Heavy ion effects on cellular DNA: strand break induction and repair in cultured diploid lens epithelial cells

AOP report: Development of an adverse outcome pathway for deposition of energy leading to cataracts

Cataracts are one of the leading causes of blindness, with an estimated 95 million people affected worldwide. A hallmark of cataract development is lens opacification, typically associated not only with aging but also radiation exposure as encountered by interventional radiologists and astronauts during the long-term space mission. To better understand radiation-induced cataracts, the adverse outcome pathway (AOP) framework was used to structure and evaluate knowledge across biological levels of organization (e.g., macromolecular, cell, tissue, organ, organism and population). AOPs identify a sequence of key events (KEs) causally connected by key event relationships (KERs) beginning with a molecular initiating event to an adverse outcome (AO) of relevance to regulatory decision-making. To construct the cataract AO and retrieve evidence to support it, a scoping review methodology was used to filter, screen, and review studies based on the modified Bradford Hill criteria. Eight KEs were identified that were moderately supported by empirical evidence (e.g., dose-, time-, incidence-concordance) across the adjacent (directly linked) relationships using well-established endpoints. Over half of the evidence to justify the KER linkages was derived from the evidence stream of biological plausibility. Early KEs of oxidative stress and protein modifications had strong linkages to downstream KEs and could be the focus of countermeasure development. Several identified knowledge gaps and inconsistencies related to the quantitative understanding of KERs which could be the basis of future research, most notably directed to experiments in the range of low or moderate doses and dose-rates, relevant to radiation workers and other occupational exposures.

iTRAQ-based proteomic analysis of Deinococcus radiodurans in response to 12C6+ heavy ion irradiation

Background

Deinococcus radiodurans (D. radiodurans) is best known for its extreme resistance to diverse environmental stress factors, including ionizing radiation (IR), ultraviolet (UV) irradiation, oxidative stress, and high temperatures. Robust DNA repair system and antioxidant system have been demonstrated to contribute to extreme resistance in D. radiodurans. However, practically all studies on the mechanism underlying D. radiodurans’s extraordinary resistance relied on the treated strain during the post-treatment recovery lag phase to identify the key elements involved. The direct gene or protein changes of D. radiodurans after stress have not yet been characterized.

Results

In this study, we performed a proteomics profiling on D. radiodurans right after the heavy ion irradiation treatment, to discover the altered proteins that were quickly responsive to IR in D. radiodurans. Our study found that D. radiodurans shown exceptional resistance to ¹²C⁶⁺ heavy ion irradiation, in contrast to Escherichia coli (E.coli) strains. By using iTRAQ (Isobaric Tags for Relative and Absolute Quantitation)-based quantitative mass spectrometry analysis, the kinetics of proteome changes induced by various dosages of ¹²C⁶⁺ heavy ion irradiation were mapped. The results revealed that 452 proteins were differentially expressed under heavy ion irradiation, with the majority of proteins being upregulated, indicating the upregulation of functional categories of translation, TCA cycle (Tricarboxylic Acid cycle), and antioxidation regulation under heavy ion irradiation.

Conclusions

This study shows how D. radiodurans reacts to exposure to ¹²C⁶⁺ heavy ion irradiation in terms of its overall protein expression profile. Most importantly, comparing the proteome profiling of D. radiodurans directly after heavy ion irradiation with research on the post-irradiation recovery phase would potentially provide a better understanding of mechanisms underlying the extreme radioresistance in D. radiodurans.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12866-022-02676-x.

A systematic review on the usage of averaged LET in radiation biology for particle therapy

Linear Energy Transfer (LET) is widely used to express the radiation quality of ion beams, when characterizing the biological effectiveness. However, averaged LET may be defined in multiple ways, and the chosen definition may impact the resulting reported value. We review averaged LET definitions found in the literature, and quantify which impact using these various definitions have for different reference setups. We recorded the averaged LET definitions used in 354 publications quantifying the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of hadronic beams, and investigated how these various definitions impact the reported averaged LET using a Monte Carlo particle transport code. We find that the kind of averaged LET being applied is, generally, poorly defined. Some definitions of averaged LET may influence the reported averaged LET values up to an order of magnitude. For publications involving protons, most applied dose averaged LET when reporting RBE. The absence of what target medium is used and what secondary particles are included further contributes to an ill-defined averaged LET. We also found evidence of inconsistent usage of averaged LET definitions when deriving LET-based RBE models. To conclude, due to commonly ill-defined averaged LET and to the inherent problems of LET-based RBE models, averaged LET may only be used as a coarse indicator of radiation quality. We propose a more rigorous way of reporting LET values, and suggest that ideally the entire particle fluence spectra should be recorded and provided for future RBE studies, from which any type of averaged LET (or other quantities) may be inferred.

Increasing xylanase activity of Bacillus subtilis by atmospheric pressure plasma jet for biomass hydrolysis

Xylanase producing bacteria, Bacillus subtilis, was bombarded by an atmospheric pressure plasma jet (APPJ) and screened for higher catalytic activity. The bacteria were bombarded with plasma of argon or helium with energy of 120 W for a duration of 1-5 min. A mutant with higher xylanase activity was observed under argon plasma treatment at 1 min on media containing xylan as substrate. Subsequently, the xylanase gene from the mutant was sequenced and named MxynA. Sequence analysis revealed only a single missense mutation on the MxynA gene causing amino acid substitution from threonine to serine at position 162 (T162S) within the xylanase protein of the mutant. Consequently, MxynA was subcloned into expression vector, pETDuet-1 under T7 promoter and expressed in E. coli BL21 (DE3). The optimum temperature and pH of MxynA and its parent expressed in E. coli, named CxynA were 60 °C and pH 5, respectively. Moreover, MxynA showed higher xylanase activity approximately 4 fold higher than that of the control upon a wide range of pH and temperature conditions. From kinetic parameters analysis, the mutant showed higher enzyme turnover (k cat) than the control. The hydrolysis ability of the MxynA enzyme on lignocellulosic wastes, such as rice straw, corncob and para grass was investigated using the released reducing sugar as an indicator. The MxynA enzyme showed a greater amount of reducing sugar released from all lignocellulosic wastes other than the control, particularly from para grass. This study demonstrated that the T162S mutation possibly improved the catalytic efficiency of MxynA.

Heavier ions with a different linear energy transfer spectrum kill more cells due to similar interference with the Ku-dependent DNA repair pathway

Ionizing radiation kills cells mainly due to the generation of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). High-linear energy transfer (LET) ionizing radiation induces more cell death and generates a higher relative biological effect (RBE) than low-LET ionizing radiation (such as X or γ ray). Although it is known that interference with the Ku-dependent nonhomologous ending-joining (NHEJ) pathway appears to be the major cause of iron-ion- and carbon-ion-induced cell death, it remains unclear whether other ions with a similar or different LET and higher RBE in terms of cell killing are controlled in the same way. In this study, we compared the clonogenic survival frequency of Ku80+/+ (NHEJ-proficient) and Ku80-/- (NHEJ-deficient) cells after exposure to iron (175 keV/μm), silicon (75 keV/μm), oxygen (25 keV/μm) and X ray (low-LET). The results showed that Ku80-/- cells had the same RBE value of 1 for cell killing for all types of ionizing radiation, whereas Ku80+/+ cells had different RBE values for cell killing that depended on the specific type of ionizing radiation. The results indicate that the Ku-dependent NHEJ is the major repair pathway that heavier ions interfere with, resulting in higher RBE for cell killing. These results provide useful information for followup studies that will focus on improving high-LET protection or heavier ion radiotherapy in the near future.

Distinct roles of Ape1 protein, an enzyme involved in DNA repair, in high or low linear energy transfer ionizing radiation-induced cell killing

High linear energy transfer (LET) radiation from space heavy charged particles or a heavier ion radiotherapy machine kills more cells than low LET radiation, mainly because high LET radiation-induced DNA damage is more difficult to repair. Relative biological effectiveness (RBE) is the ratio of the effects generated by high LET radiation to low LET radiation. Previously, our group and others demonstrated that the cell-killing RBE is involved in the interference of high LET radiation with non-homologous end joining but not homologous recombination repair. This effect is attributable, in part, to the small DNA fragments (≤40 bp) directly produced by high LET radiation, the size of which prevents Ku protein from efficiently binding to the two ends of one fragment at the same time, thereby reducing non-homologous end joining efficiency. Here we demonstrate that Ape1, an enzyme required for processing apurinic/apyrimidinic (known as abasic) sites, is also involved in the generation of small DNA fragments during the repair of high LET radiation-induced base damage, which contributes to the higher RBE of high LET radiation-induced cell killing. This discovery opens a new direction to develop approaches for either protecting astronauts from exposure to space radiation or benefiting cancer patients by sensitizing tumor cells to high LET radiotherapy.

Age and hormonal status as determinants of cataractogenesis induced by ionizing radiation. I. Densely ionizing (high-LET) radiation

Astronauts participating in extended lunar missions or the projected mission to Mars would likely be exposed to significant doses of high-linear energy transfer (LET) heavy energetic charged (HZE) particles. Exposure to even relatively low doses of such space radiation may result in a reduced latent period for and an increased incidence of lens opacification. However, the determinants of cataractogenesis induced by densely ionizing radiation have not been clearly elucidated. In the current study, we show that age at the time of exposure is a key determinant of cataractogenesis in rats whose eyes have been exposed to 2 Gy of (56)Fe ions. The rate of progression of cataractogenesis was significantly greater in the irradiated eyes of 1-year-old rats compared to young (56-day-old) rats. Furthermore, older ovariectomized rats that received exogenous estrogen treatment (17-β-estradiol) commencing 1 week prior to irradiation and continuing throughout the period of observation of up to approximately 600 days after irradiation showed an increased incidence of cataracts and faster progression of opacification compared to intact rats with endogenous estrogen or ovariectomized rats. The same potentiating effect (higher incidence, reduced latent period) was observed for irradiated eyes of young rats. Modulation of estrogen status in the 1-year-old animals (e.g., removal of estrogen by ovariectomy or continuous exposure to estrogen) did not increase the latent period or reduce the incidence to that of intact 56-day-old rats. Since the rapid onset and progression of cataracts in 1-year-old compared to 56-day-old rats was independent of estrogen status, we conclude that estrogen cannot account for the age-dependent differences in cataractogenesis induced by high-LET radiation.

Repair of DNA Damage Induced by Accelerated Heavy Ions in Mammalian Cells Proficient and Deficient in the Non-homologous End-Joining Pathway

Human and rodent cells proficient and deficient in non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) were irradiated with X rays, 70 keV/microm carbon ions, and 200 keV/microm iron ions, and the biological effects on these cells were compared. For wild-type CHO and normal human fibroblast (HFL III) cells, exposure to iron ions yielded the lowest cell survival, followed by carbon ions and then X rays. NHEJ-deficient xrs6 (a Ku80 mutant of CHO) and 180BR human fibroblast (DNA ligase IV mutant) cells showed similar cell survival for X and carbon-ion irradiation (RBE = approximately 1.0). This phenotype is likely to result from a defective NHEJ protein because xrs6-hamKu80 cells (xrs6 cells corrected with the wild-type KU80 gene) exhibited the wild-type response. At doses higher than 1 Gy, NHEJ-defective cells showed a lower level of survival with iron ions than with carbon ions or X rays, possibly due to inactivation of a radioresistant subpopulation. The G(1) premature chromosome condensation (PCC) assay with HFL III cells revealed LET-dependent impairment of repair of chromosome breaks. Additionally, iron-ion radiation induced non-repairable chromosome breaks not observed with carbon ions or X rays. PCC studies with 180BR cells indicated that the repair kinetics after exposure to carbon and iron ions behaved similarly for the first 6 h, but after 24 h the curve for carbon ions approached that for X rays, while the curve for iron ions remained high. These chromosome data reflect the existence of a slow NHEJ repair phase and severe biological damage induced by iron ions. The auto-phosphorylation of DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunits (DNA-PKcs), an essential NHEJ step, was delayed significantly by high-LET carbon- and iron-ion radiation compared to X rays. This delay was further emphasized in NHEJ-defective 180BR cells. Our results indicate that high-LET radiation induces complex DNA damage that is not easily repaired or is not repaired by NHEJ even at low radiation doses such as 2 Gy.

Repair kinetics of DNA-DSB induced by X-rays or carbon ions under oxic and hypoxic conditions

We studied the relation between initial DNA double-strand breaks (DNA-DSB) and the rejoining kinetics of the strand breaks, as well as the OER (oxygen enhancement ratio) after low- and high-LET (linear energy transfer) radiations. CHO cells were exposed to 200 kVp X-rays or 80 keV/microm carbon ions under oxic and hypoxic conditions. DNA-DSB in the cells were analyzed by a static-field gel electrophoresis (SFGE). The kinetics of the rejoining could be described by a sum of fast and slow components. The initial released DNA after X-ray irradiation was higher for cells irradiated under an oxic condition than that under a hypoxic condition. The OER of DNA-DSB after X-ray irradiation was 5.7. This value decreased rapidly to be 3.4 with the fast component by 15 minutes. On the other hand, the OER of DNA-DSB after carbon ion irradiation was 2.2, and this value was not changed by rejoining incubation. The OER values for cell killing were 2.8 and 1.8 after X-ray and carbon ion irradiations, respectively. These values matched to the OER for DNA-DSB with complete rejoining. We conclude that the rejoining of DNA-DSB is an important factor in the mechanism of the oxygen effect.

Induction and repair of DNA strand breaks in bovine lens epithelial cells after high LET irradiation

The lens epithelium is the initiation site for the development of radiation induced cataracts. Radiation in the cortex and nucleus interacts with proteins, while in the epithelium, experimental results reveal mutagenic and cytotoxic effects. It is suggested that incorrectly repaired DNA damage may be lethal in terms of cellular reproduction and also may initiate the development of mutations or transformations in surviving cells. The occurrence of such genetically modified cells may lead to lens opacification. For a quantitative risk estimation for astronauts and space travelers it is necessary to know the relative biological effectiveness (RBE), because the spacial and temporal distribution of initial physical damage induced by cosmic radiation differ significantly from that of X-rays. RBEs for the induction of DNA strand breaks and the efficiency of repair of these breaks were measured in cultured diploid bovine lens epithelial cells exposed to different LET irradiation to either 300 kV X-rays or to heavy ions at the UNILAC accelerator at GSI. Accelerated ions from Z=8 (O) to Z=92 (U) were used. Strand breaks were measured by hydroxyapatite chromatography of alkaline unwound DNA (overall strand breaks). Results showed that DNA damage occurs as a function of dose, of kinetic energy and of LET. For particles having the same LET the severity of the DNA damage increases with dose. For a given particle dose, as the LET rises, the numbers of DNA strand breaks increase to a maximum and then reach a plateau or decrease. Repair kinetics depend on the fluence (irradiation dose). At any LET value, repair is much slower after heavy ion exposure than after X-irradiation. For ions with an LET of less than 10,000 keV micrometers-1 more than 90 percent of the strand breaks induced are repaired within 24 hours. At higher particle fluences, especially for low energetic particles with a very high local density of energy deposition within the particle track, a higher proportion of non-rejoined breaks is found, even after prolonged periods of incubation. At the highest LET value (16,300 keV micrometers-1) no significant repair is observed. These LET-dependencies are consistent with the current mechanistic model for radiation induced cataractogenesis which postulates that genomic damage to the surviving fraction of epithelial cells is responsible for lens opacification.

[Radiation-induced cataract: physiopathologic, radiobiologic and clinical aspects]

Cataractogenesis is a widely reported late effect of irradiated crystalline lens. In this review the authors discussed the different aspects of radiation cataract pathogenesis, and the different mechanisms involved in the lens opacification, particularly the epithelium modifications such as epithelial cell death. The authors also reported the influence of radiation exposure on cataract formation following total body irradiation (TBI) and autologous or allogeneic bone marrow transplantation for hematologic malignancies. Moreover, the radiobiological parameters are not studied for the crystalline lens of human. We applied for the first time the linear-quadratic (LQ) and biological effective dose (BED) concept to TBI data. The calculated value of alpha/beta of 1 Gy is in the range of the values reported for the other late responding tissues. The other risk factors for cataract development after TBI such as age, gender, central nervous system boost, long-term steroid therapy and heparin administration are discussed. In terms of cataract or sicca syndrome prevention, numerous compounds have been successfully tested in experimental models or used for the prevention of radiation-induced xerostomia in patients treated for head and neck cancer. However, none of them has been clinically evaluated for ocular radiation late effects prevention. In this report the authors discussed some of the radioprotectors potentially interesting for radiation-induced cataract or sicca syndrome prevention.

Assessment of DNA damage induced by high-LET ions in human lymphocytes using the comet assay

The alkaline single-cell gel electrophoresis assay (comet assay) was used to analyze DNA damage induced in human lymphocytes by irradiation with high linear energy transfer (LET) ions. Our aim was to measure DNA breaks and to demonstrate the heterogeneity of the damage levels in a lymphocyte population irradiated with ions of different energies and LETs. Four experiments with heavy ions (Ar, C and U), as well as gamma-ray exposure, were conducted to enable comparisons. We demonstrated that the comet assay is able to assess the variability in DNA damage induced at the single cell level. The amount of DNA damage and its heterogeneity increased with particle fluence and LET, but saturated at high LETs. However, when expressed in terms of the mean dose, gamma-rays were more efficient than most of the ions used. The comet assay also allowed the detection of highly damaged cells (HDC), which were previously described as cells in late apoptotic stages. The rapid emergence of HDC in this study suggests that they were generated following ion irradiation-induced creation of DNA break clusters induced by ion exposure. Another clue was that the proportion of HDC increased with LET and fluence. We hypothesized that the LET threshold observed and the higher efficiency of low-LET radiation might be linked to the impossibility of measuring small DNA fragments in HDC.

Measurement of intracellular dna double-strand break induction and rejoining along the track of carbon and neon particle beams in water

PURPOSE

The study was aimed at the measurement of effect-depth distributions of intracellularly induced DNA damage in water as tissue equivalent after heavy ion irradiation with therapy particle beams.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

An assay involving embedding of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cells in large agarose plugs and electrophoretic elution of radiation induced DNA fragments by constant field gel electrophoresis was developed. Double-strand break production was quantified by densitometric analysis of DNA-fluorescence after staining with ethidium-bromide and determination of the fraction of DNA eluted out of the agarose plugs. Intracellular double-strand break induction and the effect of a 3 h rejoining incubation were investigated following irradiation with 250 kV x-rays and 109 MeV/u carbon- and 295 MeV/u neon-ions.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

While the DNA damage induced by x-irradiation decreased continuously with penetration depth, a steady increase in the yield of double-strand breaks was observed for particle radiation, reaching distinct maxima at the position of the physical Bragg peaks. Beyond this, the extent of radiation damage dropped drastically. From comparison of DNA damage and calculated dose profiles, relative biological efficiencies (RBEs) for both double-strand break induction and unrejoined strand breaks after 3 h were determined. While RBE for the induction of DNA double-strand breaks decreased continuously with penetration depth, RBE maxima greater than unity were found with carbon- and neon-ions for double-strand break rejoining near the maximum range of the particles. The method presented here allows for a fast and accurate determination of depth profiles of relevant radiobiological effects for mixed particle fields in tissue equivalent.

Track structure and DNA damage

Heavy particles like protons or heavier ions are different in their biological efficiency when compared to sparsely ionizing radiation. These differences have been attributed to the different pattern of energy deposition in the track of the particles. In radiobiological models two different approaches are used for the characterization of the radiation quality: the continuous dose distribution of the various track structure models and the separation in small compartments inside the track which are used in microdosimetry. In a recent Monte Carlo calculation using the binary encounter approximation as input for the electron emission process, the radial distribution of the dose is calculated for heavy ions. The result of this calculation is compared to other models and used for a qualitative interpretation of the induction of DNA damage by particles.

Induction of DNA breaks in SV40 by heavy ions

Simian virus (SV40) DNA was used to study the induction of DNA strandbreaks by heavy ions varying in LET. DNA was exposed to X-rays and to accelerated particles either in dilute solution or in the presence of different radical scavengers. Relative proportions of the intact supercoiled DNA, nicked form arising from single strand breaks (SSB) and linear molecules produced by double strandbreaks (DSB) were quantified on the base of their electrophoretic mobility in agarose gels. Cross sections for the induction of SSBs and DSBs were calculated from the slope of dose effect curves. Mercaptoethanol was found to protect more efficiently against DNA strand breakage than Tris. When the biological efficiency, i.e. the number of strand breaks per unit dose and molecule weight was evaluated as a function of LET, curves for SSB induction always showed a continuous decrease. For DSB induction, an increase in the yield of DSBs with a maximum around 500 keV/micrometer was observed in the presence of radical scavenger. This peak of biological efficiency gradually disappeared when the radiosensitivity of the system was increased, and was no longer apparent in the dilute buffer system, where DNA showed a high susceptibility to strand breakage. When the relative biological efficiency was plotted versus LET, the curve for DSB induction observed in a low radical scavenging environment paralleled the curve obtained for SSB induction.

Induction of chromosome aberrations in mammalian cells after heavy ion exposure

The induction of chromosome aberrations by heavy charged particles was studied in V79 Chinese hamster cells over a wide range of energies (3-100 MeV/u) and LET (20-16000 keV/micrometer). For comparison, X-ray experiments were performed. Our data indicate quantitative and qualitative differences in the response of cells to particle and x-ray irradiation. For the same level of cell survival the amount of damaged cells which can be observed is smaller in heavy ion (11.4 MeV/u Ar) irradiated samples. The highest yield of damaged cells is found 8 to 12 hours after particle irradiation and 4 hours after x-irradiation. Differences in the amount of damaged cells are attributed to cell cycle perturbations which interfere with the expression of damage. After heavy ion exposure the amount of cells reaching mitosis (mitotic index) decreases drastically and not all damaged cells reach mitosis within 48 hours after exposure. A portion of cells die in interphase. Cell cycle delays induced by x-ray irradiation are less pronounced and all cells reach the first post-irradiation mitosis within 24 hours after irradiation. Additionally, the damage produced by charged particles seems to be more severe. The disintegration of chromosomes was only observed after high LET radiation: an indication of the high and local energy deposition in the particle track. Only cross sections for the induction of chromosome aberrations in mitotic cells were reported in this paper because of the problems arising from the drastic cell cycle perturbations. In this case, cells were irradiated in mitosis and assayed immediately.

Heavy ion induced double strand breaks in bacteria and bacteriophages

DNA damage induced by heavy ions in bacterial cells and bacteriophages such as Bacillus subtilis, E. coli and Bacteriophage T1 were investigated by analyzing the double strand breaks in the chromosomal DNA. This kind of lesion is considered as one of the main reasons for lethal events. To analyze double strand breaks in long molecules of DNA--up to some Mbp in length--the technique of pulse field agarose gel electrophoresis has been used. This allows the detection of one double strand break per genome. Cell lysis and DNA isolation were performed in small agarose blocks directly. This procedure secured minimum DNA destruction by shearing forces. After running a gel, the DNA was stained with ethidium bromide. The light intensity of ethidium bromide fluorescence for both the outcoming (running) DNA and the remaining intact DNA were measured by scanning. The mean number of double strand breaks was calculated by determining the quotient of these intensities. Strand break induction after heavy ion and X-ray irradiation was compared.

The influence of radiation quality on the formation of DNA breaks

We have aimed to present a comprehensive review of our understanding to date of the formation of DNA strand breaks induced by high LET radiation. We have discussed data obtained from DNA in solution as well as from the formation and "repair" of strand breaks in cell DNA. There is good agreement, qualitatively, between these two systems. Results were evaluated for two parameters: (1) effectivity per particle, the cross section (sigma) in micrometers 2/particle; and (2) the strand break induction frequency as number of breaks per Gy per unit DNA (bp or dalton). A series of biological effects curves (one for each Z-number) is obtained in effectivity versus LET plots. The relationships between induction frequencies of single-strand breaks, or double-strand breaks, or the residual "irrepairable" breaks and LET-values have been evaluated and discussed for a wide spectrum of heavy ions, both for DNA in solution and for DNA in the cell. For radiation induced total breaks in cell DNA, the RBE is less than one, while the RBE for the induction of DSBs can be greater than one in the 100-200 keV/micrometers range. The level of irrepairable strand breaks is highest in this same LET range and may reach 25 percent of the initial break yield. The data presented cover results obtained for helium to uranium particles, covering a particle incident energy range of about 2 to 900 MeV/u with a corresponding LET range of near 16 to 16000 keV/micrometers.

Cellular and subcellular effect of heavy ions: a comparison of the induction of strand breaks and chromosomal aberration with the incidence of inactivation and mutation

Radiobiological effects of heavy charged particles are compared for a large variety of ions from Helium to Uranium and energies between 1 and 1000 MeV/u which correspond to LET values between 10 and 16000 keV/micrometers. The different cross section for the induction of strand breaks and chromosomal aberrations as well as for inactivation and mutation induction exhibit striking similarities when compared as function of the linear energy transfer (LET). At LET values below 100 keV/micrometers all data points of one specific effect form one single curve as a function of LET, independent of the atomic number of the ion. In this LET range, the biological effects are independ from the particle energy or track structure and depend only on the energy transfer. Therefore, LET is a good parameter in this regime. For LET values greater than 100 keV/micrometers, the curves for the different ions separate from the common curve in order of increasing atomic numbers. In this regime LET is no longer a good parameter and the physical parameters of the formation of particle tracks are important. The similarity of the sigma-LET curves for different endpoints indicates that the 'hook-structure' is produced by physical and chemical effects which occur before the biologically relevant lesions are formed. However, from the existing data of biological effects, it can be concluded that the efficiencies for cell killing are always smaller than those extrapolated from X-ray data on the basis of the energy deposition only. Therefore, cells which are directly hit by an HZE particle are not killed and undergo a finite risk of mutation and transformation.