The B cell antigen receptor of class IgD induces a stronger and more prolonged protein tyrosine phosphorylation than that of class IgM

Aberrant B cell receptor signaling in circulating naïve and IgA+ memory B cells from newly-diagnosed autoantibody-positive rheumatoid arthritis patients

OBJECTIVE

Altered B cell receptor (BCR) signaling has been implicated in the pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Here we aimed to identify signaling aberrations in autoantibody-positive and autoantibody-negative RA patients by performing a comprehensive analysis of the BCR signaling cascade in different B cell subsets.

METHODS

We first optimized phosphoflow cytometry for an in-depth analysis of BCR signaling across immunoglobulin isotypes in healthy donors. Subsequently, we compared BCR signaling in circulating B cell subsets from treatment-naïve, newly-diagnosed autoantibody-positive RA and autoantibody-negative RA patients and healthy controls (HCs).

RESULTS

We observed subset-specific phosphorylation patterns of the BCR signalosome in circulating B cells from healthy donors. Compared with HCs, autoantibody-positive RA patients displayed enhanced responses to BCR stimulation for multiple signaling proteins, specifically in naïve and IgA+ memory B cells. Whereas in unstimulated healthy donor B cells, the phosphorylation status of individual signaling proteins showed only limited correlation, BCR stimulation enhanced the interconnectivity in phosphorylation within the BCR signalosome. However, this strong interconnectivity within the BCR signalosome in stimulated B cells from HCs was lost in RA, especially in autoantibody-positive RA patients. Finally, we observed strong correlations between SYK and BTK protein expression, and IgA and IgG anti-citrullinated protein antibody concentrations in serum from autoantibody-positive RA patients.

CONCLUSION

Collectively, the isotype-specific analysis of multiple key components of the BCR signalosome identified aberrant BCR signaling responses in treatment-naïve autoantibody-positive RA patients, particularly in naïve B cells and IgA+ memory B cells. Our findings support differential involvement of dysregulated BCR signaling in the pathogenesis of autoantibody-positive and autoantibody-negative RA.

A new branched proximity hybridization assay for the quantification of nanoscale protein-protein proximity

Membrane proteins are organized in nanoscale compartments. Their reorganization plays a crucial role in receptor activation and cell signaling. To monitor the organization and reorganization of membrane proteins, we developed a new branched proximity hybridization assay (bPHA) allowing better quantification of the nanoscale protein-protein proximity. In this assay, oligo-coupled binding probes, such as aptamer, nanobody, and antibodies, are used to translate the proximity of target proteins to the proximity of oligos. The closely positioned oligos then serve as a template for a maximum of 400-fold branched DNA (bDNA) signal amplification. The amplified bPHA signal is recorded by flow cytometer, thus enabling proximity studies with high throughput, multiplexing, and single-cell resolution. To demonstrate the potential of the bPHA method, we measured the reorganization of the immunoglobulin M (IgM)- and immunoglobulin D (IgD)-class B cell antigen receptor (BCR) on the plasma membrane and the recruitment of spleen tyrosine kinase (Syk) to the BCR upon B lymphocyte activation.

Isotype Specific Assembly of B Cell Antigen Receptors and Synergism With Chemokine Receptor CXCR4

Expression of the membrane-bound form of the immunoglobulin (Ig) as part of the antigen receptor is indispensable for both the development and the effector function of B cells. Among five known isotypes, IgM and IgD are the common B cell antigen receptors (BCRs) that are co-expressed in naïve B cells. Despite having identical antigen specificity and being associated with the same signaling heterodimer Igα/Igβ (CD79a/CD79b), IgM and IgD-BCR isotypes functionally differ from each other in the manner of antigen binding, the formation of isolated nanoclusters and in their interaction with co-receptors such as CD19 and CXCR4 on the plasma membrane. With recent developments in experimental techniques, it is now possible to investigate the nanoscale organization of the BCR and better understand early events of BCR engagement. Interestingly, the cytoskeleton network beneath the membrane controls the BCR isotype-specific organization and its interaction with co-receptors. BCR triggering results in reorganization of the cytoskeleton network, which is further modulated by isotype-specific signals from co-receptors. For instance, IgD-BCR is closely associated with CXCR4 on mature B cells and this close proximity allows CXCR4 to employ the BCR machinery as signaling hub. In this review, we discuss the functional specificity and nanocluster assembly of BCR isotypes and the consequences of cross-talk between CXCR4 and IgD-BCR. Furthermore, given the role of BCR and CXCR4 signaling in the development and survival of leukemic B cells, we discuss the consequences of the cross-talk between CXCR4 and the BCR for controlling the growth of transformed B cells.

Isotype Specific Assembly of B Cell Antigen Receptors and Synergism With Chemokine Receptor CXCR4

Expression of the membrane-bound form of the immunoglobulin (Ig) as part of the antigen receptor is indispensable for both the development and the effector function of B cells. Among five known isotypes, IgM and IgD are the common B cell antigen receptors (BCRs) that are co-expressed in naïve B cells. Despite having identical antigen specificity and being associated with the same signaling heterodimer Igα/Igβ (CD79a/CD79b), IgM and IgD-BCR isotypes functionally differ from each other in the manner of antigen binding, the formation of isolated nanoclusters and in their interaction with co-receptors such as CD19 and CXCR4 on the plasma membrane. With recent developments in experimental techniques, it is now possible to investigate the nanoscale organization of the BCR and better understand early events of BCR engagement. Interestingly, the cytoskeleton network beneath the membrane controls the BCR isotype-specific organization and its interaction with co-receptors. BCR triggering results in reorganization of the cytoskeleton network, which is further modulated by isotype-specific signals from co-receptors. For instance, IgD-BCR is closely associated with CXCR4 on mature B cells and this close proximity allows CXCR4 to employ the BCR machinery as signaling hub. In this review, we discuss the functional specificity and nanocluster assembly of BCR isotypes and the consequences of cross-talk between CXCR4 and IgD-BCR. Furthermore, given the role of BCR and CXCR4 signaling in the development and survival of leukemic B cells, we discuss the consequences of the cross-talk between CXCR4 and the BCR for controlling the growth of transformed B cells.

The importance of B cell receptor isotypes and stereotypes in chronic lymphocytic leukemia

B cell receptor (BCR) signaling is a central pathway promoting the survival and proliferation of normal and malignant B cells. Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) arises from mature B cells, expressing functional BCRs, mainly of immunoglobulin M (IgM) and IgD isotypes. Importantly, 30% of CLL patients express quasi-identical BCRs, the so-called "stereotyped" receptors, indicating the existence of common antigenic determinants, which may drive disease initiation and favor its progression. Although the antigenic specificity of IgM and IgD receptors is identical, there are distinct isotype-specific responses after IgM and IgD triggering. Here, we discuss the most important steps of normal B cell development, and highlight the importance of BCR signaling for CLL pathogenesis, with a focus on differences between IgM and IgD isotype signaling. We also highlight the main characteristics of CLL patient subsets, based on BCR stereotypy, and describe subset-specific BCR function and antigen-binding characteristics. Finally, we outline the key biologic and clinical responses to kinase inhibitor therapy, targeting the BCR-associated Bruton's tyrosine kinase, phosphoinositide-3-kinase, and spleen tyrosine kinase in patients with CLL.

IgD attenuates the IgM-induced anergy response in transitional and mature B cells

Self-tolerance by clonal anergy of B cells is marked by an increase in IgD and decrease in IgM antigen receptor surface expression, yet the function of IgD on anergic cells is obscure. Here we define the RNA landscape of the in vivo anergy response, comprising 220 induced sequences including a core set of 97. Failure to co-express IgD with IgM decreases overall expression of receptors for self-antigen, but paradoxically increases the core anergy response, exemplified by increased Sdc1 encoding the cell surface marker syndecan-1. IgD expressed on its own is nevertheless competent to induce calcium signalling and the core anergy mRNA response. Syndecan-1 induction correlates with reduction of surface IgM and is exaggerated without surface IgD in many transitional and mature B cells. These results show that IgD attenuates the response to self-antigen in anergic cells and promotes their accumulation. In this way, IgD minimizes tolerance-induced holes in the pre-immune antibody repertoire.

Self-reactive B cells that are anergic express mainly IgD, yet the function of IgD is not clear. Here the authors analyse primary B cells from mice to show that IgD signalling attenuates self-antigen induced gene expression and promotes survival of anergic B cells that might go on to reactivate to foreign antigens and mutate away from self-reactivity.

Functional Differences between IgM and IgD Signaling in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia

BCR signaling is a central pathogenetic pathway in chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL). Most CLL cells express BCRs of IgM and IgD isotypes, but the contribution of these isotypes to functional responses remains incompletely defined. We therefore investigated differences between IgM and IgD signaling in freshly isolated peripheral blood CLL cells and in CLL cells cultured with nurselike cells, a model that mimics the lymph node microenvironment. IgM signaling induced prolonged activation of ERK kinases and promoted CLL cell survival, CCL3 and CCL4 chemokine secretion, and downregulation of BCL6, the transcriptional repressor of CCL3 In contrast, IgD signaling induced activation of the cytoskeletal protein HS1, along with F-actin polymerization, which resulted in rapid receptor internalization and failure to support downstream responses, including CLL cell survival and chemokine secretion. IgM and IgD receptor downmodulation, HS1 and ERK activation, chemokine secretion, and BCL6 downregulation were also observed when CLL cells were cocultured with nurselike cells. The Bruton's tyrosine kinase inhibitor ibrutinib effectively inhibited both IgM and IgD isotype signaling. In conclusion, through a variety of functional readouts, we demonstrate very distinct outcomes of IgM and IgD isotype activation in CLL cells, providing novel insight into the regulation of BCR signaling in CLL.

Control of B Cell Responsiveness by Isotype and Structural Elements of the Antigen Receptor

Expression of a functional B cell antigen receptor (BCR) plays a central role in regulating B cell development, maturation, and effector functions. Although IgM is solely expressed in immature B cell stages, the presence of both IgM- and IgD-BCR isotypes on mature naïve B cells raises the question of whether IgD has a unique role in B cell activation and function. While earlier studies suggested a broad functional redundancy between IgM and IgD, recent data point to an important immune regulatory role of IgD. Herein, we review these findings and discuss how the structural flexibility, mode of antigen binding, and co-receptor interactions, enable the IgD-BCR to act as a 'rheostat', regulating the activation and function of mature naïve B cells.

B cell antigen receptors of the IgM and IgD classes are clustered in different protein islands that are altered during B cell activation

The B cell antigen receptors (BCRs) play an important role in the clonal selection of B cells and their differentiation into antibody-secreting plasma cells. Mature B cells have both immunoglobulin M (IgM) and IgD types of BCRs, which have identical antigen-binding sites and are both associated with the signaling subunits Igα and Igβ, but differ in their membrane-bound heavy chain isoforms. By two-color direct stochastic optical reconstruction microscopy (dSTORM), we showed that IgM-BCRs and IgD-BCRs reside in the plasma membrane in different protein islands with average sizes of 150 and 240 nm, respectively. Upon B cell activation, the BCR protein islands became smaller and more dispersed such that the IgM-BCRs and IgD-BCRs were found in close proximity to each other. Moreover, specific stimulation of one class of BCR had minimal effects on the organization of the other. These conclusions were supported by the findings from two-marker transmission electron microscopy and proximity ligation assays. Together, these data provide evidence for a preformed multimeric organization of BCRs on the plasma membrane that is remodeled after B cell activation.

Lectins from opportunistic bacteria interact with acquired variable-region glycans of surface immunoglobulin in follicular lymphoma

B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) expression is a key feature of most B-cell lymphomas, but the mechanisms of BCR signal induction and the involvement of autoantigen recognition remain unclear. In follicular lymphoma (FL) B cells, BCR expression is retained despite a chromosomal translocation that links the antiapoptotic gene BCL2 to the regulatory elements of immunoglobulin genes, thereby disrupting 1 heavy-chain allele. A remarkable feature of FL-BCRs is the acquisition of potential N-glycosylation sites during somatic hypermutation. The introduced glycans carry mannose termini, which create potential novel binding sites for mannose-specific lectins. Here, we investigated the effect of N-linked variable-region glycosylation for BCR interaction with cognate antigen and with lectins of different origins. N-glycans were found to severely impair BCR specificity and affinity to the initial cognate antigen. In addition, we found that lectins from Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Burkholderia cenocepacia bind and stimulate FL cells. Human exposure to these bacteria can occur by contact with soil and water. In addition, they represent opportunistic pathogens in susceptible hosts. Understanding the role of bacterial lectins might elucidate the pathogenesis of FL and establish novel therapeutic approaches.

Variant B cell receptor isotype functions differ in hairy cell leukemia with mutated BRAF and IGHV genes

A functional B-cell receptor (BCR) is critical for survival of normal B-cells, but whether it plays a comparable role in B-cell malignancy is as yet not fully delineated. Typical Hairy Cell Leukemia (HCL) is a rare B-cell tumor, and unique in expressing multiple surface immunoglobulin (sIg) isotypes on individual tumor cells (mult-HCL), to raise questions as to their functional relevance. Typical mult-HCL also displays a mutated BRAF V(600)E lesion. Since wild type BRAF is a primary conduit for transducing normal BCR signals, as revealed by deletion modelling studies, it is as yet not apparent if mutated BRAF alters BCR signal transduction in mult-HCL. To address these questions, we examined BCR signalling in mult-HCL cases uniformly displaying mutated BRAF and IGHV genes. Two apparent functional sets were delineated by IgD co-expression. In sIgD^+ve mult-HCL, IgD mediated persistent Ca²⁺ flux, also evident via >1 sIgH isotype, linked to increased ERK activation and BCR endocytosis. In sIgD^−ve mult-HCL however, BCR-mediated signals and downstream effects were restricted to a single sIgH isotype, with sIgM notably dysfunctional and remaining immobilised on the cell surface. These observations reveal discordance between expression and function of individual isotypes in mult-HCL. In dual sIgL expressing cases, only a single sIgL was fully functional. We examined effects of anti-BCR stimuli on mult-HCL survival ex-vivo. Significantly, all functional non-IgD isotypes increased ERK1/2 phosphorylation but triggered apoptosis of tumor cells, in both subsets. IgD stimuli, in marked contrast retained tumor viability. Despite mutant BRAF, BCR signals augment ERK1/2 phosphorylation, but isotype dictates functional downstream outcomes. In mult-HCL, sIgD retains a potential to transduce BCR signals for tumor survival in-vivo. The BCR in mult-HCL emerges as subject to complex regulation, with apparent conflicting signalling by individual isotypes when co-expressed with sIgD. This suggests the possibility that mutant BRAF by-passes BCR constraints in mult-HCL.

The role of BCR isotype in B-cell development and activation

The development and function of B lymphocytes critically depend on the non-germline B-cell antigen receptor (BCR). In addition to the diverse antigen-recognition regions, whose coding sequences are generated by the somatic DNA rearrangement, the variety of the constant domains of the Heavy Chain (HC) portion contributes to the multiplicity of the BCR types. The functions of particular classes of the HC, particularly in the context of the membrane BCR, are not completely understood. The expression of the various classes of the HC correlates with the distinct stages of B-cell development, types of B-cell subsets, and their effector functions. In this chapter, we summarize and discuss the accumulated knowledge on the role of the μ, δ, and γ HC isotypes of the conventional and precursor BCR in B-cell differentiation, selection, and engagement with (auto)antigens.

Influence of B cells in liver fibrosis associated with hepatitis B virus harboring basal core promoter mutations

The development of the liver disease in chronic hepatitis B with common viral variants can be determined through the interaction between the virus and the host immune response. B cells constitute half of the intrahepatic lymphocyte population with an impact on fibrosis. A proliferation-inducing ligand (APRIL) has been shown to have a co-stimulatory activity on B cells. For this study HBV DNA was amplified and then sequenced to show the presence of the basal core promoter (BCP) mutations in the serum from 57 patients with chronic hepatitis B. The range of IgD-positive B cells was detected by immunohistochemistry in liver biopsies; and patients serum was assayed for APRIL levels by enzyme immunoassay. Twenty-seven patients (47.4%) harbored the A1762T-G1764A BCP mutations. Coefficients of logistic regression showed that the effect of increasing IgD-positive B cells in rising odds of the liver disease is the same in the patients with BCP mutation A1762T-G1764A and in the patients without mutation, nevertheless the effect of APRIL is not similar in these two groups of patients. Logistic regression in patients with BCP A1762T-G1764A mutations demonstrated that increasing one score of APRIL decreased the odds of fibrosis stage about 8%. These results suggest that in infection with viral variants of hepatitis B virus, the population of IgD-positive B cells may play a decisive role in later stages of the liver disease which is reduced by APRIL in chronic hepatitis patients with BCP mutations.

The SH2-domain of SHIP1 interacts with the SHIP1 C-terminus: impact on SHIP1/Ig-α interaction

The SH2-containing inositol 5'-phosphatase, SHIP1, negatively regulates signal transduction from the B cell antigen receptor (BCR). The mode of coupling between SHIP1 and the BCR has not been elucidated so far. In comparison to wild-type cells, B cells expressing a mutant IgD- or IgM-BCR containing a C-terminally truncated Ig-α respond to pervanadate stimulation with markedly reduced tyrosine phosphorylation of SHIP1 and augmented activation of protein kinase B. This indicates that SHIP1 is capable of interacting with the C-terminus of Ig-α. Employing a system of fluorescence resonance energy transfer in S2 cells, we can clearly demonstrate interaction between the SH2-domain of SHIP1 and Ig-α. Furthermore, a fluorescently labeled SH2-domain of SHIP1 translocates to the plasma membrane in an Ig-α-dependent manner. Interestingly, whereas the SHIP1 SH2-domain can be pulled-down with phospho-peptides corresponding to the immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif (ITAM) of Ig-α from detergent lysates, no interaction between full-length SHIP1 and the phosphorylated Ig-α ITAM can be observed. Further studies show that the SH2-domain of SHIP1 can bind to the C-terminus of the SHIP1 molecule, most probably by inter- as well as intra-molecular means, and that this interaction regulates the association between different forms of SHIP1 and Ig-α.

New insights into the enigma of immunoglobulin D

Immunoglobulin D (IgD) has remained a mysterious antibody class for almost half a century. IgD was initially thought to be a recently evolved Ig isotype expressed only by some mammalian species, but recent discoveries in fishes and amphibians demonstrate that IgD was present in the ancestor of all jawed vertebrates and has important immunological functions. The structure of IgD has been very dynamic throughout evolution. Mammals can express IgD through alternative splicing and class switch recombination. Active cell-dependent and T-cell-independent IgM-to-IgD class switching takes place in a unique subset of human B cells from the upper aerodigestive mucosa, which provides a layer of mucosal protection by interacting with many pathogens and their virulence factors. Circulating IgD can bind to myeloid cells such as basophils and induce antimicrobial, inflammatory, and B-cell-stimulating factors upon cross-linking, which contributes to not only immune surveillance but also inflammation and tissue damage when this pathway is overactivated under pathological conditions. Recent research shows that IgD is an important immunomodulator that orchestrates an ancestral surveillance system at the interface between immunity and inflammation.

N-linked glycosylation selectively regulates autonomous precursor BCR function

Developing B cells express distinct classes of B cell antigen receptors (BCRs) that differ in their heavy chain (HC). Although only muHC is expressed in early stages, deltaHC-containing BCRs dominate on the surface of mature B cells. The reason for the tightly regulated expression of these receptors is poorly understood. Here we show that muHC was specifically required for precursor BCR (pre-BCR) function and that deltaHC was unable to form a functional pre-BCR. A conserved asparagine (N)-linked glycosylation site at position 46 (N46) in the first conserved domain of muHC was absolutely required for pre-BCR function, and swapping that domain with deltaHC resulted in a functional deltaHC-containing pre-BCR. When tested in the context of the BCR, muHC with a mutant N46 showed normal function, which indicated that N46-glycosylation is specifically required for pre-BCR function. Our results suggest an unexpected mode of pre-BCR function, in which binding of the surrogate light chain to N46 mediates autonomous crosslinking and, concomitantly, receptor formation.

Peripheral B cell tolerance and function in transgenic mice expressing an IgD superantigen

Transitional B cells turn over rapidly in vivo and are sensitive to apoptosis upon BCR ligation in vitro. However, little direct evidence addresses their tolerance sensitivity in vivo. A key marker used to distinguish these cells is IgD, which, through alternative RNA splicing of H chain transcripts, begins to be coexpressed with IgM at this stage. IgD is also expressed at high levels on naive follicular (B-2) and at lower levels on marginal zone and B-1 B cells. In this study, mice were generated to ubiquitously express a membrane-bound IgD-superantigen. These mice supported virtually no B-2 development, a greatly reduced marginal zone B cell population, but a relatively normal B-1 compartment. B cell development in the spleen abruptly halted at the transitional B cell population 1 to 2 stage, a block that could not be rescued by either Bcl-2 or BAFF overexpression. The developmentally arrested B cells appeared less mature and turned over more rapidly than nontransgenic T2 cells, exhibiting neither conventional features of anergy nor appreciable receptor editing. Paradoxically, type-2 T-independent responses were more robust in the transgenic mice, although T-dependent responses were reduced and had skewed IgL and IgH isotype usages. Nevertheless, an augmented memory response to secondary challenge was evident. The transgenic mice also had increased serum IgM, but diminished IgG, levels mirrored by the increased numbers of IgM(+) plasma cells. This model should facilitate studies of peripheral B cell tolerance, with the advantages of allowing analysis of polyclonal populations, and of B cells naturally lacking IgD.

CD19 is essential for B cell activation by promoting B cell receptor-antigen microcluster formation in response to membrane-bound ligand

Here we describe the spatiotemporal architecture, at high molecular resolution, of receptors and signaling molecules during the early events of mouse B cell activation. In response to membrane-bound ligand stimulation, antigen aggregation occurs in B cell antigen receptor (BCR) microclusters containing immunoglobulin (Ig) M and IgD that recruit the kinase Syk and transiently associate with the coreceptor CD19. Unexpectedly, CD19-deficient B cells were significantly defective in initiation of BCR-dependent signaling, accumulation of downstream effectors and cell spreading, defects that culminated in reduced microcluster formation. Hence, we have defined the dynamics of assembly of the main constituents of the BCR 'signalosome' and revealed an essential role for CD19, independent of the costimulatory molecule CD21, in amplifying early B cell activation events in response to membrane-bound ligand stimulation.

Association of protein kinase C-δ with the B cell antigen receptor complex

Protein kinase C (PKC)-delta is a diacylglycerol-dependent, calcium-independent novel PKC isoform and has been demonstrated to exert negative regulatory functions in B lymphocytes as well as in mast cells. Whereas in mast cells PKC-delta functionally interacts with the high-affinity receptor for IgE, FcepsilonR1, no such association has been described for the B cell antigen receptor (BCR). In this report, for the first time, we demonstrate the interaction of PKC-delta with different classes of BCR by means of affinity purification and native protein complex analysis. Using a C-terminally truncated Ig-alpha as well as non-phosphorylated and phosphorylated peptides representing C-terminal regions of Ig-alpha, the dependence of this BCR/PKC-delta interaction on tyrosine-phosphorylated Ig-alpha is shown. Finally, splenocytes from PKC-delta-deficient mice are found to exert reduced phosphorylation of PKD (a.k.a. PKC-mu) in response to BCR engagement, suggesting the early, membrane-proximal activation of an attenuating kinase complex including PKC-delta and PKD.

Stimulation of mast cells via FcvarepsilonR1 and TLR2: the type of ligand determines the outcome

Little is known about the interplay between pathophysiological processes of allergy and infection, particularly with respect to mast cell (MC)-mediated responses. The presence and recognition of pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) might have broad impact on the development and severity of diseases. In this study, we assessed the influence of toll-like receptor 2 (TLR 2)-dependent synthetic analogs of bacterial lipopeptides (LPs), Pam(3)CSK(4) and MALP-2, on Ag (DNP-HSA)-triggered responses in bone marrow-derived MCs (BMMCs). Both LPs strongly synergized with sub-optimal amounts of Ag in the stimulation of cytokine release. Intriguingly, Pam(3)CSK(4), but not MALP-2 suppressed Ag-induced degranulation of BMMCs (together with early tyrosine phosphorylation and calcium mobilization) in a TLR2-independent manner. Further analysis revealed that Pam(3)CSK(4), most probably by electrostatic forces, reduced the level of active DNP-HSA and that this, in turn, was responsible for the suppression of Ag-induced degranulation. Thus, our work demonstrates that LPs can synergize with IgE+Ag in stimulating the production of IL-6 by BMMCs. As well, our findings with Pam(3)CSK(4) indicate that one must be cautious when interpretating results obtained with "model" substances and the combination of ligands must be carefully chosen when functional interactions between the high-affinity receptor for IgE (FcepsilonR1) and TLR2 are examined.

Molecular characterization of immunoglobulin D in mammals: immunoglobulin heavy constant delta genes in dogs, chimpanzees and four old world monkey species

Antibodies are adaptor molecules that neutralize pathogens and link humoral and cellular defence mechanisms. Immunoglobulin D (IgD), one of the five antibody classes present in mammals, is expressed as an antigen receptor on naïve B cells. The functional role that IgD plays in the immune response is still poorly understood, but the recent characterization of immunoglobulin heavy constant delta genes (IGHD) in a variety of species challenges the view that IgD is of minor importance and is not present in many animals. On the basis of serological studies, IgD appears to be expressed in the majority of mammalian species examined. To confirm, at the molecular level, that IgD is present in different species, we cloned and sequenced IGHD cDNA from dogs and five non-human primate species (chimpanzee, rhesus macaque, cynomolgus macaque, baboon and sooty mangabey). Our results show that in all six species, IgD heavy chains possess three immunoglobulin domains and a long hinge region encoded by two exons. Only the hinge region of non-human primates is similar to the human hinge region, with conservation of O-glycosylation sites and multiple charged residues at opposing ends. The preservation of IgD in primates, dogs and previously characterized species suggests an important functional role for IgD, possibly involving binding to a receptor. The high degree of similarity existing between the structural features of human and non-human primate IgD suggests that non-human primates are suitable for in vivo studies designed to define the role that IgD plays in the immune response.

Tolerance to DNA in (NZB x NZW)F1 mice that inherit an anti-DNA V(H) as a conventional micro H chain transgene but not as a V(H) knock-in transgene

Lupus-prone (NZB x NZW)F(1) (BWF(1)) mice were made transgenic (Tg) for an anti-DNA Ab inherited either as a conventional V(H)3H9- micro H chain Tg (3H9- micro ) with or without a conventional V(kappa)8-kappa Tg, or a V(H)3H9 V(H) knock-in Tg allele (3H9R) with or without a V(kappa)4 V(kappa) knock-in Tg allele (V(kappa)4R). V(H)3H9 yields an anti-DNA Ab with most L chains including an anti-ssDNA with the V(kappa)8 Tg and an anti-dsDNA with the V(kappa)4 Tg. BWF(1) mice that inherited the conventional 3H9- micro had normal serum IgM, little to none of which was encoded by 3H9- micro, and only a small percentage of those mice had serum anti-DNA, none of which was transgene encoded. B cells expressing the conventional 3H9- micro Tg were anergic. BWF(1) mice that inherited the knock-in 3H9R Tg allele also had normal serum IgM, one-half of which was encoded by 3H9R, and produced anti-DNA encoded by the Tg allele. Most B cells expressing the knock-in 3H9R Tg also had an anergic phenotype. The results indicate that autoimmune-prone BWF(1) mice initially develop effective B cell tolerance to DNA through anergy, and anergy was sustained in 3H9- micro Tg peripheral B cells but not in 3H9R Tg B cells. B cells expressing the 3H9R knock-in Tg allele were able to achieve an activation threshold that B cells expressing the 3H9- micro conventional Tg could not. The maintenance of B cell tolerance to DNA in autoimmune-prone BWF(1) mice appears to differ from both normal mice and autoimmune-prone MRL(lpr/lpr) mice.

Differential segmental flexibility and reach dictate the antigen binding mode of chimeric IgD and IgM: implications for the function of the B cell receptor

Mature, naive B cells coexpress IgD and IgM with identical binding sites. In this study, the binding properties of such IgM and IgD are compared to determine how size and shape may influence their ability to bind Ag and thus function as receptors. To dissect their intrinsic binding properties, recombinant IgM and IgD were produced in soluble form as monomers of the basic H(2)L(2) Ab architecture, each with two Ag binding sites. Since these sites are connected with a hinge region in IgD and structural Ig domains in IgM, the two molecules differ significantly in this region. The results show that IgD exhibited the larger angle and longer distance between its binding sites, as well as having the greater flexibility. Relative functional affinity was assessed on two antigenic surfaces with high or low epitope density, respectively. At high epitope density, IgM had a higher functional affinity for the Ag compared with IgD. The order was reversed at low epitope density due to a decrease in the functional affinity of IgM. Studies of binding kinetics showed similar association rates for both molecules. The dissociation rate, however, was slower for IgM at high epitope density and for IgD at low epitope density. Taken together, the results show that IgM and IgD with identical Ag binding regions have different Ag binding properties.

Functional folding of a cytoplasmic single-chain variable fragment and its use as elutable protein purification tag

The variable fragment (Fv) of the monoclonal B1-8 antibody recognizes 3-nitro-4-hydroxy-phenylacetate (NP) and 5-iodo-NP (NIP) allowing for the affinity purification of the respective B cell antigen receptor with NP-sepharose and its specific elution with NIP-capronic acid (NIPcap). We generated an intracellular single-chain B1-8 Fv (iscFv), fused it to the N-terminus of the regulatory subunit (p85alpha) of phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase (PI3K) (isc-p85alpha), and examined the potential of this iscFv to serve as an intracellular elutable protein purification tag. The isc-p85alpha fusion protein could be specifically affinity-purified from the lysates of transfected Drosophila S2 cells with NP-sepharose and eluted with NIPcap, indicating the functional folding of the iscFv in the reducing environment of the cytosol. Furthermore, co-purification of the catalytic subunit of PI3K (p110) was achieved from lysates of co-transfected S2 cells as well as RBL-2H3 mast cells stably expressing isc-p85alpha. This indicates that the iscFv part of isc-p85alpha does not negatively influence p85alpha folding and interaction with p110. Moreover, successful incorporation of the p85alpha-moiety of isc-p85alpha into endogenous protein complexes in mast cells suggests the use of isc-containing fusion proteins for the native purification, elution, and analysis of intracellular signaling complexes.

Differential signaling via surface IgM is associated with VH gene mutational status and CD38 expression in chronic lymphocytic leukemia

The mutational status of tumor immunoglobulin V(H) genes is providing a powerful prognostic marker for chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL), with patients having tumors expressing unmutated V(H) genes being in a less favorable subset. However, the biologic differences correlating with V(H) gene status that could determine the clinical course of the disease are unknown. Here we show that differing responses to IgM ligation are closely associated with V(H) gene status. Specifically, 80% of cases with unmutated V(H) genes showed increased global tyrosine phosphorylation following IgM ligation, whereas only 20% of samples with mutated V(H) genes responded (P =.0002). There was also an association between response to IgM ligation and expression of CD38 (P =.015). The Syk kinase, critical for transducing B-cell receptor (BCR)- derived signals, was constitutively present in all CLL samples, and there was a perfect association between global phosphorylation and induction of phosphorylation/activation of Syk. Nonresponsiveness to anti-IgM could be circumvented by ligation of IgD (10 of 15 samples tested) or the BCR-associated molecule CD79alpha (12 of 15 samples tested). These results suggest that multiple mechanisms underlie nonresponsiveness to anti-IgM in CLL and that retained responsiveness to anti-IgM contributes to the poor prognosis associated with the unmutated subset of CLL. The prognostic power of the in vitro response to IgM ligation remains to be determined in a large series, but the simple technology involved may present an alternative or additional test for predicting clinical course.

Oligomeric antigen receptors: a new view on signaling for the selection of lymphocytes

Antigen receptors on lymphocytes utilize different signaling modes to control the positive and negative selection of lymphocytes. In addition, these receptors have to detect the amount and affinity of the antigen and set delicate threshold values for the activation of lymphocytes. It is suggested that the antigen receptors on B and T-cells form oligomeric complexes, inside of which, signals can be processed and amplified in a manner that might explain the different signaling outputs of these receptors.

Structural and functional properties of membrane and secreted IgD

More than 35 years ago, study of an unknown immunoglobulin (Ig) in the serum from a myeloma patient led to the discovery of IgD. Subsequently, the finding that it also exists as a membrane-bound Ig stimulated a large number of studies during the 70s. Then, the interest on IgD shrank, largely because of the lack of known function of secretory IgD (secIgD) and of a stagnating knowledge of the functions of surface IgD. In the recent years, very significant advances followed the tremendous accumulation of data on the physiology of the B cell receptor, of which IgD is the major component, on the role of secIgD in normal and diseased individuals. This review, which is focused on human IgD but integrates data in the mouse and other species when needed, summarizes present data on the structure, synthesis and functions of both membrane and secIgD, IgD receptors and the involvement of IgD in various diseases, especially the hyperIgD syndrome.

Monomeric and oligomeric complexes of the B cell antigen receptor

The current structural model of the B cell antigen receptor (BCR) describes it as a symmetric protein complex in which one membrane-bound immunoglobulin molecule (mIg) is noncovalently bound on each side by an Ig-alpha/Ig-beta heterodimer. Using peptide-tagged Ig-alpha proteins, blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE), and biosynthetical labeling of B cells, we find that the mIg:Ig-alpha/Ig-beta complex has a stoichiometry of 1:1 and not 1:2. An anti-Flag stimulation of B cells coexpressing Flag-tagged and wild-type Ig-alpha proteins results in the phosphorylation of both Ig-alpha proteins, suggesting that on the surface of living B cells, several BCR monomers are in contact with each other. A BN-PAGE analysis after limited detergent lysis provides further evidence for an oligomeric BCR structure.

Stability of the B cell antigen receptor complex

The B cell antigen receptor (BCR) comprises the membrane-bound immunoglobulin (mIg) molecule and the Ig-alpha/Ig-beta heterodimer. By comparing the stability of the IgD-BCR and IgM-BCR in different detergent lysates, we find that the IgD-BCR is more stable than the IgM-BCR. Analysis of chimeric mIgD molecules suggests that the deltam transmembrane region is responsible for the more stable association of mIgD with the Ig-alpha/Ig-beta heterodimer. Further, the differential glycosylation of Ig-alpha molecules, in the two different BCR complexes, is determined solely by the ectodomains of the mIg molecules. The implications of these findings for the intracellular transport and the signalling capacity of the BCRs are discussed.

T(h)2 cytokine dependence of IgD production by normal human B cells

IgD is a minor component of serum Ig and the control of IgD secretion is virtually unknown. We measured concentrations of IgD (and IgE and IgM as controls) in culture supernatants of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from 60 normal donors as well as mononuclear cells from 10 tonsils following culture in the absence or presence of CD40 mAb and cytokines. Low levels of IgD were measured in cultures of PBMC, either unstimulated or stimulated by anti-CD40 antibodies. IL-4 and IL-10 significantly increased IgD production by CD40 mAb-stimulated cells in the majority of normal subjects studied, whereas in a limited number of individuals, spontaneous IgD production was either low or high, but with no increase upon stimulation. Spontaneous IgD production by tonsil-derived mononuclear cells was higher than by PBMC and increased after CD40 stimulation and even more in the presence of IL-10, but not IL-4. IL-2 and IFN-gamma exerted a dose-dependent inhibition on spontaneous as well as CD40- and cytokine-induced IgD production by PBMC, but not by tonsil mononuclear cells. Activation by IL-4 of CD40-stimulated purified B cells from tonsil and PBMC, and by IL-10 of tonsil B cells increased IgD production, whereas IL-2 and IFN-gamma had no detectable inhibitory effect. This suggests that accessory cells indirectly regulate IgD synthesis. IgD production induced in PBMC by IL-4 or IL-10 appeared to result from an active synthesis, and correlated with an increase in the number of IgD-containing plasma cells as demonstrated by immunofluorescence and increased expression of secreted IgD transcripts. These findings suggest that IgD production by normal peripheral blood human B cells is regulated positively by T(h)2 cytokines and negatively by T(h)1 cytokines.

Distinctive roles of Fyn and Lyn in IgD- and IgM-mediated signaling

Src family kinases Fyn and Lyn associate with the B cell antigen receptor (BCR). Accumulating data show that Lyn plays important roles in BCR-mediated signaling, while the role of Fyn remains obscure. Here we dissected the role of Fyn and Lyn in BCR signaling using B cells from fyn(-/-), lyn(-/-) and fyn/lyn double-deficient (fyn(-/-)lyn(-/-)) mice. In contrast to previous reports, fyn(-/-) B cells were slightly hyporeactive to both anti-IgM and anti-IgD-dextran. Although lyn(-/-) B cells were hyper-reactive to anti-IgM, anti-IgD-induced proliferation was impaired in lyn(-/-) B cells. Most of the other phenotypes of fyn(-/-)lyn(-/-) mice were similar to that of lyn(-/-) mice, except that proliferative responses of B cells to various stimuli, such as BCR cross-linking and lipopolysaccharide, were significantly lower in fyn(-/-)lyn(-/-) mice than in lyn(-/-) mice. Finally, immune responses to thymus-independent type 2 antigen were affected in these mutant mice. These observations suggest that Fyn and Lyn are involved in B cell functions, and play similar, but partly distinct, roles in BCR signaling.

Inhibition of B-cell receptor-antigen complex internalization by FcgammaRIIB1 signals

Membrane-expressed immunoglobulins are B-cell receptors (BCR) for specific antigens (Ag). Upon Ag engagement of the BCR, B-cells are activated to internalize Ag-BCR complexes, process Ag and subsequently present Ag-peptides loaded in class II MHC. Due to the specific nature of the BCR, the cognate interaction between T-cells expressing Ag-specific T-cell receptor and these Ag-presenting B-cells occur in a highly regulated and precise manner. Accordingly, efficient control of T-cell activation may be achieved through regulation of Ag presenting B-cells. A potent form of regulation of lymphocyte responses is mediated by Ig end-product and anti-idiotypic antibodies via Fc-dependent mechanisms. In this communication, the authors present data that an anti-idiotype (anti-Id) Ab inhibits BCR-mediated internalization of specific Ag. Coupling of BCR to the cytoskeleton was also abortive in anti-Id Ab-treated B-cells. Inhibition by anti-Id Ab was dependent upon the presence of FcgammaRIIB1 on B-cells. As a result of anti-Id Ab suppression, B-cells were unable to initiate Ca2+ responses in Ag-specific T-cells. The results suggest that co-crosslinking of FcgammaRIIB1 and BCR inhibits cytoskeletal coupling and internalization of the Ag-BCR complex thereby preventing specific Ag presentation by B-cells. Anti-Id Ab may mediate a negative regulatory mechanism that suppresses B-cell-mediated Ag-specific T-cell activation.

Differentiation and apoptosis of human germinal center B-lymphocytes

An in vitro experimental model was developed to characterize the cellular and molecular factors that regulate germinal center (GC)-B-cell differentiation and apoptosis. In the culture system that sustains the GC-B-cell survival, CD40L stimulation is essential for GC-B-cell proliferation and differentiation in the presence of 1L-2, IL-4, and IL-10. IL-2 and Il-4 promote proliferation of GC-B-cells, whereas IL-10 is required for generation of plasma cells. Generation of memory B cells requires CD40L, IL-2, IL-4, but not IL-10. There are two mechanisms that cause apoptosis. In the early stage, spontaneous apoptosis occurs in the absence of CD40 stimulation. Following CD40L stimulation, Fas-mediated apoptosis operates to eliminate GC-B-cells, unless activated GC-B-cells encounter a second signal via B-cell Ig receptors. Physiological significance of these findings is discussed.

The two membrane isoforms of human IgE assemble into functionally distinct B cell antigen receptors

The human C epsilon gene expresses two membrane IgE heavy chain mRNAs which differ in the sequence that encodes their extracellular membrane-proximal domain. In the long IgE isoform (mLIgE), this domain contains a stretch of 52 amino acids which are absent in the short variant (mSIgE). We have now generated B cell transfectoma cell lines that express these two isoforms and show that both types of mIgE form functional B cell antigen receptors (BCR). Both receptors associate with the Ig-alpha/Ig-beta heterodimer, as well as with protein kinases that are capable of phosphorylating this complex. Upon their cross-linking, both receptors can activate protein tyrosine kinases that phosphorylate the same substrate proteins. Both IgE receptors also associate with two novel proteins that do not bind to mIgM. Apart from these similarities, the two IgE-BCRs show several differences of which some are analogous to the differences between the IgM- and IgD-BCRs. First, the mSIgE is transported to the cell surface at a higher rate than the mLIgE. Second, the two IgE-BCRs associate with differently glycosylated Ig-alpha proteins, the mLIgE associates with the completely glycosylated form, whereas the mSIgE associates with an Ig-alpha glycoform that is partially sensitive to endoglycosidase H. Third, the kinetics of protein tyrosine phosphorylation induced by receptor cross-linking is significantly different for the two IgE-BCRs. Finally, cross-linking of the mSIgE-BCR leads to growth inhibition of the B cell transfectoma, whereas signaling through the mLIgE-BCR does not affect the cellular proliferation. These data show that the two human membrane IgE isoforms assemble into functionally distinct antigen receptors which can induce different cellular responses.

Signal transduction: specificity of growth factors explained by parallel distributed processing

Mutations in proteins of receptor tyrosine kinase signalling pathways might change signalling properties and contribute to the progression towards neoplasia. Ligands for these receptors (growth factors) which elicit the same signal transducing cascades can trigger different developmental pathways in identical cells. For example, PC12 cells differentiate after treatment with NGF, but proliferate after stimulation with EGF. However, their receptors seem to utilize the same signal transducing components. Thus, intracellular signalling specificity remains an enigma. Here, we apply a network model, in which each protein species participating in signal transduction is represented by an element. The elements are connected to each other according to the signalling pathways resembling parallel distributed processes. A general property of these systems is applied to the problem of signal specificity: slight differences in the input may result in completely different outputs, which negates the necessity of specific proteins to each pathway. This line of thinking might explain the specificity of hormones, although they use the same signal transduction network.

Evidence for a preformed transducer complex organized by the B cell antigen receptor

The B cell antigen receptor (BCR) consists of the membrane-bound immunoglobulin (mIg) molecule and the Ig-alpha/Ig-beta heterodimer, which functions as signaling subunit of the receptor. Stimulation of the BCR activates protein tyrosine kinases (PTKs) that phosphorylate a number of substrate proteins, including the Ig-alpha/Ig-beta heterodimer of the BCR itself. How the PTKs become activated after BCR engagement is not known at present. Here, we show that BCR-negative J558L cells treated with the protein tyrosine phosphatase inhibitor pervanadate/H2O2 display only a weak substrate phosphorylation. However, in BCR-positive transfectants of J558L, treatment with pervanadate/H2O2 induces a strong phosphorylation of several substrate proteins. Treatment with pervanadate/H2O2 does not result in receptor crosslinking, yet the pattern of protein phosphorylation is similar to that observed after BCR stimulation by antigen. The response requires cellular integrity because tyrosine phosphorylation of most substrates is not visible in cell lysates. Cells that express a BCR containing an Ig-alpha subunit with a mutated immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif display a delayed response. The data suggest that, once expressed on the surface, the BCR organizes protein tyrosine phosphatases, PTKs, and their substrates into a transducer complex that can be activated by pervanadate/H202 in the absence of BCR crosslinking. Assembly of this preformed complex seems to be a prerequisite for BCR-mediated signal transduction.

The specificity of association of the IgD molecule with the accessory proteins BAP31/BAP29 lies in the IgD transmembrane sequence

Mature B cells co-express on their cell surface two classes of antigen receptor, the IgM and IgD immunoglobulins. The structural and functional differences between the two receptor classes are poorly understood. Recently two proteins of 29 and 31 kDa (BAP29 and BAP31) have been described that are preferentially associated with membrane IgD but only weakly with membrane IgM. We describe here the cloning of full-length murine and human BAP31 cDNAs encoding proteins of 245 and 246 amino acids respectively. The two BAP31 proteins are 95% identical. The BAP31 gene is ubiquitously expressed in murine tissues and is located on the X chromosome in both mouse and man. The murine BAP31 protein has 43% sequence identity to murine BAP29. Both proteins have a hydrophobic N-terminus and an alpha-helical C-terminus which ends with a KKXX motif implicated in vesicular transport. By a mutational analysis we have identified amino acids in the transmembrane sequence of the delta m chain that are critical for binding to BAP31/BAP29. A structural model of the BAPs and their potential functions are discussed.

CD45-null transgenic mice reveal a positive regulatory role for CD45 in early thymocyte development, in the selection of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, and B cell maturation

The CD45 transmembrane glycoprotein has been shown to be a protein phosphotyrosine phosphatase and to be important in signal transduction in T and B lymphocytes. We have employed gene targeting to create a strain of transgenic mice that completely lacks expression of all isoforms of CD45. The spleens from CD45-null mice contain approximately twice the number of B cells and one fifth the number of T cells found in normal controls. The increase in B cell numbers is due to the specific expansion of two B cell subpopulations that express high levels of immunoglobulin (IgM) staining. T cell development is significantly inhibited in CD45-null animals at two distinct stages. The efficiency of the development of CD4-CD8- thymocytes into CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes is reduced by twofold, subsequently the frequency of successful maturation of the double positive population into mature, single positive thymocytes is reduced by a further four- to fivefold. In addition, we demonstrate that CD45-null thymocytes are severely impaired in their apoptotic response to cross-linking signals via T cell receptor (TCR) in fetal thymic organ culture. In contrast, apoptosis can be induced normally in CD45-null thymocytes by non-TCR-mediated signals. Since both positive and negative selection require signals through the TCR complex, these findings suggest that CD45 is an important regulator of signal transduction via the TCR complex at multiple stages of T cell development. CD45 is absolutely required for the transmission of mitogenic signals via IgM and IgD. By contrast, CD45-null B cells proliferate as well as wild-type cells to CD40-mediated signals. The proliferation of B cells in response to CD38 cross-linking is significantly reduced but not abolished by the CD45-null mutation. We conclude that CD45 is not required at any stage during the generation of mature peripheral B cells, however its loss reveals a previously unrecognized role for CD45 in the regulation of certain subpopulations of B cells.

Non-tolerant B cells cause autoimmunity in anti-CD8 IgG2a-transgenic mice

Using a pair of gamma 2a/chi immunoglobulin genes, transgenic mice were generated to study tolerance induction in B cells that express IgG2a autoantibodies. The transgenic IgG2a specifically binds CD8 alpha chains of the CD8.2 allotype expressed on the surface of CD8+ T cells, but not CD8 molecules expressed by the CD8.1 allele. Thus, IgG2a transgenic mice expressing the CD8.1 allele were used as controls to monitor B cell development and mice expressing CD8.2 were used to study B cell tolerance. Both types of mice showed transgenic gamma 2a expression on the surface of B cells. Expression of endogenous heavy chain alleles was strongly inhibited in immature B cell subsets, whereas mature B cells co-expressed transgenic gamma 2a and endogenous IgM/D. The transgenic chi chain expression leads only to partial allelic exclusion of endogenous light chains. B cells that express high levels of transgenic CD8.2-specific IgG2a were identified using soluble CD8-Ig. In CD8.1+ and in CD8.2+ mice, we found no differences in expression and maturation of transgenic anti-CD8.2 IgG2a+ B cells. High levels of serum anti-CD8.2 IgG2a antibodies led to the elimination of CD8+ T cells, causing a severe defect in cytotoxic immune responses. These results show that tolerance induction is incomplete in the CD8.2+ mice, either because IgG2a+ B cells are resistant to censoring mechanisms or because the secreted CD8-specific IgG2a antibodies render the CD8 autoantigen inaccessible to the B cells. This contrasts strongly with the efficient induction of B cell tolerance in mice expressing anti-CD8.2 IgM autoantibodies.

Positive and negative selection events during B lymphopoiesis

Early in B-cell development, large numbers of cells have to be generated, each of which expresses only one type of B-cell receptor (i.e. Ig) on its surface. This is achieved by the surface expression of a pre-B cell receptor containing a mu heavy chain/surrogate light chain which differentially provides signals for two responses of precursor B cells at this stage of development. On the one hand, it signals inhibition of further rearrangements of variable heavy chain to diverse-joining heavy chain loci to achieve allelic exclusion at the heavy-chain locus. On the other hand, it signals proliferative expansion by factors between 20 and 100. Later in B-cell development, tolerance to autoantigens must be established and maintained. Tolerance is achieved by developmental arrest and induction of secondary light-chain gene rearrangements in those IgM+ immature B cells that are reactive to autoantigens presented in the primary B-cell generating organs. Even later in development, when mature surface (s)IgM+/sIgD+ B cells encounter autoantigens presented to them in the periphery, either deletion or anergy of the autoantigen-reactive cells occurs. Anergic cells have a sIg-dependent, sIg-proximal defect in signaling and are short-lived. Anergy can be broken in vitro by polyclonal activation via ligation of CD40 in the presence of IL-4. A small part of the remaining immature B cells not reactive to autoantigens are selected to become mature, antigen-reactive sIgM+/sIgD+ B cells. Molecules which might guide such positive selection of B cells still remain to be identified.