Requirement for non-T cells in the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. I. Use of nude mice as source of non-T cells

Direct estimation of the frequency of human cytotoxic T lymphocytes and their precursors following in vitro allosensitization

Cell mediated lympholysis (CML) has been proposed as an in vitro model of the rejection process that results from transplantation of allogeneic tissue. To date, the absolute frequencies of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and their precursors (CTL.P) have not been directly estimated in man because of technical difficulties. Through optimizing the conditions for radiometric detection of 51Cr release and the attendant improvement in CML sensitivity, direct CTL frequency estimates have been determined in peripheral blood (PBL), spleen (SPL), and lymph nodes (LNC) after in vitro allostimulation using unrelated human cells and limiting dilution assays. The mean frequency of CTL generated from PBL is 1 in 826 cells (0.121% +/- 0.101%) which, from preliminary experiments, is significantly greater than that generated from either LNC or SPL (p less than 0.05). With restimulation of primed cells on day 10, the frequency of CTL generated from PBL was increased 400%. The CTL.P frequency (0.0064% +/- 0.0050%) was approximately 5% of the corresponding CTL frequency. The CTL.P frequencies were found to be minimal estimates as both accessory "filler" cells and T cell growth factors increased the level of detection of CTL.P an average of threefold. The limiting cell dilution assay as detailed in this report should be a powerful tool for defining the cellular requirements and related factors necessary for optimal induction of a CTL response and should provide the means for determination of the immunogenetic requirements and the allospecificity of human cytotoxic lymphocytes.

Selection of the T cell repertoire during ontogeny: limiting dilution analysis

The relative frequencies of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) specific for minor histocompatibility antigens that are restricted to either k or b major histocompatibility complex antigens in normal B6 mice and in B6 leads to (B6 x CBA)F1 radiation chimeras were estimated. The ratio of k-restricted to b-restricted CTL-P determined for the radiation chimeras served as a base value to which the ratio of k: b-restricted CTL from normal B6 mice can be compared. The frequencies of allorestricted CTL-P in B6 mice were determined after the B6 cells had been depleted of k-reactive cells by filtration through irradiated B6.H-2k mice. Lymphocytes from immunized animals were used to obtain frequency estimates of CTL-P specific for minor H antigens. The cultures contained nu/nu spleen cells syngeneic to the responder, but no exogenous interleukin 2 (T cell growth factor) since a high degree of nonspecific killing was found in IL2-supplemented cultures. It was found that the CTL-P frequency of B6 mice to BALB.B antigens in the lymph node cells of normal or immune B6 mice were 1 in 300 000 and 1 in 8000, respectively. In B6 leads to (B6 x CBA)F1 radiation chimeras, the ratio of BALB.B/BALB.K-specific CTL-P was 3:1; this ratio was 17:1 in normal B6 mice. Twenty-five percent of CTL clones from normal B6 mice lysing BALB.K target also lysed BALB.B target whereas less than 1% of CTL clones lytic on BALB.K target from the chimeras showed this cross-reaction The results are compatible with the idea of complete positive selection of self MHC-restricted CTL-P in the absence of priming effects by foreign antigen.

Cytotoxic T cell response to minor histocompatibility antigens: apparent lack of H-2 restriction in killers stimulated by membrane fragments

The secondary cytotoxic T cell response of BALB/c to B10.D2 or DBA/2 minor histocompatibility antigens in vitro requires the participation of an adherent cell. Nylon wool-passed spleen cells were only able to respond to nonadherent intact stimulator cells, or to membrane fragments derived from those cells, if a syngeneic adherent cell were present in the cultures. When the H-2 restriction properties of cytotoxic cells generated in response to various types of stimulation were analyzed, it was found that responses to B10.D2 or DBA/2 intact cells were always H-2 restricted. Responses to syngeneic adherent cells presenting B10.D2 or DBA.2 freeze-thaw antigen were either entirely or predominantly lacking in H-2 restriction as defined by efficient competition by B10 (H-2b) cold target cells. These unrestricted killers appeared to recognize minor histocompatibility as an independent determinant rather than as an H-2d/minors moiety cross-reaction with H-2b, because they were not absorbed by BALB.B (H-2b) macrophage monolayers, but were absorbed by B10 monolayers. Similarly, B10 but not BALB.B cold targets were able to compete for the anti-B10.D2 killers. These experiments eliminate the possibility that the lack of restriction was due to an H-2b restricted receptor cross-reactive with H-2b. Possible models to explain these findings are discussed.

Generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes in vitro. XI. Accessory cell requirement in secondary responses to particulate alloantigen

The non-T accessory cell requirement for cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) generation in vitro was studied in a system which makes use of particulate membrane preparations as a source of alloantigen, and spleen cells from alloimmune mice as a source of responding cells. It is shown that removal of nylon-adherent cells from the responding cell population strongly reduced CTL generation, whereas direct removal of Ig+, phagocytic or plastic-adherent cells had no effect. The CTL response of the nylon-nonadherent cell population could be reconstituted by the addition of normal spleen cells, which by themselves do not generate CTL in response to particulate alloantigen. The accessory cell function of normal spleen cells was not affected by depletion of T cells or of phagocytic cells, but was sensitive to gamma-irradiation (1000 rd). The system thus demonstrates the requirement for a nylon-adherent accessory cell population in the secondary CTL response to particulate alloantigens which does not exhibit the typical characteristics of T cells, B cells or macrophages.

Generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes in vitro. XII. Detection of memory CTL precursors in peripheral blood of alloimmune mice

The memory cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response of mice was studied in vitro using peripheral blood leucocytes (PBL) of donors previously immunized with allogeneic cells as responding cells, and particulate alloantigen for stimulation. It is shown that alloimmune but not normal PBL respond to particulate antigen and that small numbers of PBL generate high CTL responses provided non-T accessory spleen cells are added to the cultures. The system provides means to analyse the kinetics of the appearance of memory CTL precursors after primary alloimmunization in individual mice.

Analysis of mechanisms of maintenance of neonatally induced tolerance to foreign alloantigens

Mice made tolerant to allogeneic tissues in neonatal life have been examined at different times for their ability to respond to the tolerizing determinants in a variety of assays (in vitro CML, MCL and in vivo GvH assays). All animals were tolerant in terms of their inability to produce CTL to the relevant determinants, and to induce GvH in lethally irradiated F1 recipients. Nevertheless, some mice also showed a normal MLC proliferative response and contained antigen-specific serum inhibitory factors, while other mice contained apparently antigen-specific suppressor cells. The pool of the latter, futhermore, was expanded considerably upon adoptive transfer of tolerant cells (with tolerizing antigens) to lethally irradiated syngeneic recipients. The data are compatible with the notion that suppression of clonal expansion represents the primary mechanism of tolerance maintenance (induction), and that the infrequently observed serum reactivity in such tolerant mice represents a vestige of the means whereby-cell mediated suppression was induced.

Quantitative studies on the precursors of cytotoxic lymphocytes. III. The lineage of memory cells

In the course of a mixed lymphocyte culture, memory cells are produced which can give rise to a large secondary cytotoxic lymphocyte response on reexposure to the sensitizing alloantigen. We have studied the lineage of these memory cells using a clonal assay for precursors of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CLP). Our data provide conclusive evidence that individual CLP, upon stimulation with alloantigens, gives rise to clones which contain memory cells of the same specificity as the CLP. Only half of the clones that responded in the primary stimulation could be reactivated upon exposure to the original priming alloantigen.

Differentiation of functionally active mouse T lymphocytes from functionally inactive bone marrow precursors II. Limited recovery of T-cell responses from mouse bone marrow in tissue culture

The limited differentiation of mature T cell function from mouse bone marrow in tissue culture is described and compared with similar differentiation occuring in vivo in irradiated bone marrow protected mice. Data are presented to show that a pool of precursors, similar in size to that able to produce early (transient?) regeneration in thymectomized recipients, is responsible for the development of mitogen responsive T cells active in MLC (proliferation) and CML (development of cytotoxic cells) assays. In contrast, a helper cell population which augments antibody formation from T-depleted normal spleen cells derives from a pool of similar precursors yet does not seem to be theta positive. Similarly, larger cells (perhaps typical of those giving rise to suppressor T cells in vivo) give rise to a suppressor cell pool after 4 days of culture, though again only a fraction of this suppressor activity could be attributed to theta positive cells. It is suggested that much of the data for regenration of T lymphocytes in vitro from T-depleted sources needs to be re-interpreted in terms of this evidence for a pool of post-thymic precursors of T cells in such T-deficient cell populations.

Cellular requirements for the induction of cytotoxic T cells in vitro

The stimulator and accessory cell requirements for the induction of cytotoxic T cell responses to alloantigens in vitro are reviewed. The ability of lymphocytes to stimulate was acquired early in development and was found to be a property of both Ig+ and Ig- cells. The presence of Fc receptors, complement receptors or Ia antigens on lymphocytes did not confer superior stimulator capacity. In contrast to lymphocytes mature macrophages were poor stimulators. When resting lymphocytes were used as a source of stimulator cells there was an additional requirement for an adherent accessory cell population for the induction of cytotoxic T cells. The accessory cell population functioned whether syngeneic or allogeneic with the responder and was required for the induction rather than the maintenance of the response. It was further characterized as an Ig+, theta, FcR+/-, CR +/-, Ia- cell which was not a mature macrophage. Accessory cells could be replaced to some extent by supernatants from spleen cell cultures. A model for T cell induction is proposed where only cells which produce unique inductive stimuli are able to function as stimulator cells. Stimulator cells are defined as those cells capable of stimulating cytotoxic T cell precursors directly and independently. Stimulator capacity is suggested to be a function of activated cells only, thus lymphocytes only stimulate following activation by accessory cells. Cells lacking innate stimulator capacity but exhibiting Ia antigens are suggested to stimulate via an alternative means.

Histocompatibility antigen-activated cytotoxic T lymphocytes. II. Estimates of the frequency and specificity of precursors

Using limiting dilutions of responding cells in mouse mixed leukocyte cultures, we obtained direct estimates of the minimum frequency of precursors of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL.P) for a variety of antigens. Depending on the strain combination, there were as many as 4-15 CTL.P reactive to DBA/2 among 10(4) lymph node cells. Taking into account that only 5-10% of peripheral T lymphocytes have the potential to develop into cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) (6), this implies that at least 1-2% of all CTL.P are responsive to any given H-2 haplotype difference. Precursors of cytotoxic cells thus have the same high frequency of cells reactive to alloantigens of the major histocompatibility complex as found among proliferating cells in graft-vs.-host reactions and mixed lymphocyte interactions. The frequencies of CTL.P reactive to xenoantigens (rat) or trinitrophenyl-modified self were less than half the frequency of alloreactive CTL.P. A minority of the CTL.P specific for one H-2 haplotype were also reactive to a third party H-2 haplotype, presumably on the basis of recognition of shared determinants. By dilution of sensitized cells from single microcultures, it was shown that a single CTL.P undergoes a minimum of three to four cell divisions and generates at least 8-16 CTLs after antigenic activation.