paraplegia. The tumour was initially nonfunctioning but finally showed rapid dissemination and the patient then developed Cushingoid features and virilisation.

Experience with adrenal cortical carcinoma

Eight cases of histologically proved cortical carcinoma are reviewed and compared with several series from the literature. Emphasis is given to defining endocrinologic function in these tumors and to the role of nonoperative treatments. Whereas surgical therapy offered significant demonstrated in any of the patients.