Hypoxia tolerance in sculpins is associated with high anaerobic enzyme activity in brain but not in liver or muscle

Hypoxia-acclimation adjusts skeletal muscle anaerobic metabolism and burst swim performance in a marine fish

Red drum, Sciaenops ocellatus, are a marine teleost native to the Gulf of Mexico that routinely experiences periods of low oxygen (hypoxia). Recent work has demonstrated this species has the capacity to improve aerobic performance in hypoxia through respiratory acclimation. However, it remains unknown how hypoxia acclimation impacts anaerobic metabolism in red drum, and the consequences of exhaustive exercise and recovery. Juvenile fish were acclimated to normoxia (n = 15, DO 90.4 ± 6.42 %) or hypoxia (n = 15, DO 33.6 ± 7.2 %) for 8 days then sampled at three time points: at rest, after exercise, and after a 3 h recovery period. The resting time point was used to characterize the acclimated phenotype, while the remaining time points demonstrate how this phenotype responds to exhaustive exercise. Whole blood, red muscle, white muscle, and heart tissues were sampled for metabolites and enzyme activity. The resting phenotype was characterized by lower pHe and changes to skeletal muscle ATP. Exhaustive exercise increased muscle lactate, and decreased phosphocreatine and ATP with no effect of acclimation. Interestingly, hypoxia-acclimated fish had higher pHe and pHi than control in all exercise time points. Red muscle ATP was lower in hypoxia-acclimated fish versus control at each sample period. Moreover, acclimated fish increased lactate dehydrogenase activity in the red muscle. Hypoxia acclimation increased white muscle ATP and hexokinase activity, a glycolytic enzyme. In a gait-transition swim test, hypoxia-acclimated fish recruited anaerobic-powered burst swimming at lower speeds in normoxia compared to control fish. These data suggest that acclimation increases reliance on anaerobic metabolism, and does not benefit recovery from exhaustive exercise.

Hypoxia Tolerance of Two Killifish Species

Hypoxia tolerance in aquatic ectotherms involves a suite of behavioral and physiological responses at the organismal, tissue, and cellular levels. The current study evaluated two closely related killifish species (Fundulus heteroclitus, Fundulus majalis) to evaluate responses to acute moderate and acute severe hypoxia. Routine metabolic rate and loss of equilibrium were assessed, followed by analysis in skeletal muscle of markers of oxidative damage to proteins (2,4-DNPH), lipids (4-HNE), and DNA (8-OHdG), hypoxia signaling (HIF1α, HIF2α), cellular energy state (p-AMPK: AMPK), and protein degradation (Ubiquitin, LC3B, Calpain 2, Hsp70). Both species had a similar reduction in metabolic rate at low PO2. However, F. heteroclitus was the more hypoxia-tolerant species based on a lower PO2 at which there was loss of equilibrium, perhaps due in part to a lower oxygen demand at all oxygen tensions. Despite the differences in hypoxia tolerance between the species, skeletal muscle molecular markers were largely insensitive to hypoxia, and there were few differences in responses between the species. Thus, the metabolic depression observed at the whole animal level appears to limit perturbations in skeletal muscle in both species during the hypoxia treatments.

Sorption of PFOS onto polystyrene microplastics potentiates synergistic toxic effects during zebrafish embryogenesis and neurodevelopment

Microplastics (MPs) have become an emerging anthropogenic pollutant, and their ability to sorb contaminants potentially enhances the threats to the ecosystem. Only a few studies are available to understand the combined effects of microplastics and other pollutants. The present study investigated the sorption of perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS) onto polystyrene microplastics (PS-MPs) at varying concentrations, using molecular dynamics simulation (MDS) to preliminarily explore the adsorption behavior. The MDS results revealed negative interaction energies between PFOS and PS-MPs, underscoring PS-MPs' role as a potential adsorbent for PFOS in an aqueous solution. Thereafter, zebrafish embryos were employed to explore the toxic effects of combined exposure to PS-MPs and PFOS. Fluorescence and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) suggested PS-MP accumulation individually and in combination with PFOS on the embryonic chorion membrane. As a result, the exposed group showed increased inner pore size of the chorionic membrane and accelerated heartbeat, indicating hypoxic conditions and hindered gaseous exchange. PS-MPs aggravated the toxicity of PFOS during larval development manifested by delayed hatching rate, increased mortality, and malformation rate. Additionally, increased ROS accumulation and altered antioxidant enzymatic status were observed in all the exposed groups suggesting perturbation of the redox state. Additionally, co-exposure of zebrafish larvae to PS-MPs and PFOS resulted in an abrupt behavioral response, which decreased AChE activity and altered neurotransmitter levels. Taken together, our results emphasize that PS-MPs can act as a potential vector for PFOS, exerting synergistic toxic effects in the aquatic environment, and hence their health risks cannot be ignored.

Oxygen consumption rate during recovery from loss of equilibrium induced by warming, hypoxia, or exhaustive exercise in rainbow darter (Etheostoma caeruleum)

Animals routinely encounter environmental (e.g., high temperatures and hypoxia) as well as physiological perturbations (e.g., exercise and digestion) that may threaten homeostasis. However, comparing the relative threat or "disruptiveness" imposed by different stressors is difficult, as stressors vary in their mechanisms, effects, and timescales. We exploited the fact that several acute stressors can induce the loss of equilibrium (LOE) in fish to (i) compare the metabolic recovery profiles of three environmentally relevant stressors and (ii) test the concept that LOE could be used as a physiological calibration for the intensity of different stressors. We focused on Etheostoma caeruleum, a species that routinely copes with environmental fluctuations in temperature and oxygen and that relies on burst swimming to relocate and avoid predators, as our model. Using stop-flow (intermittent) respirometry, we tracked the oxygen consumption rate (MO2) as E. caeruleum recovered from LOE induced by hypoxia (PO2 at LOE), warming (critical thermal maximum, CTmax), or exhaustive exercise. Regardless of the stressor used, E. caeruleum recovered rapidly, returning to routine MO2 within ~3 h. Fish recovering from hypoxia and warming had similar maximum MO2, aerobic scopes, recovery time, and total excess post-hypoxia or post-warming oxygen consumption. Though exhaustive exercise induced a greater maximum MO2 and corresponding higher aerobic scope than warming or hypoxia, its recovery profile was otherwise similar to the other stressors, suggesting that "calibration" to a physiological state such as LOE may be a viable conceptual approach for investigators interested in questions related to multiple stressors, cross tolerance, and how animals cope with challenges to homeostasis.

The hypoxia response pathway in the Antarctic fish Notothenia coriiceps is functional despite a poly Q/E insertion mutation in HIF-1α

Antarctic notothenioid fishes, inhabiting the oxygen-rich Southern Ocean, possess a polyglutamine and glutamic acid (poly Q/E) insertion mutation in the master transcriptional regulator of oxygen homeostasis, hypoxia- inducible factor-1α (HIF-1α). To determine if this mutation impairs the ability of HIF-1 to regulate gene expression in response to hypoxia, we exposed Notothenia coriiceps, with a poly Q/E insertion mutation in HIF-1α that is 9 amino acids long, to hypoxia (2.3 mg L-1 O2) or normoxia (10 mg L -1 O2) for 12 h. Heart ventricles, brain, liver, and gill tissue were harvested and changes in gene expression quantified using RNA sequencing. Levels of glycogen and lactate were also quantified to determine if anaerobic metabolism increases in response to hypoxia. Exposure to hypoxia resulted in 818 unique differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in liver tissue of N. coriiceps. Many hypoxic genes were induced, including ones involved in the MAP kinase and FoxO pathways, glycolytic metabolism, and vascular remodeling. In contrast, there were fewer than 104 unique DEGs in each of the other tissues sampled. Lactate levels significantly increased in liver in response to hypoxia, indicating that anaerobic metabolism increases in response to hypoxia in this tissue. Overall, our results indicate that the hypoxia response pathway is functional in N. coriiceps despite a poly Q/E mutation in HIF-1α, and confirm that Antarctic fishes are capable of altering gene expression in response to hypoxia.

Osmo-respiratory compromise in the mosshead sculpin (Clinocottus globiceps): effects of temperature, hypoxia, and re-oxygenation on rates of diffusive water flux and oxygen uptake

In nature, mosshead sculpins (Clinocottus globiceps) are challenged by fluctuations in temperature and oxygen levels in their environment. However, it is unclear how mosshead sculpins modulate the permeability of their branchial epithelia to water and O2 in response to temperature or hypoxia stress. Acute decrease in temperature from 13 to 6 oC reduced diffusive water flux rate by 22% and ṀO2 by 51%, whereas acute increase in temperature from 13 to 25 oC increased diffusive water flux rate by 217% and ṀO2 by 140%, yielding overall Q10 values of 2.08 and 2.47 respectively. Acute reductions in oxygen tension from >95% to 20% or 10% air saturation did not impact diffusive water flux rates, however, ṀO2 was reduced significantly by 36% and 65% respectively. During 1-h or 3-h recovery periods diffusive water flux rates were depressed while ṀO2 exhibited overshoots beyond the normoxic control level. Many responses differed from those seen in our parallel earlier study on the tidepool sculpin, a cottid with similar hypoxia tolerance but much smaller gill area that occupies a similar environment. Overall, our data suggest that during temperature stress, diffusive water flux rates and ṀO2 follow the traditional osmo-respiratory compromise pattern, but during hypoxia and re-oxygenation stress, diffusive water flux rates are decoupled from ṀO2.

Metabolic resilience of the Australasian snapper (Chrysophrys auratus) to marine heatwaves and hypoxia

Marine organisms are under threat from a simultaneous combination of climate change stressors, including warming sea surface temperatures (SST), marine heatwave (MHW) episodes, and hypoxic events. This study sought to investigate the impacts of these stressors on the Australasian snapper (C. auratus) - a finfish species of high commercial and recreational importance, from the largest snapper fishery in Aotearoa New Zealand (SNA1). A MHW scenario was simulated from 21°C (current February SST average for north-eastern New Zealand) to a future predicted level of 25°C, with the whole-animal and mitochondrial metabolic performance of snapper in response to hypoxia and elevated temperature tested after 1-, 10-, and 30-days of thermal challenge. It was hypothesised that key indicators of snapper metabolic performance would decline after 1-day of MHW stress, but that partial recovery might arise as result of thermal plasticity after chronic (e.g., 30-day) exposures. In contrast to this hypothesis, snapper performance remained high throughout the MHW: 1) Aerobic metabolic scope increased after 1-day of 25°C exposure and remained high. 2) Hypoxia tolerance, measured as the critical O₂ pressure and O₂ pressure where loss of equilibrium occurred, declined after 1-day of warm-acclimation, but recovered quickly with no observable difference from the 21°C control following 30-days at 25°C. 3) The performance of snapper mitochondria was also maintained, with oxidative phosphorylation respiration and proton leak flux across the inner mitochondrial membrane of the heart remaining mostly unaffected. Collectively, the results suggest that heart mitochondria displayed resilience, or plasticity, in snapper chronically exposed to 25°C. Therefore, contrary to the notion of climate change having adverse metabolic effects, future temperatures approaching 25°C may be tolerated by C. auratus in Northern New Zealand. Even in conjunction with supplementary hypoxia, 25°C appears to represent a metabolically optimal temperature for this species.

Functional exploration of SNP mutations in HIF2αb gene correlated with hypoxia tolerance in blunt snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala)

Blunt snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala) is sensitive to hypoxia environment. Hypoxia-inducible factor (HIF) is the most critical factor in the HIF pathway, which strictly regulates the hypoxia stress process of fish. In this study, we found six hifα genes in blunt snout bream that demonstrated different expressions under hypoxia conditions. In HEK293T cells, all six hifαs were detected to activate the HRE region by luciferase reporter assay. More importantly, we identified two linkage-disequilibrium SNP sites at exon 203 and 752 of the hif2αb gene in blunt snout bream. Haplotype II (A²⁰³A⁷⁵²) and its homozygous diplotype II (A²⁰³A²⁰³A⁷⁵²A⁷⁵²) appeared frequently in a selected strain of blunt snout bream with hypoxia tolerance. Diplotype II has a lower oxygen tension threshold for loss of equilibrium (LOE_crit) over a similar range of temperatures. Moreover, its erythrocyte number increased significantly (p < 0.05) than those in diplotype I and diplotype III strains at 48 h of hypoxia. The enzymes related with hypoxia tolerant traits, i.e., reduced glutathione, superoxide dismutase, and catalase, were also significantly (p < 0.05) induced in diplotype II than in diplotype I or III. In addition, the expression of epo in the liver of diplotype II was significantly (p < 0.01) higher than that in the diplotype I or III strains at 48 h of hypoxia. Taken together, our results found that the hypoxia-tolerant-related diplotype II of hif2αb has the potential to be used as a molecular marker in future genetic breeding of hypoxia-tolerant strain.

Effect of acute hypoxia on the brain energy metabolism of the scorpionfish Scorpaena porcus Linnaeus, 1758: the pattern of oxidoreductase activity and adenylate system

The activity of oxidoreductases, malate dehydrogenase and lactate dehydrogenase (MDH, 1.1.1.37; LDH, 1.1.1.27), as well as parameters of adenylate system-[ATP], [ADP], [AMP], total adenylate pool (AP), and adenylate energy charge (AEC) in medulla oblongata (MB) and forebrain, midbrain, and diencephalon (FDMB)-were studied in the scorpionfish under acute hypoxia (0.9-1.2 mg O₂·L^-1, 90 min). A higher MDH activity level was observed in MB and FDMB, as compared to LDH (p < 0.05). At the same time, MB showed a higher adenylate content and increased AP (p < 0.05). AEC did not exceed ~ 0.7 (vs. the maximum of this index ~ 0.9-1.0) in the brain of the scorpionfish indicating adaptation of the tissue energy status to hypoxia. A rapid decrease in MDH activity (p < 0.05) was observed in MB under acute hypoxia. These changes were accompanied by insignificant LDH activation. A pronounced LDH activation (p < 0.05), a decrease in MDH activity, and the highest AP raise (p < 0.05) were observed in FDMB, suggesting activation of glycolysis and simultaneous decrease in the rate of ATP consumption. MB and FDMB demonstrated the ability to a relative retention of AEC during hypoxia. The unidirectional metabolic adaptation was based on the intensification of glycolysis, a decrease of ATP consumption, and a subsequent increase in adenylate concentration that allowed the scorpionfish brain structures to maintain the energy status under acute hypoxia.

Physiological and behavioural strategies of aquatic animals living in fluctuating environments

Shallow or near-shore environments, such as ponds, estuaries and intertidal zones, are among the most physiologically challenging of all aquatic settings. Animals inhabiting these environments experience conditions that fluctuate markedly over relatively short temporal and spatial scales. Living in these habitats requires the ability to tolerate the physiological disturbances incurred by these environmental fluctuations. This tolerance is achieved through a suite of physiological and behavioural responses that allow animals to maintain homeostasis, including the ability to dynamically modulate their physiology through reversible phenotypic plasticity. However, maintaining the plasticity to adjust to some stresses in a dynamic environment may trade off with the capacity to deal with other stressors. This paper will explore studies on select fishes and invertebrates exposed to fluctuations in dissolved oxygen, salinity and pH. We assess the physiological mechanisms these species employ to achieve homeostasis, with a focus on the plasticity of their responses, and consider the resulting physiological trade-offs in function. Finally, we discuss additional factors that may influence organismal responses to fluctuating environments, such as the presence of multiple stressors, including parasites. We echo recent calls from experimental biologists to consider physiological responses to life in naturally fluctuating environments, not only because they are interesting in their own right but also because they can reveal mechanisms that may be crucial for living with increasing environmental instability as a consequence of climate change.

The transcriptomic responses of blunt snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala) to acute hypoxia stress alone, and in combination with bortezomib

BACKGROUND

Blunt snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala) is sensitive to hypoxia. A new blunt snout bream strain, "Pujiang No.2", was developed to overcome this shortcoming. As a proteasome inhibitor, bortezomib (PS-341) has been shown to affect the adaptation of cells to a hypoxic environment. In the present study, bortezomib was used to explore the hypoxia adaptation mechanism of "Pujiang No.2". We examined how acute hypoxia alone (hypoxia-treated, HN: 1.0 mg·L^- 1), and in combination with bortezomib (hypoxia-bortezomib-treated, HB: Use 1 mg bortezomib for 1 kg fish), impacted the hepatic ultrastructure and transcriptome expression compared to control fish (normoxia-treated, NN).

RESULTS

Hypoxia tolerance was significantly decreased in the bortezomib-treated group (LOE_crit, loss of equilibrium, 1.11 mg·L^- 1 and 1.32 mg·L^- 1) compared to the control group (LOE_crit, 0.73 mg·L^- 1 and 0.85 mg·L^- 1). The HB group had more severe liver injury than the HN group. Specifically, the activities of alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and aspartate aminotransferase (AST) in the HB group (52.16 U/gprot, 32 U/gprot) were significantly (p < 0.01) higher than those in the HN group (32.85 U/gprot, 21. 68 U/gprot). In addition, more severe liver damage such as vacuoles, nuclear atrophy, and nuclear lysis were observed in the HB group. RNA-seq was performed on livers from the HN, HB and NN groups. KEGG pathway analysis disclosed that many DEGs (differently expressed genes) were enriched in the HIF-1, FOXO, MAPK, PI3K-Akt and AMPK signaling pathway and their downstream.

CONCLUSION

We explored the adaptation mechanism of "Pujiang No.2" to hypoxia stress by using bortezomib, and combined with transcriptome analysis, accurately captured the genes related to hypoxia tolerance advantage.

Identification of Candidate Genes Associated With Hypoxia Tolerance in Trachinotus blochii Using Bulked Segregant Analysis and RNA-Seq

Golden Pompano (Trachinotus blochii) has rapidly developed into the one of the main valuable fish species in Chinese marine aquaculture. Due to its rapid growth, active metabolism, and high oxygen consumption, hypoxia will increase its mortality and cause serious economic losses. We constructed two experimental groups of fish with different degrees of tolerance to hypoxia, used BSR-Seq analysis based on genome and genetic linkage groups to locate SNPs and genes that were related to the differences in hypoxia tolerance. The results showed that hypoxia tolerance SNPs of golden pompano may be jointly determined by multiple linkage groups, especially linkage groups 18 and 22. There were 768 and 348 candidate genes located in the candidate regions of the brain and liver, respectively. These genes were mainly involved in anaerobic energy metabolism, stress response, immune response, waste discharge, and cell death. The prostaglandin-endoperoxide synthase 2 (PTGS2) on LG8, which is involved in the metabolism of arachidonic acid, has a G/A nonsynonymous mutation at position 20641628, and the encoded amino acid was changed from hydrophobic aspartic acid to asparaginate. The specific pathway of the RIG-I-like receptor signaling pathway in the liver may mediate the metabolic system and the immune system, linking glucose metabolism with immune regulation. The death of the hypoxia-intolerant group may be due to the accumulation of lactic acid caused by the activation of anaerobic glycolysis during the early stage of hypoxia stress, and the activation of type I interferon was inhibited, which resulted in decreased immunity. Among the genes involved in the RIG-I-like receptor signaling pathway, the CYLD Lysine 63 Deubiquitinase (CYLD) located on LG16 had a G/T nonsynonymous mutation at position 13629651, and the encoded amino acid was changed from alanine acid to valine. The interferon induced with helicase C domain 1 (Ifih1) located on LG18 has a G/C nonsynonymous mutation at position 16153700, and the encoded hydrophilic glycine was changed to hydrophobic alanine. Our findings suggest these SNPs may assist in the molecular breeding of hypoxia-tolerant golden pompano, and speculate that the balance of glucose and lipid metabolism plays a key role in Trachinotus blochii under acute hypoxia.

The hypoxia adaptation of small mammals to plateau and underground burrow conditions

Oxygen is one of the important substances for the survival of most life systems on the earth, and plateau and underground burrow systems are two typical hypoxic environments. Small mammals living in hypoxic environments have evolved different adaptation strategies, which include increased oxygen delivery, metabolic regulation of physiological responses and other physiological responses that change tissue oxygen utilization. Multi-omics predictions have also shown that these animals have evolved different adaptations to extreme environments. In particular, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and erythropoietin (EPO), which have specific functions in the control of O2 delivery, have evolved adaptively in small mammals in hypoxic environments. Naked mole-rats and blind mole-rats are typical hypoxic model animals as they have some resistance to cancer. This review primarily summarizes the main living environment of hypoxia tolerant small mammals, as well as the changes of phenotype, physiochemical characteristics and gene expression mode of their long-term living in hypoxia environment.

Ecological adaptations of Amazonian fishes acquired during evolution under environmental variations in dissolved oxygen: A review of responses to hypoxia in fishes, featuring the hypoxia-tolerant Astronotus spp

The Amazon Basin presents a dynamic regime of dissolved oxygen (DO) oscillations, which varies among habitats within the basin, including spatially, daily, and seasonally. Fish species inhabiting these environments have developed many physiological adaptations to deal with the frequent and periodic events of low (hypoxia), or no (anoxia) DO in the water. Cichlid fishes, especially the genus Astronotus (A. ocellatus and A. crassipinnis), are hypoxic-tolerant species that can survive in very low DO levels for long periods, while adults often inhabit places where DO is close to zero. The present review will focus on some metabolic adjustments that Amazonian fish use in response to hypoxic conditions, which include many strategies from behavioral, morphological, physiological, and biochemical strategies. These strategies include ASR (aerial surface respiration), lip expansion, branchial tissue remodeling, increases in glycolytic metabolism with the increase of blood glucose levels, and increases in anaerobic metabolism with increases of plasma lactate levels. Other groups over evolutionary time developed obligate aerial respiration with changes in pharyngeal and swim bladder vascularization as well as the development of a true lung. However, most species are water-breathing species, such as A. ocellatus and A. crassipinnis, which are detailed in this study because they are used as hypoxia-tolerant model fish. Herein, we draw together the literature data of the physiological mechanisms by which these species decrease aerobic metabolism and increase anaerobic metabolism to survive hypoxia. This is the first attempt to synthesize the physiological mechanisms of the hypoxia-tolerant Astronotus species.

Histopathological, hematological, and biochemical changes in high-latitude fish Phoxinus lagowskii exposed to hypoxia

Hypoxia is one of the most significant threats to biodiversity in aquatic systems. The ability of high-latitude fish to tolerate hypoxia with histological and physiological responses is mostly unknown. We address this knowledge gap by investigating the effects of exposures to different oxygen levels using Phoxinus lagowskii (a high-latitude, cold-water fish) as a model. Fish were exposed to different oxygen levels (0.5 mg/L and 3 mg/L) for 24 h. The loss of equilibrium (LOE), an indicator of acute hypoxia tolerance, was 0.21 ± 0.01 mg/L, revealing the ability of fish to tolerate low-oxygen conditions. We sought to determine if, in P. lagowskii, the histology of gills and liver, blood indicators, enzyme activities of carbohydrate and lipid metabolism, and antioxidants changed to relieve stress in response to acute hypoxia. Notably, changes in vigorous jumping behavior under low oxygen revealed the exceptional hypoxia acclimation response compared with other low-latitude fish. A decrease in blood parameters, including RBC, WBC, and Hb, as well as an increase in MCV was observed compared to the controls. The increased total area in lamella and decreased ILCM volume in P. lagowskii gills were detected in the present study. Our results also showed the size of vacuoles in the livers of the hypoxic fish shrunk. Interestingly, an increase in the enzyme activity of lipid metabolism but not glucose metabolism was observed in the groups exposed to hypoxia at 6 h and 24 h. After combining histology and physiology results, our findings provide evidence that lipid metabolism plays a crucial role in enhancing hypoxia acclimation in P. lagowskii. Additionally, SOD activity significantly increased during hypoxia, suggesting the presence of an antioxidant response of P. lagowskii during hypoxia. High expression levels of lipogenesis and lipolysis-related genes were detected in the 6 h 3 mg/L and 24 h 3 mg/L hypoxia group. Enhanced expression of lipid-metabolism genes (ALS4, PGC-1, and FASN) was detected during hypoxia exposure. Together, these data suggest that P. lagowskii's ability to tolerate hypoxic events is likely mediated by a comprehensive strategy.

Individual variation in metabolic rate, locomotion capacity and hypoxia tolerance and their relationships in juveniles of three freshwater fish species

Individual variations in metabolic rate, locomotion capacity and hypoxia tolerance and their relationships were investigated in three cyprinid species [crucian carp (Carassius auratus), common carp (Cyprinus carpio) and qingbo (Spinibarbus sinensis), in 60 individuals of each species]. Either the active metabolic rate (AMR) and critical swimming speed (U_crit) (30 individuals) or critical oxygen tension (P_crit) and loss of equilibrium (LOE) (30 individuals) were measured in each species after measuring the resting metabolic rate (RMR). Both the AMR and U_crit were found to be significantly and positively correlated with the RMR in all three cyprinid species, indicating that high-RMR individuals have high aerobic capacity and thus good swimming performance. P_crit was positively correlated with the RMR in all three species, whereas the LOE was highly positively correlated, weakly positively correlated and not correlated with the RMR in qingbo, common carp and crucian carp, respectively, possibly due to specialized morphological and biochemical adaptations involved in hypoxia tolerance in crucian and common carp. Crucian carp showed relatively poor swimming performance, i.e., a low U_crit (relatively high variation), strong hypoxia tolerance, and low LOE (relatively low variation); qingbo showed relatively good swimming performance (relatively low variation) and weak hypoxia tolerance (relatively high variation); and common carp showed moderate swimming performance and relatively strong hypoxia tolerance (moderate variation). These interspecific differences may be due to the different lifestyles of these cyprinid fishes based on their associated fast-slow-flow regime and are outcomes of long-term selection.

The effects of temperature on oil-induced respiratory impairment in red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus)

The 2010 Deepwater Horizon (DWH) crude oil spill, among the largest environmental disasters in U.S. history, affected numerous economically important fishes. Exposure to crude oil can lead to reduced cardiac function, limiting oxygen transport, ATP production, and aerobic performance. However, crude oil exposure is not the only stressor that affects aerobic performance, and increasing environmental temperatures are known to significantly increase metabolic demands in fishes. As the DWH spill was active during warm summer months in the Gulf of Mexico, it is important to understand the combined effects of oil and temperature on a suite of metabolic parameters. Therefore, we investigated the effects of 24h crude oil exposure on the aerobic metabolism and hypoxia tolerance of red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus) following 3 week chronic exposure to four ecologically relevant temperatures (18 °C, 22 °C, 25 °C, 28 °C). Our results show that individuals acclimated to higher temperatures had significantly higher standard metabolic rate than individuals at lower temperatures, which resulted in significantly decreased critical oxygen threshold and reduced recovery from exercise. As predicted, crude oil exposure resulted in lower maximum metabolic rates (MMR) across the temperature range, and a significantly reduced ability to recover from exercise. The lowest temperature acclimation showed the smallest effect of oil on MMR, while the highest temperature showed the smallest effect on exercise recovery. Reduced respiratory performance and hypoxia tolerance are likely to have meaningful impacts on the fitness of red drum, especially with climate-induced temperature increases and continued oil exploration in the Gulf of Mexico.

Cardiorespiratory adjustments to chronic environmental warming improve hypoxia tolerance in European perch (Perca fluviatilis)

Aquatic hypoxia will become increasingly prevalent in the future as a result of eutrophication combined with climate warming. While short-term warming typically constrains fish hypoxia tolerance, many fishes cope with warming by adjusting physiological traits through thermal acclimation. Yet, little is known about how such adjustments affect tolerance to hypoxia. We examined European perch (Perca fluviatilis) from the Biotest enclosure (23°C, Biotest population), a unique ∼1 km² ecosystem artificially warmed by cooling water from a nuclear power plant, and an adjacent reference site (16-18°C, reference population). Specifically, we evaluated how acute and chronic warming affect routine oxygen consumption rate (Ṁ _O2,routine) and cardiovascular performance in acute hypoxia, alongside assessment of the thermal acclimation of the aerobic contribution to hypoxia tolerance (critical O₂ tension for Ṁ _O2,routine: P _crit) and absolute hypoxia tolerance (O₂ tension at loss of equilibrium; P _LOE). Chronic adjustments (possibly across lifetime or generations) alleviated energetic costs of warming in Biotest perch by depressing Ṁ _O2,routine and cardiac output, and by increasing blood O₂ carrying capacity relative to reference perch acutely warmed to 23°C. These adjustments were associated with improved maintenance of cardiovascular function and Ṁ _O2,routine in hypoxia (i.e. reduced P _crit). However, while P _crit was only partially thermally compensated in Biotest perch, they had superior absolute hypoxia tolerance (i.e. lowest P _LOE) relative to reference perch irrespective of temperature. We show that European perch can thermally adjust physiological traits to safeguard and even improve hypoxia tolerance during chronic environmental warming. This points to cautious optimism that eurythermal fish species may be resilient to the imposition of impaired hypoxia tolerance with climate warming.

Interactive effects of temperature and hypoxia on diffusive water flux and oxygen uptake rate in the tidepool sculpin, Oligocottus maculosus

The osmorespiratory compromise hypothesis posits that respiratory epithelial characteristics and physiological regulatory mechanisms which promote gas permeability also increase permeability to ions and water. The hypothesis therefore predicts that physiological responses which increase effective gas permeability will result in increased effective ion and water permeabilities. Though analyses of water and gas effective permeabilities using high temperature have generally supported the hypothesis, water permeability responses to hypoxia remain equivocal and the combination of high temperature and hypoxia untested. We measured diffusive water flux (DWF) and oxygen uptake rate (Ṁo₂) in response to acute temperature change, hypoxia, and the combination of high temperature and hypoxia in a hypoxia-tolerant intertidal fish, the tidepool sculpin (Oligocottus maculosus). In support of the osmorespiratory compromise hypothesis, Ṁo₂ and DWF increased with temperature. In contrast, DWF decreased with hypoxia at a constant temperature, a result consistent with previously observed decoupling of water and gas effective permeabilities during hypoxia exposure in some hypoxia tolerant fishes. However, DWF levels during simultaneous high temperature and hypoxia exposure were not different from fish exposed to high temperature in normoxia, possibly suggesting a failure of the mechanism responsible for down-regulating DWF in hypoxia. These results, together with time-course analysis of hypoxia exposure and normoxic recovery, suggest that tidepool sculpins actively downregulate effective water permeability in hypoxia but the mechanism fails with multi-stressor exposure. Future investigations of the mechanistic basis of the regulation of gill permeability will be key to understanding the role of this regulatory ability in the persistence of this species in the dynamic intertidal environment.

Transcriptome analysis of liver provides insight into metabolic and translation changes under hypoxia and reoxygenation stress in silver sillago (Sillago sihama)

Hypoxia can lead to adverse effects on growth, reproduction, behavioral activities and survival in fish, and is one of the most critical factors in the aquatic environment. The liver is an important target organ for reducing toxin accumulation and hypoxia in fish. In this study, silver sillago (Sillago sihama) was exposed to normoxia (dissolved oxygen, DO = 8.0 mg/L), hypoxia for 1 h (hypoxia 1 h, DO = 1.5 mg/L), hypoxia for 4 h (hypoxia 4 h, DO = 1.5 mg/L) and reoxygenation for 4 h after hypoxia 4 h (reoxygenation 4 h, DO = 8.0 mg/L). Results showed that the expression of 506, 1721, and 1230 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) (|log₂₍fold change) > 1.0| and padj < 0.05) were identified at hypoxia 1 h, hypoxia 4 h, and reoxygenation 4 h in the liver, respectively. The enrichment analysis showed that the DEGs were significantly enriched in metabolic and translation changes pathways, including mapk signaling pathway, p53 signaling pathway, fatty acid metabolism, protein export, ribosome biogenesis in eukaryotes. The DEGs of 17 genes validated the RNA-seq results by quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). This study provides a comprehensive understanding of the transcriptional changes that occur in different hypoxia and insights into the mechanisms of hypoxia adaptation of the liver in S. sihama.

Loss of hypoxia-inducible factor 1α affects hypoxia tolerance in larval and adult zebrafish (Danio rerio)

The coordination of the hypoxic response is attributed, in part, to hypoxia-inducible factor 1α (Hif-1α), a regulator of hypoxia-induced transcription. After the teleost-specific genome duplication, most teleost fishes lost the duplicate copy of Hif-1α, except species in the cyprinid lineage that retained both paralogues of Hif-1α (Hif1aa and Hif1ab). Little is known about the contribution of Hif-1α, and specifically of each paralogue, to hypoxia tolerance. Here, we examined hypoxia tolerance in wild-type (Hif1aa^+/+ab^+/+) and Hif-1α knockout lines (Hif1aa^-/-; Hif1ab^-/-; Hif1aa^-/-ab^-/-) of zebrafish (Danio rerio). Critical O₂ tension (P_crit; the partial pressure of oxygen (PO₂) at which O₂ consumption can no longer be maintained) and time to loss of equilibrium (LOE), two indices of hypoxia tolerance, were assessed in larvae and adults. Knockout of both paralogues significantly increased P_crit (decreased hypoxia tolerance) in larval fish. Prior exposure of larvae to hypoxia decreased P_crit in wild-type fish, an effect mediated by the Hif1aa paralogue. In adults, individuals with a knockout of either paralogue exhibited significantly decreased time to LOE but no difference in P_crit. Together, these results demonstrate that in zebrafish, tolerance to hypoxia and improved hypoxia tolerance after pre-exposure to hypoxia (pre-conditioning) are mediated, at least in part, by Hif-1α.

Acute hypoxia changes the mode of glucose and lipid utilization in the liver of the largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides)

Dissolved oxygen (DO) undountedly affects fish distribution, metabolism, and evern survival. Intensive aquaculture and environmental changes will inevitably lead to hypoxic stress for largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides). The different metabolic responses and mechanism still remains relatively unknown during acute hypoxia exposure. In this study, largemouth bass were subjected to hypoxic stress (3.0 ± 0.2 mg/L and 1.2 ± 0.2 mg/L) for 24 h and 12 h reoxygenation to systemically evaluate indicators of glucose and lipid metabolism. A regulatory network was constructed using RNA-seq to further elucidate the transcriptional regulation of glucose and lipid metabolism. During hypoxia for 4 h, the liver glycogen, glucose and pyruvic acid contents significantly decreased, whereas plasma glucose content and liver lactic acid content increased significantly. The accumulation of liver triglycerides and non-esterified fatty acids was enhanced during hypoxia for 8 h. The activity of key enzymes revealed the different metabolic responses to hypoxia exposure for 4 h, including the enhancement of glycolysis, and inhibition of gluconeogenesis. Furthermore, hypoxia exposure for 8 h increased lipid mobilization, and inhibited the β-oxidation. In addition, an integrated regulatory network of 9 major pathways involved in the response to hypoxia exposure was constructed, including HIF signaling pathway, VEGF signaling pathway, AMPK signaling pathway, insulin signaling pathway and PPAR signaling pathway; glycolysis/gluconeogenesis, pyruvate metabolism, fatty acid degradation and fatty acid biosynthesis. Additionally, reoxygenation inhibited glycolysis, and promoted gluconeogenesis and lipid oxidation, but energy deficits persisted. In short, although the mobilization and activation of fatty acid in liver were enhanced in the early stage of hypoxia, glycolysis was the main energy source under acute hypoxia. The extent and duration of hypoxia determine the degree of change in energy metabolism.

Acute high temperature exposure impairs hypoxia tolerance in an intertidal fish

Acute heat shock has previously been shown to improve subsequent low O₂ (hypoxia) tolerance in an intertidal fish species, a process known as cross-tolerance, but it is not known whether this is a widespread phenomenon. This study examined whether a rock pool specialist, the triplefin fish Bellapiscis medius, exhibits heat shock induced cross-tolerance to hypoxia, i.e., longer time to loss of equilibrium (LOE) and lower critical O₂ saturation (S_crit) after recovering from an acute heat challenge. Non-heat shock controls had a median time to loss of equilibrium (LOE₅₀) of 54.4 min under severe hypoxia (7% of air saturation) and a S_crit of 15.8% air saturation. Contrary to expectations, however, treatments that received an 8 or 10°C heat shock showed a significantly shorter LOE₅₀ in hypoxia (+8°C = 41.5 min; +10°C = 28.7 min) and no significant change in S_crit (+8°C = 17.0% air saturation; +10°C = 18.3% of air saturation). Thus, there was no evidence of heat shock induced cross-tolerance to hypoxia in B. medius because exposure to acute heat shock impaired hypoxia tolerance.

Hypoxia tolerance is unrelated to swimming metabolism of wild, juvenile striped bass (Morone saxatilis)

Juvenile striped bass residing in Chesapeake Bay are likely to encounter hypoxia that could affect their metabolism and performance. The ecological success of this economically valuable species may depend on their ability to tolerate hypoxia and perform fitness-dependent activities in hypoxic waters. We tested whether there is a link between hypoxia tolerance (HT) and oxygen consumption rate (ṀO2 ) of juvenile striped bass measured while swimming in normoxic and hypoxic water, and to identify the interindividual variation and repeatability of these measurements. HT (loss of equilibrium) of fish (N=18) was measured twice collectively, 11 weeks apart, between which ṀO2  was measured individually for each fish while swimming in low flow (10.2 cm s-1) and high flow (∼67% of critical swimming speed, Ucrit) under normoxia and hypoxia. Both HT and ṀO2  varied substantially among individuals. HT increased across 11 weeks while the rank order of individual HT was significantly repeatable. Similarly, ṀO2  increased in fish swimming at high flow in a repeatable fashion, but only within a given level of oxygenation. ṀO2  was significantly lower when fish were swimming against high flow under hypoxia. There were no clear relationships between HT and ṀO2  while fish were swimming under any conditions. Only the magnitude of increase in HT over 11 weeks and an individual's ṀO2  under low flow were correlated. The results suggest that responses to the interacting stressors of hypoxia and exercise vary among individuals, and that HT and change in HT are not simple functions of aerobic metabolic rate.

Interspecific variation in hypoxia tolerance and hypoxia acclimation responses in killifish from the family Fundulidae

Hypoxia is a pervasive stressor in aquatic environments, and both phenotypic plasticity and evolutionary adaptation could shape the ability to cope with hypoxia. We investigated evolved variation in hypoxia tolerance and the hypoxia acclimation response across fundulid killifishes that naturally experience different patterns of hypoxia exposure. We compared resting O2 consumption rate (ṀO2 ), and various indices of hypoxia tolerance [critical O2 tension (Pcrit), regulation index (RI), O2 tension (PO2 ) at loss of equilibrium (PLOE) and time to LOE (tLOE) at 0.6 kPa O2] in Fundulus confluentus, Fundulus diaphanus, Fundulus heteroclitus, Fundulus rathbuni, Lucania goodei and Lucania parva We examined the effects of chronic (28 days) exposure to constant hypoxia (2 kPa) or nocturnal intermittent hypoxia (12 h normoxia:12 h hypoxia) in a subset of species. Some species exhibited a two-breakpoint model in ṀO2  caused by early, modest declines in ṀO2  in moderate hypoxia. We found that hypoxia tolerance varied appreciably across species: F. confluentus was the most tolerant (lowest PLOE and Pcrit, longest tLOE), whereas F. rathbuni and F. diaphanus were the least tolerant. However, there was not a consistent pattern of interspecific variation for different indices of hypoxia tolerance, with or without taking phylogenetic relatedness into account, probably because these different indices are underlain by partially distinct mechanisms. Hypoxia acclimation generally improved hypoxia tolerance, but the magnitude of plasticity and responsiveness to different hypoxia patterns varied interspecifically. Our results therefore suggest that hypoxia tolerance is a complex trait that is best appreciated by considering multiple indices of tolerance.

Anti-Hypoxic Molecular Mechanisms of Rhodiola crenulata Extract in Zebrafish as Revealed by Metabonomics

The health supplement of Rhodiola crenulata (RC) is well known for its effective properties against hypoxia. However, the mechanisms of its anti-hypoxic action were still unclear. The objective of this work was to evaluate the molecular mechanisms of RC extract against hypoxia in a hypoxic zebrafish model through metabonomics and network pharmacology analysis. The hypoxic zebrafish model in the environment with low concentration (3%) of oxygen was constructed and used to explore the anti-hypoxic effects of RC extract, followed by detecting the changes of the metabolome in the brain through liquid chromatography–high resolution mass spectrometry. An in silico network for metabolite-protein interactions was further established to examine the potential mechanisms of RC extract, and the mRNA expression levels of the key nodes were validated by real-time quantitative PCR. As results, RC extract could keep zebrafish survive after 72-h hypoxia via improving lactate dehydrogenase, citrate synthase, and hypoxia-induced factor-1α in brains. One hundred and forty-two differential metabolites were screened in the metabonomics, and sphingolipid metabolism pathway was significantly regulated after RC treatment. The constructed protein-metabolites network indicated that the HIF-related signals were recovered, and the mRNA level of AMPK was elevated. In conclusion, RC extract had markedly anti-hypoxic effects in zebrafish via changing sphingolipid metabolism, HIF-related and AMPK signaling pathways.

A methodological evaluation of the determination of critical oxygen threshold in an estuarine teleost

One measure of hypoxia tolerance is the critical oxygen threshold, P_crit, which is the point where standard metabolism can no longer be maintained through aerobic processes. Traditionally, P_crit was determined using closed respirometry, whereby the fish's respiration naturally lowered O₂. More recently, intermittent flow techniques have been adopted, where N₂ is used to displace O₂, which ostensibly reduces end-product build-up. This study used a paired design on the marine teleost, red drum. P_crit is comparable between closed (4.6±0.2 kPa; mean±s.e.m.) and intermittent flow (4.4±0.2 kPa; mean±s.e.m.) respirometry. pCO₂, ammonia and pH changes within the chamber were measured prior to the onset of P_crit and at the end of a typical P_crit trial and revealed changes in water chemistry in both closed and intermittent flow. P_crit values were similar in both methods of hypoxia induction regardless of subsequent water chemistry changes that occurred in both methods.

Summary: The two leading methods of measuring the critical oxygen threshold in fishes are similar in their estimations, regardless of changes to water chemistry.

The osmorespiratory compromise: physiological responses and tolerance to hypoxia are affected by salinity acclimation in the euryhaline Atlantic killifish (Fundulus heteroclitus)

The characteristics of the fish gill that maximize gas exchange are the same that promote diffusion of ions and water to and from the environment; therefore, physiological trade-offs are likely to occur. Here, we investigated how salinity acclimation affects whole-animal respiratory gas exchange during hypoxia using Fundulus heteroclitus, a fish that inhabits salt marshes where salinity and oxygen levels vary greatly. Salinity had marked effects on hypoxia tolerance, with fish acclimated to 11 and 35 ppt showing much longer time to loss of equilibrium (LOE) in hypoxia than 0 ppt-acclimated fish. Fish acclimated to 11 ppt (isosmotic salinity) exhibited the greatest capacity to regulate oxygen consumption rate (Ṁ _O2 ) under hypoxia, as measured through the regulation index (RI) and P _crit At 35 ppt, fish had a higher routine metabolic rate (RMR) but a lower RI than fish at 11 ppt, but there were no differences in gill morphology, ventilation or blood O₂ transport properties between these groups. In contrast, 0 ppt-acclimated fish had the highest ventilation and lowest O₂ extraction efficiency in normoxia and hypoxia, indicating a higher ventilatory workload in order to maintain similar levels of Ṁ _O2 These differences were related to alterations in gill morphology, where 0 ppt-acclimated fish had the smallest lamellar surface area with the greatest epithelial cell coverage (i.e. thicker lamellae, longer diffusion distance) and a larger interlamellar cell mass, contrasting with 11 ppt-acclimated fish, which had overall the highest respiratory surface area. The alteration of an array of physiological parameters provides evidence for a compromise between salinity and hypoxia tolerance in killifish acclimated to freshwater.

Caffeine supplementation in diet mitigates Aeromonas hydrophila-induced impairment of the gill phosphotransfer network in grass carp Ctenopharyngodon idella

Some evidence suggests the involvement of phosphotransfer network in the pathogenesis of fish bacterial diseases, catalyzed by creatine kinase (CK), pyruvate kinase (PK) and adenylate kinase (AK); nevertheless, the effects on fish affected by Aeromonas hydrophila remain unknown. Recent evidence suggested a potent protective effect of caffeine on the branchial phosphotransfer network of fish subjected to challenge conditions. Therefore, the aim of this study was to evaluate whether A. hydrophila infection impaired branchial bioenergetics. We also determined whether dietary supplementation with caffeine protected against A. hydrophila-induced gill bioenergetic imbalance. We found that branchial cytosolic CK and AK activities were significant lower in fish experimentally infected with A. hydrophila than in uninfected fish, while mitochondrial CK activity was significant higher. Branchial lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) activity and lactate levels were significant higher in fish experimentally infected by A. hydrophila than in uninfected fish, while sodium-potassium ion pump (Na⁺, K⁺-ATPase) activity and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) levels were significant lower. No significant difference was observed between groups with respect to branchial PK activity. The dietary supplementation with 8% caffeine improved the branchial CK (cytosolic and mitochondrial), AK, and LDH activities, as well as ATP levels, but did not prevent increases in branchial lactate levels or the inhibition of Na⁺, K⁺-ATPase activity elicited by aeromonosis. Based on this evidence, we believe that reduction of CK (cytosolic) and AK activities contributes to impairment of bioenergetic homeostasis, while augmentation of mitochondrial CK activity can be considered an attempt to prevent or reduce the energetic imbalance during aeromonosis caused by A. hydrophila. The use of 8% caffeine dietary supplementation improved the energetic metabolism via protective effects on CK and AK activities, avoiding the necessity of using anaerobic metabolism. In summary, 8% dietary caffeine can be used to improve branchial energetic homeostasis during aeromonosis caused by A. hydrophila.

Repeatability of Hypoxia Tolerance of Individual Juvenile Striped Bass Morone saxatilis and Effects of Social Status

Chesapeake Bay is the primary nursery for striped bass (Morone saxatilis), which are increasingly being exposed to hypoxic waters. Tolerance to hypoxia in fish is generally determined by a single exposure of an isolated individual or by exposing large groups of conspecifics to hypoxia without regard to social status. The importance of social context in determining physiological responses to stressors is being increasingly recognized. To determine whether social interactions influence hypoxia tolerance (HT) in striped bass, loss of equilibrium HT was assessed in the same fish while manipulating the social environment around it. Small group settings were used to be more representative of the normal sociality experienced by this species than the paired encounters typically used. After establishing the dominance hierarchy within a group of fish, HT was determined collectively for the individuals in that group, and then new groups were constructed from the same pool of fish. Individuals could then be followed across multiple settings for both repeatability of HT and hierarchy position ( X ¯ = 4.2 ± 0.91 SD groups per individual). HT increased with repeated exposures to hypoxia ( P < 0.001 ), with a significant increase by a third exposure ( P = 0.004 ). Despite this changing HT, rank order of HT was significantly repeatable across trials for 6 mo ( P = 0.012 ). Social status was significantly repeatable across trials of different group composition ( P = 0.02 ) and unrelated to growth rate but affected HT weakly in a complex interaction with size. Final HT was significantly correlated with blood [hemoglobin] and hematocrit. The repeatability and large intraspecific variance of HT in juvenile striped bass suggest that HT is potentially an important determinant of Darwinian fitness in an increasingly hypoxic Chesapeake Bay.

Hypoxia enhances blood O2 affinity and depresses skeletal muscle O2 consumption in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Zebrafish (Danio rerio) are widely used animal models. Nevertheless, the mechanisms underlying hypoxia tolerance in this species have remained poorly understood. In the present study, we have determined the effects of hypoxia on blood-O₂ transport properties and mitochondrial respiration rate in permeabilized muscle fibres of adult zebrafish exposed to either 1) a gradual decrease in O₂ levels until fish lost equilibrium (~1 h, acute hypoxia), or 2) severe hypoxia (PO₂ ∼ 15 Torr) for 48 h (prolonged hypoxia). Acute, short-term hypoxia caused an increase in hemoglobin (Hb) O₂ affinity (decrease in P₅₀), due to a decrease in erythrocyte ATP after erythrocyte swelling. No changes in isoHb expression patterns were observed between hypoxic and normoxic treatments. Prolonged hypoxia elicited additional reponses on O₂ consumption: lactate accumulated in the blood, indicating that zebrafish relied on glycolysis for ATP production, and mitochondrial respiration of skeletal muscle was overall significantly inhibited. In addition, male zebrafish had higher hypoxia tolerance (measured as time to loss of equilibrium) than females. The present study contributes to our understanding of the adaptive mechanisms that allow zebrafish, and by inference other fish species, to cope with low O₂ levels.

Functional coupling in the evolution of suction feeding and gill ventilation of sculpins (Perciformes: Cottoidei)

Suction feeding and gill ventilation in teleosts are functionally coupled, meaning that there is an overlap in the structures involved with both functions. Functional coupling is one type of morphological integration, a term that broadly refers to any covariation, correlation, or coordination among structures. Suction feeding and gill ventilation exhibit other types of morphological integration, including functional coordination (a tendency of structures to work together to perform a function) and evolutionary integration (a tendency of structures to covary in size or shape across evolutionary history). Functional coupling, functional coordination, and evolutionary integration have each been proposed to limit morphological diversification to some extent. Yet teleosts show extraordinary cranial diversity, suggesting that there are mechanisms within some teleost clades that promote morphological diversification, even within the highly integrated suction feeding and gill ventilatory systems. To investigate this, we quantified evolutionary integration among four mechanical units associated with suction feeding and gill ventilation in a diverse clade of benthic, primarily suction-feeding fishes (Cottoidei; sculpins and relatives). We reconstructed cottoid phylogeny using molecular data from 108 species, and obtained 24 linear measurements of four mechanical units (jaws, hyoid, opercular bones, and branchiostegal rays) from micro-CT reconstructions of 44 cottoids and 1 outgroup taxon. We tested for evolutionary correlation and covariation among the four mechanical units using phylogenetically corrected principal component analysis to reduce the dimensionality of measurements for each unit, followed by correlating phylogenetically independent contrasts and computing phylogenetic generalized least squares models from the first principle component axis of each of the four mechanical units. The jaws, opercular bones, and branchiostegal rays show evolutionary integration, but the hyoid is not positively integrated with these units. To examine these results in an ecomorphological context, we used published ecological data in phylogenetic ANOVA models to demonstrate that the jaw is larger in fishes that eat elusive or grasping prey (e.g., prey that can easily escape or cling to the substrate) and that the hyoid is smaller in intertidal and hypoxia-tolerant sculpins. Within Cottoidei, the relatively independent evolution of the hyoid likely has reduced limitations on morphological evolution within the highly morphologically integrated suction feeding and gill ventilatory systems.

The fallacy of the P crit - are there more useful alternatives?

P _crit - generally defined as the P _O2  below which the animal can no longer maintain a stable rate of O₂ consumption (Ṁ _O2 ), such that Ṁ _O2  becomes dependent upon P _O2  - provides a single number into which a vast amount of experimental effort has been invested. Here, with specific reference to water-breathers, I argue that this focus on the P _crit is not useful for six reasons: (1) calculation of P _crit usually involves selective data editing; (2) the value of P _crit depends greatly on the way it is determined; (3) there is no good theoretical justification for the concept; (4) P _crit is not the transition point from aerobic to anaerobic metabolism, and it disguises what is really going on; (5) P _crit is not a reliable index of hypoxia tolerance; and (6) P _crit carries minimal information content. Preferable alternatives are loss of equilibrium (LOE) tests for hypoxia tolerance, and experimental description of full Ṁ _O2  versus P _O2  profiles accompanied by measurements of ventilation, lactate appearance and metabolic rate by calorimetry. If the goal is to assess the ability of the animal to regulate Ṁ _O2  from this profile in a mathematical fashion, promising, more informative alternatives to P _crit are the regulation index and Michaelis-Menten or sigmoidal allosteric analyses.

Variable gene transcription underlies phenotypic convergence of hypoxia tolerance in sculpins

Background

The degree by which mechanisms underlying phenotypic convergence are similar among taxa depends on the number of evolutionary paths available for selection to act upon. Likelihood of convergence will be influenced by an interplay of factors such as genetic architecture, phylogenetic history and population demography. To determine if there is convergence or divergence in mechanisms underlying phenotypic similarity, we assessed whether gene transcription patterns differed among species with similar levels of hypoxia tolerance.

Results

Three species of marine fish from the superfamily Cottoidea (smoothhead sculpin [Artedius lateralis], sailfin sculpin [Nautichthys oculofasciatus] and Pacific staghorn sculpin [Leptocottus armatus]), all of which have previously been shown to share the same level of hypoxia tolerance, were exposed to short-(8 h) and longer-term (72 h) hypoxia and mRNA transcripts were assessed using a custom microarray. We examined hypoxia-induced transcription patterns in metabolic and protein production pathways and found that a high proportion of genes associated with these biological processes showed significant differences among the species. Specifically, the data suggest that the smoothhead sculpin, unlike the sailfin sculpin and the Pacific staghorn sculpin, relied on amino acid degradation rather than glycolysis or fatty acid oxidation to generate ATP during hypoxia exposure. There was also variation across the species in the transcription of genes involved in protein production (e.g. mRNA processing and protein translation), such that it increased in the smoothhead sculpin, decreased in the sailfin sculpin and was variable in the Pacific staghorn sculpin.

Conclusions

Changes in metabolic and protein production pathways are part of the key responses of fishes to exposures to environmental hypoxia. Yet, species with similar overall hypoxia tolerance exhibited different transcriptional responses in these pathways, indicating flexibility and complexity of interactions in the evolution of the mechanisms underlying the hypoxia tolerance phenotype. The variation in the hypoxia-induced transcription of genes across species with similar hypoxia tolerance suggests that similar whole-animal phenotypes can emerge from divergent evolutionary paths that may affect metabolically important functions.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12862-018-1275-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Can variation among hypoxic environments explain why different fish species use different hypoxic survival strategies?

In aquatic environments, hypoxia is a multi-dimensional stressor that can vary in O₂ level (partial pressure of O₂ in water, Pw_O2 ), rate of induction and duration. Natural hypoxic environments can therefore be very different from one another. For the many fish species that have evolved to cope with these different hypoxic environments, survival requires adjusting energy supply and demand pathways to maintain energy balance. The literature describes innumerable ways that fishes combine aerobic metabolism, anaerobic metabolism and metabolic rate depression (MRD) to accomplish this, but it is unknown whether the evolutionary paths leading to these different strategies are determined primarily by species' phylogenetic histories, genetic constraint or their native hypoxic environments. We explored this idea by devising a four-quadrant matrix that bins different aquatic hypoxic environments according to their duration and Pw_O2  characteristics. We then systematically mined the literature for well-studied species native to environments within each quadrant, and, for each of 10 case studies, described the species' total hypoxic response (THR), defined as its hypoxia-induced combination of sustained aerobic metabolism, enhanced anaerobic metabolism and MRD, encompassing also the mechanisms underlying these metabolic modes. Our analysis revealed that fishes use a wide range of THRs, but that distantly related species from environments within the same matrix quadrant have converged on similar THRs. For example, environments of moderately hypoxic Pw_O2  favoured predominantly aerobic THRs, whereas environments of severely hypoxic Pw_O2  favoured MRD. Capacity for aerial emergence as well as predation pressure (aquatic and aerial) also contributed to these responses, in addition to other biotic and abiotic factors. Generally, it appears that the particular type of hypoxia experienced by a fish plays a major role in shaping its particular THR.

Cardiorespiratory physiological phenotypic plasticity in developing air-breathing anabantid fishes (Betta splendens and Trichopodus trichopterus)

Developmental plasticity of cardiorespiratory physiology in response to chronic hypoxia is poorly understood in larval fishes, especially larval air‐breathing fishes, which eventually in their development can at least partially “escape” hypoxia through air breathing. Whether the development air breathing makes these larval fishes less or more developmentally plastic than strictly water breathing larval fishes remains unknown. Consequently, developmental plasticity of cardiorespiratory physiology was determined in two air‐breathing anabantid fishes (Betta splendens and Trichopodus trichopterus). Larvae of both species experienced an hypoxic exposure that mimicked their natural environmental conditions, namely chronic nocturnal hypoxia (12 h at 17 kPa or 14 kPa), with a daily return to diurnal normoxia. Chronic hypoxic exposures were made from hatching through 35 days postfertilization, and opercular and heart rates measured as development progressed. Opercular and heart rates in normoxia were not affected by chronic nocturnal hypoxic. However, routine oxygen consumption M˙O2 (~4 μmol·O₂/g per hour in normoxia in larval Betta) was significantly elevated by chronic nocturnal hypoxia at 17 kPa but not by more severe (14 kPa) nocturnal hypoxia. Routine M˙O2 in Trichopodus (6–7 μmol·O₂/g per hour), significantly higher than in Betta, was unaffected by either level of chronic hypoxia. P_Crit, the PO₂ at which M˙O2 decreases as ambient PO₂ falls, was measured at 35 dpf, and decreased with increasing chronic hypoxia in Betta, indicating a large, relatively plastic hypoxic tolerance. However, in contrast, P_Crit in Trichopodus increased as rearing conditions grew more hypoxic, suggesting that hypoxic acclimation led to lowered hypoxic resistance. Species‐specific differences in larval physiological developmental plasticity thus emerge between the relatively closely related Betta and Trichopodus. Hypoxic rearing increased hypoxic tolerance in Betta, which inhabits temporary ponds with nocturnal hypoxia. Trichopodus, inhabiting more permanent oxygenated bodies of water, showed few responses to hypoxia, reflecting a lower degree of developmental phenotypic plasticity.

A rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss strain with higher aerobic scope in normoxia also has superior tolerance of hypoxia

This study compared parr from three strains of rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss to examine intraspecific variation in metabolic traits, hypoxia tolerance and upper thermal tolerance in this species. At the strain level, variation in absolute aerobic scope (AAS), critical oxygen level (O_2crit ), incipient lethal oxygen saturation (ILOS) and critical thermal maximum (CT_max ) generally exhibited consistent differences among the strains, suggesting the possibility of functional associations among these traits. This possibility was further supported at the individual level by a positive correlation between ILOS and O_2crit and a negative correlation between O_2crit and AAS. These results indicate that intraspecific differences in hypoxia tolerance among strains of O. mykiss may be primarily determined by differences in the ability to maintain oxygen uptake in hypoxia and that variation in aerobic scope in normoxia probably plays a role in determining the ability of these fish to sustain metabolism aerobically as water oxygen saturation is reduced.

Interspecific variation in brain mitochondrial complex I and II capacity and ROS emission in marine sculpins

Environmental hypoxia presents a metabolic challenge for animals because it inhibits mitochondrial respiration and can lead to the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). We investigated the interplay between O2 use for aerobic respiration and ROS generation among sculpin fishes (Cottidae, Actinopterygii) that are known to vary in whole-animal hypoxia tolerance. We hypothesized that mitochondria from hypoxia tolerant sculpins would show more efficient O2 use with a higher phosphorylation efficiency and lower ROS emission. We showed that brain mitochondria from more hypoxia tolerant sculpins had lower complex I and higher complex II flux capacities compared with less hypoxia tolerant sculpins, but these differences were not related to variation in phosphorylation efficiency (ADP/O) or mitochondrial coupling (respiratory control ratio). The hypoxia tolerant sculpin had higher mitochondrial H2O2 emission per O2 consumed (H2O2/O2) under oligomycin-induced state 4 conditions compared to less hypoxia tolerant sculpin. An in vitro redox challenge experiment revealed species differences in how well mitochondria defend their glutathione redox status when challenged with high levels of reduced glutathione, but the redox challenge elicited the same H2O2/O2 in all species. Furthermore, in vitro anoxia-recovery lowered absolute H2O2 emission (H2O2/mg mitochondrial protein) in all species and negatively impacted state 3 respiration rates in some species, but the responses were not related to hypoxia tolerance. Overall, we clearly demonstrate a relationship between hypoxia tolerance and complex I and II flux capacities in sculpins, but the differences in complex flux capacity do not appear to be directly related to variation in ROS metabolism.

Evolution of Cytochrome c Oxidase in Hypoxia Tolerant Sculpins (Cottidae, Actinopterygii)

Vertebrate hypoxia tolerance can emerge from modifications to the oxygen (O2) transport cascade, but whether there is adaptive variation to O2 binding at the terminus of this cascade, mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase (COX), is not known. In order to address the hypothesis that hypoxia tolerance is associated with enhanced O2 binding by mitochondria we undertook a comparative analysis of COX O2 kinetics across species of intertidal sculpins (Cottidae, Actinopterygii) that vary in hypoxia tolerance. Our analysis revealed a significant relationship between hypoxia tolerance (critical O2 tension of O2 consumption rate; Pcrit), mitochondrial O2 binding affinity (O2 tension at which mitochondrial respiration was half maximal; P50), and COX O2-binding affinity (apparent Michaelis-Menten constant for O2 binding to COX; Km,app O2). The more hypoxia tolerant species had both a lower mitochondrial P50 and lower COX Km,app O2, facilitating the maintenance of mitochondrial function to a lower O2 tension than in hypoxia intolerant species. Additionally, hypoxia tolerant species had a lower overall COX Vmax but higher mitochondrial COX respiration rate when expressed relative to maximal electron transport system respiration rate. In silico analyses of the COX3 subunit postulated as the entry point for O2 into the COX protein catalytic core, points to variation in COX3 protein stability (estimated as free energy of unfolding) contributing to the variation in COX Km,app O2. We propose that interactions between COX3 and cardiolipin at four amino acid positions along the same alpha-helix forming the COX3 v-cleft represent likely determinants of interspecific differences in COX Km,app O2.

Transcriptome comparison reveals insights into muscle response to hypoxia in blunt snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala)

The economic and biological significance of blunt snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala) makes this species important to explore the underlying molecular mechanism of hypoxia response. In the present study, we compared the transcriptional responses to serious hypoxia in skeletal muscle among hypoxia tolerant (MT), sensitive (MS) and control (without hypoxia treatment, MC) M. amblycephala obtained according to the time difference of losing balance after hypoxia treatment. A total of 88,200,889 clean reads were generated and assembled into 44,493 unigenes. Transcriptomic comparison revealed 463 genes differentially expressed among different groups. A similar hypoxia-induced transcription patterns suggested a common hypoxia response involved in cell cycle, p53 signaling pathway, apoptosis, heart contraction and blood circulation. Interesting, four genes, heat shock protein beta-8 (hspb8), cysteine/serine-rich nuclear protein 1 (csrnp1), salt-inducible kinase 1 (sik1), and visinin-like 1a (vsnl1a) were up-regulated in MT Vs MC but down-regulated in MS Vs MC. Additionally, FoxO signaling pathway was significantly enriched only in MT Vs MC. These results not only provided the first insights into the mechanism that muscle tissue coped with the hypoxia stress in cyprinid species, but offered a theory base for breeding of M. amblycephala with hypoxia-resistant traits.

Metabolic and regulatory responses involved in cold acclimation in Atlantic killifish, Fundulus heteroclitus

Ectotherms often respond to prolonged cold exposure by increasing mitochondrial capacity via elevated mitochondrial volume density [V _V(mit,f)]. In fish, higher V _V(mit,f) is typically associated with increased expression of nuclear respiratory factor 1 (Nrf1), a transcription factor that induces expression of nuclear-encoded respiratory genes. To examine if nrf1 expression or the expression of other genes that regulate mitochondrial biogenesis contribute to changes in whole-organism metabolic rate during cold acclimation, we examined the time course of changes in the expression of these genes and in metabolic rate in Atlantic killifish, Fundulus heteroclitus. Cold acclimation rapidly decreased metabolic rate, but increased the expression of nrf1 more gradually, with a time course that depended on how rapidly the fish were transitioned to low temperature. Cold-induced nrf1 expression was not associated with increases in biochemical indicators of mitochondrial respiratory capacity, suggesting that cold-induced mitochondrial biogenesis may occur without increases in oxidative capacity in this species. These observations imply that changes in nrf1 expression and metabolic rate due to cold acclimation occur through different physiological mechanisms, and that increases in V _V(mit,f) are likely not directly related to changes in metabolic rate with cold acclimation in this species. However, nrf1 expression differed between northern and southern killifish subspecies regardless of acclimation temperature, consistent with observed differences in metabolic rate and V _V(mit,f) at 5 °C between these subspecies. Taken together, these results reveal substantial complexity in the regulation of V _V(mit,f) and mitochondrial capacity with temperature in fish and the relationship of these parameters to metabolic rate.

Interspecific and environment-induced variation in hypoxia tolerance in sunfish

Hypoxia tolerance is a plastic trait, and can vary between species. We compared hypoxia tolerance (hypoxic loss of equilibrium, LOE, and critical O2 tension, Pcrit) and traits that dictate O2 transport and metabolism in pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus), bluegill (L. macrochirus), and the naturally occurring hybrid in different acclimation environments (wild versus lab-acclimated fish) and at different temperatures. Wild fish generally had lower Pcrit and lower PO2 at LOE in progressive hypoxia than lab-acclimated fish, but time to LOE in sustained hypoxia (PO2 of 2kPa) did not vary between environments. Wild fish also had greater gill surface area and higher haematocrit, suggesting that increased O2 transport capacity underlies the environmental variation in Pcrit. Metabolic (lactate dehydrogenase, LDH; pyruvate kinase, PK; citrate synthase; cytochrome c oxidase) and antioxidant (catalase and superoxide dismutase) enzyme activities varied appreciably between environments. Wild fish had higher protein contents across tissues and higher activities of LDH in heart, PK in brain, and catalase in brain, liver, and skeletal muscle. Otherwise, wild fish had lower activities for most enzymes. Warming temperature from 15 to 25°C increased O2 consumption rate, Pcrit, PO2 at LOE, and haemoglobin-O2 affinity, and decreased time to LOE, but pumpkinseed had ≥2-fold longer time to LOE than bluegill and hybrids across this temperature range. This was associated with higher LDH activities in the heart and muscle, and lower or similar antioxidant enzyme activities in several tissues. However, the greater hypoxia tolerance of pumpkinseed collapsed at 28°C, demonstrating that the interactive effects of hypoxia and warming temperature can differ between species. Overall, distinct mechanisms appear to underpin interspecific and environment-induced variation in hypoxia tolerance in sunfish.