Application of immunoassay in the food industry

Unveiling the underpinnings of various non-conventional ELISA variants: a review article

INTRODUCTION

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is a key bio-analytical technique used for the detection of a large array of antigenic substances of scientific, clinical, food safety, and environmental importance. The assay primarily involves capturing and detecting target analytes using specific antigen-antibody interactions. The wide usage of ELISA shoulders on its high specificity and reproducibility. Notwithstanding, the conventional microwell plate-based format of ELISA has some major drawbacks, such as long assay time (4 - 18 h), large sample volumes requirement (100 - 200 μL), lack of multiplicity, and burdensome procedures that limit its utility in rapid and affordable diagnostics.

AREAS COVERED

Here, we reviewed microfluidic-ELISA, paper-ELISA, aptamer-ELISA, and those based on novel incubation such as heat-ELISA, pressure-ELISA, microwave-ELISA, and sound-ELISA. Further, the current trends and future prospects of these ELISA protocols in clinical diagnostics are discussed.

EXPERT OPINION

The reviewed non-conventional ELISA formats are relatively rapid, require low reagent volumes, are multiplexable, and could be performed in a low-cost setup. In our opinion, these non-conventional variants of ELISA are on a par with the conventional format for clinical diagnostics and fundamental biological research and hold added clinical translational potential for quick, inexpensive, and convenient measurements.

Investigation of major amino acid residues of anti-norfloxacin monoclonal antibodies responsible for binding with fluoroquinolones

It is important to understand the amino acid residues that govern the properties of the binding between antibodies and ligands. We studied the binding of two anti-norfloxacins, anti-nor 132 and anti-nor 155, and the fluoroquinolones norfloxacin, enrofloxacin, ciprofloxacin, and ofloxacin. Binding cross-reactivities tested by an indirect competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay indicated that anti-nor 132 (22–100%) had a broader range of cross-reactivity than anti-nor 155 (62–100%). These cross-reactivities correlated with variations in the numbers of interacting amino acid residues and their positions. Molecular docking was employed to investigate the molecular interactions between the fluoroquinolones and the monoclonal antibodies. Homology models of the heavy chain and light chain variable regions of each mAb 3D structure were docked with the fluoroquinolones targeting the crucial part of the complementarity-determining regions. The fluoroquinolone binding site of anti-nor 155 was a region of the HCDR3 and LCDR3 loops in which hydrogen bonds were formed with TYR (H:35), ASN (H:101), LYS (H:106), ASN (L:92), and ASN (L:93). These regions were further away in anti-nor 132 and could not contact the fluoroquinolones. Another binding region consisting of HIS (L:38) and ASP (H:100) was found for norfloxacin, enrofloxacin, and ciprofloxacin, whereas only ASP (H:100) was found for ofloxacin.

A general strategy to control antibody specificity against targets showing molecular and biological similarity: Salmonella case study

The control of antibody specificity plays pivotal roles in key technological fields such as diagnostics and therapeutics. During the development of immunoassays (IAs) for the biosensing of pathogens in food matrices, we have found a way to rationalize and control the specificity of polyclonal antibodies (sera) for a complex analytical target (the Salmonella genus), in terms of number of analytes (Salmonella species) and potential cross-reactivity with similar analytes (other bacteria strains). Indeed, the biosensing of Salmonella required the development of sera and serum mixtures displaying homogeneous specificity for a large set of strains showing broad biochemical variety (54 Salmonella serovars tested in this study), which partially overlaps with the molecular features of other class of bacteria (like specific serogroups of E. coli). To achieve a trade-off between specificity harmonisation and maximization, we have developed a strategy based on the conversion of the specificity profiles of individual sera in to numerical descriptors, which allow predicting the capacity of serum mixtures to detect multiple bacteria strains. This approach does not imply laborious purification steps and results advantageous for process scaling-up, and may help in the customization of the specificity profiles of antibodies needed for diagnostic and therapeutic applications such as multi-analyte detection and recombinant antibody engineering, respectively.

Development and comparison of immunochromatographic strips with three nanomaterial labels: Colloidal gold, nanogold-polyaniline-nanogold microspheres (GPGs) and colloidal carbon for visual detection of salbutamol

In this study, the three nanomaterials: colloidal gold, nanogold-polyaniline-nanogold microspheres (GPGs) and colloidal carbon were respectively labeled with the antibody against salbutamol (SAL). We aimed to develop immunochromatographic strips with these nanomaterial labels and determine their performance in visual detection of SAL. For the colloidal gold-based strip, the detection limit of SAL was 1.0µgL(-1) in standard solution and 5.0µgkg(-1) in meat samples. For the GPG- and colloidal carbon-based strips, the limit of detection was 2.0µgL(-1) in standard solution and 10µgkg(-1) in meat samples. The results obtained using the test strips were found to be highly consistent with those obtained using a commercial kit, indicating the high accuracy of these strips. The three strips were also found to be stable up to 18 weeks under laboratory conditions. In terms of sensitivity, the colloidal gold-based strip was slightly better than the other two. For the GPG- and colloidal carbon-based strips, the difference between the results obtained for different batches was small (high consistency), and the stability was much better than that of the colloidal gold-based one. Our results indicate that colloidal carbon can be used as a label in immunochromatographic tests; it can also help reduce the cost involved and scale-up the production. The use of immunochromatographic test strips labeled with colloidal carbon can be a rapid and inexpensive method for SAL assays in on-site applications.

Signal amplification strategy using gold/N-trimethyl chitosan/iron oxide magnetic composite nanoparticles as a tracer tag for high-sensitive electrochemical detection

This study presents a novel signal amplification method for high-sensitive electrochemical immunosensing. Gold (Au)/N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC)/iron oxide (Fe3O4) (shell/shell/core) nanocomposite was used as a tracing tag to label antibody. The tag was shown to be capable of amplifying the recognition signal by high-density assembly of Au nanoparticles (NPs) on TMC/Fe3O4 particles. The remarkable conductivity of AuNPs provides a feasible pathway for electron transfer. The method was found to be simple, reliable and capable of high-sensitive detection of human serum albumin as a model, down to 0.2 pg/ml in the range of 0.25-1000 pg/ml. Findings of the present study would create new opportunities for sensitive and rapid detection of various analytes.

Development and evaluation of a monoclonal antibody-based inhibition ELISA for the quantification of chymosin in solution

Chymosin is the major enzyme of natural rennet, traditionally used in cheese making for its high milk-clotting activity. For technical reasons, an accurate characterization of rennet should include its total clotting activity and also its enzymatic composition. Monoclonal antibodies specific to chymosin were obtained from mice immunized with purified bovine chymosin, and an inhibition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed for the quantification of chymosin in solution. No cross-reactivity was observed with other milk-clotting enzymes commonly used in cheese making. The limit of detection and limit of quantification were 125 and 400 ng/mL, respectively. The values of precision within and among runs were 7.23 and 7.39%, respectively, and satisfying recovery, from 92 to 119%, was found for spiked samples. The inhibition ELISA was successfully applied to commercial rennets, and the results were consistent with those obtained using the standard chromatographic method (IDF 110: A, 1987).

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for triclocarban in aquatic environments

A sensitive, competitive indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was developed for the detection of triclocarban (TCC) in waters and sediments. Haptens were synthesized by derivatizing the paraposition of a phenyl moiety of TCC. The synthesized hapten was then coupled to bovine thyroglobulin to be used as an immunogen, based on which, a high affinity monoclonal antibody 4D5 was produced with the hybridoma technique. Under the optimized conditions, using the monoclonal antibody, excellent performances of the assay were obtained: satisfactory sensitivity (IC50 (50% inhibition concentration) value, 0.43 ng/mL; limit of detection, 0.05 ng/mL); good linear range (0.05-10 ng/mL); and satisfactory accuracy (recoveries 70.7-107% in waters; 74.8-98.3% in sediments). Furthermore, TCC was found with the concentration ranging from not detected to 422.12 ng/L in waters and from 6.68 ng/g to 78.67 ng/g in sediments in Yunliang River, Ancient Canal and Hongqiao Port in Zhenjiang City. In conclusion ELISA could be applied for monitoring TCC in aquatic environments.

Sports doping: emerging designer and therapeutic β2-agonists

Beta2-adrenergic agonists, or β2-agonists, are considered essential bronchodilator drugs in the treatment of bronchial asthma, both as symptom-relievers and, in combination with inhaled corticosteroids, as disease-controllers. The use of β2-agonists is prohibited in sports by the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) due to claimed anabolic effects, and also, is prohibited as growth promoters in cattle fattening in the European Union. This paper reviews the last seven-year (2006-2012) literature concerning the development of novel β2-agonists molecules either by modifying the molecule of known β2-agonists or by introducing moieties producing indole-, adamantyl- or phenyl urea derivatives. New emerging β2-agonists molecules for future therapeutic use are also presented, intending to emphasize their potential use for doping purposes or as growth promoters in the near future.

Hamburger meat identification by dot-ELISA

The use of low cost meats to adulterate meats and meat products has been reported. Appropriate methods of analysis then are needed in order to detect this practice. The dot-ELISA method was used to identify the meat of different animal species and to detect adulteration of hamburgers. Antisera to bovine, chicken, swine and horse albumin were produced and they could detect the meat extract of the homologous species at concentrations as low as 0.6%. Thus, the anti-albumin antisera could identify bovine, chicken, swine and horse meat with adequate specificity and sensitivity both in isolation and when added to hamburger. Commercial samples of bovine, chicken and swine hamburgers showed no adulteration with bovine, chicken, swine or horse meats. Our expectation of hamburger adulteration was not confirmed.

ELISA for monitoring lipid oxidation in chicken myofibrils through quantification of hexanal-protein adducts

The objectives of this study were to optimize a monoclonal competitive indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (CI-ELISA) for hexanal detection, optimize solubilization and alkylation procedures for the formation of hexanal-protein adducts, and compare the ability the CI-ELISA, thiobarbituric acid reactive substances assay (TBARS), and a solid-phase microextraction-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC/MS-SPME) method for monitoring lipid oxidation in freeze-dried chicken protein. Freeze-dried myofibrils with added methyl linoleate (0.6 mmol/g of protein) were stored at 50 degrees C at two water activities (a(w) = 0.30 and 0.75) for 5 days. Hexanal was measured by GC/MS-SPME and CI-ELISA, and malonaldehyde by TBARS. At an a(w) of 0.30, 34.7 and 39.7 microg of hexanal/g of myofibril were detected by GC/MS-SPME and CI-ELISA, respectively, after 4 days of storage. At an a(w) of 0.75, 39.8 and 61.1 microg of hexanal/g of myofibril were detected by GC/MS-SPME and CI-ELISA, respectively, after 4 days of storage. The CI-ELISA was well correlated with the GC/MS-SPME (r = 0.78) and TBARS (r = 0.87) methods. The correlation of the hexanal-specific CI-ELISA to both GC/MS-SPME and TBARS verified the ability of the CI-ELISA to be used as an index of lipid oxidation, offering the convenience for use in a kit to be utilized within a food-processing facility.

A rapid most-probable-number-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for the detection and enumeration of Salmonella Typhimurium in poultry wastewater

The rapid and accurate detection and enumeration of low levels of Salmonella Typhimurium in food processing facilities are critical components of an effective hazard analysis critical control point program. The objective of this study was to develop a rapid (8 h) most probable number (MPN)-enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the detection and enumeration of Salmonella Typhimurium in wastewater. The specific objectives were to (i) characterize poly- and monoclonal Salmonella Typhimurium-specific antibodies in order to select the most specific and sensitive antibody for Salmonella Typhimurium detection, and (ii) validate the MPN assay through a correlation between the 8-h MPN-ELISA and the traditional 48-h Salmonella Typhimurium MPN method in poultry scald water. Poultry scald water samples were spiked with 10 and 50 CFU/ml of Salmonella Typhimurium. The traditional MPN method used a 48-h enrichment period followed by an analysis, while the MPN-ELISA used a 5-h enrichment period followed by a 3-h ELISA analysis. No differences (P < 0.05) were found between the traditional MPN and the MPN-ELISA, indicating the promise of the MPN-ELISA for the rapid detection and enumeration of Salmonella Typhimurium within an 8-h shift. This abbreviated assay will permit increased product sampling and more rapid movement of food between production and processing, resulting in reduced spoilage and quality losses.

The production and characterisation of dinitrocarbanilide antibodies raised using antigen mimics

Polyclonal antibodies were produced to detect the coccidiostat nicarbazin. Due to structural constraints of the active component of nicarbazin, dinitrocarbanilide (DNC), three different compounds that shared a common substructure with DNC were used as antigen mimics. The compounds (N-succinyl-L-alanyl-L-alanyl-L-alanine 4-nitroanilide (SAN), L-glutamic acid gamma-(p-nitroanilide) (GAN) and p-nitrosuccinanilic acid (NSA)) were conjugated to a carrier protein and used in the immunisation of rabbits. Five different polyclonal sera were produced and consequently characterised. The antibodies exhibited an IC(50) range of 2.3-7.6 ng/ml using a competitive ELISA procedure. Serum from one rabbit, R555, exhibited an IC(50) of 2.9 ng/ml for DNC and cross-reactivity studies showed that this serum was specific for DNC and did not cross-react with other coccidiostats such as halofuginone, toltrazuril or ronidazole.

Elisa to quantify hexanal-protein adducts in a meat model system

Monoclonal antibodies (MAb) were produced to hexanal-bovine serum albumin conjugates. An indirect competitive ELISA was developed with a detection range of 1-50 ng of hexanal/mL. Hexanal conjugated to three different proteins was recognized, whereas free hexanal and the native proteins were not detected. The antibody cross-reacted with pentanal, heptanal, and 2-trans-hexenal conjugated to chicken serum albumin (CSA) with cross-reactivities of 37.9, 76.6, and 45.0%, respectively. There was no cross-reactivity with propanal, butanal, octanal, and nonanal conjugated to CSA. The hexanal content of a meat model system was determined using MAb and polyclonal antibody-based ELISAs and compared with analysis by a dynamic headspace gas chromatographic (HS-GC) method and a thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) assay. Both ELISAs showed strong correlations with the HS-GC and TBARS methods. ELISAs may be a fast and simple alternative to GC for monitoring lipid oxidation in meat.

Separation and quantification of two fluoroquinolones in serum by on-line high-performance immunoaffinity chromatography

To demonstrate that two structurally similar chemicals can be extracted from a complex matrix and then separated from each other on the basis of their relative affinities for an antibody, an automated column-switching system was used, incorporating on-line, high-performance immunoaffinity chromatography (HPIAC). A high-affinity monoclonal antibody (Mab Sara-95) against the fluoroquinolone sarafloxacin was covalently cross-linked to a protein G column and used to capture fluoroquinolones in fortified serum samples. Interference from matrix components adhering nonspecifically to the column was minimized by the insertion of a protein G cleanup column between the injection port and the Mab Sara-95 derivatized HPIAC column. Upon injection, serum samples containing the fluoroquinolones passed through both columns. The cleanup column detained serum components, that otherwise would bind nonspecifically to the HPIAC column, but allowed the fluoroquinolones to pass through unhindered to the HPIAC column. The fluoroquinolones were then eluted from the HPIAC column according to their relative affinities for the antibody, and individual peaks were monitored using fluorescence detection. By using an on-line cleanup column in tandem with an HPIAC column, the fluoroquinolones could be separated from the serum matrix and then separated from each other on the basis of their affinity for Mab Sara-95 without the use of organic solvents or reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC). This method demonstrates true immunoaffinity separation of structurally related compounds in a complex matrix.

Production and specificity of polyclonal antibodies to hexanal-lysine adducts

Hexanal content is a widely used index of lipid oxidation in foods. The objectives of this study were to develop antibodies to hexanal-lysine adducts, devise an ELISA, and characterize antibody specificity. Hexanal was made immunogenic by covalent attachment to lysine side chains of bovine serum albumin via reductive alkylation. Polyclonal antibodies had antiserum titers as high as 6.15 x 10(5). A competitive indirect ELISA was developed with a detection limit of 0.7 ng of hexanal/mL. Antibodies were carrier-independent, reacting with hexanal conjugates of several proteins but not with the corresponding native proteins. Cross-reactivities with chicken serum albumin conjugates of n-heptanal, n-pentanal, and n-octanal were 86. 3, 11.8, and 2.2%, respectively. Antibodies reacted strongly with hexanal-modified lysine and hexanal-modified epsilon-aminocaproic acid but did not recognize free amino acids or free hexanal. It may be feasible to use this ELISA to monitor lipid oxidation in food provided hexanal is alkylated to a carrier protein prior to analysis.

Quantitative computer image analysis of a human chorionic gonadotropin colloidal carbon dipstick assay

Colloidal particles are widely used in qualitative dipstick assays for the determination of various proteins and haptens. Recently, a new colloidal label has been introduced based on elemental carbon. With this carbon label we have prepared a human chorionic gonadotropin-specific dipstick assay with a sensitivity of 10 mIU/ml. In addition, an image- and data-processing procedure for the quantification of the dipstick assay has been developed. The sum of the pixel grey levels of a carbon line was taken as a measure for this quantitative purpose. The measurement range of the assay is almost three orders of magnitude, i.e. 10 mIU/ml to 500 mIU/ml. The deviation from the mean of two dipstick determinations was 1.22% on average. The within-run and between-run precision, expressed as coefficients of variation at 50 mIU/ml were 1.03% and 1.84%, at 150 mIU/ml 2.14% and 3.77% and at 450 mIU/ml 2.55% and 5.28%, respectively. We have correlated this quantitative sol particle immunoassay with a commercial human chorionic gonadotropin specific radioimmunoassay. In an experiment with 25 human urine samples containing the hormone in amounts from 5 to 300 mIU/ml the correlation coefficient was 0.999. The sol particle immunoassay quantified by computer image analysis has been termed Sol particle Image Processed ImmunoAssay (SIPIA).